#SKR Feedback Thread
1 messages · Page 2 of 1
you should clarify what you meant in Shattered feedback post
but no
I think its an absolutely great sign that the only thing being really discussed around skr is the money and loot situation. Shows that the content is universally very much enjoyed :D

Uh
what did i miss 
i thought we finally got content the playerbase enjoys
(also mind that i include drop rates as loot and money situation because they are heavily linked from what i can gather)
yeah its just what it feels like from trying read as much of this post as possible
like i have seen few critiques of the scroll or room system
Also ppl hate button
just the "basis" of skr seems well-received and im happy about that
i dont thinj people are complaining about the content itself
just how rarely you get to play it
How to tell if content is enjoyable if i cant play it
Like there is nothing explicitly bad i can say about rooms themselves except button room
But i cant say its smth really amazing cuz its just not for right stage of progression despite being locked behind both sirius and cz
grahh i want to play new content but i cant
buy scroll , sell all reward , repeat
HAR sinkatron?
alternatively the scroll frag to scroll HAR price might help depending on the ratio of scroll to scroll frag in revamped rates.
easiest way to add har sink is to add a 1/10000 drop to casino 
On a side note
I think we fan safely say that portal nondaily droprate is 1/50
Which seems not allat bad ig.
now grind pois to see the rates
@nova mango hop on pois at 6pm ehen im home
im doing them rn.,
what
im starting tomorrow......
it is more common than that tbh
Xd
Dunno if this was brought up but the minesweeper puzzle having 50/50s is so silly. Real minesweeper doesn't have those because you can't logic them
?
yea its not fun 
me and 2 other guildmates were helping abtruse clear minesweeper and at the very end there was a 50/50 at the bottom middle of the board and he lost 😭
Dont those exist in regular minesweeper
Confused by the “real minesweeper” thing then
They exist in like the windows minesweeper, but for good minesweepers it should be avoided as much as possible such that no guessing is required, but that's also somewhat at odds with randomly generating them. I have no clue, but I'd guess it'd be a lot more work to have "provably solvable random generated"
1/4 minesweeper free r1
most real minesweeper doesnt
wdym "real minesweeper"
Minesweeper.com itself literally has separate guess/no guess game types
Categories of "Poi Difficulty"
(for determining scroll drop chances from end pinatas)
(chart contains a couple jokes)
https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/1134852913735421963/1346179235718365224/image.png?ex=67c73e9c&is=67c5ed1c&hm=fac2ec5cf7c12ebdb31ada8a1ff97ef207a2c38496afc009101163551ae86209&=&format=webp&quality=lossless&width=1161&height=351
the ones charging designed are also real
I mean dedicated ways of playing minesweeper, not minesweeper on an mc server
wtf is amped coven
Coven can be amped??????
what is coven amped
the mysterious coven ampd
ok well the ones in monu are also real minesweeper, they're just in minecraft
this is just schizophrenia
the mysterious drask
also we need harder operatiors man
are you sure that's the right image
maybe as its own thing
that image is mostly right
because these like bar loot
can u explain what the éklfgjekélgéjl is and amped coven and drask

this is elifahoiuhe
duodeviginti
and figure out
you also missed bewitched dominion
amped coven is running it at 2am with a coffee
oh I cut it off when I added frossoli I think
hold on let me fix
amped coven is blue
pretty sure the tree is green
I cant tell if thats shitpost or real
updated the image
its 95% real 5% shitpost
as all charging uv posts are
If we ever reworked Poi Stars in r3, they'd abide by this list I think
Im gonna presume amped coven is real
ok so
- bewitched is missing
- drask (postcard)
- frossoliduopdeviginti
It’s as real as real can be
use the notion 
fixed the first
And it will feature a Frogvisborea reference
use the notion
drask i think is ex willows
What... 
