#sk-discussion

1 messages · Page 6986 of 1

graceful oyster
#

They weren't very fun puzzles

opaque sigil
#

the best puzzle game is blue prince

#

also the puzzliest

lavish apex
#

super metroid for its time is respectable and it's undeniably very influential, i would also rather eat a microwaved tire than replay it

light swan
#

i like the combat enough so if the bosses actually were good then things may go well

vivid belfry
#

the best puzzle game is Umineko if you're a fucking jackass who considers it a puzzle game

light swan
#

actually never mind nothing (metroidvania) is topping mio LOL

orchid spruce
#

i gave blue prince like 4 hours then decided i am too illiterate for this

exotic dome
#

portal 2...

orchid spruce
vivid belfry
#

best puzzle game that's actually a puzzle game is Outer Wilds

light swan
#

i thought about it and realized nothing could touch mio

lavish apex
#

samus returns is just bad

orchid spruce
#

i want braindead combat where i think nothing

lavish apex
#

that's not a good game

old raft
#

dude i read puzzle as pizza

opaque sigil
orchid spruce
#

like slopsols

exotic dome
#

who is this

vivid belfry
#

I don't know what else it would be

opaque sigil
#

if we count outer wilds it's the best puzzle game but it's a bit nontraditional (not that blue prince is totally traditional either)

light swan
#

if afterimage had actual good bosses and polished art it could 100% be better than silksong

vivid belfry
#

like it definitely has puzzles in it and those are one of the only things gating progression

light swan
#

since at the moment it already is better than silksong, i just enjoy witch crest

lavish apex
#

there is basically nothing good about samus returns

exotic dome
#

is there a good metroid game

light swan
opaque sigil
exotic dome
#

i'm thia close to changing this genres name to holloworbit

lavish apex
#

i don't like any of the metroid games that i've played

light swan
#

hollow memories in blasphemous

lavish apex
#

i might give prime remastered a shot and zero mission/fusion whenever i can be fucked enough to buy the nso expansion pack and play path of radiance

vivid belfry
#

okay so what you need to know about metroid prime is that the combat basically doesn't work at all

#

but the exploration is good

opaque sigil
lavish apex
#

but currently i don't enjoy the franchise

light swan
#

can we get poptlc representation here

vivid belfry
#

so if you like afterimage you'll probably like prime feelspkman

vivid belfry
#

I've only had bad experiences with castlevania, I understand

light swan
orchid spruce
opaque sigil
quartz cave
#

Are we talking about metroids

light swan
vivid belfry
lavish apex
#

afterimage combat works but the enemy design has universally been bad so far

quartz cave
#

Is metroid dread good

light swan
#

once you get into combos and shit it’s pretty fun

lavish apex
#

and it's also so easy that you barely have to try against literally anything

opaque sigil
lavish apex
#

as far as i've seen

graceful oyster
vivid belfry
#

let me repost my list of games that I actually recommend

exotic dome
light swan
#

it’s not the combat thats bad it’s what you fight

vivid belfry
opaque sigil
#

afterimage enemies are mostly punching bags but they're fairly fun bags to punch

lavish apex
#

maybe this is my fault for not playing on hard but like the game just tells you not to for a first run

orchid spruce
lavish apex
#

so idk

light swan
#

but the true ending 1 final boss is like… peak probabky

light swan
orchid spruce
#

is it

#

i will wait until blebbles finishes

light swan
#

like i’d put afterimages postgame combat above everything except witch crest and mio

orchid spruce
#

if he recommends the game, i'll play it

light swan
#

regular combat is like… blasphemous 2 level

graceful cairn
keen helm
#

i HATE seth bro he almost just ended my steel soul run

vivid belfry
#

is there anything wrong with it

exotic dome
#

everything about it is mid

vivid belfry
#

like the combat is completely brainless but you can just ignore it, and the platforming is good

graceful oyster
#

Ori 1 is decent at best

keen helm
#

i love the character and the story behind it and everything the fight just pisses me OFF

quartz cave
exotic dome
#

ori 1 could be decent if im really drunk

graceful cairn
#

very mid game

graceful oyster
#

I didn't not enjoy playing Ori, it's not bad at all, it just doesn't excel

quartz cave
#

Its not a masterpiece but i wouldnt call it a waste of time or something id rather not have played

light swan
#

seth is funny because it’s also a fight where everyone either loves it or hates it

graceful cairn
#

ori 2 improved on everything ori 1 was slacking on so its a great game

vivid belfry
#

I recommend Ori as training wheels for Mio

light swan
orchid spruce
#

Ori is not training wheel for MIO cmon

opaque sigil
light swan
#

and for the area, does it just look cool or is it much funner than everything else

exotic dome
#

ori insists upon itself

graceful cairn
#

mio is training for the tough bosses in ori 1

light swan
graceful oyster
#

Ori is a good primer for MIO because then you'll see just how much better MIO is

keen helm
orchid spruce
light swan
graceful oyster
quartz cave
exotic dome
#

only memorable thing was ginso tree escape

vivid belfry
keen helm
light swan
#

ok i guess y’all should sell me on pops combat

opaque sigil
#

idk if I could really do it justice

vivid belfry
#

it's some devil may cry shit

graceful oyster
#

Path of Pain???? Combat??? Are you deranged???

odd hull
#

hi !

