#Tournament Chat
1 messages · Page 5 of 1
I think that 350k tournament would be interestinf and faster.
imagine people bring battery ships and everyone stalemates after losing power lol
i mean
It could happen
A rule can be made to lets say you need to have one ship[ with a reactor.
could we get mini matches for inbetween real rounds
won't that just slow down everything 
idk that’s why I ask
i mean you can set up lobbies betwen the tournament so
you mean the first rounds
scrimmages :D
That's why reactored ships aren't complete poodoo.
You could also be extra cheeky and bring EMPs.
Instantly over for reactor squibs 
battery ships with massive armour anti-emp cages then
Hmm. Would basically waste all the money that not having a reactor would save them to begin with, plus without the advantages that come with having UUUNLIMITED POWWWWAAAAR!!
👍
@thin dagger where is the design competition submission chat
nvm
why no dedicated chat anymore tho :(
there are dedicated threads to the design competition
3m fights aren’t that long
3m tourney next hopefully
Imagine if I won with an unpainted brick lmao
I'd prefer to keep it at 1.5m. Everyone prepares ships at 1.5mil.. I doubt players have a lot of ships above that price range
But that's just my take
Then they would make them
I doubt many would have 300k or 100k ships either
But the time investment to make ships in that price range isn't high
You can’t really make a good ship with that
Neither is 3m if you spam
Tournament would hardly be worth watching in that case
You can make good ships with spam
Anyways, you want it, I don't. It is what it is ^^
Fair enough
The reality is, most tournaments are going to be 1.5M or lower
Always been like that
Things can change
3m will be rails/ions/missiles/deck cannons because they can scale their defense. Cannons and lasers cant do that
And?
nobody uses cannons
hls aren’t effective at that scale anyway
If it's been that way for many years, no real reason to expand the budget by that much
1.75M? More likely to happen
Look I just wanna use 3m brick in competitive
I would rather see this sort of thing in a shared price team tournament than as its own thing with required 3m ships
Rip
when 2/5 of the weapons being used normally cant be used it resutst in less ship variety, specially when factoring that lasers are used by far the most archetypes compared to any other weapon.
Yeah, a fusion of ships would definitely make that a reality when in a tag team
Like the tournament combiner kite
Oh well then I’ll get a teammate to use a 100k ship and use a brick anyway
Good luck
gl convincing your teammate
Assuming the tournament is set where the team controls who uses what % of budget
brick has to be fast enough to catch other ships or long range enough to engage with other ships regardless
ez dodge
GameKnight and I would 100% be down for another team tournament…
Dodge... EMP?!
That's the neat thing, EMP is like a boomerang. It COMES BACK.
EMPs are like a certain afton fella
Oh we finally get to know EMP's gender :DDD
high explosive missiles will more often boomerang than emp
because they recieved a pathing buff while emps didn't
Yeah, very sad.
That's why I'm saying that all different types of missiles should have their own kind of pathing.
more dodgable than he l0ol
BTW @narrow path it looks like @serene latch and I need the champion role.
I already pinged him 🥹
will old tourney winners lose their roles?
IIII Don't get it
Damn, I’m looking hot
jk, great edit tho^^
I hope so, cuz‘ I’m feeling like I don‘t deserve it anymore
Don't say that... You did amazing!
Well let me put it that way… after steam release I wasn’t able to play how much I wanted and I lost interest pretty quick while others where grinding this game. That’s why I don’t want it anymore cuz other put way more effort then I did.
I see... Pains me to hear that.
I've seen some older tournaments and you were an absolute BEAST!
Really I think you're fine Zquey. I'd prefer to have you here, regardless of time you spent prepping
Anyway, as for the 1v1 or 2v2 conundrum;
1v1s require a ship limit and banning system, which requires that ships be submitted so that they can be given to players during the tournament. The issue with this is that I am intent on participating in tournaments, so I cannot reasonably do this. It could be percieved, despite my stellar reputation, that I sabotage my competitor's ships, or study them and learn to counter them, both giving me an unfair advantage via my position as the tournament producer. However, it takes significant management for the weeks leading up to the event to process submitted ships, such that I don't want to saddle other people with such an intense amount of work.
This combination of factors means that until an alternative solution is established, tournaments will be 2v2s indefinitely. I am pinning this post such that if anyone has a solution or workaround they can suggest it.
Also worth mentioning that an alternative solution to counterpick loops than a banning system that doesn't rely on randomness, IE a countdown or turning previews off, would allow for 1v1s to take place again.
why not have ivi do the ship stuff
IVIemories understandably doesn't want to do or be involved in the actual production due to the nightmare of management involved. I'd have to ask the tournament assistants like Atris or Fusion, but I feel as though that would be an unreasonable request
I would be open to helping but it depends on my plans for the month
Same
I think I could run a tournament, just need to not have any pressing deadlines around that time
I think most of the time you would probably be able to find someone that has the time to do the ship management stuff for you.
not being able to participate in the tournament definitely makes it more difficult, since most people who actually care also want to participate
If anything, I have lots of time now and am not planning to participate in the tournament again.
I might not be very familiar with cosmoteer, but I'm fine with dealing with ship submissions if I am explained what to do with them.
I think there's still a lot of counter picking in 2v2s
Also another thing:
In my previous communication with saris, he said that I could use locking tech for this tournament, but only this one.
I believe that locking tech doesnt actually give that much of an advantage, but still agaisnt the rules I think
I'd love for it to not be agaisnt the rules, as it allows for more voltron ships and most people think its cool
2v2s indefinitely?!
Oh my god...
That's both a blessing in disguise and a really risky thing at the same time.
wait, locking tech against the rules? why would it be? we've always done it as, if you can ship it, bring it
I overestimated how useful it would actually be, so it's fine
This has been the case... for the first time something is seen, typically derailing the tournament for the obvious exploit to sweep. Given the lack of power in locking tech it's not an issue
fair enough. I guess usually we can expect walt to fix things which greatly disrupt multiplayer after a tournament
if something ever can't be fixed for whatever reason and is a major exploit that becomes the only meta thing, it would definitely make sense to ban it in the next tournament though.
Explosion guns were banned as far as I remember, as were nuke flingers
W H E W
Locking tech is one of the coolest ''bug'' that has ever come out in the game, it's one of the best things about 2v2 tournaments and banning it would make both playing and viewing the tourneys way less interesting.
