#š¤ļ½theories
1 messages Ā· Page 6 of 1
He's looking at stuff surrounding the victim's life to try and understand what happened
Also, thanks
they just live in a weird world
We all forget to think about the killer of laura
We all are like
Lake this
Lake that
Maybe its all related to killer
most of the focus of the games are on lauras death and her killer
isn't there a theory that she commited suicide
you are right there!
also we have evidence
The Cave part 2
submarine
she cut open her own throat
It was black cube I believe
now the only counter evidence we have is, she might be influenced by the other factors of doing that
such as her inner CS
like Van Gogh
either Laura CS or William CS
nevertheless
more counter points of that
why would they want Laura to be dead? Is it easier to take over her body? Why would they do that
anyway
It seems like I am talking to myself
sorry for spamming
Eh it's fine
yeah it looks like she cuts it herself under influence of her cs
thats why its hard to define suicide
technically, if thats her own CS
she cut her own throat
thats suicide...
right?
yep but if it's william's it's murder
yea
Well, thats leads to a more philosophical question, is it still suicide if its the phisical manisfetation of the bad things you lived killing you?
id say its suicide
if someone tells someone else to shoot a person, theyre both charged with murder still (second degree granted)
suicide/assisted suicide
thats what I have been thinking, because afterall, suicide is the only serious philosophical question (quote Albert Camus)
Calling my boy phoenix wright for this brb
what's more, Bob came to know that Laura committed suicide (only some characters knew all the stuff involving Laura)
crack theory that this is all just dales guilt fuelled nightmare after not being able to save his family on his birthday
and so all the "normal" people all around
so hes haunted by a murder of a woman he cant solve
I mean he saw it on the news?
yeah
But why is dale seeing laura if he don't know her
as i said, crack theory, but you can see unknown people in dreams lol
shes a generic lookin woman
its not a fact lol
people say its a fact
but its made up to say the spoopy āoooh youve seen everything in your nightmares beforeā thing
find me any study that says its a proven fact and ill change my mind on that
Well, the thing is, do we believe that it was laura's CS that killed her or was it william's? Or are they even distinct CS's
Are they even CS
If they are alive
How can laura and Laura's cs exist at same time
That proves it is a murder
mayb its like a jekyll and hyde thing
where theyre the same person but the āgoodā and the ābadā parts
It was split personality
But here we can see 2 different people
And that contradicts the theory of Laura's suicide or murder by william cs
Well, laura is a bit of a special case because she is william reborn
actually no everyone u've seen in ur dreams u've seen somewhere
But soul is one
on the streets, in school, somewhere
nah
I'm
Axing the dream conversation
That's not leading as anywhere and we'll just go in circles.
Feel free to keep discussing the duality of Laura's soul, though.
Conclusion
Laura was murdered by someone else's CS
Now who???
Or is it a normal murder
And dale is suffering from schizophrenia
Dont we see that it is laura's corrupted soul in the paradox movie?
thank you thank you
We see as the corrupted soul separates from her and then slices her throat
anyway, I wrote all Laura suicide things here, feel free to scroll a bit
in Paradox, it's Dale the one killing Laura
to some extent, maybe in a moral way
he was killing Laura if he gave up
saving her
but I cant judge
obviously
self sacrifice is pure altruism
yeah that's a good interpretation in my opinion
How can laura and her CS exist as 2 personalities together
If what stray said was true
I once formed a theory but a bit too far fetched and gave up
It was about Laura's CS wants to end her Human form's suffering so CS just...yea
I've in the past proposed laura and William are two souls in the same body
indeed
thats another way
But It's probably an impossibility considering the Samsara wheel
but as I said
Ye
Why would william do that if he wants to sort of live?
Maybe laura's soul is formed of both frank and leonard's soul
he would rather destroy something that he cant get?
thats the only explanation for William I can think of
interesting point, could u elaborate
Well, frank and leonard are both grabbed by the roots of the family tree in the end of roots, just all the other sacrifices
ehm
the problem with this is that Rose's soul is not fused neither
so I guess its still no strong evidence we got
My gramma has a stroke
forgive me
Do we know when william dies?
Like, the season?
Maybe the clock has some protecting properties, considering that william's body stayed there atleast from spring 1860 to summer 1860 and there isnt any decomposition
William dies in 1859, so its got to be atleast a few months that he's been in that grandfather clock
always thought it happened in 1859, and some months after James received the letter from Aldous/Jakob
William comes out of clock in many games
Like in samsara room
So you are thinking that william is time itself?
