#2025 Scaled And Icy Song Battle #7

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

viscid spindleBOT
#

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1754838000:R>

grim cosmos
#

mhm

mighty juniper
#

THE SATURDAY SWEEP 🗣️

frosty sand
#

Choker easy

cosmic forum
#

choker ez

drowsy willow
#

Trash vs trash

#

Jokes

neon palm
#

SATURDAYY

oblique latch
#

choker

cosmic forum
#

come on guys choker easy

oblique latch
#

choker

sand chasm
#

choker

oblique latch
#

chokerrr

winter plank
#

sweepturday

oblique latch
#

CHOKERR

sand chasm
#

choker sweep

unique flicker
#

This is so unfair

halcyon prawn
#

No idea im gonna cry

hollow oak
#

Gotta do choker

cosmic forum
#

only smoking second hand?

unique flicker
#

This is so unfairrr

tough sedge
#

Man I love the day before Sunday_Tea

cosmic forum
#

we are all chokers here do not lie

winter plank
#

today is saturday ffs

distant finch
#

Oh dear

dark bloom
#

EASYYYYY CHOKERRER

iron harness
#

Rip bounce man

vale elbow
#

Guys why did bounce man lose

raw valley
#

CHONKER

unique flicker
hollow mulch
#

how

lament elbow
#

NOOOOO THIS IS LIKE ASKING ME WHO MY FAV CHILD IS

oblique latch
#

choker choker choker choker

worthy smelt
#

DUDE NO I CANT PICK

viral pike
#

im on team saturday

lone urchin
#

Hydrogen bomb vs coughing baby ahh matchup bro

hollow mulch
#

HOW

halcyon prawn
viscid spindleBOT
unique flicker
#

saturday…

hollow mulch
#

BOUNCE MAN LOST

drowsy willow
#

Yeah Choker. I hated it at first, the first tøp single I didnt like, but then then live stream experience make me love it

pulsar oxide
#

hydrogen bomb vs saturday

unique flicker
#

IM SO DISTRAUGHT

raw valley
#

i broke my wrists while listening to choker so it wins 💯

hollow mulch
#

this is a horrible, dismal day

jade blade
worthy smelt
#

NO I CANT PICK BETWEEN CHOKER AND SATURDAY

winter plank
#

saturday.

worthy smelt
#

I LOVE BOTH

hollow mulch
#

Choker takes my vote though

exotic reef
bitter salmon
#

Choker easy

gentle oasis
#

this some bullshit

dim crane
#

my streaming for choker more than doubles saturday💀 still a good song tho

hollow mulch
#

#underrated

oak tiger
#

Saturday mv came out on my bday so it’s automatically Saturday for me

heavy bough
#

choker 100%

tacit cobalt
#

I'm still angry about formidable losing 😡😡

runic hedge
#

Choker vs Saturday this is interesting. I gotta say Saturday tho

exotic reef
runic hedge
#

Who tf is xing me

signal sierra
#

Saturday will always be my favorite

lost oasis
#

my prediction is choker will win but it will be really close

short wedge
#

Oh goodness

stable vessel
#

I know it's over, choker is about to sweep hard

signal sierra
severe gulch
#

im laughing so bad everyone was riding for bounce man and shy away still got a thousand more votes

exotic reef
short wedge
#

Choker is like my anthem but I love Saturday..

strange nebula
#

Choker sweep

signal sierra
mental crag
#

okay i’m voting saturday for the sheer purpose of it won’t win to redecorate even though choker is one of the best

strange nebula
#

Sweeper

short wedge
#

I'm sorry Saturday 😔

severe gulch
#

this is like the first hard round

stable vessel
#

if saturday wins this then yall have no ears /hj

exotic reef
mental crag
#

but i really love choker

signal sierra
#

Saturday has ALWAYS been my favorite Andi will RIOTT if it loses.