I think their ought be a better effort to actually share how it works though, if it is being kept
iirc nuke flingers were fixed long before the next tournament, and explosion guns were nerfed heavily, but idk if they still existed in some form when the next tournament happened
Wait, what's wrong with nuke flingers?
I remember when walt wanted to keep explosion guns in the game, just weaker, but one update or another eventually made even that obsolete
They can be unfair but they require a lot of skill and setup... Right?
What's an explosion gun...
explosion gun (timestamped) https://youtu.be/WWF2uutsJnA?t=5403
I'll make a doc on Sunday if you want
Infinite range unavoidable projectiles dealing huge damage is just so much fun y'know?
I can't imagine why people wouldn't want to deal with that
Okay.
Wow that's so cool!!
Now I'm sad you can't push nukes with TB any longer 😔
I don't see anything overpowered about it.
It's just a way to give nukes more range.
it wasn't nukes being pushed, it was their explosions
They need a ton of setup so they aren't that worth it.
Aah.
an armour pellet was propelled through 16x nukes, and the explosions inherited its momentum. The thing with explosions is that they disregard all armour and shields, they just deal full nuke damage to every part in their way.
OH GOD.
I see why it was banned...
It's still an epic thing though.
I'd love to have seen it nerfed, like it didn't have to go through shields and armors or something.
Which is why it was okay for the one tournament
God forbid I'm so happy that ion capacitors aren't overpowered or they'd be banned too...
Cool tech should be celebrated but not worshipped through exclusive usage is my take on it
I am going to make an ion capacitor PvP ship...
Yup.
Not a viable one lol
The fact that things like 2 player contraptions and ULMSFs and what not exist is in my opinion what keeps the meta interesting and not completely stale.
Like, I'd rather see these weird ships be able to do something over just staring at railkites and DC rams smash at each other for 5 hours straight.
The fact that Cosmoteer competitive allows wacky experimentation like this is really cool and Walt should be proud he accidentally made such a thing...
It's rarely seen in other games' competitives, if ever.
also there's a very good reason that 2019 nuke flingers were quickly patched https://youtu.be/jJm0yqNELiY?t=1974
they had momentum boost range and could be autofired for pinpoint accuracy with zero effort from the player
so just... heavy artillery in cosmoteer, hits enemy as they spawn in
EMOTIONAL DAMAGE!!!
I don't see a case against Explosion cannons though.
They weren't really overpowered.
Just a neat abuse of game's system.
Should've been made into a feature to be honest
If you argue that it's overpowered, then there's a very good argument that railfans are OP too. Insanely good penetration and ability to burry through 500 layers of armor.
after walt made nuke explosions have limited lifetime damage, the explosion guns were fine
idk what change eventually broke them though
like how nuke mobile spinner forts used to be meta but are now a pale shadow of what they once were
lmao, I didn't even remember this, but I just watched the finale of the april 2019 tournament and found out that I was beating oem with the nuke flingers and then after I stopped using them with a laser triangle of all things, but got lured into AI ship missile spam and died
it was a bug with explosions phasing through ships, when he set the explosions to ship relative it was basically patched
I had no idea the loss vs oem was so close, the game was exactly 2 seconds from ending then too and my CR got hit by a missile
ever since then I usually had more than 1CR in my ships though
DID SOMEBODY SAY NUKE MSF-
How were they broken before?
Wasn't that big of an investment back then 😔
well, let's see. Nuke spinners back then could:
-have permathrust cores, becoming ludicrously nimble in all directions despite heavy armour
-fire nukes directly and with accuracy and a momentum boost from spinning, making approaching one pretty suicidal
-exploit the shield bug which caused shields to turn in a direction at high spin speeds (good or bad depending on the design)
-have infinite nukes, since well, no storages
Wait, how ludicrously nimble.
nuke spinners now get less responsive and bulkier cores, limited ammunition, and most importantly, nukes which don't launch directly at your opponent but rather in a random direction and then home in (not very well)
They aren't even that fast right now with the glorious 100% thruster buff...
like, pretty close to what my ultralight spinner pulls off now relative to other thrust arrangements of the time
But yeah, the nuke storage part is pretty accurate.
nuke storage isn't even that bad, in a way it's an advantage since less expensive factory logistics
Okay right XD
less top speed, but they did also have like 2000 extra tons of armour on them
perma boost
back then, boost thrusters could be supplied while boosting
u just need 2 crew and a reactor
Yes, you might've been able to align boosters inside, but look at this!
Boost thrusters boosted back then ~5000 kilonewtons
Huge thrusters now 8000 kilonewtons.
It's still better.
Wait... So boosts could be supplied while boosting?!
uh no... huge thrusters were definitely worse
...Plus we have ER now.
+50% thrust boost.
boost thrusters have more thrust than huge
and less weight and no ramp up time
this was all before larger reactors and ER distributing thrust
also engine rooms were optional because it would push the energy consumption past what could be supplied by a single reactor
so they were only used with a hotkey for when u need that extra speed
also the drag formula was way different back then
and also not as many ships used monothrust
Did they really have more thrust than huges have now?
ya?
pretty sure it has always been like that
u can download an old version of cosmoteer to check
also it was before direct control
I have it but too lazy to open... Okay no that's be a lie I'm in clutter right now and should be doing something else :agony:
idk if ppl still use rts for the cores
No I always pilot the core myself. I've tried in RTS and it easily gets stuck and jammed.
yeah, so u had to pilot it with rts, meaning the slow ramp up time of huge thrusters made them way less responsive
Yeah that's one thing about boosts and what could've made permaboost impossibly powerful... It has ZERO rampup time, like, none at all!
yeah the cores were very responsive. You can pilot modern cores in rts too though, it's just less efficient
The rail kite was the only joiner in the tournament to actually use the exploit to lock ships tho
I could help with that, If you want I could type up a paragraph in discord or something
you literally just clip through because walt's physics code is inaccurate at low speeds
i think walt already hinted at the exploit being possible in ask-walt lmao (<#ask-walt message>)
Genius, so clear, so intuitive. If you go slowly your ship welds together, nevermind that there's specific arrangements that improve it or means that make it more consistent
I wonder why, if it's so extremely basic, that only one of the four combining ships used it?
it's obviously a bug, but I definitely didn't know there were ways to do that intentionally.
