#📚lore-discussion
1 messages · Page 188 of 1
In the loretab I just send the Ahamkara in question took the form of an elderly man for the poker game
Awoken marriage is like a harem anime. Do with that information what you will
Umm what
Idk what that means so
Ignorance is bliss
:D
Multiple partners
Yea
I mean
It makes sense ig
Awoken be like that
Is Mara sov single
That’s the real question
Sjur Eido was female right?
Yes
Yes
Or rather that was her bow
Her statue in the shattered throne
No
How’d she die
She fell in the reef wars no?
What exactly is shattered throne, who is dul incaru, and why is there a sjur eido statue there
Or I guess it’s more like a shrine
Mara Sov is bald
She died in the reef wars. But it is unknown who was the killer
It's maras throne world
As the name "shattered throne" implies
And dul incaru is a daughter of savathun
Oh?
So did savathun/dul Incaru place the curse on the dreaming city or did riven
It was Savathuns design
She came up with the plot to curse the dreaming city
And I think she worked with Riven to create said curse
Bruh she’s a schemer
shes the God of trickery and desception for a reason
Yes
So why exactly would riven want to put a curse on the dreaming city
Cause didn’t she help make the city
With Mara
Riven is an Ahamkara
Granting wishes and putting funky little spins on them is basically their food
Remember Mara essentialyl imprisoned Riven and build a device that would make wishes without these side effects
The Wish Wall you can find and (ingame) use to teleport yourself to specific encounters
so Poly?
does that mean Mara have several partners?
at oncee
Yes
Mara doesn't have any partners though
So basically Mara imprisoned Riven and made her the wish generator so riven got revenge by building the curse with savathun
Essentially
ye
Who sent Keith to kill Eris huh
More likely
The sundered doctrine warlock robes have cool lore about Keith
Yeah, I saw but who sent her to kill Eris tho, or it couldve been wrong place and time
Probably the latter
It could also be some plot by the remaining leadership of the Witness forces but I dont see why the Psion whos name I forgot would want Eris dead
It does seem weird that she killed Eris and not drifter even though she could’ve easily killed them both, probably drifter’s ghost also
Drifter is a lightbearer yeah
What’s his ghost’s name?
Much harder to kill one of those than Eris
Doesnt have one
He never named it
Cold
I think it was just for the plot and the reveal of Eris throne world tho
Remember him and his Ghost never really had a good relationship
Drifter resented being a lightbearer for a long long time
I dont think you can anywhere really
Nezzy stuff is rather cryptic and scarce
No detailed origin story like Rhulk who got a whole ass lorebook
Shattered Suns or what it was called
Havent gotten around to read it yet
Oh it’s so good
We know that hes been messing with humanities dreams since even before the golden age
There’s all the psion worship & stuff
We know that Savathun killed him during the collapse and cursed his remains
The Pryamid on the moon also housed many of his artifacts and also inherited his power which is why the Nightmares came to exist there
He wasnt even properly alive for 90% of the raid
He spends the entire time up until final encounter slowly resurrecting and only breaks out of his "coccoon" as we get there to fight him
Mmm so is the first encounter the same area as the last
The Pyramids were generating them. The Europa one can too. Without a Pyramid on hand, it's possible he couldn't. Or, maybe it's because he was a corpse for 90% of the Raid.
Exactly
His nightmare shit seems to be mostly passive anyway
Just a side effect of his existence
Did Rhulks pyramid house a veiled statue?
Possibly
Cause we basically see them in all pyramids expect his pyramid
We haven't seen it, but it's quite possible.
I mean cmon
Rhulk who has a whole museum and he is a Witness rider
Not housing a veiled statue
Theres probably one sitting in some corner but its not really relevant or needed cause well its Rhulks pyramid
He saw a shit ton of them anyway
Why keep one when hes got all those other treasures to put on display
It's also possible that, as a manned Pyramid, it did not need a Veiled Statue to help control it.
Rhulk was its master already.
That too
Well, there was Essence.
Witness pyramid yeah
the Witness most likely had the coolest pyramid
Makes sense
Btw Savathun never got her own pyramid right?
She did not, but she didn't quite make it to DIsciplehood before her betrayal.
Yeah
Imagine if Rhulk managed to use The Upended to shatter her throne world
Not a big loss ngl
Was essence the RoN ship?
Yep
Yes
Aye. The Witness's Pyramid.
How so
Is it the same leviathan that the cabal mention and calus built his ship after?
What is it?
No.
Understandable confusion though as there are a number of things called Leviathan
The Leviathan was basically a proto worm god that acted as a disciple for the arrival of the Traveler on Fundament
So, the Fundament Leviathan was a creature that lived within the seas of Fundament, acting as the jailor of the Worm Gods. It was... vaguely described at best.
The Leviathan, the ship, was designed after a totally unrelated, sand whale/worm creature from Torobatl.
We do not know it was a proto-Worm like Ahsa. In fact, the little description we do have is decidedly unlike Ahsa.
Asa is from fundament too is she not?
Yes
Yes
Is it possible theyre of a similar species?
It's possible.
And the Leviathan loomed over them, its brow as huge all the continents of their childhood, its great array-fins crackling with the lightning of its life. Booming into the hull of the needle ship in a microwave voice:
Unfortunately, this is about all we know of the Leviathan's description.
That said, it does not sound akin to Ahsa.
