#šāoff-topic
1 messages Ā· Page 178 of 1
For all the wrong reasons IMO. I think it should be the most controversial due to the blatant copyright infringement.
Yep
But naturally people are focused on the job impact more.
Its the ways people use it that should be criticized
Not the tool itself
Training your ai on non public domain art without acquiring rights for example is very scummy imo
AI would not have been such a disruptive force in our society if it hadn't trained on all of that copyrighted material without consent. The only reason it's so disruptive is because companies exploited untested legal circumstances to rapidly push viable LLMs into existence.
But if you did aquire the rights to the art or only use public domain art then I see no problem with that art AI
Yeah they're rushing to do shady shit while the laws are still lagging behind
By asking for forgiveness instead of permission, AI companies accelerated the growth and implementation of AI by who knows how many years. If they did everything by the book, we probably wouldn't even have the kind of frontier LLMs we have today until maybe another 5+ years.
I'd say longer honestly
And the job market would be far less disruptive.
Laws and regulations move at the speed of tar
Yeah, it's unfortunate. As a tool, it's really cool.
Are they even asking for forgiveness? I was under the impression companies were just throwing lawyers at the problem and trying to make it too expensive for anyone to fight.
Yeah that's basically what I mean by "asking for forgiveness" haha
They're all involved with copyright lawsuits as defendants, so basically that's what I mean.
I would be astonished if OpenAI or any other company actually admitted fault regarding the massive amount of copyright violation going on.
It's all still In a grey area law wise so they kinda just don't care tbh
If you try to sue they send lawyers that say it's technically not illegal and they're right so nothing happens
I think some have, but honestly it's meaningless because the damage is done and they aren't required to face any meaningful accountability.
The only actual argument I've seen from them is "you have to let us do this, because if we don't china will, and that's bad."
That's their big one, yeah.
Didn't one of the companies already complain about china copying their model
China has actually contributed the most "open source" (technically not open source, it's called open weights) LLMs to the world.
To be fair it's not a horrible argument because it is true. But ultimately it's about if you even like them more than the Chinese companies lul
As far as enabling the average person to use LLMs on their own hardware, China has been the biggest contributor to that.
So as far as I'm concerned, China isn't my enemy lol
Yea
NVIDIA, Microsoft, OpenAI, Anthropic, xAI ... these are the real companies that are a threat to the average American, not China.
it's like thanos stones, evil in bad hands
OpenAI is hemorrhaging right now tbf
They haven't really made anything that makes any real money compared to their spending
I doubt they'll go bankrupt or anything but they'll prob have to slow down
Microsoft and NVIDIA have a strong interest in keeping OpenAI afloat, though. If OpenAI collapses, it's going to look bad for them.
i hope ai falls apart at the seams until itās nothing but a forgotten seam in-between old photographs
TBH the entire business model seems ridiculous to me; there are very few contexts where I actually find LLMs / AI-assistance or whatever "helpful" -- and in basically all of them I'm not really comfortable with trusting some megacorp with my data, meaning it either has to run locally or I'm just not going to use it at all
To be fair the average person isn't this conscious about their data
I wish they were
Yep
the average person doesn't even know where their data is š¤£
Gen AI as a tool is going to be around forever. I expect it to be a ubiquitous tool in many fields of work. Similar to the growth and wider adoption of the Internet after the dot com burst. The ideal and most practical outcome is that NVIDIA, Microsoft, OpenAI etc are punished hard.
Yeah AI isn't going anywhere
doesnāt mean i canāt hope for a better world lol
But I do think there's way too much spending going on for how big its market will realistically turn out
my mom had a bunch of pictures stored on google cloud (she thought they were on her phone, and still didn't understand after I spent 5 minutes explaining) -- the only reason she even found out they were stored there was because she started getting scary messages about reaching her storage limit, and google wanted her to pay for more
the files are somewhere, surely
I mean depending on what the images are of stuff like Google cloud is whatever
Just don't put anything sensitive on there
But I wanted to put my saucy pictures there
food pics with a lot of sauce on them
ai has done irreparable damage to the three things i am most passionate about
there will never be a day i donāt hate genai
Copyright infringement has done that.
ā¦no?
What are the things if they're not copyright related?
We wouldn't even have the kind of Gen AI we have today if not for copyrighted training materials.
99% of the AI art issue is copyright infringement
i mean sure, thatās a problem, but itās not the damage iām talking about
thatās just immoral
But the damage wouldn't have existed if people didn't copyright infringe. It's like saying knives have done atrocious things because people use them to do bad things no?
That you can generate images or stories is not the problem.
it is absolutely the problem lol
How so? If you haven't trained it on anyone else's art without their consent
I don't really see the issue
No, it's not. We've had the ability to generate stuff like that for a long time. It never got this crazy because we didn't have a tool that could just ingest copyrighted work and learn to generate content based on that training data.
This situation is 100% because of copyright infringement.
The tech has always been there.
(obviously you can make it make good art but you'd need to pay the artists for the art you want to train it on)
have you seen google gemini making games like zelda, roblox? If it wouldn't used copyrighted games, then how would do it?
the damage:
- writing, it has permanently altered how people perceive written works and how youāre even allowed to write within them. most writers need to consciously write different than ai now, and it causes severe problems on a broader scale.
- visual artistry, people canāt look at any piece of art now without second guessing themself, and regular artists get told theyāre ai generating when they arenāt. itās made it even harder to get your work out there
- music, on the backs of already bad companies like spotify genai has essentially made ai music impossible to avoid, and it further suppresses real artists, small or not, in a time where making money from their music is already difficult. and that canāt be reversed or improved overtime either
sure them infringing on copyright was what led to it but itās not the specific damage iām talking about lol
iām not arguing that stealing art was Okay Actually
- Copyright infringement
- Copyright infringement
- Copyright infringement
Literally the cause of all of these emergent issues.
just that these are the specific things/ways i think itās caused irreversible damage
iām notā¦
yeah?
The first one I completely disagree with, if your writing seems like it might be written by AI that just means people think there's something uncanny about it. In the past that would be attributed to you having a weird writing style but nowadays people just attribute anything unnatural to AI
Social media sucks, right? I think so. Does that mean the Internet is bad?
good question
Gen AI is a tool.
Isn't discord social media too?
