#Server Challenge Submissions
1 messages · Page 67 of 1
f that is a big skill issue
why do you have "No randomized cycle durations" active? 

did i? i thought it didn't matter for 1 cycle challenges anyway
uhh but this is not a 1 cycle challenge
,.............r.ehjected.............................................
unless you carried the jetfish from SB in one cycle
is this acceptible
or not 1 cycle challenges, but challenges that would take less than 1 cycle record
it is not allowed unless stated
probably not
you could change your username tho
discord will force you to do so anyways
in the next few months i'm gonna be rrrrrrrrrrre anyway so
i just happened to get a long cycle? ¯_(ツ)_/¯
i mean, the username doesn't matter as much as the id
yeah... Speedrun validation totally snitched you out 
and I recall you having the same issue during your charged run 
yes, but this time i forgot to turn it off after symbiote instead
this is getting hot
@verbal mural oh! A fellow verifier! What do you think?
uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
it depends... If you actually had it on for your whole run that means it is invalid
i mean most of the challenge there's no way to tell just by looking at the gates and for the video portion it doesn't matter anyway
yeah
monk style? i have never turned that on
so if you forgot to turn it off after doing symbiote, that would imply you mistakenly left it on for the entire run 
i'm leaning on the side of invalidating it
im sorry
me too... I just feel bad to invalidate such hard work 
especially as the last one needed for ascended too 
true
i figured as much
time to slowly sap my remaining life away as i redeem my stupid ass
asbestos' brethren shall be known as hemorrhoid
Verified 
huzzahh
best white ever seen
where
on mushrooms
what software should i use to record videos
obs
Obs is the goat
idk i use builtin Xbox gamebar

obs doesnt work on my computer for some reason
obs
make it work
windows key + g
make sure your gpu isnt being hogged by something else
it said it woulnt work
the built in xbox live screen recording is good enough i think
I’m gonna do journey but I’m gonna download every single mod on the illegal mod list

is it the latest update
it said something about it not working on my driver
ugh thats annoying
you could update drivers that usually works but its annoying and tedious
i dont feel like doing it
yea i wouldnt either
the fact that i can easily do visitor but cant submit it is so fucking annoying to me
I've had some more ideas for challenges involving downpour. wish we had separate channel/thread to discuss that.

is the thirty referring to the number of challenges because that's a Lot
yep
ask server staff theyll probably do it
me waiting for that fabled ping in dp-soilers 
there are some very cool possible challenges for downpour
imagine the possibilities
oh, you want to hear it? 
i think the reason it doesnt exist yet is just bc its innaccesible to a lot of people bc of price and its only on pc
wouldnt be fair to some people
but idk
sure! I'm always curious about challenge ideas
true
a lot of the challenges we already heave seem like they would be annoying for console users to submit
I hope to see dp related challenges after dp realease on consoles
would be cool
downpour ranger
@tranquil stream do i need new gate screenshots for re-submission?
i wonder if it would become a seperate challenge or replace the old ranger
yes. The submission itself is invalid so you need to get a new set of gate screenshots 
i'm in industrial and forgot the SB > SL screenshot 

reminds me of the panic when i remembered i had forgotten the SI-FA gate screenshot while in sub as in guardian
good thing i had a screenshot right outside the gate that counted
yeah
but that is a big rip
you doing chef?
again, yes
ah, shoreline and gw are the easiest ones anyway
i went through shaded
but i don't know if i want to head to pebbles and then back or go back and get it now
all this finesse because my stupid ass forgot to click a checkbox
I believe you are doing it legit rn and with all other evidence you collect this one isn't a big deal
wait im a dumbass i think i forgor to resubmit the stupid
so you're letting this one slip is what you're saying
yes
ᵗʰᵃⁿᵏ ᵍᵒᵈ ᵃⁿᵈ ᵗʰᵃⁿᵏ ʸᵒᵘ
you can include the old one in case someone else is going to verify this and would be out of context
i'm torn between despair and relief right now
i've just that realized journey was my 10th challenge
tasty glup
thanks 
Verified 
wahee
Please turn off Key items on passage for future challenges 
sorry lo
It's not allowed, only verified because it didn't effect the challenge
And because it's <@&1098342948057399356> 
since i'm probably gonna go for all (or at least a good few more) of these challenges, what should i do about the few challenges i beat pre-1.9?
You have old challenges you did?
yeah
Were they ever verified
by drift yea
Drift?
Oh I see
Well if they've been verified in the past I believe you can double check with a staff to confirm it
they still keep records of pre-subsheet submissions afaik
you don't need to redo any challenges you did in the past
Yeah
ty 
I wonder who caused that pin 
Please tell me that these king vultures count as pacified
ah, doing the pain challenge
indeed
a bit undercooked but look kinda pacified
it can be confirmed if you show them trying to bite you
We call that rare vulture
the first guy decided to slam himself on the ground until he couldn't move any more while I was tenderizing the second one
I'll upload the full cycle video and hope it is verifiable
Here is the full video:
https://youtu.be/6pRucsZQf-A
Local slugcat asserts dominance over vultures
(Rain World Discord Challenge)
0:00 Start
3:32 First KV appears
6:16 Second KV appears
6:30 Both KV Pacified (?)
One of the vultures are incapable of walking when the 2 vultures are actually pacified, I'm really sorry I have to invalidate this 
:glue:kocyte

