Every Discog in a Nutshell

[muted sentinel]

cool

this isn’t specifically about TOP either

[empty summit]

whys that so accurate though

[rough ember]

i dont find this accurate at all

[ivory relic]

strokes

literally the strokes

add this and it’s literally the strokes
fifth: their worst album of all time
sixth: legendary comeback that everyone loves

[slate yarrow]

this really fails thinking of some bands, idk, just tell me with what band does it work

[muted sentinel]

yeah the strokes were the first band i thought of

i’d say the killers if it weren’t for battle born

no one likes battle born

[slate yarrow]

i may know not enough bands

[muted sentinel]

weezer could work too

[chrome current]

radiohead but remove the classic part

[muted sentinel]

almost works with foo fighters

one by one isn’t a fan favorite i don’t think

[brisk plover]

I can’t think of who this goes for

Kanye I guess

but 3 doesn’t apply

[plush turret]

Tøp definitely applies here

BF was technically their third album

Trench fourth

[verbal elbow]

muse fails number 2, imo tøp fails number 4, tdcc kinda works for number 2, i don’t listen to many more bands with more than 3 albums

[chrome current]

would arctic monkeys count?

suck it and see seems like it could have a cult following, except humbug probably fits that more

fall out boy kinda works too i think

[timid void]

kind of works with avenged sevenfold

seventh trumpet is a metalcore classic, waking the fallen added more clean vocals and solos since syn joined the band, city of evil is significantly better and more polished than the first 2, and the s/t fourth album is not really the fan favorite or a cult classic

[gilded cradle]

def not for the pilots

not sure what bands other than the strokes and the killers i could see you making this argument for

weezer maybe?

[turbid tiger]

i think the pilots fail especially the first one imo, s/t aint a classic
i agree with fob although for weezer i think maladroit falls behind as cult classic lol

my contributions would be led zeppelin and the white stripes

[muted sentinel]

white stripes for sure

[brisk plover]

this is actually radiohead

other than 1 and 2 only kinda fit

[gilded cradle]

W A I T …

[brisk plover]

I said this

easily the best example of 1 and 2 but it doesn’t fit 3 at all

I guess some people say it’s significantly worse than the other 2 (it’s not) but it’s not the most essential

[gilded cradle]

applies to me for sure

it doesnt say most essential

it just says essential

its def the worst of the trilogy

[brisk plover]

I guess so

[gilded cradle]

tcd and lr are 10s, grad is like 8 or something but not a 10

[slender turtle]

i like battle born

[tired garden]

Graduation is the worst of the three but the most essential one imo

I think this could appeal to death grips
To some extent
Exmilitary is considered a classic in the community, tms has more instruments/the beats are a little bit more tuney (i suppose), nldw is worse than both although not that much, and idk how essential it is
Gp isnt a fan classic tho
I wouldnt say so

[tired garden]

I guess nldw is essential though cause the whole drama around it made them get dropped from the label lmao

[teal zealot]

nah, muse and radiohead ruin this. For Muse, 2nd album (origin of symmetry) is their best and for radiohead kid a is definitely not their best. Kid a is is my least fav of the first 4 tbh.

[brisk plover]

4 doesn’t say best

and kid a is also the second best of the 4

[teal zealot]

i was so disappointed listening to kid a. It couldve been such a good album after ok computer and they ruined it.

[willow crow]

For Number Girl i'd say it's true. 1st album has one of their best and most iconic songs so by virtue of that it's classic. 2nd is essentially the first album but just way better. 3rd album widely considered their best (at least from what i gather) and it marks a shift in the bands sound. and the 4th album is kind of a cult classic idk i guess it fits in there LOL

this applies to a lot of bands but like it doesn't apply to most bands

i've been looking thru some discogs to see where it applies but like

this would count if flower boy was his 4th album LOL

this is true

[tired garden]

Bruh

[teal zealot]

?

[tired garden]

Pretty much yeah

[tired garden]

Kid a is v good

Possibly liked it more than ok computer in first listen

On*

[teal zealot]

nahhhh. its alr but not even close to the rest of heir stuff

[tired garden]

But pablo honey and bends defo aint better than kid a

[teal zealot]

i was so dissapointed after ok computer

[tired garden]

Its ur opinion tho :]

[teal zealot]

they are

yeah :)

people like diff stuff

[tired garden]

Yea

[tired garden]

Also true

[solar veldt]

pretty sure every MCR fan would disagree since Danger Days was 4th

[willow crow]

what we thinkin ⁉️

[dusky bronze]

😭

[tired garden]

Wow

[dusky frigate]

if we start at RAB (first album as a duo) it kinda works for twenty one pilots

[teal zealot]

yeah it 100% does

trench is far better than bf

[dusky frigate]

doesn’t work for the Beatles though, their five first albums are not good at all

[dusky frigate]

🤝

[teal zealot]

its not as popular though and that blows my mind

[dusky frigate]

it’s more sophisticated, and the whole concept is really difficult to understand for a non-clique person

the thing could work for Radiohead too

and David Bowie

[teal zealot]

yeah thats true, i can see why bf was so popular but i dont listen to modern chart music because it annoys me lol

[teal zealot]

no, kid a isnt their best imo

[dusky frigate]

unpopular opinion: Blurryface is the best thing that happened to the 2010’s music charts

[dusky frigate]

it’s the best of the first four albums (at least in my opinion)

[teal zealot]

lmao, i agree, the rest of the chart stuff is rubbish tbh

[dusky frigate]

I admit In Rainbows is better though

[dusky frigate]

this year no because the last Maneskin album is great

[teal zealot]

REALLY? i was so disappoined listening to it after ok computer.