To me this is too much of a black and white stance where anything AI has to be bad. If your art could be perceived as maybe being AI, what does that say about your art? What makes art look like AI art. To me it doesn't even really matter, if the art looks good it looks good, that's all there is to it. If the art was made with an AI that was trained on other people's art without their consent that's obviously a bad thing. But if it wasn't and it produced something decent then that's all there is to it, you can go out there and make your own art that's as good if not better. AI art will never surpass what it's trained on, that's not how current models work at least
It is, yeah. So is YouTube. Discord can be bad, but overall it's probably on the good side of classification as far as social media goes.
100%, very nuanced and reasonable take. I completely agree.
as a professional artist i have noticed a varied paradigm shift in how people even treat art as a topic thanks to ai, this convo not withstanding. i already voiced my base examples so i wonāt continue but i truly do encourage yāall to listen to me, especially when we exist in a reality where genai isnāt very nuanced.
I hate thinking in absolutes.
That's because as a society we haven't been given the proper opportunity to have a discussion on AI. These companies violated copyright, trained a bunch of models on tons of copyrighted data and forcefed the AI discussion onto us overnight. It's understandable why there are so many conflicting and unformed opinions on the subject.
it being copyrighted is only part of the issue, genai has had very direct impacts on the entirety of society and art, ramifications that canāt be fixed by ānuanced conversationsā
TBH the most annoying thing about AI when it comes to writing (in my opinion, as someone that reads a lot of stuff published online) is the sheer number of authors that choose to use it but try to hide the fact that they're doing so
it's so painfully obvious when someone does
AI makes stupid errors from one chapter to the next, like a number randomly changing from 100 to 1000, and the author never acknowledges it
or the AI repeats the same sentence multiple times over the course of a chapter, slightly reworded each time
or the AI is excessively verbose, with completely unreasonable amounts of detail on story aspects literally nobody would ever care about
etc
thereās so many examples i can think of off the top of my head lol
I mean. I'm not going to be okay even with one that's "locally trained" or whatever you call it. Generative AI is a plague and I think anyone using it is impairing themselves in multiple fronts. But I'm not here to discuss it frankly, because trying to talk about it with people who actively use it is like bashing my skull into cinder blocks.
You're missing the entire point. Gen AI is nothing without data. The copyright argument is everything because it completely shapes the form that Gen AI takes in our society.
like if you want to use AI assistance in writing, more power to you, but don't try to pretend it's all you lol
Yes things shift and change in society. Change isn't always bad, even if let's say the majority of people think a change is bad sometimes it'll still happen. For example I think most people would agree modern social media is bad, but it's still a growing field. I think instead of trying to fight the inevitable it's better to figure out how to best live with it
this change is bad
I'm not saying it isn't
yeah thatās cool and all but itās not the convo iām having lol
maybe if you read what i said youād know that
It's the one you should be having instead of blaming a good tool that was created from bad intent.
i literally specified in my beginning message that iām talking about a few specific points and that the copyright stuff isnāt relevant to what iām trying to discuss rn
I think what byteflux is saying is that if companies didn't do shady shit with AI from the getgo all these bad changes that have come to the fields you love wouldn't have happened
Good tool is still a good tool, the intent matters.
i donāt believe itās a good tool tho
i think itās intrinsically evil
but yāall also use ai
Because?
If you don't use it to copy anyone else
Why is it evil
Right, we would've actually been having nuanced discussions, artists wouldn't immediately sign away their art, they'd have a choice.
i think itās a failure of the human race to wish to express themselves without the furthering of themself
i think itās had extreme ramifications on art, current artists and potential artists
i think it has philosophically irreverential, malformed and inherently evil
It wouldn't have if it wasn't trained on unlicensed art though
no, it would be
everything i believe applies with proper copyright or not
i think the act of generating art without your own skill expressed is inherently wrong
I use tools. If you can't explain why a tool is evil, you've got no argument.
If I, an artist with a very unique style didn't want ai to copy my art style I would be able to say no if the laws were in place and I would be able to keep my style and not have AI generate something akin to it.
The reason AI has invaded the art space is because it's a grey area legally so companies just trained their AI on everyone's art without consent. I think that's immoral and damaging
iām explaining my thoughts
i think that anyone generating anything through genai is inherently wrong
idk where the message is lost here iām being very direct
Right, it's a very absolute take that's seemingly based in ignorance and not any actual nuanced reasoning.
The why is lost because you don't mention it
i explained why
tbh I can agree with that sentiment, at least when it comes to art
But why do you think this? I'm genuinely trying to understand. I'm very willing to change my mind honestly I have no stake in this. I pretty much never use AI myself
i think the act of creating expression without expressing or furthering yourself in inherently wrong
if you're just generating something technical, like code or documentation or whatever, I don't think generative AI is immoral, it's just stupid
but for art, yeah; the whole point is human expression
if you're not expressing yourself it's just a lie
If using Gen AI to ingest a bunch of unformatted, tangled data and instructing it to output it into something coherent and better formatted makes me evil, guess I'm evil.
iām a professional artist. i can plainly see the concern that if āgenerative artā is easily accessible to people from a young age, there may be whole groups of artists who never progress because they donāt see a point, can ādo it easier,ā etc
and thatās only one of my many problems
yeah i do think youāre evil byte
like iāve been pretty clear about that for months lol
Tbf that's what vibe coding is to software engineering lol. And vibe coders have extremely limited success
Just like pure AI artists would
i donāt think the success matters
If you buy AI generated art, you are stupid but some arts are so similar and it will be more difficult to seperate AI from real art
also, byte, then just think iām ignorant and move on with your life
Not just me, basically half the world. People you know, people in here you know or don't. In some capacity has willingly used AI.
Sure, so your very direct take is that anyone who willingly uses AI in any capacity is evil.
So if I train an AI completely on my own work, and then use it. Is that evil too?
half the world being evil aināt news to me i get so much phobia for being a lesbian anyway lol
Isn't the AI itself an expression of me at that point?