how do i get the champions role?
yoo congrats
god dang it that took a frikin while
if you dont recognise it its the shelter below the gate to fp
I have a question, do lizards stay in the shelter during passage?
just ask a staff for it if you have 10 challenges verified 
@verbal mural do you have this info? It would be very useful xd
thanks 
i have no idea how it works in v1.9 
just let them know, you should have your
soon
i just want to get this challenge done with 
i want to rest in the den right before fp though so i need to get this popcorn rq
oh my god
this is it
They passage with you
@tight estuary what room should i zap gibbon in?
I did the room that is the transition from memory conflux and RTA
hmm
this room?
oh this
ye 
yeah that room is really good because theres no risk of dying yourself
got it
you have to like go through memory conflux a little to get there right
mhm
sigh...
marty just got through like six DLLs
but he cannot for the life of him make a single leap
across a gap
just why
Is journey not too difficult?
journey is pretty easy
make sure to memorize your route though
(especially places like ds and fs)
Want to finish Spearmaster before I continue challenges
And I’ll start Saint once I get 20
I’m used to DS now I’ll just need to memorize FS
Journey isn’t that bad
Especially since no rando cycle is allowed
Unlike ascension 
well, I am proud to say that Marty proved his expertise in moving through hell filled with hell monsters. Now it is time to do it in zero G hehe
@tight estuary we dont have to record the entire cycle right? just the zap and eat?
ghotta record wakeup to eat
oh ok
thats okay i started recording from the beginning of the cycle
im currently paused out rn
The community helper gets asked instead of a chalver. Smh my head my head
@tight estuary can you verify my 6 hour passages run?
the community helper i trust more 
erm, I'm a gameplay helper 
Chalvers literally verify challenges. 
Who are you again?
Are you sure? Rules only say video of the zap and consumption
also uhh yeah
creep feeding lies to the challenge community ...
It’s always better to have waking up also
yeah
To show speedrun verification
yeah It shows speedrun verificaion
so we can check your remix settings and stuff
yeah fair
How’s that trust doing now? 
im ashamed to admit i have monk breath time leniency on, which invalidates the entire chef run /j
I mean I showed speedrun verifiction and thery didn't catch my warp mod/j
🤯
chalvers have a combined three braincells dw !! 
the only requirement to become a chalver is to submit your personal information to a staff
I wonder if anyone’s just reposted someone’s video before
I eat them when they fight over peanuts
I mean the one I verified you didn’t show it
I guess you did get your wish
Invalidated 
I really hope we get downpour challenges
(I'm so sorry abpout that the editing was horrible
)

Nah its fine. I already gave you the warning and you did for your chef so its all good lmao
😭
oh my god creep got moderated
Take [REDACTED] through the entirety of the wall to the leg back and forth in one cycle 
tunder you missed it I messed up bad 
There might be some once it comes out for consoles
That’s the main reason there isn’t any rn
We should just ask for them if they don’t release like a month after console releases
Also the sheet is gonna be a nightmare to fix with discords new name change 
shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh (/j i dunno what we can say)
I don’t either 
apperent;ly it'll be fine
I mean
yeah that's what some of the staff have been saying
I think it's causew of the user id yeah
You could come up with a devious Saint challenge
You can come up with some dp challenges if you want. I can give them to staff on your behalf or smth (or dms work too)
I can say, they care more about the challenge being interesting than difficult
So keep that in mind
all I'm gonna say is I may or may not have done soemthing with something 
The funny G one?


I kinda want to make a thread for downpour challenge ideas tbh
i still want some type of squit genocide challenge in a later batch
its the one thing i need in life
besides winning against creep in The Race
there are many brewing already atm
Well, do it and verify you did it, then show staff and they might consider it
Really?
adding to my list ...
Just prove you did the challenge, explain it, and show staff or a chalver

Imagine challenges for that one
this would be an awful challenge methinks
I feel there should at least be one challenge for them
So it can be mass 10 ranked

