#2025 Breach Song Battle 2P #1

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

scenic lilyBOT
#

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1762012800:R>

quick oxide
#

first

cerulean zinc
#

ONE WAY

bronze dragon
#

i hate these

fluid isle
#

oh i feel SO bad for one way

mossy mist
#

Ooo… i dont like this

hoary citrus
#

garbage

spare lynx
#

GARBAGEEE

short grail
#

One way

silent epoch
#

onEWAYONEWAYONEWAYONEWAY

strange whale
#

its Garbage

sweet viper
#

garbage live was amazing

buoyant magnet
#

Garbage

fleet tendon
#

I FEEL LIKE GARBAGE

hidden dagger
#

ONE WAY ONE WAY

jovial kraken
#

i feel like

willow marten
#

one way

knotty copper
#

GARBAGE SWEEPPPPP

drowsy junco
#

one wY

prime relic
#

GARBAGE! GARBAGE!!! GARBAGE PLEASE!!!!!

leaden crystal
#

GARBAGE IS PEAK

restive star
#

LETS GO GARBAGE

quick oxide
#

this ones tough, once you see garbage live your opinion on the song will change so much

tacit geyser
#

one way

undone breach
#

this is so hard

honest radish
#

There’s only ONE WAY I can vote on this

jaunty vortex
#

garbage ez

tropic sable
#

GARBAGE

jolly jackal
#

ONE WAY

dusty plank
#

garbag

jovial kraken
#

gavage

visual temple
#

GARBAGE FTW 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️

balmy dawn
#

come on guys, let's avenge garbage

spare lynx
#

GARRRRRRRBAGEEEEEEE

fiery flame
#

...

hasty haven
#

I FEEL LIKE GARBAGE

jolly jackal
#

I WANTED TO FLYYYYYYYY

fluid isle
#

i love one way but there's absolutely no way it's winning this

delicate sundial
#

bro 😔

sacred birch
#

YEAHHHHH IM BITING DOWN ON MY SHIRT SLEEVE UEAAAHHHH ILL LASH OUT 8F YOU'RE IN ARMS REACH

leaden crystal
#

I FEEL LIKE GARBAGE

brazen sail
#

GARBAGE

jaunty vortex
#

BRIGHT EYED WITH WONDER

dry sandal
#

I’m so sorry one way you didn’t deserve this 😔

dim sundial
#

TYLER AND HIS PIANO>>>>>>> GARBAGE! GARBAGE! GARBAGE!

lyric mural
#

Garbage does not stand a chance

hasty haven
#

DO YOU KNOW WHICH NAME IT'S UNDER??

dusty plank
#

lmao the reactions

spare lynx
#

TRASH'S COUSIN IS WINNING

leaden crystal
weary heath
#

Oneway

hasty haven
leaden crystal
#

ILL WALK YOU THROUGH THE NUMBERS

naive pewter
#

One way

frail pulsar
#

One Way clears

untold saddle
#

I WANTED TO FLYYYYYY!!!!

quick oxide
#

GUYS WHY IS ONE WAY GOING AGAINST OLDIES STATION droidcry

sacred birch
naive pewter
#

I WANTED TO FLYYYYYY

hidden dagger
#

NOOO THATS CRAZY ITS GOTTA BE ONE WAY

lyric mural
#

Garbage is so bad

leaden crystal
#

garbage literally means the absolute world to me

naive pewter
#

ITS LITERALLY TAME IMPALA C'MON, ONE WAY

spark mirage
#

Garbage glassesPray

jaunty vortex
#

im sorry one way but you are my only top skip song 🥀

quick oxide
hasty haven
young halo
#

the duality of man

lyric mural
spare lynx
small ivy
#

wait stop theyre both so good this isnt fair

leaden crystal
carmine stratus
#

GARBAGE

hidden dagger
carmine stratus
#

I THOUGHT MY BELOVED DIDNT MAKE IT

young halo
#

trapdoor will forever be my most relatable but garbage is super close

small ivy
leaden crystal
quick oxide
#

me and my scene just aint gellin

keen chasm
#

why....

quick oxide
#

someone next to me keeps yelling

night jungle
#

wouldn't 2nd place be downstairs?