opaque sigil
#

I don't want to say what the abilities are

quartz cave
opaque sigil
quartz cave
#

But then you add the abilities on top of that? And the potential is insane

quartz cave
#

Gets you feeling like a god at the winning attempt

opaque sigil
orchid spruce
#

potentialcombat is illusion's favourite type of combat

opaque sigil
#

there's stuff that can't be blocked and allat

light swan
quartz cave
#

Yeah theyre not too prescise and they can be made easier in settings

exotic dome
#

why does prince of persia have 4 dlcs

quartz cave
#

And they never feel like they overstay their welcome

exotic dome
#

they are skins nvm

cerulean sable
quartz cave
light swan
#

y’all already know my type of combat (mio, witch crest)

orchid spruce
#

potential combat

light swan
#

also xenoblade chronciles 3, my favorite combat system of all time, but that’s not metroidvaniaslop

orchid spruce
#

aka high ceiling

opaque sigil
#

pop lets you move enemies around a lot more

light swan
graceful cairn
lavish apex
#

i wish i liked xc3 combat more

orchid spruce
#

and you dont love afterimage combat do you

opaque sigil
exotic dome
light swan
#

it’s the bosses that arent satisfying, except 1 of them is

orchid spruce
quartz cave
#

One of my favorite combos is throwing them up to the air, comboing them, pushing them bach, dash into them midair, continue the combo, then slam them into the floor

#

Its so peak,.,.,..,.

opaque sigil
quartz cave
#

But if you do play poptlc PLEASE go to the training thing at base every now and then it geniunely teaches so much

lavish apex
#

it's quite hard for me to name any specific area that mio is like severely lacking in, i just have a few nitpicks

orchid spruce
#

i entrust you with whether i play afterimage or not blebbles

lavish apex
#

uhhhh ok

#

i mean regardless of what i say you should probably try it, just wait for a sale

#

i got it for $4

orchid spruce
#

i will try it if you recommend it

#

i trust you stupid_yi

graceful oyster
#

Eggnog is a problem
I have stuff to do but I am fiending for the hitless

opaque sigil
quartz cave
#

TRUE

light swan
#

i guess the word im looking for isnt high ceiling, but instead "depth"

quartz cave
#

Poptlc has quite some depth yes

lavish apex
#

my assessment thus far is if you're an exploration fiend it's probably great, though it has kind of a slow start

quartz cave
#

TO THE 3 POPTLC FANS
PLEASE
MAKE A RANDOMIZER MOD

exotic dome
#

another mv is getting glazed here, adding it to a wishlist

lavish apex
#

movement is quite enjoyable once you get the second upgrade as well

graceful oyster
#

I fully believe I have Nog down to the point where I could beat her hitless very slowly if I just backed off and became patient, but I'm too stuck trying to kill her fast

quartz cave
odd hull
#

Have anyone else played Ender Lilies?

exotic dome
#

i have

#

but dropped it

light swan
#

@opaque sigil @quartz cave do you think the combo capabilities are like ssbu or is it more of a secondary thing

odd hull
light swan
#

also whats buildcrafting/strategy like

quartz cave
#

-# what did ssbu stand for again

normal bramble
#

Smash bros ultimate

quartz cave
#

Oh smash

orchid spruce
odd hull
opaque sigil
light swan
# light swan i guess the word im looking for isnt high ceiling, but instead "depth"

like mio has depth in certain scenarios like when you shairpin, use the few bits of energy you got from shairpin to hold sail and power up your 3 hit combo with both BOP and foolish ideal
but the depth comes in by releasing sail right before the thrust to both fully restore energy, take advantage of kinetic thrust, and leave bop up just in time to shairpin (while bop boosted) again and continue the combo

quartz cave
#

Well i wouldnt say its as deep as a game designed for the entire gameplay loop to be entirely combat but thats not really something you can ask of any non combat only game

light swan
#

the perfect type of balance where every aspect feels wonderfully interconnected

light swan
rough anvil
#

Hi guysNuuVestigate

quartz cave
#

It for sure feels as fucking good as hitting a good combo in smash that i can attest to

orchid spruce
rough anvil
#

Touhou .. . .

light swan
#

i mean i already know im getting poptlc at some point but its good to know beforehand :D

opaque sigil
odd hull
orchid spruce
#

u played grime yet illu

exotic dome
# odd hull Why tho?

combat felt boring, level design wasn't that good iirc and i didn't really like the map system. i think i was gonna give one more chance but it got lost in the shuffle i guess

light swan
#

witch crest is less depth in combat and more depth in how well designed it is

lavish apex
#

also like, lowkey, i think mio probably has my favorite soundtrack in the genre

light swan
lavish apex
#

although silksong is close

orchid spruce
opaque sigil
#

I've played some of grime but never finished it

light swan
#

i dont have anything against chunky soulslike combat but its just not exactly like my cup of tea

opaque sigil
exotic dome
light swan
#

that may be apparent from my witch crest days :D

lavish apex
# lavish apex also like, lowkey, i think mio probably has my favorite soundtrack in the genre

Provided to YouTube by IDOL

The Chase · Nicolas Gueguen

MIO: Memories in Orbit (Original Game Soundtrack)

℗ Douze Dixièmes and Focus Entertainment, Kromatik, under exclusive license to Kid Katana Records

Released on: 2026-01-20

Choir: Mathis Capiaux
Choir: Marion Cassel
Choir: Manon Iattoni
Choir: Melody Linhart
Choir: John Linhart
Choi...