@tight estuary have you been getting progress on any other challenges after completing chef?
not yet, Ill do visitor and cheiftan maybe later tongiht though
actually lemme do visitor now
ah
my top priorities would be like scholar, leukocyte, chieftain in that order
https://youtu.be/V3UaDMYFJro visions eveal
all done
I'll probably do visions necxt on this save
Pilgrimage challenge: (Marty was a very good boy - we don't talk about exterior tho)
visions was really really really free, did it first try
hope it is sufficient like thi
Yeah it doesn't seem bad
it is indeed
waiting for the tab to load so i can snipe the peanut and give you the verify 
verified! 
i just mentioned it in the helper chat but you could ask any of the mods
sorry no thumbnail this time

its almost 2 am here, I would make one but it would suck and I know it XD
either way, good night fellow discorders
good night pilgrimager 
lol
Creep saying “I don’t plan on doing more challenges” * proceeds to do more challenges *
I changed my mind
truly showing one of the signs creep will become ascended

inability to stop doing challenges
the reason I decided to continue is so funny but also personal so i shall laugh about it to myself
how do you do the chieftain
get high rep with eastern SB scavs so they follow you to the SL gate
@tight estuary it has been done 
i barbecued my fish and then barbecued myself in shame
rest in pieces gibbon 
then if you rest when you're in the region they simply choose some of moon's dens as their new dens
thunder: hey guys I grilled my fish but also grilled myself
creep: SLOGGERS
Compress2Go also works. Allows you to pick its size in mbs too
its ok id rather upload it to yt anyway
and its only gonna take like 5 more mins
anyway im gonna start writing my submission because theres a few things i need to clear up in it
i was almost done with decension but the sky islands death was kinda weird so i think ima do the whole challenge again and use my practice to not get a 3 hour recording
akdfhk
helloo <@&904855320189370409> submission here :D
i don't have the screenshot of the sub/sl gate BUT i do have a screenshot of me chilling in SB_S05 (the shelter right before the gate) and laura said it should be fine as a substitute so yeah!
as for the video, i recorded the whole cycle so you guys can check the speedrun validation stuff, but the video is a terrible pain to watch due to frequent pausing & terrible jetfish antigrav movement, so i'd advise the unlucky chalver verifying this to skip to 18:25 to watch the zap + eat
now that the elephant is out of the room, heres the submission itself lol:
https://youtu.be/lFIfOAxUe5E
sorry no sound D: my obs bricked itself idk
the video wont load yet because its still processing and is such still private
you have a pretty slugcat
thank youu :)
7 more minutes until it goes public!
@tight estuary what did you rate chef out of 10?
I gave it an 8 persoanlly iirc
giving it a 7 to one up you 
i think it was more on the fun side though, looking back

dont scroll through my progress history
honestly i probably bumped it up one or two cause of my leg experience in the previous run lmao
oh yay it went public
now i can submit the challenge
@tight estuary feeling extra happy rn so ill go ahead and verify ur visitor challenge :)
@tight estuary use the tube worm method smh
The answer is always yes 
Bouta make chalvers listen to my favorite song on repeat for my vision run 
….. what song 
Science blaster by Cfish 
okay but which
besides chef
What haven’t you done
charged, collector, devotee, enlightenment, martyr, passages, symiote, and usurper
(and chef but im not doing that one yet)
Charged
I’m sure you can find the perfect song for it 
its not the song im worried about
i just dont wanna have to wait fo rthe baby centi to spawn 
impatient 
Guess who forgot to turn off random cycle duration and is drowning at the drainage gate 
Just get it from Industrial then
Time to restart 
but thats so much farther away 
I did it from Industrial 
shouldve posistioned yourself better /j
feel free to stream your suffering
(if I’m still awake when you get the baby centi lol)
i do not know when i will get it but i will let you know 
god tha temote is cursed
Verified
should get your role sometime!!
Usurper is going very well
that's gonna be my next challenge pretty soon, so I'll share your pain
The hardest part is having both disabled at the same time
It keeps happening, the first one beats itself against the ground until it can't move or jumps off a cliff before the 2nd is finished 
how to squidcada starve flight
i got it once but now i cant for some reason
(doing visitor)
If I beat Spearmaster tommorow I’ll start Journey
Backflips are easy to do once you get used to them
I backflip in gates for fun now
Recommendations: Maybe do it in an area with more mobility for you, or in an area with less mobility for the KVs…? That or demasking them really helps, from my experience
I would reccomend the room near the indust gate in chimney canopy
If you can collect a good amount of spears
The middle pieces allows for you to spam them with spears
And my recommendation would be the CC room to the west of the gate to the Wall. But on the top of the section…. Not the inside part 😅 that makes it really hard to verify
Or idk maybe I’m dumb
That rooms also good im just bad at dodging the spears currently
I was mostly just there in that clip because frustration 
I usually use the big long CC room near the Wall
I see i see. Fair!! Have you tried demasking them…? I swear my only two successful attempts were due to having both demasked. But it also sucks and I spent hours on Usurper 
I feel like I’m getting deja vu, I feel like I’ve seen you post Visions every time I see you in this chat, whar
oh yeah, if you demask a vulture will it fight you to the death then and there, or will they still try to run away if you bring them to low enough health?
They will stay.
Which handily proves that they’re pacified ^^ and you can injure them enough

I didn’t really notice the size diff between kings and normals until I demasked one
Is this the first time 
tyeah lol
Nooo stoppp
doing nomad or usurper next
I’ve verified like 5 Visions but it feels like more, it’s all blurring together
My closest attempt Ii had them both demasked. The only issue is that the first one likes to injure itself more before the 2nd is pacified, so they are not pacified at the same time

