#2025 Clancy Song Battle #10

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

waxen depotBOT
#

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1755961200:R>

celest zenith
#

oh no you did not nico

fair iris
#

RITN sweep

dim spade
#

Ugh

wide crag
#

oldies station best song on the album

high nimbus
#

Oh no

ashen agate
#

OH NO

fair iris
high nimbus
broken kraken
#

are you serious

ashen agate
#

oldies station is just helping me out in life

merry thicket
slate moat
#

Bro what

sonic forge
#

help

errant jay
#

oldies

fallow mica
#

oldies but i won't be mad if ritn takes it

subtle quest
#

OLDIES STATION

timber cargo
#

i cant help with this its always peak vs peak

sonic forge
pallid oracle
#

Oldies pls pls

fresh lichen
#

ROUTINES

fresh thunder
#

OH NO THIS ONE'S HARD

high nimbus
#

I want to do justice to my name but oldies station got me through so much

frosty tartan
#

Oldies

merry pebble
sleek vine
#

oldies but if ritn wins i can accept that

mighty ferry
#

Oldies station

dim spade
#

Okay so i chose RITN cause i wanna go by “songs i’d blast in public” and i dont wanna sob and scream in public

rugged fiber
#

routines is a nice song and its chill with good lyrics but oldies station is just amazing

terse light
#

its oldies and it aint even close

subtle quest
#

oldies helped me get through a lot soo

oblique umbra
#

Sobbed at the concert for oldies station

upbeat bramble
#

I'm sorry, Oldies Station, but I'm voting for Routines in the Night

pallid oracle
#

RITN is very good but Oldies means so much to me as a fan who grew up with this band

wise sentinel
#

Prefer oldies but as long as one of them can beat navigating I'll be happy!

high nimbus
fair sonnet
#

i think routines is my least favorite song on the album

brazen finch
#

Oh jeez

light zealot
#

OLDIES STATION

high nimbus
#

I fear I won’t be able to vote

subtle quest
molten peak
brazen finch
#

Oh shit, Clancy battles are hard af

subtle quest
#

peak vs peak tho ngl

fair iris
#

oldies really means so much to me but i'd be lying to myself if i said RITN isn't a better song

fair sonnet
high nimbus
placid wadi
#

Clancy sb 10 songs vs their seeding(fanmade from the 2 previous clancy song battles):

#1: Navigating
#2: At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb
#3: Midwest Indigo
#4: Vignette
#5 Oldies Station
**#6: Routines In The Night **
#7: Next Semester
#8: Overcompensate
#9: Paladin Strait
#10: Lavish
#11: Backslide
#12: Snap Back
#13-14:The Craving (both versions)

terse light
errant isle
#

Routines against Oldies? How am I supposed to choose grief

subtle quest
terse light
#

oldies is peak top

pallid oracle
#

I really hope they bring Oldies back the next time they tour internationally

fair iris
pallid oracle
#

Everyone deserves to hear it live imo

errant jay
humble elbow
#

If routines loses. I riot

subtle quest
terse light
fair sonnet
errant isle
high nimbus
pallid oracle
fair sonnet
#

okay the craving jv is my least favorite

gentle fulcrum
#

routines in the night is like my fav song of all time in the clancy album, yeah that is right, fight me

slim wind
terse light
fair iris
sonic forge
hard walrus
#

routines ez

lilac rain
errant jay
pallid oracle
viscid saffron
#

oldies station.

placid wadi
errant jay
#

oldies is very loved in the clique

slim wind
terse light
brazen finch
#

I feel like there’s no world tour because stealing drums and booing, that’s why we can’t have nice things

lean sandal
#

YEA I WANNA

terse light
#

ONLY CONSISTENCY IN YOUR PERIPHERY

errant isle
#

Nico was being a little shit took three tries to vote for oldies

fair sonnet
true creek
#

obvious winner is ritn

errant isle
jolly agate
pallid oracle
errant jay
placid wadi
#

by all means Oldies wins this one pretty sure

errant jay
terse light
lean sandal
#

nico WORK

errant isle
#

This is probably gonna be close but my vote is Oldies just because those fake fans were so shitty about and cried because they didn't get slowtown

fair sonnet
#

routines aesthetic in the video and live is so good but i fear the song is a little lackluster for my taste

