#2025 Breach Song Battle 2P #8

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

latent forgeBOT
#

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1762617600:R>

mellow compass
#

GARBAGE

pure obsidian
#

City Walls

grave badge
#

Garbage

modern goblet
#

GARBAGE

#

garbage has no chances but i still wish it won

sick sedge
#

City walls

bright fulcrum
#

Bro how am i supposed to choose

fringe yarrow
#

I’m so so sorry garbage my beloved

pure nebula
#

garbage

quaint helm
#

city walls

worthy tiger
#

Garbage all the way

halcyon ore
#

Garbage

grave badge
#

Garbage is an everyday listen, city walls isn’t

pure obsidian
#

I am sorry Garbage

sudden comet
#

Garbage is named garbage for a reason ngl

reef vigil
#

Sorry but city walls is my fav grief

crude egret
#

city walls supremacy

tepid blade
#

GARBAGE NO MY BABY SHES GONNA GET DESTROYED

pure obsidian
fringe yarrow
#

city walls has prime Ty screams grief so I must choose it

tepid minnow
#

city walls sweep

supple aurora
strange zinc
#

rip garbage

floral flax
#

CITY WALLS

crude egret
sudden comet
#

City walls is a perfect continuation of the lore

digital bronze
#

Erm Garbage ☝️ 🤓

tepid blade
modern goblet
#

ah yes, cgairtybw

tiny plinth
#

Listen I love City Walls but there’s something so special about “DON’T! GIVE! UP! ON ME!”

somber plaza
#

City walls is just too catchy

urban remnant
#

City Walls, but I love Garbage

smoky slate
#

Imagine how funny it’d be if Garbage got voted second place

pure obsidian
#

ignoring the lore City Walls is Overcompensate level hype

simple halo
#

NIW WHY WOULD YOU DO MY BELOVED GARBAGE THIS DIRTY NICOgrief grief grief

untold stratus
#

city walls ain’t deserve any more wins GARBAGE FTW

surreal tangle
#

City walls has got this

vapid zephyr
#

Garbage my beloved. grief

dreamy hearth
#

HELP I CAN'T DECIDE

teal snow
#

It's a shame City Walls is such a banger, but I would have picked Garbage if it was the live version--the studio version has always sounded very strange, especially production wise, and I'm just not into the mixing

tiny plinth
pure obsidian
fringe yarrow
#

Abandoned by the sun is succchh a good lyric thooo

sudden comet
latent forgeBOT
crude egret
#

city walls interpolates my favorite song of all time its a no brainer for me

keen fractal
#

oh god

fringe yarrow
#

aaaaaaaa

fringe yarrow
#

Yeah that too

untold stratus
meager flicker
#

love both but gotta go city walls

sudden comet
dire willow
#

i hate to choose

humble mountain
#

i vote garbage even though city walls is better

crude egret
steady meteor
#

This is one of the hardest choices ever why 😭

tiny plinth
dreamy hearth
#

Going City Walls but garbage is still one of my favorites

fringe yarrow
#

I love the… synth (????) or whatever in the background of city walls so much too aagahhhh

modern goblet
#

i get that ppl have opinions but garbage hate will NOT be tolerated

pure obsidian
keen fractal
#

i genuienly cant pick here

crude egret
fringe yarrow
#

But garbage does speak to my SOUL and almost made me cry live

meager flicker
sudden comet
#

How could anyone NOT vote for “address my soul, address my soul, address my sooooooooooouuuuulllllll”

hidden solstice
#

This battle is garbage am i right chat?

keen fractal
#

i think i need to go garbage here

#

wait no

#

i cant pic

#

j

#

oamnwjpf

dreamy hearth
fringe yarrow
surreal tangle
#

City walls also references two of the best songs off Vessel which already adds on to my love for it

Banger + well integrated references + whatever those neat Instrumental segments are = no brainer

sudden comet
modern goblet
#

i really really hope they play garbage at electric castle

tiny plinth
keen fractal
modern goblet
meager flicker
ebon stratus
#

This is evil how can I choose

teal snow
simple halo
fringe yarrow
modern goblet
#

IKR

fringe yarrow
#

I would NEVER have guessed it was a sax???????

