#ideas-feedback-discussion

1 messages · Page 40 of 1

quick tapir
#

a

void raft
#

Banishing touch is immune to NER?

glacial rock
void raft
sand rain
#

Cries in f2p

void raft
#

Bounty hunt wasn't worst SP's idea

glacial rock
#

Then what was?

void raft
#

Banishing touch

#

Lol

glacial rock
#

Let me guess banishing touch?

#

Knew it

void raft
#

I will be laughing if thats intended behaviour

karmic fable
#

Whoever made the idea of Ban touch not being able to be cleansed is dum

#

I already saw a ban touch guy in PvP, safe to say this game is not my thing anymore

void raft
#

That has to be a bug, known since burning hands was added into the game. But they are too lazy to fix bugs

#

Still waiting for vulnerable to be working properly

final flint
#

@umbral comet Any kind of Trading is in the list of suggestions that shouldn't be suggested.

glacial rock
#

Pins

alpine creek
#

hmmm, pretty sure I posted an idea regarding resource dungeon. I guess it was deleted

void raft
final flint
#

Probably the latter.

#

Ima play osu!.

signal lance
#

@valid kite Could you try balancing that relic Idea

valid kite
#

Ok thanks for the feed back! 😊

glacial rock
#

The relic is just bad.

signal lance
glacial rock
#

Both

signal lance
#

No that relic at its original state is OP

glacial rock
#

Badly op

signal lance
#

oh

glacial rock
#

See

#

It is badly op it burns my eyes

#

Also that heal. 15% will really help me only the long run

signal lance
#

The first part of the relic is good but second part needs a rework

glacial rock
#

A whole rework on the second part

#

Yea I can agree

void raft
#

@shut slate elementium dungeon similar to mythic ones was suggested multiple times

shut slate
#

Ok

void raft
#

@cunning rose that would be broken

rigid thorn
#

ZHC doesnt even hold an amuelt

#

amulet*

#

lol

void raft
#

Xiron cant hold essence, but there is xiron's essence

rigid thorn
#

Yea but still

#

if he actually had like the pure amulet in him

#

would make more sense

void raft
#

@karmic fable more adventure map islands idea is in the list of ideas that should not be suggested

karmic fable
#

Oh didnt know that

#

What about gifting legends pass. It would be pretty helful for youtubers and the people with no payment methods

void raft
#

This is first time i see such idea

clear stump
#

gifting pass is a repeat

#

buying pass with gems is alsoa repeat

gritty widget
#

@haughty gull What does that even mean??

haughty gull
#

@gritty widget wdym?

void raft
#

feedback probably

haughty gull
#

yes but what is his doubt

#

?

void raft
#

do you know that war monsters can be used in el colosal?

haughty gull
void raft
#

ping nervouschamless

clear stump
#

What

#

You can get gems outside of the pass bruh.

haughty gull
void raft
#

is vampir trait repeat or was it effect in suggestion before?

haughty gull
clear stump
#

No. I dont.

#

So whatever that was above is kinda just offtopic gibberish to me.

#

Lol

void raft
#

whats the problem with war shop if the only change is that all war monsters are available at once?

#

it didnt become worse in any way

haughty gull
#

so u can complete your collection easily

void raft
#

tbh they should just bring back 72h challenges or other way to easily obtain legendaries

#

i just got offer to buy varuna for 249 gems Sonnorsmallconcern

haughty gull
#

the problem is that is hard to get old monsters and war shop was one way

clear stump
#

@eager wren you do know theres many many monsters with skills that do that... lol

#

Soul hugger for example

void raft
#

cuz we definitely need more vampires

haughty gull
#

its fine to have moves that is like lifesteal but make it as a trait we could break the game

#

also about banishing touch is simple (NER should have clean it, thats all)

void raft
#

i am not for vampiric trait or effect, but kraster exists

haughty gull
#

i could say its not a attacker more should be like a bulky

#

so its fine to have him

#

wait

#

it could be for the new megataunt monster bc i dont get it why does he have dmg boost instead of shield or heal life

eager wren
signal lance
#

@glacial echo read the pins since any kind of trading Idea is banned

glacial echo
#

Oh didn't see sorry

sour vortex
#

I have a new trait idea

glacial rock
glacial rock
#

@stable dew wouldn't people just get so many avarters so they can farm them?

stable dew
#

I mean socialpoint only has them available for less then their price in the shop in so many places and by having some form of incentive for players it would cause people to want to participate more in events.

signal lance
#

@low comet I wanna ask how would that be beneficial? if anything that's either going to get completely Ignored or make the people who buy the legend pass get more resources if anything that should be free that way at least the F2P players get something out of it

clear stump
#

in comparison to regular gold pass i wouldn't pay more than $5USD for that

#

seems too pointless

#

FallenWarrior I'm not seeing much point to your idea isaThonk I feel like you need to give it some full thought before suggesting, bc otherwise it's just "a monster with this skill" which goes to #monster-ideas

signal lance
#

@karmic fable I think the Idea is neat but the part with the Corrupted Morgz should probably be in #monster-ideas

#

Its alright and the Idea actually sounds really good

void raft
#

Are some people obsessed with youtubers' monsters 🤔

signal lance
glacial rock
void raft
#

I just saw assassin trait. How being murderer makes you immune to these tortures

glacial rock
#

Lol

void raft
#

And to death countdown

glacial rock
#

Make immune to torture while your at it

clear stump
#

sus!!

#

you could probably look at the 3000 or so submitted ideas and see how many are in there in some way, shape or form.

#

and in fairness, you'll be doing me a favour, bc i am quite curious myself lol

void raft
#

@rare eagle there is "do all other goals and get 3 gems" goal

rare eagle
#

@void raft that's not the point it gives me a reason to stay on the game and not just pick it up for 2 minutes collect my stuff and then get off

void raft
#

MW, race, and pvp are good reasons to stay online

#

You could just leave game for hour doing nothing to get these gems anyway

random sand
#

is it a good idea to bring back sharing is caring event during end of easter...

cursive topaz
#

I think you should show leads and Co leads who comes online on the team chat as there is so many people that join a team during the races and do nothing to contribute to team success , this would help players monitor their team and filter out the non contributors

void raft
#

@cursive topaz that was suggested dozens times before

cursive topaz
#

And it needs to be done!

clear stump
#

Repeating a suggestion does not do anything good

cursive topaz
#

Well it's a first suggestion from me! Chill out!

grand haven
#

First suggestion from you, 100th suggestion from many

#

repeats always get deleted here

clear stump
#

It would be a good idea to remain calm and read the pinned messages, NotTheOne :)

karmic fable
#

Any chance the golden frame can be available for f2p members and maybe add silver too? Since there’s already bronze frame

slim sedge
#

uh

#

what gold frame?

