.

[balmy lake]

That sounds like auras in rs3 which is a pretty universally disliked concept, waiting for your cooldown every time you want to do a hard boss or some skilling activity. Also i would recommend to not use AI ifyou want your suggestions to be taken seriously

[gloomy bay]

English is not my first language, so the idea is simply written out in a professional and understandable tone, rather than being an "AI Idea". Unfortunate you only see similarities to other game, rather than making our own, but ay - it won't please everyone. Just a concept for now

[balmy lake]

Fair enough, its just not possible to distinguish what is AI and what isnt and people generally prefer a genuine human suggestion even if the english is a bit wonky 👍

[gloomy bay]

All the things stated above is entirely in my own words, just written a little cleaner.

[balmy lake]

I mean i say that because you probably didnt know that a very similar thing exists in rs3 and is heavily disliked. Its not disliked because it is in RS3 but because it has a severe gameplay problem as i mentioned. But you can of course argue why that wouldnt be a problem with your suggestion or how to fix it so it wont be

[gloomy bay]

I don't know anything about Rs3 - beside the very fact, that the games in its core is the same and very similar. So cutting out the idea, because there might be similaries to something in RS3, rather than think how we can make it old-school is what I don't understand

[balmy lake]

Again, its not because it is in RS3

Waiting for cooldowns to come up to do content you want to do is not fun gameplay, it doesnt matter which game

[gloomy bay]

From what I heard of other players, there is several concepts in RS3, that was imported in to OSRS, but made "old-school" with the community feedback. Thats the idea I want to bring with this as well, and make something great with the community.

[balmy lake]

i feel like you arent responding to what im saying

ignore the entire rs3 thing. i dont think waiting for cooldowns is fun and i dont want to see it in osrs

[gloomy bay]

No, you're not listening to what i'm saying. I see you mentioning the cooldown thing, but thats nothing definite, as i'm trying to explain. Thats the kind of thing we tweak. As example - the soul reaper axe. Hit 5 times, get full stack, unleash special. Similarities could be made to this

Core idea was mentioned. Multiple ways of "charging it" or consumption, or a whole 3rd option is possible. I provided 3 different meaning of "unleashing this". And it doesn't even have to be any of those 3.

It could also be a permanent unleash, but instead drains something - similar to prayers. Thats what the community could brainstorm to bring the concept to life. Rather than have another "bis weapon" added, which seem just pointless and boring at this point.

If the cooldown thing is what ruins it, then we simply remove that option, and think of another

[balmy lake]

Well the SRA is pretty disliked for a reason too.

But assuming you find a way to make the activation of this transcendance not annoying or tedious, firstly i dont think it should work with any skilling activity, its a megarare from a raid and doesnt fit the skilling niche, it shouldnt be expected to farm/buy a 2b gp megarare to do optimal skilling.

Regarding combat, triple protection prayer is utterly broken imo. Acceleration is a minor and frankly boring dps increase, prayer save does basically nothing worthy of a megarare. Storing damage taken and releasing it sounds like a cool concept, i just wonder where you would actually ever use that. To me it seems extremely difficult to design an effect that is both cool and not utterly overpowered or useless and im not sure i would trust Jagex or the players to find an effect or even multiple effects like this

[tidal temple]

acceleration is a 50% damage increase for blowpipe

[gloomy bay]

Thanks! This is the feedback I was looking for!
Like, it could also be an item, that gives an effect?
Also, the ideas for the transcensions were 5 minute ideas. You can literally make your own concept and add it to the list here. If you have suggestions, its the perfect time to list them. If those mentioned are to OP, then what else could we do? Something that brings the ascension idea to new heights. Do remember that even items like Shadow staff was giga DPS increase on certain places too etc, but can be tweaked to be worse at other places etc 🙂

I believe they also mentioned, that raids 4 would or could have impact on skilling, but they didnt make any definite ideas themselves, if I remember correctly

[balmy lake]

Yeah i mean that is my issue, i dont have any idea what a both cool and balanced ability could be like and thats really the first and main point that should be talked about

[gloomy bay]

Yee - thats why I hope the idea is not just dismissed immidiately, as mentioned in the note, but could be balanced around feedback and ideas given life on what could be ascended - which is a very normal concept in other MMORPG's

[balmy lake]

Did they? If you have the source for that id appreciate it i havent heard that before. Anyways if it is true, it will definitely not be in the form of the megarare

[gloomy bay]

This doesn't have to be the megarare either btw - just part of the rewards

Or even a currency, that you get by doing the raid
so even "white light raids" is rewarding
Instead of getting more toadflaxs, uncut diamonds or cocunot milks...

[balmy lake]

Well true i guess but how this forum here works usually is that youll have to propose some solid and actually defined concepts to get people on your side and vote for your idea. People will probably not upvote or discuss a lot if the suggestion is "please come up with your own ideas that work"

[gloomy bay]

guess ill see if ppl come with some feedback for now, and remake it later

[balmy lake]

yeah that can work but then we have the problem of needing to be in this particular raid constantly to refill your scrolls for skilling and any other type of pvm

[gloomy bay]

Not necessarily. It could be like LMS specific reward. Some being 1-time unlocks, and other being "rune arrows". In this case, it could be seconds for restorations potions, isntead of doing mixology (just an example)

[lofty dust]

turns out chatgpt isnt very good at making osrs reward ideas

[hallow tendon]

100%

[hallow tendon]

If it's a comsumable that sounds even more like an absolutely-not from me, especially if it only comes from a raid. I already don't like the concept and it's even worse if you can't really farm the resource on its own. Lily of the sands already exists as an herblore secondary unique to ToA and it's pretty awful because you can't ever go of your way to specifically go for it on an ironman

[gloomy bay]

I think you misunderstood then. I didn't mention about a unique 2nd. Im talking of a reward shop, to get 2nds you can only get 1 place elsewhere, like the 2nds from mixology

[gloomy bay]

Turns out your few braincells couldn't even comprehend reading the comments.

.