#🤔|theories

1 messages · Page 28 of 1

azure bay
#

with enough effort they could make Dale a president

#

but they'd have to win the elections

#

"Hey, Mr. Owl! Future Mr. Owl speaking. I have a chosen one I need to teach about the universe, could you please change the program of the next performance and use some magic so The Lady appears dead and changes outfit to something looking like a corrupted soul? Great, love you, see ya!"

#

of Rusty Lake

#

of one who's in control of the cube, one who makes changes

#

by analogy with The Past Within both Rose and Albert in the past have an idea of normalcy

#

Albert warns Rose that she's inside a cube and someone will change it

#

the Vandermeers wouldn't question much an extra present Dale got on his Birthday

#

but they definitely would question a weird old man pretending to be a family

#

unless, the thing I recently realized, the changes to Crow's appearance are his disguise that fools the family but still technically looks like Crow so we the players recognize him

#

what I'm saying, he probably looks like Crow only to us

#

so we know who's that for real

#

you didn't get it

#

the theory is, grandpa is looking like Crow only so the players recognize him as such. In the reality, he faithfully assumed the appearance of Dale's grandpa so nobody questions him

#

As far as I know, Crow can't break the 4th wall

#

or rather...

#

nevermind

#

maybe

#

but what I'm thinking

#

imagine it like a stage play

#

we have an actor that picks the outfit of a different character

#

and, by the plot, he fools other characters

#

but it's made deliberately cheap so the audience sees through his lies

#

one of the reasons why the Vandermeers don't question a face swap, because, by the plot, it's not a face swap but a faithful illusion

#

no

#

I'm saying that it's just a game, a form of art

#

the author may choose a look for his characters that conveys the intended message

#

Room Escape games can't tell the story in the same way a movie would

#

or a book for that matter

#

there are still a lot of gameplay elements and other technicalities

#

a good example is Paradox

#

Mr. Crow and VanderDeer both speak of some kind of choice

#

and if you only play the game, you don't see where that choice is

#

when it's made

#

but you clearly see that in the movie

#

because in the movie all 3 vials are equally accessible

#

Dale has to choose one

#

but in the game it's not the case because the devs don't want the Player to make the choice for Dale

#

they want the players to only watch the consequences of a certain choice at the certain point of the story

#

they don't want to reveal too early that the blue vial corrupts Dale and it's Dale who kills Laura

#

so they make an artistic choice

#

and grandpa looking like Crow could be another artistic choice like that

#

I presume that if there were a novelization of Birthday, grandpa wouldn't look like Crow from Dale's point of view

#

but there would be a different way to let us the readers know that grandpa is an impostor

#

@mild creek do you get it now?

#

more or less

#

these are the backers that made the movie possible

#

the majority are

vivid bridge
#

jojo canon in rusty lake

carmine field
#

What do you think "The Golden Cube" card refers to? The card looks too fancy to be just a reference to the golden cube

azure bay
#

I thought there could be another society lead by Owl

#

now I think Albert could be a new player

#

unless it's just some metro-like metaphor

carmine field
#

Interestingly, we still don't know the exact origin of the golden cube in TPW

#

We only know that it came from the "energy of the future"

#

or something like that

carmine field
azure bay
#

I have a theory how Owl's cube could be connected

#

that would make sense of all of this

#

but it's just a theory

#

the reality could be harsh. stupidly soft magic system

carmine field
#

tell us

azure bay
#

Owl's cube was created using William's memories

#

theoretically they could be copied and saved for later use

#

BKM-style

#

and energy was a support for sending that memory data in a form of signal

carmine field
#

It's weird because it might imply infinite elixir, but if there's any limit, I think it's possible

calm glade
frosty wolf
#

the screenshot is from Cube Escape: The Cave

azure bay
frosty wolf
#

but there is no mirror at the train station, assuming the picture was taken there

azure bay
#

they are not literal

frosty wolf
#

hm.

calm glade
frosty wolf
#

well she could have just took it in front of her randomly..

vital mantle
#

My theory is that someone put some drug in Dale's coffee and all Rusty Lake is a weird af journey while he is sleeping in his desk.....with eyes open

#

Being serious I don't know, the old ones are testing the cubes?

floral mauve
#

From the new UB secret

#

(I dont think its necessary to spoiler mark it cause its still tpw), middle aged Rose already got Albert CS in the tank seems like

#

thought you could say those are the fragments that occur in different time

#

but as I stated before, there is no way for her to have those record if Albert CS in the future is teleported from the past instantly

vivid bridge
#

huh you're right

#

wow classic rusty lake plothole

azure bay
#

Unlikely, considering who's the protagonist

#

yet it could be such

#

1st and foremost I see the subway as a metaphor

#

which may represent whatever

#

I tend to think these are memories because of the blossom

#

blossom likely means the lake

#

it's again a discussion about gameplay and artistic choices

#

the devs decided to put the story into the subway scenery

#

which probably means absolutely nothing

#

except for "our life is like a railroad"

#

so far, the subway makes little sense, so does the protagonist, and it's all expected to make even less sense when the game is finished

#

I bet we're to see the same events of Seasons and The Lake from a different perspective

#

and somehow in metro

#

does it make sense? I don't think so

#

when so?

#

mostly The Lake

#

if I'm right it only confirms the senselessness of what's hapenning

azure bay
#

I don't

#

Samsara Wheels in Rusty Lake shout that he's a bird now

#

likely since 1894

#

yes, then he was an Asura. But died a year later and was reborn as a birb

#

actually we never saw any other asura transform into a human at will

#

besides these 2

#

I mean

#

The guests, other Hotel employees

#

I think that was just an asset reuse. Because the devs said that both Bat and Toad used to be humans before working for Owl

#

yes, Harvey is weird not only in that sense

#

(or any consciousness for that matter)

#

what's the point?

