#2025 Clancy Song Battle #9

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

iron scarabBOT
#

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1755874800:R>

cerulean glade
#

oh come on

hazy socket
#

dude

vestal iris
#

Navigating

raw dove
#

ez

pure tangle
#

Pleaseeeeee Navigating

magic breach
tame hedge
#

atrofd

slender horizon
#

Thse are both two of the best songs in Clancy.

wispy hedge
#

😐

pallid agate
#

voting atrofd because someone has to

sinful phoenix
#

at the risk of SWEEPING

quasi rivet
#

NAVIGATING MY LOVE

hazy socket
#

i gotta go atrofd

eager yacht
#

not voting

dapper pilot
#

I wonder which one I will choose

cobalt anvil
#

navy gay ting bruv

pure tangle
#

“Kinda feels like everybody leaves” bridge is so important to me

lament dragon
#

Navigating

stone briar
#

navigating

wispy hedge
#

CHECK INNNNNNN

winter flume
#

ATROFS

cerulean glade
#

navigating ig??? this is so hard

atomic sparrow
#

NAVIGATING TheDreamp

tame hedge
#

this will be very close but i think navigating will win

pallid agate
#

navigating is definitely going to sweep

turbid knot
#

Atrofd is about to be destroyed

viscid stag
glass basin
#

atrofd my wife forever and ever best song ever ever

dapper pilot
wispy hedge
#

JUSTICE FOR ATROFD 🥀

clear solar
#

I love at the risk but NAVIGATING IS PEAK

cyan valve
#

This is tough, but I’m saying ATROFD only because it’s given me my motto:
At the risk of feeling dumb, check in, it’s not worth the risk of losing a friend.

hazy socket
#

atrofd is so dear to me bro

cyan valve
#

The Navigating bridge is hard tho

sleek cave
#

oh this matchup HURTS but its navigating

fallow orbit
#

How is the worst song on Clancy (navigating obviously) still in??

little heron
#

at the risk of feeling dumb is good but navigating is gooder

sinful phoenix
#

JUST KEEEEP YOUR PLAAAANS I HOOOOPE THAT YOU NEVER HAVE TO DROP

cyan gulch
#

i could never put navigating over atrofd mannn....

sinful phoenix
hard basalt
#

Navisweeping.

glass basin
maiden quest
#

ATOFD PEAKKKKKKK

hazy socket
#

dude i liek both but i gotta choose atrofd

calm flame
#

AT THE RISK OF SWEEPING OMG

quasi rivet
#

IF YALL ARE ON THE FENCE JUST REMEMBER THE LORE REVEAL IN THE NAVIGATING MV AND HOW GREAT IT WAS

sleek cave
#

these are both in my top 3 on clancy but navigating slightly beats out atrofd for me

brittle lantern
broken rivet
#

this one is hard, honestly this is like comparing apples to apples; they have very similar song elements imo

acoustic marten
#

ATROFD MY BOY DONT LET HIM LOSE 😭😭😭

languid compass
#

At the rissskkkkkkk ☺️

dark bolt
#

It said it failed 3 times before letting me vote navigating

maiden quest
pure tangle
#

GIIIIIIIVE ME SOOOOOOME ADVIIIIIIIIIICE

edgy cedar
#

AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB

woeful lily
#

CHECK INNN

maiden quest
bitter lark
#

I love both but like

languid compass
#

At the risk of eating too many eggs this am 😞

bitter lark
#

AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB

woeful lily
#

Guys what should I vote for???

bitter lark
#

IT'S SO GOOD.

pearl holly
#

NAVIGATING

broken rivet
#

yes but has everyone considered give me some adVIIIICEEEE

glass basin
pearl holly
#

HAS TO BE NAVIGATING

bitter lark
hazy socket
#

ITS NOT WORTH THE RISK OF LOOSING A FRIEND

maiden quest
fallow orbit
# hard basalt Crazy rage bait.

