#📚lore-discussion

1 messages · Page 97 of 1

empty fern
#

You think oryx’s symbol is the same as crotas? Used for rituals for them (easy question)

empty fern
#

(Meant same role)

#

Like, crotas plates have his symbol and oryx has his

#

Actually what is the plate symbol for oryx again?

chrome fog
#

Kill it with a wooden stake

empty fern
#

Oh that also uses part of the crota FeelsThinkingMan

fresh zephyr
#

I need to ask y’all something

#

Is quira dead?

#

Or did it fake its death

jagged badge
#

Quria dead

fresh zephyr
#

Darn

#

I hope to see it back one day because that fight felt to easy

blazing wasp
#

or, so we think.

fresh zephyr
#

But idk why

fresh zephyr
blazing wasp
#

well, because if we dont stop the witness

#

the universe fucking ends

#

and savathun kinda lives in the universe

west cloak
#

it doesnt really end, just that it gets warped and shaped into a balaced final shape that's a perfect image in the witness' eyes

blazing wasp
#

Which is the end of all life and all death

#

complete, true stagnation

#

It's effectively the same thing

fresh zephyr
blazing wasp
#

no more life, no more death

#

no more suffering because there's nothing to suffer

#

nothing to die because nothing will live.

raw hazel
#

It’s like how Immaru put it

chrome fog
fresh zephyr
#

What I hope when or if we beat the witness will the witness race be back again and we have to fight them like the great hunt

raw hazel
# raw hazel It’s like how Immaru put it

Alternative Dialogue from the seasonal activity Altars of Summoning during Season of the Witch.

**

Immaru: The final shape, the way we think about it? It's the winner, the one who's so smart or strong that they beat everybody else. The final shape may not be the most interesting or best looking or whatever, but it's the one who makes it to th...

▶ Play video
chrome fog
fresh zephyr
#

That sucks

#

I always wondered what would happen if they got revived

#

Maybe like a Great War

rugged bluff
#

Are the star cats you find in the dreaming city related to the star horse?

jagged badge
#

I don’t think there’s any lore to them so

#

We don’t know

#

Starhorse barely factors into the lore itself

empty fern
#

Honse

#

Stop breaking the 4th wall honse

blazing wasp
#

4 horseman???!?!?!?!?!???

clear knot
#

Didn't we kill Riven? Why are we working together?

exotic cloak
#

She's still dead

jagged badge
raw hazel
#

Ahamkara persist after death and we needed her help to chase after the Witness

jagged badge
#

We needed the power of an Ahamkara to follow the Witness. Riven negotiated so that we’d help her first by securing and protecting what remained of her clutch

clear knot
#

And... who made the deal with Riven? I don't know these characters except osiris

raw hazel
#

Mara specifically, if you’re referring to the deal to find her eggs

clear knot
#

Why is Mara important?

jagged badge
#

She’s the queen of the Awoken and an incredibly important ally

#

She raised Riven basically

raw hazel
#

She’s the Queen of the Awoken and the one who created the Dreaming City alongside Riven

clear knot
#

So the two have a history?

jagged badge
#

Yep

raw hazel
#

Aye, seeking to impress his sister Uldren brought Mara an Ahamkara, which was Riven

#

And Mara participated in the Great Hunt so she would have the only Ahamkara, ensuring she would have a unique and useful power

clear knot
#

And why did we kill Riven if Riven was an "ally" to Mara?

jagged badge
#

Well, she wasn’t when we killed her

#

Mara was “dead” and Oryx, the Taken King Took Riven

#

A while later, Riven was working with Savathûn instead

#

Riven was closely tied to the Forsaken campaign and manipulated Uldren Sov, Mara’s brother into doing some bad shit

#

We find out and we kill her in the Last Wish raid

raw hazel
#

Aye, during the Taken War she was partially Taken by Oryx and was partly responsible for the Taken corruption of the Dreaming City, and she was the antagonist for the events of Forsaken.

jagged badge
#

That being said, even when Riven was an “ally” to Mara, it’s still a complicated relationship. Ahamkara are by nature manipulative and duplicitous and self-serving

#

(Except Taranis)

raw hazel
#

They feed on the differential change that occurs in universe when they grant a wish- The bigger the change, the more they can eat

#

Which is why they monkey paw wishes, so there’s more for them to feed on

blazing wasp
jagged badge
#

That’s not what I said lmao

blazing wasp
#

its what i interpreted

#

and its what i will interpret

#

because its a little funny

ember storm
exotic cloak
#

Wait before this season we actually hear Riven voice or

jagged badge
#

Nah

exotic cloak
#

Even in final cutscene after the raid she uses other voice?

gentle geyser
#

Shes not in the final cutscene because thats after the raid, because shes dead

#

They probably didn’t have a voice actor for riven because of her ability to change voices, they gave her a unique voice to make sure you could tell it was her speaking

jagged badge
#

It is her title after all

#

Riven of a Thousand Voices

outer dragon
#

And as I said
"Mostly dead is slightly alive"

outer dragon
exotic cloak
#

Yo why Mara sacrifice herself and everyone at the start of taken king

gentle geyser
delicate cypress
#

what are the taken

exotic cloak
#

I saw that cutscene long time ago and was really confused

outer dragon
gentle geyser
outer dragon
remote sky
#

Aye so reed n the gang are basically the box legndaries of destiny

#

..and they were never even NPCs?? Crazy

gentle geyser
#

Who?

jagged badge
#

They mostly wore Trials armour in their lore

#

But the CGI cutscene uses actual character models and not game models or something

#

And they already had those models

#

Reed, Aisha and Shayura don’t actually have anything to do with Destiny 1 in the way you’re suggesting

gentle geyser
#

Pretty sure the entire reason they aren’t characters is because they are stand ins for the main player and their fireteam

#

Yes they exist, but they aren’t really meant to be characters that we need to connect to

exotic cloak
gentle geyser
jagged badge
remote sky
jagged badge
#

Otherwise he would have continued through our Solar System further

gentle geyser
#

Still then, its less of a sacrifice and more of an actual attempt at victory

remote sky
#

Also
I keep hearing about shaxx and mara and I'm confused, and concerned based off of what I'm assuming

#

Please someone clarify

#

This is gnawing at me

jagged badge
remote sky
#

Oh ok

jagged badge
#

Mara wanted Shaxx to read from some Awoken book but he said “fuck that, you can’t tell me what to do” and recited Shakespeare off by heart instead