#

the conclusion about Harvey

#

(Owl became asura via elixir pretty much directly, that's what Caroline created in the purgatory)

#

for Bat, that's just not true

#

the devs said so

#

he and Toad used to be humans

#

before working for Owl

#

that's a very unnecessary mental jump

#

at least because it's unheard of

#

no, like Mr. Bat becoming a bat 1st

#

leave the bat in The Cave alone, there are other examples of animals reusing asura visuals

#

We have a pigeon that looks like Mrs. Pigeon

#

and we have a boar that looks like Mr. Boar

#

but that doesn't mean they are them

#

I'm speaking of the pigeon helping Harvey

#

it has next to no way to be Mrs. Pigeon

#

ok, back to Harvey

#

as for now, there's no evidence that Harvey can transform back and forth asura<->animal.

We have next to no info about his life before the hotel, so we have no idea if he could. And know too well about his life after, when we can tell for sure he couldn't.

#

maybe he could before Hotel indeed

#

but for now it's kinda useless

#

we don't focus much on that time period

#

@mild creek

#

at least when it comes to Harvey or OWl

vivid bridge
#

He was probably able to switch until he died after Hotel and became a regular parrot

azure bay
#

Probability is usually based on data you have, not the one you don't

#

He didn't go back to asura. It contradicts the established lore

#

Technically speaking, he had time to somehow become asura. The bigger problem is, he had to cease being one again by at least 1971

#

Likely even earlier since he spent a lot of time at Laura's

vivid bridge
#

sometimes i'm unsure if the devs even think about it that hard or if they're just like "woah what if you look in the mirror and then HARVEY is there! Wouldn't that be a cool easter egg??"

azure bay
#

Yep

vivid bridge
#

I always figured that was just Owl teleporting Dale

azure bay
vivid bridge
#

yeah but prior to that moment in the mill, Dale didn't get attacked or whatever. He activated the machine, blacked out and was teleported to the chapel

azure bay
#

He still had to somehow become a parrot by 1971.

That would better happen onscreen. And if we don't get a substitute, that "onscreen" will be 1894

#

The wheels say he did

#

"a fish and a parrot" is a play about animals

#

Period

vivid bridge
#

Harvey in his animal form doesn't seem to possess any human consciousness, the implication being that he died and became a full on animal

azure bay
#

Sorry, that's just stupid

#

Just think about it

#

You are, for instance, Mr. Crow

#

You've decided to become a human

#

To take a human state

#

Humans need elixir to become asuras and have 50% chance to die

#

If you can turn back into asura, you are no human anymore

#

And you are no parrot

#

No animal

#

Then get out from the stage, Harvey, you are f*ing asura

#

You missed the point

#

If you change state, you change state

#

That's not how samsara works

#

If you are an asura looking like an animal, you are still an asura

#

You didn't die

#

By samsara wheels the devs say that Harvey is an animal. Anything else is overthinking and is against Occam

#

Go ahead

vivid bridge
#

one dies, the other becomes a funky animal person

azure bay
#

Not necessarily, Dale will become a deva

vivid bridge
#

Since the dog didn't become an asura, I guess the transformation only works on humans

azure bay
#

So no Owl makes it deal with unwanted guests or young female courpses! A genius beyond Albert FrankLaugh

covert wyvern
#

No.

azure bay
#

@mild creek in the meantime here's what I see

#

We have 3 cases of elixir consuming

#

Aldous, the dog and Dale

#

And all 3 have a different outcome

vivid bridge
#

But Dale only drinks it in the paradox simulation so that might not be accurate

azure bay
#

Why?

azure bay
#

Theatre says, he'll be deva

#

Whenever it happens, I take it for granted

#

So why are these 3 cases are so different?

#

I think it's like you said, @mild creek, it depends on consciousness

#

Dog had no consciousness, thus the elixir only prolonges life as long as the elixir stays inside the body

#

Humans like Aldous or even braindead Gerard are humans and have basic consciousness

#

Thus they also get some magical powers

#

And Dale gets his super-elevator journey, faces his fears and demons, learns about samsara, "reaches a higher state of consciousness"

#

Thus he's getting even a better boost whatever it is

#

And likely he'll still have lesser benefits

#

Like prolonged life and Asura-like look

#

Maybe Harvey had enough consciousness to become an asura. Maybe not. We don't know yet. He's weird enough to be a wildcard

#

(I don't doubt Harvey has at least some level of consciousness because we have HB where he solves a lot of complex tasks and has some thoughts but more so because we have UB, where Rose entrusts him Laura)

vivid bridge
#

I'd say he's a lot more animal in HB than in any of his asura appearances. He has no idea where he is or whats going on, he's just a panicking animal

#

yeah but thats because we're playing as him

#

we hear his thoughts because we're playing as him

azure bay
#

We know next to nothing about the Parrot, why he's so cool and how he became asura in the 1st place

vivid bridge
#

of course he's doing stuff that regular parrots couldn't do but like, you gotta suspend your disbelief a certain way

azure bay
#

And I don't think Rose is stupid to entrust her daughter to a birb

vivid bridge
#

this was like the fourth game, back then Harvey wasn't known (or even thought up) to be an (ex) asura. Back then the idea was just that he's a regular parrot

vivid bridge
#

nah i'm coping with the fact that 2015 was 8 years ago

#

I'll just pretend undertale is still fresh and new

azure bay
vivid bridge
#

I don't think we've ever seen an Asura turn into the full animal

azure bay
#

Neither do I

#

The best course of action is keeping all this stuff in mind until we get something substantial and until then consider absence of evidence as evidence of absence. Just to save brain power for more interesting and important topics.

But as soon as I see Harvey or someone else transforming that way, I'll be the 1st to reconsider that

#

What's funny

vivid bridge
azure bay
vivid bridge
#

Ah

#

Yeah okay

#

so I guess enlightened Dale might not even look like an animal, he might look like something completely else

#

never thought about that

#

oh that'd be so lame, though

azure bay
#

We've got VanderDeer. He knows what choice Dale made and appears even beyond Paradox.

So until further notice I consider that his deva form

vivid bridge
#

its gonna happen

azure bay
#

Well, they are making him one

vivid bridge
#

well, you need the full elixir made with the golden cube

#

any other incomplete elixir will just make you an imperfect asura

azure bay
#

That's why Dale has his journey

#

No, but it's all he has in The Cave

#

So anything but could be considered full, if you think about it

vivid bridge
#

yeah but the implication is clearly that the "full elixir" is whats needed to save the lake aka what dale needs to ascend to deva

azure bay
vivid bridge
#

thats not how the lake works

#

just because time is kinda weird down there doesn't mean its like four dimensional

azure bay
#

Back to VanderDeer, Paradox is a creation of not only Owl but partially Dale himself and I think even the Lake.

