2025 Clancy Song Battle #12

[radiant elk]

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1756134000:R>

[slow sinew]

first

[sharp atlas]

Oldies

[vale hare]

second

[honest patrol]

Are we fr

[simple girder]

uh shit

[dapper wraith]

oldies station solo

[tepid escarp]

uh oh

[slow sinew]

navigoating ftw

[trail shuttle]

easy navigation

[dark hazel]

Navigating is sweeping

[wraith ether]

😩

[kindred umbra]

navigating

[hard escarp]

CMON OLDIES

[frail pine]

navigation sweep fs

[simple girder]

navigating sweep pls.

[modern lark]

Oldies sweeption

[limpid osprey]

oh fuck me bro

[dark hazel]

Navisweep!!!!!!

[tepid escarp]

SARLIGHT WHAT U VOTING FOR

[blissful sandal]

Oldies Station I beg

Navigating’s a great song don’t get me wrong but it’s not the best on the album

[tranquil monolith]

NAVISWEEP

[honest patrol]

None of these should be in the final 😭

[final gull]

didnt think navigating would make it this far

[golden ivy]

Navigating the song battle!

[worldly bluff]

please win oldies

[ionic shoal]

oldies station fr

[full lotus]

oldies in top 3 is sick

[cyan olive]

OLDIES 🙏 🙏

[slow sinew]

i was first tf chat

[simple girder]

NAVIGATING 😭😭😭

[toxic tapir]

OLDIES SWEEP

[hard escarp]

WHEN DARKNESS ROLLS ON YOU, PUSH ON THROUGH (by voting oldies station :3)

[fierce wagon]

This is gonna be fun

[limpid osprey]

tyler’s favorite song vs. tyler’s least favorite song

[sinful oar]

HELL NO

[brisk jolt]

OLDIES

[gusty grail]

OLDIEEEEEEEEEES

[tepid escarp]

OKKK I FOLLOW YOU

[nimble citrus]

oldies station reaching the finals was so unexpecting

[onyx karma]

Oldies station better win

[ionic shoal]

oldies station please brother </3

[warm birch]

Aw c'mon

[brisk jolt]

OLDIES OLDIES OLDIES

[blissful sandal]

Honestly though Overcompensate woulda been here instead of Navigating

[near valley]

Sweep station‼️

[obtuse ledge]

oldies station but i’ll still b happy if navigating wins

[warm birch]

Theres no way i have to pick one

[ionic shoal]

OH WAIT THIS IS FINALS?

[tender patrol]

oldies PLEEEEASE

[mortal knot]

i'm just really happy navigating is going to win

[final gull]

i thought next semester would be up here

[dreamy salmon]

Let's take Oldies to the win !

[tribal rock]

Even if NS lost my top 3 is still in the top 3

[warm birch]

Is there a both option?

[signal axle]

When the darkness rolls on you...

[copper drift]

oldies station please

[final gull]

but yeah oldies ftw

[sullen lance]

How does one chose in this vote😭

[dark hazel]

NAVIGATING

[blissful sandal]

Anyway voting for Oldies because it’s a great song

[dreamy salmon]

Btw, I love navigating

[simple girder]

genuinely thought next semester made it instead of navigating 😭

[round breach]

Navigating cuz I love oldies

[azure island]

OLDIES STATION

[ionic shoal]

rip next semester </3

[exotic aspen]

Idfk😭

[signal cypress]

if oldies won does that mean you bring it back to the setlist?

[onyx karma]

Same

[mystic shale]

I AM WASTINGGG ALLLL THIS TIIIIIMMEEEE

MY OH MYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

[toxic tapir]

Oldies they could never make me hate you

[round breach]

I'm seeing a lot of oldies hate 🙏🏻

[vale hare]

I love oldies as much as the next person but I love navigating for driving and tyler’s vocals and ahhh the bass

[acoustic hinge]

theres no way navigating wins this. im surprised its gotten this far already. like over next semester??? yall crazy

[lapis frost]

called it lol

[round breach]

AMEN

[simple girder]

only reason im picking navigating is bc it (and ritn) made me a clikkke 💔

[mortal knot]

next semester was never better than the raw emotion of navigating

[warm birch]

Nico i will kidnap u if you dont have a both option /j

[final gull]

ITS GONNA BE A CLOSE ONE HERE IM HYPED

[dim ore]

bro oldies station isnt even top 10 on clancy

[twilit delta]

par don my delay

[ionic shoal]

oldies is so good </3

[toxic tapir]

Okay but have you considered being in the crowd at her first dance recital

[twilit delta]

(im 2 minutes late)

[mystic shale]

people liking oldies a lot, how the hell is it even in the last round

Its definitely top 5 but navigating needs to win this round, no doubt

[solid carbon]

crazy how the song that was booed is probably going to win this song battle

[pearl osprey]

Hearing navigating live (everybody leaves part) shortly after my great grandma passed away destroyed me

[vale hare]

oldies is amazing 😔

[ember lagoon]

if navigating wins i’m gonna be pissed off so much bro

[signal axle]

Truthfully I like navigating more than oldies for sure, but I’m voting oldies to get revenge for navigating beating NEXT SEMESTER WHICH SHOULD BE HERE RIGHT NOW

[mystic shale]

navigating Should win

[ivory gorge]

oldies :)

[simple girder]

i swear i love oldies

[silver hollow]

NAVIGATING ✨

[signal cypress]

navigating is my fav but oldies deserves some love

[ivory gorge]

navigating also deserves to win so either works

[signal axle]

OLDIES

[ember lagoon]

yes bro fr

[dreamy mantle]

I LOVE BOTH SM

[lime imp]

navigating ez

[deft parcel]

FUCK

[tawdry charm]

Is this a sign that oldies should be back on the track list for your???

[vale hare]

navigating tickles my brain right

[mortal knot]

a mod with taste

[keen palm]

i’m voting oldies out of spite why did next semester lose 💔

[mystic shale]

it already got a lot of love its like 3-2 against navigating 😭

[cyan olive]

Oldies cause oldies and midwest are my favourite but i voted oldies because i knew midwest couldnt stand in the finals 💔

[gusty grail]

I agree that NS should’ve won but I don’t think I could have handled NS vs. Oldies

[marble badge]

I did not expect Oldies Station to get this far. Let's make it win!

[tepid escarp]

yes yes of course you do

[signal axle]

SAME

[simple girder]

/gen.

[twilit delta]

he did not take the jacket guys

[patent pond]

I’m not voting, justice for Next Semester

[static ember]

I just love the lyrics on oldies way too much ill have to vote it

[remote talon]

So are we gonna have MTV unplugged next

[signal cypress]

i second that

[silver hollow]

After the third time you should get a notification that Nico is tired of your bullshit and has dragged you into his tower

[signal axle]

That one would’ve easily been next semester

[simple girder]

AHAHAHAHA

[runic parcel]

this one is brutal

[signal axle]

Vote oldies to get revenge on navigating

[deft parcel]

I hate this, these are my two favourites of the album 😭

[mystic shale]

it seems like about the right time for oldies to go

[cyan olive]

Oldies sweeeeep

[vale hare]

livestream experience would be…ouch

[ember lagoon]

navigating should not have beaten next semester, atrofd, OR paladin strait

[tawdry charm]

I’d love to see it live (I’m going to my first show ever in September)

[minor copper]

the oldies slander is wild

[ember lagoon]

WHY is it here

[simple girder]

shy awAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

[mystic shale]

i am a BILLION percent right sorry

[frail pine]

the ones that get it, get it

[vale hare]

Jumpsuit/ Heavydirtysoul forever

[patent pond]

(I mean I do like Navigating more, but I’m never forgiving it)

[simple girder]

also so real

[mystic shale]

u cant stop me

[solar abyss]

what if we agreed all the songs were the best?

[rotund prism]

i'm nor even that big of a fan of oldies station but i'm voting for it out of pure spite

[vale hare]

Clancy is a masterpiece anyway

[remote talon]

Livestream and MTV stressed out >>>

[glacial temple]

your favorite song was on the oldies station push on through

[warm birch]

Ykw im voting Oldies Station cuz sadly theres no both option 😔

[ember cedar]

I don't even really care which one wins, Navigating, Next Semester and Oldies Station are locked in on the top 3. And that's exactly how it should be!

