#2025 Breach Song Battle #11
1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)
Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1761753600:R>
Why are you making me choose
tally
oh lawd
CITY WALLSSSSS
Oof.
TALLY EZ
For fucks sake
Im actually torn for once
oh
THE CLASH OF THE TITANS IS HERE
DE WE AROU DOS SITI WALS
dude
easily tally
tally tally tally tally
NO
unfair as fuck lowkey
Tally
City Walls lol
TALLYYY
Oh hell naw
oh uhhhh
Tally.
tally or busy
Don't make me choooose
bust
uhhhh
uhhhhh
city walls. bro
NOOOOOOOOOOOOO I CANT
City Walls. Sorry friends
City walls
you were keeping traaaaaaAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACK OF EVery time
tallyyyyy dude it gets so stuck in my head
Tallyyyyyyyy
wrong! tally is better
this is evil
i lost my rank and title
I have to give it to the one and only Tally
IF TALLY LOSES, I'LL LOSE MY RANK
my smile wraps around my head splitting it in two is making me pick city walls sorry tally
absolutely diabolical
this is hard but i'm going city walls
tally live was absolutely insane
Dayummm
It's between the address my soul screams or the tally high note cmon I can't choose 😭😭😭😭😭
CITY WALLS
this is hard but city walls is just too good it’s so similar to ode to sleep with tempo change
i have no fucking clue tbh, i had tally above city walls for a while, but city walls had really grown on me, they're literally tied now
tally 100%
guys nico is so fast with the votes now who did that
City walls better win over tally
city walls cause it makes me feel more emotional.
Dawg City Walls and it's not even close
did alex do that
As a tally lover this is the only valid argument
I WANTED YOU TO SHOE ME
man i dont know
shoe
I went to Tinley and Cincy and didn’t get Tally or Downstairs 😭😭😭
City Walls vs Downstairs finale?
I feel like im betraying tally but city walls my beloved
love both but tally's the winner here
tallyyy
center mass vs downstairs is gonna be disgusting
CITY WALLS
City walls 
Tally easily lol
oh no
and downstairs better win
city walls vs center mass. trust 🙏🙏🙏
center mass winning
Tally clears here
Center mass vs downstairs. I forgot about that possibility
AAAAAAAAAAAQ
No downstairs will sweep
WHYYY
To quote Reno “City walls that’s a cool ass song, but this is something different u might catch me dancing around my room to this shit”
downstairs has a temporary boost due to being played live
I love City Walls but I prefer the energy of Tally :3
Center mass has to win the whole thing
We are down to my top three songs
I want city walls to win here so that we don’t choose between downstairs and tally- I want downstairs to win the whole thing
Tally sweep but I love city walls so so much
everyone was wanting it played live before it was tho
nuh uh
Don't make me pick bro
Oh downstairs vs center mass is gonna kill me
Downstairs wins because of it being debuted recently live
Center Mass must win because he said I would hate the song and I am wired to be defiant
to those reacting with crosses who dyt shld win
City Walls is so good.
Nuh uh Robot voices robot voi (idm which wins tbh they're all peak)
yes but people have heard the live performance they posted online and have likely been listening to it a lot.
i think i gotta go with city walls for this one, just barely. the production on that song is up there with their best
Im sorry city walls
downstairs wins cuz it’s a BANGER song which speaks to all of us if we know it or not
evil matchup
i heard downstairs live LA n1 and it shot up to top 10 ever so fast. magical
exactly
I'm skipping this vote. I can't decide.