Plus, in corrupted state Dale sees many different versions of himself including those from the immidiate future and the immidiate past.

Focusing a bit on the future notion, an extra emphsis is made not only on VanderDeer but also on the hanged Dale. They both appear separately from other Dales before CDale leaves the room.

These 2 look like they symbolise possible outcomes of Paradox. 2 secrets endings that are true endings (in a way that they trully end Paradox cycle)

#

Maybe not literally

#

I have strong doubts Paradox can change the past

#

Maybe the lake where paradox takes place can but it's overthinking with no evidence

vivid bridge
#

what do you mean

#

blasphemy

azure bay
#

He has a point

#

It looks like the island is floating over the forest without drowning or drifting away

#

Well, the lake may exist in all these realities

#

And just be some kind of a portal into the forest

#

There's still water

#

Still land

#

Still caves

#

Maybe you just see and feel them less as you transition

#

I assume there was a lake

#

but the reality became thinner there

vivid bridge
#

what I really want to know is if a person can enter the hell state from the wheel

#

which is just represented by the lake's forest on the wheel

#

maybe thats what happened to Rose idk

azure bay
#

did you hear an idea that trees could be what's supposed to be "souls of sinners"?

#

however for Rose it seems more positive

#

like for her it's not naraka but nirvana

vivid bridge
#

yeah

#

actually

#

So if an asura dies they become an animal, maybe when a corrupted soul dies they become a tree (aka "hell")? Thats kinda what happened to Mr. Rabbit in Birthday

azure bay
#

I wouldn't be so sure about Rabbit becoming a tree

vivid bridge
#

yeah but its the closest thing we've seen about whats probably a corrupted soul dying

azure bay
#

for starters there was a tree even before he came there. It just blossomed when Rabbit withered away

#

considering the cube floating above it, I'd rather bet on that tree somehow representing Dale's soul

vivid bridge
#

yeah I was just trying to connect dots

azure bay
#

so am I

#

just different vector

vivid bridge
#

Would be nice if Albert died and somehow became a naraka

#

that guy deserves it lol

azure bay
#

didn't think of him in that way until... Chad... 🥺

vivid bridge
#

it took until he killed Chad to dislike that guy? The guy who kept his nephew in a well for like 30 years? The guy that killed his own brother and his wife? The guy who caused his sister to commit suicide?

#

well yeah "hell" is the place, the state you'd become is naraka

vivid bridge
azure bay
#

eh?

#

but the guests are still around terrorising the lake and only Dale can somehow stop them

vivid bridge
#

I hope when he ascends to Deva, he just gets a gun

azure bay
#

Case 23

vivid bridge
#

yeah

azure bay
#

Birthday

vivid bridge
#

well thats debatable

#

;)

#

I still believe that the birthday rabbit is a different person from hotel rabbit

vivid bridge
#

yes

#

I don't think the hotel guests are the eilanders

#

but I don't want to get into this right now

#

no :)

azure bay
#

Phe just thinks that masks and foreshadowing isn't enough

#

since we see 2 rabbits in the same room

vivid bridge
#

yeah and the games are consistent with the differences between them

#

and also the hotel guests aren't anything like the eilanders outside of like gerard

azure bay
vivid bridge
#

I mean, who doesn't

azure bay
#

back to being productive

vivid bridge
#

okay

azure bay
#

it seems, somehow ||Albert's CS existed even before TPW started||

vivid bridge
#

I didn't say anything :)

#

crazy

high talon
#

oof man avoid saying that in a big server

#

modded discord is against the TOS

vivid bridge
#

So what do you think? Is he?

high talon
#

i do

#

but still sm could report it

vivid bridge
#

okay I think we should change the discussion before the mods come in here

#

but also you mean "she"?

azure bay
#

About Albert's weird timeline

#

what question?

#

who are you guys anyway?

#

what am I doing here?

#

how did I get here?

#

can anyone call a taxi?

vivid bridge
#

no you're stuck here

#

ooooh

#

I get it now

#

we're the naraka

#

we're stuck in this hell of our own making

#

bravo rusty lake I clap

azure bay
#

so about Albert

#

how?!

#

ok, I can accept him lurking behind Laura

#

but being ||captured by Rose|| that early and staying invisible???

vivid bridge
#

well, I thought him lurking behind Laura was post-TPW. Like after he was revived he's now creeping around in his granddaughters memories

vivid bridge
#

hmmm

#

maybe

#

I always figured that Real Life Albert wasn't revived, that just happened in the memory

#

I guess it could have happened in both

azure bay
#

I'm confused how he's corrupted if PRose had to deliberately make that happen

#

following FRose's instructions

vivid bridge
#

I guess Real Life PRose revived him, then realised she needed help from the future so she spent the next whatever years to build a machine so that she could help Memory PRose revive Memory PAlbert instead of the real one?

azure bay
#

I have problems with that. If PRose didn't know she needed to do that without FRose, how would FRose do that back at her time? She had quite a small window before burial

#

also I have problems with coins

#

how the heck it was enough?

vivid bridge
#

well, somehow Real Life PRose must have revived Albert as a CS without FRose's help

vivid bridge
azure bay
#

lore and sense breaking gameplay, mind you

vivid bridge
#

its like how making elixir is super inconsistent. Sometimes its this whole elaborate thing and sometimes you put two liquids together and bam, elixir. Sometimes the games just need a quick way of doing something

azure bay
#

James didn't corrupt

#

tons of dead men before him didn't corrupt

vivid bridge
#

yeah but what else are you proposing? The coins were actually microscopic corruption machines?