[vale hare]

Sooo I basically love all of the clancy songs

[lethal abyss]

I love navigating, didn't realize it was this popular tho

[clever wren]

CLANCY SB FINALE SONGS vs their seeding(fanmade from the 2 previous clancy song battles):

#1: Navigating(DEFENDING CLANCY SB WINNER)
#2: At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb
#3: Midwest Indigo
#4: Vignette
#5 Oldies Station
#6: Routines In The Night
#7: Next Semester
#8: Overcompensate
#9: Paladin Strait
#10: Lavish
#11: Backslide
#12: Snap Back
#13-14:The Craving (both versions)

[deft parcel]

honestly i don't need to vote here. whichever one of these wins I'll be happy

[signal cypress]

i'm so excited for you. you gonna have the best time of your life. also bring some tissues cause you gonna cry

[pale bridge]

Oldies wins here, it has to

[mortal knot]

navigating has more raw emotion and power behind simpler lyrics, repeating often and dragging on

next semester talks about a deeper, more complex topic of starting fresh after failure

they're the same in having mainly drums and bass as the roots to the song, like drum show.

in short: it's only the lyrics that are different

[mystic shale]

3-2, the only right choice is making them even

[lethal abyss]

Fr

[dim ore]

we give oldies station too much glaze

its a good song, its heartwarming and sweet, i love it for what it is

you CANNOT tell me it has a better structure or is sung better than most other songs on clancy

[solid carbon]

tyler seeing navigating against oldies knowing that it’s one of his least favorite songs:

[clever wren]

No navigating won 3 times already

I think

[tawdry charm]

Oh I’m fully expecting to cry at the show (esp during the line, trees, etc)

[gloomy oracle]

navigating can't win another battle

[mystic shale]

clearly says 2

[signal axle]

Y’all have no taste letting navigating win over next semester

[pale bridge]

let Oldies win for Tyler's sake

[elder sorrel]

Oldies Station sweep

[digital tusk]

navigating

[vale hare]

I am sad for ATROFD 😔 it’s my fav clancy song

[clever wren]

It's very buggy overcomp had 1 and it showed 0 so 😭

[swift crag]

???? Navigating beat next semester

[digital tusk]

even tho oldies is about us, i like the lore in navigating

[swift crag]

Yall are foolish

[dim ore]

this is actually the worst possible ending

[cyan olive]

Oldies sweep

[dim ore]

it shouldve been backslide vs vignette

[signal axle]

This is true

[lethal abyss]

Doesn't really matter what wins anyway like. What's it gonna do. It's not like we're forced to only listen to the winner from then on. Just a silly little fun thing

[crude wraith]

OLDIES SWEEP

[mystic shale]

oldies 2nd would still be an insane result for all the hate it got

[mortal knot]

i have faith in yall to make the right decision

[signal axle]

Idk about backslide but why tf did vignette lose to RITN

[frail pine]

the bass line in navigating alone is an immediate sweep

[mortal knot]

-# navigating

[mystic shale]

navigating is too real and a bop

[signal axle]

The bass in navigating is the most stale shit ever, next semester has way better bass, production, lyrics, and singing

[clever wren]

Vignette's seeded higher but the only matchup where it loses to a lower seed is RITN which it has lost twice to

[frail pine]

it's okay to be objectively wrong

[still gorge]

How is it these two over Next Semester, Paladin Strait, Vignette, and Backslide?

[mortal knot]

that's subjective btw

[dim ore]

FR BRO

[mystic shale]

not better production, ns kinda overproduced with the ukes

[dim ore]

its nothing special

navigating is soooo overrated

[upbeat rock]

How is At the Risk of Feeling Dumb not up there for yall

[signal axle]

Navigating is very stale, if you want Tyler to write about ppl dying listen to the line it’s leagues better

[mystic shale]

also better singing is crazy, the emotion in navigating is way more real

[frail pine]

? the line isn't in the bracket friend

[still gorge]

They're stating their subjective opinion then. Don't try to invalidate it. You can disagree.

[mortal knot]

yall just prefer NS because it has more lyrics and it changes more tbh

[signal axle]

The “emotion” in navigating is so forced and face level

[fringe hare]

the bass line on navigating isnt anything special compared to much of their other bass heavy songs

[mystic shale]

thats... dumb as hell

[upbeat rock]

Dawg the emotion in Oldies Station is in the lyrics, the actual music kinda carries Navigating

[mortal knot]

they didn't say "i think" they said it like it's fact

[mystic shale]

thats actually next semester 😭

[signal axle]

That’s not my point it’s still better

[remote talon]

I heard it on the radio 🔥

[cyan olive]

Or personal preference 🤷

[frail pine]

doesn't mean it doesn't hit

[upbeat rock]

Drum Show's bass line is basically better Navigating

[mystic shale]

not talking about oldies dw

[chilly urchin]

OLDIES SWEEEPPPP

[fringe hare]

Exactly

[still gorge]

You can state an opinion confidently.

[signal axle]

Next semester isn’t the song that up front says “kinda feels like everybody leaves”

[fringe hare]

but it’s not even like half as good

[mystic shale]

navigating is a bop and its REAL and u cant say anything to prove us wrong hater

[prime kayak]

i was not aware of the navigating hate yikes

[still gorge]

Sorry, not trying to start a fight

[frail pine]

opinions exist, i like loud songs

[still gorge]

All good vibes here

[mortal knot]

ok

[signal axle]

Drum show is hands down top 3 TOP bass heavy songs

[mystic shale]

we're clearly talking about the singing

[fringe hare]

ok

[chilly urchin]

istg if oldies doesn't win

[fringe hare]

oldies should not have made it this far but navigating deserves it even leas

[signal axle]

Yeah fr

[clever wren]

For anyone wondering:
Seed 1 Navigating: Won against Seed 9 Paladin Strait - Seed 2 ATROFD - Seed 7 Next Semester
Seed 5 Oldies Station:* Won against Seed 13 The Craving - Seed 3 Midwest Indigo - Seed 6 RITN

[mystic shale]

happy that oldies made it tho, whatever happens happens

[winter pewter]

Please oldies station! You better win oldies!

[untold vector]

OLDIES STATION

[still gorge]

I voted Oldies Station. But I think it only made it this far because people felt bad about what happened on tour.

[upbeat rock]

Navigating is kinda repetitive, more like background music to me

[fringe hare]

What happened on the tour

[signal axle]

I do like navigating more than oldies but navigating winning over next semester is a travesty and I’m out for blood

[untold vector]

I like navigating but honestly kinda same

[clever wren]

No it's a genuinely loved song I feel like

[craggy heath]

I completely missed how oldies beat RITN
Like it's a great song, but my least favorite from the album 😭

[untold vector]

Real. Next semester or navigating I’ll choose next semester any day

[rotund prism]

i know it's not about the same thing, but drum show is just a better version of navigating in every way. more lively production, better vocals, better instrumentals, ect

[still gorge]

People booed when he sang it because they were hoping for Slowtown instead.

[mystic shale]

omg it did?? fucking amazing

[craggy heath]

What happened?

[fringe hare]

Bruhhhh

[frail pine]

ew what??

[untold vector]

Oldies is better than Slowtown by far I love Slowtown but like 😭

[signal axle]

Next semester is top 5 TOP, navigating is just top 50

[frail pine]

i love slowtown too but like hello??

[clever wren]

Back then yes and I hope that never happens again so ungrateful smh

[still gorge]

Yeah, it was so stupid

[craggy heath]

Nooo, that's so sad
Why do people do shit like this??? 😭

[late coral]

It's crazy we're down to the worst vs the best on Clancy lol

[mystic shale]

someone is a little emotionally attached it seems, i get it

[cold coral]

navigating is the best song on clancy, fight me

[craggy heath]

My exact ranking XD

[iron vault]

oldies takes oldies peak

[stark tiger]

EXACTLYYYY

[clear mural]

OLDIES STATION SUPREMACY

[signal axle]

Overcompensate next semester Paladin strait vignette ATROFD and backslide are right in front of your eyes

[brave wolf]

WOWH PHILZA FAN IN THE WILD CRAZY

[fair pond]

@brave wolf HOW DID I FUCKINF KNOW

[still gorge]

Is Navigating the worst? If so, I agree. (Except maybe ATROFD. I just didn't like the sound of it.)