I've only ever seen a random AI ship get stuck in a station or something.
setting it up is not trivial, since it really gets down to float-level precision, so in most cases, the collision detection works as intended
(trust me i tried)
u missed the sarcasm
i missed worse
Lack of popularity
I don't think any of the other people who did joiners knew about it
"It's always 30, though it does change collision detection algorithms depending on their relative speed to each other."
(Having the collision detection algorithim that's at 21 m/s or lower is vital)
honestly, locking is actually pretty easy after doing it enough times, its just getting a feel for it that takes the longest (in my experience anyways)
Huh really? I thought the combiner spinner used it too... 
See? It's not a bug if it's confirmed by the developer to work... And it's honestly a really innocent and interchangeable thing so banning it is quite trivial.
Nah, it used a detachable ship lock and bunch of hooks
Hmm. That's why it snapped, no pun intended.
What are y’alls thoughts on a tournament where the only rule (in regards to building your ship) is that you must build within the restrictions of a certain shape?
For example, a triangle grid could be provided, and everyone must place ship parts in only that triangle shape for all competing ships. No money restrictions, just space restrictions
I got the idea from several mobile shipbuilding games where players must build within grids, and wondered if it would translate well to a hypothetical cosmoteer tournament
it could work, but we need to think through which weapons benefit and which suffer
if you can just spam large reactors, you can get very strong shields at the expense of internal durability. Which is an interesting difference.
I have an insane potentially broken suggestion:
Asteroids are free. They have a lot of HP.
YES.
ASTEROID ARMOR
FREE ARMOR
Literally rock orbiters
Orbiters aren't good friends with Dwaine wannabes, because of their orbital one-way thrust.
With missiles
not very popular
the song
I came up with idea
They work well but missile orbuters/kiters cna do the same thing
And rock orbiting is actually super boring
They're in the same boat as railkites, just that they take more skill then setting a single move command, so they didn't catch on
Cool idea I guess.
It should take a lot of skill though...
They have different counters
Also rely on rock placement rng
Bc you can't really push a rock
No, you're just circling, idk wasn't too hard to use
Hmm.
Just make a ship with a lot of mining lazers then burrow into an asteroid
With enough boost thrusters you could probably get a small one to move
Mining laser meta?
I'm all for it lol.
it's very very boring and painful to fight
and to use
either u get rushed and just die or it's everyone turtling for a year
boost thrusters would probably be worse than huges
When will be next tournament?
25th and the 26th
This month?
Yes
Cool
Official Tournaments, or the ones hosted by me, are a monthly affair excepting of course December
fun
Got it, thx for the info. And I want to ask, the atomic missiles and explosive charge are banned on the tournament, or no?
IF the rules are the same as the last tournament, then no they are not banned
If you mean nukes, no, both are fine
Nice
I haven't read half the discussion that went on here, but just to make sure. It;s only going to be 2v2's for a while correct?
See, so the issue is 1v1s have counterpicking, so there needs to be a minimum 3 ships per player, so ships need to be submitted
Buuuut I also want to participate, so I cannot organize and catalog the ships and keep them updated, which is a lot of work that I must then just divert to a different person
why can't someone use a single ship the entire time?
Because I don't think rock vs scissors is entertaining for anyone or engaging for players
And the Last question, it will be 1.5 m credits per person?
Or another cost of ships
Yup
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1RhFiu5-lfKedpUeyi07hK40Y3ejlDXB9OI_4tU8edgU/edit?usp=sharing
If you want to try my method of locking, here's a doc explaining how to do it.
Cosmoteer Locking Guide Locking is a method of joining ships that allows for extremely stable and consistent joins. How it works:The game uses at least two different methods of collision avoidance depending on ship’s relative speeds to each other. I’m not sure what these are called, but one ...
THANK YOU
How many would be interested in doing a Domination tournament?
Lol imagine self-reacting
I'm not completely against it, but epic piloting maneuvers is what makes tournaments enjoyable, which is a thing Domination completely rips out of the game.
Yeah, that would be epic
Cant wait for the 200 accel railkite :D
500 accel is just barely under 4mil^
Well, it wouldnt be good but itll be funny
Excuse me...
How does the illegal mode allows you to make accelerators cheaper.
17 full length guns, that's the maximum I reached.
136X Accel
I did say it wouldnt be good but itll be funny
Ah right.
:p
I'm afraid of illegal tourney because this.
Imagine a rail orbiter with this many engines.
Nah 1 less er than normal
And more compact
Easier power supply
But its fine since everyone can do it too
Balanced :D
tighter deck cannon packing
would mean more crew stun tho
but probably worth it for focus in a ram
I would enjoy it, new stuff to experiment with
oh boy tiny msfs
no, you are not allowed to phase reactors inside of your enemy
trust me illegal ships will be a lot less interesting than dom
Agreed. "Illegal ships" really just means ships that are faster than normal because you can stuff engines everywhere.
It doesn't really change anything else because weapons need clearance for their projectiles.
tourney where ships get 2x speed and projectiles use their oooooold code (~1/4 speed and nukes home)
Yeah Walt just undo all your balancing work for this one 😄
A domination tournament is a cool idea, but it has this strange issue at the moment where the credit generation of the points isn't "standardized" in the same way that elimination has a standard of 1.5mil, so players aren't used to what is viable and what is not for any given tournament.
That's how we end up with players spamming a single 50-100k storage-based design for the entire match (which is also an annoying effective strategy).
It's a symptom of players playing it safe with their designs, so to speak, because everyone has ships ready to go for elimination but not for domination.
Not to mention that even a small change in credit generation can have a huge effect on what is viable from tournament to tournament, much more so than a small change for elimination.
definitely true, plus there's changes in strategy depending on the viability of snowballing etc.
Of course now that I'm thinking about it, if there is an option to make destroyed ships drop resources, then you could encourage players to use airlocks and factories to scavenge from dead enemies, which would be an interesting war of attrition 😄
I could see this being mitigated if there's over a month to prepare and build for the tournament ruleset though
It wasn’t a miscalculation on my part, there was nothing I could do to get away
Add that too
If we had better teamwork, cosmic would be covering me to push his corpse away
I didn't imply it was a miscalculation on your part, only a calculation on Nugg's part
Ultracompact. That's it big advantage.
Way more power per ER so it's way more worth it too.
actually polar mentioned an important thing, instant reactor bombing and other stuff abusing the grid
you can extend a ship very far from grid center and have it spawn elsewhere on the map
but the opponent can do the same to avoid it
it would be like battleships lol
Just cover the entire map with large reactors
Or make a grid pattern so that you could always explode the ships
not in 1.5m at least, so that's good
OH MY GOD THIS HAS EVIL AMOUNT OF POTENTIAL
Just have an autofire mine generator on your enemies' doorstep.