balmy dawn
#

garbage used to be my least favorite from the album, but once you get the lyrics, you really really get them

keen chasm
#

you cant do this to me

young halo
#

A A A

spare lynx
quick oxide
#

why am i still walking something must be wrong aaaaII JUST DONT BELONG HERE

vital lake
untold saddle
#

Hey it's Josh, call me back
Uh, I'm not opposed to "One Way" going into "Days Lie Dormant"
But it does feel like quite a vibe change
And, uhh

sacred birch
#

guys im still voting for shy away livestream version in my soul

honest radish
hidden dagger
#

i hope 2nd place is tally

scenic lilyBOT
latent vigil
#

One Way :❤

quick oxide
#

no one answered me why is one way against oldies station droidcry

vital lake
#

it's possible a song lost to Center Mass early but would otherwise be #2

fierce python
#

I WANTED TO FLYYYYYYYYYY

thorny kraken
#

DRAG FREAKING PATH

fierce python
#

YES

fierce python
#

LETS DRAG PATH

vital lake
leaden crystal
#

like garbage is so pure

#

and holy

bronze dragon
leaden crystal
#

and everything

vital lake
#

drum show for example lost to center mass so it could be #2

cosmic pendant
#

drag path needs to win

devout stag
balmy dawn
keen chasm
#

I put this on someone

devout stag
leaden crystal
spare lynx
#

i wonder who

leaden crystal
livid pumice
#

ONE WAY RAHHHH

rich pond
#

Garbage really speaks to me more and its such a comfort song for me :33c

Sorry One Way

quick oxide
livid pumice
#

But good luck both songs fr

fluid isle
#

i sorta learned garbage on the piano

hexed root
#

Uhh. Dang.

#

Doubt demo or something

leaden crystal
#

Garbage has so much more meaning to it than one way 😭

night jungle
#

I love Garbage. The way he smiles when the crowd starts singing with him is stuck in my mind and gives me a dopamine boost lol

ivory hare
#

Not the 6 7😂😂

fluid isle
#

god i really hope he plays tally and garbage at electric castle (the festival in my country)

quick oxide
#

i feel like, like
i feel like oldies station

spare lynx
ivory hare
leaden crystal
fluid isle
#

i was looking for a trashcan emoji but i only found trash the dragon

ivory hare
#

I love garbage so much

undone breach
#

I can't choose ahhhg

night jungle
#

I love Oldies Station, too.

faint linden
#

OMG THIS IS SO DIFFICULT ALSO TALLY HAS TO WIN

#

LIKE

#

IN THE WHOLE THING

deft osprey
#

i love both of these this is actually a very hard choice

faint linden
#

TALLY SECOND PLACE

night jungle
#

ngl. the first time I heard the "I feel like Garbage" line at my listening party, I immediately thought of Bo Burnham

jovial kraken
#

DRAG PATH OR TALLY GUYS LETS LOCK IN

faint linden
jovial kraken
#

WE MUST STAY FOCUSED BROTHERS

spare lynx
#

my 2nd place is dld but idm tally winning 2nd

inland ice
#

ouh this hard

night jungle
#

Hello brethREN

fluid isle
#

TALLY #1

deft osprey
night jungle
#

lol

spare lynx
deft osprey
#

audibly laughed ty twin

night jungle
#

The Council of Rens. I think there is at least one more of us

fluid isle
#

ren means reindeer in romanian i hope asgore doesn't run y'all over

spring verge
#

This vote is hard. On the one hand they made one way too short but on the other, they cut off the garbage vocals for streaming 💔

fluid isle
#

WDYM THEY CUT THEM OFF

spare lynx
spring verge
fluid isle
deft osprey
#

the few the proud the …. emo - ren - al

night jungle
#

I tried to change, but my irl name is probably also popular here lol

fluid isle
#

why hasn't my cd arrived T-T

night jungle
#

YES

keen chasm
#

I'm still reading Oldies slander for some reason on this thread?????

