general

[wise marsh]

there’s awesome

[hidden robin]

I want a rdr remake

[maiden abyss]

Sorry for the inconvenience

[wise marsh]

yes

[steady saffron]

btw how did Mary Beth Gaskill leave the gang i forgot

[dense arch]

Pretty sure she escaped In late chapter 6

[wise marsh]

she just left

[dense arch]

So did Pearson and uncle

[wise marsh]

Dutch he comments on it during the train robbery mission

or the my last boy mission

I forgot

[dense arch]

No he only comments on Pearson and uncle on that mission

[steady saffron]

yeah cuz i could remember that tilly left when they were with arthur and jack but i dont rlly remember when she left Pearson and Karen

[wise marsh]

he also says “I think Mary-Beth left too”

[dense arch]

Mary-beth baddest in the game btw

[wise marsh]

Arthur’s very last journal entry is just depressing

[wise marsh]

no

it’s Sadie

👅

[dense arch]

Hell nah

[steady saffron]

Sadie is kinda Chopped

[maiden abyss]

Simps 🫵🏿

[remote siren]

I think i am genuinely about to lose my mind trying to make hosea on Nomad sculpt this app is hell behind a screen

[young steeple]

Sadie is not chopped bro

[steady saffron]

Abigail in rdr1 tho big glow up

[wise marsh]

yeah

wait

idk about that

Jack in the epilogue is so ugly

[young steeple]

Nah rdr2 abigail is peak

[wise marsh]

I wanna punch Jack in the epilogue

[steady saffron]

i aggre hes so annoying too i liked 4 year old jack way more

[young steeple]

Jack peaked at 4 true

[wise marsh]

uncle is the most bad character in the game

[steady saffron]

idk bro her hair and face structure is weird

[wise marsh]

idk if I can list anything bad about Abigail

[young steeple]

Yeah but her face cheeks

[steady saffron]

nah peaked at 19 then 4 then 16 then 12

[hidden robin]

Agreed mister

[wise marsh]

and 19

wait

nvm

I skipped the first 4 sentences for some reason

[hidden robin]

Jhon your girlfriend is so peak

[wise marsh]

ik

just don’t sleep with her again

[maiden abyss]

You ain't Hosea

[hidden robin]

I'm literally him

[steady saffron]

Hosea Abigail is ours you can keep tilly

[wise marsh]

bro is him

[remote siren]

Nuh uh

[dense arch]

I'm sad that noth of the games end in revenge

Both

[remote siren]

The real hosea is in my bed as we speak actually

[steady saffron]

or grimshaw choose which one u like better

[maiden abyss]

Nah actually you're Jose Swehtam

[wise marsh]

both of the games end with you using dead eye

[steady saffron]

i kinda forgot molly existed for a sec

[outer wolf]

Do you think the Game should've ended with John death?

[wise marsh]

no

[dense arch]

Rdr2?

[steady saffron]

it already did

[outer wolf]

Like without jack

[wise marsh]

that would screw up the timeline

[outer wolf]

Just credits after

[steady saffron]

?

[dense arch]

He's probably talking about rdr1

[hidden robin]

Jack is so cute

[fathom herald]

[wise marsh]

what do you guys think Jack did after Remember my Family

[steady saffron]

he already died in rdr1 bro

[dense arch]

We're talking about the jack part where he killed ross

[steady saffron]

stay depressed for a couple years

[dense arch]

I think the game would've been better off without it

[maiden abyss]

Cat

[remote siren]

LMFAO ya know what deserved i won't argue

[maiden abyss]

[wise marsh]

the game wouldn’t have a smooth end to it tho

[steady saffron]

why who would you play in free roam if john diead then

[wise marsh]

like

nvm

[dense arch]

Uncle in heaven

[maiden abyss]

It's been awhile since someone complained about the server logo

I'm surprised actually

[wise marsh]

uncle would probably be in hell actually

[fathom herald]

You just jinxed us

[wise marsh]

he killed people before

ran in a gang

[dense arch]

Grrr I hate server logo too woke

[wise marsh]

and got drunk a lot

[steady saffron]

the jack part was the best part bro

[dense arch]

It's the woke mind virus

Elon musk is right

[wise marsh]

the game felt empty playing as Jack

[steady saffron]

the whole victim of the whole gang getting their revenge

[inland rain]

.

[dense arch]

It was not

[hidden robin]

When Arthur and I went hunting, that bear showed up but I wasn’t scared. It’s just that my poor, delicate bones didn’t quite hold up

[outer wolf]

I just want the antagonist to win and live in peace

[steady saffron]

thats cuz there were no more missions bro trust if there were missions it would be the same

[wise marsh]

I usually get to the part where you get to Beecher hope and stop progressing the story

so John can just live with his family and stuff

dude

[maiden abyss]

You can't do bad things and have good things happen to you

[dense arch]

Rdr1 felt too short

[maiden abyss]

Agent Milton was just doing his job

[wise marsh]

I feel like the developers deliberately put barking noises at Beechers hope while playing as Jack

I swear I hear Rufus as Jack at Beecher’s Hope

[dense arch]

All gang members fate were deserves

[steady saffron]

its just a bug because the dog spawns under the floor of the house

[wise marsh]

oh

that’s weird

[dense arch]

It's only sad because we play with them

[wise marsh]

why didn’t they just

[outer wolf]

Especially Dutch

[wise marsh]

get rid of him

[hidden robin]

I just don't want any more folks to die, Dutch

[maiden abyss]

Kept you waiting huh?