Maybe it was kinda rage bait, but navigating is legitimately my least favorite, the only one I skip every time. Can't stand the ehhh ohhhs

maiden quest
#

EVEN IF THEY SAY

acoustic marten
hazy socket
#

JUST KEEP YOUR PLANS

stray sierra
#

alright

bitter lark
languid compass
woeful lily
#

IDK MAN I LIKE BOTH SM

stray sierra
#

fuck everyone WHY DID OVWRCOMEPENSATE LOSE.

bitter lark
#

THAT YOU NEVER HAVE TO DROP

stray sierra
#

😢😢

hazy socket
#

THAT YOU NEVE HAVE TO DROP

hard basalt
summer scarab
#

Navigating

manic turret
#

This is a really hard one...

winter oyster
#

navigating, i like atrofd but i still can't get over that circus music sounding intro

hazy socket
#

if im being real man

woeful lily
pure tangle
#

Either way this vote goes, just knowing that Navigating brought about the “we’re not leaving” fan project makes me so happy

broken rivet
#

imma go ahead and do navigating 1) because of the music vid and 2) the lyrics resonate with me fully

twin geyser
#

AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB VOTE ITTTTTTTTT

bitter lark
fallow orbit
rugged spire
#

ATROFD MY BELOVED grief grief grief grief

maiden quest
acoustic marten
bitter lark
hard basalt
languid compass
grand glen
#

navigating.

maiden quest
sleek cave
#

i love navigating too much

pure tangle
stray sierra
rain laurel
#

Navigating is my favourite song on the album, so my vote goes to Navi, obviously

viral gazelle
hazy socket
patent summit
#

NAVIGATINGGGG 🗣️ 🗣️ 🗣️

pure tangle
acoustic marten
#

if atrofd loses im leaving the server

elder loom
#

atrofdci frfr

hazy socket
#

true

bitter lark
#

I CAN'T CHOOSE MAN

glass basin
#

if ur voting solely based on lore i dont trust u

sonic stratus
#

This is gonna destroy me

viral gazelle
#

At the risk is the best on the album

quasi rivet
restive vine
#

Nooo what am I supposed to do 😭

left abyss
glass basin
vital dock
#

peak vs peak

hard basalt
pure tangle
broken rivet
#

navigating also resonates with me fairly well, like that feeling of not knowing where to go and needing someone to help but ultimately knowing its your own landscape you have to traverse

left abyss
acoustic marten
glass basin
#

LOL

hard basalt
sleek cave
#

also the clancybearer ship might be canon bc i think the lavish marriage is canon to the lore???

#

i may be completely wrong tho

chrome prism
#

Navigating ez

wet compass
#

This is hell

vital dock
#

but i prefer atrofd because i feel closer (TO GOD) to this song

woeful lily
glass basin
sleek cave
hard basalt
glass basin
fallow orbit
hazy socket
#

dude i love overcomp

sleek cave
#

ppl were saying the lavish marriage is canon because of the video that got posted with blurryface/nico singing lavish so. idk

glass basin
#

THATS FUNNY TBH

hard basalt
hazy socket
#

oh my god i forgot abt that video

quasi rivet
pure tangle
winter oyster
glass basin
hard basalt
hazy socket
#

lavish was a song made just for fun 😁

hard basalt
#

Also random RAB input, but I like the RAB OTS a lot.

pure tangle
errant scarab
#

navisweeping

hazy socket
#

theres no lore behind it

hard basalt
#

Lavish was just silly.

glass basin
hazy socket
#

tyler did say that it was made because they wanted a song where they could wear suits and drink caprisun

woeful lily
glass basin
pure tangle
#

Lavish is a callout about the music industry and they got to do a lighthearted video for it 🤷‍♀️

hazy socket
#

that too

#

alott of ppl just started figuring that out

woeful lily
hard basalt
barren cloak
#

Wait how does this work? How come ATROFD doesn’t have a trophy even thought it has a win?

glass basin
lone gull
#

NAVIGATINGGGG

hard basalt
hard basalt
#

I don't know why.

glass basin
#

i stg it had one and navigating didnt when i opened it earlier

hazy socket
hard basalt
hazy socket
#

it did hae one

pure tangle
#

Probably just a glitch that it doesn’t have a medal I guess. Nico struggles a little with song battles sometimes lol

glass basin
#

thats fair theres a lot going on tho

#

id struggle more

lone gull
#

not just with song battles

vital coral
#

I hate this i am struggling

glass basin
#

two of the bestest bestest best songs on the album fr

hazy socket
#

fr

maiden condor
#

Navigating next question

iron scarabBOT
acoustic marten
iron scarabBOT
vital coral
#

They are both my favorites unfortunately but i liked navigating more first

acoustic marten
hazy socket
#

atrofd is my favourite song off the album other than midwest indigo

wind gale
#

Navigating CLEARS

#

it's not even close lol

#

Navigating is top 3 on the album atrofd is bottom 3 on the album

(PLEASE REMEMBER bottom 3 on a fantastic album is NOT BAD but something has to be there)

whole sandal
#

Clancy sb 9 songs vs their seeding(fanmade from the 2 previous clancy song battles):