Yes, but samsara room isnt the real world, in roots we are in the real rusty lake world, not a memory or a sort of "in-between" place
Is there even a theory in game
Or devs are just watching us saying crazy things to each other
I just broke the 4th wallš
Maybe they change rhe lore depending on best theories
But the thing is
The devs havent revealed anything directly
Like.. I would change my story if some guy thought of something better
We know that the past is not even past
I am that f'ed up I am questioning my own relaity
Like am I really breaking 4th wall
Or am I just mad
Thats the point
I don't think so, that would be too cheap, they definetly already have the way they want to tell this story in their heads
Explain
What loop
Idk
Then how do you know it's a loop
But in many games they say the past is not even past
And how does it mean past is not past
Best I can think of it is
Their words
That the past we see through dale is
Altered
And that explains how past is not past
They say that the past is never dead its not even past because of the golden cubes, which are shown to affect time
Phd
Explain
White,black and gold cube
Good memories, bad memories, time altering shenanigans in that order
When did golden cube altered time
Birthday
*shenanigans š
Gold cube in bday
When
You put the gold cube in the clock in the wall and time reverses to before mr.rabbit came in and murdered everyone
thats blue cube not golden cube š
SHOOT, you're right
Bro got point
Sorry about that
Phd 0
Random dude 1
I got the blue cube and golden cube confused, thats all
golden cube only exists in cave and paradox afaik
@bright parrot don't correct people's English without their permission.
I never did that
Sure.
I am not correcting it
I am just repeating it
I just love that word
Maybe phd wrote it correct (yup he did)
So coming back
Random cubes like blue and golden are not shown correctly
Will they ever return
@real lantern maybe golden cube is for memory altering
No, thats the blue cube
Blue is for time altering
Maybe i didnt express myself correctly, i meant time altering as in altering time in the memories
Because birthday is dale revisiting his own manipulated memories while being guided by Mr.owl
Only golden cube exist
We see the cubes exist in real life in games like the mill
And in real life with the ARG
I doubt the existence of mill incedent
And why is that?
Idk why but I am just not convinced enough by RL the mill
Coz there is not prior context
They be like
Boom
You are someone now
Idk who
People say it's albert
You play as Mr.crow in the mill
Yup
It's actually set up rather well
The mill guy is the boatman
I am currently seeing it all again
brb
Exactly! A very important character right
Is that sarcasm
Who happens to be mr.crow
No he is not mr crow
Except he is.
Ok, tgat came out of left field
But aldous already became mr crow when he was with william
I think you're confusing aldous with albert
is there any evidence for or against the boatman being aldous
Ok that makes more sense
In case 23 you cut the stitching in his mouth and he turns into the crow
I think the most obvious is probably Aldous being portrayed as such in case 23 I guess?
In the cave you play as mr.boatman and when he drinks the elixir he turns into mr.crow
And in secret level of roots
The biggest evidence is birth of Mr. Crow
In RL ROOTS
Nope
You play as aldous
ohh
Ok, im gonna send some screenshots, brb
Sure
I actualy gotta get to chapter 3 of case 23
This is from the mill
Send it from walkthrough
Good idea
ok I think that confirms it lmao
Yes, thats what im saying, you play as aldous who is the boatman
mr crow = aldous = boatman
Ohhh yeah
But how did aldous land in this position
How did he become human again
Whe he got stitches
We are dale
Exploring Aldous place
how does this prove we're dale?
we're reading a message addressed to mr crow
this seems to imply moreover that we're mr crow right
Dale is on the other side of the phone
In the mill we see mr.owl do some magic to an unconsious dale to make it rain
We're talking to Dale
No
Check the walkthrough for once
that's what I thought
I see familiar faces
I was confused about it too for a while
And with the phone dale is on the side, we are seeing the same conversation as in case 23
Mill takes place at the same time as Case 23
No
But from mr.crow's side
Maybe yeah you are right
Dale does say fate in one game
Sry phd
I caused a bit of confusion
Now I am sure we are mr crow here
It is verbatim to the phone call in case 23, so unless you're saying that we dont play as dale in case 23 dale has to be on the other side of the phone
Ah yes, complex analysis
Agreed
Also we litteraly see dale on the other side of the lake in the mill, so there's no way we're dale
The reason why crow brought dale to cabin
And what dale will do
But we don't know why dale
Ic
In case 23 dale finds the two cubes in the church and then he gets brought to the cabin, so that checks out
this link between case 23 and mill is interesting
do we ever the see the phone call in paradox from the other person's perspective?
Dale was the sort of chosen one and then case 23 was a test to confirm whether he is truly the one
Then
so laura's death was a test?
By the end of the cave, he will face his final challenge to prove that he is sort of worthy?
Maybe, but I think itās destiny
Both are in same timeline
When is that phone call again? Chapter 1 or 2?
