#Magic: the Gathering

1 messages ¡ Page 14 of 1

rare sparrow
#

if they draw it, 66.5%

#

largest improvement in winrate when in hand

#

the thing that i think you may be underrating about time walk in cube is how good it is when you splash it in a white or red aggro deck

molten maple
#

Ocelot Pride? Seriously?

rare sparrow
#

if you cast time walk in an aggro deck, you are almost certainly going to win the game

#

by speeding up your clock by a turn

rare sparrow
molten maple
#

I mean Ocelot Pride is obviously a hilariously broken card but its crazy that it is up there with the 3 strongest power 9 cards

rare sparrow
#

and ocelot pride and ajani are just the best white aggro cards

molten maple
#

What about the lands

#

Like where is Gaea's Cradle at

rare sparrow
#

which ones?

#

tolarian academy was also top 10

#

as was karakas

molten maple
#

Surely Gaea's Cradle is up there too

rare sparrow
#

looks like gaea's cradle is in the 20s

molten maple
#

That's shockingly low

rare sparrow
#

probably sort of the opposite of what's going on with the white aggro creatures

molten maple
#

I wonder how much of that is green being kinda bad

rare sparrow
#

a reflection of green being bad

molten maple
#

Like I get that Ancestral Recall draws 3, and drawing 3 for 1 mana is insane

rare sparrow
#

nadu (and mox emerald, if you want to count that although you should play it even in a non-green deck) are the only green cards above cradle

molten maple
#

But at the same time, drawing cards is only as good as the cards you draw. I would rather have a Time Walk

rare sparrow
#

yeah, i think ancestral recall also really benefits from being played alongside ways to accelrate yourself so you can make use of the extra cards early

#

which means either having green cards (not good) or other power 9 (unlikely0

gloomy pagoda
#

My conclusion from poorly skimming the conversation is that Time Walk is good because it lets you draw a card. Therefore, Ancestral Recall is three times as good.

rare sparrow
#

time walk is an explore with an extra combat step

#

and that combat step is better than it sounds

gloomy pagoda
#

Honestly, I feel like the bigger more important distinction is cost. You can AR on turn 1, and that's bigger than taking a third turn before your opponent takes their second.

rare sparrow
#

also i think you basically win the game if you have any way to cast your time walk twice (underworld breach, tamiyo, snapcaster, etc.)

#

while casting AR twice is less good

gloomy pagoda
#

Sure, Time Walk can let you win the game with a neat combo on an extra turn, but AR gets you consistency, and consistency is king

rare sparrow
#

that seems to be a big thing people try to do when they draft time walk from cube videos i've watched

molten maple
rare sparrow
#

ultimately the distinction doesn't matter too much, as last i heard the arena cube is designed intentionally so two power 9 cards never appear in the same pack

#

so you're talking about mtgo cube or real life powered cube as the places the decision might matter

tepid stirrup
#

I think my biggest surprise with Time Walk is that for as easy it is to build into a wincon, I feel like its also really easy to waste

molten maple
#

There are other online power cubes that will have multiple power 9 in the same pack im pretty sure

leaden tide
rare sparrow
#

yeah, just assuming that MTGA is the most likely place people are engaging with powered cube

leaden tide
#

To that effect though, you're more likely to draw Time Walk if you have AR in your deck.

leaden tide
gloomy pagoda
leaden tide
#

He's got enough interns at Dragonsteel to do it

leaden tide
rare sparrow
#

doesn't brandon's cube have a lot of custom cards?

#

i feel like he's said that before

#

but also he probably has multiple cubes

leaden tide
rare sparrow
#

since i think draft is all he plays

leaden tide
#

Where he's had the artist doodle another card on the back

#

and you can play both sides

rare sparrow
#

ooo that sounds cool

#

why are we getting star trek leaks* already 🙁

tepid stirrup
rare sparrow
#

have to wait basically half a year between strixhaven and reality fracture for two non-UB sets

#

i really hope if we get into a world of 6 sets and 3 UB a year we are going to always be alternating between UB/non-UB

leaden tide
leaden tide
rare sparrow
#

it looks like the big oversized things they put up at conventions

#

i'll try to track it down and can remove if needed

#

i'll relabel it as a leak to be safe

leaden tide
# rare sparrow

Well in the mean time, some notes and impressions of this card:

  • ||The set symbol is impeccable, sooooooooo much better than the Marvel ones.||
  • ||Set code is TOC, so this is likely a commander card. Which explains the set number, it's awfully low. Even if Star Trek were a small set, that's way too early to be starting the multi-colors||
  • ||However, that does bring up another question, if it's the Commander set, why isn't it lower? Face commanders come at the start of the set numbers. And he doesn't use the face commander borderless frame. My conclusion then is that he's in a Starfleet catch-all deck, and Picard and the Enterprise-D are the face commanders.||
gloomy pagoda
#

Huh, magic rules question: Are you allowed to do a search that's guaranteed to fail?

leaden tide
#

Yep!

#

Failed to find is a thing.

#

You can even declare 'failed to find' if the thing is in your deck.

gloomy pagoda
#

And by guaranteed, I mean known to be guaranteed to fail

tepid stirrup
leaden tide
#

Yep!

#
Magic: The Gathering Wiki

Search is a keyword action. It was introduced on Demonic Tutor in Alpha. It is exclusively used as the action used to look at the cards in a player's library, though it is also used for known-information zones hand and graveyard when mentioned in conjunction with the library.

leaden tide
tepid stirrup
#

I've heard enough of the Magic Player Does Some Crafty BS type of story that its hard to keep them all straight but I think this is one of them?

rare sparrow
#

failing to find was a pretty common play pattern with gifts ungiven. it let you guaranteed put two cards of your choice into the graveyard

#

ah, they even talk about gifts ungiven on that exact page

gloomy pagoda
#

Neat. In Pokemon TCG guaranteed deck knowledge usually isn't a thing, but in the close Commander analogue there are some searches that are known to be guaranteed to fail, and IIRC they fail to even start

leaden tide
#

The only time you can't fail to find is if the thing you're searching for isn't specified, aka a generic tutor:

701.23d If a player is searching a hidden zone simply for a quantity of cards, such as “a card” or “three cards,” that player must find that many cards (or as many as possible, if the zone doesn’t contain enough cards).

rare sparrow
#

funnily enough, if you are playing with the top card of your library revealed, and your opponents as a result all know you have a specific type of card, you can still fail to find on your tutor searching your library with that card revealed

#

e.g. if you play three visits and the top card of your library is a revealed forest, you don't have to actually get that forest

#

not sure why exactly you'd do that, but it is a thing that you can legally do

molten maple
leaden tide
#

Pretty sure it's just Panglacial Wurm

molten maple
#

So you use the three visits to search and cast the card while searching, but you do not get the forest to avoid milling yourself

leaden tide
#

That's it, that's the whole list of that particular rules nightmare

molten maple
#

Thats the only reason I can think of to ever not get the forest though

leaden tide
# molten maple Good

Apparently there's more, but two of them are Alchemy cards and two are test cards.

rare sparrow
#

my favorite rules nightmare is trying to cast panglacial wurm using selvala, explorer returned

leaden tide
#

They're also all far more limited than good old Panglacial

molten maple
#

Can someone explain to me why Channel is only worth like, 50 cents?

#

It seems so comically strong how can it possibly be so cheap

leaden tide
#

Ultra-turbo banned literally everywhere

molten maple
leaden tide
#

The Power 9 are much more efficient at winning games.

molten maple
#

It seems at least as strong as the moxes to me

tepid stirrup
#

Power 9 is also inherently a collector's set, by virtue of having that name

leaden tide
rare sparrow
#

channel is a card that has been reprinted a gazillion times and can't be played in any format

leaden tide
#

By the time you have two mana to play Channel in Vintage, your opponent will have already won with free spells.

molten maple
#

Why do they keep printing it if its not legal anywhere lol

molten maple
#

With your own mox or lotus or whatever

rare sparrow
#

all of its original very old printings were at uncommon, not rare, as well

rare sparrow
leaden tide
leaden tide
rare sparrow
molten maple
leaden tide
#

Yes but you're not spending mana to cast the Moxen, which means it's far less of a tempo loss.

rare sparrow
#

green is also just the worst color in vintage

#

you don't want to be casting double green cards

leaden tide
#

Basically, in Vintage, there's far more efficient ways to use the two mana you'd use to cast Channel.

