#Magic: the Gathering

1 messages · Page 7 of 1

turbid falcon
#

As for what you're looking for in your play testing, are you able to get spells out on curve? Do you have good answers for a variety of problems? Does it feel smooth to play? Do you consistently have the correct colors? Do you have a distinct way to win?
If any of these feel lacking or any other issues pop up you can address them by tweaking the list

#

Still working on an initial concept for Toph the first metalbender
I had a brilliant thought of making her an affinity deck, but unfortunately without blue, artifact affinity is a lot less powerful of an option

sweet kettle
#

official cosmere MTG packs when

#

can you imagine how awesome that'd be

molten maple
#

That would be epic

#

It probably wont happen but I might cry if it did

turbid falcon
#

Sanderson did express that if he ever does MTG cards in collaboration it would be a full set

#

He's not taking any of that wimpy Secret lair nonsense LUL

#

And apart from my deep love of the cosmere, I think it's far more likely to fit into the MTG system than many of the other stupid properties we're getting this year

molten maple
#

Problem is I dont think WotC cares at all whether or not a set actually fits

#

In 2027 you will get Muppets and iCarly, take it or leave it

leaden tide
#

In terms of protecting Zur during combat, this would be a great include:

#

If your opponent goes to block Zur with a creature that would kill him, you can just use Reconnaissance to yoink him out of combat.

leaden tide
leaden tide
leaden tide
molten maple
#

🛌

turbid falcon
#

They'll care when the sales numbers come back

molten maple
#

Marvel kiiiiiinda fits but c'mon, TMNT???

#

Bruh

turbid falcon
leaden tide
molten maple
#

Personally I dont mind UB, I just want the UB sets they choose to be MTG adjacent in terms of feel you know?

leaden tide
#

(I'm leaving FF out of this, because no set is ever gonna sell as well as Final Fantasy again, period. It's the Spiders Georg of Magic sales)

turbid falcon
#

FF had a number of additional advantages

molten maple
#

Like FF and LotR and Avatar are cool because they feel like they fit in the MTG world at least a little bit

leaden tide
turbid falcon
#

Namely, it's not often you get stuff from the old FF games anymore

#

So this was kinda the first time in probably decades that those characters got some real love

leaden tide
turbid falcon
#

40k was perfect

#

Having it as 4 commander decks was just right

#

Frankly I'd love for them to do another 4 40k commander decks at some point

leaden tide
#

That, and far-future space-magic stuff feels very classic Magic, like Dominaria vs the Phyrexians.

turbid falcon
#

And it's tabletop as well so it just kinda fits into the same headspace

molten maple
#

Cosmere would fit really well

#

🥺 👉 👈

leaden tide
#

Yep. Cosmere is the kind of property that'd feel almost indistinguishable from Magic.

turbid falcon
#

I mean, there's gotta be a way to turn the radiant orders into guilds LUL

leaden tide
#

I'd put it in the same category as Avatar, which only stands out because of the high density of anime/cartoon art.

molten maple
#

I swear to god if I get my ass kicked by a Morbius deck im gonna crash out

leaden tide
molten maple
#

Would you guys want a hypothetical Sanderson set to be the whole cosmere or only Stormlight Archives

turbid falcon
#

SA probably has the best density

#

Without it feeling too scattered

surreal stag
surreal stag
#

I don’t think my “I’m never buying cards” would last lol

molten maple
#

I dream of one day being able to play a Yumi + Nikaro partners commander deck 🙏

#

So selfishly I hope it would be the whole cosmere but realistically I think keeping it just SA makes more sense

leaden tide
molten maple
#

The cosmere is just way too big

leaden tide
#

I personally would want to see the rest of the Cosmere in cards though.

surreal stag
#

Allomancy is just kicker

#

Sorry had to say it

turbid falcon
#

EVERYTHING is kicker LUL

leaden tide
#

I wonder if Stormlight main set + Cosmere commander decks would work. Hmm. Assuming 4 commander decks:

  • Mistborn Era 1
  • Mistborn Era 2
  • Worldhopper (Sel, Nalthis, Taldain)
  • Hoid's Tales (Secret projects)
#

Would that be a decent split?

molten maple
#

God I would kill for a playable Vin card

turbid falcon
#

Vin, 3/3 flying deathtouch

leaden tide
#

Those are the three mechanics.

turbid falcon
#

Flashback is kicker

#

Just graveyard kicker LUL

#

Or, they could do the whole cosmere and do it more like with Avatar where it's more character focused

molten maple
leaden tide
#

Hmm.

turbid falcon
#

And Hoid could be our 5 color legendary named "Hoid, the Storyteller"

molten maple
#

🙂‍↕️

turbid falcon
#

Oh here's an idea, he turns creatures into sagas

molten maple
#

Uhhh

#

That seems complicated

#

How would that work

turbid falcon
#

They gain a lore counter and become enchantment sagas

molten maple
#

What would the chapters do though

turbid falcon
#

Working on that LUL

leaden tide
#

The chapters insult you

surreal stag
#

I did make this once upon a time

#

Just a dope looking proxy

granite whale
#

And the crystal/gem frame too, flavor on point 👏

surreal stag
#

finally got mtg arena and jsut threw away my free quick draft becuase i didnt read and had no idea how to format worked

lucid jewel
#

That sucks. Honestly mtga is a great way to play LOTS of magic

#

I can play anytime of the day or night

surreal stag
#

yea im liking it and i think itll just help me be a bit better at the game

#

did some Uber driving on my days off so i rewarded myself with a little $5 welcome bundle

lucid jewel
#

its helped me become a much better player

#

just the sheer number of games i play now

#

has increased my skill dramaticly

leaden tide
#

Ugh, I have a strange dilemma.

#

I had an internet friend with whom I used to talk shop about Magic stuff. She carried her decks around in a Stanley took box.

#

Well recently this friend and I had a falling out over some boundaries things, and now we don't talk. But I want to know what variety of tool box she uses because I can't remember 😭

leaden tide
#

That's similar, but I can't remmeber if it's the exact one.

plush bear
#

It’s the standard one that gets recommended

leaden tide
#

Thank you though

plush bear
#

I’ve found that the Dragonsteel book boxes perfectly fit 4 decks

leaden tide
#

Sadly, I've not kept any of those boxes for space considerations.

sleek valley
#

Is it one of the DeWalt ones?

#

Oh, I didn't see that you mentioned Stanley specifically. Then it would probably be the one Bean linked.

leaden tide
#

It could be DeWalt. Idk, will just have to check and see what my local hardware stores have.

leaden tide
#

I found an even better one. 13 deck-sized trays by default, and I can remove the two big trays to have room for my playmat.

surreal stag
#

Noice

leaden tide
#

Update: the playmat is just a half inch too long, so I had to take out the fifth cup of the row. Still this is great, it can fit as many decks as the Stanley case and peripherals too.

#

Now just to finish building/rebuilding my decks...

surreal stag
#

this is SATIRE

leaden tide
#

Yeah you need to pay for the uncensored version.

turbid falcon
#

Oh ho my patience has been rewarded

#

I cracked 18 packs leaving the rest for my brother and I to play sealed tomorrow but this is what I got LUL

#

I can't believe I managed to crack all 4 Legends of Avatar enchantments, AND A BADGERMOLE CUB

#

And a fire lord azula who seems popping

#

I'm still hoping for a mythic Appa and Walls of Ba Sing Se in the packs for tomorrow but we'll just have to wait and see

leaden tide
#

Hella jealous right now.

turbid falcon
#

I know right? And it's only half the box!

leaden tide
#

Guh. I wish I had the money for a box.

#

Might get to help my friend crack some of hers in a couple weeks. Which will be fun.

turbid falcon
#

Shockingly they aren't horrifically overpriced rn

#

Got one for $150, which is downright reasonable nowadays

leaden tide
#

Hmmm that's not bad. It's about what the cost of the rest of the main-set cards I need is. But I doubt I'd get all the pulls I want.

