Dungeon Loot for Cylinder Erg Break

[weak plinth]

Summary:
Unable to use dungeon loot Celtic Tetra Cylinder special upgraded to step 6 blue for cylinder erg break from S45 to S46.

Difficulty:
Intermediate

Occurrence:
Always

Details:
The expected outcome is to be able to use dungeon loot for erg break. Other players have shown they are able to use dungeon loot for erg break, as seen here: #🧡・mabinogi message
(Please excuse the poor quality of my last screenshot, it was the only way I could capture the cursor showing the erg system not accepting the dungeon loot cylinder)

[frail spindle]

oh we're actually supposed to be able to use them for that? was erg'ing mine and had the same thing happen, didnt realize it was actually supposed to be possible lol, unfortunate i threw away the dungeon loot i got to step 6

[hollow python]

the ones that dropped from the leprechaun event didn't work either, kinda figured they would remember to fix that when new rise hit....

[weak plinth]

Yeah, OTR drops are more restricted, but outside of that it's still hard to tell what's allowed or not. Some confirmation or clarification would be nice, since I didn't see any mention of this specific mechanic in the New Rise patch notes.

[kindred sentinel]

Having this issue at staff erg level 35, my celtic tribolt wands are not accepted. Tried with an OTR celtic tribolt wand and a dungeon loot tagged one.

[gilded fulcrum]

what if you inherit Sp Up to a regular celtic and try again? It wont have #dungeon loot and (Event) tags. Just a theory. I dont have weapons to try erg atm

[grizzled prism]

I'm actually down to test this theory, I DM'd Arcie about this stuff, so we'll know what's up soon, hopefully

[barren kayak]

Hi this is what I've tested so far:

Currently you can't use dungeon loot weapons for erg breaks that ask for a specific weapon
ex. Dungeon Loot: Celtic Guardian Staff (Special Upgrade 5) ❌

You can use crafted weapons that inherit special upgrade from dungeon loot
ex. Dungeon Loot: Celtic Guardian Staff (Special Upgrade 5) --> Inherited + Crafted: Celtic Guardian Staff (Special Upgrade 5) ✅

You can use dungeon loot weapons for non specific erg breaks
ex. Any Staff (Special Upgrade 2) ✅

Not sure if these restrictions are intentional or not

[weak plinth]

Confirming that inheriting to a crafted Celtic Tetra Cylinder works. I'm still interested in getting clarity on what Nexon's intentions are for dungeon loot for erg breaks. It's confusing how it works for some (non-specific) and not others (specific) as Taxxes tested.

[gritty adder]

It does make sense that it can't be used in that method or else it would make the crafting celtic weapons completely pointless in the game.
Why bother when a perseus weapon drops so often and they are decent enough for you to farming dungeons and techs?
Safe to say the intent is to use them purely as erg experience but require the crafted for breaking into the higher tiers, since you only ever need them for erg S.