azure bay
#

the only proposal I have, Roses had nothing to do with Albert's corruption

#

but TPW heavily implies otherwise

vivid bridge
#

TPW is already super wack with the lore. How can Albert just create a fucking golden cube when it took Mr. Owl like 100 years of planning and moving chess pieces and stuff

azure bay
#

it's weird, it ruins expectations and the devs are better to explain it rather sooner than later

azure bay
vivid bridge
#

Rose really abandonded her own daughter to spend 50 years working to bring back her shitty dad

azure bay
#

if we assume that ||Albert's CS had its vicious plans on Laura|| negotiating with it could be an option

vivid bridge
#

yeah okay but thats another reason to not revive him

azure bay
#

he actualy was quite friendly

vivid bridge
#

I don't think this guy is friendly

vital bobcat
#

can anyone help me understand why mr rabbit still exists in his corrupted form even after killing dales family?

azure bay
#

but Rose is family

#

||and Laura is pricious to her||

vital bobcat
azure bay
#

and ||Chad technically works for an enemy||

azure bay
vital bobcat
azure bay
#

Depression? Dale's CS? Owl's shemes? Dale's CS causing depression according to Owl's schemes?

vivid bridge
#

she was just a girlboss and took matters into her own hands

azure bay
#

corrupted soul

vital bobcat
#

man the vanderboom family is still understandable

#

I dont understand the eilander family

frosty wolf
#

i dont understand both

#

theyre all insane

vivid bridge
#

Presumably it just didn't work as he thought

vital bobcat
#

ahhh

azure bay
#

Rabbit probably went on rampage some time after the main story

frosty wolf
#

can someone tell me what was Mr. Rabbit's state during Birthday? Was he corrupted or was he in his rabbit form

vivid bridge
#

it depends on certain things

#

some people (thats me) believe that Mr. Rabbit from Birthday is not the same one as from the Hotel, so in that case he wouldn't be corrupted. If it is the same Mr. Rabbit, then yes, he's corrupted

azure bay
vivid bridge
#

well, if David isn't Hotel-Rabbit, then there's no reason he would be corrupted

azure bay
#

I don't expect asuras to kill in order to escape their state

vivid bridge
#

yeah thats true

frosty wolf
vivid bridge
#

It doesn't

#

thats the whole crux of my theory lol

azure bay
vivid bridge
#

Yeah but they're important

#

:)

azure bay
#

one looks like a dead creep and the other looks like a dead creep

frosty wolf
#

Mr. Rabbit when he was alive in the Rabbit Room was very different than what we saw in Mr. Owl's room that was supposed to be the same rabbit's soul

azure bay
#

we discuss if the Birthday visitor is corrupted or not

vivid bridge
#

yeah

#

I don't think he's corrupted

azure bay
#

And I say he is because he looks corrupted from a distance, during a jumpscare, and even resembles Rabbit's corrupted soul

vivid bridge
#

He doesn't act like a corrupted soul

azure bay
#

and even the chest alludes to corrupted souls in 2 whole languages

vivid bridge
#

also on that one anniversary image, it is a mask worn by David. Idk if this counts for anything

#

Hotel-Rabbit is a full animal

azure bay
frosty wolf
# azure bay we don't discuss that at the moment

but this also links to if who is who cause if the Rabbit in Birthday was the same Rabbit back in Hotel than that would make the birthday rabbit the hotel rabbit (which would make the Birthday Rabbit a corrupted soul) if they were different then we could say that the Birthday Rabbit would have lots of sense to be not corrupted

vivid bridge
#

yeah but the other cosplayers have full head costumes, while this guy doesn't

azure bay
#

he does

#

because only corrupted souls like William are expected to kill for rebirth

vivid bridge
#

whatcha mean

azure bay
#

I mean their despair

#

for them, a mere existence is a seemingly never-ending suffering

#

that's why they are usually aggressive

vivid bridge
#

yeah but they don't usually dress up and shoot people with guns and then leave written notes

#

they're usually a lot more animalistic

azure bay
vivid bridge
#

yeah

#

that is weird

azure bay
#

I agree

#

it is

vivid bridge
#

what does this mean

azure bay
vivid bridge
#

ah

#

lame

#

man, why does this series gotta be so inconsistent

#

do.. do corrupted souls bleed?

#

like from his blood to his brown hands, I just don't buy this guy being a corrupted soul

azure bay
#

except when they want to write something spooky on mirrors FrankLaugh

vivid bridge
#

yeah but thats not their blood

azure bay
#

then whose? SamuelThink

vivid bridge
#

its just red paint

azure bay
#

fair enough

#

ah

#

another question

#

@vivid bridge what year do you think is that?

vivid bridge
#

she's probably in her 50s

azure bay
#

that would be some time around early Seasons

vivid bridge
#

You think its relevant?

azure bay
#

I still think Rose could initiate Seasons for her daughter

#

but when is a different matter

#

the devise is peculiar

#

like it seems too detailed to be just an ARG easter egg

#

@vivid bridge don't you think?

#

looks like some kind of ||cube-powered chamber||

vivid bridge
#

yeah definitely

azure bay
#

a personal question

#

Would you like BKM as a concept more if it was more highlighted in other gqmes?

vivid bridge
#

I think i'd prefer it if it had an actual impact on the games

#

which it might have here

#

okay so on the left window, you can kinda see two bumps which seem to have the same lighter color as the thing on the bottom. So maybe its person shaped? Idk what it would be, though

azure bay
#

an electric chair?

vivid bridge
#

might be

#

could be anything at this point

#

yeah I guess those black lines could be cables

#

Actually, yeah

#

its not cube powered, its a cube extractor

#

its like the thing in Mrs. Pigeons room

azure bay
#

probably

#

could be not extractor but "recorder"?

#

I mean

vivid bridge
#

you think thats how the train tape was created? Laura was put there?

azure bay
#

on the security footage they take an existing cube for all the procedures

azure bay
#

I have problems with all these tapes

#

they supposedly belong to Rose or Laura but they feature them from 3rd person perspective

vivid bridge
#

yeah

#

well, thats just kinda how the memory cubes work, too

#

well, actually

#

no

#

nvm

#

so this could be a tape belonging to Asura-Harvey then?

azure bay
#

I don't think the devs would lie about such things in Paradox movie, honestly

#

and acutally...

#

they didn't

vivid bridge
#

Also the little chest here makes me think that this will be a playable thing

azure bay
#

hmmm

#

now, as I'm thinking about it

#

could the black cube belong to Albert since she already contains him in the tank?