Baby Leviathan :)
As a being capable of imprisoning 6 Worm Gods, I would expect the Leviathan was not a Proto-Worm, elsewise 6 Worm Gods would likely overpower it.
They being of a more vicious, dangerous, empowered form.
A ship from an unknown alien culture. Fundament's continents were not naturally formed, but the shattered remains of planets shattered and scattered across its form.
The Needle Ship was... likely just a remnant.
Did the Worm gods come to be naturally btw? Or were they engineered and placed there by the Witness
That is unclear
Fundament itself…is? What, like, time before time?
The Witness only made them even worse
Gas Giant.
I c
So
Was The Traveler placed on precursor planet by someone or was it there since the beginning
Unknown afaik
That is as far back as our history goes. We can't say why it was there.
That’s the DEEP end of the lore
We need more lore about The Traveler
Yeah
So it might just have taken the time to sit down and rest
We need more of Traveler lore
Its insane how the precursors found both the Veil and The Travaler
Idk why
But I feel like it was not by accident
Considering its believed that the Veil was a part of the Traveler it might have "shed" that part not too far away from the precoursor planet
Doesn’t the traveller thrive in inaction? It likes to see things play out and not have a hand in things?
Maybe The Winnower had some influence
The Traveler refrains from directly interfering
But its mere existence lets life appear so not directly
Well, not exactly. It is a gardener. It cultivates planets, helps civilisations have room to grow, but doesn't have direct influence over their decisions.
Yea that’s a better wording. Basically what I mean yea. It wants to watch and study really.
Not influence
See the Traveler wouldnt walk up and tell you how to make a sandwich
It would simply give you the ingerdients to make one and let you figure out therest
If you fuck up thats fine
It doesnt judge you
And doesn’t it do so in severely easily misenterpreted clues ?
The Traveler spoke four terms to Humanity.
The Traveler is a sentient being with free will, dreams, hopes, and fears.
The Traveler will save us.
The Traveler will leave us.```
It simply terraformed. Gave us wonders. The only misinterpretation came from it warning Clovis to cease his actions.
Imma stop it from leaving. We’ve slain gods, you’re next traveller. Dont test me
One day, in the distant future. Once Sol is settled, and the Traveler has healed, and changed, and come to terms with its new form.
I expect so.
But... not for a long time.
We dont even really need the traveler anymore
Light has no "range" so we'd even keep our powers
Need as in have it sit in orbit
Imagine Zavala getting mad and says "Lets use The Veil"
They didnt want "more" they wanted "purpose"
A reason to exist but the Traveler could not grant them an answer
The Veil no longer exists physically I believe
It was reintegrated with the Traveler back in FS
Huh

I was like
Just the link was established
So, when we destroyed all the statues freeing all the beings from the witness, were we killing them, or freeing them from the witness?
Freeing
Both, really.
death is freedom for them no?
"I..I dont understand"
We killed them, but they were of the Witness. Even as dissenters, they were it.
Kind of like a Vex. Many radiolaria make up a unit.
Bro was in denial
Yea the concept that we turned his internals against him always kinda confused me a little
Like, the room the statues were in, where in existence was that?
To continue the comparison, even Vex are like this. Not every radiolaria agrees, they are no pure hive mind.
It wasn't a physical realm, exactly. It was essentially a Mindscape.
Proof of that is the diff sub family’s of vex too
I still want to understand who or what created the Veil and the Traveler and for what purpose
They werent always like that keep that in mind
They were all individual people once
They just fused together
(Witness, not Vex)
Oh no I’m glad he said that
Maya Sundaresh did the same
Vex are literally idk
Microorganisms
More than that
can someone help me with this mission?
No. This is a lore channel.
Ever Vex you killed were hundreds if not millions of "people"
where should i post it
;lfg
Looking for more players?
Check out #looking-for-group for links to our LFG channels, and further resources including:
• Fireteam Finder (in-game LFG, available in the Roster tab or when launching an activity)
• Destiny 2 LFG Discord
• Final Shape LFG Discord (Requires TFS DLC)
• D2Checkpoint
• Bungie Fireteam Search
• Reddit's r/Fireteam
• Reddit's r/DestinySherpa
#❓destiny-questions
Inspect your Ghost. If it is any Shell bar the very first, you can just put a mod in. Shaxx sells one.
I always forget about ghost mods. Lmao
Every individual particle of radiolaria is sorta its own thing
Acting together they can reform, think and act
Imagine it like a shit ton of ants coordinating
Except all these ants are liquid and control a robot frame
i dont have shell just normal one and where is shaxx
Vex are prob the hardest to understand in terms of lore tbh
Tower Courtyard. The Crucible vendor.