spring verge
#

Its just a little bit at the start

keen chasm
#

🍅 🍅 🍅 🍅 🍅 🍅

fluid isle
#

why did they remove the DRUM BREAK in DRUM SHOW on the cds tho

leaden crystal
#

every line to garbage is so me. Also the cd version where he goes “YOU CAN SAY YOU CAN SAYYY” and then continues to say I feel like garbage BROOOO

night jungle
#

Twenty One Rens

spring verge
steep turret
#

GARBAGE

leaden crystal
spring verge
#

All the votes this time around have been so fucking close. Is this the closest album voting has been??? Bc it feels like it

night jungle
#

the "maybe this is you. Maybe you don't fix and you like it like this" voice break had me in a chokehold when i first heard it

leaden crystal
night jungle
#

It healed something I didn't know was damaged lol

static bear
#

One Way got done far too dirty in the first song battle

plain charm
#

one way sweep soz

night jungle
#

It's hard for me to rank the songs because my choices change with my mood lol

mossy vigil
#

IM SORRY EVERYONE I LOVE ONE WAY, BUT GARBAGE HAS A SPECIAL SPACE IN MY HEART

static bear
#

I prefer the happier-sounding songs on Breach (One Way, Drum Show, Robot Voices) yet Cottonwood is my favourite song on the album

exotic nimbus
#

Cotton enjoyer 🙏

spring verge
#

Idk what it is about cottonwood

mossy vigil
spring verge
#

I want to like it but it just. Doesnt stick to me

bold mason
#

cant wait for drag path to win

lapis crypt
#

Best song on the album will always be Cottonwood for me.

#

Also, One Way and Garbage, my two least favorites on the album. (Still like them.) Giving it to Garbage.

mossy vigil
lapis crypt
#

I can't type today

mossy vigil
unborn spruce
#

Idk, I’m kinda feeling like garbage rn

mossy vigil
radiant moon
#

Y’all we need to make sure Downstairs gets second. Maybe Drag Path but let’s all team up to make sure Downstairs gets second!!!

lapis crypt
#

I tend to connect songs to characters and stories. Cottonwood is no different. But also, I've known many people who have died, and we lost our dog back in July 8.

mossy vigil
undone breach
#

I have decided my vote, because of these lyrics my vote goes to Garbage

static bear
#

One Way genuinely could of been a top 5 song by the boys if they just made it a little longer

lapis crypt
#

Garbage does have lyrics I relate to, honestly.

static bear
#

Its still fire how it is though

lapis crypt
mossy vigil
#

i feel like garbage

static bear
fluid isle
#

i can't decide it
if i could feel more, or i just knew less
when i was younger, bright eyed with wonder
do you know which name it's under?

frozen harness
#

what is the point of an entire second place bracket

sweet oasis
#

Garbage 💖

lapis crypt
radiant moon
static bear
quasi dawn
#

idec about the 2nd place Im just so stoked center mass won

undone breach
lapis crypt
#

When TOP does repetitive lyrics, it doesn't pull me in like King Gizzard & the Lizard Wizard or Swans do. It kind of often pulls me out of it.

patent slate
#

if garbage loses first round I will lose it

scenic lilyBOT
patent slate
#

😭

quick eagle
#

i think i love both of these songs equally

mossy vigil
lapis crypt
#

Now, it's not every time. Jumpsuit has repetition, but how it's executed, how every time the "jumpsuit, jumpsuit, cover me" line is said, it gets more aggressive, works insanely well for me. Also Jumpsuit is a fantastic song through and through.

undone breach
quick eagle
#

i have to say garbage though because its just so applicable to my life

radiant moon
quick oracle
#

I love One Way but today is Garage

lapis crypt
#

I've already expressed my dislike for Doubt. Even though I'm not head over heels for One Way, it does every Doubt wanted to do, but better. I still think One Way is a good, fun track, but it's also my easy bottom pick for Breach.

rose crow
#

IF TALLY DOESNT WIN THIS SECOND ROUND IM GONNA CRY PLEASE GUYS

mossy vigil
#

i like doubt, but tbh i like all of their songs almost. but i don't like the demo as much as others, which feels weird because it's good, no doubt (no phun intended)

undone breach
#

Doubt is amazing, Hot Take, Doubt Demo is better 🙂

mossy vigil
undone breach
#

True, I love the beat behind the chorus in the Demo

strong rose
#

i feel like something that lost to Center Mass is bound to win the 2nd place round? so Downstairs or Drum Show?
no way Days Lie Dormant is taking this

mossy vigil
#

but to be 100% honest, ANY SONG LIVE is AMAZING. just my point of view

undone breach
#

YES

mossy vigil
# undone breach YES

the shivers on my spine when i see them being happy and their "we made it" moments. the dedication!!! gosh, i tear up just thinking about the fact how much they did for so many people and for themselfs

undone breach
#

fr

robust agate
#

One way all the wayy!