#

maybe not, he's supposed to be unconscious in The Past initially

#

and while "entering" the cube Rose was more like taking her other body before it channels the consciousness further

#

or maybe that works for any cube as long as the other-self is inside?

vivid bridge
#

no idea

carmine field
#

You guys discussed a lot today, I'll read everything soon

carmine field
#

Why so many deleted messages?

carmine field
azure bay
floral mauve
#

The guy just gone💀

carmine field
#

That said, I believe Birthday gun isn't the only substance Mr. Rabbit was looking for. He possibly found other substances off-screen

vivid bridge
floral mauve
#

I thought Rose is also in bkm which is quite obvious atm

#

I think Albert is hostile towards Laura is still mainly due to William

#

not hostile, lets say, stalking

covert wyvern
#

Either way now that I've solved that mystery for you; let's focus on the theories again:)

ripe flame
swift void
#

I dont completly understand the lore(partly bcause i had only played the free games and demos) but maybe this is at least a little bit senceable

ripe flame
#

I thought Mr.Rabbit somehow reborn after he got corrupted in the Hotel?

swift void
#

Is hotel before or after cube eskape?

#

Aldo hadnt played the hotel

ripe flame
swift void
#

Huh
Idunno then

frosty wolf
#

birthday is much later than hotel

#

hotel is 1893 and birthday is 1939

swift void
#

Oh ok, didnt know that

steel imp
#

I don't think there's a single Cube Escape game that fully happens before Paradise, Hotel or Roots

steel imp
#

You usually get corrupted when you create a Black Cube when extracting a bad memory or, alternatevely, being the unlucky one of the two when driking the elixir

#

An animal head (with a human body attached to it, to be clear) indicates that such person as reached an higher state, the demon. This happens when you drink the elixir, and comes with some extensive advantages, like longevity, human masking and power over "the lake"

#

Now with animal head I don't mean a mask, like the one that Mr. Rabbit is wearing in Birthday

terse niche
#

The events of the Rusty Lake Hotel game take place in 1893 and the Dale's birthday events originally took place in 1939 and are revised in 1972 in Cube Escape.:Birthday

steel imp
#

Yes

#

I'm not opposing to that

#

However, what do you mean by revised?

terse niche
#

I'm just saying MrMemoryThumbsUp

steel imp
#

I literally don't know what it means in english

#

I'm italian

terse niche
#

Dale returns to his birthday memory cube in 1972

steel imp
#

Yes

terse niche
#

that's what i mean revisited

steel imp
#

Oooh ok

#

Well, yes. Dale manages to go back to 1939, sees everything for the second time, then blue cube and changes the past

terse niche
#

Mr. Rabbit from Hotel maybe is not the same from Birthday because they are quite different.

steel imp
#

No way

#

They are certified to by the same

#

If you recall paradox (if you played it)

#

When you call Mr. Rabbit the number is D. Eilander

#

However in Birthday it leaves a letter as Mr. Rabbit

#

They have not the same appereance because Mr. Rabbit got corrupted, and to hide it chise some nice clothes and a mask

steel imp
terse niche
#

Yes. That's pretty cool and reinforces the theory that the guests could have been the Eilanders reborn as an asura by the ritual that created Mr. Owl

steel imp
#

There's a "but"?

terse niche
#

a but?

steel imp
#

Yes

#

Like

#

...by the ritual that created Mr. Owl, BUT...

#

I was expecting one by how the message was phrased

terse niche
#

I imagine that Mr. Owl wanted revenge on his family, hence the Rusty Lake Hotel events, but Mr. Rabbit was the wrong one.

steel imp
#

What do you mean?

#

By "Mr. Rabbit was the wrong one"

terse niche
#

I believe that Mr. Owl wanted revenge on his family, so he invited, killed, corrupted and imprisoned the guests of the Rusty Lake Hotel.

steel imp
#

Well to a certain extent, he also needed the memories

#

Two pidgeons with a rock

terse niche
#

But David Eilander might not be Mr. Rabbit that we see in the Hotel.

steel imp
#

Could you explain yourself

#

You're concerned just about the appereance or something else?

terse niche
#

I don't have anything that really says that to be honest. Only in David's possible interest in ceasing to be a corrupted soul or an asura and for that, having to kill Dale's parents.

#

There is two Mr. Rabbits in Rusty Lake Hotel

#

If I remember correctly

steel imp
#

Two you say?

#

Do you mean two forms of mr. Rabbit?

terse niche
#

Yes. I vaguely remember, but we have a brown Mr. Rabbit and white Mr. Rabbit also appears.

steel imp
#

First, that's racist

terse niche
#

I could be wrong

steel imp
#

Second, there are sctually two forms of Mr. Rabbit

terse niche
steel imp
#

But there's not two colors of them

#

There's his asura form

#

And then its corrupted form

#

Now I'll show you something

#

This is probably the white mr rabbit

#

You're refering to

#

This it's his corrupted form

terse niche
#

Oh! That one!

steel imp
#

Now look closely to the Mr. Rabbit you see in birthday

terse niche
#

He looks more like he's dressed in black, disguised than he's really corrupted.

steel imp
terse niche
#

Exactly

steel imp
#

They are identical

#

By face

vivid bridge
#

But they're not

#

;)

steel imp
#

The only thing that changes is a nice clothing and a mask in paradox

steel imp
#

What else now?

#

Are there any other differences?

vivid bridge
#

I mean, I don't really get your argument. Are you saying Mr. Rabbit from Birthday is the corrupted Hotel-Rabbit... wearing a mask?

steel imp
#

It wears a mask in paradox

#

That's why I recalled that

vivid bridge
#

Cause I do agree that the Birthday-Rabbit wears a mask, as signified by the whiskers and the brown hands

#

the corrupted soul doesn't have whiskers

#

its a very small detail but its very consistent across the games

steel imp
#

And that its your major concern

#

The whiskers?