They are so unique so complicated
okay thanks
They are rather complicated indeed
And we havent even factored in how they see time completely different than us
They even saw a future of our guardian being dead
They prob knew we are gonna defeat The Witness
We’ve not even gotten enough info on them to figure out answers we all ask questions about them for. It’s all speculation based with lore
Same kinda goes for the Traveler too
For a lot
They start a ton of good stories and then leave us hanging
thank you man a lot i just ranked up
They see all possible futures
Infinite ones in which we win, infinite ones in which we lose
I can’t wait to see xivu again
Knowing which is the right one is impossible for them because they cant accurately simulate the light
Yeah
Again? We have never seen her lmao
Seen her as in, not a literal appearance
When that was the best moment to reveal her
But just story content bout them
We haven’t seen xivu in any cutscene? I swear we’ve seen her
The fact that she didnt show up in person shows shes still scared as shit of dying
We saw her in cutscenes
At least two
Only in the drawn cutscenes
No ingame model exists yet
I mean
She might the hive god of war
But she is fr scared to show up in battle
Hive god of war without a throne world
Proving that she is indeed a coward
Shes mortal now and thus scared of death
Zavala who literally went to defeat the Witness knowing that might be the last of his
The new question now, I wanna know, and it’ll be revealed hopefully in this episode, is where tf did Eris end up? Her own throne world? Did she steal crota/oryx’s (idk which or how it all works)
You see unlike Xivu Zavala is a fucking baller
Bald*
We dont know but the leading theory is that shes in her own throne world now
When u realize
But we dont know for sure yet
Zavala couldve done what ever titan does in this game
I assumed this too. She’s always had some hive curse so, why wouldn’t she have her own throne world
Little did we know he’s just so powerful with it, he took a vow to never use it as to not embarrass Saladin
He prob did but we havent seen him in action with it
Solar Titans are kinda rare if you look at the lore
The only group that got good with it were the Sunbreakers and they dipped the Last City after six fronts
Thats because they mainly use arc
What
What
wdym the whole point of the Sunbreakers were that they specialized in Solar
theyre the Sunbreakers
I was talking abt titans in general
There is no such thing as a default subclass
Void and Arc are more common because those who teach it remain in the last city making it very available for new guardians to learn
Titans dont wake up and only know how to use arc
They dont know how to use anything they gotta learn it all from scratch
If a Titan hung out too long with Hunters they might even learn Golden Gun
Nothing is stopping them
Yeah
me when warlock doing ground slams with the synaptic spear
I was talking in general that Titan prefer to learn arc
Id argue they'd prefer Void because Bubble alligns closest with the general beliefs of the Titan order
I still think Void is for Warlock
your a BULWARK
The Titan creed is very focused on protection of the lightless, thats why they were the heroes of six fronts
So it makes sense for the defensively sided ability to be preferred
Yeah
titan protec
Average titan
bruh
Me
then you got me
My defense is a strong offense
i think id be cool to have more guardians that utilized various other classes abilities in lore
titans with sweet business and that chest rig
ACCURACY BY VOLUME OF FIRE!
Actium War Rig
ignoring the gamebreakingness of it YES....id love complete freedom of all 3 classes, subclasses, and abilities to just mix mash and match things up
lmao warlocks just cannot learn how titans and hunters jump VERTICALLY
Like if I were a guardian id obviously be a Titan but I also would 100% learn Goldie for the coolness of it
arc warlock code of the missle could be totally viable
Golden gun but its a rocket launcher
Reading more of the timeline rn
Doesnt imprisonment go against the Sword Logic?
Shouldnt Oryx kill Alak-Hul to uphold said logic?
I actually really love the new cutscenes
The art drawn ones were cool, but they got so old and formulaic
The new style is a fire evolution
Alak Hul is one of the most horrifying encounters in Destiny, maybe Oryx just wanted to sharpen his enemies lmao
Yeah but Alak Hul fought Oryx and Sword Logic dictates that the loser (Alak Hul) does not deserve to exist after a defeat
Which one
Oryx had a lot of prisoners. And we know he sometimes deviates from the sword logic as he wanted vengeance for his son. Which is dumb. Because the dead deserve to die
As savathun said in season of the witch to xivu “oryx was a heretic and so are you”
It seems none of the hive gods can truly stick to the sword logic 100% of the time
ironic
Because it’s a flawed logic
Its like they knew they got pranked by the worm gods
Didn’t savathun tell xivu? And she just didn’t care
Siblings amiright
I think savathun is the only one of the three who cares that they were lied to
Which again is ironic seeming as she’s the god of lies
Did Oryx even know?
Any lore nerds in chat I call upon you
Can I get a rough rundown of who Chalco Yong is?
They appear to be a hidden or some other ally of Ikoras
Yeah, she’s a Hidden agent with a fairly close and personal relationship with Ikora
And now she may have taken over leadership from Ikora even
Oh neat
On the topic of Ikora, I just got to reading some red war era lore and I didnt know that Ikora also tried to regain her light from the Shard of the Traveler but it didnt work....why?
Why did the Traveler grant us the light again but not Ikora
I know I'm not allowed to say that to the Warlock Vanguard or to IKO-006, but given that we're under double-trouble encryption, I'm going to say it anyway. How's your whole mess in the City? Glad I missed all that....```
```What is this thing we do, Ikora? Are you my one true love, am I yours? We agreed it's not love like most people have love. Nobody's getting married or turning up arm in-arm at the Crimson Ball. It's a special and radical kind of friendship, right? That's what you said. An endogenous need to strike the lies away from another soul. It's the promise to seek truth in each other without mercy or fear, but always with compassion.
So: speaking mercilessly and fearlessly, but with compassion, where is our friendship now? What does it mean? Does it mean that I check in on you every few years and otherwise just let you do your thing? Is that your nature—to draw away forever while I chase after you and nag to be sure you're all right? Friend, you are not Mara Sov, and I am not one of her cadre. I'm not doing that. I want to see more of you, and I want you to want that.```
@jagged badge Do you have an answer for this aswell?