[steady saffron]

ppl like that to be a theory but the game just bugged idk

[wise marsh]

Jack Marston schizophrenia theory

[maiden abyss]

John has one major flaw in rdr2 epilogue

[crisp smelt]

Huh

[wise marsh]

I wish they didn’t just put John’s skin on Arthur’s body in rdr2

[steady saffron]

nah not jacks he was just a little kid who didnt do anything and both of his parents died before he was even 20

[maiden abyss]

He suffers from Arthur Morgan model

[dense arch]

He's boring and he sucks

[hidden robin]

Guys I'm fighting micah rn

[dense arch]

He didn't die

[maiden abyss]

Arthur fan?

[gilded sky]

coming after playing rdr2 first
too limited in what you do

[dense arch]

And he chose the outlaw life

[wise marsh]

he meant his parents

[hazy compass]

Should I get rdr1 on steam now? I have finished rdr2

[wise marsh]

John and Abigail

[dense arch]

No

[steady saffron]

you said fate not death

[gilded sky]

ofc

[dense arch]

In epilogue johns suppperrr boring

[wise marsh]

what do you guys think would happen if Uncle survived

[gilded sky]

finish the story

[maiden abyss]

Hey it's you again wassup man

[outer wolf]

Yes

[fathom herald]

too many cattle rustlers in here

[hazy compass]

It’s twice as expensive as rdr2 though…

[outer wolf]

Now IM in charge!!!

[steady saffron]

sorry you dont like seeing families happy

[dense arch]

Still

[wise marsh]

imagine instead of Jack surviving Uncle survives and you can’t jump and you can only walk

[gilded sky]

glad I made an impression to remember me

[dense arch]

Jack chose to be an outlaw

[gilded sky]

is that so?

[dense arch]

Very stupid decision

[hidden robin]

[gilded sky]

it's worth it

[wise marsh]

Jack took after his father

[dense arch]

After being told by his father and mother to not

[wise marsh]

they raised him to be an outlaw basically

[hazy compass]

Yup, 35 bucks. Still worth it?

[hidden robin]

😭

🙏

[wise marsh]

there’s a camp interaction where Jack throws rocks at Kieran because he was influenced by the gangs hatred for O’Driscolls

[gilded sky]

Nice coincidence I was playing and he mentioned to his dad that he's reading some book about someone who avenges his dad

[hidden robin]

Me and uncle are old folks respect us

[wise marsh]

At least you have some respect to your name

[dense arch]

Yeah but that's wild young and free john who hates his family

[gilded sky]

uncle acts as a degenerates

not worthy of my respect

[outer wolf]

Arthur has sketches of events in New Austin. So sad it was scrapped

[hidden robin]

Guys what do I do

Arthur won't get up

[wise marsh]

I don’t think the idea of Arthur going to New Austin was scrapped

[steady saffron]

bro do u not even understand what you wrote before? you said every gang member deserved thier fate jack was just a innocent kid that didnt do anything his both parents died, he became a outlaw after abigails death because his life was terrible and he wanted revenge

[wise marsh]

since in rdr1 strange man comments the blackwater massacre

[gilded sky]

I thought rdr2 is 70 or 80 standard

[wise marsh]

so they kinda built on that idea

[dense arch]

Oh my god dude

[gilded sky]

my least fave part about rdr1 is the stranger missions
unlike rdr2's

[dense arch]

Jack did not need to go the outlaw route

[gilded sky]

they seem more boring

[outer wolf]

What currency?

[dense arch]

That was completely on him

[hidden robin]

Arthur won't egt up

[wise marsh]

ngl I think the very mention of the blackwater massacre could probably freak out John since it happened in the 1800’s and the amount of people who still remember the incident could probably be counted on one hand

[hidden robin]

Jack vengeance was important

[steady saffron]

i dont think you seem to understand.

[gilded sky]

dollars

[dense arch]

And you don't seem to understand

[surreal sphinx]

hi cunts

[dense arch]

A shame you seemed an honest man

[trim acorn]

strange tales of the west

[wise marsh]

Jack was influenced by the Van Der Linde gang basically

[outer wolf]

RDR2 standard was never that expensive from what I recall. Always 60

[trim acorn]

is that robs announcement

[wise marsh]

He said he does not do announcements for Rockstar

I think

[steady saffron]

his "fate" was that both of his parents were already dead by the age of 19 ingore what happend later bro him becoming a outlaw has nothing to do with it his parents were already dead

[wise marsh]

that’s rockstars thing

[gilded sky]

no he wasn't
if the ross didn't betray john
Jack would be an honest man

[maiden abyss]

Low honor help John is canon

[gilded sky]

a writer

[maiden abyss]

And historically accurate

[hidden robin]

Well you know well about your son

[wise marsh]

I’m pretty sure Jack does become a writer

[surreal sphinx]

wgeres my kittle xjox badge gone

little

[wise marsh]

since he has a book written by him in GTA 5

[surreal sphinx]

cbox

[steady saffron]

you just heard the gta 5 easter egg theory bro get out

[gilded sky]

I missed that

[surreal sphinx]

[maiden abyss]

It's not canon

[gilded sky]

we got a book by Jack marston before gta 6

[steady saffron]

this

[wise marsh]

oh

[maiden abyss]

Wanna know what is canon though?