Why is drask in region 3
he walked here
by that logic fross is probly ex rev
anyway I am adding scrolls to fishing
both bonus dungeons
but it will have to be new chests
wait no fross would be in why-long if it's ex rev
@ frozenearth are you a pinata
no
its a shitpost dont think too much about it
I refuse
i dont think he's young enough to be pinata'd by scp 956
This is clearly an indigo teaser
We must overanalyze it
ok drask is ex willows confirmed
Source?
every other "dungeons"
wait
is indigo a fucking bonus dungeon like willows
what is indigo's like wording thing
like the theme
Ephemeral corridors is a poi
👽
Im scared 
Yeah there's no feasibly codable way that I'm aware of to randomly generate a minesweeper board and also totally avoid 50/50s. Generally "No Guess" minesweepers are initialy generated at random and then manually curated to either remove 50/50s or trash the board entirely
You could maybe try to code in a search for specific instances where a 50/50 would be likely, but I doubt it'd grab every possible case
The first thing that came to my mind was have a separate "solver" system, so it first randomly generates the puzzle, then solves it by programming traditional minesweeper logic and if it ever encounters a non-100% option before finishing it re-generates the puzzle. But then that sounds like it's a fast track to more issues, even with programming your own solver 
However I think minesweeper is simple enough that finding a 50/50 and losing is fine to just play it again, but I might be slightly biased there 😅
This is one method used
not a fan of puzzles in general so I wish for a free or cheap conversion to combat
This is generally called “player trading” i think
1 frag 👍
arent puzzle scrolls more valuable than combat scrolls? you can sell one and buy a combat one with money remaining
supply and demand something something
Given combat scrolls have like triple the droprate of puzzle scrolls
And puzzle scrolls are generally more desirable
I also am personally of the opinion that the ability to reset on the fly is a bit too easy to justify programing a solver to detect 50/50s
Neither of those concepts are relevant here for your complaint
But I also think the same thing about first-click mines
They aren't hurting your time as you can just instantly reset and also its funny
hmm
anyways
should I make separate thread for charm balance, cause I posted my feedbacks here but they are buried
like specifically skr charm balance
?
If its skr charms than me think so since thats a jar of pickles
yeah either way honestly just new thread it
Fox healing charm my beloved ❤️
if you can keep it from turning into a slop discussion I'll bring it up with the item guys when I am done fixing drop chances
yes, its at top
gonna write it in more detail
that charm looked so booty
why would ij ever take it
-25% dmg
tbh i'd rather it is just a 2* with no downside
dont have it so Im unsure how it works, but if that +5% healing means +1 hp heal (kinda like that one +hp infusion) then personally I'm definitely using it
hunting companion heal is so underrated
Surely 1/30 because I feel like I got atleast ten by now surely
I forget tho
lets run a large scale statistical trial to spite the developers and figure out the real rates with sheer sample size alone
I will start randomly changing it in hotfixes
do not the wynncraft
have we considered tracking all the runs we have done.....
i feel like weve done enough runs to get somewhat accurate results
idk if minesweeper is in mechs or plugins but if its in mechs then thats probably an instant no lol
all puzzles are in mechs
az what if isntead of typing on discord you tried fixing gallery..
yeah i cant imagine a solver is super feasible then
the approaching 1500 line mech abomination
Remnant cache cost is going up to 8 or 10 I think
sounds good
chance of a rare in a cache is doubling
and silver dust is lowering a bit
scroll frags are now 2-3 rather than 1-2 but I might go 3-4 instead
for those curious: 1201 combat rooms have been cleared (includes sequence's long) and 479 puzzle rooms
Minesweeper has no where near 1500 lines 😛
thankfully, I think a 1500 line mech might kill me
consider pinning this and the messages below
or maybe adding it to the already pinned message with changes next week
no I will write something proper
I am just sending some loose ideas so that if someone thinks its stupid theres the most time to say that is stupid
alr then
most delusional statement I've ever written I think
I like how rares are more common in caches. The corresponding price increase makes sense, but i just wanna say that it might feel bad to do a whole combat/puzzle room and not get enough for a cache. thats as long as the scrolls will not be made MUCH more common. im still not sure what rough idea of scroll rarity you got in mind
yeah I am kinda worried about that too (not enough for caches)
you could always increase chest count
I could but that kind of puts us back in square 1
i, for one, live for the ding sound i have when i click a chest
like what was the point in increasing cost at that point
Na bro this varnish guy c gonna make it inaccurate
im increasing daily rates by roughly 10-20% with some eyeballing on the margins. I'm also adding Fragments as potential drops when you dont get a scroll
First figure out what the average from 1 scroll is?