That I don’t know, I’m afraid
Unfortunate
Ill wait till Mael or Dova are online
maybe they have an idea
In other news
man I forgot Taeko-3
She and her group who went down there as a squad of nine, got picked off one by one, watched a Wizard rip the light out of my friend and fiddle it into some kind of crystal
Shit was d2s version of the "Whether we wanted it or not"
Don't think they actually confirmed what Drifter provided for it
Some time after the death of Panoptes, Infinite Mind and the City’s venture to the Infinite Forest:
Osiris stepped back to look upon his work. It towered stories above him.
The Sundial was complete, a shining beacon in Mercury’s sky. He needed only to seal the chronometric core, which lay bare at the center of the spire, and activate the Arc con...
He literally shows up after its completion for a chat with Osiris
Do we know what exactly that core is?
if its Drifter its more likely to be of taken origin no?
What's the Sundial?
A time machine
Time machine Osiris built through unknown and heavily implied sinister means to try and find a way to save Saint from his fate
He failed and decided to leave it around on Mercury for anyone to find
Well lateron in season of dawn with our help he did find the correct Saint and brough him back to our reality
I've always found it bemusing that despite how close Osiris was with Saint he couldn't figure out a basic connection with Saints idol and the player guardian
With infinite possibilities its unlikely that the solution was so close at hand probably
Wasn't like Saint couldn't identify us
Said we would be Crotas killer among other things
There are infinite timelines in which we kill Crota
Osiris was literally searching through an ocean trying to find the right drop of water
Yep. But there was a key moment that never seemed to occur to Osiris.
The whole deal where Saint first runs into us on Mercury and we inspired him to keep fighting
"But siblings we were lied too! We can choose our own path!"
Xivu and ghost of Oryx: autistic screeching
Time travel is unusual even for us
If you go to the log he actually visits that precise moment but leaves shortly beforehand
Can't blame Oryx for that one. He's a diehard believer in the Sword Logic. Even calls out Xivu for heresy lol
Had the Echo stayed a bit longer he probably would have found his moment
Except for when it comes to his son
Even the Echo-Oryx is perplexed on that one
yeah, Xivu is a bit of a coward now as she is the only one not to show up in person for their reunion XD
yeah he was like "Why would i go to war over the fact i lost a offspring who proved not worth existing"
And that's what I'm pointing out, Osiris didn't bother to check how our guardian saved Saint despite probably knowing of our interference. Quite the overlooked factor
Okay that one is kinda insane
I wonder if they were still walking when Sagira was slain or by the time we actually got Saint out
I'm thinking her worms gonna be eating her eventually
yeah given idk if the tithes her still few loyal armies are feeding her are enough
true she is hiding more to the fact we can 100% beat her
And?
It's a known fact the worms are never sated and always demand more. Eventually the tithe lines wont be enough
Are you sure?
Saint told the story of this exact moment but the Saint we rescue from the infinite forrest is not the same one who initially ventured into it in this timeline, as Episode 1 details there are slight divergences
Maybe this is a Saint who we merely helped with the Fallen but never showed the image of the last city of how it would look centuries later
Or the initial Saint never told this exact story to Osiris in full detail, he could have left out the part where our ghost showed him the future
That only happened to Savathun because the DC curse generated imbaru every waking moment of every day
Unless Xivu actually gets a massive win and a boost to her tribute then her worm’s appetite won’t grow in return
You can just ration it out if you want to
I'd argue a few massive losses would also add up and screw her over. Like how Oryx got screwed over by getting unlucky and some of his champions dying
Which are acts of war
And still give her tribute
That was the entire point of Seraph
Xivu was willing to kill a vast portion of her troops just to get an immediate boost
She's not invincible heh
Eventually we can find out where's she hiding. Or maybe... huh that would a twist
Maybe Echo-Oryx will tell us where the coward is hiding
Went as far as to call Xivu a heretic..
yeah
by her saying that we are not worthy of Oryx's throne when we are the ones that killed him i sopouse that does mean heresy?
Echo oryx straight up says its heresy in a line
yeah
Xivus hiding and letting her armies do all the fighting only works if she remains hidden
A direct challenge to Xivu and her running from it won't be an "act of war".. it's plain old cowardice
yeah
i kinda headcanon after she became mortal and ran into hiding that several of her armies deserted from her
either doing their own thing and worshipping the sword logic on their own and what not
That is Hive Logic, the whole basis for a strike actually
Navota in the Disgraced strike
yeah if your leader is a weak coward will you follow em?
yeah cause she ran?
Yep
And as Xivu didn't do a thing while we had a whole "final battle" vs the Witness where even Savathun showed..
Perfectly fits if some of Xivus tithing lines have been disrupted
As of right now who is the most powerful hive? Savathun?
By pure actual hive power probably Xivu
Savathun relies solely on outsmarting her enemies, strength wise she’s basically just a full fireteam stacked on each others shoulders
Hey waltz
Guess what
What
Yeah but xivu can die. Savathun has two backups (Immaru and throne world)
Savathun pops golden gun. It’s joever
Xivu had a few war moons 
Her throne world won't do shit
Only one
She has a ghost
Her throne world isn’t a real one anymore
What you mean it isn’t real
I eated it
She doesn't have a hive worm anymore that's in our parasite
It was collapsing the moment she died as a mortal in the end of Lost

She doesn’t have any connection to the ascendant plane anymore
She had to rebuild the physical infrastructure with light
It’s just solid ground now
It doesn’t do her any good
So. Where is it?