#1: Navigating(DEFENDING CLANCY SB WINNER)
#2: At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb
#3: Midwest Indigo
#4: Vignette
#5 Oldies Station
#6: Routines In The Night
#7: Next Semester
#8: Overcompensate
#9: Paladin Strait
#10: Lavish
#11: Backslide
#12: Snap Back
#13-14:The Craving (both versions)

#

Rematch here for ATROFD and Navigating

stray sierra
left abyss
barren cloak
glass basin
# wind gale Navigating is top 3 on the album atrofd is bottom 3 on the album (PLEASE REMEMB...

real bro as much as i love shooting the shit in these battles and fighting over “better” songs this album especially is peak as hell. all of these albums have been hard their discography just bangs. and breach will probably only just he even more difficult lol. but CLANCY in particular is just a magnificent piece of work that i know had a big impact on a lot of people. myself included lol.
it is so fun we all love these things enough to be this passionate about it. and argue lmao

whole sandal
woeful lily
hard basalt
glass basin
barren cloak
acoustic marten
wind gale
barren cloak
#

I wish I liked navigating more everyone loves it!!!

iron scarabBOT
wind gale
hazy socket
#

i liek both but i prefer atrofd

glass basin
#

i got a tattoo for ATROFD so thats a little indicative of how i feel about it

hazy socket
#

i like all the songs on the album tbh

glass basin
#

navigating is peak asf also tho i would also. get a tattoo for that

wind gale
#

the only song on the album I don't really enjoy is lavish but it is growing on me

whole sandal
#

im surprised we immediately have a back to back back to back seed matchup

acoustic marten
#

atrofd is in my top 3 tøp songs tbh i love it sm

glass basin
wind gale
#

for me the break is the craving

#

and lavish just unnecessarily extends it while I'm waiting for navigating to come

glass basin
#

the craving makes me cry a lot because im unwell but if i dont pay attention it is also a break lol

wind gale
#

I do love the lavish video tho

twin kraken
#

CHICKEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEN

hazy socket
#

??

wind gale
lunar flame
#

I need to listen to clancy again it's been a while

tough citrus
#

Navigating everyday

lunar flame
#

I voted atrofd tho

acoustic marten
hazy socket
#

im in heaven noones hating on the craving

lunar flame
#

Lol

winged marsh
#

At the risk of feeling dumb is better but y'all ain't ready for that conversation

hazy socket
#

i mean abt what mentals saying btw

wind gale
#

second best Jenna song

woeful lily
hazy socket
#

fr

hazy socket
#

i prefer jennas version over single

glass basin
#

the craving is so beautiful anyone who hates it i think just doesnt get it genuinely

woeful lily
#

It's still beautiful

wind gale
#

Jenna's version feels so much more personal imo, it's like he's actually singing it to her. The voice crack kills me inside I love it so much

acoustic marten
glass basin
#

i thought i was crazy for this but thank god im not the only one

wind gale
lunar flame
#

I like both versions but the single is my fav

woeful lily
glass basin
#

jennas version is soooooo. yessss

rugged inlet
#

Navigating is my top song

glass basin
#

single version is better for when im trying to keep a certain vibe and also not be SAD

#

but i prefer jennas hardcore

cinder oak
#

I screenshot because why not

wind gale
#

To me the single version is just redundant of the best Jenna song, which is Formidable

#

so I'll just listen to Formidable if I want that

hazy socket
#

wait is formidable abt jenna?

wind gale
#

Yea

#

it's SAI's Jenna song

glass basin
#

whattt

#

how did i not know that

hazy socket
#

cool

wind gale
#

yessir

glass basin
#

claps hands together. ok. i have something to go listen to with a new perspective now.