TBH I'm still mad that LLMs even get to be called AI; this is not the AI I was sold on as a kid, it's glorified autocomplete
yes i believe so
no i do not believe so
Just wait real AI is right around the corner
Actual AI cannot exist
the duality of humankind
Surely we'll also all get replaced soon
Well I guess it depends on how you define it
Yes one might even use sarcasm
anyway real sentient ai would be cool but weāre so many hundreds of years from that (hyperbole)
To me even humans don't have complete intelligence
Average Neomuna citizen
well weāre all arguing in a discord off topic chat about ai so i think thatās clear
tbh AI in tech has been a thing long before LLMs too, think like NPC logic in games, that's always been called AI
I don't expect anyone to understand that joke
ough i think someone disturbed my light particles
call me an AI coder because I scripted some basic logic for NPCs in skyrim, oblivion, and morrowind
caught in 4K
Well nah I mean it more as in I think the human brain is pretty much no different from a computer. There's no such thing as real consciousness, we're also just a super complex algorithm
You're clearly the ai. Nice try grok
Yeah I'm pretty nihilistic. I think everything that will ever happen is already guaranteed and that we don't really actually have any choice in anything
nihilism is for five year olds
thatās my take
stupidest philosophical foundry ever
Meh. I'm open to changing my mind if there's anything to dispute it
Nihilistic, or just a fervent follower of Albert Einstein?
i donāt care enough to dispute you
itās just philosophy 101 bullshit tbh
people very quickly move on to āoh yeah that perspective is stupid. wow, iām happier nowā
If I remember, Einstein also subscribed to a deterministic universe.
not all forms of nihilism are the same; it's a family of philosophical views not a single view
iām talking about all of them
nearly as bad as stoicism tbh
nihilism i mean
I mean I'm pretty happy. I've come to terms with it and will live my life without really thinking about it. It's just that if you asked me if I think the human mind could be emulated completely by a non living thing I'd say yes
I like stoicism :)
that doesnāt surprise me
To me the only way to think humans/living things are special and have this unique "consciousness" would be via some kind of god or similar
And like I said if someone showed me absolute evidence of that I'd change my mind, I just haven't seen or experienced anything to do so yet
i mean i believe in a god and i donāt believe humans are special
I'm still undecided, but I've recently started to lean more into the idea that maybe humans are special in the cosmos at large. The Fermi Paradox is doing a lot of the heavy lifting for that, though.
though thatās also a pretty fundamental part of my belief system
What separates us from a computer then?
If consciousness isn't anything special to living things
if it were an intelligent ai? nothing
i never said otherwise
Oh okay
i donāt believe humans are special
But you still think we have free choice? That feels a bit weird to me
sure why wouldnāt we
Because a computer for sure doesn't
an intelligent ai would
Would it?
yeah
Not really no?
Everything in it would be predetermined by its programming
A set input would always give the same output
sure and the way i am is predetermined by my traumas and upbringing and environment
i still have free will
if you put me in the same situation a thousand times, like a time loop, and erased my memory each time yeah iād probably do the exact same thing every time
iām still choosing to do that thing in the moment though
You think you have free will. You (nor I) can be certain you do, though.
tbh I don't really like the assertion of nihilism that life or reality is meaningless; I prefer to think of it as something impossible for humans to know, not something impossible to exist; and I think it's insane to try and find universal meaning by extension, you should focus on finding personal meaning in your own life
Idk to me that's no choice at all
You should look up "hard determinism"
I feel like the only thing we disagree on is the definition of free choice
byte ik what determinism is lol
None of us can actually prove the concept of free will.
Well, I specifically meant "hard determinism"
ik what hard determinism is byte
i sat through way too damned many college philosophy courses
Alright, good. So you believe you have free will. Knowing it is a completely different thing.
no i know it
To me if everything is on a single track with no variance then there's no choices to be made, you can only go forward
You can't know something that you can't actually quantify.
my god told me
lol
Like I can say oh I'm gonna play pantheon today and not yasuo in league of legends
the world has told me
But I was always gonna say that
There's no way I wouldn't say that
So did I really make a choice?
you just sound depressed tbh
like thatās the reality
nihilism is rly common in people with a depressive mind
you both need hug fr
Honestly I'm not, I'm actually extremely happy right now. I got to see a childhood friend I haven't seen in years recently
because they force themselves to consider this grand scale and then they go on and on and on until they feel thereās no point or value
thatās the crux of nihilism
Well no, just because I have no choice doesn't mean there's no value
So when you make a bad call or injure someone it's predetermined and you're not at fault for drunk driving or stuff like that?
I think it's possible to be happy and depressed, tbf :)
iām stating depressive as the uh. adjective here not the state
depressive mind =/= sad
Eh, in a way? But I'm not gonna say that I wouldn't feel bad. I obviously would
And I would think it was my fault
I wouldn't be like nah the universe made me
anyway i can know it because i choose to know it
it doesnāt matter if i can prove it or whatever
or quantify it
Since like I said while I believe in nihilism I don't really think about it
I don't go around thinking how everything is meaningless
That's kind of a sad view to me. You have so many choices to make and this view would just absolve you in a way
That's called belief, not knowledge. Words have meaning.
my belief is true
like iām never going to shit on someone for believing otherwise but i know itās true
i think deias described my philosophy/religion as āneo-pagan druidic classical alchemistā so take from that what you will
Honestly to me I don't really care what the grand scheme of the universe is. Whether I do or don't have free will, If there is or isn't a god etc. because I can't prove any of it. So while yeah right now my current belief is nothing really matters I'm still gonna strive to do my best and live my best life. Because I could be proven wrong in the future
There's no reason not to do my best
your belief hinges on ability to prove so that makes sense
whereas i could never prove my belief real and donāt think it could ever be proven wrong
which i think is funny
(and nor do i try to prove it to people or convince them into my belief. this is shade at organized religion)
I still have need for pleasure, etc., if I don't have free will. I can't choose what I like, I just am.
Like if someone tomorrow showed me irrefutable proof that the christian god exists and that if I follow his word I'll go to heaven and live in paradise I'd do that lol
To me the idea of free will vs hard determinism doesn't change how I live my life. As far as life is concerned, they are the same thing. For example, let's say that free will is an illusion, that means you've never truly experienced free will in the first place, in which case why does it even matter?
Exactly
I think having enough right to talk and chatting must be free will. it would be insane If some power would mute you everytime
Huh, neat; there actually is a school of philosophy that describes (at least part of) my thoughts: pyrrhonism. TL;DR: it's impossible to know the true nature of reality, and by choosing to suspend judgment entirely and let go of the need to find an answer, you can achieve mental tranquility.
funnily enough i stumbled into my answer
I mean I guess this is pretty much what I think too
though i think thatās how it goes for people who werenāt raised religious but end up so
I just default to nihilism but I don't believe it to be the absolute truth
iāve seen other people describe it similarly so
I don't know what the truth is nor do I think I'll ever know
Whether I believe I have free will or believe I don't have free will means nothing to me. It doesn't change my thinking or decision making at all.