In the ascendant plane still
But it’s not a real throne world anymore
It can’t help her at all if she dies
It also can just like be destroyed
The scorn are trying to capture the wellspring and destroy everything

When it gets vaulted in 2035 it’s getting destroyed
Wonder what fikrul was doing during that
Hiding, they mention it
He was building up his own scorn ranks
Which is why he has knights show up in WR
I see
He tried to get all of the fresh scorn over there in his ranks
But then hefnd scooped up his troops too
That’s the thing with scorn. Always being controlled by something else.
Well they would be able to have some autonomy
Scorn are puppets without fikril now
Fikrul’s Knights were capable of speech
Fikrul specifically stagnated their growth because of his obsessions
Witness just turned the purple ones into actual mindless corpses
Remember back in lost they started their own gladiator pit without any outside input
Remember when the throne world scorn were still yellow for like the first two weeks
why say this
Idk, I thought we were comparing power stuff
Savathun also have her whole lucent brood who uses both hive magics and light
We only captured like, 4 didn’t we?
No there were repeats
Savathun has a buttload of hive guardians to throw at us like cannon fodder kek
Oh
Did anything ever happen with that?
Yep
Season of the Dawn
Bunch of Psions found it and started messing with history
Yet another mess of Osiris we had to clean up 
yee
Savathun used him as a puppet for a reason
Osiris was quite the arrogant fool who could never admit fault lol
No one would be suspicious because he's already prone to causing trouble
Guess he was trying to rival Clovis
Not really it was just a perfect opportunity to infiltrate the city. Osiris had just lost his ghost to xivu araths forces and after that his mind was weak enough for savathun to make the switch and imprison him while she went to back to the city using his face.
Osiris was never prone to cause issues. He was exiled because people were afraid of his research into the vex.
But he never actually caused any kind of serious problem.
Shayura is a guardian who went through a lot of shit
Initially guardians starting to use stasis was what tipped her over the edge
Aisha is the guardian who watched over shayura
Guardians who were Trials regulars. Shayura had a whole mental breakdown and turned into a murderous Light zealot
She went out and killed a bunch of guardians that were known to use stasis, like properly killed them
And then she ran into a lucent hive and just completely lost it
She then went back to the last city for rehab
💀
So “shayura’s wrath” is yeah
And Aisha’s embrace and Aisha’s care
She’d hate us
I think shes slowly coming around
Reed was another guardian who was part of her fireteam
Hes the Titan you see the Witness turn into a bunch of floating blocks in the opening cutscene to Lightfall
I don’t even remember that. Wait in the last city?
Like in the market
We only have one weapon with reed right? Reeds Regret? What did they regret
In the lightfall cutscene where you see the witness "slice" that one guardian
That was all of them
Rip reed
Shayura and Aisha were also there in that assault
But we unsliced them right?
But their Ghosts survived
No
Dead dead
That’s not how it works
:/
Wait wait Shayura was too?
Loss of ghost means a guardian is mortal
Aw man I thought we'd get more of her story having to deal with the loss of her fireteam
No more emotional torment for her
😔
Sadge
The Witness did that with its own strength and abilities basically a year and a half before enacting the Final Shape
And it was the Traveler who reversed the effects of the Final Shape specifically, before we stopped it fully from being carried out
Reed probably used bolt charge and storms keep
Not directly, at least
Now how exactly do we kill the witness? Like I know in excision we have 12 guardians shoot light beams into it
But like
He's quite negligent
The Sundial is pretty obvious why
Is that all it really took
We unmade it
Because it was made in darkness?
Yes
So we unmade it with darkness?
No
Or light
But a strike back in Curse of Osiris is directly a result of the crazy Warlock remaking a vex mind we destroyed to keep it as a "pet"
0-0 CoO
@warm acorn to be more specific the dissenters helped us find a way to get inside and actually wound it. After that it retreated to monolith and we then had to cut it off as if you noticed it had a snake like form.
Then 1 final time in excision we dealt the final blow
The Witness was created by the amalgamation of an entire species fusing their minds in Darkness. However, we discovered that the Witness had dissenting voices, growing in number. We then discovered that in Darkness, we could use the Traveler’s Light to destroy these dissenting voices
Piece by piece we unmake the Witness
Okay yeah when we destroy the statues in the campaign
Wait no
In that mission
And in excision
If you've done salvations edge if you look at the aftermath after beating the witness you'll see a stump.
We essentially cut the head off a snake
The little like
Box thing
?
Where you focus the weapons?
We destroy a few in Iconoclasm before the Witness cuts us out, but it shows us at least that it works and it can wound the Witness
Yeah that’s the mission
Then in Salvation’s Edge we break the Witness’ hold on the Traveler and prevent the Final Shape
No further in front of the platform.
Ah dang I’ve never noticed that
I’m ngl watching worlds first salvations edge was crazy
And then going into excision
And finally, in Excision, we press the attack on the Witness and destroy many more of its dissenting voices, unmaking it to the point we are able to directly channel the Traveler’s Light as a beam to destroy the Witness entirely
Why does the witness have 6 buttons on its chest that make it vulnerable, is there a lore reason for that or just the mechanic they chose
Is that light beam from ghost a one off thing because our ghost wasn’t looking too hot after it used that
But it was op
The ghost was already being destroyed by the witness’ influence but yes the beam is probably a one off. Because it completely destroyed it
So this subjugator we see kill eris and who’s popping up in the story
Are they the first subjugator?