Its important all of you read this
RL MILLS AND RL CASE23 ARE IN SAME TIME WATCH THEM TOGETHER TO SEE THE RESEMBLENCE
there's one in chapter 1 and two in chapter 2
as far as I remember
If u include Johnson and crow
chapter 2 has the present mind one (burn soul) and also the calling the magic rabbit
Bird food
Oh I forgot the bird food
so chapter 2 has three
chapter 1 has only one though as far as I remember
yep
The room in the back
Is it from seasons
Seemingly yes
That one might have been mr.crow speaking because of the voice
Ah yes
But then again, it is bob rafferty that does the vlice for both LMAO
No itās Bob speaking
Tbh
I donāt think I remember crow saying tonnes of stuff
Itās always owl the wordy introduction guy
So i believe itās still owl but I aināt sure
I mean, in most games he doesnt have a voice, he just makes crow noises when he taljs

Corrupted Souls speak that more often than Crow. Plus, I don't think Crow would ask for searching for him in the past
Crow spoke in case 23 and mills
Same lines
Actualy, why does mr.crow speak with the thing where you talk backwards and reverse the track, when thats something thatmostly corrupted souls do
Maybe he was corrupted for a sec
He is showing small signs of corruption slowly he will become a CS
Some of the same lines
The others are different
And the message overall deviates
In The Mill it was "leave memories behind"
Not what Laura does in Seasons
And you simply don't go corrupted for a sec
Removing corruption is one hell of a task
- his voice was never revealed before that game
maybe they decided to develop him as a "normal person", while before he was more a misterious entity
Laura is not corrupted by any event.
She is corrupted by birth
That's an interesting take š¤ It makes sense to me since William was corrupted and achieve his reincarnation through unethical means, plus the whole reincarnation kinda loopholed around the "one with die and the other will become enlightened" thing
How and when was william corrupted
Bt this is Laura's birth scene from roots
Have you seen in some movies a character goes mad or smth.
He shows a few signs
Goes mad for moment like that.
Thats william's soul
Upon rebirth, the soul is renewed, since it started another stage on samsara
Laura just got corrupted way after
If I remember correctly, in Roots we see us as him in a mirror, corrupted
But the soul is same
That is what makes both laura and william related
Oh plus Samsara Room
Coz we play as him in soul form
That's just not true. All samsara material say she's human. While corrupted soul is a different state of existence
"Extraction of the memories caused a corrupted soul, one of the 6 stages of the wheel"
This is William gradually transforming. He becomes Laura only in the end
Using other movie tropes is a slippery road.
Nobody guarantees the devs watch them.
Plus that wouldn't make sense. We play as Crow in The Mill, we speak as him to Dale and Laura. CS are generally agressive and unintelligent and he definitely isn't.
Also sounds like "death isn't an excuse to stop working"
@real lantern
Remember yesterday we talked about cubes
So listen the conclusion
We get all three cubes in
RL the Cave
Then we put that in a machine which makes a golden cube.
Now dale is free from the lift journey we give him the cube
Andddd.
To be continued.....
yep those sure are the events as they happen in Cube Escape the cave.
Now Dale's story will move in present
But I have some doubts related to timeline
Like how can aldous change his form with his choice.
We saw mr owl changing his form just once in RL PARADOX
We also see that in the cave
Give timestamp or explain
Before we get on the submarine we free a person from a diver's suit and give them the elixir, they turn into mr owl
Coz that guy is mr owl
And can then turn back into the bald guy if you tap on them
So Hotel guest too
Maybe
But that's doesn't make sense
Then why would they like to look hybrid
Like power rangers without power
Just Ranger
And are there hybrids that look human but are hybrids
Thats assuming something you dont know, maybe they like looking like animals in front of fellow enlightened
Maybe they dont feel comfortable looking like Mr.owl's family in front of him
Theres 100 possible explanations
Signature look of superiority
Thats possible too
All this is like cheese
(Lot of holes)
It may take like 20-30 games for story
Thats a meme š
Thats possible, but also maybe it gets explained in the train game, maybe it gets explained in an easter egg in the past within, who knows
Phd what do you think and know about corrupted souls
What it take to be a hybrid
The Cave is just a beginning of that trip
man, there's only one trip
A trip through the lake with its cubes
and I can prove it
All ears mate
Edit- eyes š
-
When Dale stood up he started flickering between human and corrupted state. When we see him in Birthday-Theatre he's still flickering
-
Birthday-Theatre is Dale riding by the cubes floating around the lake so is the trip seen by Owl in the prophecy that is to end at the hotel
The Cave machine is exclusively about Paradox without an apparent beginning, ending with the elevator and the cube
in ch2 secret ending that is
while Birthday and Theatre both begin and end with said elevator
the same elevator Harvey rides in Rusty Lake Hotel game
Listen
1st harvey rides same elevator
Because that room and whatever dale is in is part of hotel
2nd Currently dale was in his altered memories now he is free
And maybe now he will be the fate of hotel
exactly, and it means that the Birthday-Theatre elevator is real
memories are cubes
floating around the lake
Actually both are imaginary
please, don't disappoint me like that
So how are they connected to lift
Lift ain't no rollercoaster
Sorry bud
But both are past
In his mind
And giving him the illusion
While he is sitting
In the whote room
The elevator is real, the cubes are real, whenever he enters a cube what happens there might be manipulated to help him in some way
of course the memories are past but you enter them from the present. You can look in them, you can relive them, that's what the whole series is about
So Dale's a unreliable narrator somewhat
How are memories real
I mean how is he living them like it is today
Yes
But the younger him
kind of. occasionally. but it's not his fault
We play RL Bday as kid dale
This is litteraly a series where people turn into animald, occams razor can only go so far lmao
That's fair
you have to replay the series. because so many games speak of memories being stored in cubes. Pretty much physical objects
we look for them in Paradise
We extract them in The Mill
I kinda know
But we are not present dale in them
we recover them in The Cave
So what I'm getting is
Dale's a unreliable narrator somewhat atleast due to things outta his control
I don't mean it's present Dale, I mean there's only one trip of present Dale reliving his past memories while going upwards
Agreed
So it could be what we see is either real or fake (atleast if we consider reality)
that's true only for 3 games
Birthday, Theatre and Paradox
Well yeah but it's still semi true from what I got?
