I'm reposting my own suggestion for the new system in place.
Make it so your followers can have nightmares:
-
If you don't interact with them, the nightmare last until the end of the night, make them tired for the day and loosing faith
-
If you interact with them (IDK, talking, hugging them ?), they go back to sleep like nothing happened, and you gain faith (or they do)
-
You can craft plushies (of yourself?) to give to members more prone to have nightmares (nightmares occurrence depends on how you got them, like if it's from a boss, less likely to have one, but if you get them in the dungeon with the "They killed all my family and I'm the only one left" type of recruit, they're more likely to have nightmares) so they can be comforted while you're not here (maybe prevent faith reward so it's balanced?)
-
Finally, the nightmare chances should decrease each time you heal a nightmare (but you won't be able to hug your followers as often and that's a problem)
