Which is your favourite Dark Phoenix design?

[obtuse pagoda]

didnt wee have this already

[tranquil fulcrum]

Eh

[finite compass]

I was thinking the same thing

[obtuse pagoda]

didnt we have this poll already???

[stray shard]

Yeah

[polar dirge]

much more a fan of the comic version but i will say, this shot for the movies one is pretty good

[tender summit]

we did yeah i think

[polar dirge]

round 2 i guess

[charred basalt]

the design in the movie was dope

[amber laurel]

we did, but it was comic vs last stand

[charred basalt]

loved dark phoenix too

[bitter lava]

It isn't any different, and I dislike the design from Dark Phoenix even more than The Last Stand.

[amber laurel]

Will the film industry ever get a burning chicken right 😆

[echo lichen]

The suit.

[marsh plaza]

The Dark Phoenix movie design was a good upgrade to the 2000s one, but comics wins every day for this character.

[onyx trail]

The last one was with X-men III, this one is with the Dark Phoenix movie

[bitter lava]

Bro guys obviously the comic version, GYATT

[untold citrus]

Comic version >>

[merry veldt]

Wait a minute

Haven't we done this before

[untold citrus]

Yes

[amber laurel]

Yes, but it was comic vs 2000's film.

[untold citrus]

Like a week or 2 ago

[obtuse pagoda]

oh

[onyx trail]

Different movies, same poll

[merry veldt]

Lame

[solid prawn]

i swear weve had this

oh

yea

[untold citrus]

It’s beautiful

[onyx trail]

I like the particle effects with Dark Phoenix but overall comic design is just better

[topaz hare]

Movie design is pretty but the comic one is just better

[solid prawn]

this

[bitter lava]

The comic version shows more of who she is to me. The movie version is just red :|

[merry veldt]

I like this one the best

[merry veldt]

Yeah, the movie version isn't creative AT all

It's just a red outfit, no design, no symbol

[untold citrus]

Is it just me or does fhe Phoenix saga not have a lot of phoenix? I’m 4 volumes in and I’ve seen her ONE TIME 😭

[merry veldt]

You could walk past someone wearing the Dark Phoenix outfit on the streets and you wouldn't know any different

[untold citrus]

^^

[merry veldt]

It gets more active later on

[untold citrus]

Nice

I think the Claremont design might just be the best design ever ( maybe excluding the white and yellow costume )

[gray quiver]

I hate the movie version. It's just red leather. Ion like it, never will. It's unoriginal and I prefer the red n yellow suit

[sudden lion]

its just cold

[untold citrus]

That’s the best one imo , it’s the only one that rivals the original

[sand lynx]

Yeah

[cedar jolt]

I'm not use to the actual person.

[merry veldt]

I'm going to post the three best Jean Grey costumes

[untold citrus]

That first one is just so good

[merry veldt]

Close fourth

[untold citrus]

Ehhhh

I don’t love that one

Here’s my HM’s

[valid cave]

idk im board

[merry veldt]

I already posted that saying "close fourth"

Those three are just better

[exotic sequoia]

The hair down’s prettier than the ponytail, in my opinion.

[merry veldt]

It's still the same exact costume

[exotic sequoia]

Worn differently…

Much like how the inside-out costume from NWH is the same exact one from FFH. Just worn differently, even though they’re technically the same I think they’re different enough to count as two separate ones even if they technically aren’t different ones

[merry veldt]

This is a stupid comparison. The costume isn't different because the hair is different, it literally changes nothing. Whereas in this example, the entire color scheme changes

We aren't judging hairstyles here, we're judging the costume.

Just because Superman has longer hair in one of these images, doesn't mean the costumes are different

Because they're the exact same costume

[exotic sequoia]

These two are the same exact costumes too. Just worn in a different way that changes the design

[merry veldt]

It changes the overall design, but we are judging the COSTUME

Not the HAIR STYLE

[exotic sequoia]

The hair style contributes to the design and the poll asked about the design

[merry veldt]

You replied to a conversation talking about people's favorite COSTUMES though

Not designs

[exotic sequoia]

You’re so bent out of shape because I think how the costume is worn contributes to the overall look lol

[merry veldt]

You're the one who keeps replying even though you're quite obviously wrong

[exotic sequoia]

Obviously wrong… for believing that the way a costume is worn contributes to the overall look…

I don’t think it’s irrelevant. Same with the Superman example you gave

[merry veldt]

My point proven

[exotic sequoia]

You keep replying too lol

If you’re trying to use this as a sort of “gotcha!” it doesn’t work because you do it too, when you could just not

But sure… moving on from the relevance of how a costume is worn.

[merry veldt]

I'm not sure pinging me five minutes after I stop talking is the best way to prove that "I keep replying"

[exotic sequoia]

I’m not even replying about the same thing anymore. I’ve moved the topic of costume/design onto your actual picks for the three best ones

… I was going to explain why I think the yellow suit is better than the green one, but Ducki seems pissed at me right now lol that even if I talk about something else besides the relevance of Jean’s hair to her costume, Ducki’s still hung up on that

[exotic sequoia]

Anyone else interested to have a nice chat, feel free to ping me lol

[merry veldt]

You did reply about the same thing five minutes after I stopped talking though, making a snide remark counts as stating on the topic

I'm not the one who's hung up on this, you keep replying to me and are trying to make me continue through insults 😭

[exotic sequoia]

I wasn’t trying to come off as snide in that comment. That’s just what I called the topic to make clear that I was happy to move onto a different one. You could feel free to name it whatever you prefer. Again, not trying to come off as snide here just fyi

[exotic sequoia]

And I never insulted you

I was trying to make clear I was moving onto another topic besides Jean’s hair

[vital forum]

cuz its js better

[twilit breach]

I meant to choose comic

[manic jay]

because its iconic obvi

[timid glen]

Isn't this the same poll we had a while ago???

[gusty hinge]

Why is this even a question, obviously the comic.

[ebon tide]

^^

[shut elk]

to clear up any confusion - yes, last week's poll was also about Dark Phoenix

they were intentionally back-to-back for the fun of it

all things considered, i quite liked the Phoenix visual effect they used for Sophie Turner

it really felt like she was burning up from the fire inside her

[exotic sequoia]

I like Sophia’s design better, but Famke’s performance and story better. But overall as for Jeans…

[late zenith]

Sometimes these movie writers need to realize it is a bad idea to change things.

[onyx trail]

Yeah the visual design with the particle effects is cool and I liked that but can we call that a costume design?