Paradox is not true
Maybe dale was never there
Paradox is more complex but still a memory
a memory of a dream
But he does not remember
How I need proof
Lucid dream maybe?
It maybe a dream not a memory of dream
Dale, as you said, is connected to a machine unconscious. In the ending he's still unconscious and sees everything around himself as the Ch2 secret ending. Therefore, it's a dream.
Originally it was just a dream but its architects put a cube of this very dream in its end. And cubes are memories. When he enters said memory he watches the dream from the beginning and in the end finds its cube again and so forth.
So it's a dream transitioning into a looping memory of itself
So loke he finda another memory in a game and then goes into it and cycle continues
Vanderboom have same sets of siblings
1 sister 2 brother
Emma, albert, samuel
Rose, frank, leonard
So there is a chance that aldous and william may have a sister who was married so don't live with them or is dead
And there can be 2 brothers of laura
Sons of frank and leonard
It's just a thought
Can be just a coincidence
aldous and william having a third sibling is a very recurrent theory, it would explain how none of them seem to be james' dad
i doubt laura has any brother considering how she was born, unless rose married after giving her birth and had 2 kids (that would be kinda weird to be introduced at this point of the story), id say that bit is a no-no
but i do like the trios thingy tho, i usually take laura/dale/bob crew as the new one since theyre the newest gen
Oooh that's an interesting idea
That's an interesting take as well
A trio that isn't related for a change
(and just to make things clear, rose, frank and leo arent sibs, but i get the trio thing)
But linked with the case rather than blood
Well.....
Considering the way Rose was born, I'm pretty sure she's Leonard's half sister
But also cousin
oh, that yeah
Courtesy of funny jar man
best part of that theory? the 3rd person with aldous and william is the dog and in the james/mary group we have the ring hand
all the pieces fit together!
Maybe those three are related but they don't know
Incest is not thet odd in RL as Rose and Frank liked each other
Sort of cousins
Then the hand must belong to someone
A male
Ehh i prefer to think rl isnt all about one big family quarrel
Dale could be from a family bastardized by crow and that would explain why his grandpa is identical to aldous? Yes
Bob could be somehow related to the vanderboom and/or eilanders? Sure
But why?
Eilanders are dead
And Dale's grandpa does not exist neither does blue cube
If Dale's grandpa was real
Then why is he not in newspaper articles
From roots and paradise
You can't think more of it
Family underestimated you
You go boom boom
Btw is damy there or is she sleeping with screen on
It mustnt in the end of the day tbh, aside from the possibility of aldous and william having another sib (which is, in its turn, totally irrelevant up until now), so far the trio thingy is nothing more than a mere coincidence (in-universe ofc, the devs prolly did that on purpose, either if its for roots' gameplay sake or for future developments)
And i prefer to not dwell too much over things that doesnt change anything (in other terms, its on my text notes, but not highlighted)
It ain't no coincidence
Like a new villian every season
They may also bring characters
By now i just take it as a rule of thumb from the devs' so the games' casts get enough different characters to never bore the players, in the end trios are present all over lots of stories so its no surprise they did it in rl too
But again, its nice to mark it in the book to revisit it in case future developments bring that back to the spotlight
š
If James isn't Aldous' son then there must be a 3rd brother otherwise he wouldn't keep the last name
Nobody is in the newspaper article if I recall it correctly
To keep the trio
3rd sibling is a she
Dude, you are applying a pattern created by your own brain.
