2025 Scaled And Icy Song Battle #4

[robust plaza]

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1754578800:R>

[shut plaza]

Formidable pls pls pls

[pastel saddle]

No Chances all the way

[hazy stag]

Easily formidable

[fair prairie]

i'm sorry my beloved formidable

[oblique haven]

Voting Formidable, but I expect No Chances to win

[fervent moss]

no chances all the way

[sturdy flume]

no chances clears

[frank aurora]

FORMIDABLE

[velvet geyser]

no chances more like NO CHANCE OF FORMIDABLE WINNING THIS ONE

[bitter shuttle]

FORMIDABLE SWEEP

[true shore]

no chances

[modest jolt]

no chances

ez

[severe sluice]

formidable top bottom tracks of the two

[wanton ledge]

it’s no chances for me but i won’t be mad if formidable won

[lethal shore]

voting for formidable but it has no chances

[last pelican]

I don't like both songs all too much, but even then I go back to No Chances more.

[dry dock]

This is a joke of a poll see you tomorrow when no chances wins by 2000

[polar eagle]

No chances 🗣️

[hasty light]

whatever tf people are saying here yeah

[wide plank]

formidable

[fervent moss]

its a mix of formidable and no chances

[sturdy flume]

Nofcormidahblea clears

[hasty light]

formidable i am rooting for u

[bitter shuttle]

Formidable haters in full swing damn 🥀

[stuck spear]

Probably my two favs but formidable is number 1 always

[exotic cipher]

underrated masterpiece vs underrated masterpiece

[cold chasm]

whatever floats your boat man

[shut plaza]

No chances is difficult for me bc I really like the “NO CHAAAANCES” and “we want you home in one piece” parts and the instrumental but it’s one of my least fave Tyler raps

[silver zenith]

NO CHANCES

[cold chasm]

both are good

[autumn iris]

NO CHANCES

[quiet condor]

im a formidable defender im voting for it

[oblique haven]

Formidable is the most underrated TOP song

[silver zenith]

NO CHANCES

[fervent moss]

i dont hate formidable but no chances is better

[olive sable]

Song is so special to me

[bitter shuttle]

Formidable is top 3 jenna songs IMO

[calm quiver]

no chances has no chance

[bitter shuttle]

Maybe top 2

[sage moon]

NOOOOO formidable is so so special to me but it has no chances 💔

[wide plank]

guys we should quit arguing and all listen to SELF-iSH by will wood and the tapeworms

[sturdy flume]

formidable is pretty mid but still underrated imo

[olive sable]

But I can’t lie I don’t think it’s gonna win 💔

[stuck spear]

This

[acoustic lake]

cant pick

[frosty otter]

diabolical

[livid pawn]

no chances

[sturdy flume]

quadeca 🔥

[acoustic lake]

formidable is such a sentimental song

[wide plank]

that too

[hoary needle]

I don't like formidable I'm sorry 😞

[hazy stag]

Formidable has the greatest beginning ever

[wide plank]

VHS by quadeca

[dark anvil]

i love formidable

[obsidian jetty]

This is one of the most difficult choices I’ve had to make in this whole battle

[calm quiver]

i love the song battles bc i reminds me i don’t have bad takes 🫶🏻

[bitter shuttle]

No chances is criminally underrated as well

[fallow merlin]

oughh formidable

[strong drum]

this album as a whole is very iffy imo✌️

[lofty pendant]

WE COME FOR YOUUUU
NOOO CHAAAAANCES

[abstract sequoia]

FORMIDABLE MY BELOVED

[bitter shuttle]

Why are they pitting 2 bad bitches against each other </3

[mint basin]

WE COME FOR YOU 🚨

[fallow merlin]

literally my favorite somg on the album

[shut plaza]

The beginning feels like a sunny spring day to me, I can’t explain

[fallow merlin]

against no chances

[acoustic lake]

i'll pick formidable cause no chances is probably gonna win

[bitter shuttle]

Formidable sweep plz

[fallow merlin]

this is tragic

[sturdy flume]

contender for aoty (breach looks promising though)

[abstract sequoia]

I BEG FORMIDABLE WINS

PLEASE

[fallow merlin]

i love all the sai songs dude 😭

[wanton coral]

Eh I don't feel strongly for either

[sage moon]

IT WONT LET ME VOTE FOR FORMIDABLE
WHAT DO YOU MEAN "this interaction failed" 😭

[abstract sequoia]

PLEASE

FORMIDABLE

[whole barn]

Close out the app and then try again

[bitter shuttle]

Lowkey no chances has a really good "vibe" but as a song its not my favorite i dislike the chorus

[fallow merlin]

KEEP TRYING IT'LL WORK

[keen anvil]

Formidable is my pick.