#

That makes me like it even more

crude egret
#

city walls is already my favorite album opener ever so

vapid zephyr
#

Why is this so hard? grief

ebon stratus
#

Guys what should I pick

fringe yarrow
#

I feel horrible to do it to ya Garbage bc that song is ME but I really gotta give it to city walls

rare tapir
#

Citywalls

teal snow
sudden comet
tiny fulcrum
#

Garbage

#

But is garbage garbage?

ebon stratus
fringe yarrow
pure obsidian
#

The way around those City Walls, the way on through!

simple halo
#

Welp...today my systems are operating at 20 percent...or lessgrief

sudden comet
fringe yarrow
#

which is why I feel bad not voting for it grief

crude egret
#

tyler’s written a lot of relatable lyrics in the past but “i feel like garbage” may be the most relatable thing he’s ever written

#

/hj

gleaming burrow
#

Garbage 🗑️

teal snow
mellow kindle
#

This is painful but garbage gang wya

pure obsidian
mellow kindle
#

I remember crying at the listening party listening 😓

teal snow
#

tyler usually is very creative with how he writes and I'm sorry, but "I feel like garbage" just feels so... cliche

simple halo
crude egret
rocky river
#

garbage ngl

meager flicker
#

bro got straight to the point 😂

pure obsidian
teal snow
#

Like I've heard some iteration of "I feel like garbage" too many times lol

teal snow
sleek cosmos
#

I'm voting for Garbage, it probably will lose with City Walls, but it just may be my favourite song from the album (along with Tally)

teal snow
#

LITERALLY CITY WALLS

eternal lotus
#

I think the point was to be as fundamentally universal as possible

fringe yarrow
#

sometimes you just gotta say it plain

rocky river
#

i as a biotechnology student relate to garbage very much

crude egret
#

like the second i heard “entertain my-“ i LOST IT

latent forgeBOT
eternal lotus
#

Point blank - I feel like garbage, dude lol

meager flicker
#

I FEEL LIKE POUBELLE

teal snow
dark remnant
#

Garbage deserved her flowers one day

But I’m so bias towards city walls

stark latch
#

PLEASE DON'T MAKE ME CHOOSE BETWEEN MY CHILDREN

rocky river
pure obsidian
#

City Walls lyricism is just too good

#

there's a reason it's almost first

teal snow
burnt citrus
#

I love both but if i dont pick my goat than ill feel like garbage

teal snow
#

that bridge especially is so good

merry gull
#

Hot take garbage would be a top 3 sai song but it gets outclassed by the rest of breach

#

No disrespect to sai at all, breach is just crazy good

keen pendant
#

i loev garbage

#

city walls mv made me bawl my eyes out💔

stark latch
#

I love Garbage but City Walls just ties together over 10 years in a single song so well

dapper obsidian
#

city sweep ‼️‼️

latent forgeBOT
red maple
#

City walls

limpid moss
#

City walls>

merry gull
#

City walls has everything. Cinematic, lyricism, heavy sounds, rap, callbacks,

#

Love garbage but city walls is just. Amazing

pure obsidian
#

the way he says "This is the last time"... breaks my heart

supple aurora
#

tbh garbage is probably my least fav off breach </3

#

not that it’s bad it’s just topped by everything else

vital tartan
#

okay okay wait they expect me to choose here? grief

supple aurora
#

maybe not intentions

merry gull
#

Im such a sucker for layered vocals that are done well

crude egret
#

i still love garbage but imo city walls slams it into the ground

merry gull
#

Thats one of the things i love most about this band

stark latch
#

But Intensions is Truce! It's the final tie!

merry gull
#

When they layer vocals its always stellar

stark latch
#

Totally not saying that because it's my name here

vital tartan
merry gull
#

Like the dichotomy of the clean "address my soul" with the gutteral emotion mixed under

simple halo
vital tartan
#

like, there is the whole entertain my faith buildup, but in Garbage there's the "would you move closer, if i grew quieter?" that gets me

dire talon
#

city walls vs one of the worst songs on breach

#

hmmmm i sure wonder who is the best pick

nocturne pine
simple halo
#

Sometimes i wish it would be in 2 part tho, lore related vs not lore

tidal scarab
finite haven
vital tartan
#

Garbage is amazing

dire talon
#

garbage is self evident by its name

tidal scarab
#

you were the one who made the garbage tweet weren’t you

vital tartan
#

yk what

#

Imma vote Garbage

#

it needs all the support it can get cause it's so good

dire talon
tidal scarab
#

eski is pamella confirmed

nocturne pine
simple halo
#

Can we please normalise that one song can be loved or not loved ????? Like okay you might don't like it, BUT IT'S STILL A GOOD SONG LET'S NOT CALL THEM SHIT ETC LIKE HELLO???

little garden
#

I hate tøp for only making good songs

vital tartan
nocturne pine
#

Bc city walls is EVERYTHING

dire talon
#

if you cant decide then vote city walls bc its the only good option

nocturne pine
#

Forreal though both have my heart 😭😭😭😭😭😭

tidal scarab
nocturne pine
#

Also garage live is just so grief grief grief grief

dire talon
#

im not on board with that third option

crimson epoch
tidal scarab
dire talon
#

STOP THE COUNT

crimson epoch
#

BAN ESKI

latent forgeBOT
vital tartan
quiet spire
#

Garbage but it has to be the cd/vinyl version PLEASE

little garden
nocturne pine
tidal scarab
vital tartan
#

Eski lookin desperate

nocturne pine
#

L?