[wise marsh]

I mean

[hidden robin]

Omg really I didn't know about that easter egg

[wise marsh]

it’s possible you could live an honest life

[dense arch]

John faking his death and fleeing back to scottland

[maiden abyss]

"Damn us both!"

[wise marsh]

all you have to do is just kill Ross

[maiden abyss]

BANG

[wise marsh]

it’s not like you have to kill millions of people like John did

[outer wolf]

Thought GTA and red dead universes were separate

[wise marsh]

completely optional

[gilded sky]

revenge is a fool's errand

[steady saffron]

the canon is not confirmed what we know is what we last saw of jack, murdering ross bruttaly on a lake

[surreal sphinx]

i livr kn scotkand rn

[wise marsh]

and even killing Ross is optional

[gilded sky]

I'm definitely killing the son of bitch

[steady saffron]

its a canon storyline mission

[dense arch]

Whats it like

[wise marsh]

ik

[maiden abyss]

GTA and RDR are separate

[outer wolf]

Milton shouldve lived

[wise marsh]

false nuke

[dense arch]

That's like saying the entire story of rdr2 is optional

[wise marsh]

like

[maiden abyss]

He was just doing his job

[hidden robin]

🙏

[wise marsh]

uhhh yeah it is

[dense arch]

Sure

[hidden robin]

He literally killed me

[surreal sphinx]

alot of alcoholic homesless people i gave way too many of thek fivers tonight bro

[dense arch]

The end credits play when ross dies

[wise marsh]

“I stopped playing rdr2 at the snow part it was boring”

[steady saffron]

rdr1 ending gotta be more satysfing then rdr2 ending bruttaly killing ross> bruttaly killing micah to avenge this random friend he had 8 years ago

[dense arch]

What had sketch so mad here

[surreal sphinx]

football

idk

[gilded sky]

"friend"
more like brother

[maiden abyss]

Red dead fan theories are fucking stupid

[gilded sky]

grew up together and all

[surreal sphinx]

im so snuggled up in bed rn im so comgy cosey

[wise marsh]

realistically I know this wouldn’t happen because Arthur knows Mary would get dragged into the outlaw life but do you guys wonder what would happen if Arthur accepted Mary’s offer to run off with her?

[dense arch]

I want 1 good idea for rdr3

[hidden robin]

Agreed

[surreal sphinx]

comffyyyy

[steady saffron]

arthurs been dead a long time

[surreal sphinx]

weed farm. in tahiti. with arthut.

[viscid oriole]

brand new red dead game

[wise marsh]

ngl despite the greatness of the red dead games I don’t want them to milk the series

[gilded sky]

it was legal

[wise marsh]

or maybe more red Harlow

[gilded sky]

sadie is a bounty hunter

[dense arch]

Yeah

[wise marsh]

that’s the only rdr3 I would accept

[outer wolf]

Callander brothers or play as Landon Rickets

[dense arch]

Different story

[viscid oriole]

Sadie realistically died

[dense arch]

Make rdr3 about pirates pretty please

[maiden abyss]

Fun Fact
RD1 / Red Dead 1 = Revolver
RD2 / Red Dead 2 = Redemption 1
RD3 / Red Dead 3 = Redemption 2

[wise marsh]

rdr3 but it’s in the medieval era

[viscid oriole]

Lilith faker

[hidden robin]

Doesn't make sense

[steady saffron]

playing as mac callander set before rdr2 or playing as jack marston set after rdr1

[dense arch]

I know but it'd be super cool and stuff

[viscid oriole]

If I played as Mac it would be no different than playing as Micah or bill

[dense arch]

Nerp

[maiden abyss]

I could not find the original message Morty

[dense arch]

Norp

[wise marsh]

playing as Jack would just be a war game at that point

[dense arch]

Nope

Let's think about those ideas for a second

Mac callendar

[viscid oriole]

Why would I want to actively play as a violent drunk who threatens and probably has shot people for no reason

[dense arch]

Was a violent killer and died as one with no redemption

[steady saffron]

dosent have to be set in 1917 could be set in 1920s

[dense arch]

So you can't call it red dead redemption

Since there's no.. redemption

Jack marstonater

[wise marsh]

the world would be more civilized and cowboys probably wouldn’t be a thing

[hidden robin]

Yeah you can say that to rock star to make a game on pirates just like they made games about american mafia or wildwest outlaws

[steady saffron]

so was arthur and john depending on how you play them 👍

[maiden abyss]

Did you do that thing in Kcd2 yet

[steady saffron]

so?

[wise marsh]

rdr3 should be an entirely new idea with new characters and MAYBE a few mentions of the first three

[dense arch]

Doesn't matter what

Charles says it himself

Wtf are you talking about

[maiden abyss]

Hello Forge

[dense arch]

You can't just break the cannon lol

[steady saffron]

john was even that with good honor

[wise marsh]

I think the low honor helping John ending is the cannon one

it’s way more realistic

[steady saffron]

since honor dosent change the ending of rdr1

[balmy marsh]

@near meadow u made this didn't u:

[wise marsh]

honor effects both of Arthur and John’s graves

[dense arch]

John died for his family

[balmy marsh]

Hello Luke

[dense arch]

That's his redemption

Arthur well

Died for the good people in the gang?

[wise marsh]

yeah

[dense arch]

That's his redemption

What would be mac Callanders redemption

[hidden robin]

Well they were outlaws they deserved to die

[maiden abyss]

Whatcha up to

[dense arch]

For sure

[balmy marsh]

I'm just trying to warm my hands rn, wbu?