It’s not been actually confirmed I don’t think but all signs point towards it.
It was a specific instance of the Traveler giving us this power because it was needed
It was probably a very costly expenditure of energy considering how the Traveler was wounded and is healing
About time the traveler did something
Like in the Collapse? And the Red War? And Arrivals?
And Lightfall?

What did it do in arrivals and lightfall
A lot
Idk what it did in the collapse cause I wasn’t there for it
It reformed and pushed back the darkness in arrivals
In the red war it got wrecked by ghaul
In lightfall it literally fired a giant beam
Why this guy help us, like, he ran away from every other planet but why with us he remains? Also there's an embodiment of Darkness like the Traveler is for the Light? Cuz the Witness isn't the embodiment of Darkness right?
dude missed the cutsecnes
And then destroyed him at the end
It broke free from its cage and eviscerated him
In red war it got wrecked because it broke free and slaughtered ghaul who had become a god like being of light
The Traveler isn’t a he. It’s either it or sometimes she or they. Never he though
Don’t we fight ghaul?
Yes
And he’s using supers
It helps us because it simply wants to be benevolent and promote growth and complexity in the universe
And we have no light
Yes. But he is reborn as pure light. And then the traveller kills him
we did have light
To help species reach new potentials
My bad
lore wise our guardians killed a buttload of red legion during the red war
The Traveler stayed with us because it realised it had to make a final stand
but the Witness doesn't want exactly that? Meaning for a meaningless universe?
It couldn’t keep running
peak character development
The witness wanted perfect stillness. A universe with no pain or suffering because nothing would be happening.
True
The Traveler doesn’t impose meaning. It doesn’t tell species what to do or anything. It gives them the means to grow, but it also allows them choice
It hopes that people choose true
Raiden shogun be like
So is the traveler mad at us that we use darkness
And it does try to warn Clovis against meddling with the Darkness but
No
Good :)
It tried to tempt the vanguard by promising them it would freeze them in their favourite moment or life dreams
We use the Darkness for good. We use the Darkness to prove the Traveler’s ideals right
:D
But we are also inadvertently proving the winnowers logic right by doing so right?
I don't think it's simple like that "oh I don't want to suffer anymore"
The Witness just couldn't bear the existential crisis anymore
you mean the sword logic?
The witness should chill out
The sword logic closely follows the winnowers ideals and philosophy yes
bomb
i mean, i guess bomb, though i dont believe the traveler coined that at all
i think it was mara?
Wait bomb is the actual name?
bomb logic, yes
Bomb logic?
lol
Oh I thought you were joking lmao
same
a sword is simple, yet effective
a bomb is complicated, lots of moving parts, and hard to use properly
i mean it shot a giant terraforming laser beam to try and defend it self so i guess
true
I see I see
but the appropriate construction and application, and it is dramatically more potent
its bomb logic was making us and going "Now go my loot goblins, KILL EVERYTHING THAT THREATENS YOU!"
Bomb logic is, in simpler terms, arguing for complexity
yeah
which is what the traveler encourages, complexity, free will, life
Imagine if we subscribed to sword logic
"a gentle city ringed with spears"
we dunked on the hive logic a lot
shes not telling us to be pacifists, but to like... not go and kill everything on sight because why not
"NOO YOU NEED A SWORD!"
Me uses a grenade launcncer instead
We do kind of do that though
canonically, not exactly
When the hive knight with only a sword tries to hit me
also most of the enemies we fight are as a form of defense or counteroffensive
legit
the cabal we fight? at war with us and trying to kill us
the hive we fight? those too
the vex? youre never gonna fucking believe it, but they actively wanna kill us too
Can we talk about when cause was fighting in the prison of elders and used multiple different hunter supers
house dusk are like the only enemy faction thats not outright actively seeking our annihilation
Saint puts it best
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=i9TQuD3Ckj0&pp=ygUYRGVzdGlueSAyIGd1YXJkaWFucyByaWlz
Alternative Dialogue in Override: Europa during Season of the Splicer.
**
Mithrax: I am joyful of our victory! Though it is difficult to watch Guardians deal violence with the Light, as many Eliksni have seen before.
Saint-14: Save your false-holiness for Ikora! Guardians did not go to Riis to attack Fallen. Fallen came to Earth to attack u...
House dusk is?
and they're very much still hostile
Just normal fallen?
Pretty much houseless fallen
Gotcha
common fallen outlaw or bad guy
Ye
They’re the old houses from d1 who formed under one banner because we decimated the houses 
So is house salvation still a thing now or?
maybe the only instance where my argument does not apply
House of wolves 👀
Yeah but it has no leader. Eramis abandoned them and the witness is dead
the red legion still exists too
I guess they could join house of light under mithrax
I think the Vex aren't searching that also, cuz if they wanted too they could just simulate humanity, the guardians and the Traveler in speedlight until they find something to counter us
They cannot.
no, seriously, they cant
How so?
Saints reciting all the atrocities the Fallen did to humanity while Mithrax was having an innocence play
they keep trying
Why don’t these enemy species wanna just be on our side
Like the fallen
And the vex
Most of the atrocities he claims are overblown, and he generalises the entirety of the eliksni
Some are just that deluded like Eramis
They don’t want to they hate us
that entire season was saint having a character arc from "violent xenophobe" to "gentle giant" towards the eliksni
And they hate house light for living with humanity
But why
fucking plot armor
no
Cause paracausality I think
are you familiar with the term "causality"?