vital tartan
#

these votes conclude: Garbage is better than City Walls, so ban Eski lmao

simple halo
candid moon
crimson epoch
#

Bye eski

vital tartan
dire talon
simple halo
vital tartan
simple halo
vital tartan
simple halo
#

HE ALWAYS COMPLAINS THO IF THE FLOOR IS STICKY...I SEE THE VISION

#

THAT WORKS TOO

worldly spire
#

garbage easy

#

just yeaaah

simple halo
#

Never in my 26 years...

bleak moon
#

Garbage

regal turret
#

garbage and it isn’t closesteamhappy

astral solar
#

Wait both options are just garbage lol

#

-# jk I love them both

simple halo
#

I'm biting down on my shirtsleeveeeee

slow bloom
#

City wallsssss

simple halo
flint sky
#

i lash out if youre in arrrms reach <//3

grave palm
#

man

simple halo
#

IM SO LOST, LIKE WHAT IS HAPPENING

grave palm
#

I may abstain from this one i love them for entirely different reasons 😭 I dont even know what like. criteria i could use to compare and rank them in my head

white canopy
#

sorry garbage but city walls is literally him

minor zodiac
#

i wonder where you are

grave palm
#

oh my god I actually cant choose

steady crystal
#

im biting down on my shirtsleeve

simple halo
grave palm
simple halo
grave palm
#

garbage is like I need an emotional release of negative emotions that feels more cathartic and city walls is i need to cry and yell and smack my steering wheel like it just entirely depends. What's worse is I cant even say that it depends on my mood because I usually listen to them consecutively even if I'm not listening to the full album . help

weak bloom
#

bye garbage

simple halo
#

I feel that 100% and not lessgrief

grave palm
#

decision paralysis getting my ass so bad today ive not made a single choice I couldnt even decide if I wanted eggs or toast this morning shjddksk

#

diabolical

silver tundra
#

20% or less
(the people that vote for City Walls)

simple halo
long snow
#

Oh my god these are both awesome

simple halo
#

HI IVY

long snow
regal pelican
#

This is kind of a sad match up. City walls is so important to clikkie culture, so it’ll win. I am not a garbage hater, it’s just funny to see these two go against each other.

grave palm
#

save ME

simple halo
long snow
long snow
grave palm
#

I suppose 😭 ill be sad to see either lose tho too

long snow
#

&THANK YOU YOURE COOLER

long snow
simple halo
long snow
#

WE IN THIS FOR THE LONG HAUL

simple halo
#

LET'S PUT 5 ON IT!!!!!

long snow
#

WE GOT 5 ON IT YASSSSSSSS

simple halo
#

(Great song)

long snow
#

(It’s so addictive)

lament whale
#

GARBAGE FANS ASSEMBLE
I'm sure all 12 of us can win this battle together

long snow
#

DID YOU SEEME IN HERE OR IN HOMETOWN?? YOU SHOULD TALK IN HOMETOWN MORE DUE

simple halo
#

(yes!!! ALSO WHEN I HEARF IT WHEN I WAS WATCHING "US" crashed out)

long snow
simple halo
long snow
simple halo
#

DO I??? I GOT BJÖRK BEFORE, MY FIRST TIME BEING COMPARED TO MITSKI

pseudo zenith
#

You can’t compare these two bro

#

They’re too different

granite pebble
#

so like does this hate me

#

I CANT DECIDE

pseudo zenith
#

My gut says garbage but when I think about it I want to put city walls

pseudo zenith
#

I might have someone pick and number and I’ll go back and forth that many times

crimson epoch
# simple halo

I had Frosted Flakes this morning, I KNEW they tasted weird!

#

Bruh why did my message send like an hour late 😭

misty iron
#

This one’s hard

merry gull
vital tartan
#

okay so this is like trying to decide between Fairly Local and Lane Boy

harsh mist
#

This is impossible

smoky wolf
#

OKAY BUT REMEMBER TYLERS FACE DURING GARBAGE HE SO SILLY AND HAPPY!!!

#

GARBAGE PLSSS

harsh mist
#

Lemme think

#

Idc about how they look in stage

#

I care about the sound

smoky wolf
#

but garbage is so good

harsh mist
#

It's hard, ok?