#

Naturally

remote sky
#

Significantly more pg than what I had assumedbe_blueperfecto

outer dragon
jagged badge
#

Does that actually specify the book as being The Tempest?

outer dragon
#

Yes

jagged badge
outer dragon
#

Mara slapped the mug out of his hand. It shattered on the floor. She shoved a weathered book in his face. "I told you there would come a time when I collect for the Reef Wars. Read this. Out loud."

jagged badge
#

It’s an unnamed “weathered book”

outer dragon
#

It's implied that it was Tempest

exotic cloak
#

Anyway we can confirm Shaxx is a gigachad

outer dragon
#

Yes

#

Shaxx is based and chadpilled

trim grotto
jagged badge
#

Ah

#

This whole time I’ve just interpreted it as Shaxx just randomly wanting to like share his special interest or something lmao

remote sky
#

Id like to imagine that shaxx incinerated some random ass book she gave him and, essentially said "fuck you, wench! I can recite The Tempest by heart!" And so he did.

exotic cloak
#

Nah the version where he destroys ancient relic is better

raw hazel
#

Funny Darkness blokes

But in all seriousness they’re individuals who are Taken, and then whittled down by the Witness into their “perfect” selves- End result is they become mindless, Darkness-infused beings typically devoid of individual will that serve at the behest of a stronger controlling will.

raw hazel
delicate cypress
#

oke

outer dragon
marsh spire
#

do we know who the astronouts on mars are from the cutscsene when you first start d2?

jagged badge
#

Yep

#

Jacob Hardy, Ulysses Qiao and Dr M. Mihaylova

marsh spire
#

nice

jagged badge
#

It’s pretty interesting imo

#

And cool to see lore of pre-Golden Age humanity

dim minnow
#

there was also a 4th person with them named Evie Calamut, but she died on the way to Mars

jagged badge
#

Not on the way

#

Before launch

jagged badge
#

I believe this orders all those armour lore pieces

#

You can ignore the Micah letters

#

Evie died in an incident involving a fire and a wet staircase the day of the launch so the launch had to be delayed another day

jagged badge
#

I feel so terrible for Evie

sharp osprey
#

did the witness use the veil to create itself?

jagged badge
sharp osprey
#

essentially?

#

ok, just rewatched the season of the deep cutscene

next bobcat
#

Favourite cutscene ever

sharp osprey
#

"Having witnessed the truth in the Darkness, they used its binding power to merge themselves into the salvation they craved."

#

i think that says it pretty clearly, they used Darkness to create the Witness

sharp osprey
#

but the witness origin is probably like top 5 or even top 3

#

do we know why the veil is in Sol?

trim grotto
sharp osprey
#

is it ever explained why or how it was brought here in the first place?

#

did it do it itself?

trim grotto
#

I imagine that was the Black Fleet bringing it here during the Collapse. Savathûn's shenanigans involved killing Nezarec and hiding the Veil on Neptune.

sharp osprey
#

that actually makes sense, since the precursors originally found the veil, so the witness wouldve kept it for that whole time until savathun stole it and put it on neptune

#

savathun the real mvp CATGRIN

trim grotto
#

Shockingly, yeah

exotic cloak
#

We really need a name for those guys

#

Precursors was a Vex division right?

sharp osprey
#

lets call em the witnesses CATGRIN

exotic cloak
#

I mean

#

Is actually a fitting name

sharp osprey
#

yeah

exotic cloak
#

They witnessed the truth

#

To become The Witness

trim grotto
sharp osprey
#

we should call them the doomers

#

bad joke

exotic cloak
#

I mean

#

They are

exotic cloak
sharp osprey
#

the witness is the ultimate doomer, thats like the dude's entire point of existence

exotic cloak
#

Witness when no porpuse

sharp osprey
#

side note: Lightfall is obviously deeply flawed narratively, but i loved the cutscene where ol' witness gets actually mad at Calus. It feels so weird seeing a being so eldtritch and beyond us feel any ounce of human-like emotion

#

and then it also gets angry at the end of the newest trailer of course

#

i hope the writers havent overdone that aspect of its character with final shape tho

#

it should be something to be used very sparingly

modern lodge
#

I'm going to punch the witness in his big fugly eye

next bobcat
#

Eye?

#

He has 2 eyes

modern lodge
#

Yeah specifically the left one

shadow crypt
#

How many Precursors formed to become the witness

trim grotto
shadow crypt
#

Any guesses

trim grotto
#

all but one

#

which doesn't really answer your question

shadow crypt
#

Who’s the one

#

Oh

#

The Witness itself?

next bobcat
#

If we estimate the planet is the size of earth and is more advanced than earth, that may entail a larger population - so I would estimate between 7 and 9 billion

trim grotto
#

Except they're also an interstellar species

trim grotto
next bobcat
trim grotto
#

just rolls of the tongue doesn't it

#

I instead dubbed RS6243199 and HN W047622 as Rose and Henwy

next bobcat
#

This is peak Mael

trim grotto
next bobcat
shadow crypt
#

Are they still here today

trim grotto
#

Precursors

#

One joined the others and became the Witness
The other... well, nobody knows.

shadow crypt
#

Were there people who opposed to form together to become the witness?

#

Like didn’t want to

next bobcat
#

Idk

#

One guy didn’t

#

You see a bunch of mutilated corpses in the cutscene - maybe not willing?

shadow crypt
#

Wow only one person

next bobcat
#

Other people may have refused - but got yoinked just the same

shadow crypt
#

Like their leader

sharp osprey
#

I think its said that a subset of the precursors decided to become the witness, and went on a crusade killing those who wouldnt be part of it

trim grotto
sharp osprey
#

The only precursor left is RS

#

Assuming they're still alive

#

Which is possible cuz it seems like they are immortal, or just live very long

trim grotto
# shadow crypt Like didn’t want to

Even as I say those words, I feel the old doubts crawling through my thoughts again. But it has been long, and longer still, since you renounced the Consensus and set off into the cosmos. You have not seen the violence that visited our shores; a terrible reflection of that ancient history, which we believed was behind us. Though we were steadfast in our position and would have continued to argue it, however long it might take... there were dangerous elements. Subversives and defectors. We did not strike first! Nor did we choose our response lightly.

It had been so long since I wielded pruning shears; I had forgotten how. My hands shook. I could only imagine how you would have looked at me. But it is over now. What has been done, is done.