This sounds great
I dont have exact numbers because I am still making things up as i go
but they are more rooted in reality
also Skt / fishing are getting drops
heard its 5-15 from puzzle, 6-(?) from combat?
puzzles are getting lowered
Normal Combats always give at least 6 chests
Not hexfall 😭
guh
hexfall is fake
Its 4 minimum from puzzle which feels kinda bad
But it’s a raid like skt 💔💔
going to standardize puzzles to 5/6/7 ish
dont know what to do with lower puzzles but i thought of having shuffle + logic in the same room
find the button is going to 7 max at 3 buttons
That sounds fine i guess if scroll rates r being buffed
Find me 20 people who would want to add that to the list and I will consider it
anyway i still think doing a whole room and not getting enough for a cache (or the option to buy it) feels bad, unless you make scrolls so easy to get you can reliably do 2 in one day by just doing some dailes /weeklies
wtf stop giving rewards to find the button
just make torture device
Find the button only has 11 after u get first clear so atp just do combat and fish for the normal room with 10 chests
If scroll rates are being buffed its probably fine, besides the 4 room
personally i would kinda like the puzzles to maybe be doubled for some of them slider puzzle and irrus puzzle
this is my worry.. theoretically once you get your 2nd you can kind of almost get one every room after because some frags are carrying over. But we will have to see
might end up Week 2 tuning that but I am getting ahead of myself
still wnt this to be a rare/passive thing afterall
Yeah the slider ones really easy
being first content post freeze is making this tricky
Do scrolls still drop from caches?
I think operator and minesweeper and tower are perfect rn
@feral cliff what if we halved loot and then halved cache price
but frags +1 if you dont get a scroll
huh
I would kinda prefer that be removed personally, if it would allow rates to be normalized elsewhere
tower is unfortunately going to get lowered because it takes 10 seconds to use a solver..
lower the loot in caches to the point where we can have guaranteed caches per comp
you could:
- decrease har/pdia reward from cache
- increase rare prices, introduce a rare->pdia trade
- make the cache cost around what youd expect to get in one run
- introduce more scroll frags, so that it feeds into more caches
This leads to doing SKR leading to more SKR and more minor rewards. At some point when youve got the rares, you want to sell mats instead of trading for cache. Also, the larger amount of scroll frags means you can chain SKRs more often, and sell the frags to people who want to do them more often.
Same for minesweeper tho I just meant in length
I want more opinions on this me thinks
I am very scared of getting close to skr looping into more skr but theoretically could work
since a lot of the money in that chest is balanced around rarity rather than content difficulty
no cuz that makes skr like its own content
this is alarge misconception ive had all this time...
i thought it was supposed to be more common tbh
it is hoard adjacent
increase rare prices, introduce a rare->pdia trade
this would be hella cool cause you can't do absolutely anything with shit rares rn
Personally i dont like caches dropping scrolls idk
and it was very enjoyable when i played it so i would have wanted to play it more (it was also very short)
The issue is people need it more common on a big release
Yeah for how rare it is currently the pdias it makes is not going to impact the market
Yeah that too
much loot at once -> big dopamine -> addiction -> good design
elaborate please
truth
tbf im kind of not a fan because if youre sitting on a few mats but cant buy it feels quite rewarding to get "yippee i can finally buy it" instead of "every skr is a cache or two"
true maybe
saving up
Not doing it for now
-> finished all content -> craves for more content -> player drop
might player poll for week 2
we probably should put pzuzle and combat at a 50 50 @feral cliff
people seem to want to do puzzles I thinlk
50/50 I think really
no
you also need both for sequence
75/25 is fine
I dont like the gambling encouragement its introducing with having a 100+ har jackpot reward
if there was an endless mode for skr that yielded 0 rewards I would still play it
75/25 creates a bottleneck for puzzle scrolls
all of smoke (definetly 20 people)
you are genuinely fake people bro
wtf
WHAT
exceptions are
guildcism
Youve kinda essentially stacked a casino on top of your content w sequence scrolls dropping directly
I see
damn
schizophrenia
but thats what makes mmorpgs addicting 🥺
please dont be rude to my pookie jhil ...
never talked to him in my life
or oxzy ...