#

Like, say this guy.

#

Literally will win you the game on the spot if you have the right card (usually Protean Hulk) in your hand.

rare sparrow
#

channel is also kind of a card you need to build your deck around to take advantage of (e.g. eldrazi, big X spells) and when it's restricted you can't rely on getting it

leaden tide
rare sparrow
#

yeah, and flash is also unplayable in vintage for essentially the same reason, it being restricted makes it too hard to rely on

#

also usually vintage likes compact combos

#

and flash + hulk + a bunch of creatures is a lot of deck slots

#

time vault + voltaic key, less so

leaden tide
#

Which is why the 4-of rule was first implemented.

rare sparrow
#

channel is also competing with this

leaden tide
rare sparrow
#

which is a two mana green combo card that doesn't require you to have the card you combo it with in your hand

#

you just need to have atraxa be the only creature in your library

#

and you're good

#

(and it's also allowed as a 4-of)

gloomy pagoda
tepid stirrup
#

A not-terrible rule of thumb unfortunately is that if a card, especially an old card, sees less play than you expect and it is green, the fact that it is green often is the answer

gloomy pagoda
#

And then like a month of public testing later, oops, the game is broken if there are no deck-building limits

tepid stirrup
#

Took them kind of a long time to figure green out and even now I think its maybe the easiest color for them to let drift into an underpowered state

rare sparrow
#

i'm fairly sure 4 of was picked pretty arbitrarily too. there needed to be some more restrictions once tournaments became an actual thing, and playing cards have 4 copies of each card in the deck, thus a 4-of limit

leaden tide
gloomy pagoda
rare sparrow
#

it's funny to me how green is so good in both casual commander and cEDH because of ramping but using basically entirely different sets of cards

#

cedh decks don't play land ramp (just ways to cheat out gaea's cradle) and play lots of mana dorks, while in casual people play far fewer mana dorks and lots of land ramp

#

it really is just so good at ramping in every single way

leaden tide
#

To make things abundantly clear, Sir Robin, Channel is very good. You're not wrong in that assessment.

#

Hence why it's banned almost everywhere.

#

And the only pace it's not banned is the format with even more insanely broken stuff.

tepid stirrup
#

Yeah pricing just kind of has a separate line of considerations

rare sparrow
#

not that a ton of people play timeless but i think it was at one point very good there despite being restricted

tepid stirrup
#

Collectible set, and they're priced way out of band for the card's power

#

Collectability, age, number of printings, number of legal formats, a lot of things go into a card's monetary value and it can be hard to guess just by looking at it

#

In other words, reading the card may explain the card but it doesn't necessarily explain the card's market value

molten maple
leaden tide
#

Man it's funny going through old cards.

#

We were just talking about Channel and the Power 9.

#

And then there stuff like this:

rare sparrow
#

my favorite incredibly bad one from a while back isn't quite that bad

#

but it's certainly at a point where you'd think they would've known better (original ravnica)

#

like, stuff in the first 5 years, you can excuse them, they had no idea what they were doing yet

#

but releasing a 6 mana creature that bad over 10 years after the game came out is just a head scratcher to me

tepid stirrup
#

I remember that card!

#

I might even have one in a box somewhere

#

I think maybe I thought it had flying for a while (as a middle schooler) because the art kind of makes it look like it should

#

Even if it had flying it'd be ass tbh

molten maple
#

1 mana do nothing, cool

tepid stirrup
#

My guess is they thought lifegain limited only by the mana you could generate when they had all these crazy mana rocks lying around was gonna be real strong

leaden tide
# rare sparrow

This would be perfectly reasonable if it like, cost 2 or 3 mana. Would cut it in limited and might even see play in the right niche deck.

tepid stirrup
molten maple
#

explain

#

why do people even play decks like this

#

yet another player who literally did nothing except spam removal and counterspells

#

what is the goal here

#

if youre going to play control at least have some sort of plan to win the game

tepid stirrup
#

I think you'd be surprised how often controlling out an opponent's wincon results in a premature gg

#

Their opponents aren't often thinking "all I have to do is get something through", they're thinking "this game is unplayable"

#

Control makes for a fantastic bluff because it is so aggravating, and for the opponent it often feels like they are not in, well, control of the game

lucid jewel
#

They just had to control you 1st

slender moss
#

Also they probably run like 2x Riverchurn for that sweet sweet Lantern Control feeling

surreal stag
#

Turn 4 [[Unexpected Results]] rips a [[apex devastotor]] which rips [[maelstorm wanderer]] metor golem and Terror of the peaks, Maelstorm gets two enchantments.

#

absolutly nuts slot machine pull

turbid falcon
#

https://archidekt.com/decks/18308149/earthbending_aristocrats
Made a lot of changes in the past few days to the decklist, based on performance in testing and in a playgroup
Readded some more removal, cut some protection I don't really need due to the nature of the deck, and am sort of considering getting amulet of vigor
I had originally included Spelunking in my original draft of the deck, but frankly it didn't do much besides that so I cut it
Amulet of vigor has the massive advantage also being a 1 mana artifact, meaning in practice my deck should be able to tutor it pretty consistently
Though since I've fleshed out that niche, I've found in testing those cards end up being far more tool boxy, able to grab basically whatever I need most at that slot
Removal, +1/+1 counter retention, card draw, sac outlet, it's all there

Archidekt

Toph, the First Metalbender - Commander deck
Earthbending • Artifacts
(1) Commander • (26) Artifact • (14) Creature • (10) Earthbending • (4) Enchantment • (3) Instant • (36) Land • (2) Planeswalker • (4) Sacrifice

#

Basically it'll mean my earthbent stuff will re enter untapped

#

Which means I can abuse certain cards even more

surreal stag
turbid falcon
#

I'm thinking of cutting the Machine gun combo, walking ballista in practice hasn't had much utility outside of that combo

#

And overall I prefer the Bumi/ashaya combo for utility

surreal stag
#

W Ballista, cna go IMO. Lots of poeple just get salty when they see it. the Bumi Ashaya combo is more fun IMO and the set up is more enganging.

leaden tide
surreal stag
#

going more of a tool box setup is the way to go here IMO

turbid falcon
#

Weirdly the deck is very consistent but also just, slow to win

#

It usually doesn't win before turn 8 at the earliest

#

But I do have a lot of potential win states, and the deck is fairly resilient to a certain amount of removal

surreal stag
#

i have no idea how much it cost but i could suggest a 3rd GC....Grim Monolith.

#

you earthbend and sac it instead of paying to untap.

turbid falcon
#

The answer is, not cheap

surreal stag
#

do you owna printer?

turbid falcon
#

Problem is, earthbending usually brings it back in tapped

#

So that doesn't really allow me to abuse it

surreal stag
#

that whty you toolbox your amulat of vigor

#

gamble is pretty cheap but you have to be in a deck that doesnt mind stuff going in the bin

turbid falcon
#

Yeah no if I were adding another tutor it would be...that other white one I'm forgetting the name of

#

And text oc

#

Yeah no never mind, idyllic tutor isn't what I want

#

It only finds enchantments

#

Oh I'll probably include the flash artifact myr

#

Realistically I should probably add bagel and shmear but I refuse to add it on principle

#

I am not including a stupid bagel

#

It makes no sense to earthbend a bagel and I won't do it

tepid stirrup
#

I'll never understand what they were thinking

surreal stag
#

brb building Toph, UB artifacts only....