Do you mean….. Navigator 
Who did that lol
I'm gonna fall down the stair in a really fashionable way
It used to be Nomad, got renamed
Nomad passage copyright striked it
@quartz gull you have drawn the wrath of chalvers /lh
Hmmmm. Yeah…. I guess I just often put myself in the way to distract the second kv
but it’s definitely difficult.
Nomad > navigator 
Eh, I'll get it eventually. Maybe I'll try that room near Idustrial
I had Hunter spawns
- youtube vid for extra verification https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRP-xYnYKDo
2 more away from 10...
Uh guys, can somebody set my role to champion
I think only staff can do it, but chalvers can at least ping them. It might take a while, just continue doing challenges.
Only few of the chalvers are currently online
If you want I can at least ping them when they are back online and chatting
I was about to finish the downpour campaigns and then continue grinding for ascended
Your choice
Yea would be fine
you just commited to your fate at that moment
descension moment
Also isnt it 1AM in your timezone 
2

Okay apparently I have not grinded liz rep enough
CC lizards still attack me
this entire gang came out of a single pipe in the same time
these clowns always did this during my mother attempts
@dense geode I just got to SH echo with more than a quarter of a cycle left, but my memory got full and ended the recording 2 rooms before meeting it, which are basically free. Would it count? (the aura is present)
hmmmmmmm
big sloppa
I mean in the recording you can pretty much see it is a win from that point
You got 3 minutes to walk through 2 rooms
idk
we need to see you actually complete the objective
can i just start another recording and put them together?
what do you mean
his recording stopped due to full memory
you dont need to do devotee in one sitting if thats what you mean
i got out of memory
hang on let me find the gwyn quote
i changed my mind i mlazy
it was something like cycles in different save files and parallel timelines are ok
1 echo in 2 recordings, since I ran out of memory while 2 rooms from finish, free win
You can at least expect for me to finish the 30 seconds walk in 4 minutes
With no enemies
And 2 spears
thats what id say too. what exactly could kill the run at that point? i dont see an issue with putting the 2 clips together.
staff get final say tho 
if you dont purposely backtrack to kill yourself you are guaranteed to win
youre asking if a recording where it stops before you meet the echo is fine and im saying no it isnt
i dont know what else there is to be confused about
I can show a recording where i meet the echo too, but only if sliced due to my memory getting full.
as long as its obvious theyre the same cycle
Ok
this is why i have my timer on in all my runs, incase my recording bugs out 

demasked vultures can still run away. I swear they do it all the fucking time on me, and not just during the usurper.
it legitimately made me doubt the stories people tell about being hunted down by demasked vultures, but nope, they indeed becomes much more aggressive and single you out, it's just that sometimes they decide that they're not going to deal with you this cycle.
The way the work is that they make every other creature have much lower prey releation to them, meaning you are the preferred target most of the time, and they keep the demasked status even when the region is unloaded. Their crippled and pacified states are completely the same as before.
yeah, i know that they stayed demasked untill killed. I had survivor save where I had the same demasked vulture hunt me in industrial occasionally, when I would forget it even existed.
it's just that people kind of exxagerate demasked vulture behavior. "oooooh, it will hunt you down relentlessly and won't rest untill you're dead" and it's like nope, you can still make it back away and the hunt just means it will occasionally show up on some cycles.
Land fish
Can i ask you spmething
sure?
Were you the person who suggested a bunch of DP challenges yesterday in #downpour-spoilers
yes
Please never suggest challenges again ❤️
Ty ily
I'm not sorry and I will do it again

what did they suggest
if it is similar to pilgrimage
i will commit war crimes

I'm assuming it's about the sequel to pilgrimage. which, truth be told, wasn't a serious suggestion.
thats it
murder 
come on, don't you want to bring more friends on the journey
Challenge idea: Lineage the BLL in Spearmaster Shoreline and kill it
Feast v2
Anyways LF and CC and Depths until i do Devotee
SB can fuck off
Roadtrip: hmmm, bearable pilgrimage be like:
Adventurer: sounds hellish
Merchant, there is a limit or smth for shelters iirc. it starts deleting shit if you bring too much in (did it with vulture masks before, scammed)
Pilgrimage 2: just no
link to the message 
others sound interesting, but you need to think of some ways to make evidence reliable tbh
like for Adept
For merchant: The limit is 9 items of same type
Fasionist sounds like fun tho
alright
also
land fish
i am in the same boat as you with Fog