runic hedge
#

Choker is great, but Saturday is generational. The song, and the music video being the only one with Tyler pink hair

exotic reef
#

i love saturday but i love choker more

bronze oriole
#

i’m stuck between choker and saturday 😔

vale wadi
bronze oriole
#

idk what to choose

mental crag
#

sorry i changed my vote to choker i just love it more

severe gulch
#

FUCK THIS ROUND IS HARD

umbral trail
#

choker clears

worthy smelt
limpid ledge
#

Come on, it is the day on the title of the song

signal sierra
#

I'm willing to hand fight anyone who voted for choker if choker wins

runic hedge
#

Choker by a mile

#

Although I do love Saturday

warm juniper
stable vessel
exotic reef
celest ore
#

i wanna watch friends with you

exotic reef
#

both are so good

severe gulch
lost oasis
#

what do people like about saturday? like what’s your favorite part of the song or favorite lyric

radiant hare
#

CHOKSWEEP

bronze oriole
#

my ah is gonna be sitting here the whole day trying to make up my mind

runic hedge
midnight trellis
#

this so hard

lost oasis
dry pagoda
#

id choose 2007 by jid decent song 7/10

trail horizon
#

I like choker

vital snow
#

I don't understand how Saturday won any rounds at all

runic hedge
jade blade
midnight trellis
exotic reef
warm juniper
lost oasis
radiant hare
dry pagoda
wise storm
#

choker sweeps

vital snow
tender dagger
severe gulch
#

i am in pain

stable vessel
#

saturday is repetitive as shi

dry pagoda
#

some short songs are more monotone than long songs making them feel longer

dry pagoda
#

are they longer

severe gulch
karmic edge
#

choker eas

stable vessel
#

genuinely just a 7/10 song

dry pagoda
#

no

radiant hare
#

This is basically the equivalent of Bandito vs The Craving but only SAI songs

exotic reef
dry pagoda
#

Good

stable vessel
#

i didnt say it was bad

errant agate
#

i can’t make up a sweep word for choker so i’ll just say choker sweep

jade blade
#

saturday is very good but choker describes me to a t

hexed thicket
#

Saturday is my least favorite on sai ill admit that but it doesn’t mean it’s bad

karmic edge
#

chsweepker

exotic reef
warm sierra
#

tyler literally made a music video as an analogy for saturday not hitting how he wanted it to

errant agate
vital snow
stable vessel
karmic edge
severe gulch
jade blade
stable vessel
#

repetitive music can still be good????

errant agate
hexed thicket
warm juniper
#

Mulberry street is fun but not saturday

runic hedge
severe gulch
devout wadi
#

i’m sorry i hate the bridge in choker but i like the rest of it

warm sierra
flint trellis
#

Choker is elite I fear

errant agate
signal sierra
#

Saturday will always have my vote nm the song it's against
-# the only one I would have to consider it with is redecorate

vital snow
hexed thicket
#

Leigh i wouldnt have said that i think they’re coming for you

flint trellis
#

Not my opinion but I respect it

stable vessel
#

aint no way yall are hating on someone who doesnt like the happy music on sai cause it feels forced

midnight trellis
frozen totem
#

choker

signal sierra
severe gulch
flint trellis
#

Trees rab 🫵🏻

velvet rivet
#

I dislike Saturday so I'm going for Choker

hexed thicket
signal sierra
flint trellis
#

Chokerrrrrr

vital snow
flint trellis
#

I love the meaning of that song

tender dagger
raw valley
#

Saturday is ok but Choker is just better

vital sphinx
#

These are my dancing shoes 🔥

warm sierra
#

i personally think in my opinion saturday is weak on the album, and i think it’s weak for the band, so im voting for choker