▶ Play video
orchid spruce
#

i already bought it so gotta finish it. maybe silksong will no longer be the worst metroidvania i played.

odd hull
orchid spruce
light swan
orchid spruce
lavish apex
keen helm
#

guys did they remove being able to lifeblood OD for free in memories???

exotic dome
lavish apex
#

i will never forget when the distorted part of Where You Come to Die kicked in in-game

#

for the first time

exotic dome
#

yeah that is so beautiful

quartz cave
#

I need to finish mio

graceful oyster
exotic dome
#

mio ost is really good

light swan
#

its hard to identify my tastes for the osts

graceful oyster
#

It's gonna stick in my memory for a while

opaque sigil
light swan
#

because while i deifnitely like mio ost more i cant tell why

quartz cave
#

Nothing really bad of it i guess but it simply hasnt managed to get me yet

opaque sigil
light swan
#

where are you at rn

exotic dome
quartz cave
#

And that just discourages reopening the game

orchid spruce
graceful oyster
#

9S has the best introduction I've ever played I think now that I think about it

orchid spruce
graceful cairn
opaque sigil
odd hull
graceful cairn
#

actually no dont play constance please its not worth it 😭

quartz cave
# exotic dome how many hours have you played

Idk its been a while since i last entered but i somewhat remember ||a scatecrow boss and a very colorful naturey area, also some unerground frozen tunnels i couldnt figure out what to do in||

opaque sigil
orchid spruce
#

guys stop telling me to go play games i dropped and refunded

orchid spruce
exotic dome
quartz cave
#

Am i because i know ive played at leas like 5 hours 💔

odd hull
orchid spruce
#

sorry i only play peaks

exotic dome
#

it gets infintely better trust the process

light swan
#

couldnt find the way to false knight its ok guys !

graceful oyster
light swan
#

trust the process

quartz cave
#

Once i finish brothership ill get back to it i suppose

exotic dome
light swan
graceful oyster
#

Yeah well Ismoil is sucks

light swan
#

the case of ||missing the wide open pathway next to mel and not being able to find hairpin||

orchid spruce
#

a guy i know made it up to crow without any abilities

exotic dome
orchid spruce
#

using some bizzare skips

quartz cave
#

I knew i wasnt too far but i thought id be at least decently into the early game what the fuck you mean im not out of crossroads

orchid spruce
light swan
opaque sigil
graceful oyster
orchid spruce
#

wait what

#

is that a common mio skip

quartz cave
graceful oyster
#

Yeah

light swan
#

its like... atempting to fight the big baldur

orchid spruce
light swan
#

without finding false knight

opaque sigil
#

I'm pretty sure I just did that the first time

light swan
#

thats basically where youre at i think

quartz cave
#

Well now i gotta find that i suppose

graceful oyster
#

I know someone whose 2nd ability was ||striders|| lol

quartz cave
#

Only other boss i remember is this like ||big machine with wind pushing up and down||

orchid spruce
#

who is that lmao

graceful oyster
#

They didn't unlock the feral undergrowth door till well after ||Blood||

exotic dome
orchid spruce
#

i think i forgor half the mio bosses

lavish apex
#

mio has really cool map design

light swan
#

nevermind

quartz cave
#

They have like four arms was i not supposed to fight them-

light swan
#

youre at hornet

orchid spruce
graceful oyster
#

Oh lawdy

light swan
#

or mantis lords

exotic dome
#

fourth xhorus

light swan
#

i thought you were stuck in the very first area in the game before ||egis|| lol

vivid belfry
#

MIO fucking sucks at fortnite

quartz cave
#

Wait was i supposed to find and fight crow before that guy?

light swan
quartz cave
#

Cause i did not do that

lavish apex
exotic dome
#

crow is like 3rd boss normally

opaque sigil
#

with mio the notion of an intended order especially early on is not really there

light swan
orchid spruce
#

I said this ten times now, but MIO communicated to me that I should try to reach everything I think is possible no matter how cheesy it feels because there's probably something there

orchid spruce
#

and I loved it, no other game did this for me

opaque sigil
#

yes

exotic dome
#

mio has the best map design in a mv

light swan
#

honestly im surprised blebbles is enjoying afterimages rewards because i could not remember the rewards being very good

opaque sigil
#

you just sorta naturally push your movement to its limits

visual musk
#

i genuinely just got a new favourite boss fight oh my god

opaque sigil
quartz cave
#

Well at least its good to know i am not like ultra super slow at progression

visual musk
#

i love ||first sinners fight|| SO much

light swan
lavish apex
#

i like it when there are treats everywhere

odd hull
light swan
#

we thought you were in moss grotto but you were in far fields lol

odd vine
#

yk lace? isnt she hornets aunt?

quartz cave
#

Did i like do dnail before fungal kinda shit or

lavish apex
#

talent points, health/mp upgrades, exp

light swan
#

mio is very nonlinear

quartz cave
#

Thats cool

visual musk
# odd hull Oh, she's cool

dude oh my goodness, ||the fight, the moveset, the music|| is absolutely amazing i love it so much. definately bunking ||fourth chorus|| to my second favourite 🥹

quartz cave
#

Also means im lost as fuck

opaque sigil
quartz cave
#

Last i left it i had no idea where to go even while following my trusty "go to every empty spot in the map"

light swan
lavish apex
#

i love how you can stroost through some doors and that's just on purpose

quartz cave
light swan
light swan
light swan
quartz cave
#

Only two dead ends i remember are a ||giant door with wind howling too strongly for me to go past it, and underground frozen tunnels||

light swan
#

WAIT NO IM WRONG

graceful oyster
#

MIO for the map design miosmoke
Nine Sols for the bosses stupid_yi
Silksong for the combat h_HornetSip
Hollow Knight for the vibes h_HollowCool