[bitter shuttle]

Formidable top 3 jenna songs

[dark anvil]

formidable is my favourite jenna song :)

[abstract sequoia]

BEST JENNA SONG

FORMIDABLE PLEASE

FORMIDABLE SWEEP

[exotic cipher]

i think i gotta go with no chances, formidable is very underrated but i love when they get weird and experimental ad no chances is pro ably their most experimental song, along with pet cheetah

[sage moon]

Finally

[abstract sequoia]

FORMIDABLE FTW

[lofty forum]

No chances for me, the beat, the chorus, it’s dope. Formidable is meh, it’s a skip for me most of the time 🥲

[sage moon]

This is rigged

[abstract sequoia]

NOOOOO

[dull moon]

No Chances

[fallow merlin]

formidable has made me cry and not many songs can do that

[wanton coral]

I havent listened to them in a while

[abstract sequoia]

FORMIDABLE PLEASE

[harsh nacelle]

NO CHANCES

[wispy terrace]

Formidable is my fav song

[knotty smelt]

no chances probably

[abstract sequoia]

PLEASE NO

[bitter shuttle]

Its definitely up there

[abstract sequoia]

FORMIDABLE CANT LOOSE THIS EARLY

[stiff relic]

my hot take today is no chances is poop

[bitter shuttle]

1.5th place for me

Second feels too low

[sacred tinsel]

https://tenor.com/view/family-guy-peter-griffin-head-shake-no-chance-nope-gif-17521786

[abstract sequoia]

FORMIDABLE FTW

[fallow merlin]

i will not be super upset if no chances wins but i WILL be so fucking stoked if formidable wins

[bitter shuttle]

Very fair take

[abstract sequoia]

justice for formidable

[bitter shuttle]

No chances has one of the best "vibes" of a song i just cant explain it

The atmosphere feels good to me

[fallow merlin]

yeah that's very true

[dark thorn]

I love this

[bitter shuttle]

I find the chorus somewhat annoying but the "aura" it gives off is great

[fallow merlin]

valid so true

[wanton coral]

I gotta listen to them again

[drowsy portal]

FORMIDABLE

[fallow merlin]

i’m voting for formidable but no chances is so good for exactly that reason

[bitter shuttle]

Both these songs should win

[vital minnow]

IM SO SORRY FORMIDABLE BUT NO CHANCES HAS TO WIN

[drowsy portal]

No chances is so good but I feel like formidable is so underrated

[bitter shuttle]

Why couldnt they face like good day instead of each other smh

[elfin vessel]

i have to vote formidable but this is so tragic

[abstract sequoia]

YEAH YEAH I CAN DIEEE WITH YOU

[wanton coral]

I remember liking formidable more, but we'll see

[vital minnow]

yall are convincing me to choose formidable

i’ve changed 😔

[fallow merlin]

omg should i change my dn to theformidablerabbid

[wanton coral]

Okay I like this more than I remember

[robust plaza]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 1!

[abstract sequoia]

YESSS

[fallow merlin]

that’s kinda clever

[bitter shuttle]

Both are the most underrated songs from this album i think this is heartbreaking seeding

[vital minnow]

YAYAYA

[wanton coral]

https://tenor.com/view/love-gif-12659694221793289748

[wanton ledge]

i’m voting for no chances but i ADORE formidable and i wouldn’t at all be mad if it won

[abstract sequoia]

YOU ARE FORMIDABLE TO ME

[lone rapids]

NO CHANCES IS SO GOOD

[nocturne cave]

Oh no

I love formidable but like

[abstract sequoia]

CAUSE YOU SEEM TO KNOW IT WHERE YOU WANNA GO

[nocturne cave]

No chances😔

[loud kiln]

FORMIDABLE ON TOP

[silver zenith]

NO CHANCES

[wanton ledge]

no chances was my most played song when sai came out

[silver zenith]

IT'S LORE RELATED AND GOES SOOOOO HARD

[abstract sequoia]

YEAH YEAH YEAH I'LL FOLLOW YOU

[silver zenith]

Formidable is my least favorite Jenna song

[wanton coral]

I like guys

[steel moat]

No chances should win

[wanton ledge]

same

[wooden siren]

whoever votes formidable

im coming for you. no chances.