[craggy heath]

I'll stand besides you and fight hand to hand if anyone disagrees
(Navigating is my #1 song of them all)

[brave wolf]

lmao

[untold vector]

I love oldies more than navigating but I listen to navigating more because oldies is just such an emotional song for me

[iron vault]

oldies please win oldies please win

[cold coral]

ill accept that overcompensate, paladin strait and atrofd are up there with navigating

[mystic shale]

oc and paladin dont do SHIT against navigating dawg 😭

[iron vault]

oldies is just objectively better

[signal axle]

Nah they’re above navigating

[clever wren]

If anyone wants to know how these 2 songs got here and what fanmade seed they are in here you go

REMINDER THAT THIS SEEDING IS FANMADE AND TAKEN FROM THE PREVIOUS 2 CLANCY SBS DONT TAKE IT TOO SERIOUSLY

[soft lark]

OLDIESS

[iron vault]

like oldies is just so full of substance

of just everything

[signal axle]

Let me guess because of the minute of birds?

[rotund prism]

it's a good song but the community had a giant switch up on it after they stopped playing it on tour and it's really weird, suddenly everyone started acting like it's always been their favorite off the album when the community consensus before was that it was one of the weaker songs on the album. like i'm not at all saying that's you, it's an amazing song and i'm glad it's getting more love, it's just a weird switch up that happened accross the community

[fair pond]

I’m cooked up six ways to Sunday famalam 🙁🙏

[cold coral]

yall are sleeping on the lyrics of navigating

[frail pine]

god forbid we get worldbuilding

[signal axle]

The lyrics are so face level they’re nothing special

[mystic shale]

no... its just not that insane 🧍‍♂️

[clever wren]

Ungrateful top fans when their actions have consequences 😭

[iron vault]

this fandom has a huge issue on over-correction
i was oldies fan D1

[signal axle]

Paladin is SO insane especially in the bridge and third chorus

[mystic shale]

cus paladin strait is definitely not face level lyrics !

[somber hazel]

Guys if you don’t vote navigating we are OPPs

[trail solar]

most surprising album battle tbh

[mystic shale]

i listened to the paladin stems, its not that crazy

[iron vault]

god forbid i'd rather vote the song that saved my life

[clear mural]

while i personallly loved the song before people boo'd it on tour, i kinda agree with what you're saying here because i have seen this happen

nontheless, oldies station is my favorite off of clancy besides ATROFD and next semester so IT GETS MY VOTE

[iron vault]

real and true

[mystic shale]

paladin is amazing but it just doesnt win against most of the other clancy songs 🧍‍♂️ they're too peak

[iron vault]

oldies please oldies please

[atomic grove]

give me some advice (on which song to vote)

[signal axle]

Overcompensate and next semester are the only ones above Paladin for me

[clear mural]

man im so excited for breach because of how good clancy was and how good drumshow is

[scarlet dragon]

YESSS NAVI YOU GOT THIS

[signal axle]

Oldies cause navigating don’t deserve this

[iron vault]

oldies station is perfect for when you're ready for it

[fresh sigil]

oldies peaktion

[iron vault]

true

[fair pond]

I got into them after the tour ended so Oldies has always been my goat anyways

[brave wolf]

i voted for oldies cos i cried to it like 2 days ago

[iron vault]

navigating is top 6 at most lowk

[fair pond]

I cried to Navigating like two days ago wdym

[mystic shale]

right..

[coarse cosmos]

you already know

[solar abyss]

I think all the songs are peak for their own reasons. No song is lesser or better than the others in the track. Like, Overcompensate was the opening song of an era and that's beautiful. Next Semester, Navigating, At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb, Midwest Indigo, all have an impactful message with some sick vocals and music. Routines In The Night is simplistically captivating and catchy. The Craving is emotional and sweet, the Smithereens of Clancy. Oldies Station is a bop, it's sweet and has some clever harmonies riddled throughout. Lavish is the funniest song I've ever heard and I love the way it pays out the famous; pure wit. Vignette and Backslide are hard hitters, emotional and ughhh the vocals are perfect. Snap Back is catchy and raw. Paladin Strait is The Final Battle TM and is such an experience, while also being another emotional song. They're all the best songs ever

[atomic grove]

alright oldies it ks

[signal axle]

I’ll admit I definitely like navigating more than oldies but I am out for blood with navigating for beating my boy next semester

[iron vault]

TES

[fresh sigil]

yk what really should be sweeping rn? vignette.

[clever wren]

Also chat I'm not an admin but I'd like to remind you guys that everyone's opinion on which song is better is different so please don't hate anyone if your song didn't win and at the end of the day it's just a fan voting it has no impact on YOUR own favorites

[brave wolf]

i voted for navigating last time, and oldies is my pookie too

[iron vault]

SHOULDVE BEEN OLDIES V NEXT SEMESTER

[narrow isle]

I'LL CRY IF OLDIES WINS NO WAY IT'S THAT GOOD

[untold vector]

Everything else should be swallowed by the vignette frfr

[iron vault]

THE FACT THAT KINTON AND I ARE UNITING AGAINST NAVIGATING JUST MEANS NAVIGATING MUST LOSE

[signal axle]

THANK YOU! I’d 100% vote next semester but WHY ARE WE STUCK WITH NAVIGATING RN

[fresh sigil]

u ate that

[untold vector]

I would’ve voted neither I love both 😭

[signal axle]

NO NEXT SEMESTER WAAAA

[small sleet]

SWEEPVIGATING

[nocturne kernel]

hear me out

[iron vault]

i mean i'd pick oldies but ns is my number 2

[untold vector]

I love both too much

[nocturne kernel]

next semester sweeps this

[pseudo stream]

EXACTLY!!

[signal axle]

Oldies station wins for me

[radiant elk]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 30!

[smoky vigil]

Navigoating

[signal axle]

yay

[late coral]

Yep haha, Navigating is just kinda annoying for me, even though I love all their other songs with cool bass lines (jumpsuit is their best song)

[signal axle]

This is such a weird moment for me cause I like navigating more than oldies, but navigating is SOOOOO overhyped to the point where I just don’t give a shit

[narrow isle]

NEXT SEMESTER SHOULD'VE WON

[pseudo stream]

Who 101 more people voted navigating??

[iron vault]

i want oldies to win, but i want navigating to lose much more

[dim ore]

thank you bro

[clever wren]

Would you believe me if I told you Oldies won against Next Semester the one time they were out against each other

[brave wolf]

WAIT THIS IS THE LAST ROUND LMFAOOOOOOOO

[iron vault]

navigating is so overrated bro

[brave wolf]

i js realized

[nocturne kernel]

times have changed

[dim ore]

yall fucked up

[signal axle]

EXACTLY

[clever wren]

True

[signal axle]

It’s still good but why are ppl overhyping it so much

[frail pine]

womp womp

[iron vault]

its really good but yall over hype it cause it has cool bass and nice lyrics

[untold vector]

Next up is breach just two songs against each other 😭

[narrow isle]

YES!! IT'S NOT BAD BUT OVERRATED

[solar abyss]

I think the only overrated Twenty One Pilots song is Heathens, and even then that's still an awesome song

[pseudo stream]

None of my fav songs ever made it to finals 😭

[iron vault]

bet u felt so tuff sayin this huh

[signal axle]

And the bass and lyrics are nothing compared to next semester

[brave wolf]

drum show wins /silly

[clever wren]

Lowkey drum show sweeps that

[mystic shale]

ritn the only kinda overrated one, everything else is decently rated

[nocturne kernel]

next semester sweeps breach

[finite wolf]

the contract or drum show which one are you voting for

[brave hornet]

hey don’t say that 😡

[iron vault]

oh fs

[signal axle]

Drum show 100%

[late coral]

Loving this take down navigating hype we have going on (it's an okay song)

[nocturne kernel]

drum show

[frail pine]

nah but at least i let ppl like the songs they like ?? 😭

[untold vector]

Drum show sweeps absolutely

[late coral]

Drum show for sure

[signal axle]

routines in the night would win if i had any to say

[fair pond]

I voted for Oldies bc there are very few songs out there that could deadass inspire hope in anyone and I’m pretty sure Oldies lyrics could inspire hope in anyone

[mystic shale]

drum show easy

[iron vault]

since when did i restrict people from liking a song tf???