#

do you mean the one from the race?

karmic fable
#

Yeah

slim sedge
#

just do a lot in the race lmao

#

also it's temporary anyway so it doesn't even matter

karmic fable
#

Actually not from race. From legend pass 1

#

And should be permanent as bronze is too

void raft
#

Suggest random frame chest then

karmic fable
#

Or instead of a random frame chest. It could be worked for?

#

Bronze given at start. Then silver then golden

#

How could u work for it is the question

void raft
#

Level maybe

#

Like achievements

karmic fable
#

Yeah

#

Rusty bronze, bronze, rusty silver, silver, rusty gold, gold?

#

Maybe it could be from ur profile level?

#

Frame: Lvl 1 rusty bronze. Lvl 25 bronze. Lvl 50 rusty silver. Lvl 75 silver. Lvl 100 rusty gold. Lvl 125 gold. Lvl 150 ultimate shiny?

void raft
#

Similar to egg avatars, but for level instead of years

karmic fable
void raft
#

I dont think there is egg avatar for playing two years

#

Same for playing 4 years

karmic fable
#

Really weird I don’t see why not

#

I guess it’s not a big deal having a 1 year off between

clear stump
#

Sailor... you can get all of those mons in 11 days including Wang... MW exists lol

void raft
#

Tbf, not everyone can watch videos in MW

ashen palm
#

I struggle to watch MW videos as the internet is terrible here and it limits the monsters I can manage to get

void raft
#

I think similar idea about marathon was suggested

raven shale
clear stump
#

I know, so exciting

raven shale
#

4 down, 96 more to go

signal lance
#

Honestly I don't mind the MW things I just do them while I watch a movie

raven shale
#

Having the time of my life here

#

The satisfaction when you get a 10 or less second ad tho

void raft
#

i like that arguing about MW, while some players have no videos there at all

strong snow
#

What about a slow megataunt trait tank with megataunt as a trait but they start with trait disable as an SC?

#

Possibly a resurrection block to both teammates and enemies if that’s too strong too

#

The trait disable would (ofc) prevent him from initial megataunt which would prevent him from being too overpowered (at least in my mind), the same way that it does for Glubu

clear stump
strong snow
#

Yes

#

Another idea I had was a monster with... I don’t know, (let’s say water protection for now) as a trait

#

And then had hydrophobic shield

#

So it would be a tank, maybe not megataunt as that might be too strong

#

Probably just taunt

#

Or I could make it a support with high sustainability

#

Similar to Fatid almost

#

With resurrections and the like

#

But rather than huge healing, it’d be shields with their corresponding resistances

clear stump
#

@tawdry gorge this is something suggested many times before and would be incredibly disjointed and broken if we matched based on monster level

tawdry gorge
#

oh ok, sorry, i didnt know

void raft
#

and you can edit messages in discord

signal lance
#

@karmic fable I think you wanna increase the damage abit since 10k damage is easy to do

#

30k

#

There is nothing stopping us from using a Master rat, Spek and MT Combo

#

Change of plans

#

Vishamah, Spek, and MT Combo

#

And?

void raft
#

That sounds like free way to get a lot of gems

#

I wonder how much gems could steamwrath get

void raft
#

Thats still free way to get a lot of gems

karmic fable
#

Sp is way too Money hungry to give players practically free gems because if they did that no one is gonna buy gems and they want money

slim sedge
#

utterly broken way to get gems

karmic fable
#

Yea but it might be more balanced if it stayed and you could only play once a month

#

Also the gems need to be decreased

void raft
signal lance
#

Also thats copyright grounds right there

final flint
#

@karmic fable That's literally just Solgaleo.

lethal wraith
final flint
boreal eagle
#

@fluid sable don't discuss here

slim sedge
#

this channel is literally meant for discussing ideas lmao

void raft
boreal eagle
signal lance
#

OMG we have more dream stuff

#

Someone add another tally mark to the score board

void raft
#

at least not technoblade

slim sedge
#

still cringe

karmic fable
#

These kids wont stop coming

boreal eagle
grand haven
#

Idea - Future era:
Celestial Era

When the Lord was defeated, cosmic portal was opened again but it became stronger. It is now called celestial portal and the monsters that enters it must handle its power to become a celestial monster or else, they will die. Monsters in this era will also have same stats with the corrupted ones and they can also hold obscure talents and obsidian relics.

The special thing about the celestials is their ults/special skills will no longer be random or RNG but it can be trigger every 3rd or 5th turn of the monster (depending on their ult). However, their ults will now cost 100 stamina so those who can cycle won't be broken.
Feel like 100 stamina cost isn't gonna help much when you can stamina regen, double stamina pool, and also just holding stamina regen relics or Unholy Vigor. Doesn't sound like much of a balance to me

void raft
#

When players want new era Sonnorsmallconcern

grand haven
#

New era: Amogus is here omg

karmic fable
#

new imposter monster
Kills every monster in 1 hit

#

omg1!!!1

fluid sable
#

Thats too op

lethal wraith
#

nonono

#

it has a 1cd move that instakills (now its countered by cda)

#

it also has imc, true vision, and sc: stam regen

void raft
#

@real schooner part about building was suggested a lot of times

clear stump
#

"Make a Flamingo youtuber monster:

#

Who is ue

void raft
#

Another youtuber monster Sonnorsmallconcern

rigid thorn
#

Its a roblox youtuber

slim sedge
#

ew

#

youtube monsters

karmic fable
#

I'm saying for the gem event the person suggested

signal lance
#

With Patience you can get over 120 gems a week

#

And the tales event last 1 week

void raft
#

If you dont spend gems on everything you can spend them on, you have more than enough and eventually you will have more than thousand spare gems

signal lance
#

So you can get those gems before the tales event even starts

void raft
#

Tale monster cost about 120 gems

rigid thorn
#

@lethal wagon just like dragon city you mean?

signal lance
#

That sounds horrible

rigid thorn
#

Yea

#

Its quite annoying thete

#

Collecting food tasks are like 30

#

And take time

glacial rock
#

Bruh why give gems on tier 5+? Wouldn't people just farm it?

signal lance
#

@glacial rock Not to mention you get 3 free tier 5 chest from the Multiplayer challenge

glacial rock
#

It all depends on how much gems too

signal lance
#

5 - 10 gems is what I am thinking

wise surge
#

The single player race for rewards has already been done. It was called bounty hunt and it sucked. Plus we already have team race.