undone breach
#

I need to see them live some day grief

fluid isle
#

it'll be life changing dude

#

i'm still not over my concert in madrid

undone breach
#

nice

#

They just never tour where i am grief 😭

finite merlin
#

city walls shoulda won 🫩

#

but this is one way

undone breach
finite merlin
undone breach
#

they used to do more of Canada

#

but not so much anymore

#

And it sucks cause I've heard that their shows in my area were all great

undone breach
serene kayak
#

I'd be content with any of these two winning

floral cobalt
#

Yeah I’d be happy with either

zinc plinth
#

I’m scared of this round of song battles

undone breach
floral cobalt
#

Oh absolutely, for me unless they come back or go to Edmonton there’s going to be a decent travel cost + time

mossy vigil
#

I'm in europe, so my only chance is summer, the festivals

#

ALSO my playlist decided to play truce randomly, drowning in tears

mossy vigil
mossy vigil
#

Like i'm 26, i have been a fan since i was 12-13, i grow up with them. I NEED to see them

keen sand
#

Garbage is

#

I FEEL LIKE GARBAGE

mossy vigil
#

Last time they were here i was sadly in a hospital, oh 2019....

fluid isle
undone breach
#

Ha! most music festivals round here suck

brittle fjord
#

their coming to a festival in my land in the summer, like I NEED to go

floral cobalt
#

There’s music festivals?

keen sand
#

Move it up move it up up the beach

fluid isle
undone breach
fluid isle
#

two in germany

#

one in serbia or something

floral cobalt
fluid isle
#

and one in romania!!! where i lvie!!!!!!!!!1

brittle fjord
#

and one in Belguim

undone breach
mossy vigil
fluid isle
floral cobalt
#

I’d travel overseas but it’s super expensive

undone breach
#

Canada

fluid isle
mossy vigil
fluid isle
#

it's pretty well organised

undone breach
#

They hardly tour here

fluid isle
#

we're gonna have an unofficial tb flag!

scenic lilyBOT
fluid isle
mossy vigil
floral cobalt
fluid isle
#

my ig is blanketsover.mirrors

odd wing
#

WE MUST MAKE TALLY WIN

fluid isle
#

YES

finite merlin
radiant moon
fluid isle
#

no, tally

thorny kraken
cold flicker
#

Im gonna comment and say

#

Imagine letting center mass win

#

Smh

wheat mason
#

🚮 🗑️

rugged lotus
#

one way sweep

#

bye bye garbage

finite merlin
strange whale
#

i hope City Walls / Drum Show / Tally wins this one

thorny kraken
#

fair

strange whale
#

shouldn't the winner of this be Downstairs by default? going by the previous bracket

oh well I'm thankful for the chance to support City Walls / Drum Show anyway

thorny kraken
#

and also as the pairings are different. i think the match up themselves can nuance the results differently

thorny kraken
bold prawn
#

i cant pick

spiral cape
#

does anyone else think the contract is the best song on the album or am i just insane

zinc plinth
#

i hope city walls or rawfear or drum show or garbage or the contract or downstairs or robot voices or cottonwood or one way or days lie dormant or tally or intentions or drag path wins this one

barren swallow
#

I hope any of those besides intentions wins

#

Specifically tally tho

zinc plinth
#

what do you have against intentions lol

barren swallow
#

I think it's boring and just don't really like how it sounds tbh

jaunty nymph
#

one way

raven ridge
#

harddd choice but garbageee

serene harbor
#

Pain to choose

#

Garbage is so special

#

But one way…..

dawn jasper
#

tv

serene harbor
weary steppe
#

honestly…..

#

I WANTED TO FLYYYYYYY

#

BUT THEY SAY A SYSTEMS. COMING. IN.

#

THE CHANCES ARE HIIIIiiiIIIGH

#

and this is aaaaa.. One Way One Way

strange whale
# weary steppe honestly…..