downstairs center mass is ognna be close one
Breach is my favorite album and city walls is really good but. Tally <3
YOU WANNA TALLY IVE LOST THE COUNT
I fully agree
i can’t even pick a fav off breach it’s all so peak
Oof
These final three matchups are all going to be so painful
I LOST MY RANK AND TITLE
yall already killed drag path im not letting you take tally
This is garbage
ENTERTAIN MY
ENERTAIN MY
GARBAGE MENTIONED
no this is city walls vs tally
WALLS
CITY WALLS SWEEP
Sorry
i listened to city walls with my boyfriend the other day and he was immediately like "add that to one of my playlists" as soon as it ended
tally sweeeeep
City Walls makes me wanna fight and climb stuff lol
ENTERTAIN MY FAITHHHHHHHH THIS IS THE LAST TIME THIS IS THE LAST TIME
ADDRESS MY SOUL
Hope he likes Tally 
TRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACK
Oh wait this is brutal
anyone who reacts to this image votes for tally
I CANT BELIEVE THEY PUT HOLDING ON TO YOU IN THE SAME ALBUM AS BREACH
wait
that sentence did not make sense
Nooooo
Tally easy

who up keeping track
Bro WHAT
Idk if I’m even able to vote…. These are my most played out of the album
How do u even choosr
GOT YALL
Idk if u can even pick one..
WHO UP SQUARING UP WITH ME
good thing i did vote it
I like the best on city walls too much I’m sorry
peak vs peak
tally hits so hard
Deadass
These are getting so hard 
i haven't showed it to him yet, i've slowly been i̶n̶d̶o̶c̶t̶r̶i̶n̶a̶t̶i̶n̶g̶ turning him into a clikkie slowly but surely
city walls has some of the best production and sound on the album tho
I can take your right and throw a left!
AS MUCH AS TALLY IS AMAZING CITY WALLS ALSO HAS THE ADVANTAGE OF BEING FUNNY ASF BECAUSE FOR THE WHOLE MV CLANCY IS GETTING BEAT UP BY NICO AND THEN HE JUST CHARGES UP HIS ULTIMATE
fax but still voting tally
and i cant even argue tbh
GANG SAID WAIT FOR THE BEAT DROP
Pair up with me I'ma take you right to the chest
tally ftw bc city walls mv broke me 
i want tally to win
this is horible
tally isn’t just losing its rank and
title
City Walls after being a fan since 2013 was a rollercoaster of emotions
TALLY SWEEP !!!
city walls are for the ogs but tally is for the few the proud and the emotional
yes!!
HELP
i aint got enough memory from 2013
tally 🥹
more like for the GAY the proud and emotional
HELL YEAH
we already got lavish
ME
do NOT drag lavish in
WAIT I ONLY SAW SCREENSHOTS OF THIS SHIT LMAO THIS IS LIKE. A VIDEO??
jesus why am i getting reaction nuked
skill issie by nico tbh, should've just had a better ult
because we HATE gay people
i love this gif this is my son
GET OU-
whats actually the context for this 😭
hard to decide
HELP
ENTERTAIN MY FAIIIIIITTTTHHHH 🗣🗣🗣
I love both of these to death but I think Tally is better musically. City Walls was a great end for the story tho
I bet tally I gonna win.. even though I love city walls much more
City walls >>>>
people are gonna hold a grudge against city walls for beating drag path and make it lose😭
imo city walls deserves the win but tally deserves our hearts
you were keeping TRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACKKKKKKKKKKKK OF EVERY TIME
City walls all the way
Yeah bc it’s radio/tv friendly. City walls isn’t but it’s still better imo
i need this gif NOW
Whats NFL?