[frail pine]

drum show easily

[fair pond]

You had one vote each round that’s a say

[finite wolf]

drum show sweep dakn

[iron vault]

bro thinks im after his whole family cause i said a song was overrated

[signal axle]

didnt do much 200 votes short

[dawn lily]

This is a beast of my own doing

[signal axle]

Overcompensate is my favorite song ever but if it had to lose to anything I’m glad it was next semester, instead of it losing to fucking Midwest indigo last year

[narrow isle]

THE LYRICS?? THE BASS?? BETTER. LYRICS WAY BETTER. THE OUTRO AND OVERALL STRUCTURE >>>>

[mystic shale]

drum show one of the best ever lowkey

[neon iron]

oughhh my beloved

[frail pine]

"navigating so overrated bro 🤖"

[signal axle]

YEAAAAAAAS FOR SURE FACTS

[signal axle]

It's hard to call it overrated but its in the middle of my album ranking

[small sleet]

it's a really damn good song tbh, i agree people got really excited since it's something they didn't do since like jumpsuit (not counting maybe next semester) but the song itself it's not bad and I don't agree on that, it's one of the most solid songs on the album, really catchy, very punchy, the song is really emotional and it's important to the story

[iron vault]

yeah ur calling me a bot for having an opinion? grow the fuck up bro

[signal axle]

both of you maybe

[signal axle]

Holy shit. We getting aggressive today I’m here for it

[solar abyss]

Oh, if Tyler saw us squabbling over this, he'd be so disappointed 😭

[untold vector]

Real 😭

[signal axle]

He’d vote for oldies tho, he said it’s his favorite and navigating is his least

[mystic shale]

he did NOT say that

[nocturne kernel]

he'll be more disappointed that next semester lost >:P

[frail pine]

"grow the fuck up" for liking navigating mind you 😭

[iron vault]

next semester shouldve won tho hhh

[mystic shale]

just said it was too personal to be on the album 🙏😭

[signal axle]

Watch the Clancy premier livestream he said it

[smoky vigil]

I thought snap back was his favorite

[untold vector]

He didn’t even want navigating on the album iirc 💀

[mystic shale]

not like that

[small sleet]

his favorites are like oldies and snap back

[signal axle]

At the release show he confirmed it was oldies

[small sleet]

and like the craving Jenna's version probably

[mystic shale]

too personal to be on the album =!= his least fave

[narrow isle]

BRUH IF THAT'S THE REASON NAVIGATING LOOSES I'M DISAPPOINTED

[signal axle]

“I think Navigating is my least favorite song on the record” those were his exact words

[iron vault]

u called me a bot and started saying i was restricting other's opinions cause i said a song was overrated, please wake up

[signal axle]

he said that yes

[iron vault]

you're getting on my ass for saying a song was overrated

[signal axle]

Navigating is gonna win

[iron vault]

genuinely thats so depressing

[nocturne kernel]

🍵

[signal axle]

It shouldn’t

nothing you can do really

[narrow isle]

Calm down pls

[clever wren]

Also chat I'm not an admin but I'd like to remind you guys that everyone's opinion on which song is better is different so please don't hate anyone if your song didn't win and at the end of the day it's just a fan voting it has no impact on YOUR own favorites please

[late coral]

No shot

[signal axle]

i like oldies and navigating a lot so i dont mind either way

[signal axle]

won last time

[frail pine]

because i don't think it's fair to the people that like it? like it genuinely doesn't harm you in ANY way

[nocturne kernel]

popcorn, anyone? 🍿

[magic spruce]

oh gosh both of these are my favorites on the album

[signal axle]

oldies isnt an awfully strong song on the album, its sort of an ode to the fanbase, navigating is like immersive music which people are more likely to have in their rotation.

[brave wolf]

https://tenor.com/view/twenty-one-pilots-tyler-joseph-tyler-clancy-popcorn-gif-5951078545940080820

[signal axle]

Reiterating, he said on the livestream that snap back and oldies compete for his favorite, but at the release show he said about oldies “this is my personal favorite song on the record”

[clever wren]

Paint infested popcorn

[mystic shale]

oh yeah i would love the song where i talk about my loved ones dying and where im the least vulnerable to the point its hard to listen to 🔥

[dim ore]

1. vignette
2. backslide
3. overcompensate
4. next semester
5. snap back
6. atrofd
7. paladin strait
8. routines in the night
9. navigating
10. midwest indigo
11. lavish
12. oldies station
13. the craving

[late coral]

I didn't know there was a last time lol. It'll be close but with how many I'm seeing fighting against it I bet oldies wins

[signal axle]

The ashes of the glorious gone powser

[untold vector]

Nah, screw butter I want BLURRYFACE on my popcorn 😭

[signal axle]

its not gonna be awfully close i think navigating gonna win by 200 or so

[iron vault]

i mean it just feels like ur being a hypocrite cause you're not allowing me to say a song was overrated, something that doesnt not affect anyone mind you

[signal axle]

https://i.redd.it/r6hkjst43z1b1.gif

[mystic shale]

tyjo fr woulnt care what song would win

[signal axle]

He’s so face level about it and it’s so off putting. Listen to the line it’s written about the same thing except written way better

[iron vault]

wow

[dim ore]

youre correct dw

[nocturne kernel]

while sippin on straight chlorine 🍹

[small sleet]

we don't know the reason as to why, besides he's said it's a really personal song, so that could be part of the reason, it doesn't mean it's because he doesn't like it because that is bullshit, there's no way he doesn't like a song he decided would in the end be one of the lore songs, and one of the most important songs on the clancy tour, having a cutscene and being one of the most euphoric songs overall.

you can see he enjoys playing it, there's a chance he didn't want it on clancy because he wanted it for breach, and it makes sense since you guys are seeing breach's vibe; it's something more reminiscent of navigating than the rest of the songs on clancy, so why knows, it could be that.

[frail pine]

you don't see me saying oldies station is overrated ?? it's okay to think for five seconds

[mystic shale]

buddy...

[solar abyss]

I feel like regardless, Tyler's the kind of guy who wouldn't hate you no matter which song you decided was your favourite, and the fact it's causing a bit of a hateful dispute would sadden him deeply, no matter his personal feelings on any of the songs

[narrow isle]

Why you still upset about it? 💀

[mystic shale]

idk how to tell you this...

[clever wren]

Guys calm down it's a fan voting let's not throw hands at each other now 😭

[signal axle]

I’m aware how big the line was, what’s your point

the line is not similar to navigating wtf you on

[iron vault]

bro who are you 🥀

[mystic shale]

its my own plays... even if theres a better version of it out there it doesnt make it bad 😭 the line isnt even in here

[small sleet]

-# remember they said to grow up

[dim ore]

theyre both about loss, navigating is very straight forward and simple honestly while the line uses more metaphor is written better

[mystic shale]

navigating is NOT just about loss

[signal axle]

Well I do think navigating is a good song, solid 8/10, but it’s so overhyped and for nothing

[iron vault]

"it's ok to think for five seconds" when i used your points against u

[elfin burrow]

push on through

[narrow isle]

yo mama

[radiant elk]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 5!

[small sleet]

THIS

[mystic shale]

perfectly hyped, relatable, hard, bop

[elfin burrow]

have u never heard it live - I thought the same but never heard it the same since i heard it live

[frail pine]

still yapping for zero reason

[iron vault]

https://tenor.com/view/spongebob-spongebob-meme-whole-squad-laughing-got-the-whole-squad-laughing-gif-24999897

[small sleet]

like why it's hard for people to just recognize that navigating it's just solid

[nocturne kernel]

who let bro in

[brave wolf]

i relate a lot to navigating tbh cos i have rlly bad dissociation issues

like fr

[charred linden]

Oldies better win here yall

[signal axle]

I saw it live, I have pictures from the moments before they played it. It slapped, but it’s still overrated

I haven't watched Arcane and I interpret The Line is from the perspective of someone dying, and Navigating is about being lost and lonely. Not similar.

[smoky vigil]

Navigating is also about reaching out for help when your thoughts are becoming too much to handle

[mystic shale]

no idea

[iron vault]

bro pls sybau you're just pressed cause i called navigating overrated please get off your high horse

[dim ore]

oldies shouldnt have gotten past the first round guys what are we doing

just because its heartfelt doesnt make it good

[fair pond]

Sweep Station

[timid garnet]

Navigating sweep

[narrow isle]

I agree

[iron vault]

crazy thing that it is tho

[small sleet]

nahhh i don't agree

[frail pine]

oh you're still talking okay

[small sleet]

oldies is only a year long and it's already one of the most legendary songs

[iron vault]

https://tenor.com/view/emoji-crazy-crazy-emoji-emoji-crazy-emoji-are-you-crazy-gif-17566518746599549444

[cyan olive]

Because people have.. preferences, i like navigating a lot, but its solid to you, its alright if people dont like it.