[teal zealot]

i havnt given it a listen yet

[dusky frigate]

I was too at first, but after a few more listens you begin to get into the concept, and it really becomes one of the best in your mind (at least that’s what happened to me)

[dusky frigate]

you should, it’s like an Italian Red Hot Chili Peppers

[teal zealot]

yeah i will re listen. im 14 so i only really started to get into music the last 6 months or so (aside top who ive been a fan over for years). It doesnt work for muse either

[teal zealot]

oo ok yeah i defo will

[dusky frigate]

I’m sixteen and I was basically the same two years ago, I understand the pain of not being able to grow musically as fast as you’d wish 😁

[teal zealot]

yeah lol, this summer has been amazing tho ive found so much music that i love.

ive got a whole list of hundreds of albums that im gunna listen too aswell

[dusky frigate]

yeah that’s the cool thing about music, there’s always new stuff to discover😊

I binge-listened the whole Beatles discography yesterday in the car and man that feels great

[teal zealot]

oh wow, thats a lot. im listening to nirvanas discography atm.

[dusky frigate]

oh that’s great too

[teal zealot]

yeah it is lol

[dusky frigate]

not that much, I mean it took me like 7 hours but I was travelling so 💁‍♂️

and I’m happy I did it cause now I know what albums I like and that’s cool

[teal zealot]

7hrs is quite a lot in one sitting lmao

[teal zealot]

yeah thats why im listing to EVERY album an artist puts out. you never know what ur gunna like

[dusky frigate]

depends if you like it I suppose

[teal zealot]

yeah, i can listen to music all day but 7 hrs on one artist is a lot

[dusky frigate]

I didn’t really like the first albums so it was a little long but from Rubber Soul it just felt great

[teal zealot]

yeah, thats why i dont give up on an artist just because they have a bad album

[dusky frigate]

I admit I do that sometimes ahah

for Nirvana you should listen to the MTV Unplugged as well as the albums it’s great too

(Friendly advice)

[teal zealot]

lol, i didnt really want to carry on with radiohead but i convinced myself to listen to amnesiac and im glad i did because its a good album

[teal zealot]

my dad said that aswell lol, thanks :)

[dusky frigate]

I was disappointed by Amnesiac definitely not the best to my mind

[teal zealot]

i think i just had really low expectations after kid a. i will relisten to kid a tho

[dusky frigate]

mines were really high, maybe that’s why ahah. I will relisten to Amnesiac one day I think

[teal zealot]

yeah do, i thought it was better than kid a

[dusky frigate]

it’s not the same vibe as the albums, he’s not screaming and stuff so that gives a whole new perception of the song

[teal zealot]

yeah, i will definitely give it a listen once ive finished in utero aswell

[dusky frigate]

just an off-topic question: are you French? because your bio is in French

[teal zealot]

haha no, its a song with a french title

[dusky frigate]

In Utero is great too, definitely a perfect discography

[dusky frigate]

ahh okay 👍 is the song from you?

[teal zealot]

you should listen to nothing but thieves, they are a very good bad

[teal zealot]

no, from nothing but thieves

band*

[dusky frigate]

I never did, but that’s on my to-do list 😉 I can’t listen to everything right now because I still need to keep my friends haha

[teal zealot]

haha, give them a listen when you can, they are very good. im going to see them live on saturday!

[dusky frigate]

ah that’s cool ! unfortunately I can’t do anything on Saturday because I’m painting the town

[teal zealot]

hahaha

[native dome]

WATERPARKS BE LIKE-

[brisk plover]

waterparks do not have a classic

[primal steeple]

I've never been able to decide if I like Blurryface less or more than the first two

[native dome]

eh ur right

parx was never huge

[edgy cypress]

i think it cap bc the fan fav is trench and thats number 5 so

[plush turret]

well if you think about official releases

first = self titled, second = vessel, third = blurryface, 4 = trench

but rab is an album it just wasn't released

officially^

[brisk plover]

for that it works perfectly yeah

[dusky frigate]

it was released as officially as Self Titled, it is just not available on every platforms

but if you begin when Josh arrived (at RAB) it works

Vessel is really close to RAB, with just differences in production for most songs

BF is essential to the band discography because it’s the breakthrough album

and Trench is the fan favourite obviously

[stray flower]

Since when was an album with several top 40 hits considered a “cult classic”

[brisk plover]

/fan favorite

[plush turret]

I mean let's be real, Trench is kinda a "cult classic" because Trench has its own backstory, in a sense
idrk what a cult classic is so I might be a bit biased

[ivory relic]

this doesn’t work for top at all

i don’t see any arguements for it

tbh

[willow crow]

i mean more of a cult classic than blurryface? 🤷

[primal steeple]

blurryface has their most famous songs tho