While in the reality we either have nobody 3rd or it's likely a male, considering the evidence we have
What evidence for a male
I know I am making a wild guess
And making a 3rd character female will not make a huge change
Yep
But
Where is grandpa here
1st of all, I agree with you for my personal reasons.
But still, I think grandpa's abscence in Paradox isn't compelling enough as evidence
Tell me
Where would you place him there?
Physically
personal?
I. No need to tell
If you don't want to
On the sofa
And the thing is
Only grandpa messed up with timeline
He killed rebbit
I wouldn't have problems with grandpa being Crow if it wasn't rendering the universe small
Then chair maybe
What about this
Drop that for now
Lemme ask you smth
If you know something
Like I have 20 bucks
And I reverse tims
To the time you don't remember I have 20
Will you remember thta
But grandpa did
Not that I have 20 bucks
But that Rabbit will kill
I'm sure it was Dale who said everyone. Father even asks "how did you know".
And grandpa was the only adult cool enough to take him seriously.
Plus, we already have Dale speaking without us hearing. In a secret scene of TWD he asks Bob for memories what we don't realize in Case 23
Also
Your "grandpa knew" is actively used to prove that he's actually Crow
I don't deny that he is Mr. Crow
All I am Saying is
That he does not belong there
Dale is sent to Birthday scene by Mr. Owl
And Mr. Owl is fixing his traumatic memories
I say that people use the same argument to prove that he belongs there
Like he fixed the memory of death of his parents in RL bday
You don't have to explain this to me. We already agree. (It seems)
Yes
All I am saying is he was not there at the time of murder
He is in the memory
The grandpa
But Crow and Dale are relatives, you think?
Nope c:
Like Crow is not Dale's grandpa
They don't have to be linked to move the story forward
Yep
I don't think this resemblance is strong enough to be noted
Still
It's the same art style kind of resemblance
Before Paradox global redesign Bob resembled van Gogh the most appearance and action-wise
And is van Gogh related or they just put him coz they ran out of ideas
Edit -Homage
That wasn't idea hunger. It was an hommage
Van Gogh had a bit triangular face and bob is blocky
Yeah sry
Both bearded redheads shooting themselves in a head with a revolver. That kind of resemblance
I meant face resemblance
Just like all dutchees 
00101 001 1101
But that's not relevant to theories.
Also not relevant to theories.
Finished here
So coming back to pint
Damy
Who do you think
Bob's face
Resembles
/shrug Bob.
In game character
O okay discord
Funny enough, nobody theory worthy (maybe except for van Gogh)
And nothing else
Shall we drop this then
I guess so
Despite loving Mr. Crow the history decided that I'm not him
So call me either noWhere or nowHere
nwh
You got something nwh
I always have something
The problem is, I have so many of thing to say I don't always remember what I already told and definitely don't know where to start
Ok here's one
Acc. To me
What they are doing to dale
They are fixing his bad memories
So that he can become the new god
And corrupting all his memories may result in him being new Mr. Owl
Wdym by new Mr. Owl?
You and me bud
You and me
Wdym by corrupting memories?
Jakob wants dale to take his place
Making them sad.
And crow is betraying
Owl
I saw the opposite. Dale's black cube of birthday turned white
By helping dale
Yes
It was a bad memory
Murder of parents
It turned white
Then where's corruption?
If you played mills
You know
Mr crow (grandpa) fixed it
Making it white
And maybe owl wants to make white cubes black
So
If a game ends with white cube
Means the memory is good now
And if it ends with black
It's bad now
Owl helped changing it more than anyone
It was him to send the machine
Then maybe owl is also good guy
He wants to stop all this
Coz we have never seen bad of owl or crow
So we don't know what side they are on
We seemingly saw
Are they the bad guys
I think they just have their pov on the greater good
We don't know what the greater good is
I am going for now but type your opinion
I will ping you when I come online
It seems that Paradise plagues are more regular than we think
I don't think Caroline was the direct reason for them
since memories stop plagues, I think it's about them
I'd assume giving the lake fresh memories prevents an apocalypse of sort
Then maybe dale will bring an end to the plagues
And I heard that these are the plagues from bible
Anyone to confirm this
some of them are, iirc
Ih rusty lake paradise we have many plagues from the bible
And We cleared out paradise
From them. Later this place became a hotel
Yes
Sup cass
Today is the day 
Today is theast day
ohhh. Yeah
Disclaimer; we do not have a release time.
Or maybe it wont
then don;t bring it like it's fact.
Because demo came at that time
it's a good time to release it at least
Theories here
your next infraction will earn you a mute.
Agreed, i dont think its caroline personaly that was the reason for the plagues, i think its the lack of memories, and maybe no one else in the island knew how to collect memories
Actually, while we're on theories, my boyfriend made me aware of a very particular question last night.