Would you move closer if I grew quieter? Maybe this is you... maybe you don't fix and you like it like this...

(ultra relatable and i hope too many people don't relate)

quiet tendon
#

one way continues to be the second weakest while garbage is still the third weakest on breach

#

one way has amazing vocals but garbage actually has meaning so

weary steppe
quiet tendon
#

and im sure one way has a meaning too

silent oar
#

ond aU oneua onwards one way one way one way one way one way one way I wanted to flyyyyyyyyyy ones way one way

quiet tendon
#

but thats all one way has

#

"one way one way one way" apparently there was only one way to write this song and thats by making it mad repetitive

rugged lotus
#

garbage bottom 3 breach songs

#

ONE WAY SWEEP

weary steppe
#

i consider it almost an intermission song lol but it still is really good “am i dreaming? if its so, can i take back who i was before? if its no, then all my dreams have not been interesting in a while, this has not been interesting in a whiiile a whiiiiile”

quiet chasm
#

This fight only goes

#

One Way

frigid robin
#

ONE WAY, ONE WAY, ONE WAY

abstract pond
#

if garbage doesnt win im BECOMING garbage.

round panther
#

how I feel about ts

strange whale
#

you can change votes?!

golden gale
#

haha this aint even a challenge

#

tally solos

#

"YOU WANT A TALLY I'VE LOST THE COUNT"

hazy island
#

I know full well that it'll lose but I'm voting for Garbage anyway

frigid summit
#

i’m biting done on my shirt sleeve!!!!

ashen turtle
#

Chat can we get Drum Show to be second thanks

slender crest
#

this is very very hard

#

but one way

distant pollen
#

One way clears

paper minnow
#

i didn’t think center mass would win damn

#

also one way wins

sinful cloak
#

JUSTICE FOR TALLY!!!!!

thick dirge
#

Oh yeaaahhh more song battles!!!!!!!!!

#

Downstairs gas to be taking second place imo

jovial kraken
tame creek
#

I'm actually listening to Garbage rn

stuck latch
#

You can't put my two favorites head to head right off the bat!

junior hollow
#

one way gotta clear this

spark topaz
#

Ooooof I like both but I did it for Tyler's cute smile on tour

wheat wraith
#

one way just becasue it matches with days lie dormant

frigid robin
#

I love One Way

chilly glade
#

Tally #1

#

But one way frfr

frigid robin
#

And Center Mass too. Center Mass is great and deserves all the love it gets 💙

eternal wadi
#

Garbage

zinc plinth
#

One way is such a vibe and has better lyrics but garbage is so much more emotional and also has lyrical significance in its own way

frigid robin
#

Yes, yes !!

golden gale
#

i vote tally

sinful cloak
#

tally beats every song except center mass

calm fable
#

I feel like garbage

frigid robin
snow hawk
#

I voted One Way but do I regret it I dont know i think i love the song

nova edge
#

one day all the way

mossy siren
#

I missed 8 song battles (im sorry i had other things i was focussing on) and came back to One Way losing...

#

how???

#

One Way better not lose this one

#

i love garbage but one way is just catchy af i love it

#

and the transition to Days Lie Dormant is GOLD

plucky oriole
#

one way is breach's lavish

#

im still taking garbage tho 🤷‍♂️

zinc plinth
#

One way is breach's lavish and garbage is breach's vignette - i'd pick vignette over lavish personally

#

though i mean that doesnt really say everything

plucky oriole
zinc plinth
karmic elbow
#

Rah

wide gyro
#

I FEEL LIKE CABBAGE

thorny kraken
thin kraken
#

i heart garbage but one way you have my heart tonight

#

don’t tear it

thick dirge
#

Oooh we'll know in 4 mins 👀

livid pumice
#

stop

patent slate
#

VICTORY FOR GARBAGE

quiet chasm
#

What the hell

cold flicker
#

Gross

sage fractal
hazy island
#

Yeah, I didn't expect Garbage to win with One Way to be completely honest

nocturne gull
#

one way is literally so so so much better how did it lose
no offense to garbage

cold shadow
#

garbage is better imo

#

garbage connects with me more lyrically

frigid robin
#

That's understandable. We all feel like Garbage at times

outer rampart
#

damn one way got bodied oof