What you could do is make a 2 player contraption spawn waaaay closer to one-another, causing it to be able to be set up much quicker.
You could just have them spawn on top of each other, no need for locking at all
🤯
u can just instantly crash the game by spawning stuff wayyyy too far away
Oh really.
Yeah I guess it could render as a gigantic ship and cause the game to D I E
I bulit one of those
until the guy spawns in an asteroid
Asteroid armor meet mining laser fastwall
for a 1v1 tourney if you wanted two ships in a single fight would you need to have them separated by charges?
usually we allow 5 ships
but the 3 loadouts rule doesnt disallow that
u just submit as a pair
WUT
OH RIGHT
You can permatrap your enemies if you spawn asteroids right inside of them.
The more I think abuot it the more daft the concept of an illegal tournament gets.
*About.
you can spawn asteroids in pvp
even if that illegal i don't that how the game work
Asteroids cost nothing, and can be as large as you want
yes but not sure the game allow it to load in pvp
They can be loaded into pvp
They can if illegal is allowed
Please be aware ladies and gentlemen that if you're making combination ships to seek out this guide for a consistent and effective locking mechanism
Ayyy new tourney
Well um anyone wanna be a team?
I have a missile orbiter that works
And uh that’s about it
I mean I have other ships as well but they all suck ass
That's why it was scheduled two weeks in advance
Yeah I need to get good ships fast
I usually build my best ships 30 minutes before my first round 
Well this would be my first tourney so I guess I will see if that’s the case
be like me and just don't build ez
And how are ya gonna win with nothing?
if you saw my performance last tournament, i only had two rounds where i did not play The Blue Pages aka my one and only decent elim ship
Yeah the blue pages is sick
thanks
I’ve tried piloting fastwalls but they are tough
i built that ship before knowing about the tournament so what i meant was like don't prepare lol
which frankly isn't good advice
but i'm too lazy to do anything else
you could always find a partner and convince them to build a combining ship so you don't have to build anything
It is certainly some of the advice ever Qawa 💀
Well fair
Combining ships are fun
Also double rail kites are sick
The what was it swashbucklers from the last tourney we’re great
if you don't mind having almost no chance of winning the first fight I might build a ship
that's better odds then he's currently working with
Mmmm but you got ions
I mean to be honest I don’t really care if I win but it would be fun to participate
i need to learn to pvp in the next month
I believe in your ability to overcome your skill issue
me too
Okay, so the next tourney is 11AM PST?
THAT, IS, PERFECT!!!
11Pm such an amazing time frame.
It will end on like ~2AM (Considering it will be split in 2 parts each lasting ~3hours) which is more than feasible for me.
yeah seems like the perfect time to me too
cool we would finally be able to bring our extremly gimmick ship i mean our skill and expert-build ship 😅
Another tournament, nice
Im looking for a partner for the tournament, would anyone want to be my partner?
if you can do VC comms during the tournament, sure (not sure how active I can be with shipbuilding this month, but I have a bunch of ships I can use regardless)
I can
ok cool!
Im sure you already have some great ships lol
btw @surreal pecan would you sign up with me this time?
20:00 so 8pm i think
I am also in need of a partner.
partner?? only if u let me optimzie ur stuff the corridor to the middle of the er really bothers me
I am down, as long as you let me keep some of my pleasing symmetries!
I can't paint! Symmetry and geometry is all I have to make my ships look nice!
I can paint
Ngl I've been considering purchasing your services
Win the tourney with an unpainted brick, get a saris paintjob as a prize
for real saris you're encouraging people to enter with unpainted ships so they have something for you to paint
I'll consider 😏
But wait...
How will the free paintjob stuff work now that the ''three ships submitted'' rule is gone?
Not like that'd change anything. All of the winners including you I might add refused to submit any ships for me to paint thus far
we aren't refusing
Three of the ships used in the tourney that the winners tell you to paint will be painted or every single one used?
just need to think of a ship that i want painted
Or will you just get three free paint on any ship you desire?
isn't it just any ship you want to have painted?
If so, then...
😏
assuming it is, I have a certain ship in mind
Everybody gangsta till' Saris has to professionally paint a 1 billion
ship 
have fun with your obviously paintcard'ed ship
Ouch
Because of clowns like you thinking I'd actually do this I added the stipulation of ships used in-tournament
I think it's easy to tell that was a joke that I'd never actually do and used as a funny wordsake...
aww, so I don't get that ship painted 😿
Don't pretend that you're not somewhat disappointed I won't paint more than build-grid-sized ships 😛
Okay okay, you're correct on that one 😔
what about a 50% discount
I am going to use an intentionally aesthetic unpainted ship in one of the matches in hope I'd win or at least get second place...
Seriously though an Empyrea ship painted by Saris would be my dream.
Too bad I'm broke XD
I'm waiting for Bloodbatpony to finish their design tournament since they're trigger happy with the announcements
mm ok
also can i have free paimt pls :D
I was actually opening cosmoteer to do just that because why not, but now...
Is the priceof blueprints included in the 1.5mil
No.
Blueprint cost only really matters in Career. That system is not used anywhere else.
I see, thanks!
Made it as cursed as I could for ya concerning the not paint
Me painting it after all
@jagged flume a bit more on topic than contest chat, but what is the proper etiquette for how much/what parts of a ship someone can copy? I'm over here trying to build something from scratch without using any parts of a pre-existing ship lol
Despite the negative connotation of the word itself (the practice is fine) you can copy a lot of a ship, ultimately resulting with a 'clone' of a ship. A ton of the tournament ships were clones of Quiximo's original deck cannon rammer due to it's proficiency and effectiveness
The way I would personally go about it is not copy pasting anything, but understanding why the way things are, reverse engineering, and then building from the ground up. If a person did it this way, instead of just copying that, understand why they did it that way and reproduce the same effects from scratch
Sometimes with weapons and thrusters modules I feel like there's only so many ways to configure and optimize them lol
But I get what you mean
Which is why there's no moral issues whatsoever with ending up with a very similar looking ship
There's often an optimal way to do things, Eidolon being an example as discussed in #1059084974655033415. To go out of your way to not emulate it makes your ship worse off due to how it takes advantage of as many things as it can
Even the crew logistics when I was looking at them was like... damn why even bother lol
maybe this is part of why I enjoy making ships that nobody has really done before (at least in the current version)
on the disruptor version at least, i haven't looked a tthe PD version in detail yet
like the light nuke msf, that was a blast to build
lol yeah it could be. it's hard to strive to be original but also peak efficiency without too much overlap
yea, tiny dom ships sometimes r exactly the same and the creators have never seen each other
you see i actually have a ship in mind but like i haven't gotten around to actually working on it because reasons
wait we get three ships for the paint?
