#Would you want to see a variant of Tony Stark?

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

naive zephyrBOT
#

Who would you cast?

naive zephyrBOT
umbral lion
#

Man, I miss him

novel robin
#

Nope

#

Hes dead

#

No reason to keep holding onto him

frosty barn
#

I miss him alot but making him a big or lead role would ruin his death, cameo of a variant would be enough

hard drum
#

As cameo played by the man himself rdj

plain oriole
#

Only if it’s an entirely different character played by an entirely different actor

round fern
#

He should return in secret wars

#

As well as cap

#

But only in secret wars

rare kite
#

I'm more if he's a small cameo but I don't need it

topaz sequoia
#

He had a great ending i think it’d be cool to see just a small cameo of him

viscid cedar
#

Need to cut down on cameos in general but in a proper illuminati it’s fine

severe gate
#

Secret wars should be as big of an event as infinity wars, if not bigger

spring plover
tacit glacier
#

I already have an idea of a Next movie or TV show Morgan grows up and makes her own suit the mark 3000 and her ai is her dad Tony and she becomes iron 3000

quick raptor
#

I'm sure he'll be returning in SW, even if it isn't his sacred timeline variant

novel robin
tribal thistle
#

So was Loki and now he has his own two season show

quick raptor
#

Tbf Loki wasn’t dead for long

#

Died in IW and briefly returned in EG which was just one year

#

In the comics, characters are constantly dead and revived

tribal thistle
tribal thistle
#

A small cameo wouldn’t be much

candid lava
#

If a cameo, it's mostly effective to get RDJ back.
A full role would undermine tony stark's sacrifice so I think only a small role/cameo could work

pseudo sinew
#

cameo is ok

#

if he's leading just ruins his death

flint ocean
#

the day they bring back Tony is the day I decide to stop watching MCU in general

flint ocean
pseudo sinew
#

also no not at all if it isn't RDJ

cedar fjord
#

RDJ had a good arc and it ended in the best way possible. I think it's fine if he's done. I can see you guys are comparing him to Loki but I just don't think it's the same

cedar fjord
tribal thistle
#

It would be cool that if Spider-Man is in the movie that he sees an iron man variant and like gets distracted or something

plain oriole
# round fern He should return in secret wars

A lot of advocates for him coming back as a variant would say that bringing him back as a variant doesn’t undermine his sacrifice because he’s a completely different character.

But where I take issue with this is that even if technically he’s a different character they don’t and won’t want you to treat him like he’s a different character. They want to bank on you cheering at RDJ’s Iron Man returning and the attachment fans had to that character, so as much as you can keep saying he’s technically a different person, he sure would never be treated like a different person nor would they want you to look at him like he’s a different person

#

They want to bank on your attachment to this version of the character specifically. It’s the reason why if he returns in Secret Wars it’ll be RDJ and not someone else entirely because they want his name, his face, his voice, his recognizability and his attachment to the audience

As a hypothetical, I wanna ask when Secret Wars comes what do you think would’ve generated more cheer from the audience? RDJ making his return as Iron Man or someone like Robert Pattinson playing a random variant of Iron Man we know nothing about? ||And if your answer ended up being RDJ’s return, then ask yourself why that was your answer?||

karmic mica
#

I think bringing a tony varient back as anything more then a cameo would just ruin it

pseudo sinew
#

rebooting characters again and bringing them back after death is extremely bad even if u cn be like "not the same guy cz multiverse"

#

it CAN be good as we saw w/ loki

#

but tht's bcz before his tv series he wasn't a "main character"

#

and whenever he was he was the antoganist

#

but in tony's case he was like extremely likeable

karmic mica
#

Tony is done

pseudo sinew
#

and pretty pivotal

pseudo sinew
karmic mica
#

Tony had the perfect ending

#

So keep it perfect

pseudo sinew
#

I'm fine with another tony who is not RDJ and even if he is RDJ someone who went through way different character development than Earth-616

karmic mica
#

And if they need to bring him back to try and keep marvel alive then that’s just pathetic

pseudo sinew
#

loki's ending was kind of boring

#

like literally nobody even cried

#

except thor being like "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO"

karmic mica
#

And no one liked Loki anyways

pseudo sinew
#

nobody as in characters in the movie

#

exactly

#

didn't even get a proper memorial

#

would've loved tht

karmic mica
#

Well

#

He might’ve

#

There was 5 years we didn’t see

pseudo sinew
#

how did a question abt a variant of tony get to loki

earnest oriole
#

Surprised we didnt see a Tony Stark variant in MoM

#

I heard rumours that Tim Cruise would play Superior Ironman or smth

#

And Ironman is in the Illumanatti in the comics

daring adder
#

Do y’all think they’ll somehow resurrect Tony in the MCU?

daring adder
earnest oriole
#

Ah ok

daring adder
#

Ik

earnest oriole
#

I usually swipe-type as its quicker

earnest oriole
dry estuary
#

i miss mcu tony 😭 i need him back fr

runic cobalt
#

Doesn't mean he doesn't have variants

runic cobalt
novel robin
tribal thistle
runic cobalt
#

it makes perfect sense to bring him back

#

the multiverse saga is not confusing bro

tribal thistle
#

The people that don’t want him in the movie isn’t denying the fact that there are variants. Most of it is that it’ll undermine the death of sacred timeline Tony. I personally think that a small cameo (especially if it’s with a different actor) wouldn’t do anything to undermine his death

steady robin
#

I think a young tony stark variant would be pretty fun. I liked the variant in the Iron Man legacy comic where he was sorcerer supreme or the current ultimate variant

tepid lotus
#

he shouldn't return at all

icy tartan
#

I would love seeing other variants of character with other actors

woeful palm
#

NO, I DON'T want that to happen at ALL.. cause ik marvel would that with all intent of cash grab and they'll fs compromise with his legacy so no.. never.. though it's surely going to happen

upper elk
#

Idk, on one end, I want to say yes, just cause the character is immortal not the actor and RDJ should not be eqaul to Tony stark/iron man:
RDJ =/= Tony Stark/Iron man
Cause then it would feel like he is "typcasted" and the ONLY one actor in the whole entire world to play on the role as Tony when that is simply not true when we have so many varients of bruce waynes/Batmans, Spider-Man/Spiderverse, Superman/Clark kents, list goes on, we can still keep having stories with the character without jeopardizing RDJ's protrayal, Yes, I get it, he is iconic, but that shouldn't be, "The end all, be all". Let another upcoming actor take on the role, variant or not.

But, on another end, I don't trust Disney and they seem to have a knack of butchering leagcies for profit/cash grab