fair iris
#

it's funny how 2024 me would've voted Oldies instantly but Routines really grew on me

frigid bough
#

oh fuck

#

this one’s hard

errant jay
sullen tartan
#

Oof this one is tough for me

errant jay
#

go with the one starting with o

limber snow
#

oldiesss

true creek
sullen tartan
#

Ill give them both a listen and then vote

fair iris
#

it wants me to vote Oldies so bad it's not letting me vote Routines

frigid bough
#

I DONT KNOW

#

FUCK

jolly agate
lean sandal
#

silent voters pls pick the right one

frigid bough
#

ive already gone two rounds in the clancy battles without voting i need to make a decision

errant jay
humble elbow
lean sandal
#

like

#

be fr

errant jay
brazen finch
errant jay
#

oldies

#

be fr

humble elbow
#

Nope you be fr

lean sandal
#

oldies is good but not ritn good

humble elbow
#

Oldies is losing

lean sandal
#

you’re lying to yourself if you think oldies is better 😭

errant jay
#

ritn is good but not oldies good

jaunty raptor
#

so, routines is a good song and i dont hate it and i WILL bop to it; but imo i like it the elast off clancy

lean sandal
#

and trust i love oldies

errant jay
humble elbow
#

And if it survives. Aud will personally end song battles /jk

tired jetty
#

oldies is overrated because of its sentimental value, i love the song and its very sweet but as a song it shouldnt have gotten this far

lean sandal
#

clancy song battles always rigged cause of the navigating mv

true creek
#

walk da layout

neat falcon
#

oldies oldies oldies

inland bay
#

they hate me fr (this has happened ljke 10 times in a row)

humble elbow
#

routines should have won the last one but we dont talk about it

lean sandal
#

nico

#

is broke

fair iris
# lean sandal be fr

exactly
so disappointed in the Midwest Indigo and Paladin Strait results, just this once they should vote the better song T-T

thin anvilBOT
forest abyss
#

Oh this one is easy

lean sandal
#

bffr

fair sonnet
errant jay
#

oldies BETTER win against navigating or i will shake someone until they die

forest abyss
#

Routines in the night is like halo 3

#

Its not bad

#

But its also overrated as hell

jaunty raptor
#

so true

true creek
#

nico is having a difficult time it seems

fair sonnet
errant jay
#

it's popular but there's better ones

neat falcon
fair iris
errant jay
jaunty raptor
neat falcon
#

NS

fair sonnet
#

next semester was my top song last year

inland bay
#

nico finally worked YAY

neat falcon
#

i rember 🤩

errant jay
#

i can't stand to see my favorite song lose again

spice delta
#

next semester my fave clancy song oat

gloomy summit
#

NICO ISNT WORKING

inland bay
#

next peakmester

fair iris
gloomy summit
#

oh nevermind

fair sonnet
runic lily
near stratus
#

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

fathom musk
#

Routines in the PEAK vs. Depression Station

humble elbow
near stratus
#

chat I gotta do it

#

oldies station ftw

forest abyss
neat falcon
fathom musk
waxen depotBOT
formal kettle
#

Oldies station next question

spice delta
#

breach_r breach_e breach_a 🇱

fathom musk
humble elbow
#

Routines still better than a sad song

rustic pond
#

RITN but im still pissed at yall for making vignette lose

formal kettle
forest abyss
#

It's not even sad

inland bay
forest abyss
#

Its at worst bittersweet

snow rapids
#

ROUTINES IN THE NIGHT

fair sonnet
#

no way tøp fans hating on sad songs... the call is coming from inside the building

tender plank
#

walk the layout...

formal kettle
#

It’s about celebrating the fact that even though you lose a lot in life, and sometimes it’s hard, you haven’t let it stop you from growing as a person