Why should it?
that feeling of a sudden realization that kinda āclicksā deep in you and you suddenly believe it so fervently that you canāt believe you ever thought anything else. so afterwards, you simply believe that, and thereās no way to shake it
what If you are saying this because you have free will?
if I don't have free will I have some serious questions about the thought process of the being piloting my life, tbh
absolute weirdos
This question is meaningless lul
(this is why hypotheticals like this are dumb and pointless, because it always loops around in one big circle where nothing ever changes)
Doesn't matter! I could be saying it because I was always going to say it, too :)
Yep
āis god realā doesnāt matter, if it is then who made god, if it isnāt then it doesnāt matter
⨠philosophy 101 āØ
It's all speculation at the end of the day
I like this in person, we should talk otherwise how we can help ourselves ā¤ļø
Just live your best life because you'll never get the answer is my stance
whether or not these questions matter also doesn't matter, because we have no way of knowing either way š
Right, and not knowing is really the important part.
The fact that you cannot know means you can't actually act on it meaningfully.
Just live your life.
I know I don't have free will.
that's ominous
killer go make me sushi then
On a more important note, I still don't have an educated rat
And these digital game rats definitely don't have free will
You've succeeded at distracting me long enough that Bonchon is now closed so I can't order any pickup from there. You've inflicted a critical blow against me, rejoice.
rats sadly do not live long enough to get a masters in culinary arts
my dream of owning remy will never be real
hopefully there are more to follow!
Bio engineering to the rescue?
this is what we should be spending trillions on
research on extending rat lifespans
not AI
tbf if we created a rat that could lift steel pans and with enough intelligence to cook professional meals and stuff iād likely be more scared than anything
we fixed baldness in mice
thatās smth
I just assume we already have every imaginable research for rats lol
next step: immortality
First we'd need to somehow make ourselves controllable through our hair
We also made extremely wooly mice
They need to hurry up with that fr
the cutest things ever aside from foxes? yeah
we did that
it's perfect
Can we give them furry tails?
And emotes
you can download the gif and post that tho
:peepoRiot:
lol
did you guys see they found woolly rhino dna
In a frozen wolves stomach
2?
yeah
lol
one horn maximum
unicorn lover smh
Rhinos are like so near sighted they may as well be functionally blind
nah horses have too many teeth
wth
theyāre also bad
Unlike bats, which actually have good vision but prefer to use echolocation because it's better for navigating in the dark
I do wonder if they always were
Hence, "blind as a bat" should actually be "blind as a rhino"
And yet when I scream at people and objects in the dark I get reported as a noise complaint or harassment smh
the only good animal has four digitigrade legs often ending in darker or lighter mitts, coarse to fine fur, a medium-long snout, pointy ears, cackle when happy, have bushy tails, primarily reside in colder regions, have sharp canine teeth and are semi-nocturnal
I'm guessing maybe not, if they used to be wooly. Their near blindness means they have to stay in constant proximity to food and water, right?
I wonder if we'll ever achieve peak ergonomics to the point where nothing changes for like a million years and we evolve to have peak comfort
Also, petition to change receiver of "publicly perceived as cutest aquatic animal" from dolphin to seals
Because dolphins are mega assholes
Seals are just derp
please god give me a cybernetic spine, shoulders and arms
while youāre at it replace my hips and legs
Imagine missing an instalment on your cybernetic and oops no more appendage
yeah thatās dystopia
Using klarna on your spine
i want cyberpunk utopia
Actual side quest in Cyberpunk 2077, if I remember
And then you miss the 2nd one and the cyberenforcers come and lop it off and take it away
anyway you donāt need to imagine this
cyborgpunk
this is a real thing that happens to disabled people irl right now
This is what utopia looks like
tbf anyone who uses prosthetics is in fact disabled
"Recovery" is a full on business in India at least
lmao
Firms that harass / threaten / intimidate loan defaulters
ano
how this is possible
have you hacked costco
The final stage being sending in goons to physically toss them and their belongings out of the house
Klarna baby
thatās called being evicted
this isnāt like
this is an everywhere thing
They let you pay in instalments for basically anything
loan sharks are everywhere
I think I just need a fully replaced skeleton. Spine being screwy messed up my neck, shoulders, hips, legs, ribs.....
As long as you don't end up paying interest on the payments and it doesn't cost more to pay in installments, this is funny
youād look cute with a robo spine
Is it? Don't think I've heard of it happening in Canada at least. Well, not in the way I just described
and then a % of people who pay for a hot dog using instalments forget to pay for one and get hit with fees
This is crazy lmao
Yeah you actually don't
there's no extra fee or anything
I spent $253 on my last costco visit
if you pay on time it costs the same
I've been evicted, can confirm you can be physically tossed out
Yeah
Oof, sorry to hear that
I have all of my credit payments on auto
they were actually in a little bit of trouble recently because people would forget to pay, rack up fees. and then just not pay the fees either lmao
iām not. iāll toss her out again
and they're not gonna send you to collections for like 10 bucks
into the snow with the beast
Yeah because they weren't synced up to credit unions right
It's alright, only got evicted twice in my life, the hopping between rentals was honestly worse
So no repercussions
yea
it was only for a short time though
it's actually kinda interesting, we don't really have anything like a credit score here
they just look at your income here
thank god
That sounds like it might have its own cons, though
why yes i do love abiding by an outdated system with bad rules and no real purpose
Prob
it does mean that almost nobody uses credit cards here
I don't think I've ever known anyone who uses one
i love how routinely paying my crunchyroll subscription or whatever raises my credit score. yes, i can afford this mortgage loan, iāve always paid my crunchyroll
I mean more in terms of the actual purpose for which we use credit scores here, which is to answer the question "how good is this person at meeting their financial obligations?"
I find it unhinged that you literally get punished for being fiscally responsible in the credit system
credit score doesnāt answer this at all tho
partly due to this
If you don't have enough EMIs or you're not using enough of your credit limit
You actually lose score
Absurd.
yep
Yeah I feel like the credit system is designed for one thing but does something else
Wdym, it's designed for wealth transfer, it does that perfectly
Well yeah, it's flawed because someone could be financially well off but not actually have a credit score or engage in the credit system at all for whatever reason. The credit system only works as described when people actually use it.