Most of these challenges seem to die to the same criteria Raven told me my challenge sucks
they're not real, we're being gaslighted
"Unoriginal" or "Do X but Y"
true
i have 600 hours, where are they
(like 200 is downpour, what the fuck)
WHERE 
thats the hard part with coming up with challenges
SB, near the SL entrance and the Safari den
i think of something i find cool, yet i find it similar to another challenge so i scrap it
staff sure can be blunt sometimes 
ill say it again though
the staff have said in the helper chat that its not so much the difficulty that matters. its the uniqueness
Meanwhile challenges:
Lineage, but Monk
Lineage, but 3 lineages.
Lineage, but tame and escort
Tame
Escort
Escort, but to a different place
@craggy plank (thought you may wanna hear this too)
real
I forgot Tame is also Lineage
if you can think of a unqiue or interesting challenge, the staff may be more likely to hear you out rather than something thats just mega hard
yep
lineage ones are the literal worst
lets just make the entire challenge rng 
seconded by escorts
honestly I think of challenges more in terms of interesting concepts, if they turn out to be hard that's mostly an accident.
My responses were just:
"Hard to setup" (others are too, and I would provide the save)
"It is just Artificer but Survivor" (ignored everything else the challenge is)
"There is no rain" (Ignored Hunted burden, Martyr does it too)
It is based around an easter egg in expedition, Hunted burden, and Metro in general, which seemed enough
Specifically when compared to "Pilg in one cycle" and "Dragon slayer in one cycle"
how is "hard to setup" a criteria when pilgrimage and feast exists. or do you need to sneakily include setup as part of the challenge and pretend that the grind doesn't suck.
idk ask staff
lineaging isn't a setup but a part of a challenge 
I also provided the save with setup done but they ignored it lol
shush
silence
also don't forget "do x but one cycle".
sieze
"Do Pilgrim but one cycle"
"Do Dragon Slayer but one cycle"
"Do Unfortunate Development but one cycle"
"Go ascend from the point you are tasked to ascend but one cycle"
challenges are made not only to test your skill but also your patience 
I mean I understand that they would want good challenges but looking at the existing ones... the bar is not that high. that's not to say they're bad, it's just that if those were suggested the majority of them could be rejected for being unoriginal or uninteresting.
I think people have enough patience to restart expeditions for 10 minutes and unlock a part of the expedition gamemode
Or to just take the save file
erm, basing a challenge on an rng factor basically invalidates it from being a "challenge" as there is nothing that is testing a player's skills, but only testing their luck which is not challenging, but once again, luck 
Yeah my response too. If it was for any other problem I wouldnt even care, but unoriginality being the problem is just a hilariously bad excuse
thus, it shouldnt even be a challenge to begin with 
I mean no hate towards the person who told me it is unoriginal, it was likely a group decision or something.
you prolly misstyped the word 'patience' more that once 
enlightenment is prime example. do x but y times. I like it conceptually but it's a huge time waster in practice. if you can do the trip once you can do it again. other collection challenges are at least either challenging (like mother) or require you to go different places with different methods that might be required to collect the stuff (like scholar and collector).
yeah, if we cut out the "unoriginal" challenges at most 15 will still be there
the point is fun
(which Enlightement lacks too)
so it is mostly just a bias
I mean ignoring challenges until DMed the thousandth time is a bit of bias on its own
patience shouldnt be the main focus of a challenge, as a challenge should test a players skill and knowledge of the game. Patience tests the mental capacity of an individual within a game that is ultimately built upon rng which doesnt sound like a good combo to me
(yes im just an impatient bitch but 6+ hours to just set up a challenge is complete bullshit)
(not to mention the other 20 to actually do it)
As someone who setupped Foe for an hour and a half, making challenges out of RNG is still a bad design
thats what im saying 
Why would someone flex over the fact they wasted 10 hours for nothing?
which is what all the lineage challenges are about 
Everyone could do that.
but it isn't the main focus. Just having some patience based challenges is ok 
Having SOME patience based challenge is ok, not making every second challlenge based around that.
some, but it feels like each challenge drop we always get another lineage x or patience based challenge and thats a bit much 
believe it or not i dont wanna spend 10 hours a day slogging away at a rain world challenge
because people somehow respect others wasting numerous hours 
do NOT ask timby their playtime hours, biggest mistake in my life

And that is not supposed to be the center of skill-based challenge list, right?
I actually don't want to have any lineage based challenges anymore 
(im just memeing around btw animo)
agreed
we have plenty
i prefer the challenges that test my skills of the game rather than my patience
At the end i just want to see what the "original" challenges are and slander it
this is like demonstrating your high endurance and determination
I mean, one good thing about community challenges that we are, in fact, part of community as well. server stuff might not make any challenges we suggest official, but it doesn't mean that we can't do them. we need to like. organize the suggestions and then we can just do them for the fun of it. maybe even keep track of people who completes them for some semblance of recognition.
Yet where is the "skill" part of "skill-based challenges"?
gone.
it doesnt exist on half of them.
"hey guys, i wasted 2 hours of my time slogging away to just set up a challenge (foe) that should take 13 minutes. ill take my reddit gold now"
what do you mean?