#

and i swing at you with my HOT DOG CART

rare sparrow
#

through the omenpaths is dead

#

(title doesn't make this clear but they are also putting spiderman on mtga as well)

lucid jewel
#

Let's goooo

#

I do love some of the through the omenpaths art tho

rare sparrow
#

i'm not a huge spiderman fan or anything but i've always thought it was bad for the game to not have the real cards on the digital client

turbid falcon
#

Also rip fleem

#

You will be missed

lucid jewel
#

They did this in the best way as well

#

So all omenpath cards in your collection will grant you a Spiderman version of the card so if you have one copy of fleem you will now have one copy of fleem and one copy of green goblin

#

And it will work just like other card styles

#

And the spiderman cards will be the default style unless otherwise selected

#

But you wont have extra copies of things

turbid falcon
#

Fleem survives wwhw

tepid stirrup
#

I wonder if this is the result of Snap problems they've been having lately

molten maple
#

Question: lets say you have 1 card left in your library and you get milled for 5, but that card puts itself back into your library when it goes to the graveyard. Do you lose because all 5 mills happen simultaneously and then the cards gets shuffled back to your library?

spare harbor
#

you only lose if you try to draw from an empty library

#

you can mill as many cards as you want, and as long as you don't draw you're fine

lucid jewel
#

I think that depends on the specifics as well as to where the card ends up and how it works

#

But yeah you dont die untill you draw

molten maple
#

Oh, so milling with 0 cards doesnt lose you the game?

spare harbor
#

it does not

leaden tide
#

So much for proxying any of the Marvel cards I might want.

surreal stag
lucid jewel
turbid falcon
#

Toph took it's first dub tonight
Turns out shimmer myr + unwinding clock is crazy

#

I mean what I ended up doing was then playing Meria to make all artifacts tap for mana, mycosynth lattice so everything is artifacts, and from there winning was just a matter of making my creatures big

surreal stag
#

Hell Yea dude

leaden tide
#

Okay I'm a lot happier with how this draft is feeling. Still need to add a couple cards, but now I have an actual gameplan in mind. And I even managed to keep the angel subtheme!
https://archidekt.com/decks/22661835/always_an_angel_never_a_god_v2

Archidekt

Bre of Clan Stoutarm - Commander deck

(1) Commander • (10) Beaters • (7) Draw • (36) Land • (19) Lifegain • (7) Ramp • (10) Removal • (5) Wincons

#

Okay down to one more. Might just find a big Angelic beater

#

Okay but this guy is tempting.

turbid falcon
#

I remember drafting that for Tarkir

#

It failed me spectacularly when I went up against Teval what was a 6/6 and I lost 😭

wanton hazel
#

I suppose I'm glad Omenpaths is dead, the idea of having two versions of a set would probably continue to get exhausting

tepid stirrup
#

I kind of still think the opposite

#

I think they should print Omenpaths and have an Omenpaths option for every UB set

gloomy pagoda
#

Yeah, but that'd be putting value in the lore and setting of MtG, and we can't have that!

tepid stirrup
#

I don't think that's ultimately realistic unfortunately but I'd prefer that to what we have

tepid stirrup
#

Its the smell, if there is such a thing

#

The vibes

#

The pizza block is bad vibes

wanton hazel
#

I don't think I liked the vibes of omenpaths either, is how I look at it

#

but the new york pizza didn't bug me as much as it bugged some

tepid stirrup
#

Omenpaths isn't an all-timer for sure

#

But at least the cards look like Magic cards

leaden tide
#

Omenpaths was a decent execution. But imo it would have worked better with being a bit more cohesive and not just a grab-bag of random slush art + some extra commissions.

tepid stirrup
#

I also suspect that Omenpaths was very last minute anyway so like, I don't think it'd always have to be that mid

leaden tide
#

But that would require Wizards paying the writers to actually work on the set, which is a no-go.

leaden tide
tepid stirrup
# tepid stirrup The pizza block is bad vibes

I suppose I should add that it is more than just that the pizza block is bad vibes in its own vacuum, it is bad vibes that threatens to alter the vibes of what Magic is as an artistic statement, which is the primary reason I like Magic at all

leaden tide
#

I have nothing particularly against Street Fighter, but i'm so glad I can run this guy in my walls deck instead of Dhalsim

leaden tide
#

Like, back when they first made Avishkar, they wanted to do a steampunk plane. And after some iteration, they ended up on an Indian-inspired aetherpunk plane, a pretty unique take on the aesthetic.

tepid stirrup
#

I got into Stormlight because it had a Magic vibe to its art (which, of course it did, it used Magic artists, but I didn't know that yet)

#

It is a statement

#

New York City is historically not part of that statement

leaden tide
#

That "Magicness" of taking tropes and making them their own was already strained with hat sets, but it's gotten so much worse with Universes Beyond.

#

And not all Universes Beyond either. Warhammer and AtlA feel right at home next to classic Magic sets, they're not that much of a contrast. But anything that's just straight-up real world is....not it.

tepid stirrup
#

For as good as the Final Fantasy sets are I think it worked in part because they depicted Amaurot and Midgar (which are both based off New York) very fantastically and tried not to lean on them too much visually to begin with

leaden tide
#

It's....it's the same thing that happened with Destiny, where the people making the game don't realize the value of their own brand and identity, and just start treating their property as a platform for other things. Which undervalues how unique that 'platform' was to begin with.

leaden tide
#

The gross pizza spam is a 'no' from me, but other elements of the set looked like Kamigawa with the serial numbers filed off.

#

These all don't feel too far off from classic Magic art.

tepid stirrup
#

I wonder if they got those notes in time to curate submitted art more in that direction

leaden tide
#

I think it's also a source material thing. Marvel being "everyday superheros" vs TMNT being a whacky mutant underworld setting.

tepid stirrup
#

That's true, probably any superhero set is going to stray into hats territory even if they adjust them all to fit into fantasy

#

I mean "what if the superheroes you know except period piece" is a whole subgenre of comics at this point

molten maple
#

Idk TMNT was pretty bad too in my eyes lol

tepid stirrup
#

It was but Spider-man is an easy contender for the worst set artistically in MTG history. Not even sure what else I'd nominate tbh

leaden tide
#

Yeah TMNT is probably the closest. It claws back a few points from some of the cards like the ones I posted, but there's just too much disgusting pizza.

molten maple
#

we arent counting stuff like spongebob right?

#

since that was just SL and not a full set?

wanton hazel
#

SLs are like 6 cards, I wouldn't call that a set

molten maple
#

personally I dont mind UB stuff if it is at least aesthetically adjacent to MTG

leaden tide
molten maple
#

So stuff like final fantasy is OK. Marvel is really pushing it, depends on the character. TMNT... please no

#

I would kill for a cosmere UB set man

#

I feel like it would actually fit really well aesthetically

tepid stirrup
#

Final Fantasy is okay but I think very strongly because of the execution

#

There's a world where the Final Fantasy vibes wrongly and it isn't that different from what we got

molten maple
#

thats fair

leaden tide
acoustic wedge
leaden tide
#

(these are from the same game though, so maybe we should just dunk on XV)

molten maple
tepid stirrup
#

I think there's certainly better things even from 15 they could have chosen

leaden tide
#

Turtles had this problem too, but it was somewhat subdued because their version of New York is a bit weirder and has an edge of fantasy to it.

tepid stirrup
#

And, actually, the ramen quest was as jarringly non-Final Fantasy to me as the Spider-man set is non-Magic

molten maple
#

TMNT is way, way too cartoony and unserious to fit with MTG

leaden tide
#

(the list is 3 things long lmao)

tepid stirrup
#

15 pimped itself out to Top Ramen, Coleman camping supplies, and American Express and it was the same sour note as some UB, maybe worse

leaden tide
#

I love having a crossover in a crossover

molten maple
#

I would legit spend so much money to get a Kaladin or Yumi or Nikaro or Vin or- (you get the idea)

charred ruin
#

There's no way FF15 suddenly stops to shill you, the player, actual real-life Cup Noodles?

#

That would be too insane, right?

molten maple
#

What color identity would Kaladin be? Mono white?

acoustic wedge
leaden tide
molten maple
#

just because I love the characters and it is very similar aesthetically to MTG

leaden tide
leaden tide
molten maple
#

oh really? I had no idea they did that, thats cool

#

which characters were part of that set?

leaden tide
#

None, this was very early in Secret Lair and UB's history and was before they were regularly doing mechanically unique cards.

molten maple
#

oh alright

#

ok ok

#

what color would Shallan be?

leaden tide
#

Dimir, imo

molten maple
#

I feel like there are a lot of potentials for her. Certainly blue, but I could also see her as (Stormlight Archive all) ||white and black with radiant and veil||

leaden tide
#

I feel like (Stormlight general) ||They'd probably get their own cards.||

molten maple
#

thats fair

leaden tide
#

Stormlight all ||And maybe a colorless Formless||

molten maple
#

Oh, Vin could be WURBG perhaps

leaden tide
#

Hmm, what else can we say?