[mystic shale]

fr... best bridge ever

[iron vault]

just stop responding bro

[dim ore]

its not legendary its very simple and bland

[frail pine]

they say as they reply to me again 😭

[dim ore]

its bottom 2 on clancy

[signal axle]

i mean... i get people werent very nice to you... but youre dragging it too

[charred linden]

Navigating and Oldies Station are the two most relatable songs on the album for me
Especially “then before you know you lose some people close” and “kinda feels like everybody leaves” but Oldies Message hits harder

[signal axle]

Come on that’s too far

[brave wolf]

dont say that here youll get jumped pooks

[dim ore]

no its not tell me whats worse besides the craving bro

[iron vault]

im just telling bro to shut up 🥀

[nocturne kernel]

I like the two concurrent conversations

[iron vault]

he went on my ass first btw

[nocturne kernel]

lovin the tea

[signal axle]

ENOUGH CRAVING SLANDER WTF

[radiant elk]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 28!

[clever wren]

Im gonna stop looking at this thread for the night, so before that taps sign

[fair pond]

Says who

[clever wren]

Thanks Nico

[dim ore]

craving is good but whos listening to that in their free time, its sweet but boring

[brave wolf]

i forget u like conflict

[solemn sparrow]

Impossible

[signal axle]

Okay I’ll tell you then. Snap back and Midwest indigo

[frail pine]

for saying it's not nice to tell people that a song they like is overrated... ? let people like what they like lil bro 😭

[smoky vigil]

Boring? Nah

[dim ore]

hell no snap back is top 5

[vagrant ocean]

yeesh what’s going on here

[charred linden]

You’re opinion

[mystic shale]

midwest peakdigo, peak back

[signal axle]

Snap back is bottom 2 it’s written well but it sounds boring

[brave wolf]

typical song battle arguments yk

[signal axle]

Snap Back top 2

[dim ore]

yall dont understand music quality go listen to AJR since thats what oldies sounds like

[brave wolf]

YEAHHH

[frail pine]

midwest indigo is so good oml

[cyan olive]

Real

[nocturne kernel]

normal day, nothing special

[fair pond]

It’s literally my whole character arc ok I AM the bully in the playground and there shan’t be any hanging nor drying for me

[iron vault]

i swear this point is so sensitive to literally any other situation

[nocturne kernel]

[signal axle]

Snap Back does not sound boring, it has intricate rhythms and cutting melodies

[narrow isle]

Jenna's version feels too slow

[signal axle]

Are you trying to be the rage bait king

[mystic shale]

midwest is literally clancys superhero anthem, legendary

[solar abyss]

I had no idea people had this much beef with the Clancy songs 😭 I thought SAI was the argumentative album

[dim ore]

no im just correct

[vagrant ocean]

yeah i can imagine

[iron vault]

please be so fr rn

[mystic shale]

real

[iron vault]

this ragebait bro

[dim ore]

yeah and the buildup is fire, its like cut my lip pt 2

[frail pine]

HELP 😭

[gentle frigate]

I'm so glad Next Semester got sweeped away.
But this is now torture. What do I choose.

[vagrant ocean]

anyways guys idk what to vote what did yall pick

[charred linden]

Bum bum bum bum bumbumbum

[iron vault]

oldies

[charred linden]

Oldies

[elder sorrel]

Oldies!

[brave wolf]

oldies i love both tho

[cyan olive]

Oldies

[narrow isle]

Was once one of my favourites now It's boring to me 😭

[signal axle]

It builds immense tension which becomes very emotional. It is important to the arc of the album.

[iron vault]

this is looking good

[dim ore]

tell me right now you think oldies station is the best song on clancy.

[smoky vigil]

I think it works. But also I was very biased when it came out

[charred linden]

You have a Roula Kaard PFP I trust you to make the right call

[iron vault]

its so beautiful instrumentally and lyrically

[cyan olive]

I think oldies station is the best song on clancy

[spice verge]

Oldies better win

[nocturne kernel]

oldigating

[vagrant ocean]

yeah i’ll probably go oldies as well even though it’s hard picking between my top two hahaha

[frail pine]

navistation

[dim ore]

i dont get yall

[charred linden]

I think Oldies is the second best song on Clancy but the best song already got out

[nocturne kernel]

https://tenor.com/view/next-semester-twenty-one-pilots-innervizionz-gif-8169105997715207367

[radiant elk]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 8!

[narrow isle]

Why yall voting oldies? It's not even that good 😭

[vagrant ocean]

thanketh thou

[glossy raft]

GUYS NAVIGATING IS NOT THE BEST SONG ON CLANCY PLEASE OLDIES OLDIES OLDIES

[swift patrol]

don’t know which to pick 😔

[spice verge]

Real

[smoky vigil]

I disagree but the people dogging on you for it are assholes

[last forum]

Oh my
I don’t think I can decide on this one

[narrow isle]

OLDIES ISN'T EITHER

[tranquil monolith]

Navigating is my favourite Clancy track, sorry Oldies

[elder sorrel]

I've been a fan of TOP since 2013, so oldies hits me in the feels

[nocturne kernel]

prefer it over navigating at least

[charred linden]

Thanks Nico

[dim ore]

what makes oldies station good besides the lyrics? literally nothing, theres nothing special about it and the chorus is just an AJR chorus basically “fear of the past and RELATIVE PAIN! 🤓”

[brave wolf]

yaa frr 🙏 i think it would be harder for me if midwest got farther but yeah i had to think ab this one a bit loll

[radiant elk]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 13!

[glossy raft]

ur right its the second best behind Next Semester which yall chose navigating over smh

[signal axle]

Clancy ranked:
1: Overcompensate (10/10)
2: Next Semester (10/10)
3: Paladin Strait (10/10)
4: Vignette (10/10)
5: At the Risk of Feeling Dumb (10/10)
6: Backslide (9/10)
7: Navigating (8/10)
8: Routines in the Night (7/10)
9: Lavish (7/10)
10: Oldies Station (7/10)
11: The Craving (Jenna’s Version) (7/10)
12: Snap Back (6/10)
13: Midwest Indigo (5/10)

[nocturne kernel]

w fan commitment

[narrow isle]

FR 😭

[nocturne kernel]

mad respect

[frail pine]

i mean yeah same but that shouldn't be the sole deciding factor 😭

[tranquil monolith]

0/10 ragebait

[cyan olive]

EXACTLY im not telling everyone to favour oldies station, they are forgetting the man who made the song said it was his favourite on the album

[charred linden]

Poor Midwest indigo

[solar abyss]

Damn, everyone hates Lavish???

[cyan olive]

Toxic for what

[brave wolf]

yeah it hits especially if youve grown up with them

[iron vault]

the ragebait could not be more obvious

[spice verge]

Do you not like the melody?

[neon iron]

oldies statuon is about aging and changing and it hits like a truck

[dim ore]

i almost agree with you, snap back and midwest should be way higher

[mystic shale]

the oldies bridge is a musical masterpiece 🔥

[signal axle]

Come on the instrumental is so cute with the uke and the other stuff

[smoky vigil]

The instrumental is great

[dim ore]

its just okay

[charred linden]

Yes!!

[dim ore]

theres nothing intricate or special about the instrumental

its bland

[nocturne kernel]

how did lavish spawn 💔

[signal axle]

Snap back and Midwest are bottom tier for Clancy they’re not special, the other ones are

[frail pine]

hard agree, it's the best part

[iron vault]

i think the whole song is a masterpiece

[dim ore]

and let me say i still LIKE the song

[gentle frigate]

I've made my decision, everyone.

[dim ore]

it just should be nowhere near top 5 even top 10

[gentle frigate]

Oldies.

[iron vault]

if you are comparing oldies to ajr then you're clearly missing something

[elder sorrel]

no. it's not the sole factor. It has made me cry and i genuinely like it. I love both of these songs a lot though, so I won't be devastated at either result.