Why specifically the memories of people dealing with mental problems? Why a mental facility? Wouldn't happy, healthy minds produce better memories for the lake?
but they're avoiding the black cubes, are they not?
So here's the thing
The take a black cube
Coz nobody wants that
Make a white out of it
Maybe. Or maybe he'll do the same but more efficiently and for longer
Hmm. My memory is a bit fuzzy. This was shown in.... Mill, I assume?
Yes it was
They need a white
And taking bad memories make soul corrupted
And give a black cube
Ok, just had a random thought, what if Mr.owl had some sort of similar revelation happen to him when he was sacrificed to the lake in the end of paradise, and he's trying to simulate that with dale?
though that bring another question. Wouldn't inherently good memories be less work?
and lessen the chance of corruption
His death brought a stop in plagues
And maybe they are coming again
That's not a guarantee. You need to be careful
Maybe it was said in mill
It was
Maybe Mr.owl has a bit of a heart, and doesnt want to remove people's good memories
I like your optimism XD
So he makes bad memories good and takes that
Maybe the error in process gives bad memories
Dale needed his memories good as self improvement
And they can't waste memories
Hey, maybe the family murdering insane man is just a big helping softy inside LMAO
What about Laura, then?
Laura was corrupted by mistake
Laura did it herself. No Owl involved
But what if thats what they are doing in TWD, just in a less efficient way
hmmmm
They extracted painful memories and thus laura became corrupted
We don't really know what they do in TWD. Bob was a special case and even his memories were not to be altered
It is
In some sense it is
Sister location, I'd say
So they're affiliated after all? I was under the impression that they weren't too keen of each other
considering we literally erase parts of bobs memory;
id say memory work was done
if that's what you mean.
Extraction
erased, but not altered
I mean more
They didn't change what the memory was. They just took it away
See, Thats what makes me think i might be right, maybe they take depressed people to turn their sad lives into happy memories, take some, and let them on their merry way, but bob is just (pardon my lenguage) more kinds of fucked up, so it simply doesnt work on him
with others they changed it
I can see how that may be an easier process
We saw 2 members of eilander in TWD
Yeeaahh XD
It was Sarah. Owl was returning his memories and he needed both Bob and memories together
TWD is connected. Maybe not directly but still. Laura is Bob love. They broke up so Bob were at theatre later drinking
Uncle
And grandma
Oh, I was responding to Damy. I don't remember the eilanders in TWD
It's been a long time :')
wait sorry are you implying Sarah went rogue? cuss I guess that would make sense considering the ARG
Yeah, that was my impression as well
ye I mean I suppose I probably should've come to that conclusion earlier? Lmao
Hoorn warned Owl of someone going rogue and Owl asked Sarah not to touch the woman
I feel like this got sort of burried, so im gonna put it back here
Hmm. I mean, he's suffering trauma like the others. I'm actually not sure why he's special
Bob's affiliated to Laura and Laura is important. Can't say more, I'm confused about the plan
that's about as much as I know too
Owl made clear that Bob's memories about Laura are what makes him important
yup
After all Laura is showing through many games. Sheās connecting everything
So Bob really chose wrong girl
Oh my
I think it was already about William considering it was in The Cave
They needed his elixir formula
Can't say what they wanted to do with her
Maybe find his related memories
Or make her recall her past life
But something went wrong and she died
Unfortunately possibilities are next to limitless
Could be a cabin CS incident
Could be William maddening her
Could be unsuccessful and they decided to kill her
Could want to kill her from the start
Damn we need more info about her trip
Could also be it didnt work, so they killed her to try and extract the memories using the mill
But, as you said, theres a whole number of things that could have happened
that's what I said in one of the options
maybe not clearly enough
It indeed is, sorry about that one lmao
Didnt manage to get much sleep
I guess that could explain why they removed the black cube aswell, if you realy squint at it
They looked in her good memories to try and find the elixir, it didnt work, "maybe its in the bad memories, considering he died when he drank it"
in The Cave book both cubes are marked with the elixir insignia
Also I think originally (before William was the thing) the lake just needed memories and without painful ones Owl'd be unable to maintain a steady flow.
As I think about that, black cubes are more frequent too
During the stream, we see a few images of things featured in the new game. a specific thing is Albert's casket, which my theory is. It will come into use during the gameplay and that Rose will have to use her ouji board again to speak with him. Maybe for a puzzle or hint
there's a lovely thread consacrated spesifically for TPW theories
oh, thx for the help here, nowhere 
And yeah, we will prolly send a reminder about it with the official release announcement, but since the game already is available in some places, just wanted to humbly ask to move every TPW-related theory to the aforementioned thread so ppl who are yet to play dont end up spoilered by accident
For those who already played, go as brrrrrrrrrr as you want in #945320126608179231
In the livestream there was this corrupted soul in a weird position and I found it pretty similar to the one we see at the end of rusty lake: roots
good observation
don't know if there is something there, but just wanted to share this
maybe is just the fetus corpse deafault pose
the roots one was william's, no?
highly doubt he will come back as a soul again, prolly just a normal pose for corrupted ppl 
I was thinking of that too, but I was kind of bothered because there was also an image of the eye you can see in cube escape: the cave while in the submarine
there are just these images that feel out of place
peepholes are still a thing
hello!do you talk about the live on ytube?