[steel moat]

Same

[abstract sequoia]

BUT YOU SHOULD KNOW I MIGHT BE CYNICAL TOWARD YOU

[lone rapids]

WE COME FOR YOU 🚨

[abstract sequoia]

IM JUST WORRIED MY LOYALTY WILL BORE YOU

[wooden siren]

NO CHANCES

[carmine sparrow]

ima have to say no chances

[upper sage]

WE COME FOR YOUUUUUUUU

[wanton ledge]

i expected to see a lot more formidable love in this chat wow

[bitter shuttle]

https://tenor.com/view/blackbeard-blackbeard-writing-taking-notes-writing-gif-17583038544116987898

[abstract sequoia]

YEAH YEAH YEAH I CAN DIE WITH YOU

[wanton coral]

okay time to listen to no chances again

[wooden siren]

I love formidable but no chances tops it 😔

[abstract sequoia]

PLEAASEEE

[upper sage]

FEET PLANTED ON GRIP TAPE WIT MY SHOULDERS SQUARED AND MY BACK STRAIGHT

[bitter shuttle]

No chances x formidable yaoi

[fallow merlin]

formidable is so important to me

no chances is an amazing song

[upper sage]

IN THIS HOUSE WE GOT FENG SHUI

[abstract sequoia]

FORMIDABLE FTW

[glacial tapir]

no chansweep

[abstract sequoia]

I WONT BREAK YOUR HEART IF YOU CAN BREAK MY SPELL

[bitter shuttle]

This seeding feels illegal

[hasty light]

formidable is just better

[bitter shuttle]

Stop the count we need a redistricting of the bracket please 🫵

Why did discord send a fist

Wtf

[glacial tapir]

atrocious take

[bitter shuttle]

Broken app

[wanton coral]

Yeah I like formidable way more

[abstract sequoia]

if formidable looses its already justice for oldies dawg

[wanton coral]

No chances is a bit better than I remember though

[abstract sequoia]

PLEAASEE

[hasty light]

the only good part of no chances is the beginning

[bitter shuttle]

No chances is fire im not denying

[wanton ledge]

this chat is making me think that there’s “no chances” that formidable will win 😂😂😂😂😂😂 please laugh guys

[sudden night]

YOU ARE FORMIDABLE TO ME

[hasty light]

i feel like it could’ve been so much better

[bitter shuttle]

But formidable is at least top 2 jenna songs

[wanton coral]

https://tenor.com/view/frisk-undertale-congratulations-confetti-good-job-gif-13726832184032736667

[sudden night]

no chances is the least good song on SAI

[hasty light]

i shed a tear

[wanton ledge]

i hate whatever this gif is

[hasty light]

without a doubt

[bitter shuttle]

Good day is right there 🥀

[gentle rover]

FORMIDABLE BABYYYYYYYY

[hasty light]

GOOD DAY IS A GOOD SOMG

[abstract sequoia]

YEAH YEAH YEAH I CAN DIE WITH YOU JUST LET ME KNOW

[sudden night]

GOOD DAY IS AMAZING

[hasty light]

I ENJOY IT

[wanton coral]

______. ___

[hasty light]

THAT SONG IS ME

[abstract sequoia]

bounce man is right there dawg

[sudden night]

keemstar... bald...

[gentle tulip]

Formidable had better win here

[bitter shuttle]

Good day is mid as hell, if there is 1 top song im gonna hate its good day

[hasty light]

AND BOUNCE MAN IS GOOD TOO

[wanton ledge]

is this morse code

[bitter shuttle]

True forgot bounce man

[hasty light]

it took me a really long time to enjoy bounce man

[bitter shuttle]

Bounce man also mid

[gentle tulip]

best Jenna song vs a decent hype track

[hasty light]

but i like it now

[wanton coral]

It's not posting the spaces bro

[gentle tulip]

Formidable is fantastiv

[sudden night]

BOUNCE MAN IS FUNNY

[bitter shuttle]

Bounceman is lavish but somrhow even LESS replayable

[sudden night]

i used to not like it

but its fun to listen to it

[gentle tulip]

I MIGHT BE CYNICAL TOWARDS YOU

[wanton coral]

GOD

[gentle rover]

formidable has to win i need it to 😔

[sudden night]

OMG A NIN FAN

[wanton ledge]

isn’t bounce man about ned getting deported

[hybrid brook]

PLEASEEE FORMIDABLE

[wanton coral]

BOUNCE MA

[hybrid brook]

HELP WHAT

[hasty light]

it took me like 3 years to warm up to scaled and icy

[gentle tulip]

Formidable HAS to take the dub here please y'all

[wanton coral]