Ok im voting tally purely because it’s stuck in my head rn and city walls isn’t
YOU WANT A TALLY I LOST COUNT
same tho
This one’s actually hard asf I don’t know which one to choose
I CANT PICK
Gonna have to make a pros list (because these two have no cons) and see which one has more and pick that one this is too hard 
Pros: just figured you were keeping traaaaAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACK OF EVERY TIME
I LIKEN OUR FIGHT TO TWO LIGHTNING STRIK STIKES ON QUE
Pros: ENTERTAIN MY- FAAAAAAITHHH
Good point
city walls
I'm saying city walls because tally I love you sm and even doing an animatic for it for my storyboarding class but city walls is the end of the lore so like I gotta go with that
Tally
oh nooo
Man city wallsddz
I'm actually really curious where this will go
UGHHHH these are both one of my favorites

what if i just don't vote at all
City walls easy
Lwk can't choose
im not sure i can vote on this
I’m not voting
Tally is so close to my name… but City Walls…
Voting City Walls bc Tally is now my sworn enemy (for beating Rawfear)
i lost my rank and title
Tally
City walls
Just figured you were keeping track of every tiiiiiiime I let you down I breached your trust I let you diiiiiiee
ooohhbbhbh
tally is peak though
who up losing their rank and title
I find your mind extraordinary,
I’ve crawled through mud unsanitary
Let me go
Let me go
Let me go
Let me go
In other words… Tally
Tally
I really wish I enjoyed City Walls more
These are unused lyrics for Tally btw if anyone doesn’t recognize it
tally sweep please please please
Okay but city walls first listen >>
me to nico
Tally is my favorite off the whole album
still was hard cause City Walls is great too
love tally but i think city walls is a powerhouse
Tally Tally tally Tally
I'm good with either winning tbh
tally’s overglazed
Battle of the lore songs
Tally is a lore song?
I certainly say so
I feel like he's talking to torchbearer or the banditos when he says i let you down, i breached your trust
City walls, 1 because its amazing, 2 because they put so much effort into it
Like 1 million dollars is insane
it has a great melody, a great segment of rapping, good instrumentals, AN AMAZING SCREAM, a million dollar music video, and enough emotional damage to put anyone into therapy
As a Breach clique I blame City Walls for getting me into all of this
so it will always be top for me
🌆
PALADIN TOO WAS LIFE CHANGING
I just wish they did something special for city walls in the concerts
I'm glad they at least showed the music video on a massive screen in all of its glory
would be crazy if in the songs after city walls tyler donned the bishop robes
WAIT BISHOP CLANCY SINGING RIDE WITH A KID WOULD BE SO FUNNY HAHA
I was at the live debut of tally, and i saw the beginning of city walls, then it went to tally and hollly it was crazy, like a song ago he talked about not putting the full album when touring
Bro knew what he was doing
I hope next tour they have downstairs on the setlist so we can experience it
BRO YOU WERE AT HERSHEY WHOA
yess
i agree
I'm fighting for Navigating, Paladin, or Bandito to come back onto the setlist in some capacity
Lavish would also be amazing. It's fun and it gives the boys a silly little song
Whats even crazier is it was my first concert ever
actually insane
Amazing first concert
Do y'all know if the setlist is gonna be different for the festivals in 2026?
Too early to tell. Definitely will be shorter and I know they will never take off trees
if they take off overcompensate however I will cry
💔
Probably, cause it isnt their "show" so it will def be shorter
LIKE NEVER TOUCH OVERCOMPENSATE IT IS THE BEST OPENER
I also think for festivals they would focus a bit more on Breach for the Europe audiences that never got it
actually pissed that my two favorite bands are playing at the same festival in Arizona and I can't go
Yeah i think overcompensate will stay, tyler probably has so much fun jumping off the piano to start
also think Josh has fun coming out for the drums and hyping everyone up
GOOD BECAUSE THAT SONG IS SOOO FUN
Mhm
Did you know they havent played in hershey park for 9 years
So i got really lucky that they decided to play there
TALLY
I LOST MY RANK AND TITLE
TALLY EASY
yep im still voting drag path
I like both songs as equally as you can like two songs
I voted city over drag path because I hadn't listened to drag path that much yet
I now love them both so much
i ove city walls but
trally
tally
tally sweep
tally is winning this whole thing
if city walls doesn't win I'm storming dema
I LOVE TALLY!!!