vital snow
#

I think they are both pretty weak songs

hexed thicket
#

choker means so much more to me then Saturday

runic hedge
tawdry skiff
#

Voted Choker ✅

raw valley
#

Saturday feels like a filler song

stable vessel
exotic reef
flint trellis
#

C'mon chokers outro is good

signal sierra
#

Choker and Saturday are both heavenly songs BUT Saturday 😩😩

severe gulch
#

if you hate saturday you just hate fun #sorrynotsorry #idontmaketherules

vital snow
flint trellis
#

Hot take: I prefer bounce man to Saturday 🫣

solemn coyote
#

Iiiiii know it’s ooover

rocky swan
#

I know it’s over, I was born a choker

runic hedge
solemn coyote
#

I love choker music video I always giggle

jade blade
#

ppl just don't like saturday because it's not emo enough for them

flint trellis
#

Ty for ur understanding

stable vessel
velvet rivet
#

Saturday just doesn't cut it for me, I'm just not the biggest fan of it's sound

warm juniper
flint trellis
#

I still understand the choker mv

#

Don't*

warm juniper
#

Jumpsuit retelling

stable vessel
#

choker is actually lyrically strong

signal sierra
raw valley
#

Saturday is fun but Choker just feels like more

signal sierra
#

I love Saturday.

severe gulch
stable vessel
#

and saturday only has the bridge cutting for it

severe gulch
#

ok it is thank god

stable vessel
solemn coyote
stable vessel
#

but the forced happiness is way too much on saturday

pseudo temple
#

but on saturday
saturday
saturday

WE SWEEP THE TOWN

#

uhhh choker will win and that's good

solemn coyote
#

I remember last year I was so obsessed with Saturday

stable vessel
solemn coyote
#

I learned it on guitar and saxophone 😭😭

pseudo temple
#

i kinda see the final battle
redecorate vs choker

severe gulch
#

can the sun just explode already idk which one to pick

signal sierra
vital snow
#

I didn't listen to SAI until I had gotten Clancy and decided to get SAI with it because I thought all of the songs would be like choker and Saturday

viscid spindleBOT
runic hedge
#

I gotta say when I first heard SAI, The Outside and Saturday were constantly fighting for my number one SAI song for like months on end. I eventually settled on The Outside but Saturday is forever my second favorite SAI song

stable vessel
#

eugh

warm juniper
severe gulch
pseudo temple
severe gulch
#

i settled on no chances but now years later its redecorate

stable vessel
#

like saturday is js slightly better than bounce man

runic hedge
stable vessel
#

but it will forever be number 10 on the sai ranking

stable vessel
vital snow
#

Ngl SAI just isn't as strong as the other albums and has few highlights

stable vessel
#

I KNOW WHAT FUN MUSIC IS

runic hedge
pseudo temple
#

i love mulberry street for the lyrics and its connection to redecorate

stable vessel
#

SATURDAY AINT IT

earnest sparrow
#

i absolutely love saturday but like come on

warm juniper
#

Mulberry street lyrics are my least fav because i dislike the literal meaning( like ik they mean the opposite of what they say i just dont like the literal meaning)

worthy agate
#

Choker

severe gulch
#

i still have not voted this is such a hard round for me wtf

hollow yacht
#

Nitrogen bomb vs coughing baby

pseudo temple
#

choker' strings and ♪uhmm♪

severe gulch
#

ok actually

earnest sparrow
severe gulch
#

on further thought

stable vessel
#

but actively voting saturday over choker is a domino effect cause soon you'll be willing to put saturday over redecorate

thin jolt
runic hedge
severe gulch
#

im so sorry to all my choker fans im voting saturday

stable vessel
#

guys are we just gonna

glass tendon
#

Sorry Choker has to be Saturday

stable vessel
#

like move over that

runic hedge
stable vessel
#

cause we definitely shouldn't

pseudo temple
#

redecorate is gonna win sai song battles

strong rover
#

never have i been so happy for a sweep (bounce man lost lmao)

earnest sparrow
#

ur making leaps and ur making bounds

#

BOOOOO

#

bounce man hate i’m OUT!!!

severe gulch
#

yippee

stable vessel
#

like this guy js said saturday over REDECORATE any day of the week

runic hedge
stable vessel
severe gulch
#

im sorry i love choker too 💔

runic hedge
severe gulch
#

but saturday is just sm fun

stable vessel
severe gulch
#

also the “i cant feel the waves anyMOOOOOORE”

severe gulch
#

and the high note. just. yas

pseudo temple
stable vessel
runic hedge
ivory peak
#

Choker

strong rover
#

personal vote is shy away best song on the album but prediction is redecorate winning it all by votes

ivory peak
lost oasis
# jade blade i need this emoji

i just found out the server i found this emoji in originally was deleted or something 😭 i can keep looking for a png file for you though lol