They were the last, and now we are all in Consensus.```
next bobcat
trim grotto
#

normally one has to nominate you for consensus, which is then internally voted on by mods

next bobcat
#

Yeah i know

trim grotto
#

i, however, nominated myself, solely for the reason that i wanted funny lore books attached to my name

next bobcat
#

Sigma

#

You don’t even have paragon Zav

trim grotto
#

i mean, i did

next bobcat
#

Paragone

sharp osprey
#

Is there any chance RS would be part of the Final Shape narrative?

next bobcat
#

Highly unlikely

trim grotto
#

I actually doubt it but yes, it's plausible

#

However

#

It was just as possible Taox would be involved with, like, any of the Hive gods, and look where that went

next bobcat
#

I reckon we’ll turn it into an exotic weapon

#

And Taox hopefully

trim grotto
#

literally nowhere

sharp osprey
#

Oh lol

#

I Misunderstood

trim grotto
#

except for a minor implied connection to the OXA, but

#

that also hasn't yet gone anywhere

sharp osprey
#

Also, idk if this matters but "RS-17 numbers" isnt really a good name for a character that would be mainstream yknow

next bobcat
#

I have a theory that Nezarec was originally a Psion. Mael, prove me wrong.

trim grotto
#

i just knee'd my desk

#

ow

sharp osprey
#

Ouch

blazing wasp
#

Ow

next bobcat
#

Get well soon

sharp osprey
#

Wait a minute, was the dreaming city shown off before Forsaken released?

next bobcat
#

Not that I’m aware of

shadow crypt
#

Is the dreaming city Mara’s throne world

next bobcat
#

No

shadow crypt
#

Or is it the shattered throne

next bobcat
#

ST

trim grotto
#

That'd be the Shattered Throne, Eleusinia.

blazing wasp
shadow crypt
#

What’s with it being so takeny

#

Corrupted in darkness

sharp osprey
#

Big outlandish dumbass prediction time, The Dark Heart of the Veil will be the secret second location of TFS CATGRIN

next bobcat
sharp osprey
next bobcat
#

Pale heart is meant to be an opposite to the black heart AFAIK

sharp osprey
#

Ohhhh

trim grotto
sharp osprey
#

Makes sense

trim grotto
#

The... hang on

#

where's my microphone you're getting Mael Voice

next bobcat
#

Byf?

shadow crypt
sharp osprey
#

Wasnt the black heart the vex's attempt to recreate the veil or am i completely wrong

shadow crypt
#

Ik they have some correlation but im not sure

trim grotto
#

oh actually i did the black heart already, one moment

next bobcat
#

Mael my iPad can’t run mp3 files

trim grotto
#

...it's one of the most common audio files

next bobcat
#

I can’t be bothered to get my laptop

shadow crypt
#

It works for me

trim grotto
sharp osprey
#

Good explanation, thanks

ember storm
shadow crypt
#

That’s pretty harsh

#

Why’d he do that

#

Just to gain more power?

ember storm
#

he’s oryx

trim grotto
ember storm
#

the hive kill

next bobcat
#

Mael it works now I think

trim grotto
#

why did the... he's Hive

shadow crypt
#

Oh ye

next bobcat
#

What about my nezarec psion theory?

shadow crypt
#

The logic

blazing wasp
#

This is like their whole thing

ember storm
#

she also personally pulled up the majority of her fleet to face him

#

so he took it kinda personally

trim grotto
# next bobcat What about my nezarec psion theory?

Nimbus: Hang on, did it just say ""Psions""? Maybe it IS on the Shadow Legion's side.

Nezarec: I'll make sure you do. 

Nimbus: ... Or maybe not."```
It's possible he's connected biologically, yes. Or at least, he once ruled them.
next bobcat
#

Mael is Byf confirmed?

trim grotto
#

who's Byf

next bobcat
#

You

sharp osprey
#

Discord lore channel users when youtube lore channel

#

So my half joke theory of a Black Heart destination isnt too outlandish then, right? Ah who am i kidding, yes it is

#

Or is it?

ember storm
#

I don’t know what that means

#

the veil is just a thing

#

it’s not a destination

trim grotto
#

The Traveler has a far stronger connection to the physical than the Darkness or Veil does. So, I doubt it.

sharp osprey
#

True

ember storm
#

the black heart is not only a limited copy of the veil, it’s also dead

sharp osprey
ember storm
#

the veil is just the veil

sharp osprey
#

Yeah

#

You right

ember storm
#

it doesn’t have an outer shell and an inside like the traveler

sharp osprey
#

Ok

ember storm
#

pale heart/black heart aren’t exactly meant to be opposites either

#

the black heart was just a thing in the black garden

#

the pale heart is an actual place

#

and also a phrase used to describe cowardice and inaction

sharp osprey
#

Hmm

#

Almost like those are character traits of the traveler

#

But besides, bungie have said that the pale heart is a very linear destination specificially designed for the campaign, so im wondering if there'll be a post campaign destination thats more open

#

Probably not tho

trim grotto
#

the pale heart is the more open destination

#

in that it opens up after the campaign

sharp osprey
#

They said that?

trim grotto
#

yes

sharp osprey
#

Oh cool

#

Apologies for my lack of knowledge on things btw

#

This game has a lot to follow

trim grotto
#

that it does

sharp osprey
#

With the new episodic format, i wonder where itll be on the continuum of seasons to something more like Dark Below or House of Wolves
Like how will the narratives work specifically

#

It being split up into acts makes me optimistic that therell be some sort of significant story moment/mission at least each act

#

And with the episodes seeming like they will maybe wrap up the loose ends post final shape, you cant help but wonder where bungie goes next

jagged badge
sharp osprey
jagged badge
sharp osprey
#

I cant tell if it would be lame or cool if the next saga is a prequel

#

Cuz tfs seems to have such, well, finality yknow

#

How would they go beyond that

next bobcat
#

Vex

sharp osprey
#

But the first episode is about the vex

#

Not saying itll be the end of that story, but it might

next bobcat
#

So?

#

It won’t

#

Vex can time travel

#

There’s so much we don’t know about the vex

sharp osprey
#

Actually thats a cool idea, saga 2 is time travel

#

Then it can be a sort of prequel while still allowing us to keep our newer abilities

#

And future too of course

ember storm
#

more likely than not it’s going to be about Ishtar more than the actual vex

trim grotto
#

The 227, to be precise

ember storm
#

despite all their complexity vex have never been the forefront of narratives

wheat flower
#

I mean

trim grotto
#

Except for Curse of Osiris, which was...

