2025 Scaled And Icy Song Battle #10

[ripe blade]

it does sound the same for me too but mayb bc i listsn to both through yt

[frank ridge]

Redecorate one of the most overrated songs

[steep geyser]

idc which one of these win, I'm kinda disappointed with the overall results with SAI

[desert fox]

?? It’s not overrated, I’ve never heard anyone talk about it
And anyway it deserves to be popular if it is because it’s so good

[undone bramble]

Redecorate

I’m sorry choker

[undone bramble]

It has never been overrated

But okay

[limpid panther]

Sadly redecorate is gonna win this one, I thought Choker was gonna win tbh

I love choker

[undone bramble]

I do too but redecorate is my favourite song of all time 💔

[teal storm]

What song yall thinking gonna win

[shut siren]

I might need to flip a coin

[crude mango]

Real

[modest bay]

I keep choosing Redecorate every song battle. It's just that good

[quartz jasper]

Redecorate

[thorn agate]

Redecorate

[sturdy mirage]

Redec

[orchid grove]

I'm very sad to vote against choker but I have to go redecorate

[quaint night]

choker deserves to win

[novel bobcat]

Redecorate

[vale wolf]

Oh shit.

This is hard.

But Redecorate was my very first SAI song.

So I have to choose that.

[half walrus]

Real

I love Redecorate so much

[solar plover]

SIPPING ON STRAIGHT REDECORATE. I DON'T BELIEVE THE JUDGE. NOW I SEE INTENTIONS ARE EVERYTHING. THE HALF DRAWN BLINDS CHECK THE CLOCK WONDER WHAT HE'LL PULL THIS TIME WE WANT YOU HOME IN ONE PIECE NOW

[ornate otter]

This is the hardest battle yet

[twilit sphinx]

oh man I can't decide

[modern horizon]

redecorate is lwk a relatable song and it comforts me but the bridge in choker

[sterile plover]

CHOKER

[lofty steppe]

Voted for Choker, Redecorate is deep though

[wintry ravine]

redecorate sweeps

[subtle glacier]

Redecorate ✊✊

[normal cliff]

redecorate

[pine vapor]

Redecorate

[ocean summit]

IGHT I MEAN LFG YALL

[fringe axle]

How is choker even this far

[spiral moon]

Choker is peak tho

Just doesn't compare to redecorate

[fringe axle]

I love it but there is a few better off of scaled

[north axle]

redecorate forever die

[slim geyser]

i don’t think i can vote in this one 😭

it’s too difficult to choose

[modern horizon]

im not voting this round bro i feel bad if i choose one💔💔

[jolly sable]

sweep my room or redecorate

[outer hill]

I think we all already know which ones gonna win over the whole album 😭

Redecorate is a masterpiece

[normal cliff]

yup

[jade linden]

redecorATE

[boreal blaze]

choKER

xD

[jade linden]

chOKer

[boreal blaze]

PEAKer

[lunar roost]

REDECORATE

[shut siren]

I won't shy away from voting
Choker is just more catchy
It can throw you onto the dancefloor while still containing some pretty deep lyrics

[frosty crown]

I like Redecorate but it better not win against the winning songs from the other albums

[viscid adder]

It's past 11am...

[normal cliff]

something went wrong

[viscid adder]

nah the mods called the vote last few times a bit later

theres no more battles to do so bot has done its job

But the vote should’ve ended even if a new one should start

Isn’t Clancy battles next

yes should start today based on previous trends

[normal cliff]

gotta be HARD

[worldly tartan]

I DONT WANNA VOTE LIKE THIS

[viscid adder]

Clancy is my favourite album by far so im gonna be passionate about it, and also get everyone hating me over my opinions of Lavish

[worldly tartan]

claiming the snap back and oldies station glazee

[viscid adder]

RITN and snap back defender til i die

I claim overcompensate and next semester

[normal cliff]

self-titled battle when

[viscid adder]

Snap Back is gonna get killed immediately i will make sure it doenst

[normal cliff]

SAME
my two favourites

[viscid adder]

If it’s against overcompensate or next semester you’re out of luck

[viscid adder]

14 june to 27 june, already ended

[viscid adder]

I will happily allow Next semester to win

[normal cliff]

what if paladin vs ritn

[ocean summit]

I lowk love all clancy songs

[viscid adder]

Overcompensate is gonna win overall i think, routines will get as far as overcompensate allows it

[viscid adder]

Paladin 100%

paladin and lavish also have cult followings

[normal cliff]

ritn

[viscid adder]

navigating has a very good chance

[viscid adder]

Hell no

[normal cliff]

hell yea

[viscid adder]

RITN is the pilots' best song ever

That song is just different

RITN is just electropop filler, Paladin is like some of the best production they’ve ever done to date

Filler?!?!?!?!?!!?!!??!??!?