#

Maybe the gems in multiplayer chests idea could be refined. For instance it could be a small amount like 3-5 in tier 5 or maybe it could be only tier 6 and 7 and give more?

pearl yew
#

Nah because you could ask specific questions and you wouldn't have to search for them

void raft
#

@pearl yew there is such channel, but you need pupil role to access it

pearl yew
#

Oh

#

I think it's kinda dumb that you need certain roles to access certain channels

void raft
#

Gems in high tier chests wouldnt be bad, at leash in higher pvp leagues, considering that in low pvp leagues you get gems at the end of each tournament

void raft
pearl yew
#

Yeah

void raft
#

I dont and wont say how many gems there should be. This is up to SP, if they will ever make such thing

pearl yew
#

Yeah I think it would be 1 gems for tier ones 2 gems for tier twos etc.

#

What's that

#

Ok

void raft
#

What's wrong with everyone having master rat?

#

Master rat is meta only because unrelenting assault

pearl yew
#

Yeah

void raft
#

How often do you see him without UA?

pearl yew
#

I mean without ua he is a good support still

signal lance
void raft
#

Most rats that i have seen have UA

pearl yew
#

Saw a few that were support

#

?

#

I'm kinda confused by what you're trying to say

void raft
#

Rat is just the best for UA. Spammable AoE skill that also boosts damage from itself

pearl yew
#

Yeah true

void raft
#

And self NER + ET

#

Why lindworm?

#

I very rarely see rat and lindworm in one team

#

Rat goes first without lindworm, and self NER

#

Rat with UA is attacker even if 3 speed runes

pearl yew
#

Why would you run team speed on rat tho

void raft
#

Believe guy from L1. Most likely rat has 3 or 2 speed runes and it still wipes out your team in 2-3 turns

pearl yew
#

Well I use spekthra and she's like ten times better than rat

void raft
pearl yew
#

Nah I have both and I have UA and I wipe the floor will team

#

And plus the healing block helps

void raft
#

Spekthra with UA Sonnorsmallconcern

pearl yew
#

I'm in champion 1 right now but I was in L3

#

I gtg

slim sedge
#

news flash: if an attacker is given UA and is rank 4/5, they will mop the floor with your team

rigid thorn
#

Yeah they gon bring out Mop and be like:" yeah im mopping the meta"

lethal wagon
#

@rigid thorn Yeah

lethal wraith
#

@karmic fable im guessing you mean more adventure map levels cuz if so thats a repeat

karmic fable
#

Yea

void raft
#

ideas like that are in the list of ideas that shouldnt be suggested

#

@cursive topaz that was suggested before

cursive topaz
void raft
#

and is in the list of ideas that should not be suggested

#

if idea was suggested once, you dont need to suggest it again

cursive topaz
void raft
#

Please do not suggest the following, it will be immediately removed!
Adding a feature to discard your PvP eggs.
Hatching Guardian.
Grand Duel Tickets in Classic Duel Rewards
Adding monster X to book Y.
Golden Legends Pass (or the monster) obtainable via f2p means.
Rune Slots/Rune Removal for Gold.
Trading of any kind.
Eggs from Lab->Storage when crafted.
Forsaken Souls in Grand Duels.
Extra Space/Islands.
Island Edit mode.
The return of Global Chat.
Online Indicator.
Technoblade monsters/Corrupted Warmasters, that's for #monster-ideas
And more!

wintry basin
#

yeye okay okay

cursive topaz
# void raft its pinned in <#469811533762002944>

I don't understand, why it can't be requested more than once, if anything if its been requested more than once, why isn't it something thats apart of the game yet? Just curious.... (you don't ask, you won't know)

void raft
#

because ideas are moved in voting channel, and you can just upvote it there

#

repeating existing idea does nothing

#

and why this isnt part of the game only SP know

cursive topaz
#

Guessing*

void raft
#

pretty sure its in voting channel already

cursive topaz
#

Ahh thank you, I'll have a look then

void raft
#

@drifting veldt discuss/comment ideas in this channel

grand haven
#

@karmic fable @karmic fable @karmic fable discuss ideas here

karmic fable
#

oh right sorry

#

oop srry

karmic fable
#

@karmic fable isn't monster legends already f2p

karmic fable
#

o

#

being f2p is a HUGE disadvantage

#

monster legends is more like a p2w

#

banishing toucj and ua

#

i agree

karmic fable
#

and bt cant be cleansed

#

ua was already op and bt was the cherry on top to infuriate everyone

#

literally u need 3 monster with sudden death immunity

#

or area traits like pumpseed and lonradh

#

its just unfair

#

paying should only give you minor boosts or cosmetic stuff in my opinion

#

not a whole edge over others

#

its just unfair that p2w get HEAVILY prioritized

#

yea

#

and bt is making me consider leaving the game

#

i was already annoyed with ua

karmic fable
#

mmmmmm

pearl yew
#

@karmic fable there are monsters that can revive but not ones that bring back themselves with a trait

grand haven
#

sounds like a useless trait

#

ngl

karmic fable
#

yea

grand haven
#

like 1hp revive, what for

pearl yew
#

I think it could be useful

karmic fable
#

1hp ;-;

pearl yew
#

Or it could be built in for grave digger

karmic fable
#

grave digger?

pearl yew
#

The trait

karmic fable
#

hm

#

there is a hero called The Undertaker i think

#

he could revive ppl for half there hp or full

pearl yew
#

.