  • Szeth: white/black
  • Lift: red/green
  • Blackthorn: black/red
  • Jasnah: white/blue/black
  • Navani: blue/red
  • Adolin: red/white
  • Renarin: mono blue or blue/green
  • Rock: green/white
leaden tide
molten maple
#

SA all ||make two Dalinar cards. Blackthorn is Rakdos, Modern Dalinar is Boros||

leaden tide
#

I think her core identity might be abzan though? She's a tough one to pin down.

leaden tide
#

Though, like with AtlA, I think it'd work with Stormlight. Since the characters' personal growth and journies are a big part of the story.

molten maple
#

agreed

#

ATLA did a very good job at creating multiple cards for the characters that represent them at different parts of their character arcs

#

especially Aang, Zuko, and Azula

#

however... whats up with this bro

#

"Katara, Waterbending Master"

#

Looks inside: no waterbending

#

Wizards please

leaden tide
#

No but she rewards you for playing the Waterbending instants and whatnot.

acoustic wedge
leaden tide
molten maple
#

paired of course

leaden tide
#

This doesn't feel ilke it remotely represents Katara as a character. Definitely not at this point in the story.

molten maple
# leaden tide

Its a strong card but I dont see what this has to do with Katara at all lol

leaden tide
acoustic wedge
molten maple
#

ohhhh

leaden tide
#

Juggling 10 surges in a single set is already going to be a lot.

molten maple
#

ok I see what you mean now

#

sorry I misunderstood what you meant

upper moon
#

Honestly, I'm not sure if they'd need mechanics for each surge tbh

molten maple
#

a mechanic for each surge would be a lot

upper moon
#

More just focus on some general themes of the magic system for mechanics

#

Stuff like oaths and bonds

acoustic wedge
upper moon
#

Ah, that could be cool

#

Just one grab all ability for surgebinding

#

I like that

leaden tide
#

Let's see:

  • Adhesion - White
  • Gravitation - Blue?
  • Division - Black
  • Abrasion - Red
  • Progression - Green
  • Illumination - Blue
  • Transformation - Green
  • Transportation - Black
  • Cohesion - Red?
  • Tension - White?
acoustic wedge
#

Ie: Gravitation grants a target creature Flying for X turns

leaden tide
#

Let's start with the easy ones:

  • Transformation: Blue
  • Progression: Green
acoustic wedge
#

Mhm mhm

leaden tide
#

I also would want to put:

  • Gravitation: Blue
  • Division: Black
  • Abrasion: Red
acoustic wedge
#

I don't know if Division is better as red or black

leaden tide
upper moon
#

Adhesion's probably white as it's Honor's surge

leaden tide
#

Yeah. Adhesion and probably Tension as the white surges?

upper moon
#

and Honor is about as monowhite as they get LUL

molten maple
#

you know what I would kill for though? (Yumi) ||A double sided Yumi/Nikaro card that flips every turn. I am begging WotC please||

leaden tide
#

Hmm. Or maybe Tension as red or green?

acoustic wedge
upper moon
#

noice

#

forgot he had wobs about mtg colorss

leaden tide
#

Illumination also feels blue, but then we'd have 3 blues.

#

Hmmmm.

acoustic wedge
leaden tide
#

Yep.

#

It's not like Destiny, where there's a very clear single color best-fit for each element

#

And 5 elements overall

#

(Destiny's magic system is literally the perfect fit for Magic)

acoustic wedge
#

Yeah. Theres so much overlap thematically with some of the Surges

upper moon
#

Maybe gravitation as red? I could see boros still working for windrunners

leaden tide
#

Hmm. Could Transformation be green?

acoustic wedge
#

Maybe? Its green or blue

leaden tide
upper moon
#

Ah, fair

leaden tide
acoustic wedge
#

I think Grav def needs to be blue at least

leaden tide
#

The big question is, which of Tension/Cohesion should be white and red?

#

Stone magic has historically been both in Magic's history.

upper moon
#

I'd say cohesion for white so bondsmiths aren't monowhite

acoustic wedge
#

I lean cohesion towards red, mostly because bondsmith scream mono white lol

#

Ope

leaden tide
#

The problem is (Stormlight) ||Tension as Dalinar uses it feels white, but Tension as used by the fused feels more red||

upper moon
#

Duality of humanity LUL

leaden tide
acoustic wedge
#

Fair

spare harbor
#

I feel like putting a color on each surge is a bit restrictive. I feel like orders getting thematic color pairs (even if they’re not adjacent pairs for adjacent orders) would be good though

leaden tide
#

I envision it as not being a strict thing.

#

But like a "what color does this show up in most frequently?"

spare harbor
#

Mm

#

Honestly I think it would be a lot better for the set to not focus on order distinction too much actually

molten maple
leaden tide
acoustic wedge
#

The surges alone are a lot lol

leaden tide
#

And I'm sure we'd get a 5-color Dalinar to be the "oops all Radiants" commander

molten maple
spare harbor
#

Maybe have one or two radiant mechanics, but fill it out with voidbringer mechanics, bringing back energy for fabrials maybe, etc

#

Though I’m 100% calling a cycle of class enchantments for the orders

molten maple
#

but it can be a good guideline/baseline

leaden tide
#

Ugh, energy is the perfect Investiture mechanic, isn't it?

acoustic wedge
#

But yeah. My idea for the actual mechanics would be "color pip + X X, grant [target] [keyword] for X turns - cost is reduced by X if ability is targeting self (permanent)"

leaden tide
#

Either that or charge counters.

leaden tide
#

And that's saying a lot since charge counters came from the famously busted Mirrodin block

spare harbor
#

I just had a terrible idea

acoustic wedge
spare harbor
#

Day/night esque mechanic where there’s a chance a high storm hits each turn

leaden tide
#

You're right

#

That's a terrible idea.

acoustic wedge
#

Lmao

leaden tide
#

But it'd be funny as hell

acoustic wedge
#

Oh 100% hilarious. Absolutely awful, but peak funny

leaden tide
#

Another mechanical idea: (Stormlight general)
||The radiant spren as DFCs that transform into shardblade equipment||

acoustic wedge
acoustic wedge
#

I feel like that goes without saying lol

leaden tide
#

Hmm. I feel like that'd be very skewing of the limited environment at common and uncommon.

#

Maybe (Stormlight all) ||Living shardblades, at rare, give deathtouch. And dead shardblades do something more mundane, like "when a creature dealt damage by equiped creature dies, exile it"||

acoustic wedge
#

Mmmm that could work, yeah

leaden tide
#

Also, easy bonus sheet reprints: The Sword of X and Y cycle reskinned as the Honorblades

acoustic wedge
leaden tide
#

Sounds similar to Airbending

charred ruin
leaden tide
#

The mechanically unique typed duals we deserve

acoustic wedge
leaden tide
#

Oh and any Cosmere set would obviously need to reprint this card.

acoustic wedge
rare sparrow
#

makes me wonder how they would make nightblood. [probably some stormlight/warbreaker spoilers] ||how do you best capture that he's actually sentient and also an equipment? some sort of reconfigure variant?||

turbid falcon
#

Goodness lots of yapping in here today

acoustic wedge
molten maple
#

Guys: my Neyith fight club deck is finally complete! Cant wat to break it out this weekend

leaden tide
molten maple
# charred ruin

yo this would be one of the best lands printed in years, no?

#

untapped, has both basic land types, AND it can become a creature if you need

acoustic wedge
turbid falcon
#

Also it's an artifact land

#

That comes in untapped

molten maple
turbid falcon
#

Artifact lands are notorious for being insanely broken

rare sparrow
#

probably the best land not named tolarian academy or gaea's cradle

molten maple
#

also

#

why is it not indestructible?

turbid falcon
#

Because it's already broken

molten maple
#

but think about the LORE

charred ruin
turbid falcon
#

Also trucks aren't indestructible LUL

molten maple
charred ruin
#

Yeah lol

molten maple
#

and this one is just straight up better in multiple ways

molten maple
#

I guess they should reserve indestructible for the Toyota Hilux, hmmm

leaden tide
spare harbor
#

Having hoid as a planeswalker would make so much sense, except I believe there is a policy against UB planeswalkers

molten maple
#

aw man

acoustic wedge
leaden tide
leaden tide
rare sparrow
acoustic wedge
rare sparrow
#

cosmere spoilers ||like, hoid is just walking between worlds. he doesn't teleport or anything.||

past lava
#

speaking of stormlight in magic, friend made some custom cards a while ago that were only a little bit broken (whole series spoilers)

#

||i made a deck out of that kal card, it was gross||

leaden tide
rare sparrow
#

i meant it more along the lines of "power set"

#

like, if a property has people who literally teleport between different worlds or something

leaden tide
#

And I disagree, I think (Cosmere all) ||Hoid (and Nomad) are weird enough to maybe be PWs in lore, but not most Worldhoppers.||

#

Hmm. Cosmere ||Dawnshards as enchantment planeswalkers? LUL ||

rare sparrow
#

i do not think they will do them again unless the UB characters' power sets literally involves something that works the same way as planeswalking

leaden tide
past lava
leaden tide
#

Reskin Zada as The Lopen?

past lava
#

pffffff

leaden tide
#

No wait

#

Lift

spare harbor
#

I think what makes the most sense for a radiant mechanic is something that puts charge counters on the creature (possibly paired with an upkeep: remove a charge counter), then a static they gain while they have charge counters and/or an activated ability that can remove charge counters

#

I would call it infuse, but now infusion exists

leaden tide
#

Invest?