[glossy raft]

i love the nostalgic melodies in that song and the bridge makes me tear up every single time it ties the song together perfectly and nothing in that song feels out of place

[charred linden]

(Since Drum Show there’s nothing special about Navigating either)

[solar abyss]

I propose Lavish to be the 'best song' of Clancy

[brave wolf]

https://tenor.com/view/twenty-one-pilots-clancy-lavish-tyler-joseph-josh-dun-gif-9234067145833782607

[iron vault]

YAY!!

[buoyant hornet]

navigating is gonna win but i’m pleasantly surprised that oldies station is gonna get second place

navigating is gonna win but i’m pleasantly surprised that oldies station is gonna get second place

[brave wolf]

tbh based

[glossy raft]

look i love lavish but this is too much twin 😔 ✌️

[nocturne kernel]

valid

[iron vault]

hi junia

[oblique stone]

mid battles

[mystic shale]

you-dont-quite-mind how-long red lightssss are takinnn

push on throughhhhhhhhhh

absolute cinema

[signal axle]

REAL

[charred linden]

Die

[dim ore]

coughing baby vs coughing baby

[oblique stone]

ain’t even voting how did it come to this

[charred linden]

Die x2

[signal axle]

THANK YOU

[iron vault]

only consistency in your periphery

[vagrant ocean]

not gonna lie i actually like snap back, it’s not something i’d usually listen to but i’m surprised it’s so low for so many people tbh

[oblique stone]

how the fuck did next semester lose

or routines

[smoky vigil]

https://tenor.com/view/squid-game-oh-my-god-bruh-saleswoman-oh-my-god-bruh-gif-2398788864743270124

[frail pine]

yeah i'm still stuck on this one too

[oblique stone]

those are literally the best songs on the whole album

[charred linden]

Is fear, and the bridge of your nose!

[humble carbon]

oh good question

[signal axle]

I don’t think it’s a bad song like I thought last year, but compared to other Clancy songs it kinda bores me

[swift patrol]

routines hurts the most ngl

[solar abyss]

Maybe Clancy coulda hired us to kill Nico for him, we could've brought this argument and dropped the bishop dead

[glossy raft]

https://tenor.com/view/ishowspeed-wow-omg-gif-17428264941961796075

[dim ore]

routines is overrated but i agree about next semester

[iron vault]

and as you move about, you learn to tune 'em out

[glossy raft]

hi twin :3

[charred linden]

Nah Routines is hella overrated

[signal axle]

Do me a favor, vote oldies just to get revenge on next semester’s loss

[iron vault]

https://tenor.com/view/deltarune-kris-deltarune-susie-deltarune-noelle-deltarune-ishowspeed-gif-10481516553238668546

[vagrant ocean]

yeah i get that

[glossy raft]

no i get the love for routines ngl

[mystic shale]

real

[charred linden]

But they say they continue to grow

[dim ore]

its still awesome but not one of my favorites

[oblique stone]

argue with a wall btw clancy is literally ns>ritn> everything else

[glossy raft]

i love the dark vibes on that one they're so cool 🥺

[brave wolf]

i was lowki sad when midwest indigo lost but it seems like nb cares so ill be the midwest stan or smth idk

[mystic shale]

right...

[dim ore]

bro doesnt know about vignette, backslide, or overcompensate

[solar abyss]

I can only imagine the debates for Blurryface

[mystic shale]

MEE i care

[glossy raft]

excuse me but ns>os>atrofd>vignette>everything else

[signal axle]

RITN is not all that great it’s just the pop song in the middle of the album, like never take it but better

[smoky vigil]

Today I've learned that every song on Clancy is overrated apparently

[oblique stone]

backslide #3 don’t get me wrong

[brave wolf]

[charred linden]

Midwest is so good it didn’t deserve to die so young but Oldies is very unfortunately, just better.

[vagrant ocean]

it’s so hard picking songs from a 10/10 album

[glossy raft]

https://tenor.com/view/oh-hell-nah-no-no-thank-you-gif-5556407309512400852

[iron vault]

ns being first mustve been a fluke

[brave wolf]

if i had it my way midwest wouldve won but yk, we cant all have what we want ☹️💔

[mystic shale]

except snap back 🔥

[charred linden]

Except Snap Back and Backslide

[cyan olive]

I love next semester but i played it too much on fn festival so its just hard to listen to 💔

[oblique stone]

[dim ore]

next semester is one of their most powerful and well written songs ever, and yet we have OLDIES STATION and NAVIGATING in the top 2

[oblique stone]

i miss not being staff so i could run my mouth in here

[dim ore]

where did this go so wrong

[glossy raft]

oldies station deserves it

[iron vault]

i think the only true and real overrated songs on clancy are midwest, ritn and navigating

[glossy raft]

run ur mouth twin nothing is stopping u

[dim ore]

https://tenor.com/view/lying-wong-gif-7845920779899236663

[charred linden]

I present to you: Trapdoor, Neon Gravestones, At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb (to name a few)

[oblique stone]

i can’t believe forest fic: the music video always wins im TIRED PICK SOMETHING GOOD

[signal axle]

I think I agree completely

[glad geode]

LETS GO NAVISWEEPING!!!

[glossy raft]

https://tenor.com/view/get-a-load-of-this-gif-2218387369813418815

[smoky vigil]

AI slop

[mystic shale]

theres like.... barely any midwest lovers 😭

[brave wolf]

idk i dont rlly have a fav from this album cos i like all tracks for different reasons but midwest is rlly special to me cos im from the midwest, very basic reasoning but like knowing my fav band has grown up in a similar place as me makes it feel special to me

[iron vault]

thats so not true lmao

[mystic shale]

its very true

[glad geode]

Love to it, but more love to Nav😂😂

[charred linden]

That’s so real

[frail pine]

me and the two other peakwest indigo fans hearing our song is overrated

[astral sonnet]

If oldies station wins I'm gonna eat lead

[iron vault]

then we must be seeing different sides of the fandom

[mystic shale]

fr

yeah have fun

[dim ore]

i wish midwest indigo had a different chorus, cause the verses are so cool and strange in a good way, with the random screams in the background and shit

the chorus is just kinda okay

[mystic shale]

a world where midwest is overrated.. sounds great

[iron vault]

get some lead ready

[glossy raft]

good luck with that lead in ur mouth then bud

[charred linden]

I like it cause it’s goofy
“CLOUD COVERAGE MATCHED MY OUTFIT TO A KNIFE (AAAAAAAAAAAAAH)”

[iron vault]

true

[glossy raft]

i like how simple it is

very very tuff

[solar abyss]

this guy knows what's up

[iron vault]

also im gonna rank the clancy mvs

like rn

[vagrant ocean]

you can be so cooold midwest indigo

[mystic shale]

i would listen to the midwest oh oh ohs on loop 24/7

[cyan olive]

Midwest and oldies are tied for my favourite from Clancy for 2 different reasons i love them both

[brave wolf]

WHATS UR ETA ??
TWO MINUTES !!!!

[iron vault]

cause i rewatched them yesterday and they affect my ranking sometimes

[brave wolf]

i love it

[dim ore]

anyways oldies is mid trench is their best album by far, hometown is mid and forest is mid thank you

[astral sonnet]

Uh oh

[iron vault]

not biased towards lore ones

[glossy raft]

lord take me back to when i wasnt a top fan and i listened to overcomp for the first time ❤️

[astral sonnet]

I agree with all except hometown because it's my second favorite TOP song

[iron vault]

alright bud wrap it up

[solar abyss]

when they announced that at the shows peak

[signal axle]

Oh man this is so fr

[glossy raft]

srry guys but clancy>trench

[vagrant ocean]

idk if it’s just me but i love when the song has some random name like midwest indigo for example and they namedrop it like that phrase goes hard imo am i weird

[glossy raft]

i feel so much more emotion listening to clancy than trench

[iron vault]

yea

[dim ore]

nah

clancy has the craving

and oldies

[iron vault]

also yea

[astral sonnet]

Trench has like

[dim ore]

trench has all 10/10 songs

[astral sonnet]

Perfection

[glossy raft]

whats with u and oldies bro thats amaizng

[dim ore]

not a single dip in quality

[glossy raft]

legend:

[astral sonnet]

It drips of perfection

[astral sonnet]

Ok fair

[dim ore]

legend is great

nah nah nah

[astral sonnet]

I forgot about that one

[dim ore]

not fair

[iron vault]

oldies is peak and the craving is the sweetest song he's written

[glossy raft]

over oldies???