#

Yeah but it's not his own trait

karmic fable
#

this guy

#

whats the point of a trait tho

#

if ur just gonna have 1hp

pearl yew
#

Yeah I know who you were talking about

pearl yew
#

Do you want me to make it so you revive 10% of your normal hp

karmic fable
#

;-;

#

just no point of a trait

pearl yew
#

Y

#

I'm gonna leave

void raft
#

Revive trait is useless
All monsters with uriel essence :Sonnorsmallconcern:

wispy ember
rigid thorn
#

For pupils lol

#

And you understood that a bit wrong

rain spire
#

so uhm, what you think of my idea?

karmic fable
rain spire
#

look at the submit ideas channel

karmic fable
#

nah too op

signal lance
#

Also 25 sounds to low for those kind of rewards so something like 35 stages sound good

rain spire
#

ok

signal lance
#

@tardy condor The Idea sounds good Until you realize a Monster holding that rune is now either Slower, Weaker or Easier to kill since that means they have to sacrifice a rune slot for a rune that might not even help them when they could just hold a rune that would actually help them

tardy condor
#

I know that's the point but imagine they GET that special skill like latalises foretold doom

#

but i see what you mean

#

it would take a negative effect just for a chance but remember it's still a choice

signal lance
#

True

#

But the Idea does sound cool

signal lance
#

@ancient sonnet that has already been suggested multiple times

ancient sonnet
#

Oh ok I deleted it

drifting veldt
#

@void raft Thanks for telling me

karmic fable
#

how is my traveling merchant idea

clear stump
#

Merchanty

#

I advise you provide done example offers of what be can provide

void raft
#

I got ulted twice in a row and lost fight because of that, and now i see ult runes in submit ideas Sonnorsmallconcern

coarse monolith
#

Gold 11 runes

#

game changing for the gamers

shy matrix
shy matrix
glacial rock
shy matrix
glacial rock
shy matrix
shy matrix
signal lance
#

We do not Tolerate spam

glacial rock
#

Yuh

#

Forcing us to be quiet smh

signal lance
#

So please I advise that you delete it before you are promptly reported and either Muted or kicked

shy matrix
#

Cry

void raft
grand haven
#

the hell did i miss

signal lance
final flint
karmic fable
#

wow didnt even delete it

boreal eagle
# shy matrix Cry

@clear stump can you mute this guy cuz he spam some emojis and he said "keep quiet" but he didn't trust us.

clear stump
#

@shy matrix I will tell you once to not spam. If you come in here again to spam, I am happy to remove your role and restrict your access to the server.

karmic fable
#

Hey Isabelle I noticed the voting channel has been quiet lately. Everything ok?

#

It looks like your the only one that posts there. Maybe u should find someone that could help u with that channel too to take away some of the load from u?

void raft
#

Migration of ideas happen rarely, but in great amount

clear stump
#

I do it when I can Kassan, currently spending a good portion of time studying for final exams in just over a months time.

#

I will spend an hr or two on Monday migrating ideas over.

proven sparrow
#

Make legendary habitat obtainable through missions for make it 30% cheaper

clear stump
#

@wheat needle This channel exists for discussion about ideas. Please use it.

clear stump
wheat needle
#

ah whoops, my bad

proven sparrow
#

Is not an idea?

#

Seems like an idea to me

void raft
#

@karmic fable exchanging gold for gems was suggested, and that would be too easy way to get gems

clear stump
#

If you want an idea to go into the game, this is not the channel for saying what you want to be implemented.

proven sparrow
#

Oh ok

#

hanks

balmy oriole
#

@karmic fable as much as I’d like it to exist, people would just abuse the Gold - - > Gems guardian, and it wouldn’t be nice at all

shy matrix
#

Aww

slim sedge
#

what is it with people wanting pokemon related stuff in ML

tranquil forge
#

who said that?

slim sedge
#

at least if you're going to suggest it, make it so that it's not utterly roadkill

tranquil forge
#

oh i see it

rain spire
#

@karmic fable that idea will be too easy to get gems, I say is pretty bad because is better off to get gems from currency, dungeons and roulette wheels

void raft
#

@somber wagon one idea per message

glacial rock
void raft
#

Imagine playing ml in discord

lethal wraith
#

finally we can play monster legends on the (official) monster legends discord on discord

karmic fable
#

LOL

wispy ember
#

@wind heron that would be op since no one can recharge and a lot of monsters are based on stamina draining and that would make them useless

wind heron
wispy ember
#

And everyone would use that monster probably with 2 megataunts

wind heron
#

Again it would be fun to have something like that

wispy ember
#

No it would be OP

wind heron
#

It could last for only 1-2 turns with the skill having a 3 turn CD

wispy ember
#

And knowing social point if they decided to do it they would probably make it so you would have to pay for that monster

wispy ember
#

I don’t want another OP thing in the game to worry about

#

Also knowing social point they would probably release a f2p counter to that monster so nobody would use it anymore and the people who payed would’ve wasted their money

void raft
#

Would be better if shock could block anticipation(if it dont rn)

rigid thorn
#

it doesnt

#

cuz it doesnt count as a skill

slim sedge
#

it doesn't block anti right now, assuming that you mean the anti monster having shock

#

unless they shadow buffed Shock

rigid thorn
#

then kurai is useless b)

slim sedge
#

I doubt anyone has actually seen that scenario

#

almost no one meta has shock

rigid thorn
#

but even then shock only blocks extra turn skills

#

so

void raft
#

Anticipation isnt skill, but it also gives ET, so shock should block it

#

And that would make shock a bit more useful

pearl yew
#

@rain spire that's really dumb

karmic fable
#

fr

signal lance
#

If that buff ever existed UA would be more OP then it is right now

karmic fable
#

do u think submitting ideas is just a waste of time because i feel like they wont even add it to the game

wise surge
#

Anticipation ignore isn't a good idea. Because no one would want to fight it. It would basically destroy the anticipation meta and make Charmless super OP

#

The end of era maze is a good idea. But it would imply that there is an end to this era. Which in pretty sure no one wants

karmic fable
#

have they even add any of these ideas to the game

wise surge
#

Negate and reverse stamina are also not a very good idea. It would make stamina deniers that much more OP and people already have a problem with Fractbot

signal lance
wise surge
#

Oh nevermind

karmic fable
wise surge
#

In what way

karmic fable
#

its just old monsters but bigger and hard to beat

signal lance
#

Its still a type of Titan dungeon so it counts

wise surge
#

It gives you Lutum. Up to 1350 in 3 days. Which is really good. And it isn't hard with ranked up tanks.

karmic fable
#

the rewards is good but its just idk boring

wise surge
#

It may be boring but it's easy and if the reward is good I don't care about the rest of it. I just want the Lutum lol

wise surge
#

Free R5 Spekthra in only a couple weeks

karmic fable
#

well they rlly needa add these ideas to the game

#

some of em are actually good and will help the game or make the game better to play

wise surge
#

I agree

signal lance
wise surge
#

Yeah

#

The elite and forsaken monsters were great. Better skills but not ranked up stats.