light swan
light swan
graceful oyster
light swan
#

so why is the thumbnail the ending

exotic dome
#

thumbnail is crazy

orchid spruce
quartz cave
light swan
odd hull
lavish apex
#

a jack of all trades if you will

light swan
#

||you shouldve gotten a key||

#

||it unlocks smth in the city||

quartz cave
light swan
#

just use that for now

graceful oyster
light swan
#

i want to get you back into the game 🥺

lavish apex
#

i still need to play nine sols that's required reading

orchid spruce
quartz cave
graceful oyster
#

9S is so so so good

exotic dome
#

vibes can be both hk and blas for me not sure

light swan
orchid spruce
#

the hk slander is crazy

light swan
graceful oyster
#

I wanted to ALSO put 9S as story but I had to pick one

patent heath
light swan
#

||in which case just go do whatever you were planning on doing ig||

lavish apex
#

he can dislike hk it's fine, not as annoying about it as some people here

quartz cave
light swan
#

i love hk

quartz cave
#

Theres this like these ||wind tunnels and simply no way for me to go forward||

quartz cave
#

So i left the area and went to the other side where i found crow

light swan
lavish apex
graceful oyster
light swan
lavish apex
#

dw

exotic dome
quartz cave
#

Im going to FUCKING GET IN so i can show you that i am STUPID

orchid spruce
lavish apex
light swan
graceful oyster
odd hull
lavish apex
opaque sigil
#

explore wherever you can go

odd hull
#

No bias

lavish apex
#

i mean like come on

graceful oyster
orchid spruce
#

MIO exploration is very good until last quarter of the game, it gets sluggggg

quartz cave
graceful oyster
chilly glacier
opaque sigil
orchid spruce
#

I wish there was a mod that hints at secrets like in blasphemous 2

orchid spruce
exotic dome
opaque sigil
#

there's like one thing that could be better signposted

odd hull
graceful oyster
lavish apex
#

yeah once you get to like, MIO SPOILS ||needing to do wheel stuff and get into canopy|| it's not super clear

orchid spruce
#

||the wheel puzzle|| i couldn't do it myself

quartz cave
#

aight char this is allegedly my map

orchid spruce
#

i had to look for help and i usually dont enjoy things as much when i dont do it myself

exotic dome
opaque sigil
graceful oyster
quartz cave
#

where should i head tunnels or right

exotic dome
#

what was wrong about ||canopy|| i dont remember it

odd hull
quartz cave
#

so they LIED to me

#

i COULDNT get past the tunnel

orchid spruce
#

i think i found ||canopy|| organically

quartz cave
#

whaddahell,.,.,,.,,.,,,,,..,.,.,,.,.,,.,,.

opaque sigil
chilly glacier
exotic dome
graceful oyster
chilly glacier
#

I love the OST a lot though

main ibex
#

is this talking about mio?

#

I bought that yesterday but i wanna finish zexion first

opaque sigil
light swan
#

tammo how would you rank pop combat compared to other metroidvanias

orchid spruce
opaque sigil
quartz cave
sinful agate
#

Alguien que hable español

opaque sigil
#

especially the pop mob combat it's just so much more interactive with enemies

sinful agate
#

?

quartz cave
quartz cave
normal bramble
chilly glacier
normal bramble
#

Trueeee

opaque sigil
sinful agate
chilly glacier
light swan
#

as in silksong, blasphemous

lavish apex
#

@graceful oyster did you ever post the full in-game version of Stargazing btw?

quartz cave
opaque sigil
light swan
#

alr great

#

how fast is the combat generally

opaque sigil
#

it's decently fast

light swan
#

would you say its about regular silksong level

iron trellis
#

i just thought of something, if the citadel runs on what appears to be steam, how the fuck does it produce so much polution

opaque sigil
light swan
#

what about movement, how much player movement is there

quartz cave
#

how far right did i need to go because this is the only place i saw but i just spotted another place above and i dont wanna round around the entire fucking area just to realize i could actually get past this lake so

opaque sigil
light swan
#

nice nice

quartz cave
#

i actually was begging for silksong to add running and they did

lavish apex
#

oh also illusion how's the mio gd level coming along

light swan
lavish apex
#

understandable

light swan
#

ill finish it at some point maybe but ive been playing other games

#
  • other things to work on when playing gd
#

also i have 2 friends making gd levels to xenoblade 3 songs, came out of nowhere and im so happy

opaque sigil
#

nice

light swan
#

one of them i rarely talk with and just got xc3fr jumpscared

quartz cave
#

the healing in this game kinda pmo

light swan
#

the other is aleph

vivid belfry
graceful oyster
opaque sigil
#

mio's lack of on demand healing really grew on me immensely

quartz cave
#

theres more than one kind of healing its been a while since ive played this shit

edgy patio
odd hull
# chilly glacier I've been listening to Mili ever since Miracle Milk, and they made the OST and I...

Idk the artstyle is strong for me — specially the scenarios and such, all beautiful. Ender Lilies doesn't play like HK/SK, reminds me a lot more of Dark Souls and Castlevania if you know them. The story is simple, but well written and made me feel it (which rarely happens personally)

If you decide to play it, both Relics (Charm's equivalent) and Spirits are very cool to try out and build around. Just don't be afraid of "waste resources" or something. The word I want doesn't exist in english I think uh.. it's a great game yeah

graceful oyster
opaque sigil
#

I liked having to actually be careful against bosses

graceful oyster
#

Clearly it resonates with me too

orchid spruce
light swan
#

i too love the healing, i wouldnt mind having actual heals because i think heals are a very interesting part of combat systems but the lack of healing isnt that bad

odd hull
orchid spruce
odd hull
opaque sigil
light swan
#

moreso, mios combat is great enough without healing

orchid spruce
#

so i suffered greatly

quartz cave
#

ok platforming feels like shit when you have to pay up your whole wallet to heal

hybrid flare
orchid spruce
#

i remember

hybrid flare
#

And thats generous yes

odd hull
hybrid flare
light swan
light swan
orchid spruce
lavish apex
hybrid flare
opaque sigil
#