Are you forgetting abt downstairs
just figured you were keeping traaaaaaaaaaaAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACK OF EVERY TIME
tally v downstairs tally is clearing sorry
Clearing?? Nahh it will be really close
tally ezzz
YOU WANT A TALLY I LOST COUNT
YOU WANNA LOVE NE I'LL LET YOU DOWN
STILL NOW
YOU BELIEVE IN ME SOMEHOW
TRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACK
OF EVERY TIME
tally is too good
my number 1
had 717 listens of tally in a single week
IM NOT CRAZY GUYS
I cried to Tally last night so gotta go with that
Its literally Clancy singing to Torchbearer
talling
WEEZER SLIGHTLY MENTIONED
i live weezer
tallyyyyyyy
YOU WANT A TALLY I LOST THE COUNT
YOU WANNA LOVE ME ILL LET YOU DOWN
STILL NOW
YOU BELIEVE IN ME SOMEHOW
WHEN I REPLAY IT IN MY MIND
I SEE YOUR HEARTBREAK EVERY TIME
STILL NOW
YOU BELIEVE IN ME SOMEHOW
This changes day-to-day for me. Ugh
i dont know tally just doesnt do it for me, like i like its message sure but i mean a song i feel lukewarm about vs my favorite off the album?? pretty easy
i think tally will definitely win tho
i relistneed to it to figure out why it's everyones favorite, is it just like the message?
its just overall a really good song, mainly the message i think
i dont relate to most tøp songs i just really like their music
not trying to hate or anything
yeah i guess i just didnt like tally's music
dunno why
i mean city walls made me cry personally
I think city walls made most of us cry lol
which is why i thought it'd be like pick it for sure ;-;
gotta be city walls
but i guess with TOP the standards gotta go up for things
tally is a banger but city walls is the finale of the last decade with references to multiple older songs and a mv with a million dollar budget
In my opinion its kinda like ride i guess? Ride is really really popular, even though in my opinion a lot of the songs in blurryface deserved it more, like heavydirtysoul
Dont get me wrong i love ride
But its jst one of those things a lot of people like
No particular reason why
ok thats a comparision i understand, thank you
such a tough battle but i gotta go with tally. it's my favorite off the album
TALLLLLLLLYYYYYYY
gang drag path should be number 1 why did it lose so early
why we fumbling bro
one way is out...? ....no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no.no... bring it back
Went up against city walls
Peak and peak
I barely even know what it sounds like so uh I doubt it would win due to it not really being publicly available yet plus it's slightly newer and stuff
Man I love city walls and tally definitely my 2 favorites tho I think I just vibe with tally more (it's literally my status rn so)
One Way won a way to our hearts 💙
There's so much to like about City Walls
oh this is hard
probably Tally tho since it's my #2 fav right underneath Downstairs, but City Walls is my #3 so i'm bummed lol
i never see anyone talk about this but i absolutely love that weird instrumental part in city walls, the part that i cant figure out what instrument it is. after he says “abandoned by the sun”, from memory.
LEVEL UP: You are now level 2!
Tally was my #1 right up until the live Downstairs vid came out, then i bawled my eyes out and Downstairs became my #1 lol
it's a broken saxophone!!
woah
Paul Meany posted about it on Instagram (probably other social medias too but i mainly use Instagram lol)
that part alone has always earned city walls many extra points for me
its so unique as well, unlike anything i’ve heard in their music before (that i recall)
real!! City Walls is #3 for me in terms of favorites off of Breach and Tally is #2 so it's not an easy decision 💔
exactly. Im voting for tally but if it loses i'm still happy with city walls
I agree its the opening act and the close act
same!!
drag path beats city walls anyday
God, Tally vs City Walls?
did what yall say
LEVEL UP: You are now level 5!