Greed, envy, pride. The list goes on
You can’t simulate paracausal beings
there's an actual ingame explanation provided for why the vex cannot simulate us
Before house light, the eliksni hated us because the traveller chose us and they were jealous because it abandoned them and let their home get destroyed pretty much
it is correct
Atheon :’)
House salvation still think this way
causality means "cause and effect"
something that, well, everything irl operates on
in destiny, the light and dark offers "paracausality", sidestepping some requirements for an effect, a different cause to give the same effect
Ok but like we’re just one person😭
If they didn’t hate us
Maybe they’d become like luxent hive
Wdym? We’re not the only guardian
And our best friend Luzaku
this puts a spanner in the works for the vex, how do you simulate something that does not obey cause and effect the only way you know
I know
They hate all guardians and humanity because the traveller chose us
They’re just jealous
they have a different way to interact with the universe
Exactly
Envy really be hitting hard
the vex? no, not really
paracausality? kinda, yes
But after all these years of us slaughtering them, like wake up y’all
Well more like “why haven’t you abandoned these guys and let their home get destroyed like you did us?”
It's stated by Clovis Bray I think
the vex are the most simplistic enemy faction by far, its why they're so terrifying
wdym
clovis barely understood shit for fuck about the vex
Pride won't allow that lol
See how many Cabal went outlaw after we became equal allies with Caital
more than most for his time of course
Well their goal is simple. Everything must become vex
but compared to what we know now it is different
I just wanna be friends :(
Not with the vex tho
Lance Reddick (Zavala voice actor) reads out Destiny 2 Meme Full Sequence. Zavala's Alternate Answer to the Cabal Empress Caiatl, daughter of Calus. Zavala bows to no one. I edited it the cutscene to make it feel like it was supposed to be a part of Season of the Chosen.
Be Legend, Subscribe! [https://bit.ly/3atzYk1] Thank you guardian!
Here's...
I wanna be friends with more eliksni
the vex are simple, they're a large colony of microorganisms in an evangelion that fights using construction equipment and a glorified future prediction thingabob
no culture, not really any language, no individuality, nothing
cold, mindless, simple, and there's no end to them.
I wonder if we’ll ever get dread homies
their concept is very interesting, it reminds me of SCP
they could be better explored
Leadership in the enemy factions currently is. Pretty much non existent. We have xivu, savathun, yirix, the resonant knife and maya
Who’s Yirix
The only SCP related one could draw from the vex is their biology
its a common misconception that the vex are robots
Psion flayer who’s commanding the dread and shadow legion
Ope
but the white stuff in their center? thats the vex
its not their organs, or blood, it is the vex
they're a collective of microorganisms in a fluid state that work together to pilot a mech
its like pacific rim but with way too many pilots
Lol
It’s like how our brains wear our bodies 
and when i say construction worker btw, im serious, all of their units are dedicated to construction in a sense
there are no combat vex frames, and they're kicking our ass
We don’t know what wyverns are do we?
we have a very good idea
They’re not combat frames for sure
are you familiar with the heavy duty construction machinery called a "boring machine"?
no, boring in this context does not mean the opposite of fun
boring like digging
When maya returns she better have assumed control of some combat frames so we can actually see them
Wait there’s no combat frames?💀
I have not
none we know of, likely none at all
No the ones we’ve met are all architects and engineers, etc.
Nailguns shoot nails, and can hurt, and kill
basically a larger construction worker, maybe doubles as a manager.
we know hydras work like a form of "manager"
What about praetorians
:~)
praetorians are just a form of minotaur with a specialised role
And that is?
all of them are unknown, but among them appear to be working the confluxes in the vault of glass
What about atheon :o
a scientist, basically
What about the Templar :o
that i dont know, probably some kind of manager under atheon, helps oversee the vault
What are the oracles
iirc they're basically just vex, their purpose involves atheon fucking around with the timestream
what they do in the raid is basically remove us from time.
Pretty much
rather, shooting the wrong one is a failed attempt at biohacking
darkness or not, we'd be donezo if we wipe from the oracles
Yeah true
they alter the timeline so that we never even existed at all.
Yea
they dont just kill us, they annihalate us from the fucking noosphere
the vault of glass was the only place they could do this
dunno, something about the location
im very unsure but i believe i recall the sol divisive being involved?
Probably
meaning it could be related to paracausality
What about the sanctified mind
p sure its like... a priest?
the sol divisive are weird, different
they worship the witness
What about consecrated mind
Hang on no shot cyclopses aren’t combat frames
Bruh they look like turrets
some kinda fucked up surveillance
cameras
a construction site having cameras and minor security is different from a workforce dedicated to combat
their main purpose is surveillance, overwatch
ah, looking at their grimoire, a cyclops is some form of sensor/beacon
likely a multipurpose communication, surveilance, etc
The goblin "slap rifle" is a high tech swis army knife for construction work, having navigation, network repeaters, etc
The hobgoblin "line rifle" is just a welder
The goblin/minotaur/hydra Torch hammer are just jackhammers
The wyvern warp lance is a play on the irl construction tool "thermal lance" that make it work like a very big drill
likely intended to make tunnels
What’s the role of the 2 vex bosses in spire?