#

Curse of Osiris

ember storm
#

mostly about Osiris and Ikora

wheat flower
#

The vex were never an immediate threat

ember storm
#

the vex were just there doing vex things

wheat flower
#

Unlike the 4 other factions

ember storm
#

the plot was about getting Sagira back to Osiris

sharp osprey
#

The vex are also not really a character, theyre just milk robots

trim grotto
#

Curse of Osiris's big threat was "They found out a way to be evil a few centuries into the future!!!"

ember storm
#

incredible

wheat flower
#

I don't even remember what CoO plit wS

ember storm
#

Mercury has the best cpu in the universe

sharp osprey
#

Mercury and Io are the only celestial bodies that are still currently taken by the witness, right?

trim grotto
#

correct

sharp osprey
#

We know more or less why it took Mars and Titan, but why those other two? (besides DCV CATGRIN )

trim grotto
#

Well, Io was a sacred place to the Guardians due to the half-terraformed world, the Cradle, and the innate energy of the Traveler still flooding the lifeblood of the world.

sharp osprey
#

True true

trim grotto
#

Also, Asher theorised it wanted to access the Pyramidian

#

As for Mercury, likely a similar concept - the Infinite Forest, locked from the inside by Brother Vance

analog torrent
#

Can an Exo recognize the faces they see in the long, slow whisper? Ex, if someone they knew in the Golden Age was resurrected as a Guardian and they know the Guardian, would they be able to tell it’s the same face in their dreams?

trim grotto
analog torrent
#

Everyone as in truly everyone then
Huh that’s neat

shadow crypt
#

Why did Osiris get exiled from the Last City?

trim grotto
#

for completely neglecting his job and allowing a literal cult in his name to spring up and begin protesting and rioting and prophesising his doomsday rants about the Vex

#

job as the Vanguard Commander by the way

exotic cloak
#

What's the context of Osiris on D1

ember storm
#

basically just that

#

he was ex vanguard exiled for his radical ideology

#

and also the cult

exotic cloak
#

And even being exiled Vanguard just let Trials Of Osiris happen?

ember storm
#

Trials were ran by Vance in D1

#

they had no jurisdiction

exotic cloak
#

Oh

ember storm
#

Osiris literally doesn’t even remember his name

#

the vanguard didn’t care

shadow crypt
#

What happened to Vance

#

Brother Vance

jagged badge
#

He went into the Infinite Forest iirc

ember storm
#

gouged some eyes out

#

normal stuff

shadow crypt
jagged badge
#

Not sure but likely not

#

His voice actor has passed since so if Bungie did particularly want to bring back Vance, they’d have to recast

shadow crypt
#

Rip

empty fern
#

Wait Vance’s voice actor passed away? The fuck?

ember storm
#

a while ago

empty fern
#

Damn

chrome fog
#

NOO MY REPLY

empty fern
#

Bozo

chrome fog
#

Too many Ss

#

Anyways welcome Hegemon, a new lorehead woop-woop

empty fern
#

Ignore the gnome

#

@sick yew wake up you got a job

upper fox
#

Anybody know the lore behind that

exotic cloak
#

How is this lore related

empty fern
upper fox
#

It’s rocket after the guardians of the galaxy it’s pretty much more

#

Lore

exotic cloak
#

If you are going to make jokes at least make a good one

#

Lol

empty fern
#

Nah, just conspiracy

dense pikeBOT
#

astral5175 muted.

sick yew
exotic cloak
#

Thanks Alex

empty fern
#

Anyways, back to being dead chat CATGRIN

exotic cloak
#

Wait for the next time someone ask if the traveler is bad

shadow crypt
#

The witness got bamboozled

ember storm
empty fern
#

You missed out on an atrocity that happened a few minutes ago

exotic cloak
#

This is the kind of things that make me be on witness side

#

Let them restart the fucking universe, I will be happy as long as they erase that from existence

empty fern
ember storm
#

they’re just stopping it

blazing wasp
#

Winning a game of chess by eating the pieces

ember storm
#

putting the whole table in resin

raw hazel
#

Like Immaru says, it’d be like winning a game by turning it off. Nothing would ever change, it would forever be the same.

empty fern
#

Damn no activity?

fresh zephyr
#

Are House Dusk (Purple Fallen) still our enemies? Since we allied with Mithraax and Caiatl I forget which groups are still fighting the Last City other than the Hive and stuff

ember storm
#

they’re just thieves and pirates

fresh zephyr
#

I thought Eramis was helping us now since she saved Mithraax and stuff

ember storm
#

not really

#

it’s never going to be “I’m a good guy now and we’re friends”

#

she did one good deed and hasn’t done anything since

fresh zephyr
#

Right, I havent played any of the story since Defiance so I wasn't sure if she did more to redeem herself in the future or anything

#

I need to catch up

ember storm
#

either she’s still under the witness’ thumb, or went into hiding and abandoned all of salvation (whom she lied to to even get form)

#

she hasn’t appeared since defiance

fresh zephyr
#

I see I see

ember storm
#

you haven’t missed anything

#

the latest “update” is salvation being in Onslaught which indicates they’re at least still pawns of the witness

#

but nothing else

fresh zephyr
#

That makes sense

#

Alrighty, thanks for the help

chrome fog
trim grotto
#

Athrys went to a different solar system.

exotic cloak
#

Wait

#

Who's running Salvation now

#

Still Eramis or another overseer we don't know

ember storm
#

the witness is probably telling them what to do and they can't really say no

#

that or the ever present threat of becoming wrathborn

#

although i think it'd be funny if they devolved back into the communal structure of dusk

clear knot
#

Do the ahamkara know they are in a game? The Claws of Ahamkara exotic lore suggests it, but it seems weird if bungie just broke the fourth wall randomly like that

ember storm
#

don't put much thought into it

clear knot
#

Why not?

ember storm
#

it's irrelevant

#

old lore

#

means nothing now

#

starhorse is essentially representative of bungie as a whole, so anything beyond that is just a cheeky reference

clear knot
#

oh...

#

it just seemed interesting and I wanted to know more...

empty fern
#

Well

#

TOO BAD

#

Get retconned CATGRIN

ember storm
#

there have been references to "the game" but the term is used in many different contexts

#

the main one being the thing that unveiling describes when it comes to light and darkness

#

which is a metaphor

clear knot
#

oh...