[dense arch]

But they atleast redeemed themselves when it mattered

[wise marsh]

red Harlow comes in and kills the entire Van Der Linde gang

[steady saffron]

there are also way more characters that could be used for a rdr game set before rdr2 other than Mac n cheese

[maiden abyss]

Trying to stay cool

[dense arch]

Let's think about that then

Hosea?

Maybe

But what would be the redemption

[steady saffron]

nah has to be someone who died or we havent seen in rdr2

[dense arch]

Maybe bonnie?

[wise marsh]

Red Harlow game

[maiden abyss]

Already happened

[dense arch]

That'd just be red dead revolver 2

[steady saffron]

bro bonnie was 14

[wise marsh]

ik

[dense arch]

Idfk

[wise marsh]

but red harlow is badass

[dense arch]

Say other characters then

[wise marsh]

and the game isn’t much

[maiden abyss]

Rdr3 is not going to happen any time soon

[dense arch]

Maybe the strange man?

One of the sherries?

[wise marsh]

Red Harlow has a bunch of potential

[dense arch]

Sherrifs

[hidden robin]

Agent milton should be a protagonist in rdr3

Even he killed me

[maiden abyss]

Also RDR1-Red Dead Revolver
RDR2-Red Dead Redemption
RDR3-Red Dead Redemption 2

[steady saffron]

they could just make up a whole new character and pretend hes been in the van der linde gang for a bit and then after the end if the game that guy dies and then you play as arthur as usual or sum if they dont wanna make the series entierly abt john

[wise marsh]

uncle game 🔥

[dense arch]

Revolver and redemption are two different cannons

[gilded sky]

I'm not buying that

[wise marsh]

red dead lumbago

[gilded sky]

I wanna be Dutch and make the gang in rdr3

[maiden abyss]

Still

[wise marsh]

rdr3 is where you should play as Lyle Morgan

[maiden abyss]

Technically Red Dead Revolver is the first Rdr game

[dense arch]

No not still

[steady saffron]

no he was hanged for being a terrible human being

[dense arch]

It's revolver not redemption

[wise marsh]

he robbed people

he got hung for larceny

[gilded sky]

imagine if they make like gta5
switching between Dutch, young arthur and hosea

[maiden abyss]

It's still rdr

[wise marsh]

that’s what I was thinking

[steady saffron]

red dead revenge

[dense arch]

What is this point

[maiden abyss]

[dense arch]

It's just an abbreviation

[gilded sky]

great minds think alike

[maiden abyss]

So?

[wise marsh]

revolver and redemption are nearly completely different games

[wise marsh]

revolver is a game with levels in it

redemption is a free roam game

[gilded sky]

redemption ironically was the redemption for the revolver game

[gilded sky]

any company would've stopped and dropped the franchise

[maiden abyss]

My point is Rdr3 Rdr4 whatever the fuck isn't going to happen anytime soon

[dense arch]

Probably

[wise marsh]

that’s true

but there’s still a possibility

[dense arch]

I think the game is just fine with rdr1 and 2

[gilded sky]

sends I have a drama MLK quote

[hidden robin]

Just like gta6 thing happened

[dense arch]

There's nothing to be done with the van der linde gangs story

It's done

[wise marsh]

rdr doesn’t need a third game but it’s gonna happen at some point

or maybe rockstar will leave the game the way it is

[maiden abyss]

I don't get this

[hidden robin]

Last of us 3

[wise marsh]

there’s really not much of there to add to the story of rdr

[hidden robin]

Uncharted 5

[maiden abyss]

HELL NO

[dense arch]

Yeah

[hidden robin]

Days gone 2

[gilded sky]

red harollow wasn't that much of a success
so any other company would've dropped it

[silk notch]

The first one is a classic anyways

[gilded sky]

or so said my favourite youtuber

[hidden robin]

Super mario with gta6 graphics

[maiden abyss]

Hotline Miami 3

[dense arch]

Did rdr1 win goty

[maiden abyss]

Half life 3

Never going to happen

[gilded sky]

TF3

[wise marsh]

rdr2 explained unanswered questions like the blackwater massacre and John being in the Van Der Linde gang

[gilded sky]

only briefly

[wise marsh]

and how John built beechers hope

[wise marsh]

I know rdr2 doesn’t outright explain what happened but it had most of the details uh there

[dense arch]

The only think there is to be explained is who the strange man is

[fathom herald]

I miss when Battlefield was fun

[hidden robin]

These theories will never get down

[wise marsh]

I really don’t think that’s needed

like

[dense arch]

Yeah probably

[wise marsh]

yeah he’s interesting and all

but

[dense arch]

His whole thing is being strange

[wise marsh]

strange man is good because he’s ominous and eery

[maiden abyss]

Don't even start the Trelawny theory

[dense arch]

And plus blind man cassidy basically confirms that the strange man is just the grim reaper

[wise marsh]

I don’t believe it

there’s no way trelawny would leave his family to go live in the swamps and paint

[dense arch]

They look slightly similar so they must be the same person

[maiden abyss]

No bro

[maiden abyss]

They are not the same person

[outer wolf]

Trelawny is just DarkViperAU

[maiden abyss]

Just how Uncle isn't Red Harlow

[maiden abyss]

Stupid fuckin theory

[wise marsh]

if strange man was explained he wouldn’t be strange anymore

[dense arch]