#

Maybe if I'm good at saving money elsewhere....

turbid falcon
#

Yeah if you're just cracking packs to get certain cards not worth it

leaden tide
#

Yeah my main thing is that I want 1 of everything

turbid falcon
#

I crack packs because A it's fun and B it's a rare chance to play sealed with my brother

leaden tide
#

From AtlA.

turbid falcon
#

It is, but I only really buy a box 2, maybe 3 times a year
It just so happens this is going to come close to me cracking a bunch of Lorwyn as well LUL

leaden tide
#

Lorwyn should be fun. I might get a box of that since I'm not gonna be chasing a complete set.

lucid jewel
#

Thats some of the most dense pulls I've seen in a bit

#

Congrats

tepid stirrup
#

This might be the most chaotic game of MTG ever played

lucid jewel
#

i watched this

#

and its amazing

#

like legit every epp ben brode is on is chaotic af and then this one is extra chaotic

#

cant wait for the next ben epp

#

i also think this is my fav commander youtube show

#

love these guys

tepid stirrup
#

Game spoilers ||Crim killed Ben and himself with two different triggers on Brian's turn, mostly by accident, and it wasn't the wildest thing to happen this game and might not even have been top 3 wildest things to happen this game LUL||

plush bear
#

Ben Brode is chaos, Crim is evil incarnate. It’s perfect

tepid stirrup
#

Ben brought an Unset deck

plush bear
#

Oh again? I gotta watch it now

tepid stirrup
#

Which like this might be the best use case scenario for Unset cards LUL

plush bear
#

Last time he brought one it was fun

tepid stirrup
#

This time he had to bring a whole bunch of props

slender moss
turbid falcon
#

Played sealed with my brother today
Lost 1-2, but the game I did win I won by repeatedly earthbending secret tunnel, included with me singing the song unnecessarily loudly every time I hit him with it LUL

#

Nothing too crazy in the back half other than fated firepower which will probably find a home in my jeskai deck

leaden tide
#

I didn't even crack a Secret Tunnel at my prerelease, but I was doing this every time someone in earshot played the card

lucid jewel
slender moss
#

Does anybody have any good decks for getting the "Gifting Spree" achievement on the Arena winter achievement set?

slender moss
#

Update:

leaden tide
#

Glad you got it done though!

leaden tide
#

Need to order a small handful of cards for all three of my main decks before I can play them. And I need to actually test them and make sure they work the way I want. But they hopefully are a lot more focused than my previous iterations.

#

Next up I want to re-design my unfinished Toph deck form the ground up, cannibalize the FF7 deck I got at Costco to make a Sokka and Suki deck, and also take another stab at my original Boros Burn deck, with either Lightning, Army of One or Taii Wakeen, Perfect Shot as the commander.

leaden tide
#

Ugh, so many of the good cards for Toph are stupid expensive 😭

turbid falcon
#

Yeahhhhh

#

Reminder that this video exists and if you've never seen it before, please watch it
https://youtu.be/nkoT4Nx2_hg

34 Siege Rhinos wasn't enough. 35 Siege Rhinos wasn't either. Today we have our Biggest Brain Brew yet, a Battle of Wits deck with 100 Siege Rhinos. What could possibly go wrong?

Get your playmat here! https://www.mtggoldfishmerch.com

Today's video is brought to you by Card Kingdom. You can pick up some Magic: the Gathering cards (and help sup...

▶ Play video
#

It's quite possibly the greatest Seth video ever LUL

slender moss
#

Above video ||Except he never actually filmed a game that included a Rhino||

leaden tide
#

I might be putting my Toph deck on hold until I figure out a direction for it that I'm more comfortable with.

#

Because right now my options look to be either break-the-bank counters stuff (which yes I can proxy, but I want the deck to have the vibes of something more affordable) or just a big pile of Earthbending goodstuff, which feels a little uninspired to me.

turbid falcon
#

Yeah I don't think I'm gonna go down the earthbending route outside of the stuff I got from my box

#

I want to go down an artifact/land route because in Naya it seems like a really interesting way to go down
I'll be looking through my collection once I get back home to see if that gives me any inspiration

turbid falcon
#

Also HOLY CRAP

#

This might be the most brilliant marketing route they can go down

charred ruin
#

👀

turbid falcon
#

@leaden tide I finally had a decent idea for Toph

#

It came together while I was looking through my collection and found Weapons Manufacturing, which I very much wanted to build around
Then I realized earthbended artifacts are gonna do the same thing when removed, they return to the battlefield tapped
Meaning i want to make artifact aristocrats

leaden tide
#

Hmmmm, that's a cool way to take it. Sac artifacts and get them back for more value.

turbid falcon
#

Exactly!

#

And they re-enter the battlefield so that'll trigger weapons manufacturing

leaden tide
#

There's probably a way to abuse Ugin's Nexus with that. Though you'd need a way to bounce it to hand at instant speed.

turbid falcon
#

How so?

#

That's completely bonkers, but shouldn't the earthbending trigger solve it

leaden tide
#

If you sac an Earthbent Ugin's nexus, it will come back instantly. Which will prevent you from taking the extra turn it just generated.

turbid falcon
#

It says if put into graveyard or exile iirc

#

Ohhhhhh

#

The first line LUL

leaden tide
#

I think they designed Ugin's Nexus specifically to hose it self, thanks to there being historically busted artifact shenanigans in many formats.

turbid falcon
#

But you could just sack it twice

#

It doesn't care until you're about to begin said turn, so if you can repeatedly earthbend it, you can stack a bunch of extra turns triggers, then remove it one final time

leaden tide
slender moss
#

Ah yes two extra turns is "Near-Infinite"

#

But still, Ugin's nexus is a one-card lock in a Drafna, Founder of Lat-nam deck

leaden tide
slender moss
#

Also they messed up the combo writeup

#

"Masterful replication on the battlefield" my bro it is an instant

leaden tide
#

In unrelated news, I think I finally found the commander I want to build my Boros Burn deck around.

#

I initially wanted to do something based around the damage doubling Gisela. But that was a very clunky deck and she took FOREVER to get online.

#

Then I tinkered with a Lightning, Army of One build, but didn't like the overall feel of that.

#

Taii though, she feels right. She's blindingly cheap, has a built in draw engine (something Boros struggles with) and is relatively unthreatening. While both Gisela and Lighting are removal magnets.

slender moss
#

So as it turns out, Emrakul, The Aeons Torn is not protected from Junk WInder

#

Flying Spaghetti Monster vs. random snake who wins

slender moss
#

Kneecapping restriction with negative synergy and an awful spot on your curve but you get to aura farm so hard

#

All jokes aside though, Immodane is great in Taii

turbid falcon
#

Finally this deck is coming together

#

Only problem is a lot of key pieces are quite expensive, especially the earthbending package sigh

leaden tide
leaden tide
lucid jewel
#

And gonna just assemble it over tine

#

Rather than toph

turbid falcon
turbid falcon
leaden tide
leaden tide
#

But so many of those directions are so expensive.

leaden tide
turbid falcon
#

Okay initial deck list done, now time for some HEAVY testing because..
The deck is rather compelx

#

Please note this is an initial draft and I'm gonna tweak it more

#

Once I get 2 or 3 repeatable earthbending stuff going the deck really starts to go

leaden tide
#

That list makes a lot of sense. But man that price is eyewatering

#

If you find yourself needing removal, Planar Cleansing and the ilk would go hard in this kind of deck.

lucid jewel
#

Any of the "real" iroh decks are around the same price

#

All the harmless offering tech is surprisingly expensive

#

This is the deck Im probs gonna build 1st but this next deck is kinda what I wish I could afford

#

There's probs some easy swaps for the 2nd deck that reduce price tho

turbid falcon
#

Like when did the Ozolith get so expensive

#

Back when I pulled it, it was like $10

leaden tide
#

Looks like it's been climbing for a while, with a big spike around Ravnica Remastered

turbid falcon
#

Huh

#

Well given how insanely broken it is with earthbending I'm glad I already own it lol

#

Well, at least with what I'm doing with earthbending

leaden tide
#

Tbh it's kinda inherently broken with Earthbending as a whole.

fierce dragon
leaden tide
#

It doesn't help that they're showint all sets and not just Standard ones but...yeah.

#

I wouldn't put Assassins' Creed on the same level as MH3

stiff horizon
#

kind of bleak seeing all the set releases on a timeline like this and watching the denisty of releases jump between new capenna and dominaria united, as well as the slow creep of more and more universes beyond logos in there

lucid jewel
#

That really does put a huge visual element to the whole increase of sets

leaden tide
#

A bunch of Lorwyn Eclipsed was leaked overnight.

#

The reveal stream starts later today so I'm not gonna bother posting stuff. But it's all on Reddit if you want to look.