wind gale
#

like I said it's the best Jenna song imo

glass basin
#

i kinda thought it was but like. did not know for sure

hazy socket
#

then theres also tear in my heart which is prob my fave off of blurryface

heavy rune
#

WHEN DID LAVISH LOSE

acoustic marten
#

wait what

wind gale
#

first battle it was in

heavy rune
acoustic marten
#

it didnt eben last a battle LMAO

hazy socket
#

it was up aganist next semester

heavy rune
#

Oh

#

Ok ok

honest bear
#

ATROFD

hazy socket
#

which in itself is a great song

woeful lily
hazy socket
heavy rune
#

Yeah that's understandable but lavish is still the best

wind gale
#

I really don't like Lavish honestly

#

it has grown on me over time so it's not like AWFUL

hazy socket
#

i only like it cause its great for like background music

wind gale
#

it's still easily the worst song on the album to me

hazy socket
#

idrk what the worst on the album is for me

#

might be paladin strait for me

humble zenith
#

at the risk>everything else on the album otay bye

humble zenith
hazy socket
#

but thats because i dont like the pause

acoustic marten
#

yea same

odd swallow
#

At the risk of feeling dumb CHECK INNNNNN

#

It's not worth the risk of losing a FRIEeEEeND

heavy rune
#

My least fav is probably the craving

odd swallow
hazy socket
#

my top three are oldies, atrofd, midwest

acoustic marten
heavy rune
hazy socket
#

and the craving is definitally higher on my list than lavish cause its just the meaning of the song

heavy rune
#

I don't really have a fav from clancy i prefer sai

odd swallow
#

Sappy songs are just not my thing
I didn't like Tear in my Heart either I'M SORRY

hazy socket
#

and also my fave albums between vessel and sai 😁

heavy rune
daring anchor
#

NavigNateing

vague mesa
alpine breach
#

voting machine broke. keeps saying interaction failed and already has navigating marked as winner? even though it says voting ends in 1 day

hazy socket
#

dude i LOVE wdbwotv

odd swallow
acoustic marten
#

wdbwotv goes HARD

vague mesa
#

wdbwotv got me in to tøp

hazy socket
#

i cant wait ti see city walls mv cause what do u mean u RECREATED past mvs for it 🥹

heavy rune
#

Isle of flightless birds. Peak. Got me into top and it's wicked to play on the ukulele

hazy socket
#

i love iofb i wont stand slander on it

odd swallow
#

SELF TITLED MENTIONED
Implicit Demand for Proof is the song that made me want to learn the piano and the reason why I am a musician today.

charred wolf
#

this is the hardest decision of my life

#

i love both but i can’t decide one song

hazy socket
#

self titled hate is kinda forced

acoustic marten
#

i love the self titled SOOO MUCH i start to cry every time i hear a song from it 😭

hazy socket
#

most top album hate is kind of forced

fiery mirage
acoustic marten
hazy socket
vestal anchor
#

atrofd is pretty nice but navigating is better

rain atlas
#

NAVISWEEPING

odd swallow
#

Shut up everybody, Car Radio just came up on shuffle

little flame
#

If Navigating doesn't win I'll be MAD

#

Like MADDDDDDD

odd swallow
#

Hello Mad, I'm dad

harsh yoke
#

ATROFD SWEEP

muted zodiac
#

at the risk of feeling sweep

frail bone
#

First aid coming over to ATROFD

#

🚑

#

Need more people because I see way too much navigating in this chat Noo

harsh yoke
#

Real

wind gale
slate cedar
#

DUDE WHAT DO I VOTE

#

both are fire...

frail bone
slate cedar
#

help

#

im not voting let the council decide 😭

spark wraith
#

it won’t even let me vote

#

keeps saying the interaction failed

untold ferry
coarse moth
#

noooooo when my boy finally got a chance to battle

#

that is so unlucky

#

what??

spark wraith
#

okay it let me vote finally

dusty solstice
#

I LOVE At the risk of feeling dumb, but Navigating reminds me of a very dear friend 😩😩

reef sundial
#

Clear winer

ancient eagle
#

sweepigating

vague mesa
#

🐔

#

vote chicken

faint fable
#

navigating

eager vigil
#

I like how atrofd goes from sounding like clown music to big rock anthem sounding

knotty hearth
#

navigating clears by a little

gusty adder
#

At the risk of felling dumb is cool, but navigating it's a banger sorry grief grief

terse kraken
#

at the risk of feeling dumb twin 💔

violet saddle
#

atrofd is so good but i already know its going to get DEMOLISHED 💔💔 its ok at least i love navigating

#

gave atrofd a vote anyway 🥹

fossil cloud
#

Navigating deserves to win

#

But I'll go for atrofd anyway

fleet torrent
#

atrofd is my fav song from clancy but come on, one of the most underrated songs from this album so Navigating its gonna win, fuck

