#Javelin Mastery and New Shadow Dark Arcana + Throwing Axes and Boomerangs

16 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

fierce wharf
#

Just a quick tip, if you block the 2 that keep spamming negative reactions on your post they won't be able to react to it.

It's so sad to see people in the community being this toxic over creative content I'm sorry you're experiencing this man

swift heath
rancid juniper
#

a giant holding a shield and an atlatl is definitely one of the top 3 scariest cryptids

oh actually yeah a master thread for arcana cooking would be a good idea

void laurel
#

I don’t mind, if they have a reason not to like my ideas they can still post them. If its the same “Mabinogi doesn’t need anything.” “Mabinogi has an arcana with that combination.” Then my answers will be the same.

dense osprey
#

it's a 'You are spamming the suggestion board while not having played the game to a point where you have sufficient knowledge to back those suggestions'

you might as well be throwing these ideas into the general chat instead of here

void laurel
#

Well as that may be. Here is another stance. I do not want to proceed past a certain point as I believe the game lacks the kind of content i would like to invest my time and effort into.

Now this is not the fault of anyone in particular but the “feedback” board, should be a place for such things if my definition of the word is not mistaken. Taking this into account with my other suggestions should the degree and discrepancy between my expectations, and the current reality of the game’s climate.

My sentiments are placed here as I have no reason to talk to the general populace of the game, while we share the same game, my experience is singular and personal, while i appreciate all words of affirmation and accept words deferment, i do not need either as my posts are meant for the developers to view, and take into consideration with or without response. If my words are met with outright dismissal, or the game does not progress in a way cohesive to my enjoyment of it, i will concede my arguments and leave. And I have to accept that my time spent on it was worth it, and that it no longer aligns with my standards.

dense osprey
#

If you're looking to share your ideas, as I've mentioned, the general chat is right there for that; that's how you engage with the community. If you're simply looking for a void to throw your idle thoughts into... well, i'd suggest just talking to a friend.

If you do not want to give time into the game, that is fine, since mabi is a long term investment mmo, but suggestions that ultimately come off half-baked due to this lack of understanding and minimum research (as someone else mentioned, wiki has information you did not even look at before posting these suggestions, or at least weren't even aware already existed) will likely not even make it to the devs to start with.

I'm not dismissing your ideas as irrelevant, but it's rather... off-putting to want to have your suggestions taken seriously when you don't wish to give proper time to think through and learn how things are already working (or not!) right now.

rancid juniper
#

maybe we could have 2 thread boards; one for relatively simple changes to things already in game (stack sizes, balancing adjustments, etc.) or simple additions (new fashion, social actions, etc.) that nexon can just plop in with little to no effort or modification, and one for more complex ideas in the realm of theorycrafting that would be new additions to the game (new arcanas, new game modes, etc.)
gen and unreleased aren't really good places for really going into detail about the latter and having it be organized into a neat little box. like you can put them in there but it'll just melt into the cesspool lol

void laurel
#

Well this board does exist, hence I am using it. I feel as though you are attacking me for posting in general it has nothing to do with the content of my post. And if i haven’t stated before I see no issue with multiple Arcana reusing the same combination of Grandmaster Traits. There are to many skills that exist under a blanket talent. Therefore the focus of an arcana can be anything existing within it. You might think my ideas are half baked but I am giving them complete thought in regards current state of existence. My ideas are not for general chat, there is no room and no rhyme or reason chop up my thoughts to fit the confines of text chat within game. If the text limit is not enough for you then you could simply take your issues address them to me in question format and I can get back to you with an appropriate response regarding your concerns about the effect of these ideas being implemented at full scale in game. If the developers do not read this forum then that is unfortunate as that means any and all submissions here are pointless. If the focus of my suggestions does not align and they would rather take submissions for more pets,clothes,emotes, and the like. Then that would fit the criteria for my stepping away from the game as we do not seek the same things. Its not an issue as the current game market does this often and when such a thing takes place i step away to other forms of entertainment. Or step back into old forms of entertainment. But i welcome you to discuss your concerns with me if you can address them to me in an itemized list in question format. If your comment is simply about me making a post then please continue your discourse and i will respond appropriately. As I am welcome to make complaints here i see no issue with providing a solution as well. Although i can limit any and all posts I am allowed to make here to complaints if I am so ordered by any moderator, but i consider that to be less than productive though i will so happily contribute to such an environment if that is the one chosen by the community.

void laurel
#

Javelin Mastery and New Shadow Dark Arcana + Throwing Axes and Boomerangs

patent fern
#

Why are people complaining or wanting him to stop? He's legit not breaking rules and there's no rules against him doing this. Just tell mods if it bothers you.. or don't cause you know they'll shut you down?

fierce wharf
# patent fern Why are people complaining or wanting him to stop? He's legit not breaking rules...

I think the part that bothers me is comments like "he's not even at a point where he can comment on stuff like this" when unreleased and general like to yap about meta or endgame like they actually participate in that and don't watch from the stands.

I see these posts as no different than people theorycrafting endgame when they don't run it, there's just irony now because they're flaming someone for doing the same thing they do

void laurel
#

Id like to disagree with one thing. I am not doing the same thing they do. I am playing at the pace allowed while trying to to avoid the obvious newbie bating tactics that seem to have prevailed in this game. The unethical continuance of content that this game has taken part in to only further one narrative, one supremacy is clear. I am simply making my thoughts on the matter known. Whether it be purposeful or the effect of lack of diverse players and ideas.

proud panther
#

There are definitely plenty of people with creative ideas. However, they tend to post them in the chat in short bursts, for people to discuss as they see fit, as opposed to using the Feedback section as a User-Generated Content section.

mighty lava
#

I don't think as many people would complain if these recommendations were included under a single post (i.e. "My Ideas for Mabinogi") rather than each idea be separated into their own post.

People like to comment on each other's ideas and having a swarm of particularly specific ideas is distracting. It's rude to suggest that this user should stop posting ideas but that doesn't mean that its appropriate to not take into account the limitations of Discord.

My recommendation would be to keep future additions to a single post if you are going to make them this regularly.

And to actually comment on the idea at hand:

A Throwing Attack Mastery is not a bad idea and all of the stats you mention would make some sense.

More skills would be nice, though it would be equally nice to have access to Ranged Talent skills such as Support Shot (and would require less work/balancing). It's not impossible to turn Atlatl into something like Gunslinger and allow off-hand if ammo is freed up but its highly unlikely since Giants aren't supposed to be good at ranged to begin with.

Throwing Axes might be one way to revive the dying Axe subclass.

There's no Javelin Talent and if it had one it would be Ranged, which would mean Javelins would use the existing Alchemic Sharpshooter Arcana if Nexon wanted to get rid of Racial Advantages/Disadvantages.

void laurel
#

I don't see why they would change much of what is already going, i am only suggesting them as changes, as such any racial indifferences should be considered soft walls. And any additions to said disadvantaged race should only be considered a matter of specialization and effort on their part. While other races do have bonuses to said skill it is not to say that the others have a disadvantage, just that it is not the focus of their racial stat growth.