HELL NO

[astral sonnet]

But it's not as bad as The craving

[brave wolf]

bro dont say that 💔😭 /silly

[mystic shale]

clancy is a bop but trench is actually insane, no wonder it took wayyy longer to make it

[dim ore]

hell yes?

[cyan olive]

Idk theyve been like number 1 hater this whole time

[dim ore]

legend is WAY better written

[iron vault]

exactly

[dim ore]

and its actually unique

oldies is bland

[iron vault]

https://tenor.com/view/uncanny-emoji-angry-hakayaki-hakayaki-angry-emoji-gif-13101565263917230073

[glossy raft]

https://tenor.com/view/jerry-meme-tom-and-jerry-meme-jerry-points-get-a-load-of-this-guy-this-guy-gif-11384860625931393733

[charred linden]

Alright, alright here’s my Clancy ranking just fyi:

1. ATROFD
2. Oldies Station
3. Lavish
4. Midwest Indigo
5. Overcompensate
6. Paladin Strait
7. Snap Back
8. Vignette
9. Navigating
10. Next Semester
11. Backslide
12. RITN
13. The Craving

[dim ore]

legend is the worst song on trench dont get me wrong but its still way better than oldies

[dim ore]

holy shit

[dim ore]

https://tenor.com/view/yungviral-gif-9161967965362335111

[solar abyss]

I think every Pilots song is a 10/10 apart from the og RAB songs that were then remastered in Vessel

[charred linden]

You’re on drugs if you think legend isn’t 10/10

[swift patrol]

ATROFD appreciation

[iron vault]

man there are just some fans who have never had their push on through moment

[glossy raft]

you're on gigadrugs if you think legend > oldies

[cyan olive]

PERSONALLY my favourite is trench but i dont have any backlash towards any album or songs i think they are all awesome 🙏

[charred linden]

I never said that

[dim ore]

dont worry you guys will understand when you grow up

[solar abyss]

I mean, Legend was in Shazam, that's pretty peak

[glossy raft]

YOU will understand when you grow up

[vagrant ocean]

i respect your opinion i’ll just add that i think routines should be higher but like still valid

[dim ore]

then youll see trench is the best album and has all 10/10 songs

[mystic shale]

all trench songs are perfect

[charred linden]

I just said Singling out Legend is completely screwed up

[stoic dove]

YOU DONT QUITE MIND HOW LONG RED LIGHTS ARE TAKING

[mystic shale]

hating a trench song is like hating a random baby

[iron vault]

trench is literally meant for people who have been in the worst state of their lives for the longest time, clancy is quite literally the opposite

[dim ore]

i love all of their albums, but trench is literally on another level, its a masterpiece in songwriting, so cohesive front to back

[charred linden]

Yeah I just don’t like it instrumentally as much as the rest of Clancy… plus it’s overplayed

[abstract summit]

i love trench but i hate babies

[vagrant ocean]

also i agree with putting snap back in the middle it deserves better

[radiant elk]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 4!

[mystic shale]

then... uuuh kittens

[cyan olive]

Can we all agree on this

[solar abyss]

I think Vessel and Self Titled are for the depressed?

[unique pendant]

i don’t CARE if oldies station wins i just want navigating to lose

[vagrant ocean]

valid yeah

[glossy raft]

NEXT SEMESTER GUYS 🥺 🥺 HOW DID U LET NAVIGATING BEAT THIS

[iron vault]

i mean they can be too

[dim ore]

well yes, writing about struggles is more effective than writing about being happy, we learned that with sai

[charred linden]

The Craving got the bottom because I’ve never had a good relationship

[solar abyss]

sai was propaganda tho

[iron vault]

nah sai and clancy are so different

[glossy raft]

i love sai hate

NO FUCK THE PROPAGANDA SHIT

[cyan olive]

https://tenor.com/view/twenty-one-pilots-tyler-joseph-next-semester-next-semester-bts-pizza-gif-14501772666832602799

[dim ore]

yes sai was propaganda in the lore but that doesnt mean its not happy

[glossy raft]

I LOVE SAI AND ITS PERFECT FOR WHAT IT IS

[swift patrol]

FR NEXT SEMESTER DESERVED BETTER

[iron vault]

sai was fake happiness and Clancy is real happiness

[dim ore]

ik clancy is still good its my second favorite

[vagrant ocean]

i’m sorry i like navigating please don’t snowgrave me i play bass

[dim ore]

im just saying i prefer the more profound songs

[solar abyss]

Sai isn't really happy if you're a lyric listener

[dim ore]

instead of just happiness

[iron vault]

you complain abt oldies being like ajr but that is literally half of sai

[cyan olive]

SCALED AND ICY ILY

[charred linden]

I’m not going to say my opinion on trench

Because last time I did…

[glossy raft]

i love navigating too but i will snowgrave you for preferring it over oldies

[dim ore]

im not glazing sai im saying it was a lighter toned album

[iron vault]

https://tenor.com/view/uncanny-emoji-angry-hakayaki-hakayaki-angry-emoji-gif-13101565263917230073

[radiant elk]

236521 total scrobbles

Hiroshix1's FM

Track

Vignette
555 plays

Album

Clancy
5584 plays

Artist

twenty one pilots
24450 plays

Now playing · Aug 24, 2025, 3:49 PM

[glossy raft]

https://tenor.com/view/deltarune-kris-deltarune-berdly-berdly-deltarune-kingofsnowgrave-gif-15460510820087390627

[glossy raft]

Congratulations twin

[radiant elk]

37523 total scrobbles

Gangygang's FM

Track

Backslide
526 plays

Album

Clancy
4567 plays

Artist

twenty one pilots
14750 plays

Now playing · Aug 24, 2025, 3:49 PM

[mystic shale]

for what

[cyan olive]

your personal preference but good choice.. i dont think this is a safe space for opinions..

[glossy raft]

5000 Clancy listens

[dim ore]

trench is one of the best albums of all time

[dim ore]

yea ur right

if you dont like trench it isnt

[mystic shale]

🧍‍♂️ not really a goal

[glossy raft]

https://tenor.com/view/roblox-this-shit-laced-tweaking-gif-402871987851581625

[vagrant ocean]

see i can’t pick i like navigating because i like fast paced music but i appreciate oldies a lot for the meaning and also the ending gets me every time i picked oldies on this battle tho

[mystic shale]

im going to get 10.000 breach plays

[glossy raft]

🥹 ✌️

[mystic shale]

https://tenor.com/view/maomao-apothecary-diaries-anime-anime-girl-cute-anime-girl-gif-2345550580971805707

mhm hm

[cyan olive]

I mean trench is my favourite personally but i can see how some might not like it

[dim ore]

i cannot see that

[solar abyss]

Devil's advocate on this one, Trench is hard to get into if you don't follow the lore actively

[mystic shale]

i cant see that

[charred linden]

SPEAKING OF TRENCH
I will never forgive you weirdos for making JUMPSUIT win… JUMPSUIT!! OF ALL SONGS!!!

[dim ore]

no it isnt

[mystic shale]

not liking trench is a CRIME

[faint finch]

OLDIES STAION PLEASE EPLEASE PELASE PELASE PELASE PLEAAE PLEASE PELAA EPWLASE PLEAS EPLEASE PEASELLPLEAW

[signal axle]

But jumpsuit is the best one tho

[cyan olive]

Silent agree

[dim ore]

even if you dont follow the lore its pretty easy to tell the gist of it

[charred linden]

No tf it is not

[faint finch]

it kept me alive and clean i need it to win please please please please please

[charred linden]

NICO AND THE NINERS

BANDITO

[solar abyss]

It really is. My mum thought Nico and the Niners was about being high because of the lyrics 😭

[dim ore]

whats your favorite then

[charred linden]

LEGEND

PET CHEETAH

[mystic shale]

natn is the best easy... and bandito

[glossy raft]

i love that snap back and backslide parallel each other. both tracks are about omg i cant go back twin and feature dialogue in the second verse and they're both 10/10s and omg i love love love clancy

[charred linden]

Probably Bandito

[signal axle]

Worst by far

[vagrant ocean]

i’m gonna be honest i really like natn since i heard it live it slaps so hard

[charred linden]

Shut it

[iron vault]

it can be???

[glossy raft]

🤫

[dim ore]

no it cant

[signal axle]

Never

[cyan olive]

Bandito 🙏 pet cheetah 🙏 leave the city 🙏

[faint finch]

WHEN VOTING ROLLS ON YOU, SWEEP ON THROUGH

[glossy raft]

yk what is the worst by far on trench?