#

There's some really neat and fascinating use of mechanics in the set. And the art looks fantastic.

tepid stirrup
#

I do wonder if that was done on purpose

#

The promo cycle is positively minimalist and sandwiched between Christmas and whichever UB comes after (Turtles? Marvel?) and they're getting public kickback about how they're burying one of the few UW sets they're even doing this year

leaden tide
#

Yeah idk. Something similar happened last year when they did a bunch of Spider-Man promo during the EoE event.

turbid falcon
#

Okay Jim Henson company absolutely KILLED it

#

Explore the dual-aspect plane of Lorwyn and Shadowmoor, an enchanted land split into forever day and eternal night where every path reveals a mirrored self. Encounter elves, kithkin, merrow, boggarts, flamekin, and more as you dive into new creature strategies and gameplay. Harness the powers of order and chaos with new mechanics. And collect th...

▶ Play video
gloomy pagoda
#

Lorwyn Eclipsed? I believe you mean the Jim Henson Company UBW set!

turbid falcon
#

I am so glad this set they're focusing on hand drawn art

#

I am going to buy so much of this set

lucid jewel
#

Looking through today's spoilers

#

Im so ready for earthbending elf balls

turbid falcon
#

That conjures a horrifying mental image LUL

lucid jewel
#

Also loving all the anti spell synergy. He's such a good little guy

plush bear
#

Why!

#

Spells weren’t the problem!

wanton hazel
#

because storm Blue in particular

plush bear
#

This doesn’t hit storm blue!

lucid jewel
#

Mabey there will be some goblinin time in standard

plush bear
#

It’s just good in storm blue!

leaden tide
#

This is also a cool one, 4 for 2 mana is rare, especially at instant speed

surreal stag
#

btw the new full art lands are absolutly peak and all my decks will run them

#

these new ones or bloomburrow lands depending on the decks vibe

turbid falcon
#

Phyrexians: we gonna compleat everyone
Also phyrexians:

#

No one touches the bogle LUL

lucid jewel
turbid falcon
#

I think the elemental deck looks sweet

#

Most of the cards are like "yup that makes perfect sense" plus a few reprints I was particularly hoping for

#

The mana base is... Slow but consistent is what I'd say. Lots of tapped lands but good color consistency

#

And this is my new favorite card, it's hilarious LUL

lucid jewel
#

What im curious about for the purpose of blight stuff. Do the +1/+1 and -1/-1 counters literally cancel each other out or is there a +1 and a -1 counter still on a creature if it has 1 of each

mild plover
#

Apparently they actually cancel

molten maple
#

Question

#

Can a spell target itself?

#

Nvm I see it cant

#

But lets say someone counterspells my spell, and I have a spell that can redirect the target of a spell. Can I redirect the counterspell to target my redirection spell? Lol

#

I assume not...

leaden tide
#

Deflectin Swat resolves, changes the target of Counterspell to the (now vanished) Deflecting Swat. Counterspell attempts to resolve, sees that its target is no longer on the stack, and fizzles with no effect.

#

The original spell targeted by Counterspell resolves unhintered.

molten maple
#

Thats sick thanks

#

I wasnt sure if a spell can target something after it on the stack

#

Deflecting Swat is a cool spell

tepid stirrup
# molten maple Thats sick thanks

The stack is Magic for me to some degree. Its such a good mechanic and they're consistently good at pushing interesting ways of playing with it

lucid jewel
#

Simular to deflecting swat

turbid falcon
#

-1/-1 counters are notoriously powerful due to this cancelling

#

I do like having them as a cost in this set I think it'll be interesting

leaden tide
#

I'm pleasantly surprised to see Wizards doing another -1/-1 set. They'd said they didn't want to put them in standard again after Amonkhet.

rare sparrow
#

if they were ever going to do it, lorwyn was kind of the place to do it

#

shadowmoor/eventide was the hardest they've ever gone in on -1/-1 counters

#

i suspect if we ever get another amonkhet set that would be the other place we might see it

turbid falcon
#

Speaking of -1/-1 counters I absolutely love the inclusion of tree of perdition in the commander deck
Because that is EVIL to blight itLUL

rare sparrow
#

also, i think part of the reason they didn't like it was the confusion that the +1/+1 counter and -1/-1 counter interaction causes...but they've shown in the past couple years with them expecting more out of their players in a commander-focused world that they are willing to push the mechanical boundaries a bit. like how they are putting random one-off cards with old mechanics in sets pretty regularly

rare sparrow
#

but honestly flavorfully fits for -1/-1 counters

leaden tide
rare sparrow
#

there's some great art in this set. i'm sad that the best art i've seen so far is on a bulk common though

leaden tide
#

So it goes. There was that one bulk common in March of the Machines.

#

Okay, uncommon.

rare sparrow
#

yup, happens sometimes, artist just turns in a banger

plush bear
#

Often you mean

leaden tide
#

However, this is clearly the best art of the set so far.

lucid jewel
#

Whats the other side look like

leaden tide
lucid jewel
#

Thats such an interesting way to do planeswalkers

leaden tide
#

The flip design? Or the fact that stupid sexy Oko is as stupid and sexy as always?

charred ruin
#

Of course he still makes elk tokens

turbid falcon
# rare sparrow

They literally used this art on a bunch of advertising and it's on a common lol

lucid jewel
#

All the + on one side all the - on the other

leaden tide
#

Yee. I like it

turbid falcon
#

Have they revealed all the elemental cycle yet?

#

I guess my real question is whether it's a cycle of 5 or 10

#

Cuz there's a dimir one and I believe that's ally colors and there's also an orzhov one and that's enemy

leaden tide
#

It's five, I'd guess. We have seen four of them (and the fifth was leaked yesterday), and they're all in the color pairs not covered by the shocklands in the set.

tepid stirrup
#

I could unironically see them double printing the ones already in since they'll rotate in different years due to the Lorwyn bump

turbid falcon
#

Not in this set though

#

We're just getting the 5

turbid falcon
leaden tide
#

Well, each of the original Lorwyn/Shadowmoor creature types had set color pairs, but there were only 8 in total I think.

#

For the return, Wizards probably decided that was too much to cram in a little set. So they trimmed it down to 5, and there wasn't a clean way to do allies or enemies, is my guess.

#

At least not with the most iconic creature types.

lucid jewel
molten maple
#

Finally got to play my Azula deck

#

It was very very powerful and fun for me

#

But unfortunately my opponents did need to sit for like 30 minutes as I combod off

#

Def not a deck to break out at every table lol, ill reserve it for games where my opponents play cringe like Vivi

leaden tide
turbid falcon
#

It's so great

surreal stag
#

my buddy built 2 Azula decks and even the "fair magic" version turn 6 he stormed off for 10 mins

#

we have since bansihed Azula from the pod (his idea) but he made it in paper and those people hate it to haha

molten maple
surreal stag
#

yes

#

you staple a "dont let me attack with my commander" sign on your own forehead and then see who has the out lol

lucid jewel
#

I might just need to buy the big booty dragon precon from tarkier if they keep printing solid cards for it like this one from lorwyn

surreal stag
#

my otehr bud just built a big booty deck before seeing this card be annoucned lol

#

Felothar plus Skulk is nasty work

#

60/60 Walls of Ba Sing Se anyone?

#

yea if i ever get my colors in a game this will be fun

#

sol ring turn 3 fyi

#

turn 7 i breach the multiverse and get Etali and Kardur plus something from everyone else and then another soemthing from everyone else

#

it all has haste +2/+0

#

you get it

#

this is the wrong discord server but oh well. reanimator is fun lol

leaden tide
#

Biggest expense is probably the land base, plus walls of Ba Sing Se. You'll get a good chunk of what you need for it out of the big-booty precon; basically I took out the life gain and +1/+1 themes out of it to go all in on the toughness matters.

lucid jewel
#

Thats so good, ill save that and look at it after I pickup the precon one day

lucid jewel
lucid jewel
leaden tide
#

Trying to decide if I'd rather have that art or this one as a playmat:

lucid jewel
#

the 2nd one feels more on theme

#

while the 1st is very epic i think i would rather the 2nd

lucid jewel
#

Lorwyn.... so this is a card, certainly wont be frustrating to play against at all

#

I guess its even handed tho

wanton hazel
#

I suppose it won't be hard to find removal for it so long as it's in your deck at all

surreal stag
#

yea if you really want it gone just wiat your turn and nope it

#

and imagine not having enchantment removal

#

eat your vegtables!

leaden tide
turbid falcon
#

I really like the use of -1/-1 counters in this set to create overstatted creatures that start underwhelming but become more powerful

