#updated tanks

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

silver coyote
#

Tanks seem to have a well balance at this point. I would like to see the addition of Tank destroyers for each nation. Possible two each?

USA - M10 Wolverine and M18 Hellcat
GER - Jagdpantner and Stug III/IV
USSR - ASU 76 and SU 100
UK - Archer and Wolverine

molten spear
iron willow
meager smelt
#

What’s well balanced about Axis having two separate viable heavies on different cooldowns, and US having one legitimate heavy and a paper one?

The whole tank / AT system needs an overhaul

ebon pagoda
# meager smelt What’s well balanced about Axis having two separate viable heavies on different ...

Goes further than that too. Why does US get a mini medium as a light while GER gets a useless auto cannon. Then you have issues with tanks like IS-1 being able to be front pened by medium, recons being generally useless, and the other two factions lights having absolutely no identity.

I agree, armor needs an overhaul. I play SQ44 armor on the reg and HLL armor when I want to turn my brain off. HLL armor could be much better.

raw zodiac
molten spear
iron willow
molten spear
#

The comment I’m replying to is talking about how the Stuart was a Mini Medium tank, the Early Panzer III Ausf.G has the same armament and almost same armor as the Stuart

  • Panzer IIIG mounted with the 3.7 cm KwK 36 (aka 37 mm)
    Armor: 10 mm – 30 mm

  • M5A1 version was equipped with a 37 mm (1.45 in)
    Armor: From 9.5 to 51 mm (0.52-2 in)

In terms of armor the Stuart would out class the P3 but mostly they are evenly matched

So I would say again to replace the P2 with a P3 and put the 20mm gun as a buildable gun or mount it to the halftrack since the American halftrack gets the .50 Cal

nocturne rock
red dew
#

1st Fix armour and at system
2nd if tank destroyer are added, for germany it's more fiting to add Panzerjäger I and Hetzer first instead of StuG III wich is not a td. It's a light inf support tank with capability against tanks. However, StuG with the elongated canon is ok. Jagdpanther is not as fitting since there were few and as i know only on sovjiet soil.

frosty pasture
red dew