waaaaaa
oxzy is fake thats true
I like scroll drops being a mini jackpot bonus from doing normal content
if that means losing jhil then id rather stay asleep 💔
need puzzle ideas
smoke vid exposing charging coming next monday
someone would need to make them
or MN can give me answers thats also cool
tower of hanoi
what is that czad
puzzle room where you play against a 1700 elo chess bot
just make bigger versions of the current puzzl
what if i moved sequence from rem scrolls to a 1/2000 from any place scrolls can drop
wow that is slop
kill me
But i feel like sequence drops stacking 2 layers of rng + a really huge payout takes it a bit too far
pretend I never said that
look it up.
surely people would enjoy 50x50 minesweeper or like 15 operator puzzles
limbo with 80 cubes
I will remove it from the drops
can we make limbo puzzle harder for more chests
not really puzzle but a parkour where the platforms disappear and appear when you jump ✍️
Az add mobs to limbo
that give you nausia
I’d prefer it maybe be turned into more remnants or allocated towards cache price budget maybe, personally
nausea
hater!!!
I think it is cool
its not even a puzzle its just the same thing each time 😭
its a puzzle, just not repeatable one 
i think it's not cool that you get 50har because lucky
me staring at the gtp ticket across the room
(we dont talk about hoard)
ok idea
I think hoard is cool
Past Sins justify Sins of the future
what if replace it with dormant version
I could vibe with this
Im ok with that
middle ground
what if we just like added gpts and leg zenith charms into skr caches to add even more rng ✍️
okay I think I have enough input
I am going to write up some changelogs
and finish the new drop chances
@silver lake reply to my dm about goobspore
i did..?
checkmate liberal.
what where
I didnt delete shit
this puzzle sucks @nova mango
mad cuz bad.
@cursive sphinx what if you implemented the tff puzzle i love that one
Az where did you reply bro
Did u see my comment about the locum gate
Beaten by an object...
that was literally tower of hanoi except 8 towers.
i strongly hate and strongly dislike calling tower of hanoi a "puzzle"
yes and with 3 towers its glorpshit
then its not towers of hanoi anymore 😭
3 towers is just repeated bs
you not fixing gallery is glorpshit.
im sure any of the devs can literally code an answer to it
it doesnt even get fun on more layers
does sirius deserve the same chances as godspore
no
my gut says sirius should be rarer
is gs repeatable infinitely
wait is sirius < gs rn?
i still dont know
does sirius have lower chance than godspore 
yes it has a slop rate
slop = infinitely repeatable
then it should have a slightly lower rate
since its both faster and doesnt have a loot cap
dailies are fine
huh isn't sirius capped at 8 loot chests per day
inverse I think sirius feels free
he was talking about goobspore
oh
maybe dailies should be slightly more cuz it's max 1, period
my steadfast tank set says true
sirius lower daily than goobspore but goobspore lower slop rate than sirius I think
since sirius doesnt have a real slop rate its just 8 uncommons
that makes sense
so rn it's sirius > daily > gs?
rn both are equal
sirius = daily > gs ic
Wait why would sirius be rarer
i think daily >= sirius > gs cuz daily is 1 cap
I would propose this
sirius daily < godspore daily
sirius uncommon > godspore uncommon
Its both capped and uh post version change sirius is fucking scary
what did version change change
sirius is awesome because you can just afk the boss fight and get rewarded with scroll chances at the end
sirius is kind of free
no
impaling doom display blocks point diagonally
Its laggier
not if you have 15 people afking with minmax blizzard
?>???
what the fuck
is this shit real?
Racism?!
does it change anything
i thought it was just visuak
it doesnt change anything its ok im trolling
like earthen tremor did
yes but like particles are fine so nobody bothered to report it
it's literally just a visual bug
???????
last sirius half the time was on 9 tps
does this outrage mean you are a smoke member
i fucking thought it was intentional and the directions were random to make it more visually interesting


cuz it casted aura and impaling doom at the same time
My game freezes when I use earthen tremor with the new charm💔 💔
me too 😂
only time i see sirius lagging the shard is when im not in the sirius
Anyway in seriousness, pub siriuses are seriously laggy and doing stuff when blight walls are all over the place for way longer is actually kinda annoying
this god damn infernal gif!!!!