Fun police here

[stray shuttle]

Trelawny looks like Austin wells

[wise marsh]

I’m pretty sure the red hollow being uncle theory is just for shits and giggles

there’s no evidence between them

[maiden abyss]

Yep that's me I hate fun I'm Mr negative

[dense arch]

Yes there is bro they look a bit like each other

[wise marsh]

I think someone just thought “imagine if uncle was the most badass character ever”

[dense arch]

So they are the same person

[wise marsh]

yeah

[maiden abyss]

It's a stupid theory that doesn't make sense

The timelines

Do the math

[wise marsh]

he barely looks like he aged a day between the games

[lusty ruin]

Im pretty sure the reason they made it was because the Fandom was so dead people just made up random shi

[maiden abyss]

It doesn't make sense

[dense arch]

Nobody genuinely believes uncle is red Harlow man

[wise marsh]

I keep on seeing those stupid ass videos where they tell you to kill certain members of the gang and random shit happens after

which is obviously a joke

[maiden abyss]

If Uncle is Red Harlow than Lumbago is fuckin serious

[wise marsh]

the red dead redemption fandom is slowly going insane…

[hidden robin]

I have a god damn plan

[maiden abyss]

Ugly ass pfp

[hidden robin]

Goated ass pfp

[wise marsh]

dutch looks even better clean shaven

[maiden abyss]

what have I done?

[hidden robin]

Well it sucked

Badly

[maiden abyss]

Wait are you the cowpoke guy?

[hidden robin]

I finished chapter 6

I'm still crying

[maiden abyss]

That's cool I got 100%

[hidden robin]

I'm not doing the epilogue

[hidden robin]

Nah because of me, you all got to see a beautiful place like Tahiti

I refuse

[hidden robin]

Yeah bro

[wise marsh]

I feel like Micah never was loyal to Dutch and could see through his “plan” so he decided to take advantage to it an eventually become his most trusted partner

[maiden abyss]

Ifhml

[hidden robin]

I love jhon Marston

[wise marsh]

okay

[hidden robin]

Not you

[maiden abyss]

Why do you refuse to do the epilogue

[hidden robin]

I needa re think my reason

Arthur

[wise marsh]

I only like rdr1 John rdr2 John epilogue is just John’s skin slapped into Arthur’s body

[hidden robin]

That's reason

[hidden robin]

I raised my kids arthur and John

[maiden abyss]

Stupid reason ngl

But okay

[maiden abyss]

Damn I'm kinda a dick ngl

That's my fault bro

[wise marsh]

whatbhappened

[crystal sundial]

Hug

[maiden abyss]

If you don't want to finish the game there's nothing wrong with that

[maiden abyss]

Just you're missing out on the resolution of the story

[hidden robin]

I'm doing it rn

In still grieving about arthur

[wise marsh]

imagine if you played 100 play throughs of rdr2 and 100% all of them maybe Arthur survives

[hidden robin]

Ykw

I'ma do that

Give me 100 years

I have no idea what happens in the epilogue

Pls tell me he becomes a cowboy again

[maiden abyss]

Just play the game

[wise marsh]

maybe whenever Arthur dies it shows you a character selection screen and you can choose who to play as

[hidden robin]

It doesn't

[wise marsh]

zombie arthur

no whenever you play the game 100 times and 100% all of them

[hidden robin]

Jhon go take them meds

[maiden abyss]

that's dumb

[wise marsh]

playing as uncle would be heavenly

[maiden abyss]

Are you having a giggle?

[hidden robin]

Wait did the whole gang split?

[wise marsh]

there’s only 5 missions and all 5 of them are either asking Arthur for money or getting drunk

[hidden robin]

Arthur, i saw you in the blackwater

[fast sigil]

yo

[hidden robin]

My keyboard got lumbago 😩

[wise marsh]

what if uncle was the richest person in the gang but he lost it on the side of the road while searching for the legendary lumbago cure

[wise marsh]

if uncle was a food who would he be

[stoic yacht]

I feel like bacon

Idk why

[wise marsh]

I understand that

[hidden robin]

Camp stew 🍲

[wise marsh]

but it’s five days old and is over burnt

[maiden abyss]

Over cooked

[wise marsh]

no one would want it

[wise marsh]

whatever

[quartz marsh]

RDO support coming back?

[maiden abyss]

Nuh uh

You're dreaming

Wake up

[wise marsh]

whats RDO?

[maiden abyss]

Red Dead Online

[wise marsh]

that’s not a thing

[maiden abyss]

Yes it is

[wise marsh]

RDO doesn’t exist

[maiden abyss]

Prove it

[wise marsh]

shhh

just go on with the joke

[silent spade]

hello guys

[maiden abyss]

Wassup

[wise marsh]

hello

[stray sun]

jhon

[wise marsh]

my name is jhon marston

[maiden abyss]

No

[maiden abyss]

Whatever you say Nhoj Notsram

[wise marsh]

grrr

[vocal vapor]

Hi John mustard

[wise marsh]

…mustard?

someone say mustard?

m…

[vocal vapor]

Yes

[stoic yacht]

Mustard...

[wise marsh]

M….

[lusty ruin]

Flinched like an abused child

[maiden abyss]

Are you the og toast?

[vocal vapor]

Wdym?

[wise marsh]

mustard!

