tame musk
Some thoughts:
If this is only trained on the island, it is going to feel like a minigame rather than a skill.
Not a huge fan of instanced training. I like seeing other players throughout the game world doing things. Helps immersion into the game for me personally.
regal crag
Construction was this way too for awhile, maybe if they could incorporate it into the main world as well. Also make it where players can visit towns and go on explorations together.
regal crag
Some thoughts:
If this is only trained on the island, it is going to feel like a...
also maybe, maybe make it where everyone can be there, but only players can only see their progression towards the town?
glacial pond
Construction was this way too for awhile, maybe if they could incorporate it int...
yeah con wouldn't pass as a skill in 2023 lol
regal crag
yeah con wouldn't pass as a skill in 2023 lol
what do you think though overall?
glacial pond
what do you think though overall?
pretty much agree with what jeso said
not too sure how it identifies itself as a "skill" and it being instanced and on its own island just feels like con 2.0
regal crag
not too sure how it identifies itself as a "skill" and it being instanced and on...
thank you for the feedback! prob is more of a minigame
glacial pond
and the training methods don't appear to have their own idenity outside of doing other pre existing skills in an instance and as an additional you would get xp in "cultivatioN"
what i've really liked about some of the other potential new skills is they have multiple clear training methods that have their own identity and tie into their proposed "skill" often not being instanced nor tied into 1 specific location. i feel like this specifically really helps the case of why it can be a new "skill"
i think you have some cool ideas there just not really giving me "new skill" feeling tho. i like the idea of quest npcs post quest being useful as to give an extra layer of reward and lore not sure how that could tie into a new skill tho
regal crag
what i've really liked about some of the other potential new skills is they have...
I have one more other skill idea. Ill work on it. I do apperciate you feedback, very useful!
glacial pond
I have one more other skill idea. Ill work on it. I do apperciate you feedback, ...
np appreciate the time you put into making it
pure hornet
I enjoyed unlocking a bank and utilities on Fossil Island. I think Jagex could incorporate construction into many locations in the game (including new areas) and that would be cool
glacial pond
I enjoyed unlocking a bank and utilities on Fossil Island. I think Jagex could i...
yeah jagex has overtime made construction less like a minigame with their like mahoghomes, stash, fossil stuff
pure hornet
"recruiting NPCs" wise is also fairly compelling. I think exploration and sailing also take some of this "recruit NPCs, upgrade your _" skill loop
I agree that this doesn't feel like a new skill though - it just feels like a new area
I think that's one of the popular exploration skill proposals
regal crag
I think that's one of the popular exploration skill proposals
Ill def read into it, Im just trying to think of osrs type skills that differ from our normal skills. I would love to have a skill where you want to lvl it because how engaging it is!
regal crag
"recruiting NPCs" wise is also fairly compelling. I think exploration and sailin...
thank you for reading and giving your feedback!:)
pure hornet
Not everything needs to be a new skill also - I think if you retitled this as just "new player run island", I'd be into it
glacial pond
that's true but i also think people enjoy the idea of being able to train something and a "level" means requirements and progression
so even if something doesn't "need" to be a new skill i think it still can be very successful as a new skill
regal crag
Yall have given such great feedback, I app the words and direction!