karmic fable
#

the traits were good

#

im so trash at ML, i been playing for 6 years and l ony at lvl 81 with pretty trash monsters

#

they should help the ogs 💯

signal lance
#

@loud maple That has been suggested multiple times

loud maple
#

Whoops lol

#

Imma delete it then

signal lance
#

@keen belfry might wanna try and balance that Idea

#

Since that means if someone is blessed they could just keep using their deny skills without stop

glacial rock
#

@crude wave bruh read pins

crude wave
#

Ok

#

That’s the only one

#

I don’t understand discord

void raft
#

Any trading ideas should not be suggested

void raft
#

waiting for "return dungeons back" ideas

clear stump
void raft
#

@dreamy cypress name change was suggested a lot before

#

Why name change isnt on the list of banned ideas 🤔

grand haven
#

the most certain thing about the ideas channel is that whenever SP do something that people don't like they're all just gonna swarm the ideas channel like it's going to help

somber junco
#

Do ideas actually get taken into account because I think my hard food dungeon idea would be very helpful and rewarding to a lot of players.

grand haven
#

@deep urchin first, discuss ideas here
second, what was your idea

deep urchin
#

Oh alright

#

My idea was the same

somber junco
#

that was my idea

grand haven
#

food dungeon was suggested many times before

#

so it's gonna be deleted soon :/

grand haven
somber junco
#

@grand haven nothing he had the same idea as me

grand haven
#

oh so yeah both your ideas were repeats

somber junco
#

E

grand haven
#

therefore it got deleted, sooner or later

somber junco
#

oh.

grand haven
#

yeah repeats aren't allowed, sorry

void raft
somber junco
#

A

#

ok

clear stump
#

@deep urchin This is the discussion channel. It where all discussion, questions, suggestions about an idea or the department goes. #submit-ideas is only for submission of your own fresh idea. If you read the Pinned Messages, you would see repeat ideas are removed, and so yours was because Food Dungeon reworks have been suggested many many times in many similar forms.
@somber junco This may be of use to you.

somber junco
#

pog

#

ok

void raft
grand haven
#

Hey isa since you're here y'know might as well add to the pinned messages something like "any changes you want reverted shouldn't be sent to #submit-ideas but to #general-feedback"

grand haven
#

coolio

clear stump
void raft
clear stump
#

@nova bane Read the pinned messages of the ideas channels please.

clear stump
void raft
#

@wispy ember relics are in the game for very long time, and they work so(talents are kinda relics too). Pretty sure SP could have changed that if they wanted to

wispy ember
#

Yeah but still

#

It’s worth suggesting

#

I’ve lost a battle a few times just because of that

void raft
#

i dont say you should delete idea, just saying what i think

wispy ember
#

K

#

I had another idea but then I forgot :c

clear stump
#

Hurts lol

clear stump
#

@short idol Can we not have joke suggestions please. I've seen the thing in your server and I don't want it being mentioned in the ideas channels, thanks.

short idol
#

:/

clear stump
#

🙂

bitter adder
#

you cant grow a tuna sandwich in the ground

short idol
#

Turn the farms into ponds

#

Easy solution

clear stump
bitter adder
#

ah yes, tuna seed

clear stump
#

@lusty junco please dont use #submit-ideas for questions or discussion. I am not an SP representative or employee, I'm simply a volunteer who wants to help the mods (also not employed by SP). if you want to use the feedback channel, it is open and free to use.

void raft
#

@lusty junco returning of global chat is in the list of banned ideas

signal lance
#

Also why do people want Global back?

void raft
#

Good question

karmic fable
bitter adder
#

because i enjoy it

signal lance
#

@karmic fable I suggest balancing the Idea more

#
  1. You said any monster so what stopping me from getting a Spek + Lind team or a Lind + Thalassa team
  2. The Rank 3 monster of choice please specify that it does not include War masters
#

Great now I can use Spek + Katherine

clear stump
#

@dark granite can we not have joke suggestions about the tuna sandwich please.

#

@short idol I dont know what you're doing in your server but the ideas channel is not the place for it. Please tell whoever is supporting your cause to keep it our of the ideas channels before I apply Forced Roleless, I dont want to sit here and have to repeatedly delete your or others messages in #submit-ideas about the Tuna sandwich bc you didnt like the titan or whatever.

signal lance
#

My question being how are we going to get a tuna sandwich from a farm

short idol
#

No

clear stump
dark granite
#

*ever

clear stump
#

Hi. Some have been added into the game before. Titan dungeon in some form was a suggested idea iirc.

void raft
#

I don't get that tuna sandwich thing Sonnorsmallconcern

void raft
signal lance
#

We need answers

void raft
#

Might also ask how we feed relics with tomatoes

signal lance
#

My theory is that we give the Tomatoes to a worker who upgrades our Relics

void raft
#

Imagine working for 60m tomatoes nervouschamless

signal lance
#

Thats enough food for life

clear stump
#

Lol

alpine creek
#

tomatoes are the hidden key to the secrets of the universe ;-;

lethal wraith
#

any r3 corrupted?

#

also i feel like that reward scaling is kinda weird

void raft
#

Damage mirror but trait nervouschamless

lethal wraith
#

@raven forum discuss his idea in this channel not in #submit-ideas

raven forum
#

Ok

#

L I'll

#

Lol

#

Samuel the simps idea will not be maked

#

Or it requires a thousand bucks

#

To open the dungeon

signal lance
#

What is a Jutsu?

lethal wraith
#

smth from naruto i think

#

also there are no commas so now that trait is called “shadow clone jutsu water breathing fire ball tailed beast cloaks susano’o”

#

gr8 tr8 name

glacial rock
#

Lol

grand haven
#

also @tribal python monster ideas go to #monster-ideas for obvious reasons

signal lance
void raft
#

When you just watched naturo and want to turn ML into naruto

#

But even knowing all these words i cant understand the idea itself

grand haven
#

in #monster-ideas he said he's a weeb and wants ppl to make anime monster

void raft
#

@tribal python

tribal python
#

Water breathing is from a dif anime called demon slayer

tribal python
#

And mb misclicked

tribal python
grand haven
#

you mean these emojis? sonnorping

tribal python
grand haven
#

it doesn't exist

#

it's a mixture of Belbreath and Cavenfish

tribal python
void raft
tribal python
lusty junco
void raft
void raft
lusty junco
void raft
#