[maiden abyss]

How's your 100% coming

[wise marsh]

I’m trying to get 100% rn

[vocal vapor]

Not great, haven't played in a bit still at 96.7%

[maiden abyss]

Did you do the exotics mission

[vocal vapor]

No

[maiden abyss]

Do that last

[vocal vapor]

Just Exotics and challenges left

[maiden abyss]

Which challenges

[wise marsh]

have you done the gambler challenges

all of them

[stoic yacht]

me too

[vocal vapor]

Yeah I've done gambler bandit and explorer

[stoic yacht]

im at 84% rn

[wise marsh]

tell me your way

I’m at 86% rn

I think

[stoic yacht]

ooo lucky ducky..

[maiden abyss]

Just keep playing

[wise marsh]

around that

[stoic yacht]

im wokring on getting all the legendary animals rn

[maiden abyss]

Fuck the gambler challenges tho

[lusty ruin]

I need fish

[wise marsh]

dude I am NOT findinh those dinosaur bones

[lusty ruin]

Please fish

I need fish

[stoic yacht]

om dont get me started on those dang fish

[wise marsh]

gambler challenges come natural to me,,,

[torn orchid]

As a new online player what's something I should do?

[stoic yacht]

i was fishing for like 2 hours for the legendary smallmouth bass and only getting muskies

[vocal vapor]

Those challenges weren't that bad the blackjack one was annoying tho

[wise marsh]

I actually kinda like fishing the legendary animals

[lusty ruin]

Mmmmmm fish

I need fish

Please fish

[vocal vapor]

Yeah fishing is nice

[maiden abyss]

I got all the legendary fish first try

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[stoic yacht]

omg you lucky ducky

[wise marsh]

I just caught the fish at sisika penitentiary

[maiden abyss]

I might %100 the game again just because I can

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[stoic yacht]

awh

[wise marsh]

I mean

the legendary fish

[obsidian atlas]

It's John Marston!! Micah !!

[vocal vapor]

I pretty much just struggled with the first one I caught cuz i didn't know how to do it yet

[lusty ruin]

Mmmmmm I need fish please fish

[wise marsh]

I wish you could just buy the legendary fish lures right off the bat

[vocal vapor]

That was the easiest one bro (once you find a canoe)

[maiden abyss]

Cousin let's go bowling

[wise marsh]

ik

[maiden abyss]

Peak right?

[obsidian atlas]

Yahh Man

[lusty ruin]

Fish

Mmmmmm

🐟

[wise marsh]

what’s your obsession with fish

[lusty ruin]

Mmmmmmm

[wise marsh]

should I be worried

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[vocal vapor]

You sir, are a

[lusty ruin]

Fish

[maiden abyss]

Bro probably puts lipstick on fish and tries kissing them

[neat summit]

wheres siren

bm

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[wise marsh]

imagine doing that with a smallmouth

[vocal vapor]

Crazy but probably realistic

[vocal vapor]

Bigmouth

Bass

[lusty ruin]

Mmmm fish

[wise marsh]

fish

[hidden robin]

Arthur, i saw you i saw you in blackwater

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[wise marsh]

wsg gurt

yo, gurt

[vocal vapor]

[lusty ruin]

Mmmmmmm I need fish

Mmmm

[vocal vapor]

🎣 🐟 🐠

[wise marsh]

did you guys kill Jimmy brooks or let him live

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[vocal vapor]

Let him live

[vocal vapor]

🐠

[wise marsh]

realistically I think that’s what Arthur would do

[maiden abyss]

I lit him on fire in one playthrough

[lusty ruin]

Mmmmmm fish

🐟

[wise marsh]

other than LIKR

Anthony Foreman

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[wise marsh]

I tried lassoing Jimmy

he fell of course

[maiden abyss]

Helped him up then killed him in another playthrough

[lusty ruin]

I need fish

[wise marsh]

I fell off the cliff

[vocal vapor]

I never sold his pen

[wise marsh]

and I died

searching for his body

[hidden robin]

Thanks

[maiden abyss]

Did you give it to Mary Beth

[vocal vapor]

What?

[wise marsh]

wait

[lusty ruin]

Mmmmmmm fish

[vocal vapor]

I regret

[lusty ruin]

Fish

Mmmmm

[wise marsh]

like

an item request?

[vocal vapor]

Here 🐟

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[wise marsh]

did you guys ever get the ancient Viking comb

[vocal vapor]

Nah here 🐡

[maiden abyss]

Mary Beth she asks for a pen at some point in the game

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[vocal vapor]

I never got that

[wise marsh]

I think it’s random

[maiden abyss]

I have literally everything

[lusty ruin]

Fish mmmmm

Fish

[wise marsh]

do you have all the cheat codes unlocked

[vocal vapor]

Why does she want the pen?

[wise marsh]

even the two undiscovered ones

[wise marsh]

probably to write a book

[hidden robin]

Bc that was my pen

[maiden abyss]

Yes

[lusty ruin]

Fish

[maiden abyss]

Because why not

[wise marsh]

tell us it

now

[vocal vapor]

You're never getting your pen back

[maiden abyss]

Just look them up

[lusty ruin]

Fish

I need fish

[wise marsh]

I don’t feel like it

[lusty ruin]

Mmmmmmm fish

[maiden abyss]

Fellow Canadian?!

[vocal vapor]

Bro has an unending hunger for fish

[maiden abyss]

Fish is good

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[vocal vapor]

Who

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[vocal vapor]

Dead fish

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[vocal vapor]

Dead

[maiden abyss]

CHOCOLATE? CHOCOLATE?