#

It's a cool design niche

lucid jewel
#

Too bad big booty deck dosent have red

#

Lorwyn card

turbid falcon
#

Why are we spoiling Lorwyn cards anyway

#

They're from official channels

plush bear
#

Set isn’t out

#

They are spoilers until release

lucid jewel
#

That

plush bear
#

It’s like Brandon reading chapters from an upcoming book

lucid jewel
#

And thats where I would stand outside of this channels spoiler rules

turbid falcon
#

I uh, disagree that that's necessary for cards revealed through official channels

#

But whatever

lucid jewel
#

Some ppl like to avoid card spoils till they go to pre release

turbid falcon
#

That doesn't feel to me like the same sort of requirement for spoiler policy that something like a story would but like I said, whatever

lucid jewel
#

Love this art

surreal stag
turbid falcon
#

It is a colossal shame that the Rebecca Guay art is only as the numbered carss

#

Otherwise I'd love to have one

lucid jewel
#

Yeppp

#

Im never gonna get a copy but it looks cool

surreal stag
#

just play on tabletop sim

lucid jewel
#

Look

#

You have a point

surreal stag
#

in your basement everyone is showering daily and wearing deorderant

lucid jewel
#

As far as you know

#

What if I dont

surreal stag
#

if not then you have direct control over that issue

lucid jewel
surreal stag
#

come to my house you cna shower whenever you need it

lucid jewel
#

You live near iowa

surreal stag
#

in midwest terms yes

#

its only like a 6 hour drive i think'

lucid jewel
#

Not too far

surreal stag
#

im in St Louis come on over baby

lucid jewel
#

Is it possible to do drafts in tts

surreal stag
#

via websites yes, you then build the deck online and import so......yesnt

lucid jewel
#

I had a feeling you couldn't do it easly directly in tts

surreal stag
#

i wouldnt want to tbh. moving all those cards/packs from person to person, orginizing them, building the decks would be hell if one person had a rough internet connection

lucid jewel
#

I imagine its easy to mess up slightly and ruin the whole thing

surreal stag
#

yea its alreadya mess when soemone spread thier entire dino deck over there board.......not me never done that.....5 times

leaden tide
lucid jewel
#

Ooooo

leaden tide
#

Did that spoiler correctly? Can't tell on mobile.

wanton hazel
#

don't think so, I can see it clearly by default

leaden tide
#

Ugh. Rip.

#

Here it is spoiled.

turbid falcon
#

Just signed up for pre release
So hype

wanton hazel
#

I'm going to play at one out of state, but that unfortunately means I can't participate in 3 the way I sometimes do

#

I might be able to do a second, not sure yet

lucid jewel
#

Uhh this seems a bit spooky

turbid falcon
#

Who would have guessed there was a dragon inside Spinerock Knoll

#

For the flavor win, get him out USING Spinerock Knoll

leaden tide
turbid falcon
#

Yes, lighting bolt

#

Weirdly it actually makes lighting bolt a ton better in commander

#

Normally it's kinda mid because of the average size and life total
But with a copy and wither suddenly it fulfils it's dual role of removal (or shrinking) and damage a lot better

leaden tide
#

Yeah. The idea is to load up on direct damage sources (even creature-only ones are good here, because Taii Wakeen draws me cards off of them), and modal spells like Abrade that can be either damage or other utility.

lucid jewel
#

Also just the stat line alone

#

A 6/6 for 5 is gooooood

turbid falcon
#

https://archidekt.com/decks/18761654/elemental_etbs_precon_upgrade
Well I think this is my pre-lorwyn pulls list, essentially focusing down on elementals with ETBS (and a few leaves the battlefield) to abuse Ashling, while still also having intrinsic value that doesn't require Ashling to function. Plus a small blink package for additional shenanigans

Archidekt

Ashling, the Limitless - Commander deck

(1) Commander • (1) Anthem • (1) Artifact • (13) Creature • (8) Draw • (4) Instant • (39) Land • (2) Landfall • (14) Ramp • (5) Recursion • (11) Removal • (1) Tokens
Precon deck but focused more on elementals, ETBs, and a few flicker effects

#

Oh and a fixed mana base

#

Also don't mind the weird categories I got the initial precon list with weird categories and I haven't really fixed it or properly followed jt

#

And yes I know Life of the party is kinda an odd add... But I think getting my opponents to make a bunch of goaded dudes to beat each other up with sounds hilarious so it's staying in

leaden tide
leaden tide
#

Hopefully you already have some of the pricy ones.

surreal stag
turbid falcon
#

I already bought a very expensive 5 color mana base once, and while I've use pieces of it for other decks that's what's fixing the deck lol

turbid falcon
#

I have no plans to ever buy such a mana base again LUL

surreal stag
#

I have no plans to ever buy such a mana base again a single card LUL

wanton hazel
#

I only really started playing in earnest this year, only really play limited in person, I've done a bit of commander but just much prefer limited

#

I played standard in Arena, would consider it in person if it was more active

turbid falcon
#

I picked up cheap copies of fetches and shocks as they got reprinted, and got a full set of triomes and several other good 5 color lands over the course of like, 3 years

#

I'm still missing a few shocks and fetches but it hasn't been an issue

#

Hm, I should go through and see exactly which ones I'm missing joeST

surreal stag
#

Yea a ton just got reprinted so hopefully it’s those

tepid stirrup
#

So I did already put this up in the Warframe channel, as this could reasonably go into either Warframe, general gaming, FFXIV, or here LUL

#

I'm putting this here as a cautionary tale

#

This is a woman's descent into madness

#

She wants one card in particular. She spends eight hours and goes through six boxes looking for that one card

#

(She was also laying aside cards for friends and family, so it isn't all tragedy)

#

Moral of the story: buy singles

tepid stirrup
#

I should also say this is full of the kind of incidental Final Fantasy spoilers you get from interacting with Final Fantasy via MTG

charred ruin
#

"Wow I didn't know there were FF14 cards in here! Maybe there will be more!"

#

(repeat every time she finds a different 14 card)

tepid stirrup
#

(The same card, White Auracite)

#

inb4 Warframe UB, 2027

charred ruin
#

Frick that one would get me

#

Also opening two Collector boxes and an entire play booster box and not getting that card is actually kinda insane

tepid stirrup
#

(Four play boosters)

charred ruin
#

oh right she's opening the box next

leaden tide
#

Buy. The Damn. Singles.

wanton hazel
#

I’ve opened about 45 final fantasy packs which is the first set I’ve been interested in collecting, and yeah it really doesn’t make sense to buy any more vs singles

#

Even that was just 3 prerelease events, 1 bundle, 4 scene boxes, and then some prize packs from the prereleases

#

(Though I would have bought a chocobundle if the price was right, demand was too high)

leaden tide
#

Yep. You reach saturation on commons and uncommons pretty quickly, so opening packs rapidly comes down to whether you pull a rare or mythic you don't already have. Which also becomes bad odds relatively quickly.

upper moon
#

See, for me I don't care as much about specific cards, and like building decks from what I've got.

#

Probably why I like draft so much LUL

leaden tide
#

Okay, first draft (still somewhat incomplete) of my new Boros Burn deck. I like the feeling of this a lot more than previous versions. But I feel like it's missing something.
https://archidekt.com/decks/18413765/boros_burn_v2

Archidekt

Taii Wakeen, Perfect Shot - Commander deck

(1) Commander • (8) Burn - Permanent • (8) Burn - Spell • (4) Draw • (7) Force Multiplier • (34) Land • (9) Modal Burn • (6) Protection • (10) Ramp • (4) Redirect • (2) Removal

#

Also I haven't been able to come up with a good name for it. All the sniper quotes I've come up with are either generic or not particularly applicable.

lethal isle
#

got to play a quick half hour of a commander match and got to play luminous moth and sun titan

#

very exciting

leaden tide
#

Sun Titan! The titans are such a cool cycle of creatures. Peak Magic design.

turbid falcon
#

...wow

#

I went into a turn expecting to kill one player with my shenanigans but underestimated just how insane Ojer Taq is

#

I had multiple effects on board that saw how many tokens I had already made at some point, then made an equal number
Ojer Taq then proceeded to triple that each time
That combined with a Mirkwood bats created a turn where I started with creating a clue and a citizen, and ended with somewhere around 130 ish damage on my end step

lucid jewel
#

Lorwyn card

#

We gonna be making so many goblins and elves in this set

leaden tide
#

The tribal stuff is fun, but honestly I'm most exited for two red combat tricks

lucid jewel
#

Which ones are they

leaden tide
#

These both fulfil very specific niches that I'm very interested in

tepid stirrup
#

More importantly, neither of them look like Monstrous Rage

lucid jewel
#

They both seem quite fair

#

But still good

#

More access to trample in mono red is nice

leaden tide
#

Trample and haste together are things I'm very interested in for my prowess deck, and cantripping is just icing on the cake. And then pump with ramp is also a very yummy combination.

leaden tide
#

We could have gotten a bit more Shadowmoor crunch/grit imo, but the weirdness is here on full display and I'm here for it

turbid falcon
#

If I pull them I think they'll slot nicely into my jeskai deck, though I'm probably not going to go out of my way to get them

leaden tide
#

I am gonna go out of my way to find them, but they shouldn't be too hard to get. My LGS opens a bunch of stuff for singles, and they just have a box of the commons/uncommons of the set on the counter. So if I don't pull them on pre-release, they should be in there.

