#How long should killed heroes stay dead?

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

mint groveBOT
#

Which character do you think shouldn't have been resurrected when they did?

mint groveBOT
swift ember
#

Until they have a good reason to return

tardy narwhal
#

I mean they should if like it’s a popular character

late harbor
#

tony should come back

silk verge
prime jay
fiery gull
pure holly
late harbor
#

yeah explain

prime jay
fiery gull
silk verge
#

We need proof

late harbor
#

😐

quasi spoke
#

Depends on what character

prime jay
#

There's also a lot of ways to bring Tony back

silk verge
#

How?

late harbor
#

i doubt they will tho

prime jay
#
  1. The same way they got Loki back
  2. Get a new Tony from the multiverse
late harbor
#

rdjs getting old he cant act anymore 😭

silk verge
prime jay
#
  1. Bring Tony back in an A.I
late harbor
#

well hell retire one day innit

silk verge
late harbor
#

ik

quasi spoke
#

Mar vell should never be resurrected but it should be at least a year or two with big deaths

silk verge
late harbor
prime jay
#

Tom Cruise is like 61

#

Age doesn't matter most of the time

late harbor
#

not enough time to bring him back tho isnt it

north sequoia
#

depends

#

it’s definitely possible

late harbor
#

what is he gonna act in 1 film and die again?

#

kinda dull lmaoo

prime jay
#

They can have an older Tony easily

pure holly
#

It not that they can’t bring him back it the fact that if he comes back then he death feels pointless

late harbor
#

plus theres only gonna be like two or three more avengers films

little sinew
#

never for the most part, but there are exception

late harbor
#

idk they could bring him back but i just doubt

#

same with nat

#

shes not old but i think her contract ended with marvel or sm

late harbor
sand remnant
#

A couple months at most

prime jay
# pure holly It not that they can’t bring him back it the fact that if he comes back then he ...

Just do it like the comics, have him as an A.I in Ironheart, then have him get back to his old body or find a way to clone a body similar to how The Jackal does them in the comics and have him go through a phase where he doubts himself about being real and then go back to his prime, or just introduce Arno Stark but change his whole character in order to have an Iron Man, but that'll screw it up

somber bison
#

I can only hope that the mcu kills and brings back Jean Grey at least 7 times

mystic gyro
#

Don't

#

Fucking

#

Revive

#

Anyone

#

It makes legacy characters pointless

#

It makes death meaningless

golden forge
#

10 years is long enough for the new generation to come and see them back again

obsidian bobcat
#

death is pointless if it can just be erased

#

characters shouldn't be brought back within the same continuity

mystic gyro
proven salmon
#

im so late to this plz

pure holly
# proven salmon im so late to this plz

I’ll fill you in some people believe characters shouldn’t be brought back from the dead because it would ruin the whole point of their death and others think they should come back in other ways

proven salmon
#

what abt captain america bro-

pure holly
#

I mean he’s not dead just old

proven salmon
#

he did die tho

#

from being frozen underwater

pure holly
#

When?

#

Plz respond when did he died

#

I did not know of this

fiery gull
pure holly
fiery gull
#

yeah but I'm pretty sure they confirmed his death in ||the falcon and the winter soldier||

pure holly
#

I looked it up they haven’t confirmed it but it would make sense

fading cobalt
#

Unless it's an annoying character nobody liked... then they should stay dead

#

But no one wants their favorite character to be dead cause then they don't get any content of their favorite hero

#

I think DC pulls off resurrection very well because they actually have the Lazarus pit and lore behind it relating to ras al ghul

pure holly
low schooner
#

Most of the times – either immediately or never
Other times 3-10 years – and the least times longer than a decade

woeful maple
#

Woah i have no idea on how to answer the question

somber bison
#

But if we stopped resurrecting characters then writers would have to stop killing them for cheap shock value when they can’t figure out how to write a genuine emotional beat

prime jay
#

And now out of nowhere she returns, she makes her family forget that she even died and they know that she's a mutant or whatever

#

Lazy writing

somber bison
#

Yeah I mean lazy shock death and recovery has been the MO of the X-men for the past 5 years

restive breach
#

Tbh they shouldn’t kill off unless they stay dead

#

Unless it’s for

#

Twists and shi

fossil dust
#

No, I don’t think I will

spare parrot
north root
#

some deserve to die permanently

#

like Barry Allen

#

let my man Wally be the Flash

proven salmon
#

No point to killing a character if they’ll just come back a few issues/ days/ weeks later

pine flax
proven salmon
#

No og characters=No grossing

#

So it's obvious some of them will return

silk verge
#

Like they do in the fast and furious series

proven salmon
violet vector
neon zinc
#

its a writing pit now, no matter who you kill in a comicbooks the impact is hard to make tangible b/c lmao theyre alive again syndrome.

#

the worst part is now writers are doing it because its a "Buy in for the character"

prime jay
#

One of the few characters that stayed dead in 616 was probably just Gwen

#

And Hobie's clone

north root
prime jay
#

So they basically had their own Hobie/Prowler but unfortunately the clone died

#

But the original Hobie is alive and he is Hornet currently

north root
prime jay
#

I didn't like Ben ss the jackal but I get it

#

Dying 27 times can fuck you up

north root
#

which is great

#

love Hobie

prime jay
#

Prowler isn't certainly meant to be a villain

proven salmon
#

Just let them die and stay dead

prime jay
#

And we only saw him as Hornet during king in black

#

Not sure how I really feel about him as Hornet

north root
#

maybe a bit hard to work with, but he'll cooperate when it comes to fighting Kingpin

prime jay
#

Yeah

#

Well not that hard

#

He works perfectly well with Peter

#

And he was good as Spider-Man disregarding the fact of him having no powers

bronze patrol
#

Jason Todd

#

Bro could have stayed dead for a few more years

north root
bronze patrol
#

It would have been better to introduce him after crisis

north root