terse light
neat falcon
#

fart the layout
poopies in the night

sullen tartan
#

Nah it's oldies for me, I just teared up giving it another listen

fair iris
humble elbow
#

Routines >>>>>>oldies

forest abyss
#

Bait used to he believable

fathom musk
terse light
#

routines aint shit compared to everything oldies has

humble elbow
#

Lies

terse light
#

but keep glazing ritn just keep doing it

terse light
#

its funny how this server is so in denial

forest abyss
#

Song battles last year was way more fun

humble elbow
#

Routines has

Made me hyped for every song on the album

sullen tartan
forest abyss
#

It just ain't the same

humble elbow
#

Nah

formal kettle
#

I’d argue that lyrically, routines is less positive than oldies station

humble elbow
#

Song battles is still as toxic as it was before

terse light
fair iris
forest abyss
terse light
humble elbow
#

Nah it was more annoying

forest abyss
#

People made posters and shit

#

That was super fun

humble elbow
#

And bait used to be believed

terse light
tender plank
terse light
#

oldies literally is like trying to help you PUSH ON THROUGH

tender plank
#

RAB and self titled were hell for me

fair iris
terse light
#

ritn is fun sure but oldies literally motivates you to keep going even when shit gets hard

formal kettle
#

I played oldies station in the car on the way to my uni graduation and I think it’s changed me as an individual

humble elbow
#

Im so glad i didnt type in till now because i can say half the results in the past..

Are wrong

terse light
humble elbow
#

Redecorate didnt deserve it

humble elbow
fair iris
formal kettle
#

It’s bait atp 😔

humble elbow
#

Choker, shy away,

formal kettle
humble elbow
#

Im not trying to rile anyone up

formal kettle
#

Ok 👍

terse light
#

people got too comfortable being on the internet

formal kettle
#

Anyway Oldies Station has my vote and my soul it’s the holding on to you of Clancy

humble elbow
#

so where else do I say it

fair iris
terse light
terse light
#

talk to urself if u have to bud

formal kettle
terse light
#

ik that's probably something you do in your freetime anyway

terse light
#

unless you HEAVILY simplify both of the songs meanings

#

which you could do with the ENTIRE ALBUM OF CLANCY

humble elbow
formal kettle
#

At their most bare bones next semester is about not dwelling on your past and looking forward, oldies is about…not dwelling on your past and looking forward - they are INCREDIBLY similar songs message wise imo

terse light
formal kettle
formal kettle
#

???

terse light
#

ITS LITERALLY THE ROOT OF THE ALBUM

formal kettle
#

????yes that’s what I’m saying????

terse light
#

you were saying next semester and oldies station had the same meaning

trail orbit
#

Guys, RITN is not this good

formal kettle
#

Unfortunately I think I know what I am attempting to say 😔

trail orbit
#

No way you can listen to Oldies and not feel emotional

terse light
#

which would only require you to pull into the bare bones meaning of the song

formal kettle
waxen depotBOT
terse light
formal kettle
#

I fear we are arguing the same thing here unfortunately

#

I’m not even trying to argue tbf 😭

terse light
#

LIKE IF ITS TO THE POINT WHERE YOU CAN ONLY GO TO THE BARE BONES

formal kettle
#

You can turn caps off it’s not that deep

terse light
#

THEN NO NEXT SEMESTER AND OLDIES ARE NOT THE SAME

terse light
lavish basalt
#

Oldies

terse light
#

learn to actually make a point right 🥀

formal kettle
#

I am howling this has escalated so quickly

tender plank
#

drum show's pretty good btw

terse light
#

top 5 top song

lavish basalt
#

Drum show is so gas

cobalt light
#

Will there be a breach battle next week

#

Contract vs drum show

terse light
#

i hope not

#

cause contract would get demolished

tender plank
#

it would be funny tho

lavish basalt
#

Drum show clears the contract

terse light
#

poor contract

#

you're an 8/10 in my heart buddy

formal kettle
timid ridge
#

oldies sweep 😉

terse light
#

if you have to go to the bare bones of the album then they dont mean the same thing

formal kettle
modest marlin
#

NOOO why are we pitting two kings against each other :(

formal kettle
#

Although I do still think that the core meaning of both songs is “don’t dwell on the past and keep looking forward”

BUT I completely agree with what you’re saying 😎😎

last cradle
#

This is a hard one but I hope oldies wins

zinc whale
#

This is far too difficult 😭

true glacier
#

routines in the night is the best song off of clancy

pseudo meadow
#

pldies ststion please please please please please please please please pleae please please please please please please please please please please please please please please

#

oldies station kept me alive and clean guys lets vote oldies station please please please please please

true glacier
gaunt hedge
#

i cant vote

frank compass
#

ROUTINES GANG RISE UP

still sigil
#

Look. RITN is in my top 5 favs off the album. But Oldies is WAY too emotionally beautiful to not adore (also it was the one that made me cry at the show so)

formal kettle
#

Thank u gronk for your continued and unwavering support

#

U a real one

mighty ferry
#

Ofc

rigid oasis
#

Push on through clancylogo

midnight turtle
#

guys.