#

Also unrelated, I've been re-organizing my Magic collection to merge it with some bulk commons/uncommons someone was giving away a few months ago.

#

And here's an interesting picture:

#

These are my basic lands, stuff I had before combined with what I got from this collection, in WUBRG order.

#

I have what's probably 60-100 more islands than swamps.

turbid falcon
#

That's probably more basic lands than I have I think

#

But I also have more than enough basics to run an entire draft, and build any decks I desire, so at that point shrug collect nice art I guess?

leaden tide
#

Yeah. I'm gonna downsize here at some point, once I have time to sort them by art. I'm only gonna keep a certain number of each art, probably like 6 or 8. Give the rest to my community or one of my LGSes

turbid falcon
#

Gotta say this elemental precon is kinda bonkers out of the box
Fix the mana base and it's basically value town
Then you do the upgrades I did to it, and now it's able to go toe to toe with my much more expensive and tuned decks
Plus it scratches my second favorite mtg itch: putting a gazillion triggers onto the stack

leaden tide
#

The precons have been hitting pretty hard lately, from what I understand.

#

Haven't had the chance to play around with the EoE ones, but they look powerful and fun

turbid falcon
#

I feel they've really mastered making them really good out of the box

#

I especially enjoyed that a bunch of cards scalpers were driving the prices up on were reprinted in the latest batch LUL

turbid falcon
#

Do NOT sleep on Twinflame travelers for your Ashling precons

#

This card is truly unhinged
With Ashling, it means any evoke you do, you're going to get 6 ETBs in total off of it

#

2 for the initial, then it copies ashlings trigger, so you get 2 tokens, each of which trigger twice
That is a truly unhinged amount of value

#

At that point, then you just evoke an "army in a bottle" type thing to make an army, then drop this bad boy

#

This guy is currently $.06

surreal stag
# lucid jewel

Acadamey Manufactor + this = new typal. Assembly worker

leaden tide
turbid falcon
#

I mean sure 6 instances of haste is a bit redundant but the army + +6/+6 out of literally nowhere ends games on the spot

surreal stag
#

IM GOING TO LE PRERELASE ON SUNDAY!!!!!!!!!!!!

leaden tide
#

Oooh exciting!

surreal stag
#

my first time playing paper magic. its my birthday weekend. this is about to be the best 3 day weekend of my life

#

Friday: Birthday with Wife and Boys, Saturday: chill day probs going to Target with the fam cuz were basic, Sunday: LE PRERELEASE, Monday: Day off gaming with friends & THE HOOSIERS WIN THE NATTY

turbid falcon
#

Pre release is fun

leaden tide
gloomy pagoda
#

Nah, it's been decades since they last printed Ante

wanton hazel
#

it's really the only paper magic I play, I've tried commander but it's just a little too much

turbid falcon
#

While I was moving out yesterday I discovered a whole bag of unsorted cards I didn't know I had

#

Maybe this is where a few cards I thought I had but then couldn't find ended up

#

Ah never mind

leaden tide
#

Oooh nice, we love finding surprise bonus cards.

#

Oh.

turbid falcon
#

Mostly lands and tokens

#

There were a few nice lands that can find some homes but really nothing too spicy beyond some more nice arts

upper moon
#

Having good looking lands is the most imporrtant part for your deck to be good though

surreal stag
#

Is it Sunday yet?

lucid jewel
#

Get that info in your brain for the limited environment

leaden tide
#

Good and interesting choices. And honestly, doesn't look horrible.

#

Stuff based on live-action properties is usually pretty uncanny valley when it comes to the actors faces, but Ella Purnell I guess just has a face that looks good as Magic art

tepid stirrup
#

I'm not really a UB purist but this feels like it crosses a Rubicon somehow LUL

leaden tide
#

That's not even the only time they do it LUL

charred ruin
fierce dragon
#

Those two feel very lazy ngl

lucid jewel
#

easly the most fun card ill play in this set

#

and im 100% buying the precon it comes in

leaden tide
#

That one is a real gem of design. Both mechanically and flavor-wise

lucid jewel
#

it just such a fun play pattern as well it creates so many fun situations

surreal stag
#

Okay chaos draft on tabletop sim is great

#

The mystery booster 2 packs are so fun

leaden tide
#

I did a MB2 draft back on Jan 3rd, got some great pulls.

#

Is a very cool environment.

turbid falcon
#

Im hoping this will finally give me an excuse to fulfill one of my bucket list goals
Goatnap a goat

#

My primary issues with this goal is that I currently don't own a Goatnap, and there aren't many goats worth Goatnaping

surreal stag
#

Goat nap and off nabd goat youd be a legend

#

but youd need a collector booster to have someone get the goat lol

turbid falcon
#

I already preordered the precon lol

surreal stag
#

hell yea

turbid falcon
#

Now I just need a goatnap

surreal stag
#

ive seen lots of them in my draft sim pools

wanton hazel
#

happy prerelease weekend to those who are attending, I'll be doing at least one today

#

don't know if I'll be able to do another this weekend

surreal stag
#

IS IT SUNDAY YET

turbid falcon
#

Finally, pre release time!

#

Well I say that but I'm gonna have to sit here and wait

lucid jewel
#

My lgs sold their entire game room out tonight

#

144 seats

turbid falcon
#

Mine has a wait-list LUL I'm glad I preordered

#

There is a LONG line

lucid jewel
#

Ours is 1st come 1st served and "when stocks run out we run out" managing by the 3rd or 4th go round they usually run out

#

So sometimes they dont do a sunday pre release cause they run out of stock

#

For pre release that is

#

For other product they have pre orders

turbid falcon
#

Alright ended up building kithkin, currently 1-0

#

The wither dragon walloped me on our second round though lol

#

Though my deck is being kind of hard carried by a ton of changelins

lucid jewel
#

The changlings go hard in this set

turbid falcon
#

Also dang, I pulled a hexing squelcher and chronicle of victory, looks like those basically made back my money on the prerelease

#

Though I imagine chronicle of victory might go down, hexing squelcher feels like the kind of card that will retain value

lucid jewel
#

It will

#

Its wanted in so many decks in multiple formats

turbid falcon
#

Yeah it's probably playable in everything back to legacy

#

Since there's nothing else that makes only your spells uncounterable

wanton hazel
#

Went 2-1 with Goblins, was a fun deck

leaden tide
turbid falcon
#

2-0 kithkin is kicking BUTT

#

Shout out to figure of fable who is an absolute house

#

Drop him turn 1, swing for 2 turn 2, 4 turn 3, and basically ends the game if I can get to 6 mana when he becomes essentially unremovable

leaden tide
#

-# I'm like 90% confident Figure of Fable is a she

turbid falcon
#

He she them IDC they ROCK

turbid falcon
#

...my opponent isn't showing up

#

I mean sure if they don't show up I basically just win but kinda lame

turbid falcon
#

Well guess I go 3-0 automatically, unfortunately other than meek attack my other prize packs were kinda duds but hey they were free

leaden tide
#

Free cardboard is always nice

#

Sad you didn't get a third match though

dense orchid
#

High Perfect Morcant in pack 1 was pretty nutty last night

leaden tide
#

Oh nice.

#

I'm going to my pre-release at noon today. Wish me luck!

fierce dragon
#

You don't need luck I know your skill will carry you sylheart

lucid jewel
#

Agreed glams gonna smash it

#

And also get some tmnt card in their pre release

leaden tide
#

Please no

wanton hazel
#

I didn’t hear anything about that happening where I played, I’m guessing it’s regional

lucid jewel
leaden tide
#

Welp. Opened a bunch of cool cards. Enough to make both a blue white merfolk deck and a green black elves deck.

#

And neither of them is working.