My credit probably sucks idk, never checked it
Well when they do check you here they do see your debts and stuff
like if you're racking up debt they'll see that
there's just no credit "score" number
Reason I say this is because the last actual bank account I had I closed with a whopping $-0.62 in it 
How does your country's financial system link with international finance then
wdym
Like how do sole business owners take investment from international firms for example
Since there's no credit score, an important part of such things
Well it's definitely a part of it. I suppose you could substitute it with base financial info
itās okay iām doing great
Instead of just a score
How
wdym how
how did you spend everything perfectly
iām just that good
My PayPal has exactly $0.50 in it 
also it was transferred out to a venmo lol
Makes sense, credit and debt still exists. So when someone is buying a house or applying to rent an apartment, what kind of scoring does the property manager use when looking at that financial history?
It's still only the 21st
I guess it would be up to them. They get to see your income, loans/credits, past mismanaged payments, debt balance in the banking system etc
obviously you have to consent for them to see any of this
Basically they need to make a judgement call in a case by case basis
instead of just having a number
i will gain access to about $1200 next year that i can invest with and stuff at least
Sounds like it's a personalized credit scoring criteria dependent on the person or organization that's reviewing the rental / mortgage / loan application, then.
yep
they get to see your financial status and make a decision if they wanna give you the loan or whatever
i have $800 in bills i need to pay tho
Credit score is impersonal and more of a standardized way of doing the same thing. So there's pros and cons, for sure.
$200 from my legally mandated doctors appointments that i literally canāt deny and $600 from some classes lol
Having to pay for something that's legally mandated is, something š
welcome to america
i am legally mandated to visit this specialist
i have 5 minute zoom calls with them every six months
Never have I heard any random fact about American healthcare that has failed to shock me
it costs me $200 and if i deny my medication is taken away
200 bucks for a 5 minute call?
yeah
sheeeeesh

it was $400 for a 5 minute call with my other specialist

what is going on 
iāve been very ill my entire life in many ways is whatās going on
at this point my family has probably paid at least a hundred thousand dollars in just my medical bills
from when i was a kid
Being legally mandated sounds like a court order or some other government order, not sure if it's the healthcare that's the issue here rather than the government refusing the cover the cost of the healthcare which they mandated.
itās mandated because if i donāt go i lose my medication
not because the government tells me to
I just pay for medication, and had a brief period where I had to pay co-pays at the clinic I go to because the government was mucking around with what my insurance covered
Are you using Medicaid, by chance?
no iām on techie insurance
additionally i only have a limited number of refills on my medication before they have to ask my specialist for more refills
(My insurance is not very good, I just haven't had anything major that it wouldn't cover)
so it's 200 bucks just to fill a prescription?
Ah, so it's an actual insurance company policy.
i also have to get my blood drawn every few months or else theyāll remove access to my medication
no just for the appointment
Ah sweet
it's only -1C
time to open a window and actually get rest
In that case, yeah screw insurance companies.
the pills are like $18 per refill
Insurance as a business model is scummy in general. Insurance and financial risk management should be the sole domain of government only, not private business.
Ah that was language barrier moment, I was trying to translate 1:1, I just meant updating the prescriptions so you could buy the medication
(my father is big in the cybersecurity sector so iām on his insurance until iām 26)
the prescription has been the same for three years
so i dunno
never rly been updated before
Heh, the sad part of that means you are actually better off than a significant portion of Americans when it comes to healthcare.
correct
š
Well when I had prescriptions I needed to do check ins for them to see how I was doing and if I still needed it they'd "refill" my prescription to let me buy more of it
I assumed that's what this was?
yeah
I have a tooth that's just gonna get removed eventually cuz the only other option is a root canal and that's about $1700 :)
thereās technically more purpose to it but thatās what it boils down to
200 sheckles is nasty work
Cyborg taught me you can Klarna anything these days! /s
I haven't had any check ins for my prescriptions 
if i wanted to doordash fast food here just for me itād be like $40 lol
I miss the days when delivery apps were just starting to come to sweden and it was sometimes cheaper to order delivery than to order pick up/take out lmao
because they all just wanted market share
tbf we also have crazy expensive food prices here in general
now it's expensive af
Yeah here food for one is like 20 bucks so you're still way worse off for sure
(same food would be like 12-14 bucks without delivery)
Friend ordered some
it came late and half the food had been eaten
seven months of this shit iām tired boss
I wouldn't be so bad if a lot of that money was actually going to the drivers.
enough snow pls
I've fortunately never had issues with deliveries
I can get a Kebab for 6 bucks here. That's like 800~ calories?
Lol we only have snow for a couple months or so
welcome to the arctic circle
All of the hard snow here is finally almost gone.
weather is great here
it's snowing here
itās snowing here too
Almost moved here
i just wanted a smoke before bed ong
Almost close to the finnish border
crazy
you might have seen a wild finn
they don't exist
-6°C/23°F rn š
don't believe the propaganda
Yeah, i'm not real
According to the "feels like" thing the wind chill makes it feel like -13°C so do with that what you will (I AM SO COLD PLEASE SEND FIRE)
Just get up from a nap
Thanks for putting Celsius there. How much is your heating's cost during winter?
let it be over
sending 9mm your way boss
I got no clue, actually. We have heat pumps in four rooms and also the internal heating system (it uses oil, it kinda isn't very good)
Well i'm actually gonna take a nap now 
comfy
I remember the heating in my old apartment stopped working one winter and I would sleep under 3 sheets lol
I ended up getting an electric oil pan or whatever they're called
One of them is giga thicc
thatās sadly not a joke
It could be -10 inside and I'd be fine under that thing
Big-ass sleeping bag for when it gets too cold (ignore the air mattress deflating)
as long as I don't move and let cold air in
that air mattress is still there from when i used it as a couch when i had a girl over lol
Mine snacks
My dad used to have doves (iirc) in an outdoor cage and foxes kept trying to eat them
smh
hell yeah
I'm kinda surprised they were able to
Seasoning
was probably dead before it know the fox was there
nah
theyāre very good hunters
oh
yeah
I thought you meant it was dead before the foxes found it
yeah they must've snuck up on it good
Dove didn't believe in free will o7
lol
I am purposefully posting this cat to interrupt your conversation. This is from over 5 years ago.
hello nyx
This is him now. He is big guy.