[viscid adder]

Maybe not filler but it doesn’t bring as much to the table as a lot of Clancy songs

[normal cliff]

paladin strait sounds too cinematic for everyday listening

[viscid adder]

paladin is brilliant as well but ritn is packed with interesting moments from start to finish whilst the silence and repetition of paladin are a downside for a lot

[viscid adder]

Isn’t sounding cinematic a good thing tho

[viscid adder]

i think it brings everythign to the table. it fits the album perfectly, can be played on repeat all day, and has brilliant lyrics

honestly if i find a song my favourite it's just cause i can play it out the most

[normal cliff]

in a certain context : yup

[viscid adder]

The drums are fake

[viscid adder]

https://tenor.com/view/noway-gif-254273188714127328

That’s a huge downside

the drum rhythm clearly written by josh dun is so catchy

i air drum the song every time

It not being real drums just bores the hell out of me

the little fills and deep kicks and brooding atmosphere

[viscid adder]

HERE WE GO SONG BATTLES CLANCY

wrong reply

[ripe horizon]

shock

[viscid adder]

im jsut saying even if the drums are fake the song sounds great to me, doesnt bother me one bit

[magic notch]

YESSSS

YESSS

[viscid adder]

This first battle better be interesting

[magic notch]

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

WELL DONE EVERYONE

OMG CLANCY BATTLES

IM SCARED

[glad mason]

OMG

[humble sparrow]

no way

[sacred plume]

taste won

[hollow rose]

overcompensate is likely to win

[warm night]

prepping for war

[glad mason]

People have the discs as pfps already

🥹🥹

[viscid adder]

Navigating or OC

[humble spade]

https://tenor.com/view/yess-yes-gif-25420589

[glad mason]

Peak

[magic notch]

im scared

CLANCY BATTLES R GONNA BE HARD

[robust saffron]

Clancy battles are gonna be like Vessel battles all over again

[viscid adder]

I would make sure of it if I wasn’t about to lock up my phone for 10 days, but do me a favor guys push overcompensate to final round

[blazing fox]

clancy battles are gonna be an actual nightmare

[orchid badge]

i don't think a single person is shocked

[magic notch]

navigating

or

[warm night]

the barracks will be seeing me shortly

[magic notch]

midwest indigo

[fluid canopy]

Next Semester sweep

[magic notch]

next semester

[viscid adder]

any minute now.

i will defend next semester, backlside, routines, and snap back until my grave

[compact pine]

Actually this is peak

[glad mason]

Bounce man sweep next time anyone?

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1381048292661657620/1405165492770967652/IMG_5918.gif

[orchid badge]

YESSSS

[dim lion]

Oldies station will win this

[blazing fox]

can’t wait to cry when midwest indigo goes out

[hollow rose]

overcompensate isnt even as good as some of the other songs, its just that everybody likes it so its gonna do what jumpsuit did

[robust saffron]

let's just agree that Clancy doesn't need a battle because all the songs are bangers

[magic notch]

next semester will win

[viscid adder]

Definitely not that one, compared to other Clancy songs not that one

[warm night]

oldies station sweep

[uneven salmon]

Omg Clancy time I’m so excited eeeee !

[compact pine]

Overcompensate.. I will fight for you

[rich pivot]

oldies station should win out of the album what

[viscid adder]

as much as i want next semester to get far, the fact thats its 3rd in my rankings means its gonna face my top 2 eventually

[warm night]

already avenging backslide 🥀

[fluid canopy]

The first three singles of Clancy set the bar so high for the full album. I think Clancy is great, but other than Oldies and PS, it doesn't hit the same highs

[viscid adder]

Wdym not as good it has so much going on in every part of the song it’s produced so amazingly and it has the first generational switchup since chlorine

[blazing fox]

im so scared for midwest indigo. it’s my baby

[magic notch]

I WILL DIE FOR NEXT SEMESTER

[blazing fox]

i’ll fight for her to the death

[hollow rose]

forgot to add the imo

[viscid adder]

The weakest part of the album is Vignette-Craving-Lavish. Outside of that, perfect album.

And I like Vignette I just think it's track placement doesn't help pacing

[viscid adder]

Same difference, overcompensate is phenomenal

A lot of my issues with Clancy are pacing

[robust saffron]

At The Risk of Feeling Dumb needs more love

[uneven salmon]

Next Semester, Paladin Strait, and Navigating top 3 let’s goooo

[viscid adder]

YES

[fluid canopy]

I agree, but if that's the worst three-track run, you have a 10/10 album

[jolly jay]

backslide 🗣️

[thin island]

REDECORATE

YEAHHHH

[warm night]

avenging atrofd too 🥀

[blazing fox]

i will fight for midwest indigo and atrofd i will fight so hard

[robust saffron]

ATROFD is such a meaningful song

[rugged laurel]

i have a confession... ||i haven't listened to all of clancey....||

[viscid adder]

Navigating-Snap Back-Oldies Station is the best three track run on the album. Absolute emotional damage.

[hollow rose]

im not saying it isnt, im saying in MY OPINION its js not top 3

[thin island]

WOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWO

[blazing fox]

well u better listen to it before clancy battles start,,

[rugged laurel]

I KNOW I KNOW

[fluid canopy]

Next Semester v Oldies Station will/would break my heart, but I have to go NS

[uneven salmon]

YOU NEED TO RIGHT NOW it’s arguably the best album imo

[viscid adder]

Facing loneliness, old habits creeping back, and moving forward with depression. I mean what the fuck.