stable vessel
vital snow
#

I should have voted neither in hindsight

pseudo temple
pseudo temple
#

but lyrically.. meh

strong rover
stable vessel
#

verse 2 is some peak top writing

pseudo temple
runic hedge
severe gulch
strong rover
#

also idk why but the vibe i get is that midwest indigo is like the mulberry street of clancy

runic hedge
pseudo temple
stable vessel
#

redecorate's metaphors actually beat every song on sai

strong rover
pseudo temple
stable vessel
#

the bridge is some of his best flow

runic hedge
severe gulch
#

it doesn’t make sense 2 me it’s a whole different album with a different sound

warm juniper
#

I dont really like redecorate either but its better than saturday

stable vessel
strong rover
#

different album but the vibe is kind of similar

runic hedge
strong rover
stable vessel
#

genuine question

pseudo temple
rain oriole
#

it's saturday why would I not vote for saturday lol
not sure if it can sweep choker tho 😔

runic hedge
severe gulch
stable vessel
tacit flax
#

choker

stable vessel
warm juniper
#

I think redecorate lyrics are kinda cringe and i dont even know why i dont wanna be offensive

severe gulch
#

😵‍💫

strong rover
runic hedge
stable vessel
#

ok so u hear the music

sour topaz
#

easily choker

stable vessel
#

that makes your opinions make more sense

pseudo temple
tacit flax
#

choker best song in sai imo

strong rover
native ingot
#

Choker sweep

#

Sweeper

warm juniper
stable vessel
#

its quite simple

runic hedge
stable vessel
runic hedge
strong rover
#

it makes sense and im a guy that just hears the music, i need to watch video analysis to understand whats going on with the music

stable vessel
runic hedge
stable vessel
#

its ok dawg not everyone has to listen to the music bro

runic hedge
stable vessel
tender dagger
runic hedge
stable vessel
shadow ore
#

saturday

pseudo temple
#

GUYS calm down

strong rover
pseudo temple
#

that's the SONG battles

stable vessel
tender dagger
stable vessel
#

it's just do you feel the music and listen to it when its on or do you only hear the music

#

it cant be simpler than that

runic hedge
stable vessel
strong rover
humble stone
#

Im mad that choker beat good day so im plotting against it

stable vessel
#

sure ok

#

my favorite example is Tyler's newest album

unreal sail
#

actually kinda close

stable vessel
#

Don't Tap The Glass

unreal sail
#

theyre both MEDIOCRE

unreal sail
tender dagger
stable vessel
karmic edge
#

don’t tap the mid (have not listened)

rain oriole
#

Will we eventually be pitting the top songs from each album together or nah

strong rover
stable vessel
tender dagger
#

WE GOT GOOD DAY GANGS HERE

stable vessel
#

its mostly dance music

pseudo temple
stable vessel
#

you're supposed to hear the music

unreal sail
#

its so good

unreal sail
#

he made the album so that his fans could dance to it, forget about whats worrying them, and just have a good time

stable vessel
tender dagger
pseudo temple
# stable vessel yes

i always pay more attention to lyrics because i believe in the rule that a skilled songwriter is unlikely to write bad music to good lyrics

runic hedge
waxen wolf
#

YAY SATURDAY

pseudo temple
tender dagger
stable vessel
#

and vice versa

pseudo temple
strong rover
robust inlet
#

saturday has a place in my heart but I know it can't beat choker

I love both anyway, can't fight me out of either side

strong rover
#

i probably listen to encore more than mtbmb

stable vessel
# stable vessel no im not

im asking if you take the music in as a whole and FEEL it all or just hear it and have to either be explained to you or need to give something more listens

#

there's nothing wrong with js hearing the music

#

but a lot of ppl that ive met that only hear music tend to like the more generic pop sound