gather the information in spire of the watcher, then blow it up to remove any evidence
said information was related to neptune and the veil located there
No like specifically the bosses, ones a siren so communication but was Percy just there to dig into the Centre of the spire
given that the wyvern was making a beeline for the reactor, it was probably making it blow up
it was having some kind of interface with the reactor when we got there
harpies are generally the scouts and recons of the vex, so it probably went to the spire for communication reasons
maybe to transmit the information
The vex are so difficult to write for because they have no personality
They have a chance now with maya but even then
Damn why did no one tell me that Hazardous Propulsion literally has us carry failsafe around
Thats so damn cute
Slap rifle sounds like mida multi tool
I want one
Yes except mida multi tool is some kind of paracausal thing
From another time or something I forget
MIDA Multi Tool is from another universe
Related to Paraverse? Ik there’s MIDA stuff in marathon
Hey, I'm a longtime player who has played since day 1 of destiny 1 and played through everything up until forsaken, but pretty much fell off of the franchise since then. Would it be worth it for me to come back and play final shape just to see the ending? Is there a good payoff?
I would very much say it had a good payoff, personally, but I'm not sure how much impact it would have on you if you haven't played for... Six and a half years.
You'd have to play...everything that came before it
Yea haha do you think it would be best to watch like a lore summary of the story from forsaken to this point?
I would be down to play it but I dont wanna buy a bunch of old content 💀
It was recently all for 30$ at Humble Bundle
I think that's probably up to you. The content is still played and updated, but there would also be seasonal content that's no longer available.
Might still be there, I think
the only thing i see is the legacy collection which has everything i think: Lightfall Standard Edition*
The Witch Queen Standard Edition*
Beyond Light Pack**
Shadowkeep Pack**
Forsaken Pack
30th Anniversary Pack
Pit of Heresy Dungeon
Shattered Throne Dungeon
Grasp of Avarice Dungeon
but its 70 dollars....
so im not sure its worth it
Must have just missed out on the sale
@trim grotto can you explain this one to me
mmm i see
well i think ill js watch a yt video or something
thank you guys for the help!
Later
My break is over and I go back to work
Try me in, uh... Like, 10 hours, haha

I have the answer
Go on
No
Anyway it’s something to do with the vision we got, spitballing here but iirc the traveler had to be very selective and only allowed/was able to let us do it
So the traveler just assumed that we'd be doing a better job than Ikora of all people
I mean "plot gotta plot" would be a viable excuse I guess but them showing that Ikora tried and the traveler was like "lol nah" is an odd decision
I meant the Light and Dark saga pack, which has everything. It should go on sale at some point, probably.
I mean, Ikora having what is essentially a cult disguised as secret service probably works against her.
I highly doubt the traveler gives 2 shits about that
Especially considering the spot it was in
?
Also yeah the hidden arent exactly like evil or anything
so do guardians actually recover like in gameplay? for example when they get shot does their ghost somehow heals them?
or is this only done for gameplay purposes but not included in the lore?
Ghosts heal their guardians using light yes
You can see it in the FS vision cutscene where Cayde talks to Sundance, Ikora gets shot by a hydra during the endless night (doesn’t die) and her ghost heals her
Technically they also showed this ingame all the way back in Warmind when our ghost patches up up after Xol reveals and almost burries us in snow
Or before Sundance got shot in the big Forsaken cutscene, he pulls her out and goes "can you help me out here little buddy?" cause hes in kinda rough shape
i thought he just said that as a way for him to get out of here like go to orbit or something
No he was just beat up
'twas to heal
unbeknownst to Cadell, twould be his lasteth mistake
The fact she's willing to do such a thing may not be something the Traveler likes.
The Traveler advocates for free will and freedom of choice, for good or ill. It's why the Hive have it.
how the hell did Oryx's tablet carver end up in Rhulk's vault
good question
Rhulk just likes to steal shit
Yeah, but the Hidden are essentially the opposite of that (at least based on the oath)
and no one noticed him taking this giant carving tool from the dreadnaught? 😭
Why didn't they make him sound British?
though I don't think he could have obtained it after Oryx's death since he was pretty much forced to stay in Savathun's Throne World for the most part
maybe oryx and rhulk were just chill like that
unless he ws able to grab it during one of his few moments of freedom from there
or savathun had it first
and rulk stole it from savathun
but i doubt it from the reaction she had
she would have known that Rhulk took it
I doubt it
she sounded stun locked rulk had it
Oryx considered the Witness a "charlatan"
Why?
which also means
oryx knows the winnower
for sure
the Witness forced Rhulk to stay in Savathun's throne world after he screwed up with the Ahslids
well yeah, the Winnower canonically referred to him as "my man Oryx"
wait rulk fumbled?
With the what?
there was a species the Witness wanted recruited called the Ahslids
so it sent Rhulk there, but the Witness wanted Rhulk to be very discreet about it
Is Rhulk a guy?
yea rulk being discreet
witness should of send nez instead
💀
Rhulk = red hulk
Chicken mommy Nezarec
however, Rhulk ended up going too far and he ended up accidentally making them kill eachother in nuclear war
until only one Ahslid was left
damn
Uun, who Rhulk considered a failure prior
that kinda sounds like earth

tbh rulk was bound to go far after what he did those his own people
🫡
How
and what we know about his experiments in SD
What did he do to his own people?
he took some of them and trained them to be assassins
🤨