#

And could use it in different ways to represent different magic systems.

spare harbor
#

Invest could work, but I think stormlight pairs a lot better with charge counters than other ones

molten maple
#

Kaladin is also a major flavor win

spare harbor
#

The reminder text I’m envisioning is: Invest N (at the beginning of your upkeep, remove a charge counter from this permanent. Whenever the Highstorm comes, put N charge counters on this permanent) and it’s paired with a day/night-esque highstorm system (but it’s fixed because it only checks if the highstorm comes If a permanent with invest is in play)

#

Is a bit wonky still but would be a flavor win for both radiants and fabrials

lucid jewel
#

Oh noe cauldron breaks another mechanic

#

What a suprise

#

This is a bit nuts tho

molten maple
#

Cauldron was a mistake

leaden tide
#

Cauldron would be fine if Standard was still on a 2 year rotation, imo

molten maple
#

time to main deck rest in peace/ghost vacuum in every single deck again

south gorge
#

Has this been discussed here

lucid jewel
#

im curious about the rest of the stats

#

im also 34

south gorge
#

Have fun

upper moon
#

Im glad lorwyn and strixhaven did extremely well. Hopefully it means more of a focus on universes within

lucid jewel
#

hence why i keep talking about 2028, changes they are learning now will take effect in 2028

upper moon
#

Oh nm, later on they say they're planning on keeping the same ratio ShallanOhNo

lucid jewel
upper moon
#

The final question is about the success of SOS and ECL, and if that changes the way they think about the mix of UB vs owned-IP sets. Cocks says they’re always playing with what the right mix is, and it’s a combination of the creative inspiration of the Magic team, the feedback from the audience, what’s available when, and the “vagaries” of release cadences. He says he thinks they’re at a decent place right now. “Could it be +/- 10% in terms of how much is first party vs how much is Universes Beyond? Yeah

#

He also said the show doing well might influence more universes within though ig.

He goes on to talk about the new animated Netflix series, calling it “killer” and “one of the biggest animation events” for fans that Netflix has helped invest in. He thinks success with the animated show could influence the mix of in-universe sets in a positive direction.

#

But i haven't heard of the show until now

#

So thats not a good sign for the marketing being done for it

molten maple
#

Could just be that it too far away for heavy advertising

#

Apparently they started in 2019, but ended up scrapping everything and starting over in 2024

#

Thats... not a great sign

#

At least they didnt release slop? Nothing > slop

leaden tide
#

I think I finally figured out how I want to build my mono-color Azula deck.

#

My initial (incomplete) pile of ideas involved a lot of forced discard for the whole table. Which I know without even having played before is a miserable time for everyone.

#

But recently I've been thinking about how Azula functions on an attack trigger. And how to get the most experience counters I'm gonna have to swing a lot with her. And I can't expect to draw Maze of Ith every game.

#

So my new plan is this: I'm still going to include a moderate chunk of discard, aim for maybe 10 cards total. But I think the main conceit of the deck is gonna be reanimator. Discard to put big creatures in the bin, swing with Azula and let her go to graveyard, and then cast some reanimator spells to bring them back.

#

Now the trick is going to be pulling this off. It's gonna be a tight balance and I'm still not the most skilled deck builder. But I think it will be a lot more fun than my original plan.

spare harbor
#

Wheels are a lot less miserable than forced discard

#

Oh wait the R is in reminder text nvm

leaden tide
#

Yeahhhh. She's mono B

#

Which is part of the appeal, I'm building each of the AtlA experience commanders as my mono colored decks.

#

My options for group wheels in black are....limited.

molten maple
#

Ahahdvsbaba

#

Do I need this play mat for when I use my Yuna deck? There are also sleeves and deck boxes Lol

#

Maybe thats too much

#

Nvm the entire stock of everything sold out immediately, ffs

slender moss
#

Dark deal is good, at least

leaden tide
#

Yeah, that one's already on the list.

#

There's even a version with Azula on it

turbid falcon
#

Whoa
Apparently secrets of strixhaven is the best selling in universe set so far
In universe is doing VERY well this year
Good

leaden tide
#

I'm glad. Universes Beyond has been bringing on a lot of players, but the worry for a while has been that they're taking a more 'touristy' approach to the game, buying a bunch of their favorite property but otherwise not really supporting and sustaining it beyond that.

#

This is nice because it means they're actually interested in and engaging with the UW sets (aka the good stuff).

gloomy pagoda
#

That or that's what the scalpers are hoping for

#

But yeah, it's good that there've been back to back "Best UW sets ever", it suggests true growth, and not just people buying UB cards so they can have a pretty Cloud

molten maple
#

I think the top 7 or so best selling sets of all time are all from the past couple years

molten maple
surreal stag
acoustic wedge
rugged solar
#

I love this game. It’s arguably my favorite TCG. 😁

leaden tide
#

I uh. I kinda like these.

#

Especially the Simiz one.

stiff horizon
#

the cats are giving cupsy yummy

dense orchid
turbid falcon
#

I think Reverent mantra is my favorite

leaden tide
#

To me that Ruinous Ultimatum is just perfect

acoustic wedge
lucid jewel
surreal stag
#

Me and a buddy did a partner draft lol I streamed it on discord and we got trophy!

molten maple
#

So

#

I finally got to play the Neyith/Vigor hidden commander fight club deck I built

#

Game 1 was was awesome, I got a bunch of dorks out, tutored Vigor, then cast chain reaction + blasphemous act to simulatenously board wipe my opponents and pump my guys to the stratosphere and win. Exactly how I drew it up

#

Game 2, everyone was playing an ungodly ammount of removal so it lasted 3 hours and ended in a 4 way draw when the store closed...

leaden tide
#

So uh. I'm slowly putting together a Tarkir block masters set right? Today I hit the white commons and uncommons. And uh. I really should pay more attention to the cards I'm pulling.

turbid falcon
#

I've occasionally pulled a random foreign language card myself from a pack

#

Probably got mixed up in the factory or something

leaden tide
#

Yeah this was just in a bulk box at the smaller of my LGSs. I was trying to churn through the boxes as fast as I could (it still took two hours to get through white lol), and was just checking cards off a list. Wasn't reading it at all LUL

dense orchid
#

Y'all I'm thinking about building a Rhoda/Timin tap deck

#

How disgusting would it be?

leaden tide
#

Find a bant commander for them and go even more evil

dense orchid
#

I want my opponents to cry, not myself

leaden tide
#

You have blue and white, there's plenty of vigilance to be had! peter

#

I looked in to building a tap deck myself a while back, built around that angel. It ended up turning into an Exalted deck instead which I wasn't the most happy with, so I never built it. But I did find this great include.

dense orchid
#

Mew mew!

turbid falcon
#

"Leave it to Steel to create a deck that loops so hard that even Steel doesn't understand it" -My friend after I managed to win

#

I was just digging for a board wipe before eventually accidentally creating a loop where I drew my whole deck and created that much mana
this was something that literally never came up in deck testing since it required like 4-5 cards to actually occur

#

Eventually I ended up creating an unresonable number of Munitions (I love Weapons Manufacturing) and sacrificing them all for unreasonable number of munitions x2 damage

#

I genuinely took me like 5-6 minutes of drawing cards to understand I could just loop it and shortcut the whole thing lmao

molten maple
molten maple
#

Oh my god, I just played against Rakdos for the first time today

#

dude swung on turn 5 and played like 7 big ass eldrazis for free

#

I was not familiar with your game Rakdos

#

I still won though, my Azula swung on turn 5 and I won by pseudo-storming on the stack. This commander is NOT ok

#

still, Rakdos is very cool, and hard to stop due to the flying and trample. It is highly unlikely all of your opponents are gonna be able to block, then add a burn spell and you should be able to play most of your hand for free

leaden tide
#

Uh, which Rakdos?