I agree with you so much...
I have made some truly bizarre shit that couldn't've even been conceived by another mind (Maybe possibly probably) because they really are that bonkers.
(Shipespam)
sadly i prefer piloting ;-;
Now I'm gonna finish the 1.5mil ion-rail hybrid and then probably get to the 2 player alpha fan.
...And then the 2 player missile kite.
teach me the ways.... i've only been career and shipbuilding up until now and am trying to learn to pvp
the ions avoider is not bizzard 
could be a little more efficent if it have kite power but that my opinion
Nope, as far as I'm aware this kind of thrust has never been used.
There's no such a thing as an ''uncombined ion orbiter.''
And rightfully so, that ship is ass.
But hey at least it's unique.
ummm enable direct control and try? (gosh i have no talent in teaching)
it's not because it was neevr used it's bad ._.
Is anyone still looking for a teammate?
Loking for a teammate!
Wait is the tourney 2v2 again?
yes
I am a rapidly advancing player who has learned many transferable skills applicable to cosmoteer tournaments through my real-world occupations and other video game experience, eager to complement the piloting of another player and forge valuable bonds in the community, and I am available on the tourney dates.
that's not a good CV, try: I am a rapidly advancing player who has learned many transferable skills applicable to cosmoteer tournaments through my real-world occupations and other video game experience, eager to complement the piloting of another player and forge valuable bonds in the community.
If you want to host your own tournament, how do you go about it? Do you pitch the idea to someone? Do you need to host it elsewhere from this server?
Thinking about maybe doing a tournament with unconventional rules, a potential prize and a proper rule set. But I’m unsure if the tournament host role is available to anyone
I'm pretty sure one could get the role, might be possible?
But you gotta have the time to go out of your way to plan all the types of tournaments, set up every little niche, etc. Sure it's a bit of a challenge
"uncombined " as in something similar to this?
Enoshade has written my resume and will be acting as my manager.
so, if you want it to be official and result in the winner getting the champion role, it has to be approved by Walt and by the current tournament managers (mainly Saris). However, unofficial tournaments are much easier to host, you just have to tell about them to an active moderator or tournament host if you want them to be posted in #events . You can host them in this server or on another server, just if it's a new discord you probably can't advertise it here directly (edit: some tournaments have been run in separate discords and posted in events before, you'd have to check with the discord staff)
Thats a ton of info, thank you :)
here's an example of a tournament spontaneously started by a discord member and then posted in events and given its own thread: #events message
Does the winner getting champion role and the tournament going in #1019749256183169065 go hand in hand?
And thanks for the example
not necessarily, blakebatpony's design tournament does not result in the role but is hosted here. I think you could probably get an unofficial tournament its own post in #1019749256183169065 , just make sure it doesn't run at the same time as anothee tournament and get the clearance of the staff.
Cool! Thanks so much
Yup.
My Absolute Radiance is basically hat except Orbiter
*That.
if we're being technical, then this is an orbiter. Yours looks more like a directional avoider which preferences one side when approsching.
More of a broadsider that has only 1 side
Yup.
The schtick is that you always have your guns pointed at the enemy whilst you let it rip around them.
Ions' rotation is still slow ass so it barely ever hits.
*Shoots.
Yeah Ion avoider is just flat out better.
i made the second one before :D
in classic though
aka most orbiters
Ionrail
it did not work well
i called it "vilda said it would be bad" or smth like that and it was pretty bad
yeah the problem is that ion and rail playstyles are fundamentally incompatible
rails fan but ions focus one spot over time
and rails prefer to stay at a distance whilst ions get more damage up close
i don't think i can make the next tourney
I’d say I’d be your teammate but my ships aren’t great
I think this could best be described as yes, it's fine to copy parts of ships but you'll have no idea why they are designed the way they are or how to use them to the greatest effect
and with most ships using large reactors the logistics and crew assignments are usually more important then the actual placement of any of the parts
The placement of ship modules can be very important at times
amazing survey lmao
Endoshade and Salephizz, the power duo
Or up to fifty different variants of Seerays ba ha ha ha
looking for a tournament partner
on a scale of 1-10, very important to extremely important
*extreamly
7806769567845768397668975678940468068670446896987589670986756804708647850078678070848674653452452875645675874978321654954562198745489897798456651578754611687444778/10
In terms of providing entertainment to the audience tho, it provided
Ima be honest this issue isn’t too bad for most
But in cases like saris it may be important depending on how much people care or not
(I don't care at all by the way)
i had a good laugh at the mispronunciation
i'm probably the only one that cares
i care when names are mispronounced intentionally
to the point that you want to punch a wall?
Just about
because if you're doing it wrong on purpose just to mess with people, you're a jerk lol
as someone whose name was purposefully mispronounced a lot growing up
I actually want mispronunciations to happen every now and then, just makes the tournaments feel all the more friendly and light-hearted and also insanely funny
Like that one time when Enoshade called me ''Nuck,'' albeit because of a typo.
nuck was piloting nuke
Yes
should we have a like
who is okay with their name being mispronounced?
and add that to ur sign up?
or or
people who dont want their name mispronounced put a name in their sign up and how to pronounce it
bc like saris would rather be called saris than appaguchee
True.
I don't even know what that means.
I only know Saris.
First time I read it like ''Appalaguchie'' for some bizarre reason.
Sounds Japanese for some reason.
Rewatching tourney highlights and hearing "lil-iac" instead of "li-lac" over and over keeps distracting me from the match
myself (good luck on mispronounce that tho)
Im fine with mine being mispronounced, but like, I doubt many people would
me seeing the name of whos typing "interesting"
lmao kwh
just because you can write your name with the international phonetic alphabet doesn't mean other will be able to pronounce it
if I show up and my name isnt mispronounced I'll be very surprised
i would be interested hwo your build look like and what you piloting is
imagine someone who just read a guide on how to build ships
that'd be me
I have some tabs up rn
Locking guide is the best tab you have open rn
Its sad that me and zachs 30 minute match wasn't in the highlights
Legitimately could have put on coffee and came back before it unfroze
Lol
@jagged flume what is your time zone?