like there are a lot of skill based challenges on the list
where is the part where you are challenged in the "Enlightement" or "Feast" challenge?
i believe timby said it best. "Pilgrimage is hard for all the wrong reasons." i think that says enough about how stupid lineage and rng challenges are
some people just want the colour yknow
erm, it takes skill to throw that gas apple at the red centipede ill have you know!!! 
gatekeeping colours behing challenges is a bit questionable on its own
some of the hardest rated challenges barely require any skill.
skill check for pilgrimage: can you kill green and pink lizards? you're set, the rest is rng.
skill check for chef: do you know how to slide pounce? you're set, the rest is rng.
skill check for guardian: do you know how to regrab stuff? you're set, the rest is, you'll never guess it, rng.
tho i wouldnt mind having some basic ones available for those who dont want to do challenges for them
you didnt even question Mother or Devotee 
I mean, it's not limited to the ones i mentioned.
enlightment forces you to travel empty handed so you should avoid predators by moving around them rather than fighting
feast tests your preparation skills and courage to take on red centi
enlightment can be cheesed with max liz rep (which i highly recommend to save your sanity)
Devotee is so funny, out of all 7 objective only one is actually challenging and it's because of what? why, deer rng of course!
I mean "empty handed"
that is just fancy wording of doing the same thing over and over
1 trip from pebbles to moon already drains my soul
3 would kill me
slight overexageration but hey, comedy 
worst part? passages are not allowed
did you want to hear my argument or just nerdout on me? 
that's my opinion
you can do 9 trips with both hands. you can do 5 trips with vulture mask. if it was required to do it in 3 trips, now that would be actual challenge. but it doesn't.
animoso defending the challenges tooth and nail while still agreeing they are bullshit 
why is there no slugchad emote
keep in mind this is part of "easier" challenges so it is done mostly by people who don't bother with lizard rep or even know about it
art people make it happen 
and to be fair I did enlightenment in 3 trips without lizard rep and it wasn't even that difficult.
"avoid predators" = the concept of Rain World, and can also be ignored under certain conditions which make the challenge, even in the fancy wording, meaningless.
"courage to take on a red centipede" = will to start the challenge, which is not a part of the challenge itself
I love the fact people can adjust difficulty of the challenge by making various decisions
max liz rep can just completely cheese half the challenges
its so funny
yet they ban echo cheese and not it
grenades 
keep in mind that these challenges aren't usually done by
28/30 people
so you made a challenge whose entire point is to be avoided and not done?
post this to make staff ma- * bonked *

I honestly would like if challenges were made to be beaten
I can't see your actual arguments
you just say mine are invalid but nothing against
alt you're even losing me rn. wdym by this?
if the design around the challenge is that people dont need to do it, you are just ignoring the point of designing one
hi
it is to give more options and more fun, not to increase a number
hi
hi
the challenges are supposed to be fun or interesting things to do in rain world that also get u a nice color at the end
how is rng challenging? patience shouldnt be the main focus for multiple challenges
I hope you read the text above
Tanner descenting opinion detected
Enjoy your ban
how many "patience" based challenges are there?
any involving lineage
or escorts like pilgrimage
with escords I can't agree
guardian ill give a pass since you are in control of both creatures
pilg is
I can feel the ban hammer dropping down on you Tanner
but others are skill based
Feast, Pilgrimage, Enlightement, Safari, Devotee, Mother, a lot of them
if i get banned for voicing an opinion, then remember my last words
pilg can be skilled out too but it is more about rng
enlightment, devotee and mother don't belong on the list
lineage challenges can be kinda tedious yeah but i thought it was fun getting to mess around with a cyan lizard and even tho mc was painful it got me a lot of funny clips and as a bottom line i like Doing Rain World

enlightement not?
yes it isn't
idk how you found escorting a toddler in lizard form fun but i am glad you found joy in soemthing that tortured me for hours
the "you dont have to do them" argument sticks because theyre optional reasons to play more rain world if you dont know what else to do or gets you more involved in the community if you w0nt a color
I like pilgrimage! Take my 

pilgrimage is a character building exercise 
you go in a toddler and come out a beast
bc cyans are silly
so preparation is, by your words, not a big part of the challenge that shouldnt be used as an exuse to invalidate ideas?
yoinked
I will complain till the day you get unbanned for having an opinion non aligned with staff 
thank you calvus, your service will be appreciated
* banned *
tf is going on in that server 
mine was too silly 
there arent set standards for what is and isnt a valid challenge, we just talk about our options and add what we think is interesting lol
is there a reason for wall being banned for pilgriamge besides "haha, challenge harder now"
like, u can criticize pilgrimage or guardian or whatnot all u want but theyre staples of the server now and likely not going away any time soon
we arent asking for their removal lol
we can only improve the quality of challenges we add in future and give them as little tediousness as possible

Yet having bias as the only excuse while all other critism is explained is not a good feedback

we are simply stating our distaste for their existance while acknowledging they do exist
My favourite topic derailer
wehn will we get challenges that make it fun for verifers to verify..
its always focus on making them fun for the player to play, never for the verifer to verify..
idk i wasnt around anywhere near when pilgrimage was added
life hack
16x video speed
just wait for some
challenge to be dropped
u cant look at slugcat at 16x speed and not be entertained
give program
I can't see shit on 16x speed 
tell me you dont have adhd without telling me you dont have adhd