why are you so infatuated by it
why does it call to you
bro its an emoji 
should it be closed
or?
fucking patrons shit
Probably not
i think it didnt help
Its doable its just more annoying
that skr was memory leaking
it's not unplayably laggy
The main thing is whenever u have to do other things like shoot down stars or chase down crown blights
should godspore slop be better than strike slop I wonder
The arena is now divided apart by walls that are barely moving
So u need way more movespeed

They said strikes
also per player cost
not just flat
the 50 vibrant hollow mats in my ec 🔥
This clearly says strike
godspore slop rate is very sloppy
id say yes because its not like anyone plays godspore right now it would definetely help
ok fair
brainless effortless runs
holy shit sudden u turn in topics tho
Godspore happens like every half an hour in lfg idk what u mean
but gs = strike rates
when iw as running with cq they were like 3.5m with everyone in the team being barely alive
A lot of ppl doing it for dailies
because gs is retryable
Thinking Ruin > skt> godspore > portal for slop rates
With pois mixed in at every stage there
Wait why is skt on that list
you are right maybe
cuz skt is repeatable
I thought skt wasnt going on it at all
wtf i didnt see more than 10 gs a month before scrolls started dropping
since ruin is way easier and takes less when optimised
sskt > nskt >= gs == ruin >>> portal imo
R u going to make hexfall drop scrolls too then
I dont know
hexfall should give guaranteed scroll if the whole team has zero comps ✍️
-# this is a joke pls don't smite me
ruin is harder than gs and gs is retryable so i feel like mr should have better chances
but gs is more expensive/more effort to get the key
you already get like 4pdias on first comp....
mr you just "buy"
idk how fast portal goes but godspore there seems like the most efficient one to spam
nobody will remember this.
like 2 min apparently
is godspore even profit after daily key if you're buying materials raw
ive seen portal runners do it in like 2:30 per portal
ig but cheaper when you consider splitting amongst a full team
since gs is ~24ar and mr 10-11
that's scary
yeah but what's the chance you're dying in a mr speedrun
not to mention that they'd probly kick you if you're dying too much
(ask carnish) in a speedrun probably low but that shouldnt be the only thing to consider since grinders are not the only players
slop score is essentially for the grinders to be honest
how many portals does a non grinder do in a day
that isnt daily
400
why dont we just reduce slop chance to 0 so that we remove grinders
czard that number feels like a lie
perchance
honestly
0 or 1 but probly 0
in here when you say scroll fragments from pois do you mean poi chests or only piñata
nothing drops from poi chests. I am adding frags to weekly, I might add to pinata. I havent figured out what kind of pinata changes I want yet
honestly, treasure wheel should have a chance to yield some scroll frags 
super tiny chance to find frags from poi chests, but not from pinata 🥺
grinding single strike for skr scrolls just reminds me of hsb f7's and i do not like it a single bit
o
in a group i think poi farming might end up be the most efficient scroll method
did grinding a single strike before not remind you of that?
i never grinded one striek for more than once
there was no rng drops back then
hoard keys...............
aside from black mist 
and bm grinding was a thing back in the day........
also like cz frush speedruns or smth
the closed i gotten to is some random emily (forgot ign) hosting boss maras at 2am and getting yelled at
also rng drops and doing the same thing too much
actually
what if we added submarines to skt and you could liek
ride a submarine into mobs and dive into those funny poison ponds
skt fishing with unique loot table
make it the submarine from ocean gate
theyre already dying
please take the schizophrenic eddie roleplaying to #gameplay-discussion
shimmy shimmy yay shimmy yay shimmy ya
what if killing juan gave you 100 sequence scrolls
monarch is alive, silver knight lore is booming, skr is getting charged to its peak
which juan
the one from cz?
the one in galengrade
there is a juan in galen
skr fishing could unironically go hard tho
thats the joke
however I thought about him playing skr last night and died a bit inside

saw monarch in locum today I think
remove redundant code rule in coding is gonna get rid of that
maybe unlocking hexfall
please never let hexfall drop scrolls 🙏
if the scroll chances only happen at the piñata why can't people just spawner rush "tier 5" pois at 0pt over and over to roll piñata chances. assuming they're higher rates than some infinitely repeatable content this would be super efficient no?