I'M TRYING TO SAY BOUNCE MAN

[snow gust]

fromdable

[abstract sequoia]

FAST FOWARD THIRTEEN YEARS NOW DONT KNOW WHAT IT WAS BUT SOMEHOW WE PLAYED IN REVERS IM AFRAID OF YOU KNOW MORE THAT I WAS AT FIRST

[gentle tulip]

AND I KNOW

[snow gust]

no chances of it winning the battle

[gentle tulip]

THAT WE JUST MET

[wanton coral]

yaaay nin

[gentle tulip]

BUT CAN I TAKE YOU EVERYWHERE WEVE EVER BEEN

I WANNA SEE IT ALL

NO SURPRISES

[abstract sequoia]

OH OH

[wanton coral]

I have been tortured with bounce man

[fallow merlin]

it makes me reallybhappy that this discussion is mostly people loving songs and not hating on songs

[abstract sequoia]

YOU ARE FORMIDABLE TO ME

[robust bridge]

WE COME FOR YOUU

[wanton coral]

I want to see it BURN

[gentle tulip]

CAUSE YOU SEEM TO KNOW OT WHERE YOU WANNA GO

YEAH YEAH YEAH

ILL FOLLOW YOU

[hazy yoke]

I love formidable but no chances is SO GOOD 😭

[gentle tulip]

but have you considered

JUST LET ME KNOW

[robust bridge]

NO CHANCESS

[bitter shuttle]

The worst twenty one pilots song is still better than anyb

[gentle tulip]

BUM DADUM DUMDUM

[bitter shuttle]

Idk whats a bad act

MGK song

[abstract sequoia]

no chances is a good song but..

[gentle tulip]

not true, MGK has at least 2 songs that are better than lane boy

[abstract sequoia]

YOU ARE FORMIDABLE TO ME

[wanton ledge]

hydrogen bomb vs coughing baby

[fallow merlin]

what does that have to do with this 😭

[snow vale]

KEEP LANE BOY'S NAME OUT YOUR SLANDERING MOUTH

[wanton coral]

why are we talking about #him

[gentle tulip]

I will not it's the worst song on Blurryface and the worst tøp song post-RAB

[bitter shuttle]

The discussion is going to naturally revolve arouns "which one is more enjoyable" and not "which song is worse to listen to"

[hasty light]

it’s just that no chances has maybw 10 seconds of good music for every 60 seconds of Whatamilistneingto whereas i feel formidable is really nice the whole way through

[wanton ledge]

you just don’t like drum & bass

[deep surge]

NOOOOO CHANCESSSSS

[abstract sequoia]

no chances is a good song

[hasty light]

it all comes down to personal taste

[snow vale]

REAL SHIT

[deep surge]

NO CHANCES IS SO COOD

[fallow merlin]

these song battle threads tend to be very much just hating on songs 😭 at least the ones i’ve been in

[hasty light]

and i guess everyone has their own connection to whichever track

[snow vale]

ugh i love lane boy

[bitter shuttle]

Lane boy and fairly local is fire

[gentle tulip]

No Chances is a fun cool song that makes you feel a bit like Batman. but Formidable is a fantastic love jam that really efficiently explores a relatively unexplored area of romance in love songs

[hasty light]

FAIRLY LOCAL IS AOOOGOOD

[deep surge]

MY FAVS

[gentle tulip]

it's effective and a bop

[bitter shuttle]

Lane boy has 1 lyric that comes off as kinda cringy now but other than that its a goated song

[deep surge]

IM FAIRLY LOCAL

[gentle tulip]

untrue I like drum and bass I just don't like bad writing

[fallow merlin]

and i hate that this is true

[hasty light]

lane boy would’ve been great if it weren’t for that huge instrumental break

[deep surge]

i wasn’t raised in the hood?

[abstract sequoia]

i love sai so much its actually so crazy

[hasty light]

maybe i’ll warm up to it eventually but like Eh

[wanton coral]

Lane Boy got that one line that screws it over for me, but I still enjoy it more than ||b0*nc3 m4n||

[wanton ledge]

my favorite yt channel put lane boy in one of their worst songs of all time videos im not living for the lane boy slander any longer

[deep surge]

EXCUSE ME

BOUNCE MAN IS AMAZING

[abstract sequoia]

NO

[bitter shuttle]

Ermm... based department????