I’d comfortably give mio a 10

hybrid flare
#

and the 2 bosses i've fought are like B or C tier ish

graceful oyster
#

I don't know if I'd put any games in an S+ tier but MIO and 9S are definitely S

#

Portal 2 is S+

light swan
hybrid flare
#

I'd rank MIO rn a 7

light swan
#

i think youre just too early to really be talking abotu it much tbh

hybrid flare
#

maybe it'll get better

opaque sigil
light swan
#

werent you stuck in forgotten crossroads like, two days ago

opaque sigil
#

??

graceful oyster
#

Clawline tech is weaksauce compared to hairpin

orchid spruce
#

tbf only one person does insane techs with it (@light swan )

hybrid flare
orchid spruce
odd hull
exotic dome
#

idc about techs hairpin does its job as a platforming tool

lavish apex
#

i think maybe my biggest problems with mio are the energy system as it applies to traversal and lack of satisfying burst movement but i have no idea how i would change the former

light swan
light swan
graceful oyster
hybrid flare
#

Personal biases aside, i dont know whats the best game ive ever played

light swan
#

at least grynne tried out the cool combat stuff i do but no one else has done shit at all

hybrid flare
opaque sigil
orchid spruce
opaque sigil
#

Well I shouldn’t say that. Made by a terrible person

odd hull
lavish apex
#

what's wrong with ori devs?

light swan
#

why are we slandering other games :(

opaque sigil
exotic dome
graceful oyster
#

Inscryption is also S

hybrid flare
#

Imo skong's better than ns, theres just more substance to skong in general and usually there isnt just 2 memorable bosses and characters

graceful oyster
#

And Caves of Qud

quartz cave
#

also whats up with the lack of checkpoints 💔

exotic dome
#

inscryption is great

vivid belfry
#

A game has to piss me off beyond belief for me to slander it

light swan
#

ok itll be hard for me to do my tier list

orchid spruce
vivid belfry
#

this is reserved for shit like Rogue Legacy and Circle of the Moon

hybrid flare
#

I will absolutely slander the shit out of every game i play despite how much i like

orchid spruce
#

i know the biggest rogue legacy 2 fan in the world

hybrid flare
#

this is natural

opaque sigil
orchid spruce
#

@Gregório

#

🙁

graceful oyster
#

I will slander Terraria

hybrid flare
#

yes we need more terraria slander

opaque sigil
lavish apex
#

outside of gachas or similar microtransaction slop i've never played a game that i truly hate

orchid spruce
#

delicious terraria slander!! (i never played it)

odd hull
hybrid flare
#

And blas 2 feelspkman

#

Blas 2's like an 8

vivid belfry
orchid spruce
#

everything above silksong except maybe grime which im playing stupid_yi

odd hull
#

But yeah, I think I can grasp better how it may feel

opaque sigil
#

I can’t think of the last time I played a game I genuinely hated

delicate temple
#

Game devs when they run out of boss ideas so they create another annoying ass spawner boss

hybrid flare
#

Odon

light swan
# light swan ok itll be hard for me to do my tier list

S+: Xenoblade Chronicles 3, MIO: Memories In Orbit, Hollow Knight: Silksong, Afterimage
S: Factorio, Nine Sols, Hollow Knight
A: Blasphemous 2, Xenoblade Chronicles X, Risk Of Rain 2, Xenoblade Chronicles 2
B: Laika: Aged Through Blood, Geometry Dash, Xenoblade Chronicles 1, Balatro, Hades

i feel bad for putting xenoblade 3 in the same tier as everything else in S

hybrid flare
delicate temple
#

Broodmother pisses me tf off because spawner bosses are straight lazy

orchid spruce
light swan
#

this is my top 16 put into tier list order

exotic dome
#

i don't hate any game either maybe league of legends

exotic dome
quartz cave
#

okay so where the fuck do i go now

orchid spruce
#

Odon can burn in hell

odd hull
lavish apex
#

i truly wish i liked xc3 as much as you or some of my friends do

quartz cave
#

all right paths are innaccessible, the tunnels are inaccessible, all ive gotten is the eye whatever that is

light swan
#

metroidvanias involve exploring on your own accord 😔

opaque sigil
light swan
#

i dont like being the only person who likes my #1 game of all time :(

hybrid flare
#

My S+ probably would be silksong, ultrakill and sekiro for now (i personally prefer bloodborne all things considered but its flawed as hell)

lavish apex
#

i mean you aren't

light swan
#

im the only person i talk to

opaque sigil
graceful oyster
#

Ultrakill Yi_Judge

light swan
exotic dome
#

my s+ is sk, lies of p and portal 2

hybrid flare
#

Ultrakill has very few flaws unironically

vivid belfry
#

what does it mean to hate a game

opaque sigil
light swan
#

although youre awesome tammo this is why youre my goat

quartz cave
#

the other spots i dont remember being anything i could get past either

opaque sigil
lavish apex
#

3 is definitely better than x although so are 1 and 2

light swan
#

at least theres like, 2 or 3 people i can talk to xenoblde about in my gd server

vivid belfry
#

that seems too generous

delicate temple
#

If broodmother keeps pissing me off I’m looking up a cheese because wtf

opaque sigil
exotic dome
light swan
lavish apex
#

x is a bad game that i like

vivid belfry
#

like I think BLUD was a massive disappointment and not worth playing but I didn't hate it

#

I hated rogue legacy

light swan
#

but if i were to put it higher i feel like thats nostalgia talking and not actually how much i like it

hybrid flare
#

S would be Nine slops, hollow knight, bloodborne, elden and hl2

light swan
#

part of why hk is so low, i feel like if i were to put it higher itd be purely nostalgia talking

orchid spruce
#

omg, nubbie likes nineslops

hybrid flare
#

forgot b2 and b1 but wtv

orchid spruce
#

i thought nineslops was mid stupid_yi

hybrid flare
odd hull
quartz cave
lavish apex
#

i haven't played 2 since i was 16, sometimes i wonder if doing that again would drop my opinion of it