#

i say generic but pop isnt really generic

#

but its a lot of restriction to pop music

runic hedge
covert shadow
#

Choker imo

strong rover
stable vessel
#

not lyrically but definitely sound wise

runic hedge
#

So are you satisfied with my response

stable vessel
#

a lot of pop artists actually get ridiculed for attempting to change their sound

static belfry
#

saturday sweep

stable vessel
strong rover
stable vessel
runic hedge
cold locust
#

I KNOW ITS (not) OVER, YOU SHOULD VOTE CHOKER 🗣️

rustic steeple
#

SATURDAY

cold locust
rustic steeple
torpid bluff
#

SATURDAY

SATURDAY

SATURDAY

real sorrel
#

VOTE CHOKER !!

foggy plank
#

i voted choker so fast icl 💀

uncut pawn
#

choker 🔥🔥

iron trellis
#

I can’t not vote Saturday

#

This is heart breaking

#

I love choker

#

But Saturday

#

Like how do you not vote Saturday on Saturday

craggy kindle
#

I like that logic. Saturday it is for me

fervent kettle
#

WE PAINT THE TOWN heeheegiggle

swift bronze
#

Saturday was written for me I used to work in a paint factory on saturdays

short knoll
#

i literally don’t know what i’m voting for

vale lantern
#

i love saturday
catch me floating circles in my fishbowl heeheegiggle 💖
but i can’t vote against choker
i heart choker

humble bear
#

Easy choker

solemn stump
#

YOU CANT MAKE ME CHOOSE grief

twin elk
#

it's Choker easily

full plover
#

I WAS BORN A SWEEPER

tropic moon
#

saturday

#

not only is it banger it is not losing to anything but bounce man in my eyes

pseudo temple
#

choker is gonna win this one too

#

i wanna see no chances vs redecorate honestly

short knoll
exotic isle
#

this gonna be a tough decision

#

(votes for choker)

red ginkgo
#

Choker sweep, easy

red ginkgo
regal shell
#

choker

distant finch
#

Spotify streams for comparison

#

this does not indicate who will win

icy plank
#

idek if i like saturday 🫣 🤐

restive horizon
#

choker is 100% winning this but im happy to be on the underdogs side

lethal cobalt
#

choker sweep

jade scarab
#

Choker music video is so funny and the song is so good. But Saturday music video is a vibe (and is lore related) and the song is a bop.

#

How do I choose

hollow galleon
#

Sigh

#

I know its over 😞

frosty sand
#

even if it isn’t a direct lore mv

runic hare
#

Choker sweep

hard atlas
#

CHOKER CHOKER CHOKER I LOVE YOU CHOKER

twin elk
pseudo temple
#

and the
rearview only
blinds you

regal shell
#

I hate Saturday

#

Kill me if you want but I just cant stand it most of the time

final solar
#

I really dont like the chorus, its super cheesy and the song can feel repetitive because of it

#

Ironically enough I kinda vibe with the pre-chorus ("Catch me floatin' circles in my fishbowl"), but the chorus kills the song for me and IN MY OPINION the song is one of the bands' weakest tracks overall

hidden surge
frosty sand
#

what do you think are their top 5

#

and their bottom 5

#

legit just curious considering you think Saturday is that bad

final solar
# frosty sand what do you think are their top 5

Well, that's always a difficult question for me to answer since I feel like my most and least favorites generally depend on my mood/how I feel.
In terms of individual albums, for SAI, I'd say my most favorite songs would be Choker, No Chances, and Redecorate. Shy Away and The Outside are also somewhat up there, and Good Day to an extent. Least fav would be, well, Saturday, lol. But on a similar note I don't really listen to Never Take it; I don't think it's necessarily a bad song to be honest - I actually really like the lyrics and message - I just don't vibe with it that much sonically

eternal harness
#

go choker

lost oasis
buoyant flame
#

Had to click view threads to see this chat 😭

umbral trail
#

nahhh

static belfry
#

y’all dumb

eternal summit
#

I actually can't pick grief

exotic copper
#

naw wtf

#

no way yall actually like choker more than saturday

runic hedge
#

Ugh

tacit flax
static belfry
oblique latch
#

its so good

umbral trail
#

choker sweeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep

sour topaz
#

this was actually so deserved

waxen wolf
#

booooo

torpid bluff
#

BOOO yall are fun haters

odd ember
#

what the fucki hate u guys