You could remove part about global chat

lusty junco
#

That's the exactly point if they don't remove it may we don't need better serch engine for player or team

tribal python
void raft
#

Clash royale doesnt have global chat, but somehow people still manage to find good teams

lusty junco
#

After good player stop playing this game we needed their replacement which we can't find in discord or Facebook or any other platform

lusty junco
void raft
#

Did you try recruiting in discord?

signal lance
lusty junco
lusty junco
# signal lance Just be patient

In my team we have 13 active player after player quit this game so imaging how hard to do race bcoz you need minimum 20 good player for good race

slim sedge
#

just disband your team and join another team if you want fast results

karmic fable
#

i think there should be a day in a week when you can request mythic cells from team.

slim sedge
clear stump
void raft
#

Isnt that repeat?

#

@lethal sapphire any ideas about trading are banned

lethal sapphire
#

In fact, in Clash Royale is an helpful feature

slim sedge
#

we get loads of that idea

void raft
lethal sapphire
#

And why does nobody approve it?

void raft
#

Ask devs 😂

slim sedge
#

imagine thinking that we have any sort of control over what goes in and what doesn't go in the game

bitter adder
#

because what wou;d you be trading

void raft
#

good bounty hunt, amber and stardust dungeons, better titan dungeon

slim sedge
#

but then one person could buy the pass, give the pass monster to someone, have them complete the era saga and get them the talent, and then trade to to someone else to do that with

bitter adder
#

pog

slim sedge
#

and when everyone has the talent the monster could just be traded back

void raft
#

Good idea

bitter adder
#

ml sysbots :poggies:

void raft
#

We definitely need trading then

slim sedge
#

and then suddenly everyone has a free gold pass talent

#

also if support relies on the monstergram to determine whether someone used to own a monster or not before giving it back to them then someone could just get a rank 5 shelly or something traded to them for the monstergram, and then they could trade it back and suddenly they'll have magically had "sold" a rank 5 shelly and will ask for one

lethal sapphire
karmic fable
#

how's my idea

karmic fable
#

Not bad

deep urchin
#

So how would yall feel abt a buffed food dungeon

#

It's long overdue

#

Plus lots of new players are coming in rn

#

So they need something to keep their interest in the gane

#

Game

void raft
deep urchin
#

Why doesn't so add it then

lusty junco
void raft
#

Move your friendly group to another team

acoustic stratus
#

You need to change the gifting system, like you can gift anything in your storage and runes, also with food and gold you should be able to choose how much food or gold you want to gift not just one set amount

rotund summit
#

we need a better titan this titan is less productive

#

we only get 400 in 15 rounds

clear stump
#

Can we all please look at which channel we are in, the pinned messages are a huge help.

harsh wing
#

i completed spekthras maze without doing the maze coin dungeon, 2 maze coin dungeons would make it way too easy

wispy ember
#

That’s good you know

signal lance
#

I think Maze is good as it is

#

It takes work but its really rewarding

white radish
#

There needs to be an option between 10K and 50K MP to be able to recruit more moderate level players. A 30k MP would be an ideal option for an intermediate level.

signal lance
clear stump
#

I am sure I removed that exact same idea earlier today or yesterday.

white radish
#

I believe I can send it where I want to

clear stump
#

Please use the voting channel to find the original idea, and up vote it.

#

No, that's not how the ideas channels works.

#

You can swipe left and tap Pins to find out how to use the ideas channels properly.

white radish
#

I thought it was an idea 🤔

clear stump
#

Your cooperation is much appreciated. isahearts

#

You would see why it was removed if you read the pinned messages

rain spire
#

so.. how you guys think of my idea?

white radish
#

All I get is a menu when I swipe left 🤷🏼‍♀️

clear stump
#

Yes

#

And then tap Pins

#

Swipe from the right side of your screen to the left

scarlet pendant
#

@karmic fable way too op

#

for 3 turns the wearer gets triple damage?

#

3 uses

#

thats 3 turns

#

thats 3 turns

#

thats litteraly 3 turns

signal lance
#

I was expecting 1 or 2 uses

scarlet pendant
#

you could essentialy kill all of the opponents with a high rank spek

#

just like that

rain spire
#

now do it with Totems and Damage Boasts and see how this works

scarlet pendant
#

it would completely ruin the game

signal lance
clear stump
#

Please consider balancing when creating your idea.

signal lance
#

@karmic fable Please don't chat their

karmic fable
#

Whatever

#

Kinda sad that two people replied or @ me bc I used a channel

clear stump
#

Preventable by reading the pinned msgs

scarlet pendant
karmic fable
#

idc

scarlet pendant
#

okay

grand haven
#

@karmic fable that seems a little too much don't you think

#

like if the wearer is under 25% I could understand that

scarlet pendant
#

Yeah if u scroll up we discussed it

#

And only for 1 turn too

grand haven
#

But still, it's under 75%

#

Way too high

#

it kinda is

rigid thorn
#

Under 50% way better lol

#

@alpine creek banned idea

#

So

alpine creek
#

ow okay

grand haven
#

yes ^

alpine creek
#

no wonder i didn't see any similar messages when i searched the word guardian

grand haven
#

really think about it, once you're under 75% HP you're guaranteed Triple Damage for your next three turns

signal lance
#

And we will argue with you for an Idea that is Blatantly OP

glacial rock
#

And we will stop talking about this until they change it right?

clear stump
#

I am gonna consider you watch balancing in this @karmic fable . I know it's "worst than UA", however making a problem worse will not help it at all.

signal lance
#

This is the one place that has some balanced Ideas

clear stump
#

On here it's much easier to have constructive, open ended discussions that benefit us all

signal lance
clear stump
#

Hahaha I saw in the feedback channels

signal lance
#

I am Angy

#

Alrighty me a Calm Zombie now

signal lance
#

@humble elbow that has been suggested multiple times

void raft
#

🤔

glacial rock
#

It even says in the pins

glacial rock
#

Bruh he posted it once or more times and now he says it again

grand haven
#

who and what idea?

glacial rock
wise surge
#

The speed up by using more workers thing is a good idea. However, if it stays at the 10% that you suggested then those that have maxed out the buff from the Legends pass and have all 5 (or 6) workers would only have to wait 10 or 20% of the time

#

Plus we would want to use our workers for other projects not just one at a time.