#

i hope not

vivid belfry
#

I think every game in my top 25 is S tier

orchid spruce
#

we live a post-eggnog world

hybrid flare
vivid belfry
#

S+? that's gotta cut off at nine sols I think

quartz cave
opaque sigil
hybrid flare
#

Ive done one Ng+ run and i plan on doing another one

light swan
delicate temple
#

My #1 game of all time is Dishonored

vivid belfry
#

actually you know what, I have that big-ass list broken up my cateogry

hybrid flare
#

I fs played more games but i wouldnt know how to rank them, how do you compare fucking half life 2 to a metroidvania?

delicate temple
light swan
#

ofc this was 6 years after my xc2 grind, ive obviously replayed xc2 multiple times before

opaque sigil
shut quartz
#

….are you really telling me, that King Khann was THAT simple??? Only ONE try???elderC

opaque sigil
#

Especially with the mercenaries

vivid belfry
lavish apex
shut quartz
#

Now I’m starting to I understand why there were all those waves

odd hull
exotic dome
#

what the hell is blud

quartz cave
#

so where do i find the bell towr pass

opaque sigil
vivid belfry
# vivid belfry

important technicality: games in the masterpiece zone do NOT have to be easy to recommend feelspkman

lavish apex
odd hull
vivid belfry
hybrid flare
opaque sigil
#

Also that list reminded me I really hated echoes of wisdom

vivid belfry
light swan
vivid belfry
#

because I fucking hate playing SAEKO

quartz cave
#

this game SUCKS

vivid belfry
#

it makes me physically nauseous

lavish apex
#

x can be a far worse slog though

light swan
#

idk replaying 2 made me realize why xc3 was my favorite game and not 2

opaque sigil
slim thorn
lavish apex
#

fuck x
i love x but fuck that game

light swan
#

i love crossette and i love xenoblade 2 and i had a lot of fun but i just got bored

#

i was pretty invested in my 1 replay tho

lavish apex
#

i wish it was better

vivid belfry
light swan
#

probably because ive never actually interacted with high level 1 combat

vivid belfry
#

combined word count of 2.4 million

lavish apex
#

it could be so so much better

quartz cave
#

im going back to brothership i thinkt

lavish apex
#

but it isn't and the story is complete trash

opaque sigil
#

I should do a full playthrough of the series probably minus x

lavish apex
#

it's so frustrating

light swan
#

i did but i stopped at xc2 chapter 5 lol

opaque sigil
#

A fire emblem meteor is approaching however so maybe after that

#

And deep rock rogue core

light swan
#

i replayed all of xc3fr in the 2 weeks before mio released

#

again, cemented why xc3 was my favorite game of all time by far

orchid spruce
#

huh xenoblade isnt on steam

light swan
#

switch exclusive

orchid spruce
#

stupid_yi well never gonna can play it looks like

opaque sigil
#

You can just emulate

light swan
#

i need to learn how to edit to phonk songs now

lavish apex
orchid spruce
#

my potato cant run emulate

odd hull
orchid spruce
exotic dome
#

what genre is xc

rose flax
#

i just realized

light swan
#

openworld jrpg

opaque sigil
odd hull
lavish apex
#

mfw one of the coolest combat concepts in the series undercut by the fact that it invalidates 70% of the other systems

exotic dome
#

i dont thijk ive seen anything about xc i'm too far from switch games

light swan
#

sylvalum is probably the 2nd coolest area ive ever seen, cauldros is probably the 2nd most well designed area ive ever seen too

lavish apex
#

mfw miserable menuing with 0 thought to qol

rose flax
#

could hornet have been a male by any chance? or is any weaver genes guaranteed 2 x chromosomes?

light swan
exotic dome
#

not yet i will play it after blas2

orchid spruce
opaque sigil
#

The xenoblade x menus are genuinely miserable

light swan
lavish apex
light swan
#

the best thing to do is ignore all the bad stuff and look at all the good stuff

#

thats what i do to my favorite games :D

lavish apex
#

core crusher is satan

odd hull
light swan
#

most of them at least

rose flax
#

like if weavers reproduce with non weavers, could they make a male part-weaver?

opaque sigil
quartz cave
#

hiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii cna i get some help

winged urchin
#

hi

light swan
vivid belfry
opaque sigil
lavish apex
orchid spruce
#

if you are already stuck this early into Mio, the rest of the game sounds miserable

quartz cave
#

basically the same as earlier i geniunely dont know where to head to

opaque sigil
#

I got stuck briefly early on it happens

orchid spruce
#

did i get stuck early game

#

i cant remember

quartz cave
orchid spruce
#

i think i did... stupid_yi

light swan
quartz cave
#

also can we make sure of this because i dont wanna go all the way to the one on the left

opaque sigil
exotic dome
quartz cave
#

and i know the right one isnt it because i was just there

orchid spruce
#

i imagined artemis was like at ||haven|| or sth, this is not what i imagined as early game

light swan
rose flax
#

this isn’t silksong

#

i’m too sleep deprived for this

light swan
#

just for a dev to go and prove me wrong

graceful oyster
#

It is with great pleasure that I announce I have found the one and only genie lamp.
My first wish will be that water no longer evaporates!
My second wish will be that it rains all around the world like, 4 times as often as usual!
My third wish will be to cast the lamp into the center of the red giant star Betelgeuse!

light swan
quartz cave
#

i only have three keys one of them is for the hall, one for the aviary, and one for the silo

#

all of which ive used already

light swan
#

you went through this room. you got something from it i hope??