I knoow but its not public so ofc city walls is going to win
i'll send it to everyone
trust
city walls is kinda underwhelming especially compared to overcompensate
as an opener
tally is also better so i voted for that
Tally reminds me of regional at best and I am loving it
Uh oh this one is evil
I LOST MY RANK AND TITLE
to be fair i dont know if i would like city walls as much without the music video ingrained in my head
Crazy
Can't stand for the tally slander
Why do you think that? Im just curious
...how am I supposed to choose this
ough.... this sucks
hmmmm city walls it is. the production, old song references, and bridge is just too peak vs tally.
okay what
tally sweep no questions asked
I TURNED MY BACK ON IT
It’s good but half of breach is better
SOLD IT ALL AT A DISCOUNT
drums
tally for sure
you're right but its not as catchy so they will never understand
RAWFEAR, city walls, downstairs, drum show, the contract, garbage, and intentions are all better than tally
peak vs peak
THIS WAS SO HARD WTF IS WRONG WITH THW RANDOMIZER 😰
I love City Walls, but I'm going with tally
I think they're both great but honestly overcompensate is such an absolute powerhouse of an album AND concert opener
I don't know if I'll ever forget hearing it for the first time
Lol no way bro city walls is the culmination of the whole lore
City walls is so freaking epic in the way its executed, the mood shifts of the song and just the way it draws everything to a close is so epic, the only complaint i might have about it is that the intro buildup sometimes sounds a bit strange with the way they did the "yeah yeah yeah yeah"s but it's a masterpiece honestly
Overcompensate is amazing as well its so hype but city walls all the way through is dramatic and is such an epic climax but overcompensate is kind of more chill so it really depends which you prefer
no literally dude
ughhh nah but like. I think I have a slight bias towards Tally because of how much I personally relate to it but on the other City Walls is just. it's such a good opener for the album and the fact that it references Vessel not one but TWO times in such a poetic way is just. AUGHURGAH
BUT THE BRIDGE IN TALLY. EUAGHH how do you even DECIDE
Tally also made me cry tho
Its literally clancy singing to Torchbearer and his screams are just so ARGHSKDHSKDH
oh really? I thought of it as a song to tyler's wife
Tally has lyrics that can be interpreted to mean different things which honestly i really love in a song
I mean ir could be. Sorry, I was exaggerating when I said literally, hes not said anything about that in interviews or anything I just see it being to Torchbearer more than how ir could be to his wife. I see days lay dormant and maybe robot voices as being the songs to his wife.
Yeah
And Tyler gives us so much room for it
Also something can mean 2 or more things at once
Thinking about the lyrics again in my head yeah I think I see what you mean
When I used to be religious I had similar feelinfs to that
Its a popular take among my friends but as a Christian that song really speaks to me
(I was raised catholic)
i think when i hear it i get bitter because i just came out of a relationship where i was constantly afraid there was a tally being held against me and at the end it seemed like there really was, and i wish i had a relationship that i felt that way about, but i dont, or if i do, im not aware of it. I mean I guess there is the whole relationship with God, and that is powerful and to be honest i hadn't thought of that. maybe when i listen to it again ill think of htat instead of being bitter
I'm curious though how do you interpret the line about lightning? That one's hard to make sense of for me
The last two lines are self explanatory but the first three are a bit too cryptic for me
I love the creativity of these lyrics, i just don't know what they mean lol
SAAAME
Usually I think I'm pretty good at deciphering tyler lyrics but this stanza has me beat
Thats the tough one that always gets me lol
I gotta get some rest for tomorrow so ill have to get back to ya in the morning. Give me some time to think as well lol
I liken our fight to two, lightning strikes strike on cue, He delivers it so well
Sounds good lol. Thanks
Yeah I love whenever he does these rap bridge things like in message man and car radio
Yeah
Did you guys notice the drum beat in Tally is super simmilar to Heavydirtysoul?