[vocal vapor]

No

[wise marsh]

🖋️

[vocal vapor]

Spinach

[maiden abyss]

Head ass

[hidden robin]

Look at my pfp you are giving me my pen back

[vocal vapor]

🖊️

[lusty ruin]

Fish mmmm i need fish please fish please I need fish mmmmm fish please fish mmmmmm fish

[vocal vapor]

No I'm taking it

[vocal vapor]

No fish

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[maiden abyss]

Ngl I might restart rdr2 again just so I can kill Jimmy

[wise marsh]

@hidden robin Heres your pen

[vocal vapor]

My pen is better Jimmy

[wise marsh]

wiat

wrong Jimmy brooks

why are there two Jimmy Brooks

other Jimmy brooks

[vocal vapor]

No that's the right one

[vocal vapor]

See this guy

[wise marsh]

oh

he changed his pfp

[vocal vapor]

Yeah

[wise marsh]

what happened to clean shaven dutch

[lusty ruin]

Mmmmm fish

[vocal vapor]

Hi John Morgan

[wise marsh]

🐟

jarthur morgan

[vocal vapor]

Don't feed him

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[maiden abyss]

Same person

[vocal vapor]

No

[vocal vapor]

He died

[lusty ruin]

Mmmm I need fish

[wise marsh]

🎏 dead fish hanging on a pole

[lusty ruin]

Fish mmmm

[maiden abyss]

Arthur fan role

[lusty ruin]

Fish?!

[wise marsh]

how do I get sigma john marston role

damn

[vocal vapor]

Have you played rdr1?

[wise marsh]

😂🫱

[wise marsh]

yes

[maiden abyss]

Mods ban discord kids

[lusty ruin]

Mmmmm fish

Y

[wise marsh]

I’m playing as Jack

[lusty ruin]

Fish

Mmmm

[vocal vapor]

Good

[wise marsh]

wdym

[vocal vapor]

Have you played revolver?

[wise marsh]

nope

[maiden abyss]

"Sigma Gyat Ohio Rizz Skibidi" are not funny

[pale moth]

helo

[vocal vapor]

Bad

[wise marsh]

some one called me unfunny in discord…

[lusty ruin]

Mmmmm fish

I need fish

[wise marsh]

😔

[vocal vapor]

Yeah

[pale moth]

yo gurt

[maiden abyss]

I'm not saying you aren't funny

[lusty ruin]

Mmmmm fish

[maiden abyss]

I'm saying those words aren't funny

[lusty ruin]

I need fish mmmmm fish

[quiet marten]

Arthur Morgan or John Marston

[wise marsh]

what am I gonna do with my life now that I’m considered unfunny

[vocal vapor]

Stop

[vocal vapor]

*Arthur marston vs John morgan

[wise marsh]

1911 John is better than 1899 Arthur

[quiet marten]

Agreed

[wise marsh]

but 1899 Arthur is better than 1899 John

[quiet marten]

Also agreed

[wise marsh]

1899 Jack solos all

[maiden abyss]

Wassup Wip Ran Vinkle

[quiet marten]

What about 1907 John or 1899 Arthur

[pale moth]

hello luke 🙂

[vocal vapor]

1899 Arthur

[vocal vapor]

Yeah

[wise marsh]

still the same as 1911 John vs 1899 Arthur

[quiet marten]

Not really

[vocal vapor]

No

[hidden robin]

You burned down my manor 😡

[quiet marten]

You deserved it

[wise marsh]

realistically Arthur wouldn’t even hurt John

[vocal vapor]

Id do it again

[wise marsh]

why’d you take my son

[quiet marten]

She is just a rage baiter

[maiden abyss]

bruh how many times are you gonna change your name and pfp?

[wise marsh]

0/10 ragebait

so I burnt down your manor

[quiet marten]

1.5/10 ragebait

[wise marsh]

yeah

[vocal vapor]

Jimmy Brooks is shapeshifting

[hidden robin]

Bc there are no other characters exept john and arthur

[quiet marten]

I killed Jimmy Brooks on my first playthrough

[wise marsh]

jimmy brooks is the single shoelace holding the entire rdr universe together

[vocal vapor]

Dutch

[hidden robin]

Ahh my keyboard got lumbago😩

[wise marsh]

I accidentally killed Jimmy

I tried lassoing him

[vocal vapor]

Sean

[quiet marten]

I killed him on purpose

[pale moth]

noooo

[wise marsh]

yeah

but I tried lassoing him

like a true cowboy 🔥

[quiet marten]

Uh actually they’re outlaws

[wise marsh]

outlaws are like

[quiet marten]

Not cowboys

[wise marsh]

wait

[maiden abyss]

Erm actually 🤓

[wise marsh]

Nevermind

[vocal vapor]

Both

[quiet marten]

Erm actually

[wise marsh]

cowboys like

herd cattle

and have farms

COWboys

[quiet marten]

Farmers

[vocal vapor]

Not necessarily

[quiet marten]

Cattle boys then

[wise marsh]

cattle just means a bunch of cows

[hidden robin]

Hahaha i used your poor gang for moonshine smuggling

[quiet marten]

1.5/10 ragebait

[vocal vapor]

You're burned to death

[quiet marten]

She did it herself too

[wise marsh]

2.4/10 ragebait

[vocal vapor]

3.2 ragebait

[maiden abyss]

Hilarious

[wise marsh]

man

clay and clyde scammed us

3 arabians

for like

only a thousand dollars

I saw that message

[maiden abyss]

teehee

[hidden robin]

John i kidnapped your son you scared of me 🤬

[wise marsh]

you’re scared of me

[quiet marten]

If there was a medium honor ending (not high or low) what do you think it would be

[wise marsh]

you had to kidnap a child because you kidnap kidnap adults

[vocal vapor]

Imagine stooping so low as to kidnap a child

[pale moth]

stooping

[wise marsh]

arthur accidentally falls of the cliff while climbing to the spot for the high honor ending

[vocal vapor]

And then showing off the fact that you kidnapped that child

[maiden abyss]

Wouldn't make sense because your honor boosts or decreases depending on what you do

[vocal vapor]

So?

