#Who is your favourite live-action Spider-Man?

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

open vineBOT
#

Who do you want to see a sequel of soonest?

open vineBOT
digital pulsar
#

Each one of them is good in their own way, but the tobey maguire spider-man movies are my childhood and I need more of em

#

However tasm movies did feel cut short

restive herald
#

Love 'em all, but if I had to pick, I guess Tom

frigid tendon
#

I feel like Tom is most like peter personality wise but Garfield is the best action wise.

#

Tobey as much as i love him just isn't as good as the others

waxen flume
#

raimi had the best movies but andrew was the best spidey

acoustic thistle
#

Tobey is the best

#

I want to see a Andrew sequel

fleet wedge
#

I really like them all but if I had to pick it is Tom

grand smelt
#

I think Tom is the best acted

#

But I'll say I wish spider man was older like the other avengers

silk coyote
#

i think the reason people pick tobey is the nostalgia attached to him and not because he’s the best lol

worthy junco
#

Tobey is overrated and tom is close second but Andrew is the goat

worthy junco
silk coyote
#

andrew soloes though

torn socket
solemn plume
#

Andrew and imo it’s not that even that close

dreamy gorge
#

Mines is Nicholas Hammond, the late 1970s spidey and the very first live action adaption of peter parker imo

torn socket
dreamy gorge
torn socket
dreamy gorge
fathom laurel
#

Andrew deserves his trilogy

torn socket
lapis wind
#

I grew up on Tom Holland so I gotta chose him

barren bloom
#

I liked how grounded Garfield was and how it tried to stick to the golden/silver age of comics in terms of relatability

dreamy gorge
torn socket
#

I’m just talking about spider-man spideyshrug

dreamy gorge
torn socket
#

If only Miles had a live action iteration…

dreamy gorge
torn socket
#

For me, if danny devito was casted as Peni Parker I’d still count him in this conversation

night aspen
#

Tom is just better

dreamy gorge
torn socket
#

Never said he didn’t

dreamy gorge
shrewd token
#

It’s the dance

torn socket
#

Andrew Garfield for me. He is so accurate to the comics and he shows a lot of emotion. Tobey and Tom are good too.

marsh plover
#

All of them are great in their own way

ivory bough
lament cairn
ruby kindle
#

people say tobey is only the best due to nostalgic reasons, and you’d be correct. tobey is my spider-man 🔥

crystal goblet
#

Garfield

mossy laurel
#

No one can ever beat the OG in my eyes plus Tobey is nice AF irl even when he was meant to be undercover with the fam!!~

plush current
#

Toby still a favorite

dreamy gorge
grand smelt
#

agreed, at least imo

umbral spear
#

how is tobey losing this lol

#

he easily had the most consistent and well made films out of the trio lol

#

in terms of sequel honestly i don't even know

#

tobey's sequel would kinda be like him becoming a peter b parker type figure which would be nice i guess, seeing him finally settle down

#

andrew i wish actually got to be in good movies but due to the past record of just how badly he was wasted i doubt a third movie would really be good (as much as i wish he got a great film)

#

tom is the most inconsistent of the 3 and he has potential for a great spider-man movie with this next one but i have very large doubts that the mcu will actually deliver and actually make that kind of great film

ivory bough
#

Tobey is the best in my eyes, his movies are the only ones I rewatch regularly tbh

#

Some of the best comic book movies imo

grand smelt
#

Because Toby's series was a bit hokey and he came off a bit too old looking for the role

#

Plus that trilogy didn't handle female characters totally well

ivory bough
#

true it has its downs but for me it does everything else right

#

mj was atrocious tho

umbral spear
#

the writing in andrew's trilogy is abysmal all around

#

and in tom's pretty much everything, including mj are extremely underdeveloped

umbral spear
grand smelt
umbral spear
grand smelt
umbral spear
#

by quite a large margin

grand smelt
umbral spear
#

tom's mj is extremely underwritten

grand smelt
umbral spear
#

and has essentially no character traits other than being a love interest, not wanting to be dissapointed and being the "quirky girl" stereotype

#

tobey's mj as flawed as she is at the very least IS flawed as in actually has motivations, a character arc, flaws.....you know things actual characters have

cunning forge
#

Andrew just feels like a modern live action 616 spider man for me

#

Hes my fav

umbral spear
#

andrew would have pretty easily been my favorite if his movies were actually good

#

he's a great actor who was cast in bad movies

cunning forge
#

Tasm 1 was flawless while 2 is decent for me

umbral spear
#

the only things i like about tasm 1 other than castings is the basketball scene and the cgi lol