Here's a dog
Your dog has 5 o'clock shadow
can't let the cat supremacy continue
no i donāt like cats either
I'm the cat enjoyer. Uh. I can't really explain why, I've had them pretty much my whole life.
i just donāt like pets so
I have an aura with cats. They just like me.
Even older picture here. Unfortunately the mother here passed over a year ago. One of those little blobs is this guy though.
i have an aura with animals. they hate me and i donāt know why
itās not even mutual
Hoots adores you what do you mean
Oh he stubby
anyway iāve smoked and iāve brushed my teeth, goodnight everyone
Attempt #5000: I shall not starve my subjects this time
:o
You got your educated rat
Finished Diablo Sin War book 1, that was good.
Yep, she's researching away
I just woke up from a nap
would've slept longer but apparently blood lvls dropping low 
It's actually insane that Uldyssian's ||awakened nephalem powers straight up erased Lucion instead of banishing him to the Burning Hells.||
now get another
yea I will once one appears
not really worth making a school right now
we're loaded on fish fr
Fish? time to make surstrƶmming
we don't have cans yet
get to it
Fancy
Time for book 2, hype
God damn scrabble is too sophisticated for me
its kind of sad they made the d4 story so much worse than their books
you'd think they would just pull the same authors for a general story direction
Honestly wouldn't be surprised if they don't work at blizzard anymore and want nothing to do with blizzard
they hired external guys for the book
I'm only book 1 out of 3 into the Sin War, but so far the first book is a better Inarius vs Lilith story than D4, for sure lol
richard a knaak did a lot of other things too besides blizz stuff
It's cool they had the whole creation story with Inarius and Lilith figured out as far back as even before D2, too bad D4's campaign is kind of boring compared to what I've read of the Sin War trilogy so far.
Or what I've listened to by audiobook, rather :)
Narrator definitely is doing a good job lol
Heh, looks like the only reference to Uldyssian in a Diablo game is actually in D3
yeah the books came way later so i assume that part wasnt done pre d3
but i enjoyed it a lot
Yeah, seems they had a lot of it all there, but Knaak stitched it all together narratively into a really cool story
And straight up killed (not banished) ||Mephisto's son.||
yeah its kinda weird they weaved nephalems into d3 but its still kinda unexplored in the games
then again gamers even think lilith does nothing wrong so maybe stories are just not worth it for games
I mean all humans are basically just unawakened nephalem, IIRC.
Awakening to your powers is basically what makes you a nephalem.
Honestly if the game characters were as strong as that guy from the book there would hardly be a game 
well the powers of them vary a lot
The reference to Uldyssian in D3 is from NPC dialog:
Itherael: Only once in the history of Sanctuary has a nephalem been as powerful as you. His name was Uldyssian.
So basically Uldyssian was as strong as the D3 nephalem lmao
the old nephalem basically are the guys whose weapons/gear you find as uniques
Yeah, Uldyssian has the power ||to awaken someone's nephalem powers||, but they vary by a lot from person to person.
lol
I think the Sin War trilogy takes place before the High Heavens even knows Sanctuary exists, right?
Yeah, ||Inarius was trying to keep it all a secret.||
Had to double check.
should give it a go again but i am currently reading ultramarines/iron warriors novels in order of events
so i am a bit occupied
Iron Within, Iron Without brother.
never touched ultramarines cos they felt so bland but the novels so far are great
Ultramarines are a good chapter, the only reason to hate them is because they are overrepresented, that's all.
i just disliked the blind following old matras
so they seemed less interesting than many other chapters
Ultramarines are generally very pragmatic thinkers, adaptable and not that blindly devoted to dogma. That said, they are quite dogmatic about the codex, yes.
i'm not sure if pragmatic is their way when they follow the codex so much in general but yeah they play nicely with the theme in the books
guess it's also a good way of bringing in some intrigues in the games with ultramarines
Even among the Ultramarines, there's variability between individuals and how they interpret the codex. Not a lot, but it's a spectrum. Some are stricter adherents than others.
And Guilliman has made changes to the codex as well since his return. I think even Guilliman may have said something along the lines of being flexible and not blindly adhering to the codex.
yeah guess it's a process for them too
Also don't forget this quote from Titus in Space Marine 1:
"The Codex Astartes is a set of rules. They guide us, shape us as Ultramarines, teach us to place duty and honour above all. But how we live with those rules is the true test of a Space Marine. And you, have failed."
sure but the books are way before that i think with uriel
didn't go to well in those times
iirc the uriel novels are (way) before the games so stuff should have changed in the meantime
hidden unenabled graphics setting in beta (ignore the artifacting from upload compression ofc)
Justice 
They just went 3/6
Well it wasn't really about that lul
Did they afk or start insulting everyone?
latter
was hating on the entire team because they got counterpicked even though all they had to do was sit back and do nothing while we carried because everyone else was stomping
including me as shen vs a fiora
like bro what more can you ask for xd
it's so busted lmao
but hey it was my first time doing it because they took my panth
That item is really funky
one time abuse
Lol
If I could abuse it on panth I totally would lmao
The dirty gwen š
Didn't say it was good.
I like it
decided to try it out
kinda fun
but somehow there's a zilean every other game
that's annoying af
Ngl I'm only really playing so I can get out of emerald lmao
for some reason every few ranks you get one where it's like way more toxic
it used to be diamond but now it's emerald
I feel like gold is the same way
or maybe it's silver idk
oh wth you only need 15 wins even on iron to get the victorious skin
so basically everyone gets it no matter what
I thought when they made it so lower ranks could get it they made it so you needed to play more for it but I guess not
I play on mute all
Game feels way less toxic that way š
That's bad, if someone wants to tell you things like "gonna gank top lvl 2, don't push", which is farely common.
Not really?
I can't remember the last time I or anyone communicated something like that
What does get communicated is stuff like if someone wants you to get anti heal
But that's about it for the chat
Everything else is pings
But regardless I'll never play with mute all, the chat is part of the fun :P
They can ping
Yea, pings work too. Ping blue, ping top i guess
I revel in it x)
If someone starts calling others names that means I can start rage-baiting them 
I was calling that Viktor a baby all game for example
And rightfully so, he deserved it for how he was acting, which is why he got punished after the game
chill out poo poo head
True, but eventually I stopped doing that and started climbing š
Meh the only reason I play ranked is because the queue times are lower honestly
I used to only play normals in the past
I don't care all that much about my rank, obviously it's nice to rank up but I don't play that much to begin with
what game Cyborg ?