[wise marsh]

you do something to decrease your honor everytime you do an honorable action

[hidden robin]

I hope Angelo bronte didn't touch your kid john 🤬

[wise marsh]

like killing someone

[wise marsh]

what

[lusty ruin]

Fish

Mmmm

[wise marsh]

what do you mean by that

[fathom herald]

Is this still going on

[wise marsh]

what is still going on

[maiden abyss]

Idk Cat I'm confused

[quiet marten]

I think the medium honor ending would be Arthur collapsing during his last ride and dies

[maiden abyss]

w

[grim prairie]

Is the July update real chat

[hidden robin]

No I'm gonna sleep with arthur

[pale moth]

ye

[grim prairie]

OMG

[maiden abyss]

okay bro

[fathom herald]

Gross

[vocal vapor]

No you're not

[grim prairie]

Oh.

[maiden abyss]

too many caps bro

[hidden robin]

Well jimmy brooks is a second option

[grim prairie]

Momment in history..

[pale moth]

you tryna play as your on pc lol

[grim prairie]

Nope

Xbox

[vocal vapor]

No gifs for you

[wise marsh]

where’s the mobile role

you can play rdr2 on your mobile device

[maiden abyss]

You can't send images here

[pale moth]

fe

[grim prairie]

💔

[wise marsh]

technically

[vocal vapor]

You can

[wise marsh]

If you use the remote play app

[grim prairie]

No dog gif

[vocal vapor]

Oh

[grim prairie]

😭

[wise marsh]

but it’s a very tedious process

[pale moth]

anyone now why afetr i completed the challenges for the outlaw pass stuff i didnt get anything

[grim prairie]

Amazing pfp

[vocal vapor]

Ty

[wise marsh]

getting best in the west achievement on mobile

[grim prairie]

I haven't played red dead in like 2 years

I've waited

So long

[vocal vapor]

Play it again

Now

Do it

[wise marsh]

undead nightmare is goated

[vocal vapor]

Yes

[grim prairie]

Noo I remmber the story me no need sadness

[wise marsh]

I’m gonna hop off now

[vocal vapor]

Stop at chapter six

[grim prairie]

😭

[vocal vapor]

Bye

[grim prairie]

Ima play online

[wise marsh]

best character in the game

[grim prairie]

I wanna see what I have and if I'm still rich

[vocal vapor]

I hate you

[wise marsh]

he’s the worst character in the game

but the best written character

is what I’m saying

[vocal vapor]

Oh yeah

[grim prairie]

1 hour and 44 mins left

[hidden robin]

Vand der linde gang, Why didn’t you stay here longer?

[grim prairie]

I'm gonna watch it download

[wise marsh]

I’m gonna go to sleep now

Or I’ll just play rdr2

[vocal vapor]

On what

[grim prairie]

Red dead bro

[vocal vapor]

Play it, you know you wanna

[chrome carbon]

i hate being a low level

[grim prairie]

I don't remmber my level

[hidden robin]

Omg i can't change my name anymore owner pls 🥺

[grim prairie]

Prob in the 100s

Idk

[chrome carbon]

that’s what my xbox acc is

but pc is 36

[hidden robin]

@owner

[prime quail]

Shoot all blue dots on sight.

[vocal vapor]

It always happens eventually. All the mods do it

[grim prairie]

I tryed playing red read online on my school pc let's js say it didn't go well

[vocal vapor]

I forgot I blocked the sheriff

[hidden robin]

Mods my sweet mods 🥺

[chrome carbon]

oh my

[chrome carbon]

what is happening

[hidden robin]

It's me tihati

Mods

🥺

[grim prairie]

I mean it wasn't as bad as I thought it was gonna be

[vocal vapor]

The mods changed their name, they're begging but no one will do anything

[grim prairie]

Js abit laggy

[chrome carbon]

as per usual

[hidden robin]

I'm the place like heaven pls do good for me 🥺

[vocal vapor]

Real, I want my name back too

[maiden abyss]

What's this mean

[chrome carbon]

blueberries

[grim prairie]

[chrome carbon]

shoot all the blueberries

[hidden robin]

@mods

[vocal vapor]

I blocked the sheriff

[maiden abyss]

L

[vocal vapor]

That doesn't work bro, and they wouldn't change it back anyway

[chrome carbon]

real

[amber sentinel]

Anyway, mods, make Arthur leave 15 year old waitresses alone.

[chrome carbon]

😦

[vocal vapor]

Stfu

[maiden abyss]

HA

[vocal vapor]

I'm blocking you to

Oh I can't

[maiden abyss]

[vocal vapor]

F ts

[waxen inlet]

[vocal vapor]

[chrome carbon]

someone help me lvl up right now