#

And just for instance. If we are only using the free pass with all 5 workers and a maxed buff it would take 9 hours and 36 minutes instead of 2 days which is a bit OP. And with the golden pass it only take 4 hours. It is a good idea but maybe the percentages taken off could be a bit more balanced

#

@merry stump ^^^^

scarlet pendant
#

its better than UA

#

....

#

why would you need 3 extra turns when you can just OTK everybody with a spek

#

the talent you submited with spek = otk

void raft
#

Do we really need more dumb op talents? SP are creating enough by their own

slim sedge
#

we don't lmao

balmy oriole
void raft
#

well, f2p players got "UA counter", that is just burning hands but with shock instead of burn

#

first saga talent that is more like usual talent

balmy oriole
#

Ig

#

It’s a semi-UA counter

#

Shock can be easily removed with torture immunity, which will be pretty common now that the mere existence of the beast that is Spekthra single-handedly changed the meta to tanks and supports

void raft
#

UA counter countered by MT

clear stump
#

UA still pierces through MT with the 60k dmg umm

grand haven
#

while f2p is sp balancing one thing and another with each other, p2w is just one upping every time

#

UA, now BT

#

Also BT bypasses MT even without pierce

void raft
#

At least BT isnt very popular on defences as i see

clear stump
#

surely

void raft
#

BT does go through MT

clear stump
#

Oh lord.

void raft
#

I guess its the same as UA's physical damage

grand haven
#

wait i forgot

void raft
#

So if skill is AoE, DC for everyone

grand haven
#

even above 50% hp

#

?

void raft
#

Monster killed my MT, and spek with famp got DC while having more than 75% of hp

grand haven
#

welp

void raft
#

Idk how it works, but its just terrible

grand haven
#

it's just like how UA works as well

#

even if you kill the MT, you dealt enough damage to other enemies to get them below 75% HP

#

therefore, another extra turn

void raft
#

Waiting to see season 4 glp talent

grand haven
#

with extra turns and dc

#

and per

#

I'm gonna presume cda next

#

or cdda

void raft
#

when turn ends, all enemies die

grand haven
#

If the wearer dies, applies 5 random controls and 11 random tortures to all enemies

#

oh yeah they might just add a deny in one of the p2w talents

void raft
#

Spekhtra the denier nervouschamless

grand haven
#

Culling The Weak now cause a concussion to all enemies babyblobface

void raft
grand haven
violet heron
#

and in 23 seasons later we'll get a talent that disable trait + per + applies MegaCorrupted after attack 😄

void raft
#

@karmic fable
1)You can edit messages
2)Really? Gambling?

#

You added "to play" in separate message

#

You could just edit first one, because one idea must be in one message

#

Gambling in game for 7+ yo kids

slim sedge
#

gambling moment

clear stump
void raft
#

black named people 😂

#

ideas' department

#

not black named people

scarlet pendant
#

@karmic fable wouldn't you have to be over 18 to do that

clear stump
#

I don't now the ins and outs of laws but I'm p sure gambling in ML already exists in the form of purchasable chests via real cash, that you don't need to be 18+ to pay for

#

if it was illegal by any means it would've been removed

void raft
#

Isnt there difference between opening loot boxes and actual gambling games?

clear stump
#

a loot box is a form of gambling

#

not to throw off topic in here but i believe Overwatch game was in hot water for their loot boxes in Belgium a few years back

#

Paid loot boxes were considered gambling and so players i belgium were blocked from purchasing them

#

it's a different game but similar logic to ML

boreal eagle
#

Gambling

void raft
#

@karmic fable changing name is banned as idea

signal lance
#

I just read a suggestion that is all Caps

lethal wraith
#

why is he/she screaming

signal lance
lethal wraith
#

they never found out how to turn off caps lock

signal lance
glacial rock
#

I didn't understand anything. The only thing I understand was pierce block

void raft
#

Effect or trait that protects you from pierce

#

I wonder how would that help MT, if i can pierce everything except MT

signal lance
#

@wise falcon that has been suggested multiple times already

wise falcon
#

What ?

signal lance
#

A Online indicator for teams is a banned Suggestion

wise falcon
#

Oooh

signal lance
#

It's been suggested multiple times and it's already in #ideas-voting

wise falcon
#

I don't know that

#

Sorry I not saw that

signal lance
#

It's alright

#

Just make sure to check the pins

wise falcon
#

Ok...... thanks

void raft
#

@blazing ginkgo why

boreal eagle
#

@blazing ginkgo the trait is TOO OP

blazing ginkgo
#

:

karmic fable
#

LOLS:
Idea: TRIPLE DAMAGE AS TRAIT
Idea Permanent MegaTaunt Mythic, Replace Santarion
This isn't even a viable idea @blazing ginkgo

signal lance
#

@blazing ginkgo Your joking right?

#

Joke suggestions are banned here

karmic fable
#

of course he deleted them

#

@blazing ginkgo please don't post in Ideas if they're not actual ideas that could be added

void raft
#

Corrupted barbael with triple damage as area trait nervouschamless

clear stump
karmic fable
#

Thank you thank you

#

Just glad they're out of there

clear stump
#

lol

rain spire
#

what about my idea?

karmic fable
#

Good idea, just not something that Sp would implement. They're too lazy/only like money making ideas

rain spire
#

facts

clear stump
#

I don't see why the bit about having it posted on reddit was needed

#

but it does sound good

signal lance
#

Honestly I love making Monster lore so I would so it

clear stump
#

so?

signal lance
#

I have no Idea what I sent last night

glacial rock
#

@worn tangle do you even read the pins?

hoary anchor
#

@blazing ginkgo sry for ping man but in friendly battle, they can request battle and make it so your level 100 goes down to level 30 so its even, its sorta already a thing, just the opposite way

signal lance
#

Disable skill sounds way to good in my eyes

lethal wraith
#

so its CDA

signal lance
lethal wraith
#

yeah they can disable 0cd skills im assuming

signal lance
#

Since now CDP does not counter this so a Monster with skill disable could in theory lock anyone from using any skill indefinitely

signal lance
lethal wraith
#

imo, its just fancy cda

#

not really a need for it

signal lance
#

In my eyes its just downright broken

lethal wraith
#

it is but we gotta see how long it lasts

#

if its 1 turn, then its legit just a regular deny

#

if its 3 turns, then its an issue

signal lance
#

@blazing ginkgo How long does Disable Skill last?

blazing ginkgo
signal lance
#

Alright so it's just regular deny then

#

It's nothing special

clear stump
#

@forest nest please dont double post in both ideas and feedback channels. I have removed your idea submission as it is already in the feedback channel.

forest nest
#

I thought they weren’t the same

void raft
#

For war fix, After winning a Battle Remove Positive to everyone because 1 time I killed the Last monster and i got a Cursed Countdown, i died Too
i won but didn't get anything, instead i got DiScOnNeCtEd or The The game Want me to re enter the Game again, That's Just Not right...