#

wouldn't they change it by now then if it is contradictory?

empty fern
#

No CATGRIN

clear knot
#

so just... don't question it?

ember storm
rich veldt
ember storm
#

they're just left where they are

#

in the past

#

claws of ahamkara is from warmind, barely into D2's lifespan

#

they had a lot to still figure out

#

if you want actually interesting early ahamkara lore, check this out

chrome fog
#

And even without changing lore tabs players still mald about retcons whenever new information gets presented

ember storm
#

nobody knew

empty fern
#

Wonder if we have any current predicting exotics

#

Is mk stand asides up for it?

chrome fog
#

We'd never know until it's retrospect

ember storm
#

those describe stuff from the traveler's pov in the past

empty fern
#

Neat

ember storm
#

or maybe not

#

i dont remember

#

and im too lazy to look it up

chrome fog
#

I remember the lore tab of MK is just a reitteration of Unveiling kinda but not really

raw hazel
iron mortar
#

did we ever get a explanation about where ahamkara came from

#

because they weren't in the golden age

#

and I don't we got a clear answer where they came from

exotic cloak
#

They are evil iguanas

trim grotto
sharp osprey
#

i just rewatched the seraph finale, and while its an incredible scene, i was left with one question. Why does the Witness encourage Eramis to destroy the traveler if it needs the traveler for the final shape? Am I missing something?

jagged badge
#

Perhaps the Traveler wouldn’t have been affected by it and the Witness just wanted to satiate Eramis’ revenge and trigger Xivu’s ritual?

#

I don’t know tbh

sharp osprey
#

i mean maybe, as powerful as the warsats are, they are still ultimately causal and i doubt that they could truly destroy something like the traveler

exotic cloak
#

I mean even if Traveler was indeed destroyed how would that affect final shape? Like at what level would be that destruction

sharp osprey
#

or maybe it wouldve weakened the traveler enough to remove the guardians' power, making it easier for witness to work with it

#

idk

exotic cloak
#

Maybe warsats could actually damage it enough to make the witness work easier

#

Yeah that

#

Didn't traveler was damaged and weakened before?

sharp osprey
#

i mean the red legion supressed it

exotic cloak
#

Yeah maybe they could get that result

#

Not killing but yeah goodbye light and ability to move

sharp osprey
#

the traveler doesnt seem like something that can be blown up with regular old human nukes, its a literal god yknow

#

but it can probably be weakened by them

exotic cloak
#

I mean I'm not at day with the warsats but those don't seem to be just regular human nukes

sharp osprey
#

still, the point is that they still seem siginificantly less powerful than the traveler

iron mortar
exotic cloak
#

Big ball is just in another league

iron mortar
#

the light itself is paracausal and needs a something paracausal to counter it

#

but the light and traveler are separate things

sharp osprey
#

i think its just safe to make the conclusion that while eramis thought she would've destroyed the traveler in its entirety, the witness knew better and decided to use her to weaken it instead

raw hazel
#

That’s what my assumption always was

#

As the Witness seems to need the Traveler at least alive for its plan

sharp osprey
#

"Your Pale Heart holds the key"

raw hazel
#

That, and the Witness is a known manipulator

sharp osprey
#

yeah

raw hazel
#

If it can use you as a pawn to its ends, it will do its best to do so

#

Or even just out of spite for the Traveler, like it did with the Hive

sharp osprey
#

with the hive tho, i think the witness did that out of its strange sense of righteousness in what its doing with the philosophy of the final shape. The Light brings suffering etc

ember storm
#

always

raw hazel
#

It was mostly out of pettiness, especially with the context provided with Entelechy

#

Anything the Traveler touches, the Witness will go out of its way to cause it to suffer

sharp osprey
#

that makes sense, that book does show that the witness takes things very personally despite being someone of immense power

ember storm
#

are you saying the traveler is not paracausal

iron mortar
raw hazel
raw hazel
#

And yeah to be fair, there’s orders of magnitudes in different between Ghosts and the Traveler

#

The only thing that has been ever confirmed to harm it, is the Witness/its Black Fleet

#

In the case of the Warsats I’ve always figured it moved so the Last City wouldn’t be damaged/so it could be in position to confront the Witness

#

As we’ve seen it done in a few cases, like it trying to lure the Witness away from Riis, or when it moved away wreckage from the Almighty to keep it from impacting the City

ember storm
#

right but what does this have to do with not calling the traveler paracausal

raw hazel
#

Yeah that makes no sense to me

ember storm
#

defensive capability doesn’t matter, paracausality is just characterized by not being causal

#

the traveler is the prime example of it

raw hazel
#

The big lass is definitely paracausal

ember storm
#

and also if you want to be pedantic, light as a concept has been trumped by causal means numerous times

#

the red legion were drilling it out of the soil on Io, and the vex engineered a mind catered to specifically drain Saint’s light

#

likewise, you can just punch taken to death and set up fancy lamps to incapacitate pyramid ships

#

the veil is also just locked in a fancy basement

gentle geyser
#

The witness, a being of millions, unstoppable, controller of darkness, slain by bullets

raw hazel
#

(To be fair the ones doing the shooting are also paracausal)

ember storm
#

guardians have magic little light fairies that bless their bullets mid flight

chrome fog
#

That was what the example was supposed to illustrate

raw hazel
#

No they said the Traveler was causal

#

(Tho to be fair given how partly obscured lore in general is, it’s an honest mixup)

grand jungle
#

do we know of how powerfull the dare horse is?

ember storm
#

it’s beyond the universe but also not narratively relevant at all

raw hazel
#

In loose terms, extremely so, not that it would actually do anything beyond the funny gameshow tho

ember storm
#

it’s purely for jokes and there’s no use trying to gauge it at all

#

but Randal is canon

gentle geyser
chrome fog
outer dragon
gentle geyser
#

The horse wishes that you traverse its wacky obstacle course

empty merlin
#

Is tech machina and veist just weapon companies?

dim minnow
empty merlin
#

ahh i see

dim minnow
#

though they do have a few other items like armor, ships, sparrows, and Ghost Shells

empty merlin
#

Is there any other weapon foundries?

chrome fog
#

Omolon, Suros

empty merlin
#

forgot about those

dim minnow
chrome fog
#

Nadir is one that has been revealed recently

dim minnow
chrome fog
#

Crux/Lomar is the Gjallerhorn guys, right?