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/addon/videospeed/
https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/video-speed-controller/nffaoalbilbmmfgbnbgppjihopabppdk?hl=en
@rotund wharf (srry for ping) im actually pretty curious on this, do you know why? 
im on opera i cannot use 
I think that's the main reason why this challenge is so spicy
I am just curious how many critism was thought of when designing certain challenges
Elder was an idea focused only around 1 toll
you enjoy pilgrimage, your opinion is biased

im sure theres a video speed controller for opera?
true 
what do u mean
The first wording of challenge did not even think of the certain details the main focus has
It took me 10 minutes to see the flaw
afaik code wise besides outskirts there are always 6 scavs who are Soul Bound to a toll
besides Outskirts, yes
if it was not just rushed and brought by bias you could have seen it
it took me 10 minutes
true chads do elder at the garbage toll near stronghold. that way you must roll the dice that a random scav from the stronghold comes and steals a mask
i dont know what you mean by bias
charged 2.0, banned, next 
counter argument: no
There should be a challenge where you have to be tanning oil
when i was told the challenge idea i thought oh thats cute and then i playtested it and thought oh this is fun and it went perfectly smoothly for me
mistakes like that just slip through the cracks lol
so by just trolling the server staff and other members constantly oyu get a role color? cool
I mean, if we considered the design of all the other challenges, then this rejection would just sum up to "it sounds awkward"
this is so
-pilled
I'm going to say this again, but official server challenges don't have to be all there is. we can just make separate unofficial challenges. no color rewards for them, but if you want to do challenges just for color you probably won't be interested in anything extra anyway.
dp spoilers spotted, snipers alerted
yeah, it would be good
I didn’t say shit just basic mechanic

people with no dp would not know this basic mechanic.
wallstrat was found significantly later than many leg submissions so we didn't want to have it less interesting, and less fair to people who'd already done it
they have to look deep inside themselves to remember
Remember landfish
Remember
isnt it told in the steam page for it at the very introduction to gourmand 
pilgrimage was made before people figured out how to climb wall?
some real challenges lore 
no dp spoilers means no dp spoilers
i mean, i guesssss. im still gonna be unfairly angy about it

Gourmand is rotund
spoilers means spoiling the experience for someone
no, there's a very specific way to get the cyan to leap the gap in chimney, due to the lack of back wall affecting its pathing
I didn't read it. and i imagine some people are trying to avoid all information and go in completely blind. so.
for a few months it was thought to be impossible
@coral nimbus TAKE NOTES TAKE NOTES
do it with two cyans or else you don't have any angy rights 
Three cyans smh
id rather take a red to meet moon
oh, I see! 
looking forward to it
do it now
ill consider it
genuinely
don't forget to lineage it as survivor
i will commit a crime
What if I do pilgrimage with 5 cyans
I'll be impressed
asking for two competent lizards is already too much as I can observe
is that even possible. reds are so bad at following you and get easily distracted by literally anything they can eat.
really?
can they swim?
when i tamed a red for friend he stuck to me like glue
in my limited experience
if so it is doable
Incredibly well
they're the fastest swimmers. but they can't dive
the diving part is the problem
since it isnt a true community challenge id just dev tool him or spawn his id past parts where he needs to dive ig
if i get the red to shoreline, fuck it im cheating if it means moon gets to meet my big angry dog 
Wonder if moon has ai for meeting lizards
doubt it
don't think there's a dialogue for that
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1G-dlme2ZUCcqczKwxDgV_5SbuBNSePb6j4vyNF5pb0U/edit#gid=0 can this open for you?
Access Google Sheets with a personal Google account or Google Workspace account (for business use).
pebbles sure ignores your friends
lyn can i submit the taking red to shoreline then going to meet guardians? (see the joke is im ripping off 2 challenges at once)
where do y'all put your challenge suggestions btw? like I haven't heard there were ones being rejected. if you'd like to DM me maybe I have more time to explain the deal (I made like a big chunk of them)
i will inform others of this in the future. expect more dms 
lol
I DMed someone from staff for it
btw I never look in this thread I'm terrified this little subsphere exists I think challenge counts in your nicknames is vaguely missing what we were going for with them 
It’s a status symbol now 
depends, some post it here, some are in #downpour-spoilers for obvious reasons. if I may make a suggestion, maybe there should be a separate channel or thread to discuss challenge ideas, so people wouldn't have to bother staff directly and you can still see them.
the worst kind of symbol 
dp soilers!!!!! staff get him
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1G-dlme2ZUCcqczKwxDgV_5SbuBNSePb6j4vyNF5pb0U/edit?usp=sharing
for a lot of things its easier to just dm staff so we can be reactive to it rather than proactive
made this thing so it can be stored in one place
I'll discuss that with staff. originally we were thinking about a separate forum for peeps to explain their idea so there's less flam
Did you know that there are slugcats in rainwrold downpour
as a chalver i wouldnt mind a form. i wanna hear peoples new challenge ideas too and give feedback
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1G-dlme2ZUCcqczKwxDgV_5SbuBNSePb6j4vyNF5pb0U/edit?usp=sharing idk i might just redirect people to store it here
Think I have an idea for Spearmaster
just put it in, everyone has admins
(I have 0 knowledge how to properly administrate stuff)
Trying to think where I want challenge to take place
Peasants. None of ya'll bear to witness. As the sole completionism of RW 1.0 and Hurrican Mod 1.0 Deathless. I am the one who bears 100 challenges. Falter as I lay down my words.
y'all*
Proof?
What is it btw?
i wouldnt worry much about someone relatively dismissing your DP challenge btw, we arent anywhere near considering adding them yet because we need to wait for consoles to actually get the mod, and give enough time for people to get done playing through it, which took maybe 2 weeks to a month for pc
I am only angry about the feedback ironically countering the mindset used in creating the official challenges, if any other flaw was pointed out i would have just moved on.
cringe, what can be more important in their lives than playing dp 
invalid and unbased
No red creatures?
well assume its not possible for us to fully deny a challenge suggestion we wouldnt even be able to implement for a few months ;3 the decision process takes more than just a person making a comment, and we discuss over the course of a lot of days ^^
@dense geode perish for that ping 
nuh uh
I don't even know what a red creature is. 