I think they removed the eye image from the doc, I can't find it
im cutting a bit, I think the eye is still in there.
axing the clutter
.. frick its gone
my bad
Readded at the bottom
it's a human eye and technically, it's a peephole
and the last thing I feel it's kind of out of place is this bedroom image (also coming back to the topic of william vanderboom) since I'm pretty sure this is samsara's room
||the game you play as william reencarnating||
it's the room seen in trailers
with Rose and Albert's coffin
o ye?
also seen in the demo
my bad so :/
we will see if this random statement by me is gonna be canon when tpw releases
Oh my
Guys, i got the code from rusty lake: hotel. Is it worth it or i shouldnt bother?
It was useful when the collection wasnt released, but now the code was added into one of its games so welp, its pretty so so
Sarah can be her daughter because they got same hair
But I thought Sarah is just a side character
Despite what Parrot said, Hotel is still the most obvious way to find the code. It's still working, it's cool, you are good to go into Birthday to enter it
But note that in RL no one is a side character
And I think we will see more of BOB
Whose daugther?
Owl
Jakob
@azure bay
Remember about the trio theory
Maybe we will see more of Bob with laura and dale.
And Bob and dale will be related to vanderbooms
Coz Dale's last name is a little same to vanderboom (vandermeer)
And I can relate bob to dale as he is in same conditions
(maybe a little)
That's what I'm scared of. Rusty Lake turning into Indian soap opera where everyone is secretely related and start a group dance in the end
Indian soap opera LOL
I am indian and can relate
Anyways
If family doesn't matter
Why are they laying emphasis on family
Why RL roots
Why RL paradise
If only info was needed
That could be done by a little story
Sometimes it's interesting and relevant, sometimes it's not
Like in real life
By the way the "van der" theory doesn't work
It's just a common prefix in dutch names
Translates as "of the"
Aldous of the tree
Dale of the lake
Which language is it
Dutch, my friend. It's dutch
Ohh like
Dale of the lake
First of his
Name
Protector of Rusty lake
What about eilander
Can you guess it?
There's nothing about protectors in any of last names
Islander
What is Bob's last name
Hill
That doesn't make sense then
Btw listen
Dale's role was decided before birth
He is for the lake
He is of laks
Like laura is of tree
The tree of elixir
Netherlands don't have mountains, in case you'll try to locate the lake
So is he related to the lake somehow
Doesn't look like it
He's related to Laura
His memories of her lade him relevant for Owl
I don't think we'll see him again in any meaningful role
Maybe we will coz he showed some progress is white door
All progress, I'd say. His story seems over despite explaining so little.
Say what u want but he's still a side character. That's the reason i
TWD is published under Second Maze
Oh
Maybe they are building a new world
In second maze
Coz I would love to see more of bob and sarah

More like highlighting obscure characters and publishing some unrelated indie stuff
Yep
The worldbuilding they do will be used in the major continuity
TWD seems to be the location of the Cubical Device in TPW
From the q&a
So it's confirmed many parts regarding those first games will be retcons
(Off topic)
I dunno seems pretty on topic for theories lol
Doesn't look like that
Off topic since it's one hour left for tpwš
I mean, it's another hint to not take those games literally
Even if some main themes were already there (memories, cubes, CS)
Thhere are many reasons not to take games literally
Soft worldbuilding isn't always one of them
Yeah yeah, I mean, that's something like a confirmation from devs in my opinion
Also TPW makes me think that we should take Seasons literally
We'll see
||RL says tpw is a spin off but I don't think it is. Albert's story has not come to an end in this game, but it is the beginning||
||To be fair, they said it was a spin off from Roots, which I agree with. This feels like another chapter of that game's specific story. Which is lovely||
I suggest to Read this spoiler theory after you finish this game, there must be tons of reviews like a day after today
||a spin off from Roots it is, but not the whole cube escape story||
Just finished the game as the past, ||so was there a reason why the reincarnation had to happen in the future?||
Could be anything, || could be the technology required, could be the time a soul needs for rebirth?? ||
ahh ||technology makes sense||
||So now he and rose can stay immortal forever since they already have all the equipment||
||Although I don't know why she had to become a tree, kind of a bummer||
ye im unsure what they meant with that.