pinatas are a slop rate
if someone really wants to do that idk let them I guess

but it does scale with players right
to the same extent that strike loot rooms do
did this today for a bit and it was pretty bad
oh i had no idea strikes did that too
but it was duo ig
Did like 30-40 quelled and got none with two people
same thing for pinatas in theory
okay yeah nvm pinatas are very low chances
gosh
yeah pinatas rates are kind of abysmal dogshit right now even with scaling
so I might just add some frags
Frags r good
quelled convent is a really quick poi with spawner rush but yeah portal or godspore would just be better to do
i like frags
i think we have different standards if you think its fast..
even with how dense the poi is 180 spawners is a whole lot
silvic is the quickest poi in r3 👍
i was able to spawner rush solo clear it in like 7 minutes. that felt somewhat fast
then you would have to split scrolls with 8 people...
In situations like this, you'd get more scrolls by having it delved and getting the normal chests just so you could then buy the scrolls off market
didnt charging make pois player scale
which is the same thing happening in strikes since each loot room is individual
hold on let me catch up
then thats 8 people sharing the chest that can drop the scroll
yea but its also scaling up to 8
instead of each rolling their own odds
Its kad who was arguing for doing pois with multiple players without considering that u have to split loot, not czad
is it delve scaling or 2 ppl = x2
its not delve scaling its base loot scaling I think
more people is definetly better but it gets to a point
scrolls appear inside the piñatas? i thought they were rolled as a chance when the piñata and put into player inventories. that makes a lot more sense now
also thought they would just appear in your inv
wouldnt that be a bit weird
not really imo
since that would fix the multiple people sharing 1 scroll "issue"
yeah^
The trailer was false advertisement 
With the funky animation
I mean in multi it should scale up and average out over multiple runs
with a chat message it wouldnt be that weird
mfw america does this all the time:
the only difference is the super picks someone for you instead of the players
this especially made me believe it worked by giving it to player inventories
Looking at the pins, what is "skt caches"
wait monu server is in canada nvm
Probably typo 
typo
🔥
supposed to say SKT scrolls
isnt that still wrong
Fire
So SKT is supposedly to drop scrolls now?
what if it said hexfall scrolls instead
no
🥺
I am not adding scrolls to hexfal
☹️
but it would be lore accurate
SKT is literally set in r2 …………
but its lore accurate
What content is supposed to drop SK scrolls now im out of the loop 
adding fishing, and SKT
not adding hexfall
Interesting choice to include SKT
Can we make this a sticker 🥺
no

what do you think about it
as with everything it is subject to opinions
Skt kinda makes sense from lore sense I think
It's thematic but it feels silly to include skt and not hexfall
well hexfall is technically still thematic
I gotta catch up to the conversation here, but personally I'm mixed in adding SKT as part of scroll drops. I get that its lore sense (hahah sk) but that is its own content
Surely one day we can drop scrolls from zenith
I may hold off on skt
Me thinks now that hexfall has liferoot sapling as a low chance unique drop skt can get a low chance unique drop (IN TERMS OF RAIDS)
I dont have good justification other than my gut
I dont have a real justification either if it makes you feel better
its not even a lore thing
Just on the basis that its a "overworld" replayability content
i mean if it's jsut an extra drop chance for the skt weekly clear i feel like that's completely fine
And well skt isnt really part of overworld
that is fair
truth
But so arent strike and kangspore so
strikes and galleries arent either and the line is fuzzy
so idfk
flipping a coin
head yes
tails no
Does godspore drop scrolls atm?
ya
Interesting
charging your coins are fucking rigged
Nah capital G foretold these event
get it twisted
Twisted coin 
Bro yoinking my memes 
I hope we get a better weekly/daily menu one day
Is skt weekly even displayed anywhere
the Dungeons list in peb
No one mentioned it earlier before I caught up, but with increasing cache cost and not having enough frags to buy one from your first clear, you could just increase the amount given to you in the quest so your first SKR clear should always give at least 1 cache
can portable gatecharm be used with armory
because i(and many others) have like 3 cases of lesser and upgraded charms
is that a question for the current functionality or a suggestion
planned implementation I believe
atm it does not work with armory
HUGE?
wait I think
SMALL?
let me confirm with @low jetty
UNDETERMINED?
maybe
must. find. all. button. locations.