#

Lord of Riots?

molten maple
leaden tide
#

Okay, is anyone online and paying attention to this channel?

#

I want to finish a first draft of one of my AtlA mono-colored decks. And can't decide which one.

#

So if someone's available, give me a number?

spare harbor
#

blue

#

second option red

leaden tide
#

Alright, Katara it is!

leaden tide
#

Okay, rough draft of Katara done. Gonna let it sit overnight before I make some more adjustments, but if anyone has recommendations for things to cut/swap, I'm all ears.
https://archidekt.com/decks/19269933/katara

Archidekt

Katara, Waterbending Master - Commander deck

(1) Commander • (12) Counterspell • (3) Creature • (13) Draw • (3) Finisher • (5) Flash • (37) Land • (6) Protection • (6) Ramp • (11) Removal • (3) The Combo

#

(pardon the jumbled mess of categories, I'll clean them up tomorrow)

#

The cards that absolutely cannot be cut are:

  • Lab Man
  • Jace
    And the trio of:
  • problem kitten
  • Ancestral Recall stick
  • Invasion of Segovia
spare harbor
#

as someone whose primary deck is a pir, imaginative rascal / toothy imaginary friend deck with lab man as a primary win con, you might not actually need both jace and lab man

#

though the general way that works is burst draw into a way to wizard class and fathom mage, which lets me exactly draw my deck, then play lab man, then draw another card

#

so if your draw isn't as controlled having two would probably be good

leaden tide
#

Yeah that's my thought. I draw when I swing with Katara, and how much I draw is set by experience counters. It gives me some control, but not perfect control. Hence the three different wincons.

surreal stag
#

Soup deck takes a trophy

lucid jewel
#

So much skill here

#

I have been slacking

surreal stag
#

its 100% due to doing "partner drafts" with my buddy who is very good at this.

surreal stag
#

5-3 witha quadrix deck

leaden tide
#

Oh my god I just realized that this would be perfect for my Silverquill deck

lucid jewel
surreal stag
#

is that the one that turns it inot rocky from PHM?

lucid jewel
#

yes

surreal stag
#

My wife loved the movie btw

molten maple
#

I NEED IT

#

it is magnificent amaze amaze amaze

lucid jewel
#

Before previews for _Magic: The Gathering | Marvel Super Heroes_​ officially begin, I thought it would be fun to do another of my Duelist-style teasers where I give hints of things to come.

First up, here are some things you can expect:

• Some creature tokens: legendary 1/1 blue Bird Scout, 1/1 red Alien, 1/1 green Minion, legendary 2/2 green Cat, and 3/3 colorless Robot Villain artifact

• A new enchantment subtype

• A flavor word that references an Un- card

• A modal card that lets you choose up to X modes

• Another card that lets you cast a subset of cards off the top of your library

• An activation with six different mana symbols

• A CARD NAME IN ALL CAPS WITH AN EXCLAMATION POINT!

• A creature that can copy three different card types

• A subtype last seen in a Standard-legal set over two decades ago

• A card that can tap for four mana in any combination of colors

Next, some cards will feature the following rules text:

• "Enchanted creature becomes a copy of that creature unti...

leaden tide
#

• “Ward – Get five poison counters.”

#

Now that is a fascinating design space

spare harbor
#

I really think gift and ward could go so well together

turbid falcon
#

Avengers assemble is definitely the exclamation point one

#

Also, new enchantment subtype is interesting

spare harbor
turbid falcon
#

Wait but avengers assemble is literally mentioned later on, maybe it's something else lol

#

And, ninjad

spare harbor
#

so there's likely something else in all caps

#

🥷

#

lol

#

no spoiler hinting at a battle 😔

#

“Equip worthy”

#

I wonder what that's for...

#

i guess we'll never know

dense orchid
#

Card name in all caps is a Deadpool reference for sure

rare sparrow
dense orchid
#

I could see some sort of onomatopoeia

turbid falcon
rare sparrow
#

oh yeah it's gotta be HULK SMASH!

molten maple
#

guys I just encountered the MOST unpleasant magic player I have ever had the misfortune of being in a pod with

#

they insisted that its not possible to build a cheap bracket 3 deck because "game changers are too expensive"

#

My brother in christ, you dont need game changers to make a strong bracket 3 deck. You can build an incredibly cheap bracket four deck with no game changers at all if you really want. Then they insisted my deck was bracket 4 and was really mad at me because I killed them turn 5 with an inkmoth nexus after they did nothing at all for the first 4 turns and I turbo ramped u nopposed. Maam, I am sorry but there isnt a rule saying I am obligated to let you live until turn 8 if you twiddle your thumbs and let me build up my board unopposed

#

oh, they also insisted on tutoring for a glacial chasm every game in every deck

wanton hazel
#

Well, Wizards does say bracket 3 should allow players to play 6 turns before anyone wins or loses

#

Not saying that person is right but the impression comes from the top

lucid jewel
#

okay just watched a vid and i might need to work on a deck

#

cause ive been thinking about a harmless offering style deck for a while but this like does that in a really fun way

#

also comes out to like 385.53usd when i cart optimize it

#

Use code COMMANDERFB50 to get 50% OFF your first Factor box plus free breakfast for 1 year at https://bit.ly/466fieO !

Visit our sponsor Manapool! https://manapool.com/?ref=cah

Join our friends at Laughing Dragon for Commandfest Tacoma on July 3-5th! https://www.laughingdragonevents.com/cf-tacoma-2026/

Thanks to Gamegenic for sponsoring the s...

▶ Play video
#

this vid specifically

molten maple
molten maple
#

If you win on turn 5 every game youve made a bracket 4 deck. If you win on turn 5 with a very good draw when your opponents do absolutely nothing to stop you, its probably bracket 3

tepid stirrup
#

Less about pedantry and more a nontrivial nuance when you're discussing a deck's power level: if you can reliably (and relatively safely) knock another player out of the game in five turns you're also bracket four

molten maple
#

Reliably, yes

tepid stirrup
#

Which is to say, I wouldn't consider the ability to kill someone on turn five but leave yourself open to the other two players to kill you in turn a bracket four deck

#

Because most players won't play that way most of the time

molten maple
#

The game went went as such
T1: tap land, pass
T2: farseek
T3: Yuna
T4: Ouroboroid, leaving up 2 mana for protection
T5: animate inkmoth nexus, ouroboroid pumps it to 7, I play a goldvein hydra and sac it to my high market so Yuna moves its counters to get the final boost of power for inkmoth to oneshot

plush bear
molten maple
#

Thats its a very aggressive, unopposed start. If she didnt want to die turn 5 to a very fast draw she couldve killed/counterspelled/bounced literally anything in her azorious control deck

lucid jewel
dense orchid
leaden tide
#

Aww hell yeah, I made some killer trades last night and knocked out two of the three big AtlA cards I was still missing.

molten maple
#

or just for your collection

leaden tide
#

For my collection, I'm collecting a (normal border non-foil) master set of Avatar.

#

Though I do have decks that want those cards, I'll be putting proxies in the decks themselves.

molten maple
#

nice, those are the big ones

leaden tide
#

Yep. I opened a Wan Shi Tong a while back and made some trades for the saga Avatars. So the last big thing I'm missing is the Jumpstart version of Katara. And 8 other much cheaper cards.

#

Also I finally decided how I want to start building a Jin Sakai deck. My initial ideas just devolved into Ninja goodstuff. Then I remembered Tempest Technique, and realized I want to build him as an auras/enchantress deck. With some good stuff like:

lucid jewel
surreal stag
leaden tide
#

Swiggity swoogity I'm coming for that
thoughness

surreal stag
#

THE DREAM! sac three things to Fell Beast, gain 21 life, play elf, reanimate dragon with commander at end step, sac token to legend rule gain 15 more

#

only regret is sanguine bond is still in my hand

dense orchid
leaden tide
#

Oooooh this is a nasty piece of tech for Jin Sakai

#

Since he has flying, odds are good that you won't need to make him unblockable with Jin's ability.