My seasons theory is that the game is happening during the end of the cave. Her soul doesn't remember who she was and thinks she killed laura so she "changes" the past, but in reality she was going trough this journey while she was on that chair.
Paradox can also be explained like this but for dale, this would make the first and last cube escape happen at the same time
although it sounds really crazy i'll admit
Hmmm, i doubt it
Seasons indeed is about laura visiting her memories, but it seems she was doing it without the chair from cave's white room
By the time of cave she was already corrupted as sheesh (not to mention completely dead)
I don't like "it was all a dream" explanations but I can't fit the game in the story any other way, did she actually time travel?
Yes, she visited her memories via the cubes and changed the past
That would mean her soul actually killed her because killing the soul in the past undoes the murder
I really like the idea of that. Are there any moments where things seem to line up between Seasons and Paradox?
I also wondered if the events of Seasons could be happening when we put Laura's head into the machine in The Mill because of the different visual references to it but I need to look into it further to see if it makes any sense.
Does anyone think that the similarity between the rounded edges of the game window in the Cube Escape games and the rounded window of the memory viewer in the submarine from The Cave (and the Memory processor in The Mill) is deliberate or am I just trying to read into things that aren't there?
Like are we, as the player, looking into a Memory cube viewer?
idk about line ups but in seasons the player learns that the corrupted soul was the killer and then we learn we are the soul, when you look at the mirror you say "it's me..."
so it's weird to be the killer and not know about it
Also Harvey in seasons is little and we know she was never young
when she became a full parrot she was an adult from the start
I think seasons harvey may just be small bc of the artwork at the time tbh?
most likely it's that
Or maybe they didn't think about making the parrot a character back then
Doesn't Dale's reflection change to a corrupted soul in Paradox?
In some sense, the games are all memories
But id say its much more design stufd than "oh lets round edges so it relates to another thing"
Yeah, I figured that's probably the reason behind it. But I like the idea that we as the player are using some sort of memory viewer the same as Mr Crow might use to look into the different memories.
But it probably is just an aesthetic choice to make things look like you're playing it through an old CRT TV
Imagine how awkward it was between Leonard and Albert in the few years that they were alone in the house
just wanted to know if the code was nice to discover or i could just pass over it, thank you!
it unlocks a magnificent lore heavy secret scene
i thought it was pretty obvious the dark soul in seasons is laura having a crisis, there are pills and she is the only one that appears as the victim and the protagonist at the end. she also has little notes in the game, she goes from wanting to eat harveys eggs to killing harvey
duuude!, awesome, thank you!, im gonna do it
is there an inconsistency with the year of rusty lake hotel? In the game it says it's 1893 but in the roots level where we see the guests inside the hotel it's 1870
I believe this served more as an easter egg (and solution to a puzzle) rather than something chronologically accurate.
Or maybe they went multiple times
I always liked the idea that they were either going to the Hotel once a year so Mr Owl could lull them into a false sense of security or that they were caught in a loop of torment that kept repeating || until the easter egg in Birthday, at least ||
whats the full timeline of rusty lake? like which game happend first and when did everything happen
There's a really good timeline on the Rusty Lake Wiki - https://rusty-lake.fandom.com/wiki/Timeline
The Rusty Lake games do not take place in chronological order, with some involving travel to previous years within their own direct timeline. This page contains an approximate timeline for known events in the Rusty Lake series, including both the Cube Escape series and the premium games. Please note that this timeline contains some speculation a...
tyyy
Although, if you haven't played all of the games it might be worth steering clear of that in case it spoils anything
what game was this showed in btw?
not a game
the White Dore ARG
so I guess a game?
not a mainline game in the traditional sense.
ah
i was a bit confused on it cause i didnt reconize it
is White Door apart of cube escape stuff?
Its set in the same universe for sure
any cube escape refrences in it?
You'd have to play to find out š
no money :C
A more serious answer would be that it's a part of the story in some way, even if it's not necessarily the main story right now
May random money appear in your pockets!
tyyyy
Wah it was so cool!
Also completing all the cube escape achivements does something?, i got this symbol
knowing RL, it will be used somewhere
for another secret
maybe during the current TPW ARG
maybe in the following young Laura metro game
yeah
Laura in the matrix
WAIT IS ROSE LAURAS MOM?
yep
Any doubts?
I thought that is pretty obvious
Yes, in Roots if yu get the "Laura" achivment rose says "my daughter will return to rusty lake"
I just realized that maybe both Frank and Leonard are still alive since Rose managed to escape the tree roots in the end of rusty lake roots (and she was also stuck inside the clock!)
I am sorry to say this but this cant prove Frank and Leonard also survived
I know
Because Rose was chosen to give birth for Laura
but I think Leonard is cool and I want to believe he survived ok?