lavish apex
light swan
#

its ok blebbles if you didnt like bad games then i wouldnt have 1shotted pharsis

lavish apex
#

😭

quartz cave
#

sobbing emoji ill go back to the other side of the map iguess

light swan
#

dude how do you go through that and not pick the thing up at the end of it 😭 sorry lol

odd hull
graceful oyster
odd hull
#

Must be a unique experience for sure

quartz cave
#

is that where you get the bell tower pass

graceful oyster
#

Yes

quartz cave
#

fuck me

vivid belfry
light swan
# lavish apex 😭

the good old days of spamming aghasura cannon against the big noctilum giants for 15 hours paid off

#

dude how do i make a phonk edit of A&T this sucks

quartz cave
#

youre telling me i went right because i couldnt go left but i forgot something so i had to go left just to go right and i dont even have a dash 💔 im so stupid

lavish apex
#

why oh why oh why does changing class on cross even if you already had mastered weapons on make them default to the base ones for that class and remove all your arts

exotic dome
light swan
#

i dont even get how you forget something when you went through a platforming segment to get it

lavish apex
#

WHY
OH WHY
OH WHY
DID DE NOT PUT BUILD SAVES IN THE GAME WHEN 3 HAS THAT

odd hull
light swan
#

mio takes place in a spaceship right

opaque sigil
orchid spruce
#

thats the whole point of MIO, explore

light swan
#

the spaceship makes no sense when compared to the map

#

i made it make sense compared to the map and everything logicwise is flawless

quartz cave
#

ok i simply had not gone through the room yet the game said i had

shut quartz
#

Man. I got all the hearts in one day after leaving reaper crest behind and using wanderer+druid’s eyes+multibinder…what have I been doing all my play through

lavish apex
light swan
#

my hopes and dreams CRUSHED

#

by the lead QA saying "I honestly dont know XD"

graceful oyster
#

Lead QA

orchid spruce
light swan
#

yea QA

odd hull
graceful oyster
#

He is not the lead dev

light swan
#

mb lol

orchid spruce
#

team cherry probably doesnt know half the lores

#

but everyone helps them fill the gap

vivid belfry
graceful oyster
#

If anyone knows how the map fits into the model it's Brimm or Rain

light swan
odd hull
graceful oyster
#

I really want to have a Magic the Gathering game with Axelato but them French timezones are hard to catch

light swan
#

the only thing that supports the other side are these vague lines that HAPPEN to be POSITIONED where theoretical elevators are positioned

#

when ITS JUST SOME FUCKING DECORATION FRAME THING

#

i hate any other interpretation that isnt my interpretation

orchid spruce
#

i hate you too

light swan
#

i am my own intereptation tho

lavish apex
#

they should make a good video game

exotic dome
#

mio devs are a real one

odd hull
light swan
#

a real 11 12s

quartz roost
light swan
#

wait its 12 tenths

orchid spruce
#

then i played other things then looked back to reflect

heady iron
#

Team cherry knows that there is no lore

vivid belfry
light swan
#

anyway time to test a theory i had that would be crazy if it was true

odd hull
light swan
#

my hopes and dreams are crushed

orchid spruce
odd hull
light swan
#

i hate you axelato x2

orchid spruce
lavish apex
#

oh yeah another thing about xcxde that i hate, the limited tries on the cool multiplayer bosses

graceful oyster
#

I know Illusion knows but in MIO there is this very cool easter egg out of bounds where the devs imported conversations from the unofficial Discord and made NPC robots for the admins and regulars who were participating in the conversations huddled around a TV

#

That's pretty epic

orchid spruce
#

wait wut

light swan
#

and im not there because bird invited me too late 😡

orchid spruce
graceful oyster
light swan
exotic dome
light swan
#

and 12 of them were devs or smth

orchid spruce
#

lmao

#

just call it the official server atp

odd hull
light swan
orchid spruce
lavish apex
#

doesn't the actual official one only have like 1 channel for mio

orchid spruce
#

and that channel is DEAD

light swan
lavish apex
light swan
light swan
odd hull
vivid belfry
#

xenoblade intrigues me but I know I can't play them because they're a million fucking years long

light swan
#

they designed a whole medieval helmet for luky and a bucket of frogs for bucket

light swan
graceful oyster
#

Mist just gets a lazy purple guy

lavish apex
light swan
graceful oyster
#

And Cimdy gets a magenta one

vivid belfry
odd hull
light swan
orchid spruce
#

i only have 18 hours on slay the princess

light swan
orchid spruce
#

vn usually doesn't have that much playtime

light swan
#

that being said xenoblade 3 is also the only game to ever make me cry but we all know we cant trust me

vivid belfry
light swan
#

i think in terms of actual playtime, gd is obviously the most but xc3 is probably the 2nd most playtime i have on a game

graceful oyster
orchid spruce
vivid belfry
light swan
lavish apex
light swan
#

i dont think omori has made me cry or ttgc and those are pretty good at making people cry i think

vivid belfry
orchid spruce
#

whats the name of that game

light swan
#

if theres anything else id cry over itd be ttgc

orchid spruce
#

i wanna wishlist it

vivid belfry
#

SAEKO

lavish apex
#

undertale and nier replicant too maybe? not sure

orchid spruce
#

ok on it

graceful oyster
light swan
#

why am i listening to cauldros i wanna play mio

odd hull
light swan
light swan
#

which part

exotic dome
vivid belfry
#

Omori is the second worst it's ever been in terms of making me completely break down in tears

light swan
#

grover stop making people interested in Life Ruining Simulator you know what it did to you

orchid spruce
#

i never cried at a game before, except nine sols ending. got a bit emotional.