#

However its an inportant point

vivid bridge
#

well also the fact that the Birthday-Rabbit (aka David) acts nothing like a corrupted soul

#

I also don't think the Eilanders are the hotel guests

#

So Hotel-Rabbit isn't David

steel imp
#

Uhm

#

I think I could piece sonething up

vivid bridge
#

The only thing the Eilanders and the guests have in common is the animal theme and that the boars like to eat. Everything else doesn't add up. The character traits, the ages, their jobs, etc

terse niche
#

Well, while I believe in the need to obtain cubes, the events at the Rusty Lake Hotel feel very personal.

vivid bridge
#

I was just about to say that people only think the eilanders are the guests so that Hotel is like a revenge story

steel imp
#

You are saying that David Eilandet (aka Whiskers Rabbit) appears in Mr. Rabbit windows for no particular reason, then Mr. Rabbit (aka. Bald Rabbit) goes and kills Dale'a family, bit then David Eilander reappears in Paradox and does the same thing

#

Do you have a plausible explanation for this?

vivid bridge
#

no, David kills Dale's parrents (and appears outside the window). Hotel-Rabbit just gets corrupted and chills at the bottom of the lake with the other hotel guests

steel imp
vivid bridge
#

no they're not

steel imp
#

Also it doesn't make sense that one's corrupted soul is identical to another one's asura

vivid bridge
#

well its not

terse niche
#

We never see what happens to the Eilanders after the end of Paradise. We only see Mr. Owl born. Whereas all the guests match exactly the same animals as the Eilander masks. And it all feels super personal after all the guests are personally killed, corrupted and imprisoned

vivid bridge
#

David is wearing a mask

#

If David is an asura, he's a brown rabbit as shown by his hands. He just wears a white mask that has whiskers

steel imp
#

If david eilander was alive and well to shoot up Dale's family

#

Or he was a ghost (CS)

#

Or he was an asura

#

To you the choice

vivid bridge
#

Asura then

#

He does have the brown hands

steel imp
#

I call them gloves

vivid bridge
#

could be

steel imp
#

Anyway

vivid bridge
#

its not

#

both rabbit asuras are brown (if he's not wearing gloves)

#

Hotel-Rabbit's CS is white while David is just wearing a white mask

terse niche
#

For me there are 2 diferrent Mr. Rabbits.

steel imp
terse niche
#

The white one and the brown one

steel imp
#

And I have an explanation for it

#

Paradox is a generation that comes from both Dale's mind and from the Paradox machine

vivid bridge
#

its the same design

steel imp
#

Let me explain

vivid bridge
#

or you mean this?

steel imp
#

In the movie masks are more realistic

#

So you can't say that its production related

steel imp
vivid bridge
#

yeah keep going

#

i'm listening

terse niche
#

Still, it doesn't mean it's a mask in Birthday or Hotel

steel imp
#

It requires Dale's mind to work on it and bring it mentally back to life

#

Now, considering that Dale had a trauma

#

It's difficult to recall the exact face of someone that you saw for 5 seconds (because paradox happens before birthday) and that killed your family

#

So what better way to recall him than just a mask

#

Problem solved for evrypne

terse niche
vivid bridge
#

I mean, I feel like thats assuming a lot about how people's brains work in fiction

steel imp
#

And you're basing and argument on rabbit mustaches

vivid bridge
#

well yeah at least thats tangible information

#

here's something else. The David cosplayer is specifically wearing a small face-only mask while the Mr. Crow cosplayer has a whole head covering mask

steel imp
#

Guess why?

#

Because he was wearing a mask in paradox

vivid bridge
#

yeah but that scene in Paradox is Birthday. You're assuming that his design changed based on how Dale perceives him

steel imp
#

Yes

#

I'm precisely assuming tha6

vivid bridge
#

well at least we understand each other

steel imp
#

And I also claim that the person is cosplaying based on Paradox

#

And not birthday

terse niche
#

This image looks more like people in costume. The corrupted soul is clearly a guy in a black costume and mask.

steel imp
#

We know

terse niche
#

So I don't know if this confirms anything

vivid bridge
#

i'm saying that if David was a full transformed white rabbit, the cosplayer would resemble that like the Mr. Crow and Mr. Boar cosplayers

#

but he doesn't

#

He specifically cosplays David wearing a mask

terse niche
#

And where did you see that David would be wearing a mask in Paradox?

steel imp
#

Channel 369

#

Past mind

#

Chapter 2

vivid bridge
#

I think its a mask due to him not acting like a corrupted soul and his hands being brown

#

and yeah, the tv thing

steel imp
#

I think it's a mask because paradox is a far more popular game than birthdsy

#

One it's a whole production tied with a 1 hour film

terse niche
#

Well, considering that that TV image is an image of "real" reality (like the film), there is no such thing as a person who has a head like a rabbit in real life.

steel imp
#

The other is a flash game

#

Might have the same lore importance

#

But not the same audience

#

I, for example, discovered the RL franchise from steam

#

And by what game?

#

Cube Escape Paradox

vivid bridge
#

I just don't see how you can argue that he is an animal person but Dale perceives him as just a guy wearing a mask. That's stretching it I feel like

terse niche
#

So if someone played Mr. Rabbit in reality, he obviously needs to wear a rabbit mask/head

steel imp
#

Dale has seen for a too short amount of time

#

He fsintly remembered it was a rabbit

#

It's confirmed by channel 369

#

There are visual diffeences between birthday and paradix

#

What do you want more?

steel imp
#

By the angle of birthday Mr. Rabbit you could have seen the teeth

#

But they weren't there

#

Why

vivid bridge
#

I think thats just a redesign thing

steel imp
#

Because the teeth are an artifact of Dale's mind

steel imp
#

Then

terse niche
#

In paradox there are several Dales. Including an asura (or god) Dale with a deer's head, a corrupted Dale, a real Dale (from the real world played by David Bowles) and many others. They are all real in their loops

vivid bridge
#

the only reason why i'm pointing the whiskers out is because they are consistent. The Corrupted Soul of Hotel-Rabbit never has them while David always has them

steel imp
terse niche
#

That's why I don't think any Mr. Rabbit wears a mask. Is just a real person that need to wear a rabbit mask to look Mr. Rabbit

vivid bridge
#

Show me an example where thats not true

steel imp
vivid bridge
#

hm yeah

#

you got me there

steel imp
#

3 whiskers, 2 without em

#

Completely random

vivid bridge
#

Okay but in the games themselves its consistent

steel imp
#

But there pther things that make all these rabbits diffrent

#

Clothing

#

Teeth

steel imp
#

Sometimes ear hairs are missing between one onother

vivid bridge
#

its just weird how in the same game, they specifically gave one whiskers while the other one doesn't

#

and also what do you think the window ghost is?

steel imp
terse niche
#

This conversation strikes me as the exact same problem with Dale's grandfather and Mr. Crow being identical.

terse niche
#

And that's why I agree with you. I stand with it stating that he is an asura.

steel imp
terse niche
#

Because I think Dale's grandfather is a lot like Mr. Crow to be conscience.