I forgor what it was and where to find it
I'm kinda dumb ngl
Knowing my timezone is irrelevant as the time I posted for events updates for you
Past that, it's at 7:00 PM UTC
Cool
Okedoke
Uhh
Me last thing
One
For the comment way back about commentating the tournament
Is there anything I need to do or information that might be necessary?
We'd have to do a microphone check at some point to confirm that you're capable of talking, are understandable, and have a functional microphone
I'm kinda young tho
Is that alright?
Cause other then that I'm good on all fronts from what I've heard
I'd prefer you participate in the tournament for whatever it's worth. You being young shouldn't be an issue if you're capable of having good cadence with the other casters
I'd honestly be one of the most epic commentators to ever live when it comes to Cosmoteer. Shameless plugin I know. But IRL I'm insanely talkative and in chats as well. Like literally I can't shut up about Cosmoteer and other things ever in the channels and I ironically love it.
Why did I say that I don't know because I'm not supposed to be a commentator.
Speaking of which, that's one thing the most recent tournament surely lacked. Your impeccable commentating!
No seriously though, even aside from your voice, your knowledgeability in the game and ability to quickly explain all the Cosmoteer-related misconception and/or any confusion the viewers and players (And other casters) alike might have in the tournament is really good.
@surreal pecan maybe we should sign up now ?
or are you waiting until the last minute 
could I be an understudy?
😏
man so many returning teams
I would be lying if I said I didn't want a lively personality to help me out
have me commentate to balance out the positivity of the other casters
Other commentators: AND HE TAKES OUT THE SHIP FROM A RAIL IN THE BACK OH THE DYNAMIC HAS CHANGED
You: so the railfan hit the back of the ship, hm.
probably would be more pessimistic
tbh, the lot of us are sorta in the middle, pretty casual but we can spice up our commentary during exciting moments if need be
tho, atris is more of the lively one, not that its a bad thing
Yeah you guys remind me of more relaxed football announcers
true
Only in big and sudden kills you guys get excited
Which is good, I like the chill atmosphere
more of "massive piloting error on xxx's part"
don't let air cook
let air fry
XD
''FR FR Skill issue smh terrible play from insert player name bruh lmfao xd rofl bruh bruh the rock provides l+ratio git gud bro ur mom.''
That's the commentator I wanna see 😏
The tournament will be at 11:00 am UTC?
11AM PST
Saris is in the PST timezone.
(I think)
Well he said he'll be participating on 3pm PST in the previous tournament.....
Okaay... Thanks
Thought you said you weren't going to be able to make it 😛
#events message look at the times stated
discord automatically converts
Say, the tourney's in 2 weeks right?
It's in exactly 10/11 days
I still require a partner
Next weekend, I see.
11 PM, will last roughly 3 hours.
PERFECT.
Someone get this man a partner!
why dont u
do realize you pinged pyraeus in the chat where he is expecting a ping to be someone offering to partner up with him
Ah fair point
My bad pyraeus
Pinging someone isn't the end of the world no matter how much some want to pretend it is. It's at worst a very slight annoyance.
I mean it depends on how much you hate being pinged
Personally I don’t really mind but some people really care
A little notification... Unless they're literally spamming you like @surreal pecan @surreal pecan @surreal pecan you shouldn't care... Otherwise in my opinion it's slightly petty.
(Wow pinging oneself actually works)
I'm free, but will only try get a partner when I secure my hardware first
I don't mind getting pinged, but it was funny to get pinged for this 😄
you can ping yourself with a reply too
but only on phone
Oh okay.
If I get My most recent diag dc up and working I may also need a teammate, however still have to get it functional and PvP tested
Epic.
The biggest bane of diags is the fact that they are really slow. So maybe consider a detachable system with engines layed out regularly but the entire rest of the ship— diagonally.
Or EVEN BETTER! a combiner DC ship!
1.5mil DC spam hull and 1.5mil drive engine with missiles maybe.
ooh now you're thinking. can you imagine the firepower of 1.5mil worth of DCs? Then 1.5m worth of thrusters and armor to combine with lol
Yes.
I could get 8 guns on DPS-centred 750K trap, so I'm very sure an engineless module could easily have like, 20-24 guns!
It wont fit in the build limit tho
As in its too wide
Unless ur combining side by side or somethint
The o my thing is that I’d need a way to keep the engines protected, any missiles from hitting engines, however if I did make the engines in a row would that stop the -30% speed decrease?
If you’d like to we could try to work together on something like this, I have school until 3 my time and am free all Friday.
It's a diag so it will. Practically have 200 metres to play around with.
*240
So would you like to work together on it?
@jagged flume You might consider splitting design contests and tournaments into their own sections. That way announcements don’t conflict and topics are easier to find.
:> Very true I support.
Smort
when is this scheduled for?
also nice status
Tron Legacy
Let me get back to you on that
Hey @azure goblet @topaz rune @vague brook yall should participate, also Pyraeus needs a partner. It'd be cool to have returns since last tournament and the first modern appearance of Vilda
Ah I got Pyraeus
You haven't yet signed up
Yup I will tomorrow
Sorry we just partnered up today, so we still have some logistics to figure out
My Sunday afternoons are TTRPG days, I'm afraid
Ah, gotcha. I'll try to keep that in mind for future reference
Well 0neye and Vilda would be a slick duo for whatever it's worth. Paint alone'd be glorious
They sounds like a powerhouse to go against
insta-win bet
I would NOT like to go against them for sure XD
Okay just kidding, at least it'd be a visually pleasing massacre :>
after obliterating my schedule for the 50th time i mightttttt be able to make it
Just because I'd rather be safe than sorry and also have sclerosis, 11AM PST right? I mean Saris said he'd be participating on 11AM and his time zone is PST...
in #events you have auto time zone converter
OH
Okay.
Okay thanks Saris I guess.