#

So instead, you can give him double strike.

#

In which case he slaps the opponent for 12 damage and becomes a 16/16

dense orchid
#

Big butt you say?

lucid jewel
#

Big butts

#

Multiple butts

dense orchid
#

Big Phenax addition you say?

leaden tide
#

Ohhohohooooo, that's evil.

lucid jewel
acoustic wedge
# leaden tide

That's sick and twisted. Cruel and unusual punishment right there

lucid jewel
#

Giving that double strike and extra combats is crazy

leaden tide
#

I went from having no idea how I even wanted to build Jin to having (most of) a first draft in like the course of two days.

#

Still need to fill a couple slots, probably with big creatures, and at least one more board wipe.

#

But I love how this is coming together.

#

Not quite as much of a mana wedge as Steel's deck, but pretty damn close LUL

slender moss
leaden tide
#

Oooh that's a good one and very abusable in blink shells.

#

Might slip it in to Aang.

slender moss
#

I once won a prize in a meme tournament for using Stonehorn to lock my opponent out of combat for 5 turns

#

We love Stonehorn (pauper all-star too!)

gloomy pagoda
#

Oh hey, apparently the next Secret Lair Deck has been leaked via mispicking

#

||Someone got a Hatsune Miku deck instead of Goblinstorm||

plush bear
gloomy pagoda
#

||A lair, yes, a lair deck, no.||

dense orchid
lucid jewel
#

New card leaked for the marvel set

#

The tictok has some swearing in the background be warned

dense orchid
#

||What is this, Questing Beast at home?||

leaden tide
leaden tide
surreal stag
#

2 more 5-3 drafts one premier one quick

lucid jewel
#

It needs to die

spare harbor
#

||nah these are all keywords green has access to||

leaden tide
#

Yep. ||It's making generous use of how WotC handles secondary colors for keywords.||

turbid falcon
#

It's not too dissimilar to other magic designs

#

Notably that one troll

#

Or the dreaded Questing Beast

surreal stag
#

I am cutting Colossal Grave Reaver from my Slimefoot & Squee reanimator deck. It hits the board/grave and my entire deck just resolves around it and im not having fun with that anymore. I need a very cool creature to replace it with and im thinking of going with a big Jund guy/gal that does soemthing fun

#

thoughts, prayers, any suggestions? not Henzie.

#

the list for those interested

leaden tide
#

I vote Coram or Thantis

spare harbor
#

same

surreal stag
#

ty for the votes!

spare harbor
#

I think coram is probably better/more controllable, but Thantis is funnier

surreal stag
#

jsut built my Boros Goad deck in 1 hour 15 mins lol

leaden tide
dense orchid
plush bear
# dense orchid

I’ve got 5 colors, by god I’m going to use them all

dense orchid
#

I guess there's also the secret CWUBRG deck too...

acoustic wedge
surreal stag
#

4c decks are either partners or 1 random dude, wierd world where you can do pretty much anything, i need to start looking at them

spare harbor
#

One of my friends has rule zeroed the nephilim as “legendary” and has some pretty sweet decks built around them

leaden tide
#

If I were to build 4c decks, yeah I think that's what I'd do

spare harbor
#

I think he ended up disassembling the ink treader one because he wanted them to be similar power levels to each other and ink treader was always too powerful

upper moon
# dense orchid

I chose 4 color as the most recent draft I did (lorwyn) ended with me making a 4 color elemental deck that was very fun

slender moss
#

4c decks can have interesting themes more than 5c decks imo

dense orchid
# dense orchid
poll_question_text

Would you rather build

victor_answer_votes

8

total_votes

13

victor_answer_id

2

victor_answer_text

a rainbow (WUBRG) deck?

past lava
dense orchid
#

Captain Sisay!

past lava
#

wrong, the correct answer is different jodah thinksmart

dense orchid
#

Ah, you mean SpongeBob

surreal stag
#

I’m Diamond 4 in constructed AND limited!

leaden tide
#

I went in to the LGS to do a trade, and ran in to one of my friends there (she apparently got back into Magic a week ago after a long hiatus) and ended getting (lovingly) roped in to play a game.

#

I didn't have any decks on me, so one of her friends just handed me a deck. It was the manifest Zimone.

I think the deck was a little short on lands but once I did a few ramps I was able to get the deck going. The first time I manifested with Zimone, I pulled out a Dark Depths. Flipped the Dark Depths, manifested a couple more times, and then the next turn I top-decked Overwhelming Stampede.

#

That was the fastest I've ever seen life totals go down LUL

spare harbor
#

Bro has never played against this guy

#

I swear you blink and everyone is at 20

leaden tide
#

Nah this was way faster

#

It was a 6 player pod, so we were playing 3 teams of two with two-headed giant rules. Each team started at 60 health, and when I drew that card, everyone was still over 50

#

One team just died on the spot, the other had a lifelinker so they managed to squeak by on 12 health.

spare harbor
#

Oh

#

Oh my

surreal stag
#

Pride Month decks?... Pride Month decks.

#

Im building Blech & Zoraline lol

leaden tide
#

I don't know if I have the time and energy to build a pride month specific deck. So I might just have Felothar marry the Walls of Ba Sing Se.

lucid jewel
#

i personally really love the most recent pride card i purchased

#

HUH THERES A LESBIAN TAG ON SCRYFALL

#

it dosent have them all but its interesting that it exists

#

this is the card i was talking about tho

leaden tide
lucid jewel
#

But they are different cards

#

Hmm mabey not different cards actually

#

🤔

#

Ahh I redid the searcy

leaden tide
#

Huh yeah lesbian is just an alias of sapphic.

lucid jewel
#

179 sapphic

#

235 lesbian

leaden tide
#

One search might be counting different artworks of the same card, etc.

dense orchid
surreal stag
#

i cant decide lol

#

wait a minute a new contender has entered the chat

slender moss
#

Meren/Teysa has my vote

surreal stag
#

the matching printings does go pretty hard

#

much aura

dense orchid
leaden tide
dense orchid
dense orchid
#

You may have to do Teysa/Meren then

surreal stag
#

would Teysa double the end of turn effect of Essceknit Scholar?

leaden tide
#

Don't think so.

#

Essenceknit's second ability is triggered by moving to the end step. Not by a creature dying.

surreal stag
#

thats what i thought

surreal stag
#

im about to ditch every instant/sorc in this deck and replace them with creatures that do the same.

past lava
#

did someone say pride deck

plush bear
past lava
#

they're wives

plush bear
#

thats cheating

surreal stag
#

i so badly wanted to go Zoraline + Caellia but due to a VERY LONG HORRIBLE running gag in my main pod/d&d table the "Gym is sa furry" jokes would be to much to handle

#

TLDR we started a D&D game set in a more grimdark Humblewood style world. the furry jokes started and never stopped. I then started playing MTG and may have mentioned when someone posted a Vraska card that i "would"

#

i sealed my fate that day

surreal stag
#

its a bit of a bear to pilot but once it gets off the ground it goes!

sleek valley
#

What a dumb card.

wanton hazel
#

eh, they don't have trample, so you're good as long as you can remove whatever trample comes up and make 5 chumps

sleek valley
#

Oh, they're mine; I'm not worried about blocking them. I just think it's absurd how quickly a 4 drop spirals out of control and leads to a lot of non-games regardless of which side of the board their on.

wanton hazel
#

it's not the only way green can pop off

surreal stag
surreal stag
leaden tide
#

Okay I will (grudgingly) admit that they're showing off some interesting card designs from Marvel today.

#

I'm not gonna post all of them here, but here's my personal highlights:

#

(the land is part of a cycle; only the allied ones seem to be in this set)

native light
#

i have 0 interest in this set, but if i was a comic enjoyer i would probably grab some of those alt frames. very nice and also legible

leaden tide
#

Yeah as a showcase frame, the comic ones are definitely among the better designs they've done.