#

Storm me.

turbid falcon
#

Oof

leaden tide
#

People here don't like playing Jeskai I guess.

lucid jewel
#

wow

#

that is a lot of jeskai stock

leaden tide
#

It's incredibly satisfying to see all the Spider-Man rotting on the shelf though.

#

That's a $15 discount on the pre-release packs too.

lucid jewel
#

again wow that is a lot of packs

upper moon
#

Im kind of conflicted tbh. I feel bad for the lgs. But this is also the only way that wizards will stop pulling crap like that

leaden tide
#

Okay deck actually functioned on round three, so that's nice.

#

One more round.

#

This card puts in so much work.

lucid jewel
#

Constant card selection is sweet

#

And im assuming you have some graveyard matters cards

wanton hazel
#

Day 2 I tried a vivid Giants deck (Naya)

#

1-1 so far, only get prize support here at 2 wins so I guess I gotta go for it

#

The Elves deck looks good, I think I might hope to pull enough for it day 3

leaden tide
#

Anyways, went 2 and 2. Should have gone with elves in my first deck, but I was distracted by getting two rare merfolk.

#

The merfolk mechanics want you to tap them for additional ability benefits. But it didn't feel like the payoffs were there.

#

And so my distaste for Azorius continues.

#

Anyways. Here's my pulls for the night. First pic is my prerelease stuff, second is my prize pack pulls.

#

Good pulls overall. Though I would have loved to pull a dragon.

lucid jewel
#

bre and doran are nice

leaden tide
#

Yee, Bre is a fun card I might eventually build. And Doran is going in my Felothar deck until I scrounge up enough money for a Walls of Ba Sing Se

#

Might keep him too if he performs well.

#

I think what this set is gonna push me to do though is build a mono-green elfball I've been considering for a while.

#

Goal will be to not buy any cards, just throw whatever elves and elf-synergy cards I have in my collection together.

lucid jewel
#

Mono green elfball is gonna be so good with this set

#

Also its easly improvable over time

lucid jewel
#

im curious if elf ball will be a standard deck too

leaden tide
#

I'm also considering doing mono-white Soldiers, and mono-red Goblins.

#

Would be interesting to figure out mono-blue and mono-black creature types too

leaden tide
lucid jewel
#

100% it will have badgermole cub and probs oroboros

#

but then its not too diff to current decks

leaden tide
#

But also I just finished designing a boros deck. And two of my existing decks are 3-colors including boros. And I have ideas for two more 3-colors with boros....I think I might have too much boros

#

But...I could use the lifegain stuff to cascade into some chonky angels, potentially.

leaden tide
#

I'll probably build it at some point. But it's going low on the priority queue

sleek valley
#

Pretty happy with how this one turned out despite only going 2-1. I'm a little disappointed that I never got to cast any of the rares, though. Bre especially seems like they would have been very good to cast here.

#

I also think it's wild how bad these are warping after only a few hours out of the pack, even the non-foils.

dense orchid
#

How bad is the Pringle-ing?

sleek valley
#

It isn't even pringling, really. They would at least be warping in the same direction in that case. Here's a pile of 6 face up non-foils.

leaden tide
#

From what I saw yesterday, that's difficult to pull off in this limited environment. The cards want you to build two-color, even if you don't follow one of the typal pairs.

wanton hazel
#

I tried 3-color vivid yesterday and it didn't go great, but I'm glad I tried it

#

had fun, won some games, my two losing rounds were 2-1

#

point is mostly just agreeing that 2 color is the way to go if prize support depends on wins

rare sparrow
#

i think the way to play into vivid is mostly going to involve playing 2 color and picking up lots of hybrid creatures

#

even in draft

#

although obviously when you have more control over picking up mana fixing etc. in draft going 3+ colors should be easier

#

i went mostly 2 color in prerelease yesterday (UR splashing two black removal spells) and went undefeated (albeit with one draw)

surreal stag
#

I’ll be happy as long as I can play anything but big spell elementals

#

I would t know how to pilot that thing

#

Just give me Golgari elves please mtg gods

wanton hazel
#

They seem pretty strong

lucid jewel
wanton hazel
#

I feel like the prerelease packs tend to offer enough cards that you usually have a couple viable options, but going in trying to make the best available deck of a specific archetype doesn’t always work

surreal stag
#

Oh I know I’ve been looking at random pools online to help start grasping what I can make work with whatever I get

leaden tide
#

The elves just have good synergy. As an archetype they also don't mind being in your graveyard, which is great for how grindy the set/format is. Means you're not afraid to throw your elves at your opponent's blockers to try and break a stalemate.

surreal stag
#

Time to shower. The cycle stops here

surreal stag
#

Yea lol it was an “oops”

surreal stag
lucid jewel
leaden tide
turbid falcon
#

Figure of fable is so peak

#

Won me multiple games

#

If they can't remove it, it will win you the game

lucid jewel
#

love those kinda "level up" creatures

#

they are almost always super good at all stages of the game

turbid falcon
#

Plus I found it meant I could hold onto a ton of gas in prerelease, and instead sink mana into figure of fable

#

The coolest thing was when I used Brigid's command to copy it LUL

surreal stag
#

im 1-0 in WG

lucid jewel
#

i had a feeeling WG would be good with your list

#

looked bannger dense in those colours

surreal stag
#

1-1 ran out of gas

lucid jewel
#

you can do the 3rd i belif

wanton hazel
#

Day 3: Built a Kithkin deck with 15 minutes to spare in deckbuilding,so I assembled a Faeries deck as well. I thought the Kithkin deck was better but the Faeries deck win every game and the Kithkin deck lost every game so clearly I’m bad at judging these things

#

I think my Kithkin build was just too weak on turn 2, the way it went

surreal stag
leaden tide
#

Okay so if I do make a green elfball deck, I have the following as Commander options:

#

Dionus is probably the best option. Yeva would be the funniest, because she's the least elf-synergy of them. But also could be very dangerous.

#

I'll probably run all 5 of them in the deck, so maybe I'll just run a different one of them every time I break it out.

lucid jewel
#

Dionus requires lots of extra tracking

#

Im leaning towards yeva or ezuri

leaden tide
#

Ezuri is probably the most consistent win-con, so the least likely to lead to durdling.

#

On the other hand, Dionus makes the elfball go turbo-brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

lucid jewel
#

untapping elves is just so much power

leaden tide
#

And obviously I'll be running the lesbian Llanowar Elves

tepid stirrup
#

Isn't that other woman her uh

#

Mom?

leaden tide
#

Is she?

#

idk, is there lore out there about this art somewhere?

tepid stirrup
#

It read like a multigenerational thing to me

rare sparrow
#

i had never seen this art before now but looking at the art it also reads to me as baby, mom, and grandma

#

here's the only comment i can find from the artist about it, which doesn't say anything about anyone other than the mother and child:

#

"Another fun piece for MTG. I enjoyed the challenge of trying to make a tender moment between mother and child. I tried to imagine what sweet song she's singing that calms the baby and also causes flowers to bloom. Some Adele? Wu Tang most likely for you, see Wu Tang is for the children. Big thanks to art director Zack Stella.”

charred ruin
#

I do like the art a lot better than the more classic ones like this

slender moss
#

Nothing will beat lesbian Heartbeat of Spring

leaden tide
leaden tide
charred ruin
#

Some old Magic art is cool or at least has charm. This one uhhhhhh

leaden tide
#

We can firmly file that in the "so bad it almost wraps around to being good again" folder

tepid stirrup
#

Llanowar Elves commonly makes me think of Brian Kibler joking about getting a lifetime achievement award for how many times he's turn 1 cast Llanowar Elves over the years

#

Gotta be thousands or tens of thousands of games LUL

slender moss
leaden tide
#

Pshhh, that's not lesbian, that's just gaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyyyy peter

#

While we're at it, let's not forget some of our trans icons.

slender moss
charred ruin
#

That second one is Alesha

slender moss
#

Is it? I thought it was just a generic Mardu warrior

leaden tide
#

Nope, it's her. Same armor, originally from the same set

charred ruin
#

Also fantastic card and I keep trying to make a Commander deck with her work

leaden tide
#

The runemark behind her also kinda looks trans colors for the foil version.

slender moss
#

Regardless,

#

Speaking of which, this one hasn't been mentioned yet

surreal stag
#

I went 1-2, 2-1, 2-1. Opened a foil Emptiness (not showcase) in one of my prize packs

leaden tide
#

Niceeeeee

surreal stag
#

I was able to trade around for Shadowmore Full Art lands for the complete set and I traded the Blood Cyrpt I opened for a Tomb cuz my Golgari heart needed it

gloomy pagoda
surreal stag
#

Coolest cards in the two little decks I was able to build

leaden tide
#

Oooh nice, the alt art on Kinbinding is cool. The showcase treatment for this set just looks cool in general.