I was NOT ready when he started performing it live on the B stage literally 20 feet from me
Hmmn, I'll have to give it another listen
That might add more credence to my theory of it being about torchbearer so that sounds really cool
But yeah usuallt I'm paying more attention to the heart wrenching lyrics
for real
Center Mass ripped my heart out
same with Garbage
but they are both so good
AND THEN COTTONWOOD RIGHR AFGEE
RIGHT
EVIL
IT'S SO HARD BUT ALSO AMAZING AT THE SAME TIME
I got choked up with the "Entertain my faith" part in City Walls
EXACTLY
Honestly first time I was too busy being flabbergasted that theyre refrencing vessel
fr
I was in rhe car with mt mom listeninf to it the first time
anyway, i gotta dip! Chat tomorrow
And I was desperately trying to find the words to explain ir but it took me a sec lol
Bye!
I hope Tally wins
Same. We shall see
City Walls, indeed 😌
City Walls bitches
tally shits on city walls
TACLIYWS
truly inspirational 🙏
CITY WALLS 🗣️🗣️🗣️
CITY WALLS FOR THE WIN
I WANT A TALLY
Okay, heres my interpretation of it:
I think it very much reminds me of the lighning line in implicit demand for proof "strike me down, I am calling your lightning, down from your dark hiding place" where Tyler asks God to hurt him, strike him down as proof. Here I think he is saying that their fight (his fight with faith and therefore God) is just like the lightning strike he was looking for, but it happens at the same time as another strike leading him to question if it was intentional or not (circumstantial proof part) so he suggests that he try his own way of life without faith but him and God both know how that goes and that they should just come together.
Idk if that was clear or not but if you have any questions pls lmk
BOTH ARE IN MY TOP 3, BUT CITY WALLS >>>>
Ohhh I see thanks. I'll check out implicit demand for proof because honestly I haven't actually listend to that one yet
okay but tally every listen>>>>>>>
I lost the count tho
1 hour till the moment of truth (pls be tally)
tally will be winning
I want city walls to win so that downstairs will win the whole thing 💯💯💯💯
downstairs will have an easier time beating city walls than tally
I respect Downstairs so much, but Tally connects with me on such a personal level, so I want Tally to win
and don't get me wrong Downstairs is fire
HOW
wow
disappointed
What the fuck
CITY WALLS
Are we fucking deadass
ARE WE FR RN
TALLY >>>>>>>>>>
INSANE
NOOOOOOOOOOOO
City Walls is good, but good enough to beat TALLY? Really?
either way this was gonna be tragic 😭
TALLY SHOULDVE WON THE WHOLE THING
Only 100 points off?!!
I demand a recount!
deserved
CITY WALLS LETS FUCKING GOOOOOO
CITY RAHHHH
WE'VE LOST THE TALLY 🔥🔥🔥🔥
We lost count 😭😭😭

Even though i voted for city walls I WAS SURE TALLY WOULD WIN I'D SELL MY SOUL FOR IT TO WIN


POOR TALLY
NNO TALLY
City Walls beat TALLY???
these were both in my top 5
Is it really that surprising? It was really anyones game there, i knew it would be really close
Well actually when you think abt it, tally lost by 110 votes
And i kinda hoped city walls did win cause like they spent so much effort on city walls, its 100% deserved
ja rip tally
rip Tally 🫡
this is the first Breach song battle i've voted for that didn't win and now i feel like a rebel 
The underdog lost :(
City walls is epic tho it deserved it lol
If it's makes you feel better, my favorite Breach song lost 😂
justice for tally 💔
TALLY NOOO
damn
Honestly I'm still happy. Only 107 votes from beating the leading track single.
That ain't easy to do
Btw I realized something earlier. What if torchbearer is God?
Yup, I like to interpret it like that a lot
I didnt even think of that!! thats a really awesome idea
Thanks! It occured to me when I was thinking about the whole Clancy becoming Nico thing and finally realized that while we know exactly what Clancy and Nico represent, I havent seen anything nearly as concrete about the torchbearer and then them representing god was the first thing that came to me. I'd love to hear any other ideas though
Loved how close this was, I voted for City Walls but was fully expecting Tally to win. Both are such peak songs 