[craggy oriole]

Next semester is my baby it's so personal to me too❤️

[robust saffron]

Clancy is my favorite album

[rugged laurel]

chat i will listen to it so i can vote <3

[viscid adder]

any second now we will get clancy.... following previous patterns

[orchid lynx]

same

[rugged laurel]

i have listened to overcompensate(?) and next semester

[viscid adder]

Top 5 Clancy songs:
1: Overcompensate
2: Next Semester
3: Paladin Strait
4: Vignette
5: At the Risk of Feeling Dumb

I would fight SO HARD for these songs

[fierce spruce]

backslide underrated

[robust saffron]

Navigating vs Routines in the Night prediction

i don't want it to be true

[hollow rose]

true

[fluid canopy]

Clancy is a 9.6 - If those middle tracks were just a little stronger, it'd be perfect - even beating Trench

[ruby kite]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 5!

[viscid adder]

That one’s my number 6

[warm night]

i wanna give up before it even starts i know how this is gonna go 💔

[magic notch]

clancy is a perfect album, but the second half lacks compared to the first 6 tracks

[viscid adder]

Trench isn’t this golden thing, Clancy beats Trench without question

[hollow rose]

i know its not BAD but is it crazy that trench isnt my top 5 album for top

[viscid adder]

The Craving is a good song... just its placement was the worst fucking decision on earth. Chuck it at the end!!!

[magic notch]

kinton ur takes never fail to shock me

[fluid canopy]

Clancy wishes it could stay as focused as Trench

[warm night]

i also like Clancy more than trench

[viscid adder]

If Trench didn’t have pet cheetah it’s an easy 10/10 album trust

[fluid canopy]

The highs of Clancy are higher than the highs of Trench.

The whole of Trench is better than the whole of Clancy.

There. I said it. Come at me

[crisp condor]

LMAOOOOOOO

[viscid adder]

That’s kinda fair. I don’t fully understand it but ok

[robust saffron]

Backslide vs Next Semester
Overcompensate vs Lavish
ATROFD vs Oldies Station
Snapback vs The Craving
Midwest Indigo vs Vignette
Navigating vs Routines in the Night
Paladin Strait is the outlier

I'm wrong disregard me

[magic notch]

bro 😭

[foggy saffron]

oh… that’s a take for sure

[orchid badge]

clancy was their most consistent album since vessel imo. like i'm not saying the albums between them were bad, trench is my favorite of theirs, but clancy is just such a consistent album quality wise

[crisp condor]

hi @foggy saffron

[foggy saffron]

hi @crisp condor

[fluid canopy]

Overcompensate - Next Semester - Backslide is the best three track run of a TOP album. Three 10/10 tracks in a row. Then the album jumps from tone to tone until Navigating. Good songs, just a little jarring.

Trench has the perfect tracklist. I love how every track feels connected. Even if a track isn't perfect (9/10 instead of 10/10 lol), it feels like it belongs. On the other hand, it feels like you could swap some of the songs from Clancy with Blurryface, and nothing major would change.

[viscid adder]

I wouldn’t call backslide a 10/10 tbh. Honestly I think the best 3 track run is morph to my blood to chlorine

[fluid canopy]

That's a good run too. I get why people don't love Backslide, but it hits hard for me. Especially live, I'm about in tears by the chorus.

[viscid adder]

I like backslide a lot but not enough to give it a 10/10

I definitely think the first 3 Clancy songs are the best first 3 album tracks in TOP discography

[fluid canopy]

Vessel's close. Ode to Sleep, Holding On To You, and Migraine is an insane run.

Actually.. come to think of it.. what's RAB's first 3?

[viscid adder]

OTS and HOTY for sure but I’m not that big on migraine

[viscid adder]

GFH, HOTY, and OTS

[fluid canopy]

If we pretend those are the Vessel versions, that'd be a better run than Vessel. (but still below Clancy)

[viscid adder]

I might agree

[sand bough]

just wanted to come here to say that I SAID REDECORATE WOULD WIN SINCE THE BEGINNING OF THIS POLL

[hoary lake]

Periodt

[karmic portal]

Redecorate winning was the most predictable thing

[molten oxide]

Not a fan

Chokers way better

[wanton edge]

literally 😭

resweeporate

[molten oxide]

Wrong

[karmic portal]

I’m saying it as a bad thing bruh
I wanted choker to win but I know everyone loves redecorate a lot 😭

[molten oxide]

‘Everyone’

I love choker and shy away more

But ill ask this

Why do the fans like the sadder songs

[strong dust]

I for example like Redecorate just because of how it sounds

[torn glade]

i think it's clear

tøp songs and topics are related to mental struggles, so naturally people who's going through similar stuff get attracted to it because the songs either help them cope or push on through, depending on if the song is just sad and depressing like in a form of vent or on the other hand if the song is encouraging and remind them to not give up

[magic sedge]

Choker definitely should’ve won

It’s the only song I’ve liked from that album

[orchid grove]

redecorate

[spice juniper]

No chances got robbed