#

And Emptiness is so pretty

charred ruin
#

Ugh I'm gonna have to buy some of this set

#

And probably see if I can join a prerelease or draft but I don't stay up late in the evening and my weekends are often busy

leaden tide
#

It's got some good stuff. The typal themes means the limited environment might not be for everyone. But it's got some good card designs outside of that.

charred ruin
#

I love typal themes

leaden tide
leaden tide
#

Kithkin and Elves seem to be the strongest two, in my limited experience

charred ruin
#

I'm quite happy with that

#

Glad to see some good Kithkin since I like a bunch of their old Lorwyn-Shadowmoor cards but they've been powercrept to oblivion

#

And Goblins, Merfolk, and Elves are always fun to see more cards for

lucid jewel
#

Don't sleep on changelings in all of this as well, also hybrid mana helping with vivid

leaden tide
#

Changelings are (as expected) a very good glue to fill in the gaps of whatever type you're running. They've got some cards that are just generic good beaters.

wanton hazel
#

My LGS did a 3 prize packs for everyone this time around to thank their community for their growth, which was cool. But it also led them to selling like 45 tickets, running out of prerelease kits on Friday and just having us crack packs for the Sunday event

leaden tide
#

TBh that might have been for the best, less chance of running into some stray turtles

wanton hazel
#

funny you say that

surreal stag
wanton hazel
#

they gave us a sealed 'promo pack' on top of it and let us use it

#

most of us got Aetherdrift cards

surreal stag
#

Hahaha nice

#

We got NOTHING but it was still fun

wanton hazel
#

I don't think anyone actually used them but mine was a Goblin so I could have considered it

surreal stag
#

I eventually cut the blue splash for a spy and mighty and I drew two cards each time I played it got the 4 power on the swing. Not bad

leaden tide
#

Not surprising. Some people at my LGS made three color work, but it's hard

surreal stag
#

Yea you needed some strong color fixing. One evolving wilds was not enough

#

And the dork I had just sat there and blocked every turn. Meh

wanton hazel
#

I tried going straight-up three color in my second prerelease and I won one round, and lost 1-2 in the other two rounds

surreal stag
#

I’m 100% going to The Hobbit prerelease but I don’t think I can get out of the house for 6 hours for more than one other set this year

wanton hazel
#

that's fair, you could always play sealed in Magic Arena at your own pace

surreal stag
#

Yea for sure I’m all about getting that new game experience online

#

And of course playing new stuff in commander online for free

wanton hazel
#

I don't think I'm gonna skip Turtles entirely but that's probably a 'play once' set rather than a 'play all three' set

leaden tide
leaden tide
lucid jewel
leaden tide
#

Star Trek is a maybe, it's gonna have to work hard convince me.

lucid jewel
#

It will probs be around my birthday too

wanton hazel
#

Marvel's the other clear 'play once' set for me, and probably Star Trek too, though I could imagine playing ST more than once

leaden tide
#

Hobbit is a probably, I'll do it unless it's a small and mechanically thin set.

lucid jewel
#

Ppl I think are also sleeping on strix

leaden tide
#

Return to Strixhaven and Reality Fracture are "gonna have to convince me to not go" sets.

#

Aka unless the previews are bad, I'm gonna go.

wanton hazel
#

for me it's like, at my LGS, the prereleases always fire but the drafts usually don't, so if I want to play limited it's usually the prerelease, so I don't really like to skip the opportunity

#

everyone always just wants to play commander and I kinda don't

leaden tide
#

For me, it just boils down to the meta-flavor of the cards.

#

I'm just not interested in turning a slice of pizza sideways to cast some turtles from the fantastical realm of New York.

tepid stirrup
#

Turning the nastiest slice of pizza devised my man or turtle kind you mean

leaden tide
#

While the Turtles set doesn't seem as bad as Spider-Man in regard, it's still just not my cup of tea. Even if the mechanics are cool, I'm a Vorthos at heart and I need my Magic to be both Magical and something I actively like the flavor of.

leaden tide
#

Though, tbh, if they were't so nasty looking, I'd probably slip one of them into one of my (eventual) Earthbending decks.

#

Because beating the crap out of an opponent with an 8/8 trampling pizza slice is objectively hilarious

surreal stag
wanton hazel
#

I don't think that angle bothered me, I'm not even a huge spider-man fan but I watched the Spider-Verse movies and like four of the live-action spider-man movies, and that's about it, but that set didn't bother me too much? I didn't have a good experience playing it, but I wonder if it's because I didn't do so much research and I'm not that great at deckbuilding strictly on my own

surreal stag
tepid stirrup
#

I go in and out of MTG on a several-year-long cycle and I'm out right now and while UB isn't really the cause I probably will be until UB stabilizes its relationship with Magic or consumes it (in the latter case I'm probably just out out)

leaden tide
wanton hazel
#

I don't think I've consumed a ninja turtle product in 20 years, I remember playing a couple ancient video games, I think some sort of handheld one? And I know I watched some cartoon in the 90s

leaden tide
surreal stag
#

Yea hard pass on the turtles

wanton hazel
#

I think if I skip any set outright this year it'd be the turtles, it's just so soon after this one

tepid stirrup
leaden tide
#

Yeah. Which is pretty depressing.

surreal stag
#

Yea might be a rough go on arena. But at least I’ll see the stupid fake copies

leaden tide
#

Not for Turtles, Wizards actually managed to get the digital rights for that.

surreal stag
#

Ewwwwwwwwwww

tepid stirrup
#

I'm probably more forgiving on UB choices than you are but for me the concerning line is UB coming at the expense of UW

surreal stag
#

Oh well

leaden tide
#

It's only Marvel that has that particular issue, with Marvel Snap having exclusive digital card game rights.

wanton hazel
#

yeah the Arena UWs are entirely a Marvel thing

leaden tide
tepid stirrup
leaden tide
#

And that's the soft version of my crossover stance.

#

-# iykyk

surreal stag
tepid stirrup
#

They are, its a bad set, but the Spider-man art choices are also just bafflingly bad

surreal stag
#

glad I missed that one

tepid stirrup
#

The Arena set at least managed to have some bangers in it

#

Artistically

surreal stag
#

I do have regrets that I love my Toph/Bumi deck so much given the Toph art has a problematic artist

tepid stirrup
surreal stag
#

I wish I didn’t find landfall boring AF I love hearthhull

leaden tide
#

Ope didn't mean to hit enter yet

#

Wanted to specifically shout out this art as well.

leaden tide
#

I like the art of Lorwyn Eclipsed a lot, but EoE still looks better imo

#

It's just that good

surreal stag
#

The LE art is so peak. One of the top reasons I went to a prerelease

#

It’s so my jam

tepid stirrup
#

I'm not a huge fan of the Jim Henson thing

surreal stag
#

Yea that was…..rough

tepid stirrup
#

They cooked, don't get me wrong, but its just not a style I like

leaden tide
#

While I liked the visuals, the...tone of it was real weird.

surreal stag
#

Being a muppets fan boy it wasn’t so bad but yea idk still off

tepid stirrup
#

Astelli Reclaimer might be my all time favorite single card, and I'm a total sucker for space whales

leaden tide
#

Astelli Reclaimer is my playmat, she's sooooo pretty

#

These ones also do it for me. And I could post at least a dozen more too

lucid jewel
#

Cant forget these elves when talking trans magic cards

#

Also same artist for the new one as Elsh norn

leaden tide
#

Hmm, they do kinda have that classic MtF body type too...

lucid jewel
#

What precon should I pick up next

#

Im undecided between the new -1/-1 counters or abzan armour

#

Cause putting doran and the wall of ba sing se into abzan armour sounds sweet but so does -1/-1 counters

dense orchid
#

My roommate has had so much fun with the Abzan deck

tepid stirrup
#

This is interesting:

rare sparrow
#

weird, because i have seen some streamers/youtubers get 2nd pick "power 11" cards in arena cube

#

i wonder what people are taking over a mox

dense orchid
#

This clearly means Sol Ring should get banned in commander. Or at least become a game changer

tepid stirrup
#

That is the joke, isn't it LUL

#

They've openly discussed it before, it isn't going anywhere

rare sparrow
#

it is kind of a joke to me that it isn't banned or a game changer, but i also accept that it won't change

tepid stirrup
#

In no small part because way too many precons have a Sol Ring with bespoke art in it I'm sure