@I Am HIDDEN#9742 whats the point of win if you lost all your monsters, that means you get 0 coins?

#

I cant @ Sonnorsmallconcern

signal lance
#

@blazing ginkgo

void raft
#

Thanks

signal lance
#

NP

void raft
#

Sometimes i hate discord

signal lance
signal lance
#

@wind heron lower the % since 50 is to high

#

Something like 10% is good

wind heron
#

25%?

signal lance
#

Spek with an Extra 25% more attack combined with Runes

#

12%

wind heron
#

20%

signal lance
#

15%

#

Sounds good?

wind heron
#

Sure

signal lance
#

Yeah 15 sounds decent

glacial rock
#

I kinda like the idea ngl

signal lance
#

Same

#

But I just think that it shouldn't affect Ultimate chances and it should affect The Speed stat in a much less number

glacial ibex
#

has anyone suggested that in ML in the race it is added that the leaders and co-leaders can see who made the last ofu and who progressed in points

signal lance
#

A Banner like system was suggested so all team members can see who is going the task

glacial ibex
#

and when it is planned to implement it in ML

signal lance
glacial ibex
#

if you know

#

😦

#

tnx

signal lance
clear stump
glacial ibex
#

i can't find it 😦

#

under Chwie

signal lance
#

I found it

#

It was like the third thing that poped up when I searched

glacial ibex
#

i also find it

wispy ember
#

@alpine creek you can already tell by the time it takes to breed, there’s no point for your idea

#

I never use a breeding calculator but I always know which rarity I’m getting

clear stump
#

It is worth noting that Crushmore has the same breed time as an epic.

#

Despite being rare.

void raft
#

Everything that isnt 1d 22h not interesting

lethal wraith
#

once i got 1d22hrs and i think it was a rare

#

im not sure why it wasnt a legendary but i was sad

void raft
pulsar hamlet
#

Oki

void raft
#

I already imagine potato monster that is fed with tomatoes

#

And there is even tomato monster nervouschamless

pulsar hamlet
#

Wow

#

Special ability potato gun

#

It just shoots potatoes

void raft
#

I just realised this game for 7+ kids has cannibalism (if tomato that eats tomatoes can be considered as cannibal)

pulsar hamlet
#

The potato will be a cyborg potato

#

Its arms will will be kinda like molem

#

Like the shooting

void raft
pulsar hamlet
#

Because this is idea discussions and I'm brainstorming

void raft
pulsar hamlet
#

Oki I'm literally going to copy and paste everything

rigid thorn
#

@fierce cliff check pins

void raft
#

Another hatching guardian Sonnorsmallconcern

fierce cliff
#

Oh

#

Forgot to read that

#

Lol

wispy ember
#

@limber tangle your suggestion has been suggested before (by me)

signal lance
hoary anchor
#

put armor claw in honor dojo book then make a corrupted version and put it in fury dojo

signal lance
hoary anchor
#

sorry i thought i clicked in monster ideas

clear stump
#

@sacred skiff you do know we get free legendary and mythic mons each month right

signal lance
#

We actually get 2

#

1 from pass and 1 from Maze

clear stump
#

Bounty Hunt will hopefully be better for the players this time round.

#

You also forget pvp

signal lance
#

I bet 50 Lutum

clear stump
#

Lots of free cells there

signal lance
#

Oh right pvp

clear stump
karmic fable
#

Oop- my bad

limber tangle
void raft
sacred skiff
signal lance
#

A month

#

1 from pvp
1 from the legend pass
1 from the Maze

sacred skiff
#

Oh yea...

#

Sorry my bad

signal lance
wispy ember
#

And you can get some mythics from watching ads

signal lance
#

So possibly you can get 5 free Mythics

wispy ember
#

More like 6 :/

#

Because you always have 2 mythics in mw cell events

ocean temple
#

@wispy ember

#

@wispy ember

wispy ember
#

Stop

signal lance
#

What the heck?

slim sedge
#

no idea what that's about but I just blocked them

boreal eagle
wispy ember
signal lance
#

Thats a quick way for a Ban

#

Or mute one of the two

clear stump
#

@uneven meteor you do realise if theres no "second fastest" if theres a coin toss? Lol. When two mons have same speed its 50/50 to ensure fairness.

wispy ember
#

I’m just unlucky I never win that 50%

wispy ember
#

He means that instead of a coin toss the second fastest monster would go first

#

But the problem with that is who would go next

clear stump
#

But if 2 mins have the same speed then theres no second fastest out of the two bc they have the same speed

#

Youre just saying make the coin toss reversed. Lol

void raft
#

We just need old classic duels SonnorMilkSip

grand haven
#

the thing we really need is just not having meta cosmics at random

#

the thought of having moon ming, pulsus and lightmare battle against targon, steamwrath and necrolicht would actually sound more interesting than lindworm, arobat and zuperfox against lupon, masher and cryo

void raft
pliant terrace
#

What message?

#

ah, I see

void raft
#

Ideas feedback discussion huge hmmm

clear stump
#

Yep

#

@wispy ember :)

wispy ember
#

Aight

signal lance
#

@karmic fable could you explain this a bit more please

rigid thorn
#

Has far i understood, a chance to get pierce like a positive effect through relics

#

Idk

#

The 2nd part doesnt count really

#

Cuz they give armor

#

Idk i might be crazy

signal lance
#

A chance to get peirce...

#

I have no Idea how they thought that this was balanced

void raft
#

Maybe you can get pierce as ult

#

AoE pierce CDA'ed

glacial rock
#

Wow

void raft
desert canopy
#

Oh sorry

wise surge
#

@karmic fable Your idea with pierce isn't very balanced.