#

i am so heartless stupid_yi

light swan
vivid belfry
#

I know I'm a bad person, but I have an agenda to maintain

lavish apex
#

how much is saeko

odd hull
#

I think only TUNIC and Ender Lilies made me cry in my entire life.

orchid spruce
graceful oyster
#

I've never dropped a tear at a game, a couple have made me well up a bit

lavish apex
#

actually i'll just check

light swan
#

wait hold on there was a youtuber who i watched a lot before xc3 released

vivid belfry
heady iron
#

I don't think I've had a game make me cry but I've had a TV show and book do so

light swan
#

who went silent when xc3 released

vivid belfry
#

it will be on switch in June

graceful oyster
#

If I replay 9S the Heng scenes will probably make me tear up

lavish apex
#

ok i'll try it when the switch port hits

graceful oyster
#

The music already almost does

orchid spruce
graceful oyster
orchid spruce
#

😠

light swan
#

of all the things ive read, this is one of them

graceful oyster
#

I misspoke

orchid spruce
vivid belfry
lavish apex
#

i gotta get to umineko at some point

vivid belfry
light swan
#

WHEN i replay nine sols ill cry at the death of shanhai 9000 (cuz i think that happened)

vivid belfry
#

and I know nobody likes hearing that but it really is worth it

tawdry valley
graceful oyster
#

When Jietong rises from the dead and kills Kuafu that made my heart melt

light swan
#

ive been wanting to replay xc3 but playthroughs take a while

graceful oyster
#

Wait that's the wrong terminology

odd hull
graceful oyster
#

(Or is it?)

tawdry valley
# tawdry valley

Bennet foddy if he was cooler and whimsical and soulful in the way old forests and harsh winters are

lavish apex
#

i have no excuse not to replay xc3 rn

light swan
#

and playing on my switch is inconvenient

#

also controller drift is annoying

lavish apex
#

but i have other stuff to play

exotic dome
light swan
#

i knocked a rock out of my controller when replaying fr

graceful oyster
vivid belfry
#

I'm supposed to be playing Look Outside but it's scary

#

not in terms of horror but in terms of I have no fucking clue what I'm doing

orchid spruce
#

just look outside

graceful oyster
#

Oh hey Bwb is back

exotic dome
tawdry valley
#

Peaks of yore makes me feel like I’m sitting on the edge of a cliff I just hiked on a summer afternoon - enjoying freshly ground coffee and a hard earned view - whether the climb is a 10 meter boulder or a 500 meter mountain.
It’s devious how the game normalizes and concentrates player confidence

vivid belfry
odd hull
light swan
vivid belfry
tawdry valley
#

@vivid belfry peaks of yore looks like a rage game meant to break the player but it’s actually the exact opposite despite everything you’d think after looking into it

lavish apex
#

i do like xc3

tawdry valley
#

I realized how familiar that’s sounds and had to share

ancient mortar
# vivid belfry tooth mom

Oh yeah that dungeon is hard. just know you can do most non required areas at any point in the game

lavish apex
#

i dislike some things about it

vivid belfry
#

I was being too precious with healing resources and didn't know I was getting into a boss encounter

ancient mortar
#

so you can always come back at a higher level

glacial kelp
lavish apex
#

but to say i don't like the game as a whole at least somewhat would be false

vivid belfry
#

but also I wouldn't know I was being too precious because I don't know how to reliably make money yet

light swan
#

at least somewhat :(

vivid belfry
#

I played White Knuckle after all

lavish apex
#

the combat is fun even though i have gripes with it, the music is solid, sometimes fantastic, most of the quests are great

tawdry valley
#

That’s true but white knuckle looks frustrating and horrifying and actually is

glacial kelp
#

how could peaks of yore be bad when it has the word peak in it

lavish apex
#

the main story has great moments and i love the party as characters

tawdry valley
#

I’m an adrenaline junkie and as such think white knuckle is peak, even though it’s also a very well designed puzzle platformer and roguelike

graceful oyster
#

First time seeing people talk about White Knuckle outside of my friend group

exotic dome
#

white knuckle was fun but i've never finished it i think

exotic dome
vivid belfry
#

nobody's finished white knuckle because it doesn't have an ending yet feelspkman

light swan
#

a quick nohit on the second final boss of mio reaffirmed my love for this game

graceful oyster
#

Funnily enough silos is some of the only gameplay I've seen of it

tawdry valley
vivid belfry
#

silos feels like home to me now

graceful oyster
#

I won't be playing this I don't think

glacial kelp
tawdry valley
light swan
#

as in none of them appeal to him and he thinks their designs are lame and boring

#

i definitively think he only played xc2 for the badoinkadoinks

exotic dome
tawdry valley
glacial kelp
#

is white knuckle like purely exploration

light swan
#

stayed for the postgame customization but earlygame xc3 doesnt have postgame customization OR badoinkadoinks

tawdry valley
graceful oyster
vivid belfry
#

air exchange doesn't have shit on the fourth area

exotic dome
light swan
#

i know he tries to ragebait me a lot but of all the things that arent ragebait, xc3 proably is one of them

exotic dome
tawdry valley
# glacial kelp is white knuckle like purely exploration

There are sections that don’t have a time pressure mechanic.
100% of the game rewards you for exploring, most of the game has you being chased or hunted as a way to punish falling and reward using items/shortcuts creative planning

graceful oyster
glacial kelp
#

idk if i jive with pure climbing but it looks really good

light swan
graceful oyster
#

So you can trust me on this

ancient mortar
#

Im still deliberating on what game i'll play next. im probably gonna do a signalis challenge run but im not sure what next. Maybe ill replay some other old games in my library.

graceful oyster
lavish apex
#

i also think exploring the map in 3 is generally better than in the other numbered games

tawdry valley
light swan
graceful oyster
lavish apex
#

future redeemed cranks that up to 11, the gameplay loop there is crack