#

Is the mass proliferation of Sol Ring bad for Commander? I dunno, I tend to think its kind of a wash and leans a little bad, but I also think its a genie far too long gone to track down and stuff back in the bottle

dense orchid
#

I mean, not all the power 9 are banned (looking at you Timetwister). But Sol Ring really should become a game changer

lucid jewel
#

We are way past putting the soul ring back in the box

#

Its here to stay

rare sparrow
#

yeah, it's something i can be disappointed on, but it's not the hill to die on if you are arguing about banning something and want to die on a hill. like, i think sol ring is clearly a more powerful card than rhystic study, but i'd much rather argue to ban rhystic study than sol ring

#

because no one will seriously consider banning sol ring

lucid jewel
#

Sol ring shouldn't be a game changer imo because it dosent change the game

rare sparrow
#

it's more powerful than other fast mana that are game changers

tepid stirrup
rare sparrow
#

if you mean "it's not a game changer because the game doesn't change when you include it in your deck because it's in 100% of decks" i'm not on board with that argument

#

plenty of people don't like how it changes the game and either refuse to put it in their decks or only play it because they feel like they have to

tepid stirrup
rare sparrow
#

i forget the exact numbers, but edhrecast did a data episode recently where they discussed data from all the games they played in 2025, and something like 60%+ of players in their games who played a t1 sol ring won the game

#

absurdly swingy for a 4 player format

tepid stirrup
rare sparrow
#

and presumably that's 60% despite having a huge target on their back from the first turn of the game

leaden tide
leaden tide
lucid jewel
leaden tide
#

Exactly

tepid stirrup
#

"Power Nine" sounds punchier than "Power Eleven" though

leaden tide
#

Also a good chunk of the ban list in Commander is for accessibility reasons, not power reasons.

tepid stirrup
#

Something very funny about seeing eight artifacts and three blue cards though LUL

leaden tide
#

Sol Ring has been reprinted into the dirt and back, you're only paying more than $2 for a copy if you want a super special edition. It's plenty accessible.

leaden tide
leaden tide
#

And honestly, I find myself not running it a bunch.

#

In my spellslinger deck, a lot of spells only have 1 colorless mana cost at most, and I also have a couple cost-reducers anyways.

#

My decks with green, I prefer other types of ramp.

#

It can lead to some explosive early turns in some decks, but that's just a fun way to engage with the format imo. Give some spicy variance to games.

tepid stirrup
#

I do feel like its pretty easy game changer territory

#

And if we're doing this more granular system for evaluating cards, why not?

lucid jewel
#

I think if commander was less social and more competative as its primary driving force then things like banning or making sol ring a game changer makes sense

#

But as it stands the primary driving force of commander is social, casual, creative

leaden tide
#

Yeah. As for why it's a not a game-changer, that one...it's just been printed too much.

#

Game-changers aren't in every precon

#

Also I looked up Mana Crypt and Jeweled Lotus prices over recent years, and this is hilarious

#

Both had massive spikes up to their pre-ban prices when the bracket system was announced, and when the first update for it was published a couple months later. Because the finance bros thought they'd get put on game-changer status 🤣

#

But yeah, this imo is why Crypt and Jeweled Lotus needed to go, and why Sol Ring is fine.

lucid jewel
#

That looks like some speculative asset bs being applied to our cardboard crack game

#

Smh

tepid stirrup
#

I don't think availability is the only consideration to be fair

tepid stirrup
leaden tide
#

No it's not. But it is a useful consideration imo.

wanton hazel
#

I imagine the #1 reason to hesitate is the fact that it's in so many precons, they probably don't want people to hesitate about playing their products unaltered at lower brackets, and calling a commonly included card a game changer would just complicate that discussion

#

'your 2025 precon is now Bracket 3, enjoy playing against upgraded decks', that sort of thing

#

it's an idea to be seriously considered, and if it seems to be necessary for the long-term health of the game, maybe you do it anyway, but I think it's probably correct to consider it carefully and not be too hasty

lucid jewel
#

The sleevs look so good

turbid falcon
#

Regarding sol ring in commander I tend to agree with the idea that frankly sol ring by itself is not an issue

#

Does it accelerate early game? Sure, but it's also well within the abilities of a 4 player pod to deal with that acceleration

#

But as soon as you start upping that consistency of powerful mana acceleration then it becomes an issue

turbid falcon
#

And it's used as a promo art card basically all the time

#

Locking it out of lower powered decks as the singular positive mana rock allowed feels like it backfire far harder than just people self regulating it if they don't think it's fair

#

I've just never found it to be an issue in games I play

wanton hazel
#

salt time, I bought a Lorwyn bundle, the bundles usually come with one copy of all three land cards regular, and one copy of all three in foil, but for Lorwyn, it was just one copy of one of them, and two copies of a second land

#

I thought they were just being lazy and only made two lands for the set, but no, in my packs I'd find a third for a few colors

#

anyway I have 32 packs worth of cards so I'm trying to figure out how many decks to try to build with them for 'kitchen table' purposes

lucid jewel
#

This is interesting I didnt know all of this stuff about the stamp

#

Like I was curious about them removing it this set but it makes sense

surreal stag
rare sparrow
#

re: giant prereleases that he talks about, it was weird playing lorwyn eclipsed prerelease in a store, because when i played original lorwyn prerelease ages ago, it was in a convention center

#

mentally comparing the two felt very strange

lucid jewel
#

Especially with the recent support

#

I think its much more "ethical" and will have less hate directed at me than the -1/-1 counters deck

surreal stag
#

Yea the blight deck is just a grind you into the ground while I get all the value in the world lol

#

I’d have it done and ready to play but Slimefoot & Squee continues to be a problem child

leaden tide
#

Like, toughness matters is probably the predominant theme, but it also has life-gain and +1/+1 cards that you can either replace/spin out into other decks, or expand upon for a more balanced strategy.

lucid jewel
#

Oh nice that will be great then

#

Cause -1/-1 counts only really has support for that

leaden tide
#

Yeah. I decided to go all-in on the toughness matters, but you can do a lot with the deck as a base.

#

Haven't had a chance to play that version of the deck quite yet, waiting for a couple last cards to arrive in the mail.

lucid jewel
#

Can you show me the version your shifting to

leaden tide
#

I currently don't have Walls of Ba Sing Se, will be using the new Doran instead for now.

lucid jewel
#

only an hour to go untill i can open lorwyn packs on mtga

#

hype

lucid jewel
#

or is this your version of what toughness matters could do

#

also do you have that version of betor cause it looks so good

leaden tide
#

But yeah this is me going all-in on the thoughness matters.

leaden tide
lucid jewel
#

i also think i might use someone like doran or betor as the commander rather than felothar

leaden tide
#

Great Forest Druid is a good common to keep an eye open for in Lorwyn.

lucid jewel
#

is that the 0/4 mana dork?

leaden tide
lucid jewel
#

lol it updates live as i have the page open

#

thats cool

leaden tide
#

Oh that's fun.

lucid jewel
#

even has a "notification" of sorts

leaden tide
#

Interesting

#

Anyways yeah, there's a couple more expensive upgrades you can easily skip (Walls of Ba Sing Se, Birds of Paradise, the shock lands, etc)

lucid jewel
#

oh yeah not getting shock lands for a bit i do however think i have a bop somewhere

#

ill also look around at what others are doing to upgrade it after i buy it

#

and have played it a few times to get a vibe for what i want

leaden tide
#

Anyways I was organizing my basic lands last night and uh.

#

I'd forgotten about this one

lucid jewel
#

whats special about that island

surreal stag
lucid jewel
#

once the patch is live you can open packs

wanton hazel
#

yeah sometimes there are delays and it doesn't go live right at the expected time

lucid jewel
wanton hazel
#

I wonder how much I'd have to pay to get a reasonable standard deck, like 20 rare wildcards are 50 bucks

lucid jewel
#

Not much really because you get plenty from just opening packs

#

If you wanted to just raw buy wild cards sure it will be quite expensive

surreal stag
#

GOT A SECOND AJANI!

#

sorry casps

#

got my packs lol

#

full art bitter blossom!

lucid jewel
#

1st deck im trying is elf ball

#

i also had 3 green quests so it was fated

surreal stag
#

nice

wanton hazel
#

huh, Arena has faction sealed pools?

lucid jewel
#

did it for avatar as well