I'm not gonna hard confirm anything but it's on my radar
🥺
Sure but give me a room build 😛
We need a galos themed puzzle room tbh
and if I do, I want to make sure it's implemented right. :)
well if it does that it should be an epic imo
but uh thats huge
i was worried about what deen told me the other day
"if everyone hoards lesser charms theres no reason to hoard them now since they arent going to be worth hoarding"
is this something
"If everyone hoards har there's no reason to hoard them now since they aren't going to be worth hoarding"
no theres a bottom price to lesser charms
and u can frag them
which is more convenient
Exactly so there's a point in hoarding them
you just lose some money by them being able to sell
but if everyone does it
no one will buy off of you
Why would I sell
so once you have like 15 theres no point
because they are worthless if u dont either sell or use
and u can only use so many
No they have a base value of 2 at
ar
Why would you hoard them as har when hoarding them as charms may increase the value above 2 ar
🤷
err what exactly triggers the heal on the evoker elite
hate not knowing if i've gotten every chest
It’s only a negative to people who collected charms before the update (me
hey it can save you some equip cases soon
It’s useful to be able to buy any charm without annoyance
Yeah that’s a great thing
It was why I was gonna buy it before I learnt

Maybe just me but I’m kinda confused as to why it was an artifact and costing quite low for what it will do
because imo
it's a bag of holding expansion disguised as a separate item
not everything needs to be an epic and with the nature of SKR I'd prefer it to be relatively inexpensive
kinda wish it could also hold rare charms, literally like 1/4 of my echest is charm storage 😭
its not that low if you consider mat prices 😭
yea fairs
the mats are some of the most expensive but fastest to grind
like doing skr wise not getting scrolls wise
on release i thinkn i got spoiled too much with 2 weeklies worth of scrolls
yes same
i did 2 weeks worth in 2 days
now i can only do daily bounty portal mr gs sirius
and like hope for a scroll but if i dont get it nothing surprising
i like the incentive to log on and do your dailies outside of just 1 pdia it feels quite fresh, bummer that it released by itself and apart from other large contents
new content soon.... surely
surely
but yeah i actually need to do stuff now
This is not going to happen because it would be a data space concern. Normal charms is already potentially a LOT of space.
That restriction was established on the get-go when I started making the item.
(oh and then the "charms" tag in armory would immediately be outclassed if/when armory integration is added :P)
Storing charms in portable gate is more data intensive than storing them in shulkers? Why
couldn't tell you exactly but
- higher amount of items can be stored than just in a shulker
- in terms of rare charms, content generally adds them - meaning that each update there would be more and more that can be added
There's also definitely less of a reason to charmbag rare charms, you aren't going to get nearly as much that'd make it worth hoarding
(unless you're in TCL)
And I swear if someone asks about storing Zenith charms in there...
/mh i put 1000 zenith charms in gatecharm and now i cant log onto the server fix it NOW. dont erase any of the charms though i paid one morbillion har for them

/mh reopen gallery now
isnt it the same as multiple shulkers that hold them? although there are 152 rn
but then theres 452 lesser/upgraded charms
wait how are u even storing 452
can i ask how storing data works
magic
ok...
I’d assume ppl would want to hold 1 of every charm in it for armoury convenience or something
Effectively treating it as an XL equipment case for charms
if it doesn't already, can you make it show the total number of all charms in it
i want to be tempted by the prospect of withdrawing them all and pcrys'ing them and knowing how much money i'll get
Why’s this a concern with charms but not bag of hoarding?
boh data is stored on player and not item
Once you purchased boh you can access the menu through exp bucket, piggy bank, etc
Limited amount of currencies
196 currencies vs 644 charms for reference
If you ever get 2 boh, you’d found them stacking together which means they have the same nbt
It’s just an interface
Er charmbag does this too
Oh
yeah this is a big part of it
and including rare charms would be, what, +8 each time content comes out generally?
isn't a lot but it adds up
I'd have to look into this, could probably do it. That would be interesting 
Only 177 of them are rare+ tho
You’re still gonna have to handle that 467 charms are gonna go into that bag
Ppl like having 1 of every currency in BoH
Those same ppl are 100% gonna put 467 charms into the charmbag
Can’t you just like separate the data in the db by class and then load them depending on page
could just allocate like 1k slots
Idk I don’t do Minecraft coding too much
like its already 470 slots
To be fair, the number of non-rare charms will likely not being going up given we already have all the variations possible, while the number of rare charms will only ever go up
but i cant know if it works
because honeypint apparently says its stored using magic...