raw hazel
#

Hakke is the best

dim minnow
#

Hakke as well yes

#

Cassoid

#

Forces of the City is for the more generic weapons

#

oh also Daito

#

Daito for the... Eastern-inspired stuff

chrome fog
#

Weeb

#

Schtuff

raw hazel
#

For a second I read that as Datto

empty merlin
#

Same

chrome fog
#

Twin Tailed Fox and Jade Rabbit being notable examples of their wares

dim minnow
raw hazel
#

Astounding

dim minnow
raw hazel
#

He’s killing it tbh

dim minnow
#

Bungie could easily state that Daito helped make the FOTL Mech armor sets in canon

raw hazel
#

Say Dova

dim minnow
raw hazel
#

okay you got me there

#

But, anything in particular you wanna see in TFS?

gentle geyser
#

Unlikely but I want at least one single instance in the campaign of every single faction excluding the couple witness sided factions going after the witnesses forces

dim minnow
#

maybe an explanation on the Traveler's origins

#

perhaps a more in-depth look at the collapse

#

I'm still certain that some of the stuff in Unveiling is true though

#

like the Vex origins and the Tree of Silver Wings

raw hazel
#

I’d like to see some stuff on the Traveler too

#

I am also hoping we get see the actual Traveler ||so we can get married||

shadow crypt
#

Do Exos eat

#

Or have a feeling of hunger

raw hazel
#

FeelsThinkingMan Tho I guess my biggest thing is I want it all to at least feel narratively satisfying

dim minnow
dim minnow
#

Ada-1 certainly doesn't

#

but Cayde has been seen driking in a trailer once

gentle geyser
#

I mean cayde also likes noodle shops

#

If exos can bleed then they certainly can eat in some capacity

chrome fog
#

There is conflict with that one lore tab where an Exo says they don't need to eat/don't feel hungry anymore, but aside from an oopsie on the writers' side it could be taken as them understanding that eating is not wholly necessary to their function but still needs to be done to satisfy their subconcious

trim grotto
# shadow crypt Do Exos eat

Yes and no
They still desire food and have cravings but not a standard hunger developed from a lack of nourishment

#

And they do eat

iron mortar
#

How are exos powered though

#

Like is it just infinite energy bodies

#

Or do they use some kind of fuel

empty fern
#

It’s highly sustainable Clovis tech CATGRIN

iron mortar
#

But logically it makes sense if the traveler does bless worlds out of kindness and isn't running but leading the witness away

#

What I am confused about is why does the traveler love humanity so much to protect time and time again, compared to other races in the past

raw hazel
#

Every piece of evidence and lore we’ve gotten over the years have painted the picture that the Traveler is genuinely caring, kind, and benevolent. It loves life, and it’s pained whenever it sees strife fall unto others

If it suddenly were revealed to be some “uber villain” at the end of the story, when the last few years of painting the Witness as the ultimate villain… Imo, that would just be very bad writing.

#

As for why it stayed with humanity, lemme find the entry.

#

Basically the Traveler was tired of running, and this is where she chose to make her stand.

empty fern
#

Me when witness inkblot

raw hazel
#

mfw Witness

#

But it’s like, even then the Traveler has had plenty of opportunities to up and leave. But when the cards where down, time and again she stayed, and when it mattered she tried to fight against the Witness.

#

Sadly she’s just not much of a fighter herself, as powerful as it is. It’s a lifegiver.

empty fern
#

Wasn’t that cause the whole, surrounded thing?

raw hazel
#

Not really

#

That’s taking what the Witness says at face value (which you should never do, the Witness is a liar and manipulator)

empty fern
raw hazel
#

It loathes the Traveler, of course it’s going to take any opportunity to make her look bad, and make itself look better

empty fern
raw hazel
#

(And also maybe a minor point but the Traveler is not the one committing genocides across the universe)

#

The Witness tries to present itself as a natural force, the lesser evil, a necessary piece of the universe-

When its precusor species were simply upset that the Traveler didn’t give them a purpose, and then it into their own hands to believe they knew what was best for the entire universe (even to the point to killing off most everyone else of their own species that disagreed with them)

#

Mini-rant over but just like, I’ve always never been a fan of all the “big ball bad” theories over the years as there’s no support for them besides supposed ideas for the original plot

#

The analogy I’ve always used is like.. There’s someone endlessly being chased by an obsessed serial killer, and instead of blaming the killer, they blame the victim

next bobcat
#

Am I not a lore knower?

#

Surely you seen me around these parts

rich veldt
raw hazel
#

You are in this channel, but we do not grant you the rank of lorekeeper

next bobcat
#

What must I do

#

I have achieved paragon

rich veldt
#

paragon is not a requirement silly

next bobcat
#

Ah yes

#

Bionicle

next bobcat
#

But I trust your lore knowledge just the same

raw hazel
#

I mean I’ve been here for years

#

Unfortunately

next bobcat
#

Ask me a lore question

#

As in trivia

raw hazel
#

What’s two plus two?

#

Actually, I am curious to see if I can find my first message in the server

next bobcat
#

It’s either 4, or the battle of twilight gap.

#

One of those two

rich veldt
raw hazel
#

ah fuck right

#

I forgot about that

#

Still mad about that, I had some pretty primo lore rants from back in the day

rich veldt
#

im glad the lore stuff from back in my day is gone

raw hazel
#

Remember when Loonis thought we’d never get Darkness?

#

Hey @heavy vortex do you remember that???

#

(He’ll see that eventually)

raw hazel
#

I will bestow you… half a lore point

rich veldt
raw hazel
#

To be fair

#

At the time it was a really out there idea

rich veldt
#

it was

#

and there was that much bullshit misinfo it seemed like the right side to fight for

#

which side did you fight for hally hmmmm?

heavy vortex
raw hazel
#

I think I was very “but wouldn’t it be COOL IF WE DID???” Especially since it was pushing us into the idea of safely using Darkness

raw hazel
next bobcat
#

When shadowkeep was released I was like “yep that’s it we get darkness soon”

rich veldt
raw hazel
#

||though I will never let you forget||

raw hazel
#

We’ll see

rich veldt
next bobcat
#

remember when cayde was dead?

empty fern
#

Yea here’s a clip of him dying

next bobcat
#

Unvaulted cayde, unvaulted weapons, next will they unvault the rest?