#

Then I was told it was an artistic choice, that Mr. Crow from The Cave was darker than Grandpa, etc.

vivid bridge
# terse niche That's why I don't think any Mr. Rabbit wears a mask. Is just a real person that...

Like in that picture with cosplayers, there are different ways of portraying rusty lake characters. Mr. Crow in Paradox wears a full on head on his shoulders because thats just how you portray a magical humanoid crow creature. David on the other hand is just portrayed by a man wearing a face-only mask. If you wanted him to appear as a legit magic rabbit man, he would also need the full mask

steel imp
steel imp
#

You just gave me an idea

#

Those two

#

Those two are the traditional aldous vanderboom

#

They have their little eyes closed

#

But this guy

#

Oh

#

This guy has his eyes opened

#

Blasphemy

#

There are two Aldous Vanderboom

terse niche
vivid bridge
terse niche
steel imp
#

What now

vivid bridge
#

one day they'll confirm the two rabbits theory and then i'll be the one who laughs

terse niche
#

I guess some things will never be answered. EmmaCry

steel imp
#

I've done it

#

The issue of double rabbits will never come up again

terse niche
#

Please bring me enlightenment. Maybe I'll become a Mrs. Cat MrMemoryThumbsUp

#

Or Mrs. Panter

steel imp
#

So I was wandering

terse niche
#

If I could choose, it would be a feline.

steel imp
vivid bridge
#

my theory is that when Dale becomes a deva, he'll look like a small mexican chihuahua

steel imp
#

And some people seem to speak alone

vivid bridge
#

nah I hope the deva form is something completely original

#

not just Dale with an animal head

steel imp
terse niche
#

That would be really amazing

steel imp
#

And it seems that he's replying to someone

#

But there's no message in between

vivid bridge
#

oh yesterday?

steel imp
#

Yeah

#

Why

#

What happened

vivid bridge
#

yeah we were talking to this new guy who then got banned for violating the discord rules

steel imp
#

Or similar stuff

vivid bridge
#

nah he said he had modded discord

steel imp
#

Oh

vivid bridge
#

I think thats the thing that got him banned

steel imp
#

Ok

terse niche
#

o.o

vivid bridge
#

its a shame, he was a knowledgable guy

#

He was like another nowhere

#

which might be too much nowhere tbh

terse niche
#

Davas look quite human.

steel imp
#

So this nowhere its pretty good at theories

#

I'll keep it in mind

terse niche
#

It would be cool of Dale look like Ganesha

vivid bridge
#

I still think it would be a crazy plot twist if Dale died and Laura became a deva

terse niche
#

Or Kali

steel imp
#

For as much as its possible

vivid bridge
#

I mean, it would be cool

#

its unexpected

terse niche
#

The only problem with this guy is that it's hard to talk about theories sometimes. He has good ideas but he acts like he knows everything and other theories are obviously wrong.

terse niche
#

But I like a lot of the ideas he has

#

Yeah

steel imp
#

I read a couple messages of his and he seems to be very respectful of other ideas

terse niche
#

Well, I may have misunderstood.

#

But as I said, ideas are good and it's great when we reach a common denominator

azure bay
vivid bridge
#

never

azure bay
#

//_-

steel imp
azure bay
steel imp
#

About the Eilander/guests dilemma?

azure bay
#

I think there's no dilemma. Until I see the second group of asuras looking specifically like these animals, I'll deny their existence

steel imp
#

What do you think about the rabbit mustaches?

azure bay
#
  1. an error due to design evolution (All 4 rabbits have some lines in common)
#

so much that you could see a transition from brown Rabbit to his corrupted soul and to Birthday Rabbit

#
  1. it's deliberate
#

There's strong evidence that Mr. Rabbit is somehow corrupted in Birthday

#

yet he doesn't look corrupted

steel imp
#

You could theoretically put up clothes and hide the black spiky part

azure bay
#

that's even beyond that

#

despite all corrupted vibes and clues, he's pretty much alive

#

he bleeds

#

and he definitely has some Dale-like rebirth journey

#

so I've got an idea that he evolved during that journey

#

1st whiskers

#

than eventually flesh and blood and dapper suit

steel imp
#

I think that's not necessary

#

I think he didn't evolve

#

And I have an example to back it up

#

Cube Escape: The Lake

#

When we fish with the prown head

#

A corrupted soul comes up

#

But when we cut it he has flesh, and consequntaly blood, in it

#

Not only

#

He has clothes

azure bay
#

when they were dead

#

and we needed some trigger to awaken them

vivid bridge
# steel imp A corrupted soul comes up

I hate playing that card but I think thats just early installment weirdness. Like when they made Seasons/The Lake, they hadn't invented the concept of "corrupted souls" yet, it was just a creepy corpse

steel imp
azure bay
vivid bridge
#

yeah i'm just saying what the original intention is

vivid bridge
#

You can definitely explain it your way, nowhere

steel imp
#

Whatever the story may have been ghen

#

It's no more today

azure bay
azure bay
#

which is pretty early too

steel imp
azure bay
# steel imp Explain yourself

Laura's dress, Albert's suit, Bob's outfit - all were consumed during corruption. In some cases even preserved after the corruption is gone.