rotund gulch
#

justice for routines in the night

#

oldies is gonna sweep but routines grief

candid wing
#

Routines better win!!!!!! 😤

surreal vale
#

that’s it i’m not voting

#

how do you even choose???

bleak aspen
#

This is a sad one

#

Oldies station is the best song they've made in my opinion

#

And routines in the night is up there

#

But oldies station is just too got to not vote it

true glacier
subtle rose
#

Routines will probably win this round, but Oldies has my heart

solemn silo
#

Routines In The Night is the best TØP song

neat falcon
next gust
#

Aaaaah ! How am I supposed to choose ?! grief

#

Oldies means a lot to me, but Routines is so good ! grief gatoamor

#

Let's take Oldies

rugged fable
#

My sister made her grad cap TØP themed and wrote push on through on it

terse light
terse light
junior ledge
#

oldies oldies oldies

stoic carbon
#

oldies ftw

twin marlin
#

I'm still going for Oldies even if it's a losing battle

#

I will protect and love this song with all of my heart and all that I am

frank rose
#

Routines in the night is more of a catchy song vs oldies being more meaningful. It’s like putting the hype vs neon gravestones

astral finch
#

Oldies and it isn’t even a close fight

hidden sinew
#

Overrated peak vs peak

hidden sinew
astral finch
torn mural
#

ritn

frank rose
hidden sinew
#

Thousand*

frank rose
#

for me it’s third but it’s still literally a masterpiece

#

every song is a good song

hidden sinew
#

Yeah

#

Top 2 lp album

astral finch
astral finch
frank rose
#

Putting you on game rn

hidden sinew
hidden sinew
frank rose
#

I agree along with In the End

#

For me

keen fox
#

this vote is rigged its just interaction failing me grief

vast briar
#

RITN takes the bag im sorry oldies station 😭

keen fox
#

please i just want to support ritn

raw ether
#

Ngl I like RITN more

turbid condor
#

Oldies all the way

#

But I now really believe ritn will win grief

fallow crystal
#

NO

#

NOOOOOO

#

MOST UNFAIR MATCH UP EVER

#

oldies deserves to win because of how much it means to ME personally!!!

wary knoll
#

IM SORRY @midnight turtle BUT ITS GOTTA BE OLDIES SWEEP

midnight turtle
#

no

wary knoll
#

i’m sorry 💔

midnight turtle
#

no.

wary knoll
#

it will always be oldies station for me sadclown

strange dome
#

Your favorite

quartz merlin
#

Wow. Two of my favourites. Routines.

#

I think Oldies will win due to sentimental value and that is okay. Routines is a very robotic song but I love it for that.

timber ibex
#

How could they do this to me

spiral lodge
#

I had to vote Routines, I am sorry guys

dim spade
#

I 400 msg

high folio
#

oldies sweep

subtle rose
#

Oldies Station ❤️

urban panther
#

THIS IS HARD 😭

real scroll
#

Oh goddamnit

#

Oldies has emotional but routines is just so mf good

lucid dawn
#

WALK THE LAYOUT

ionic night
#

STOP DONT DO THIS TOO ME THESE ARE MY 2 FAVORITE SONGS

#

OMG.

compact ridge
#

Love both of them

dreamy crest
#

some of these song matchups feels like you’re comparing apples to pears

late spoke
#

if you dont vote oldies then tyler was right to not play it for half the tour

quartz merlin
#

Oldies better sweep

west hawk
#

This one was really hard because routines in the night has such a good toon but oldies station has such meaningful lyrics

buoyant gyro
#

oldies sweep

prisma ferry
#

OLDIES!!