vestal anchor
#

i think you mean rated

brazen portal
#

navisweep

fleet torrent
little flame
whole sandal
#

1st seed and 2nd seed battling it out is always a fun one

west dawn
#

navigating is peak

fiery mirage
stray osprey
#

Whaaaaat???? Which one am I supposed to vote for???? O_o

stray osprey
#

But idk which to vote for this time 💔

alpine breach
spark wraith
little flame
#

SO PEAK

gloomy vortex
#

Navisweeping

safe moon
#

DONT MAKE ME CHOOSE

#

I have to go atrofd

stray osprey
#

I still haven't voted RAAAH

austere comet
#

At the risk ofc

sullen plaza
#

atrofd please

slate cloud
#

@sonic stratus

#

what the fuck dude

sonic stratus
#

YEAH BRO

#

This is more upsetting than Arrex shippers

slate cloud
#

DUDE YEAH

#

this is def up there

#

HOW DO I CHOOSE cryin144p

#

THIS IS GEN SO EVIL

sonic stratus
#

My head hurts idk if I’ve voted yet

slate cloud
#

i dunno if i can

#

i feel worse not voting tho

sonic stratus
#

This is -one million aura

quaint obsidian
#

i dont like navigating guys

sonic stratus
#

Boys, round em up

quaint obsidian
#

or next semester

#

end of next semster is good

gloomy vortex
#

Navigating gonna win

#

I quite like the song but I don't love it

brittle pagoda
#

Vote for ATROFD because it’s not worth the risk of losing a frieeennnddd (even if they say, “just keep your plans, I hope that you never have to drop”)

green cosmos
#

chickeeeeeeeeeeennnnnnn

scenic ravine
#

ATROFD is overrated imo

#

Navigating its just purely goated

#

im only voting for navigating

fringe peak
#

i’m voting ATROFD cuz i don’t want another navigating sweep lmao

wind gale
fringe peak
#

navigating is still prolly above ATROFD i just don’t want next semester to lose to it haha

wind gale
fringe peak
#

boooooo

#

next semester > midgating

long rose
#

ATROFD takes the slice for me

brittle pagoda
wind gale
#

navigating live scream

fringe peak
#

counterpoint
this is the studio version

#

if they release the live album we can talk

wind gale
#

and whatever live performances of the song exist count towards it

fringe peak
#

counterpoint
your mother

serene schooner
#

For me

covert night
#

navigating sweeep

scenic ravine
loud swallow
#

oh. that’s gore. that’s gore of my comfort character.

frosty umbra
#

atrofd way better

prime wasp
#

ATROFD FTW BITCHES

sour river
#

At the risk of sweeping up checkiiiiiiiiin

sullen plaza
winged plank
#

atrofd clears by alot

digital thicket
#

yes please

prisma sonnet
#

hope so

south yacht
#

NOOOOO I CANNOT PIIIIIICK

#

i like navigating but also ATROFD has a good message

#

im gonna go for navigating

hexed depot
#

AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB CHECK IIIIINNNNNNN
IT'S NOT WORTH A RISK OF LOSING A FRIEEEEEEND

#

yeah imma vote for navigating

fallow matrix
#

Navigating sweeps on this one

ancient eagle
#

eo eo eo

#

eo eo eoooh

mighty cedar
#

Voting navigating because ATROFD's message didnt do shit for me 🔥 No hate to atrofd fans

summer scarab
sleek vine
#

My vote won’t go but if I could I’d vote for navigating

tame hedge
#

rip atrofd 💔

acoustic marten
#

NOOOOOOOOO ATROFD grief grief

tame hedge
#

it's loss will be mourned

whole sandal
#

Clancy sb 9 results vs their seeding(fanmade from the 2 previous clancy song battles):

#1: Navigating(DEFENDING CLANCY SB WINNER) 👑👑
#2: At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb 👑💀
#3: Midwest Indigo
#4: Vignette
#5 Oldies Station
#6: Routines In The Night
#7: Next Semester
#8: Overcompensate
#9: Paladin Strait
#10: Lavish
#11: Backslide
#12: Snap Back
#13-14:The Craving (both versions)

acoustic marten
frank crystal
#

this best be the last time i see navigating win

cinder jungle
#

The navigating glaze needs to be studied

whole sandal
neon prairie
left abyss
austere comet
#

Navigating is not that good bro 😭

sly urchin
#

Nooo! At The Risk 😭

sullen nacelle
#

How could this happen

twin kraken
#

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

serene schooner
#

I love ATROFD but navigating will ALWAYS have my heart

knotty hearth
#

navigating

fiery mirage
#

I'm ngl I dont remember which song I voted for

rain atlas
#

NAVISWEEPING LETS GOOOO

daring anchor
#

NavigNateing

velvet ermine
#

navigATEing

quasi rivet
#

NAVIGATING MY LOVE YOU DID IT

sullen plaza
#

NOOOOOOO WHY DID ATROF LOSEEE