League of legends
LoL
bro... you do not get to complain sorry, you did it to yourself
Huh I'm not complaining?
That's a good reason tbh. I also liked the more consistency in skilllevel in ranked, compared to normals, which was more like a rollercoaster.
š¤£
True normals are a bit all over the place lol
You'll have a bronze and emerald in the same game
stop playing league bro
Why? It's pretty fun
People take games too seriously
I play at most maybe 10 games a week
Usually maybe 2-4
league is where the absolute bottom of the bottom feeders hangout for fun
2 ranked a day keep the doctor away
im not saying you, chill
I didn't say anything lol
try dota Kappa
You're not wrong. The game has some of the most toxic players, but that doesn't really mean anything
It's not like the other players can do anything to you
i mean..
Just play the game and have fun
yeah true
Not sure I agree with this
It's when you take it too seriously and sweat super hard for rank that I think it starts really impacting you
I feel like it's like that for every competitive game
I have seen some pretty toxic people on rocket league
its just competitive games in general
I don't care much if I win or lose. I'm playing a videogame to have fun either way
Imo, it got far better lately. Haven't played in a year, but before that consistently since s1. somewhere around s8 was the most toxic, or idk for sure, too long ago. But I noticed about 3 years ago, it got far better. Maybe 1 in 5 games someone was toxic. EUW, gold +
Yeah their filters and punishment systems have gotten way less lenient
You get punished super easily
the most fun you can have in RL is when you dont know how to play it
Honestly I think it's a gradient too
satisfactory is my new game atm. just pure silent bliss
I think the lower ranks are way more toxic and then it kinda smoothes out
Since the people who are super emotional about the game never really get out of the lower ranks
Obviously you'll still have super toxic people in higher ranks but it's honestly not bad
diamond is the worst in rocket league, by a country mile
In league I'd say silver or gold are the worst if I had to guess
I can't say for sure since it's been a long time since I played in those ranks
holy gigachad
no, i like that.. beast
i dunno man.. i just think humans in general are scum, and some games are like moths to a flame
to them
It's actually funny because gold has the most people in it out of any rank
You'd think it would be bronze or something
But nope, 25% of ranked players are gold
its different in rocket league for example. like the lower ranks dont know whats going on or whats possible, thats where the fun is. but then when you get to mid diamond and you miss a save or your shot doesnt hit, you will get verbally abused and they start own goaling or they just go afk so now its 2v1. its a mess.
Lol scrolled the news that CEO in Microsoft is changed in morning then I scrolled the post from last CEO in Microsoft at night
I think this will drive me nuts. I thought that season 4 announcement for LE felt small content wise, but then I thought about season 2 and it's similar in size ? Then wtf caused me to have this weird memory of massive update, because now I'm thinking of PoE2 updates and it wasn't the case either

or maybe it was indeed Abyss league in PoE2 ?
But that league did not add subclasses iirc
there really isnt anyway to judge the size of s4 before it comes out. there is just a lot of negativity surrounding LE, deserved or not, and that i think is tinting how people view it. i had a pretty long talk earlier with some people and the popular opinion is that s4 is small but no one really seems to be able to quantify what small is compared to big very well. i also think that having a 'faction' and a 'tree' to play with makes s2 seem bigger than it was.
i see a lot of complaints about poe2 being small too and i just dont see it
it will be always compared to poe 2 whatever we want or not..
Till PoE 2 release and we could actually see how much effort they will add to one league
yeah. which definately doesnt do LE any favors. but i agree its pretty unavoidable for the majority of people
Bro killed her and then complains about there being an unburied body
I find the complaints about the campaign funny when people don't care about it anyway
the only game you can compre poe2 to is wolcen, because they are both bottom of the barrel games
wolcen has the edge though..
Played a round of Deadlock with a friend against bots
Our mid minions were bugged and kept attacking air behind the walker
and one of our bots had pathfinding issues and got stuck underground for the entire round 
Huh. Never seen that before
Yeah
He ended up having 3.7k player dmg & 377 obj dmg
no items apart from queued ones
But you know the things that the character with the .. was it cat or rat? transformation can go through in mid boss arena?
he was stuck behind that
Kept walking up the slope and then back to it
Calico? And I think you're referring to the vents, not 100% certain (something broke the performance for me so I haven't played since the big map update)
oh⦠thatās badā¦
Yeah Calico
Tbf, it was a bot and we did end up winning despite the enemy having 2 tanks & 2 assassins and we didn't have tanks
Tbf there isn't really tank/dps/support/etc splits in Deadlock, not traditionally anyway
I'd say it's more apt to put the split in something like "front-line brawler, back-line/front-line damage, buffer/debuffer"
Billy and Abrams! I like Billy. I don't like Abrams, it's always a coinflip on if the Abrams is going to be actually good or literally the worst player I have ever seen.
itās just funny cause 3.7k damage is accomplishable before early game farming is over lol
in a traditional match
actually iām just playing the british museum
so
gunna steal your stuff now
and this isnāt rly a joke
I uhh ended up having 211k player dmg that round
Wish I had taken a screenshot of the minions just attacking air
If enemy minions (or heroes) came close they'd go attack them
But the moment they died or left they went back to that same spot to attack air again
Out of curiosity, who do you seem to be gravitating towards? I'm always curious which characters people play
I like being Paige and Holliday so far
I haven't actually played too many characters so far really
Infernus feels fine too
And Graves felt fine too for that 1 game I played as her
loser high schooler ong
I can say I didn't like the gun that Seven has
seven should put a lightning bolt through graves head for falling for the lichās trap
literally the entire cast of the game is telling her the lich is bad and she goes ānuh uhā
dumbass high schooler
Seven's gun is dogwater, his abilities are where it's at. His ult, despite him getting nerfed like 6 patches in a row, is still so annoyingly strong that it can completely wipe an enemy team
But what if Lich good? (is not actually good)
when the mortal enemies of the damned universe are in agreement that the lich is bad, the lich might be bad
So far I kinda hate playing against Haze
Apollo also usually wrecks me if I'm playing Paige
Holliday is really good, needs some mechanical skill to pull off her combos consistently but she can kill almost anyone in a couple seconds if you do it right. Paige is a very good pick right now as well, she provides a lot in pretty much every fight.