It's time :>
It's minute-to-minute opposite no matter the timezone converter I use, that's quirky :>
literaly on the other side of the planet 
Yes, quite literally so.
btw what do u guys think of a prerecorded tourney
altho a desync would basically invalidate a match
this should probably be in #tournament-announcements
I mean... it would be interesting
Not sure if it'd be good or bad, just interesting
in theory we can do all matches simultaneously
and with the extra time maybe a double elim bracket too
Nah, I honestly prefer the stream setting.
another possibility would be to run the double elim off stream
I prefer it streamed match after match
It gives more anticipation before the match you do starts
would be nice to have 1h between the first and second match so we could see the teams scrambling to build some contraption
same
It also gives enough time to analyze the enemy ships
and build some contraption
Quick design
Is it possible to make ship names longer than what the game allows?
I'm pretty sure you can edit the file names themselves (be careful to not touch the .ship.png part) and I've heard copy pasting more words than allowed also works
can also rename ship after they where saved in the libary which allow longer name*
There is actually a limit there
I had found it while naming one of my ion rammers
thanks
bad wording my bad
the tournament document says that there's a check-in an hour before the tourney, how much leeway is there for that?
because i won't be able to get to my pc until about half an hour before the tourney
You have an hour to check in, not have to check in at exactly an hour before it starts
that's been done before (look at the beta tester one)
ah, thanks
What timezone is that 11am in the sign in?
It's at 7pm UTC. 11am is my local time
I wonder if you can get an ai as the teammate
Hehe
Say goodbye to your tournament
If you like losing, but I doubt you can
30 mins til tourney?
in a week
sounds about right
yeah saris even start the stream
XD
RIP
our team is doing great
yesterday i was playing while blind
our comms are impeccable
i'm definitely not always crashing into rocks
Boulderdash!
Get it, like Balderdash except... You dash into boulders... I won't even try
I think the pun works well.
it becomes bad after explaining it
True.
atleast people pretend to find it funny even if they dont get it
or is it just me?
oh its really just me
🤷♂️
time to delete the evidence
Nah
Jokes on you I take screenshots faster than you can delete so there's no point
Pus laziness yeah.
i think mods can read deleted msgs anyway
That's overpowered.
The scars of your past may never be erased off the canvas of reality
February Team PvP Tournament Greetings! This is the information document for all relevant info concerning the upcoming February tournament. Everyone is welcome to test their mettle and reign supreme in spaceship based combat. Additional questions can be directed to Saris#0203 (me) on Discord, ...
Appreciate it
that sheet is also pinned in game
where?
top right corner of the main scrreen when you log in
Feb 2023 Tourney notification bubble
what if you close that
... idk actually.
Thanks
Cool 👍
Best of luck finding a new partner Blaze
Thanks but I think I'll use the time to finish some work that week end now. I'll participate in the March tournament if there is one 😄
Best of luck to all participants
It's one week left and I desperately need more powerful ships.
The only thing I managed to finish is the goofy ahh combiner missile kite.
Hey @desert sky, you remember how because you were placed above me in last night's match, you had to use the locomotive, the bottom part of the missile Wartrain combiner? I found a reason for that. The MP spawning in this game is not entirely random, even if it's incredibly janky and weird. So basically, if you're in the left team, or in other words team one, or the very top of the players list in the MP lobby (In a 2 team scenario), the person placed on the top spawns on the top, and one placed on the bottom spawns in the bottom, logically. If you're placed in the right team, or team two, or the bottom of the players list as seen in the pre-match lobby, the player placed on top will spawn on the bottom and the player placed on the bottom will spawn on the relative top...
If somebody knows more about the wacky MP spawning, please let me know, because it's an extremely crucial information for combiners.
um i guess we should have a upside down version of each build in case?
Interesting...
Perhaps you could go with two railfans instead
Due to an irl family event being delayed i will be unable to participate in the tournament. The date falls squarly on the same week-end and time of day as the tournament. I'm very sorry for signing-up only to announce that i will be unable to partake in this month's tournament, especially to @odd zealot who was my tournament partner. 😔 @jagged flume
Dont worry family is more important. Enyoy the event!
I will certainly enjoy what i can watch! I hope you find a new partner soon. Maybe we can team-up next month?
I'll have access to cosmoteer this evening, and I'll probably be searching for a team mate once i confirm that I do
It is confirmed, cosmoteer has been repurchased and I can now participate in the tournament,
I am now searching for a team mate
Would you be available as my teammate, since you are available?
repurchased? what happened before?
steam account lost, same with the ships
oooof
I'm glad I upload all my ships to steam workshop
honestly, if my ships get deleted it wouldnt be that big of a deal. Its not like any of them were actually good in the first place
Now that you've mentioned it I think I'm gonna make backups since I've lost hard drives before...
Im still not sure if i will compeate...
Why not?
Anyone who can be my teammate then?
I feel soo bad.
Especially for your gorgeous aesthetic alpha PD wall.
And THE SUN
I may be able to, I’ll confirm in 8-12 hours
Alright
Hmmm
Still searching
my resume:
-played maybe ten whole rounds of multiplayer dom/elim in my five years of playing
-have made less than 50 ships (not counting my ion shenanigans) edit: probably less than 25
-still not confident that I know how to build a ship
-has lost to Marigold before
Are you saying you are available as a partner in the tournament
sure
Nice
get this man an ion barge
I’m all set to be partners if your good with it
Agreed
Eh seems fine enough to me.
No I'm talking about Zeural's (The guy with gibberish name) weird not ULMSF railspinner with shields.
U made a sun???
How do you even make a sun?!
prolly talking abt an ion capacitor
Ah.
I'm quite open to getting a partner
Im preaty sure i will take part but i do need a teammate.
Seems then we have 4 players each looking for a team mate
I can sigh up today
ahh right i forgot about that ship
yeah
Hm
Alright, I guess it’s decided, we can move this to dms that way we don’t fill out chat
“turning previews off” do you mean like editing the ship file to look like memes or something? (still need to be reviewed but you don’t have to load the ships yourself and could easily be done by anyone)
and since someone made a program/website to change the look of ship files it wouldn’t be a limited amount of people
@jagged flume I need to retract my entry. @vital spindle is now without a partner. My apologies.
@vital spindle Can we be partners?