It's different for Rabbit. His suit isn't consumed by corruption

#

it's a normal suit

steel imp
#

I argue that's just arbitrary

#

Like when we awaken the corpse the clothes don't get consumed

azure bay
steel imp
#

A naked corpse?

azure bay
#

with a CS hining inside like Venom

vivid bridge
#

nah the corpse was wearing clothes

steel imp
#

This is not naked

#

It has clear corners

#

It's like a suit

vivid bridge
#

its like a full body diving suit or something

steel imp
#

A swimsuit

vivid bridge
#

yeah yeah

steel imp
#

And if they weren't clothes

azure bay
#

swimsuits don't cover feet

steel imp
#

But some kind of outwr substanxe

#

It will still get consumed

azure bay
#

all you see is rot

steel imp
#

I could wear a log if I wanted too

#

Or someone else skin

#

That would still be outer material

#

And by your logic

#

That should get consumed too

#

But it doesn't

azure bay
#

because we never see the corrupted soul fully awaikened

vivid bridge
#

I mean, presumably this is the same guy

azure bay
#

corruption gradually spreads across the body

steel imp
#

What establishes that the soul is awakened

azure bay
steel imp
azure bay
#

just a void black corrupted soul

steel imp
#

Then I could even argue that the incosistancy its fruit of the dev reusing a sprite

#

The thing is

azure bay
#

they always reuse sprites for corrupted souls

azure bay
# steel imp .

you see it taking over the whole body and walking around probably killing you in the process

vivid bridge
#

the closest thing to the corpse in The Lake is Bob's corruption in Theatre and even there he fully corrupts

steel imp
#

It's awakened, so it takea over the body

#

It takes over the body, so it's awakened

azure bay
#

it's really a corpse

#

immobile

steel imp
#

Just because it's immobile doesn't mean it's dead

#

I could argue that is gameplay related

#

It isn't moving cuz we ain't touching it

azure bay
steel imp
#

What do you mean?

azure bay
#

1st with a hook

#

then she had to drag it onto the peer

#

then dispose it

#

it looks dead and doesn't look corrupted

#

it's not void black

#

unlike the vaaaaaaaaaaaaast majority of corrupted souls

#

it even has an unrotten forearm

steel imp
#

That's still a circle argument

#

It has clothes

#

It has clothes, and considering that its diffrent by the others, it's not a corrupted soul

steel imp
#

It's not a corrupted soul, so if he has clothes, that's irrelevant

azure bay
#

that's not the point

#

the clothes and corruption are 2 separate matters

#

1st statement (the relevant one for Rabbit argument)

#

It's a dead corpse that becomes corrupted for a brief moment

steel imp
#

What?

#

You don't just get corrupted "for a brief moment"

azure bay
steel imp
#

I think not

#

Leaving clothes apart

azure bay
#

ok, I'll reiterate

steel imp
#

The fact that he doesn't move it's irrelevant

azure bay
#

initially it LOOKS LIKE a dead corpse

steel imp
#

Ok

azure bay
#

but it has a CS dormant inside. Just like Laura's corpse or Albert's corpse

steel imp
#

But I'm saying that the CS

#

Isn't dormant

#

I say that he acted following a structured plan

#

I say that he didn't move to be fished unsuspisously

azure bay
steel imp
#

And get a hold on how the cabin was structured

steel imp
azure bay
steel imp
#

We are discussing if the CS can have clothes

azure bay
#

that's not what we're discussing right now

#

we're discussing in what way that corpse is a CS

steel imp
#

If you discard that with "CS are just void black" then there's nithing for me to argue on

steel imp
vivid bridge
#

this is such a stupid argument

steel imp
#

You are doing too many assumption that are unproven

azure bay
steel imp
azure bay
#

ok, let's ger some statistics

steel imp
#

You are saying that the CS has to be void black, has to move and has to be dangerous

steel imp
azure bay
#

ok, not statistics, precedents

steel imp
#

That's the same thing

#

You are considering other cases

#

You don't need statistic when something happens right before you

#

I have concrete proof that this can happen

azure bay
steel imp
#

Look at it this way. You are a corrupted soul, you are trapped between the actual real rusty lake and the etheral, wider lake

#

You are between both realities

#

Not in the forest

#

But not even in the real world

azure bay
#

that was never a problem

#

The guests freely walk and leave the lake

steel imp
#

Because they're in the forest

#

They're not in a limbo

azure bay
#

it's quite a stretch saying that the corpse from physical world is in the one

#

We have a ton of references of corrupted souls

steel imp
#

Ok I have made up my mind again

#

It's true, the problem it's not related to physics

#

Let me start again

#

You are a corrupted soul who's in need to balance the substances of his past life

azure bay
#

so?

steel imp
#

So you climb up the lake

azure bay
#

why?

steel imp
#

But hey, you don't know how the place that you are going to assault is made

steel imp
steel imp
#

But this crazy lady opens you up with a knife, and you reveal for a moment your true nature

#

Now disxovered, you flee to rise again

azure bay
steel imp
#

Since you had enough time to inspect the encoirnement

azure bay
#

and doesn't even describe the observed reality

steel imp
azure bay
#

the soul doesn't panic

steel imp
#

I didn't say that

azure bay
#

or whatever

steel imp
#

I said that he reveals its nature in a slip

azure bay
#

and after both times keeps lying on the peer

steel imp
#

By pain or something

azure bay
#

until we click on it to probably drop back into the lake

steel imp
#

I claim this is all gameplay related

azure bay
#

we have all the time in the world to take the apple

steel imp
azure bay
#

the soul doesn't try to stop us

steel imp
#

Bevause it hasn't time to realize it

azure bay
#

and you base the whole situation on a very specific fanfic-level assumption

steel imp
#

I claim thst in the lore, the kinfe cuts are at a distance of a second, and when we try to give the third, the "corpse" escapes

steel imp
#

A corrupted soul has the mental capabilities (lore wise) to put on a plan like this

#

We play as a corrupted soul through seasons, and we manage to put to function a complex system to power up a phone

#

Corrupted soul don't go around killing because it's in their nature

#

They do it to escape their state of tortured ghost

#

Tho balance the substances of their past lives

azure bay
#

a desperate soul trying to swim up the lake to balance the substance of past lives (even if it's possible which is doubtful) without a single hint about it is technically a fanfiction. You try to faithfully fill the gaps where the devs left them