ok lets stop this 
not a healthy attitude around another member, if you have gripes or qualms or queries you can let a staff know in DMs 
yeah sorry about that
Alt is full of rage
staff discussing something can mean we've projected it to discuss when important, we have our own lists of challenge ideas people send and one isnt getting stricken from it from 1 staff's vibes alone
hi hi jam jam
Hi
hi
I just beat another challenge
lol
congrats goon!!!
Sheeeeeeeeeeesh I consider you a God Tier Rw player. Welcome brother. We have free pancakes here.
holy wow thats impressive as hell
what was your strat for unbeating passages?
you refund the game and then you no longer have achievements because you no longer have game. the real challenge is to convince steam that 500+ hours is still refundable.

LOL
awesome challenge
Finally a good challenge 
Just delete your steam account smh
that's like a guardian skip, very un-gamer like 
Sorry for being un-gamer 
Verified 
thanks for helping the community
Just to say definitely please do submit ideas because we're not gonna stop releasing challenge sets until we run out of like.. role slots >:) lol
To give some perspective we have what.. 30 now? Including downpour ones (once console releases) reaching something like 60 wouldn't be unreasonable at all in a couple of years time :'D

The fact that you can bring a cyan lizard, (really jumpy loud crashing angry squishy dog) through one of the most hostile areas in the game on a time limit, and then sneak it past giant mobile spiderwebs with great hearing, and then get it across these giant pits without it falling off, and then take it through zero g to meet pebbles.. the fact that that is possible purely from the creature's desire to follow you and your ability to partly control it is amazing :D it's such an emergent journey and really highlights how insane RW's design is
bringing it up CC completely skips all of that 
It just sounds like rng to me, and a test of my patience..
have you done it? >:)
Yes I have
I was stuck in leg for 12 hours
So yeah I’m not too fond of it
Maybe the wonder you have has worn off on me ig
there's a lot more control you have over your lizzo than it first seems :>
clearly you have a skill issue. you should have done what I did which is the same thing you did but it took me an hour 
Do not get me started on my leg experience or I’ll bite your ear off
lol
some challenges just like that, you will have a horrible experience somewhere because rng said so. I had this problem with chef where getting fish out of subterranean took me more attempts than going through all other regions combined.
I just don’t see the fun in guiding a toddler through the harshest areas of the game. It’s complete rng if the lizard will do what you’d like to to do. Whether it be sit still or save your ass from a silly mistake on your end. To me, that sounds more like gambling rather than a challenge, as a challenge by my definition is something to test one’s skills and proficiency in a subject or activity. Pilgrimage, is not that.
jetfish oob 
Again my opinion, but there it is ig
And I can say the same thing similarly for all lineage challenges
there are plenty of strats you can use to make things easier on yourself :>

Cherry bombing failed, trying to send the lizard back didn’t work, just trying to get it to sit still and hide with me from the dlls barely worked in the first place
But blah. I got my answer ig
I just pray for less lineage challenges in the future 
lol
The leg dll strats for me were just: be faster than it
yess
Tried that
good cycle + nyooom
That one at the top though
Goober tried to fight the DLL and died
New challenge: Fully lineage Spearmaster Shoreline 
I will kill you
Trying to get to underhang
would say with lineage a lot of it is picking one den to lineage and cycling that as fast as possible
Survivor outskirts
Non downpour
I wish I nabbed my cyans id. He had to have the highest bravery I’ve seen in a cyan
Think again.
You'd be surprised, sometimes they're just silly
I think mine had 0.96 bravery
The what the huh
Funny
Nono. Goober would straight up walk up to the DLL when it wasn’t really threatening me and trying to fight it
I remember a very brave cyan that had almost 0 bravery and max nervousness on someones pilg run
remember that one time I gave challenge idea where you need to lineage red enemy in all regions? yeah me neither.
that was mine. nervous girl Nyx.
she tried to fight DLL, very proud of her
Nyx 
Tanner not muted 

you are back! 