#

I'm glad for the Marvel fans that they seem to have brought more sauce ot the table than they did for Spider-Man.

native light
#

they dont quite hit Strixhaven, but those are like the OG incredible showcase frames

leaden tide
#

Of the cards they've shown so far, only one I might actually pick up is Monica, and even then I'd prefer to try and proxy her as something else.

native light
#

a decade ago i would have been deep in the MCU and all over this set. so im glad its getting some love in the design front

#

UB is at its best when the designers clearly love the property

leaden tide
#

The new lands are neat, but am gonna wait for in-universe versions and/or proxy them again.

leaden tide
native light
#

Those land names seem generic enough that they will get regular versions eventually

leaden tide
#

Exactly. None of them are like "Avengers HQ" or something stupid

native light
#

it would be pretty silly to lock those behind a property.

molten maple
#

The FLAVOR

#

🔥

#

||Though to truly be a Thanos card it should be random what gets thanos-snapped, not chosen. That would make it unplayably bad though so I get why they did it this way||

leaden tide
#

Lady Loki is an interesting design.

#

Try to turn your Lightning Bolt into a Blightsteel Colossus

dense orchid
#

Bolt into Shadow of Mortality for max damage

rare sparrow
#

i am once again, like with TMNT, happy that there don't seem to be many cards i'd want from this set

turbid falcon
#

I like the designs and art more than TMNT

#

One of those is going in my prowess deck lol

acoustic wedge
#

I do think I wish to possess this card mhm

leaden tide
turbid falcon
#

Of course it was hulk smash LUL

#

HULK SMASH

molten maple
#

Marvel reveals

#

Oh my god this card is absurdly broken, no?

#

Commander and limited for sure, probably standard too

turbid falcon
#

Eh

#

A bit slow for standard

leaden tide
#

Standard? Yeah 3 mana is gonna be hard to cut its teeth, but might have a home.

leaden tide
#

Commander? Definitely kill on sight.

#

Also, I need to soapbox a bit.

lucid jewel
#

there we go

#

this is the above it just didnt embed

leaden tide
#

(I'll try not to do this very often so I don't ruin the whole spoiler season)

#

But holy cow I hate the hero/villain typal stuff, it feels so forced and it's ruining what would otherwise be awesome stand-alone Magic designs.

#

I would love to try and work Sue Storm into my walls deck, but having the hero type restriction makes that virtually impossible.

turbid falcon
#

I'm wondering if any will fit into my Omo deck

leaden tide
#

I wish they'd figured out a way for heroes and villains to be a batching like they did with outlaws. That would have made these cards much more resonant with existing Magic designs, instead of siloed into their own self-contained environment.

turbid falcon
#

Though it doesn't seem to be strongly in blue green

leaden tide
#

Alright, that's it for today, I'll get off the soapbox now.

lucid jewel
#

mjolnir kinda has a simular issue

charred ruin
# leaden tide

Yo the Fantastic Four creating an infinite combo if all together is really cool

molten maple
#

Wow flavor fail. "Invincible Iron Man"

Looks inside: not indestructible

turbid falcon
#

Omo, ignoring silly things like typal restriction, my favorite

leaden tide
#

Torch > Fantastic > Invisible >Thing

charred ruin
turbid falcon
#

No you see it's exactly like the comics

#

Pretty much anyone can end up using it

lucid jewel
#

only legandary whites and reds can use it ?

charred ruin
#

Yes but "non-Villain" is practically worthless outside of limited is my point

lucid jewel
#

i was making a jok e

#

about how theres probs some legandary black characters who are worthy

#

but we dont get to see them wheild the hammer

leaden tide
#

Vision can't wield the hammer, but Elesh Norn can

#

Also RW has tons of ways of cheating Equipment attachment, so for a lot of equipment decks they just don't care.

charred ruin
#

That's true lol

lucid jewel
leaden tide
#

Like, every equipment deck is running this guy:

leaden tide
charred ruin
#

Wait how was she not in the Spider-Man set?

turbid falcon
#

Also shout out to the simulacrum synthesizer reprint

#

That card is nuts

lucid jewel
#

this is such a strange way to do wolverines healing factor

leaden tide
#

Legit reads like a custom card

turbid falcon
#

Also, captain marvel being racist towards kree made me laugh out loud

leaden tide
#

-# (this is not what the actual card looks like but I wish it was)

leaden tide
turbid falcon
#

Sauron being worthy is especially funny

#

And Nicol bolas

rare sparrow
#

i feel like mjolnir has "not a villain" to be more backwards compatible with existing magic cards

#

but flavor-wise would work a lot better if it required the creature to be a white and/or red hero

molten maple
rare sparrow
#

they probably thought that was too restrictive

molten maple
#

Not the art but the effect

rare sparrow
#

yes

molten maple
#

Oh man thats gonna be huge for my Nethroi deck

rare sparrow
#

what it actually looks like

leaden tide
#

Hold up

#

The basic lands are

#

Actually pretty decent?

#

Only one of them is New York (and of course it has Spidey lmao)

wanton hazel
#

lmao more spiders

molten maple
#

For people who REALLY hate playing against flyers, based

surreal stag
#

all my homies hate birds

lucid jewel
turbid falcon
surreal stag
#

I would never do such a thing....

dense orchid
surreal stag
#

he knows why

dense orchid
#

MTG story: ||He's just trying to save the multiverse and his girlfriend totally||

#

||Even though Jace is the STORMING PROBLEM!!!||

leaden tide
dense orchid
#

Sshhhh semantics

surreal stag
#

its like the opposite of the 2000s banger from The Offspring I Want You Bad.

leaden tide
charred ruin
surreal stag
leaden tide
#

Needs more Niv Mizzet

surreal stag
#

There isn’t more Nov Mizzet

surreal stag
#

At least not in Izzet

surreal stag
#

Oh pym particles going in my Orvar Big Fishy deck for sure for sure

#

I had to have made the fairest Orvar deck in recent history. The entire point is to duplicate my lands and artifacts to play massive sea monsters…..and then duplicate massive sea monsters lol

#

It’s the only way I found to make mono blue fun. Just make it stompy

dense orchid
#

Cap's Shield would go so well on my Phenax deck ugh!

dense orchid
surreal stag
#

That is kinda funny

#

Maybe one little fishy is okay

turbid falcon
#

For heavens sake
This guy is perfect for my Toph deck

lucid jewel
#

if its designed well they feel like they would help each other out

turbid falcon
#

They're not perfectly synergistic on the surface, cuz she only cares about non tokens, but I always find my deck gets significantly stronger if I can land mirrorworks and start copying artifacts. This is just mirrorworks but cheaper and with upside

lucid jewel
#

ultron is massive in any deck that makes a lot of treasures as well

turbid falcon
#

How so

lucid jewel
#

ohh

#

i read it wrong

turbid falcon
#

Yeah, non token

#

The only question is do I slot out mirrorworks entirely
Probably, the curve is kinda high

rare sparrow
#

Mirrorworks takes a lot of mana before it does anything

turbid falcon
#

Means I can't do funny things like copying mirrorworks but I think it being cheaper is more than worth the trade off

rare sparrow
#

You can make your first copy with ultron and also have ultron on board as a creature for the same amount of mana that it costs to get mirrorworks on the board

#

Ultron and the copies it makes being creatures is definitely a downside

turbid falcon
#

Eh not in my deck

#

I'm turning all my artifacts into creatures anyway

#

And lands

#

They're all artifact creature lands and they're all happy about it LUL

#

And Ultron is liable to get earthbent

#

Just imagine it

#

Toph, planting her feet on the ground and bending Ultron... And flinging him at someones face LUL

rare sparrow
turbid falcon
#

Also @leaden tide because the whole worthy thing isn't silly enough, you can of course use a combo to make it equipable to any creature in the game
All you need is Leyline of Singularity to give everything legendary and Leyline of the guild pact to give everything all colors, or any other color changing effect because I believe it should stay equipped even if the color changes after

#

But 2 leylines seems like the funniest option because then you hypothetically don't even have to pay mana

#

Behold, my ornithopter now wields Mjolnir. The ornithopter is worthy

leaden tide
#

I haven't found good art/concept for Monica Rambeau yet, but I did come up with these ideas for proxy flavor shifts.

acoustic wedge
#

Oooo fun fun

surreal stag
#

i didnt think about that

lucid jewel
upper moon
#

Man, I so want a non marvel version of the cap shield for my defender deck (though granted, me not using it is my fault just because I'm too much of a vorthos to use UB cards outside of their set LUL)

dense orchid
#

I like the idea of not even the hammer being worthy lol

turbid falcon
#

Whichever one comes second will be the top layer, and therefore the reigning static effect

leaden tide