astral finch
#

hit the double whammy

random needle
#

bro why isnt it letting me vote

subtle rose
south ruin
#

Routines in the Night PLEASE

#

It is the one that is most relatable to me 😭

subtle rose
#

Yeah, RITN is relatable, but Oldies is my favorite

stone bough
#

its not letting me vote MEGASUPERHYPERFLUSHED

#

nvm it worked after 15 clicks 🙂

#

lol

subtle rose
#

Lol

low spoke
#

oldies broheeheegiggle

delicate basalt
#

i love routines but i just really deeply listened to oldies and sobbed a little💔

worthy girder
#

push on through oldies

balmy warren
#

Oldies sweep

stoic carbon
#

sweep on through

formal shuttle
#

oldies all the way

crisp flax
#

OLDIESSS

drowsy dirge
#

NO. DONT MAKE ME CHOOSE

pseudo meadow
#

i really hope oldies station wins clancy battles if it does i will literally cry of such happy tears my faith in the clique will return

hasty flume
#

YALL BETTER BE VOTING ROUTINES 💔💔💔

quartz merlin
#

Oldies station is like a spoken message to keep pushing. Sonically, I fuckin adore routines in the night

snow rapids
#

Routines >>>>>

quartz merlin
#

I can't possibly say anything mean against Oldies Station, it's not within my DnA

astral finch
hasty flume
fair iris
hasty flume
fair iris
#

💔 💔

astral finch
runic lily
#

still can't vote bruh

faint axle
#

This is crazy hard

rigid oasis
#

LET'S GOOOO

placid wadi
#

Clancy sb 10 results vs their seeding(fanmade from the 2 previous clancy song battles):

#1: Navigating
#2: At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb
#3: Midwest Indigo
#4: Vignette
#5 Oldies Station 👑 👑
**#6: Routines In The Night ** 👑 💀
#7: Next Semester
#8: Overcompensate
#9: Paladin Strait
#10: Lavish
#11: Backslide
#12: Snap Back
#13-14:The Craving (both versions)

mighty ferry
#

Yesssss

runic lily
#

There's 400 votes lacking lol it's not extremely fair for RITN

neat falcon
#

YEAHHHHH

placid wadi
gray arch
#

the oldies glaze must be studied

neat falcon
#

how is push on through glaze 😭😭

trail orbit
#

Let’s go!

twin marlin
#

oh!

lean sandal
#

i’m cancelling the whole thing

nova ibex
#

Holy cow it actually happened 🥳

#

Routines Finally Got Out…. And it was to OLDIES STATION!!! Yes! Exactly as it was intended!

humble elbow
#

I hate this

nova ibex
humble elbow
nova ibex
#

Mine is the complete opposite

midnight turtle
#

this is so sick and twisted!!!!!!! /lh

fallow crystal
#

OMG THANK GOD

humble elbow
formal shuttle
#

YES!

humble elbow
stoic carbon
#

yayayayayay oldies

humble elbow
stoic carbon
formal shuttle
lament cargo
#

this is different from hwo it went before, right? oldies is climbing the ranks this time?

molten peak
#

Y'all are objectively wrong

gloomy totem
#

Hey I don’t wanna hear it! Not after ATROFD lost to Navigating 🙄

tidal mulch
#

it's my favourite song along with next semester, so i'm a happy chap (as much as ritn is awesome too)

lament cargo
# molten peak Y'all are objectively wrong

there is literally no objectivity here. it is preferences over which song is better. im so sick of people being like oh it's objectively wrong like no, nope, we're voting on our opinions, opinions cannot be wrong

lament cargo
tidal mulch
#

think of it as him just getting a workout in haha. some cheeky cardio

#

also given it represents the team's hard work they put in to make the this whole thing happen, it's more a moment to reflect (both them and us) on the people who got them through it all. which is nice to do every now and then :)

#

(the music video in particular. obviously the song itself is up to personal interpretation as per usual)

silk osprey
#

Oldoes station sweep

subtle rose
lament cargo
lament cargo
# subtle rose I agree with you. It's not fair to hate on someone for their opinion because mus...

literally every time i come to say what i'm voting for it's just some argument about what's better and what isn't, like i don't know what the better song is objectively, like i'm not a music professional, i'm just a lowly fan picking her favorite like every time a song loses like a handful of people are like wow i hate you guys like i don't even know if it's a joke but i'm just so sick of seeing it regardless

subtle rose
lament cargo
subtle rose
#

Yeah, same here. I usually just go to Bluesky if people are being mean on Discord

lament cargo
#

i think it's just how big the server is, i'm on other servers where people aren't like this

subtle rose
#

Ah, I see. I'm not in many servers. I think this is probably the biggest server that I am in

pseudo meadow
#

oldies station 🥺