Nooo, I mean the setting of turning previews off because all that does is change the game to rock paper scissors. Artificially changing the appearance of you ship in any way is expressly prohibited
Could be interesting though, where every ship is just one edited to be an image of a " me me "
Yeah nothing as engaging as rock paper scissors fifty times in a row and instant losses/concedes a proportional amount of times
It is one of the selling points of Gambling and why so many watch it
Never gonna happen for tournaments I run anyway
Nice
its not luck, its mind games
Maybe I’d win then…
i wonder if i can get away with using the same ship for every single match
You probably could, people think in a way where they’d start to doubt that you still using the same ship
In a "no way they're still using the same ship. "Similar to how you can think a question on a test was to easy
did you update the rules to include my method?
and what is a preview, maybe I'm not understanding the term
Wow you weren't kidding about only ten multiplayer games
When you enter a multiplayer game everybody picks a ship. You can see a small image of that ship. That is a preview. It allows me to not pick a wall into a railfan, and for my opponent to not pick a wall into my railfan
I'm mildly confused, would forcing people to edit the file not prevent that?
like what is this ship? a wall? a kite? a core?
Yeah that's why tampering with your ship's image in anyway is strictly prohibited
welp, fully confused now, guess 2v2 is fine then
I don't understand what's confusing
Don't make it so that your ship cannot be determined from a glance
Just like, don't modify it. Clearly that's nothing but a black square, ergo it's banned. The anime pictures Holomatic keeps posting are ships, and as you cannot determine what kind of ships they are, they're banned from use
I cannot put this in simpler terms. Modifying your ship appearance = bad
I get that it's against the rules I just don't get why it is when you also want to avoid rock/paper/scissors, and my understanding of
Also worth mentioning that an alternative solution to counterpick loops than a banning system that doesn't rely on randomness, IE a countdown or turning previews off, would allow for 1v1s to take place again.
is that you want to be able to turn previews off
Alternative solution... than a banning system that doesn't rely on randomness, IE (for example) turning previews offs
As turning previews off relies on randomness, it's not a good solution. I don't want to use it
ah I see
I'm with Iontinker on this one. I simply don't get why modifying ship appearance would be banned in any way in a million years, if you jave the previews are already off, SO THE SHIP THUMBNAIL ICONS ARE IRRELEVANT-
So I’m back on the market
It's like banning a usage of crane construction in an area where any construction as a whole is banned.
It's like also banning nuke flingers right now when the entire flinger archetype as a whole has long been banned.
Anyways, sorry for the weird rant.
Gaah the tournament is in 2 days and I don't have many viable ships made...
I've been SOO laserfocused on the 2 player missile kite that haven't really done anything else.
I guess I built an ion kiter and a ULMSF kiter, but that's all.
And the ULMSF kiter was a joke ship.
saris doesn't want to turn off previews -because it makes it random
Hm? But didn't he say that the previews will be off?
Did I misread something?
I thought previews would simply be turned off so the thumbnail of the ship wouldn't be visible.
So ummm anyone wanna be my partner?
alternative solution, find a host who's okay with not participating?
However, it takes significant management for the weeks leading up to the event to process submitted ships, such that I don't want to saddle other people with such an intense amount of work.
There’s gotta be someone else than saris willing
Hard to find a host as committed as Saris. Not saying it out of flattery, it's a fact.
The previews are not being turned off, that will never be a decision I make.
I am of the staunch opinion that if you have previews off the game turns into rock paper scissors and the focus changes from spaceship combat to mind games, which isn't the point of the tournaments
there's been no tampering w/ that, u can do that in vanilla cosmoteer w/ out any file editing shenanigans
if i say how to do it then ur going to get mad at me :(
@odd zealot is looking for a partner, @vital spindle
How do I write the rules in such a fashion that there is no question about this? Furthermore why are people so intent on trying to sidestep this? It's for the sake of improving the competition for everyone
loophole is loophole
Yeah guess what if you try it in tournament you're going to be banned
I already told him how anyway
not without a ~~ paragon ~~ ~~ crutch ~~ good teammate
I feel as though the spirit of the rule is VERY clear even if you choose to 'iNtErPrEt' the rule differently
just to be clear I am merely curious and don't actually care about the preview, I mean really? what does anyone expect me to use if not an ion ship
i'm probably not even going to be participating lol
(i don't think you can lol)
on the sarian no fly list :pensfive:
I welcome and appreciate all who attend, just beware that the rules exist for a reason and will be enforced accordingly
it's amazing how much people can misunderstand a simple statement and dogpile based on the misinterpretation
No kidding
@sweet pike it's a team tournament. If you don't show up then your opponent can't just fight by themself
i will try my best to attend but i cant guarantee it so is it ok that s20 could have a backup person if i am unable to attend
Why not just having him sign up with the backup person who can guarantee that they attend?
I'll ask around for a back up
For anyone new to competing in online tournaments, please keep in mind that even if you don't plan to not show up on the day of the tourney, if you can't say with 99.9% certainty that you'll be able to commit the time, you shouldn't sign up. That means your team will have to forfeit, which creates problems in the tournament brackets, and all sorts of other issues for event organizers.
That 0.01% is to account for random hardware malfunctions like your CPU exploded, your grandma died, or whatever acts of god life can throw at you that are completely out of your control.
Yes, nicely put, thank you
well the tournament is in a few days and im sure i can get something sorted where i have a couple hours arround 11
and if not i will notify you
Mmm with that being said I probably won’t attend the tournament
exactly why i did not participate in the last tournament, a week before it was starting that 0.01% chance of losing my steam, cosmoteer and pc in one night made it so i was not in for it
That's the reason i'm not seeking a partner despite wanting badly to compete. I know I won't be able to commit the time on the tourney days because i have RL stuff to deal with.
Then again, people sign up the day of the tournament, so that can happen. But at least those people know they have the time to commit to participate lol
You can actually sign up up to an hour before the tournament starts if you really wanted to
nice
also is the cost 3mill
I think it happened once that someone made it into the bracket a minute before the check in started
Just be sure you and your partner both plan to show up an hour after signing up lol
well like i said the tournament is in a few days and i will ensure if i cant make it you will be notified
But next tournament, I was thinking I'll design a 2.99mil ship, and then ask Salephz to pilot his Dart 🤣
Now that’s a strategy
That works for me, thank you
Hmm I’m debating on attending
Well I don’t really have time to prepare with a partner which is an issue
I don’t know
3m team, 1.5m per player
Don’t get me wrong I think minty is a fine person but there are people who I know better that want to attend next tournament but can’t this one
should we get a tournament participant role?
easier for saris to ping and co-ordinate
nah, that's for the game itself not the discord
I don’t know try dming saris
I mean I'm already watching this chat. It's an idea I've considered in the past but it would require that I be able to manage roles which is something currently only Walt himself and the senior moderator can do