[solar abyss]

WAS THAT PET CHEETAH SLANDER

[glossy raft]

legend

[faint finch]

LTC AND LEVITATE ‼️‼️

[dim ore]

its legend but it isnt by far whatsoever

[glossy raft]

smithereens is very overhated btw

[signal axle]

Worst on trench by a long shot

[faint finch]

my favs

[iron vault]

yes it literally can??? any music can be hard to get into if its just not your taste???

[cyan olive]

ONGGGG

[dim ore]

i agree

[glossy raft]

absolutely far

[dim ore]

no it cant

[mystic shale]

real

[faint finch]

IK HOW TO LEVITATE UP OFF MY FEET ✅✅✅✅✅✅✅✅

[iron vault]

hhhh look you really need to grow up out of your ragebait phase bud

[blissful topaz]

i was CONFIDENT next semester was gonna win last round wtf

[solar abyss]

I love Smithereens 😭

[vagrant ocean]

imo cut my lip i used to like it a lot but now it just kinda doesn’t hit anymore

[iron vault]

me too bro

[charred linden]

Legend is not the worst of Trench I hate you all

[signal axle]

Same it’s a travesty

[dim ore]

im not ragebaiting trench is critically acclaimed and their consensus best album

[cyan olive]

Guys.. scaled and icy is awesome and bounce man isnt that bad

[signal axle]

It’s not the worst but it’s far from the best

[solar abyss]

THIS

[hoary ferry]

Oldies Station and Snap Back my top songs on Clancy, Oldies Station sweep 💥💥

[iron vault]

weakest one on trench is arguably the hype but its still a 7/10 song for me

[signal axle]

Bounce man is better than no chances

[glossy raft]

let me tell you something. before i was BIG into top i listened to Trench for my first album without knowing much about the lore. i heard it and decided right then and there that this was one of the greatest things i have ever heard (still holds up) and now im hugeee into top so no you dont need lore to get into trench

[iron vault]

peak

[blissful topaz]

navigating is my baby i’m glad she won

[charred linden]

It’s so good. First TOP song to ever make me cry

[cyan olive]

YOU DID NOT

[signal axle]

But I did

[blissful topaz]

and she’s gonna SWEEP HERE 🦅🦅🦅

[glossy raft]

also No Chances is overrated imo

[charred linden]

(Oldies Station and Redecorate took their tolls next)

[iron vault]

nah

[vagrant ocean]

i overplayed bounce man so now i just think it’s kinda annoying but yeah it’s not a bad song

[signal axle]

Agreed

[radiant elk]

236523 total scrobbles

Hiroshix1's FM

Track

Nico and the Niners
527 plays

Album

Trench
2544 plays

Artist

twenty one pilots
24452 plays

Now playing · Aug 24, 2025, 3:54 PM

[glossy raft]

some based ppl here i see

[faint finch]

NOO NO CHANCES IS SO GOOD

[vocal egret]

oldies better win. it means so much to me as a clikkie

[mystic shale]

nico and the nicoers

[iron vault]

bounce man is what an ajr song sounds like to someone who isn't an ajr fan

[solar abyss]

I WISH Trench was my first listen. Sadly, I'm a Heathens born Clikkie...

[glossy raft]

an ajr

[vocal egret]

it literally was made for us

[radiant elk]

An error occurred!

Your Last.FM username isn't connected!

DEMA internet machine broke. Error UcykybdoImhWvN2FUeiSh

[glossy raft]

🫢

[cyan olive]

No i get overplaying it and not being able to listen to it as much but the bounce man hate is just WRONG

[iron vault]

oops

[charred linden]

If oldies doesn’t win I’m gonna boo you all like you booed it at the Concert

[young moon]

I looooove slandering bounce man until someone slanders the run and go

[vocal egret]

false

[glossy raft]

REAL

WHY DID THEY BOO OLDIES THAT ONE TIME IT MADE ME SOOO SAD

[radiant elk]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 6!

[solar abyss]

THEY WHAT?

[iron vault]

????

[vocal egret]

in favor of fucking slowtown dawg

[faint finch]

so guys, can oldies station win? for the lives it saved? for the people it kept clean?

[mystic shale]

should have kicked them out

[charred linden]

Yeah cause they wanted FREAKING SLOWTOWN

[iron vault]

slowtown mid asf btw

[vagrant ocean]

i ain’t gonna call any song especially from twenty one pilots “bad” because i’m learning how to make music and it is extremely complicated to make something that’s not going to make me want to rip my ears off so that’s that

[iron vault]

great concept but still mid

[glossy raft]

true

[solar abyss]

but but but Tyler has a premade setlist....

[glossy raft]

also guys would u agree with me if i said self titled is a 10/10 and a top 20 best album of all time

[charred linden]

Only good part of Slowtown is the scream

[faint finch]

LISTEN I LOVE SLOWTOWN BIT IT MAKES ME MAD THAT THEY BOOED OLDIES STAION COS THEU WANTED IT

LIKE

YOU AINT IN CONTROL MAN

YOU AT A CONCERT HAVE SOME GD RESPECT

[iron vault]

i cannot trust anyone who cant admit their favorite artist/band has at least 1 bad song

[faint finch]

IT AINT YOUR SHOW

[mystic shale]

whoever did that should just stop listening dawg 😭🙏

[faint finch]

anathema 💔 be concerned 💔

[solar abyss]

Goner 😬

[young moon]

some people need to listen to the most bottom of the barrel music before they speak

[mystic shale]

anathema!? true be concerned

[iron vault]

WOAH WHAT????

[young moon]

I've seen Corey Feldman live, I know ass

[radiant elk]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 2!

[blissful topaz]

yes

[charred linden]

Yeah so we don’t know why but at the very first concert he played Slowtown when oldies was on the Setlist, and after that he played Oldies and I think it was around night 6 some people booed him when he began Oldies station and IRRC he cried on stage so… you know

[blissful topaz]

i cant imagine how much of a nightmare that was

[vocal egret]

thank god fall away lost in the self titled battles

[iron vault]

song that was meant for us btw

[signal axle]

i will stone whoever did that

[iron vault]

right that song is so overrated

shouldve been implicit demand for proof bro

[signal axle]

You're personally attacking me.

[young moon]

More than one song on rab but you didn't hear that from me 🤫

[iron vault]

i hope it hurts

[forest crown]

OLDIES STATION OLDIES STATION OLDIES STATION!!!!

[vagrant ocean]

objectively bad is probably just rab trees tbh other than that it depends on your taste i think especially with twenty one pilots since they do so many different things with their music

[solar abyss]

Fall Away is a good song guys

[charred linden]

If I say which song I think is bad I will be flayed alive but just know I do have at least one song I think is not good

[vocal egret]

it beat fucking addict with a pen dawg

[signal axle]

was about to use the kitchen but someone has just taken it

[iron vault]

Wow

[vocal egret]

not good enough to beat addict with a pen

[charred linden]

Not better than The Pantaloon

Or air catcher

[solar abyss]

Yeah, no fair

[dim ore]

nobody has worse taste than top fans

[vocal egret]

are they using the kitchen sink

[young moon]

Ig I'd just do anything for Wes Borland ❤️

[blissful topaz]

also idk how trapdoor won self titled battles. i mean i LOVE trapdoor but come on

[solar abyss]

I learnt Pantaloon on guitar, I was so happy

[charred linden]

Or Isle Of Flightless birds for that matter

[signal axle]

i dont know what that means

[iron vault]

i like the harmonies on pantaloon hahahahahh

[signal axle]

Addict with a pen beat IOFB, tragic

[glossy raft]

real

[charred linden]

It’s so catchy

[charred linden]

Catchiest rap of all time

[dim ore]

well yes, its way better

[vagrant ocean]

taxi cab tho

[glossy raft]

lord take me back to the first time i heard Vignette at the listening party

[charred linden]

And then of course the scream

[iron vault]

he says as he has called oldies mid 🥀

[young moon]

https://tenor.com/view/trent-reznor-trunt-nuke-trunt-nuke-nine-inch-nails-gif-13813864890580222225

[solar abyss]

Pantaloon is the silliest little song ever but it is goated

[dim ore]

well yes thats the point

[iron vault]

look chat i have a soft spot for oldies and clancy as a whole

[signal axle]

IOFB is easily the best self titled song wdym