#

City walls are peak

#

Is*

dapper obsidian
#

lowkey think robot voices, garbage and downstairs are my least favourites on the album 😭😭 they’re not bad, everything else is just better

simple halo
cunning escarp
#

MOVE IT UP MOVE IT UP ITS A BREACH

cunning escarp
candid moon
#

@dire talon are you woke

whole sinew
#

THESE TWO ARE MY TOP 2 FAVOURITES FROM BREACH YOU CAN'T MAKE ME CHOOSE

cunning escarp
#
  1. RAWFEAR
  2. City Walls
  3. Downstairs
  4. Garbage
  5. Drum Show
  6. Intentions
  7. The Contract

Past that I don’t care too much lol, I dont have definite rankings

dire talon
simple halo
wide trench
#

help I want to pick both

keen ice
#

Garbage

rich shale
#

This is a hard choice

#

I love both songs so much

dapper obsidian
dapper obsidian
onyx ferry
#

garbage ftw pls SakiPlead

pastel bolt
#

GARBAGE

weak plank
#

im kind of feeling city walls on this one idk

pearl terrace
#

this one’s actually kinda difficult

#

i’m leaning city walls though

glass tree
safe turret
#

MOVE IT UP MOVE IT UP

dire talon
#

garbage aint making it out alive

#

BYE BYE

fossil forge
#

oh man bro corny vs peak

#

tough shit

heavy tulip
#

idk if i can do this

#

this is hard

lean pond
wooden tinsel
#

that's my fav

crystal gust
#

sad

crystal gust
#

Annotate my FAAAAAAACE

latent plume
#

UNDRESS MY SOUL

paper wave
#

Nah I know City Walls HAS TO win

crystal gust
#

garbage could make a comeback you never know...

pallid gorge
#

I FEEL LIKE GARBAGE

long snow
pallid gorge
#

MY SYSTEMS ARE OPERATING AT 20%

vapid zephyr
upper pagoda
#

This pick is not easy for me.

pallid gorge
vapid zephyr
pallid gorge
#

ooohh OOOOHHHH ooh yeAAAAAHH

vapid zephyr
#

I'm biting down on my shirtsleeve (Yeah, yeah)

lost zinc
#

if you vote for city walls fuck you

#

ok sorry im hating

noble lion
#

city walls wins

#

i dont feel depressed right now so garbage is garbage

mild merlin
#

Okay so what is this pick.

#

Why were these two thrown against each other?

pastel flicker
#

it’s not like i can’t chose but

#

i can’t choose

#

it’s like idc which one wins but

#

i can’t choose

pastel flicker
pure obsidian
#

I wonder where you are

last quail
lost zinc
storm sierra
#

I WONDER WHERE YOU ARE

pure obsidian
#

I WANTED YOU TO SHOW ME

next dagger
#

This is evil

pure obsidian
#

the way around those city walls...

late plover
#

the reactions fought so hard on this one that they spelled out Cgairty Bwa lmao

pure obsidian
#

I don't think it's close...

vital tapir
#

Ngl garbage is up there

pure obsidian
#

Garbage is nice but it's not City Walls

meager marsh
crystal gust
#

Its just like for so many of these songs you cant pick because its not like one is better than the other. Theyre just different songs. They have different vibes to each other and you cant really compare them

urban zodiac
#

city walls man

#

these lineups are killing me man

surreal cliff
oak heath
#

Both. Both are good and I say tie

#

I feel like garbage

#

I feel like

#

My OS is running at 5 FPS

#

or less

next jay
#

I feel like garbage man

tacit plaza
#

Hey City Walls people, yall better keep this same energy when it comes to City Walls vs Downstairs in the last round 🙄

cloud crane
#

i'd react with the breach cover art but i wanna keep it 67 🤲🏻

#

anyways, city walls any day. garbage isn't true to its title but i still prefer city walls.

boreal saffron
dusty tendon
#

Hehehe cgairtybwa

crisp wedge
fathom vale
rocky river
#

really hope garbaj wins

granite marlin
#

city walls deserves the win

crystal gust
#

They both deserve it

granite marlin
#

yes but you gotta pick one

crystal gust
#

I voted garbage because i like voting for the underdog

#

City walls is one of the big epic songs if garbage could win this that would be so awesome

granite marlin
#

both are epic but city walls makes me levitate so i voted it

crystal gust
#

entertain my FAAAAAAAITH

#

yea

lament whale
#

rip my child

keen fractal
#

oh dear lord

next dagger
#

Both epic I’m not mad

wide trench
tidal scarab
# tidal scarab
poll_question_text

2025 Breach Song Battle SUBSECTION 01

victor_answer_votes

13

total_votes

20

victor_answer_id

3

victor_answer_text

Ban Eski

#

@dire talon bad news

dire talon
#

RECOUNT

#

THAT POLL WAS HIJACKED

tidal scarab
#

@candid moon wanna do the honors?

candid moon
#

YES

dire talon
#

NO NO NO

latent forgeBOT
#

@dire talon was banned.

candid moon
#

(he’s not actually permabanned dw)

vital tartan
#

great! we banned Eski (now meowl) for his hot takes

untold stratus
#

the music video effect is crazy

keen fractal