#

Pls bring back scourge

#

And leviathan

#

And wrath

raw hazel
#

I would actually love Scourge or Wrath back

#

Excellent raids

#

Wrath especially I loved all the weapons

next bobcat
#

I never got to play them boohoo

raw hazel
#

Tho I do wonder what they would do for the exotic

next bobcat
#

What was wrath about? Siva one?

#

That was the one with outbreak model P

raw hazel
#

Yuh, the SIVA raid

next bobcat
#

What were the weapons?

raw hazel
#

This was back in D1 so they had set rolls

#

But each specific gun had a very fun combination

next bobcat
#

Example?

raw hazel
#

The MG was like

#

Triple Tap/FTTC on steroids

next bobcat
#

Mg

raw hazel
#

Lemme see if I can find a clip

next bobcat
#

What

#

What is an MG

#

Machine gun?

hallow holly
#

I think

next bobcat
raw hazel
#

Man, D1 Datto

hallow holly
raw hazel
#

So young and full of hope

raw hazel
hallow holly
next bobcat
#

Interesting weapon

#

Looks cool

#

What was the roll?

raw hazel
#

Triple Tap and Triple Double, when TT is triggered TD pulled extra rounds from reserves into the magazine

#

Back in D1 it actually was pretty decent as far damage

#

The auto was my favorite with Focused Firefly, when precision kills when Focused Fire was active would trigger an explosion

#

They were all kinda gimmicky like that but, they were still pretty neat

#

So it does make curious on what they would do if it was brought forward- Would the traits still be unique to each weapon in their pool, would they have new perks all together?

safe galleon
#

how hard is it, physically and mentally, to become a 'capable' guardian in-lore? like obviously it's not as easy as just having a full class kit the moment you wake up and then buying skills and aspects for glimmer and equipping them all, so how long would it take to, say for example, integrate into a specific class of guardian in-lore? including all the skills and abilities you'd need to be classed under the banner. months? years?

jagged badge
#

We’re obviously something of a prodigy

#

Many are still learning one subclass though

sick yew
#

Some have it easier
Some have it harder

#

Some master one and decide to learn another

#

Others will forever strive to perfect a single one

hardy anvil
#

what are the statues that are plastered heavily around in the Dreaming City?

dim minnow
#

the ghost scan patrols can often provide context

hardy anvil
#

Let's say Last Wish

#

for funsies

dim minnow
#

not quite sure

#

could be any notable Awoken figure

devout nimbus
hardy anvil
#

oh interesting

knotty musk
#

is there a tag search on ishtar? like to find pages with both “eliksni” and “season of the splicer”

#

wanna read entries on how they settled into the last city (like chroma rush) but don’t know which ones have that

next bobcat
#

Not sure

#

Ohhhhh so the precursors tried to make the portal to the pale heart before the traveler left?

#

Did it leave because it knew they would bring about the final shape?

sick yew
#

Let me check rq

#

If you go on Ishtar and search "Eliksni" the left hand side will have a bunch of tags from the various seasons

#

If you click that itll narrow the word search to that specific season package

knotty musk
#

oh, I was goin for the eliksni tag rather than searching the word. 2 tags don’t work I suppose. thank you!

next bobcat
#

is there an ishtar app?

sick yew
#

No clue

exotic cloak
next bobcat
#

Darn

#

Oh well

exotic cloak
#

I mean I think it is adapted to phone

#

the website

#

You can create direct access to websites so at least you have an icon

#

That is what I do with Newgrounds

next bobcat
#

interestung

#

i cant be bothered to do that

chrome fog
clear knot
#

The Traveler is roughly the size of the moon, right? In all the art it looks like the same size, only closer.

Our moon affects the tides of our oceans, guides nocturnal animals at night, and does other things (besides being haunted)

So with a second moon sized object, why aren't we getting flooded/dried up, are the aquatic ecosystems okay?

analog torrent
#

What search terms do I need to find fashion lore?
Already read Eva's Journey, Dawning Delights, and that one time a Warlock boasted about his Felwinter's Helm in GG
"fashion" usually shows usage of the word fashion as a manner of doing something and "shader" turns up the lore bits for 8 million shaders

empty fern
#

Maybe ghost stories

#

Yea much much smaller

#

Like 4 times ish

#

Wait

#

More than 4

ember storm
empty fern
#

Ooooo cabal holograms

ember storm
#

cabalogram

chrome fog
empty fern
#

Is that d1 or red war

ember storm
#

neither

#

worthy

#

you clown

empty fern
#

I’ll be damned

ember storm
#

you don’t remember the four minute cutscene where we discover the almighty is plummeting towards earth?

#

fake lore fan

empty fern
#

You hush that was like, shadowkeep era

#

And I skipped that era

blazing wasp
#

Everyone in the last city takes vitamin D supplements

empty fern
#

Ball moment

golden wolf
#

if I may ask, what exactly is the meaning behind the whole "O Bearer Mine" type thing the Ahamkara seem to do regularly?

chrome fog
#

It’s mystical~

empty fern
golden wolf
#

huh, could've sworn there was an actual reason for it outside of "it sounds funky, lets give it to the wish granting dragons"

ember storm
raw hazel
#

It’s used by the Ahamkara to invoke the Anthem Anatheme, by which they exert their will over reality by basically claiming ownership over the wisher.

ember storm
#

“O [blank] mine” is the actual phrase

#

bearer is specifically just referring to when you’re using ahamkara bones

#

you’re the bearer

golden wolf
#

yea, its the one I could think of off the top of my head so I used it as an example

raw hazel
#

It’s notable the Worm Gods also do it, since they feed in similar ways to Ahamkara.