Infernus isn't really standing out on either end, he's pretty much the "yeah this is fine" point of balance in the game, I personally think they should try to make every character feel like him balance-wise.
Eeeeeeveryone hates Haze. Also Apollo is genuinely just overpowered right now, he'll get some tuning over the next few weeks
Tbh I suck with the combos of Holliday and just blast heads mostly
Valid tbqh
But I also haven't taken her to an actual match but only tried with bots so far
iāve been learning ashe in overwatch
in the process of learning that iāve learned iām very good at ashe
I remain in Lifeweaver prison
One of the friends I invited to the game played his first game against actual players after he started feeling like he got a hang of the stuff
went like
0/9/15 and got told to "never play this again" and worse things
Yeah the community sucks. Turn off chat.
theyāre steam fans
steam fans are notoriously bad
me when the half life player says half life 1 is the best game ever actually and if steam still made games nobody else on the market would make money
Half Life sucks and I'll die on this hill. Clunky ass game with no fun to be had and a mediocre story.
Only played half life 2
enjoyed my time in black mesa
I thought "the best game ever" was d2 
I'm obviously not being serious with this
I haven't actually played Dishonored 2
It's one of the games I keep on meaning to play
And never get around to doing it
dishonored 2 has better level design and gameplay but dishonored 1 has better story
this is primarily because the dlcās for dishonored 1 are crazy good
the dishonored 1 dlcās are the best part of the entire series so
Dishonored 3 someday....
dishonored 3 soonTM
I didn't play the dishonored 1 dlcs either
i donāt personally count deathloop as being dishonored 3 despite the fact that itās a sequel
iād say itās more a side story, same with death of the outsider
@twilit mountain i just realized that my own writing having a continuous universe despite the fact that sometimes the writing in it is in entirely different genres might spawn from my childhood love of dishonored and how it does the sameā¦
Tbh I do kinda want to play more deadlock now
buut it's probably better that I start relaxing for the evening and get ready for early sleep š¤
disnhored franchise ended with last episode death of outsider
they would need make new trilogy and way || to make source of powers ||
uh
no
dishonored is still an ongoing franchise, look at deathloop
also that's not how the void works
The Outsider was a man-made creation made from an orphan child born in the Month of Darkness. A cult used him and ritualistically sacrificed him to create a "god" of the Void, which created a connection between the Void and our plane that could be exploited. The Void itself does not and could never die with the Outsider, as he's a subjugate of its power, just the immediate link is severed. Leviathan's, whale bone and leviathan bones would all still exist and could serve as power sources of the Void. Additionally, other entrances or exploits could be found, much like the Eye of the World that Billy uses -- which is where the Outsider was sacrificed. The Void is more powerful than the Outsider ever could be or was.
Also they could just set in the same time period with different stories, in the past, etcetera
Much like the books
dishonered's game visuals and art style were amazing
I don't remember story because it's been to long but I remember killing enemies in different ways was so fun
and the skill progression in the game was satisfying too
I think there was a skill we could teleport
it was so cool
I believe that's the very first thing you have as Corvo yea
yeah, every character has some form of a teleport traversal skill
daud and corvo share blink
emily gets the most op one
and billie gets to place smth and swap with it
that's why it has proper ending..
Going somewhere beyond with all that what happened from start of series to end of last game would be just too much nonsense..
We don't need go to discover "void" or some BS (that would just be like bad written manga..)
Just making another character with same powers in 4th game.. This isn't some kind of assassin creed and hope it wouldn't become one
even 3rd continue of dishonored was unexcepted but welcomed since it made little deeper to lore but that's..
what joining the labor pool at the ripe age of 4 does to a man š
we already have a forth dishonored game, itās called deathloop
I've ordered some kenyan tea 
Would rather new Arx Fatalis (prequel before end of sun or something) or Prey..
I'd love new Dark Messiah game, but surprisingly there is one upcoming game that looks like it
Dark messiah has successor in upcoming games, Arx Fatalis is just about mods so far where mostly never got released..
Monomyth should have been next "arx fatalis" but their "EA" is now freeaking loooong that i'm afraid if it ever get released
I've tried Monomyth out, I did not like it tbh
oh yeah, the game I'm waiting for is Fatekeeper
https://store.steampowered.com/app/2186990/Fatekeeper/
hopefully it will deliver
Imagine having to sit through this not able to surrender while your opponents Wincondition is just flexing at you for almost a minute straight 
Oh man LoR. I remember when that deck was semi-meta for a bit and people would just force quit the app
Yeah it's my all time favorite deck in it. I was so sad when rotations first started and they yeeted xerath lol
Both azir and xerath are in currently but a good amount of the cards you'd wanna use are still rotated so it's still not the best
Don't think I've played against mono shurima in ages lol
Ah rough. I basically stopped playing once they announced they were stopping pvp updates. It's a fun deck but really gets run over by aggro/tempo if I remember right
Honestly there's a pretty popular kata deck right now and I actually do decently vs it. But yeah generally it struggles with those
The worst thing to ever happen to it were the explorer cards
Because now everyone has landmark removal
So you have to rush to get spell shield on it
Oh that's right, I totally forgot about those cards. Basically mandatory to have some in your deck. Once they went down the route of explorer cards + things like Seraphine making card advantage not matter anymore I started to really dislike the meta
I was a big Thresh Nasus player (+anything that let me cheat out big units early), but I liked grinding games out by being more efficient and that whole archetype just does not care
I don't know what's in rotation at the moment, but highly recommend Yeti Remitter if you want to play a casino deck. Basically, get abominable yeti onto the board by turn 5, then play remitter to kill it and get a 10 cost unit. 2/8 chance to win the game with atakhan and Cithria, 3 ok options in Arbiter, Heisho, and She Who Wanders, 3 š options in Bandle, Plaza, and Scuttlegeist
good morning, 10 days left before the free day
No power to write a review + no idea where to start a review + no idea should I write that in Chinese or in English
English please to help combat the negative unless Chinese Reviews are hurting it more
there are a lot of valid reasons to leave a negative review on LE lol
There are valid complaints for sure, but at least have it be for something that's a problem in the actual game: not I'm going to leave a bad review b/c Krafton