💀
I mean, it is a portal...
@feral cliff whats the variance of the chance for scroll in poi depended on the diffculty ( like 2x common from t1 to t5?)
not quite that high
💀
maybe its just forsaken manor propaganda
the why-long category is actually a lot longer
but its like 2 minute diff between super short and long
so lol

theoretically your best time investment is in medium / long
but I also made that up
so who knows
im still waiting gallery reopen to test its scroll chance
class depending ngl
optimal speeds
like spawner rush or blizz or dot apoth

yeah you mention gallery a lot
surely it'll help it be opened faster
same for ssteve trust
figuring out all the button possbile check
14/~50
😭
and what if hexfall also got some low chance unique drop from non weeklies......
silver sapling
Its too bad vigil already takes the theoretical cosmetic space skt couldve had
I guess scrolls could make a good consolation
wdym
Silver knights tomb cannot use silver knight cosmetics as a reward
SR/Eternal vigil already used all of them
So there’s not much room for SKT to have a rare drop like hexfall does
So 146 coven fortresses was a right decision got it
well you did amped right
Yea the one frogvis made on build shard
womp I dont think the patch hit those shards
💀 how’s the amped coven
I don't think coven deserves to be under long POI tier
coven deserves a bit of favoritism once in a while
That poi sucks anyway
Max pts coven took 9 min max pts doomed encamp took 12 min
I run that poi aloy back when I was active
fine by me
buff scroll rate this week?
See pinned
ok cool
wait what is amped coven
am i missing something
Frogvis said he will build one on build shard
Could the name of the SKR currencies be renamed maybe
Tbh the naming of mats is getting confusing at this point
Something like Silver Memory Wisp and Remnant Scroll Sliver/Shard or something maybe
in my opinion there is usually not much reason for a currency name to be three words long
but that may just be me
When there are this many currencies involved due to how long the game is
Especially when a bunch of content shares a theme
You start running out of both accurate and unique descriptors without stepping on toes
You like a Silver [Something]? 
Remember that quest items, currencies, equipment all have to compete with each other for names
Personally i think infusion currencies should be renamed to be more similar and maybe to reduce the amount of dusts
Pulsating Gold Nugget and Pulsating Gold
Or “Half a Pulsating [currency]” 
But that’s outside the bounds of this thread now
@silver lake do you know how to item replace to a new name
i do not know if its that easy
imo skt mat should be something different now that skr is a thing
"iridium scrap" or something idk
does it have lore i forget
Probably a wider issue than just SKR at this point
Esp given how often content involving SK is gonna pop up again in the future
Memory Fragment -> Memory Lattice
Remnant Scroll Fragment -> Remnant Scroll Canto / Remnant Canto
which one
this one
that has names I can copy
epic
"lattice" doesn't match the sprite but rn they're just kinda rocks
i imagined them to be more data-like than literal pieces of knight armor
cantos are sections (read, fragments) of poems
lattice may get synonymed into oblivion
wisp or sprite or cute rock would work
strand also works
I will make a big wheel and spin it tonight with all the suggestions
What if the strands were twisted so it was called twisted strand
what the scallop
Apparently memories are inherently strand like
you could do "Memory Chip" if you want to lean into the whole "we're collecting data for the record keeper"
Canonically lore accurate to make them strands 
me when texture
the current texture isn't cool enough to have me work around it
it looks like unholy shards from thorium but mirrored
Remnant Information Nugget
that's too close to iron and gold nuggets
Silver Knight's Rocks and Stones
rock.. and.. stone?
FOR KARL
there you go charging
All that Remains
thanks
ATR tomorrow
#bugs-fixed-for-next-update message
k
wait no this is differnt
nonononono
i want puzzles to onlyu have 1 solution man
Unless you searched for the other solutions that should not be a problem though? You'll enter a solution and it gets accepted