And sometimes Ahamkara, and people who are not Ahamkara like Calus or Savathun, say it in regular speech just to be cheeky.

golden wolf
#

so what exactly is the Anthem Anatheme?

empty fern
#

A musical Score about a sea anemone

ember storm
#

it’s the power used to influence material reality

#

ahamkara have to do it because they feed on desires

#

Xol just did it because he could

empty fern
#

Worm moment

golden wolf
#

so the ahamkara basically use the "O <word here> Mine" phrase to stake a claim over the wisher and start the ability to manipulate reality to feed off the desire of the wisher? sounds complicated

ember storm
#

they’re not staking a claim

empty fern
#

Sounds too complicated

ember storm
#

there’s no ownership or anything involved

#

they just do that

blazing wasp
#

If that's true or not is, well

#

Questionable.

ember storm
#

I am statementable

golden wolf
#

truth to power being notorious for being vague in how true and factual it really is

ember storm
#

the problem isn’t being vague the problem is that it’s literally made as a lie

blazing wasp
#

The best liars make you question the truth

ember storm
#

stuff having small truths in it isn’t really intentional

#

it wasn’t left as a clue

#

Savathun just used some facts and twisted them to fuck with us

blazing wasp
#

So some parts are probably true, some parts are bullshit, it's ultimately just fucking with us

ember storm
#

same thing with Martian missives

empty fern
#

1 or 2 (pick a number)

golden wolf
#

17

empty fern
#

1 it is (since it’s closest)

raw hazel
empty fern
#

Time to talk about the sunbreakers and the followers of osiris

golden wolf
#

tf was option two then?

ember storm
empty fern
empty fern
ember storm
#

the sunbreakers were a mercenary group

#

they left the city after Osiris drama

#

that’s the extent of it

empty fern
#

Pain

ember storm
empty fern
#

What’s the sunbreaker lore tab rn?

ember storm
#

or what the mask is referencing

empty fern
empty fern
#

Oh

ember storm
#

why act this way

empty fern
#

I should ask you that

ember storm
#

wdym

empty fern
#

You know what mean

ember storm
#

I actually don’t

#

from what I can tell that’s just an actual reference to the mask

empty fern
raw hazel
#

I see nothing wrong here

ember storm
#

we should ask the expert

#

where’s jeem

raw hazel
#

Right behind you…

empty fern
#

Oh cool, byf says the worm in titan is ahasa https://youtube.com/shorts/bMWugh0fUKk?si=SVF9hInqDj7I4E3W

Deep within Titan's Methane Ocean, you might see a distant looming shadow. This is Ahsa, a proto-Worm God who escaped from Fundament when the Witness corrupted her species. She's been known as the Leviathan of Titan and the for the longest time the Drifter called her the "Long boy in the soup" before actually meeting her. She was a crucial part ...

▶ Play video
raw hazel
#

I suppose it would make sense

jagged badge
#

I thought this was established back in Deep

raw hazel
#

I’m admittedly less familiar with the lore of the last few seasons

#

(Due to extend game break)

jagged badge
#

No excuse, gonesensus

raw hazel
#

(And I’m just naturally skeptical of anything Byf)

jagged badge
#

Fair

empty fern
#

Wait

#

After we defeated the Worm God Xol, the whispers came for us. They led us to Io and the Lost Oasis. Within the Grove of Ulan-tan, we discovered a secret passageway into Io's underworld. A place of shadow, mystery and Taken monsters. But we were triumphant and discovered the Whisper of the Worm.
Subscribe to My name is Byf: http://www.youtube.com...

▶ Play video
#

Asphodelia might just be a flower but it seems like it's actually even older than The Witness. It's recorded as being on a Precursor ship's manifest from before the time of The Witness, but it's also been found in the Black Garden, which implies that it might even be as old as The Traveler.
Subscribe to My name is Byf: http://www.youtube.com/su...

▶ Play video
#

That’s all for now

ember storm
#

no explanation would ever explain how this happens

raw hazel
#

I, for one, am shook

dim minnow
ember storm
#

that sounds kind of stupid

dim minnow
#

so maybe they aren't resurrected and taken per say

ember storm
#

but then what else would explain the resurrected taken from Deep

dim minnow
#

they could be manifestations similar to counterfeit taken

ember storm
#

if they’re not more leftovers from Xol shenanigans, what are they doing there

empty fern
#

Wait

#

Did we finally get the name reveal for the planets boss?

dim minnow
ember storm
#

John Planet

dim minnow
#

Zo'aurc

empty fern
#

Ah

patent glen
#

Is there any lore about what the various bullets are in each gun in destiny or any images.

ember storm
#

I mean there’s not many specifics like what caliber a gun has

#

if a weapon’s ammunition is mentioned it’s usually just the distinction of whether or not it’s an actual bullet or pure energy

#

like graviton lance literally just shoots black holes

patent glen
#

I hope ratkings bullets have engraved rats on em.

empty fern
#

We don’t have projectiles for most weapons

#

Tho ghally does have wolf rounds

#

And thorn/malf have thorns

#

But you can’t tell that mid flight (since primaries don’t have mid flight)

ember storm
#

Shaxx giving the most insightful lore drop during Dawn:

#

“It shoots bullets, Saint. It’s a gun.”

iron mortar
#

also outside of terra forming, do you ever get a explanation of how the traveler gives knowledge

#

or did humans/other races just lock in when they saw worlds being terraformed

iron mortar
rich veldt
ember storm
iron mortar
ember storm
#

the opposite

#

they died out in the dark age

#

ours was the last one since he was born essentially right after the collapse

#

and yes, that made him incredibly old and decrepit by the time we meet him ingame

eager trout
#

Vex Mythoclast

ember storm
#

Fabian Strategy

chrome fog
exotic cloak
#

Both are accurate though

#

Big ball that looks like a machine and travels

#

The most iconic moment of destiny is seraph

#

The Traveler actually travels

raw hazel
#

You're technically correct

#

Which is the best kind of correct

chrome fog
#

But to that extent, the Traveler does not appear to belong to a species or race nor does it follow conventional sentient entity

forest yoke
#

What’s inside the traveler

#

Space baby

gentle geyser
smoky rose
#

Luna's howl's new lore tab is goated

#

(original lore tab)

smoky rose
#

Rip Luna

eager trout
#

How exactly do we get some of our enemies' weapons as exotics?

gentle geyser
#

Not super important

#

Not that hard to pick up a gun from a dead enemy

eager trout
#

What if...Destiny roleplay server?

chrome fog
#

Could probably find one on disboard or something else

eager trout
#

Ok, just searched that up. Now I'm scared.

next bobcat
sharp osprey
#

i never really fully understood how oryx was involved with riven, the dreaming city, shattered throne, mara, uldren, cayde, etc. Can someone give me a basic rundown?

next bobcat
#

Yes someone will answer that

#

In the meantime,

#

What’s going on with Ishtar collective website?

sharp osprey
#

weird

#

ishtar isnt an official bungie website is it?

fresh zephyr
#

uses the api

sharp osprey
#

but what i mean is that if this is an ARG, its not actual bungie doing it

rich veldt
rich veldt