#

2 is just genuinely awful

#

tasm 2 turns spider-man into a "chosen one" character which quite literally undermines the entire point of what makes spider-man spider-man

#

(btw im talking about how they made it so that the only reason he was able to become spider-man was because his dad put his own dna in the spider. the entire point of spider-man is that anyone who gets bit by that spider could have ended up becoming spider-man)

cunning forge
#

Yeah i hate the chosen one part too

umbral spear
#

the entire parents arc shouldve been taken out

cunning forge
#

I love tasm 2 suit tho

umbral spear
#

the suit is really good

cunning forge
#

Rippes stright out of the comics

umbral spear
#

if tasm 2 just focused on one singular villain it could have been a much better film

#

and without the stupid parents stuff

#

and obviously better writing lol

cunning forge
#

I dont think electro shouls be in the movies anyway theres not much backstory to him

#

Harry was a meh

umbral spear
#

there should have just been a better and more well rounded antagonist

cunning forge
#

Rhino somehow worked as a little villian juat for the start

umbral spear
#

rhino is fine as the "villain of the week"

cunning forge
#

Yeah

umbral spear
#

but let him be a guy in a big rhino suit please

#

not some weird robot mech

cunning forge
#

Maybe both

#

A high tech rhino suit

#

Like in insomniac

umbral spear
#

yeah make him physically bigger

cunning forge
#

Sandman wouldve worked in tasm 2

#

Maybe have him lose his wife and daughter

umbral spear
#

nahhhh

#

sandman was really good in spider-man 3

cunning forge
#

He was but the venom problem

umbral spear
#

its not a good idea to recycle a villain who was already done really well in a movie

cunning forge
#

Yeah

umbral spear
#

i don't think we need another sandman in a spider-man film as a main antagonist

cunning forge
#

Maybe a lil clone saga would work in tasm 2 if it was changed then

#

Like ben riley ruining peter life after he graduated

umbral spear
#

idk if a clone arc would work well that early on lol

#

imo they shouldve just chosen one villain and built a compelling story for him

#

the best spider-man films USUALLY are the ones that have a strong antagonist with a personal connection to peter

cunning forge
#

Im thinking kraven

umbral spear
#

the only case where multiple antaognists works is across the spider-verse because both miguel and spot are handled with perfection

cunning forge
#

Wait nvm

#

Ok prowler could be a side villian then, building off a tasm miles morales spin off then have mr negative as main villian

cunning forge
grand smelt
#

I want him to face venom but idk about black cat

umbral spear
#

in this time when he's devoting all his time to spider-man it would make perfect sense for him to fall in love with felicai

#

venom prolly wont be in spider man 4

#

since they prolly saving his suit for avengers secret wars

grand smelt
#

I don't think he should fall in love

umbral spear
#

it would make sense narratively

grand smelt
#

Idk

#

I think he needs to be without romance for once

#

Good change of pace

umbral spear
#

it would be very different

grand smelt
umbral spear
#

also it makes sense for him to veer towards someone like felicia

#

she's the opposite of mj

grand smelt
#

Maybe they can do a valentine day special about Peter and Felicia failing as a couple

umbral spear
#

nah itll be a spider man 4 thing

#

and prolly 5

#

then you can have mj again in 6

#

but no mj and ned till 6

#

except as small cameos

#

they should not remember peter till 6

umbral spear
#

problem is tom holland's only been in one great spider-man film

#

that was homecoming

#

nwh is a 7/10 and overrated as hell

#

ffh is actually bad

torn socket
#

obviously the OG

south swan
gaunt wren
#

amazing spider man

toxic tinsel
#

Thor

umbral spear
#

well yeah obviously

#

but it makes him not the best spider-man

#

best live action is easily tobey since he has the best movies out of the lot

#

if we were talking animated as well shameik would easily take it but this is just live action

umbral spear
#

japanese spider-man sweeps

grand smelt
#

I've only seen clips of him

thin skiff
#

How is Tom winning this lol

#

Worst of the three

civic moth
#

Actually none of them is the worst.. it’s just abt whose better

vale plinth
#

Tom’s a good actor

#

Andrew is objectively the best Actor out of the three

#

But I feel as though Tobey had more consistency when it comes to being not shit

#

TASM 1 wasn’t god awful, but it was mid. All TASM 2 really had going for it was the CGI, Andrew and Emma and the OST.

#

Tom was great in Civil War but all his solo movies were kinda mid

#

Homecoming was pretty good

#

But Spider-Man 1, 2, and 3 are all consistently pretty good

#

Even at their worst they’re still enjoyable movies