[wanton ledge]

no way we’re censoring bounce man like it’s a slur

[hasty light]

YES

[wanton ledge]

it’s not that deep

[fickle crystal]

Formidable my baby 🛐 Love you No Chances but I love love and this is parental and platonic love so yeah

[abstract sequoia]

its unhealthy

[wanton coral]

you don't understand the psychological torment that song has brought me

[deep surge]

YES

[hasty light]

except idk about the batman part

[abstract sequoia]

NNNNNNNNNO

[deep surge]

BUT ITS SUCH A BANGER

[abstract sequoia]

BOUNCE MAN IS ASS

IDC

[hasty light]

bounce man is a fun song

[gentle tulip]

as time goes on I've loved it more and more tbh. Def better than Blurryface but I can't put it above my top 3 cause personal reasons

[hasty light]

i like the background vocals

[deep surge]

YEEEEEEERRRRRSSSSSSSSSSS

[fallow merlin]

bounce man is a great song :(

[acoustic sky]

Formidable sweep

[hasty light]

when it’s likeladadlaaaaaladadadasaaa

[fallow merlin]

all sai is so good

[deep surge]

I LOVE SCALED AND ICY ITS MY JOINT FAVOURITE WITH CLANCY JUST BEFORE ST

[bitter shuttle]

I personally dont find it super grating listwning alone but. It feels cringy when listening with other people? If that makes sense

[abstract sequoia]

BOUNCE MAN HAS MADE ME SAD MULTIPLE TIMES

[astral stream]

WE COME FOR YOUUUU🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[gentle tulip]

except for never take it

[wanton ledge]

if you don’t like bounce man you just have no joy and whimsy in your life. you don’t frolick around in fields. i don’t make the rules

[bitter shuttle]

Self titled my beloved

[fringe acorn]

https://tenor.com/view/twenty-one-pilots-tyler-joseph-josh-dun-you-should-bounce-bounce-you-should-bounce-gif-17578184892695173678

[fallow merlin]

i like never take it honestly :,)

[deep surge]

BOO FUCKING HOO

[wanton coral]

Or maybe I just like better joyous music

[fallow merlin]

i like all of them

[hasty light]

oh my gurt yes

[wanton coral]

https://tenor.com/view/frisk-undertale-congratulations-confetti-good-job-gif-13726832184032736667

[bitter shuttle]

Self titled is extremely fucking inconsistent but it has 2 of their best songs

[deep surge]

https://tenor.com/view/twenty-one-pilots-tyler-joseph-josh-dun-you-should-bounce-bounce-you-should-bounce-gif-17578184892695173678

[coral cipher]

please win formidable i need formidable to win

[abstract sequoia]

BOUNCE MAN IS HORRIBLE

[royal viper]

NO CHANCES

[deep surge]

ITS SO GOOD THOUGH

[hasty light]

self titled has fall away and air catcher

[deep surge]

can you stop seriously the convo is over

[hasty light]

and taxi cab

[abstract sequoia]

WHICH

[deep surge]

MY FAV

[gentle tulip]

bounce man is chill but it's also nothing special and that's okay. it works as a fun song but it's really nothing past that. filler track on the album for sure but also not terrible

[hasty light]

and oh ms believer but that song makes me cry so i can’t listen to it

[fallow merlin]

i love self titled

[bitter shuttle]

As an album i put it lower than the likes of sai and clancy and vessel bc half the songs i just dont ever listen to

[hasty light]

self titled also has trapdoor

which is so good

[abstract sequoia]

air catcher gets ruined by the autotune part

[wanton ledge]

AND isle of flightless birds AND a car a torch a death AND addict with a pen AND friend please AND march to the sea

[hasty light]

but air catcher is my favorite on that album

[fringe acorn]

i like all of sai cos i like listening to tøp in general :DD

[bitter shuttle]

Fall Away and Trapdoor

[fallow merlin]

i love tøp!!!!!!!!!! all of it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[wanton ledge]

why are yall forgetting those songs

[hasty light]

i warmed up to it really quick

it’s one of my favorite parts

now

[bitter shuttle]

Trapdoor top 1 song

[fallow merlin]

rahhh!!!!!!!!!!

[wanton ledge]

i love the air catcher autotune so much

[hasty light]

I ALSO LIKE ISLE OF FLIGHTLESS BIRDS A LOT

it has a fun instrumental

[fringe acorn]

YEYSYEYYSYEYEYSYSHESSYEYSS

[bitter shuttle]

Idk what it is trapdoor just does somethin to me man

[gentle tulip]

I put it lower than most of their modern albums because a) no Josh Dun and b) Tyler could not rap yet and it actively hurts my ears

[hasty light]

trapdoor has really good vocals and i like the lyrics

[fringe acorn]

iofb is my top played song

[olive prairie]

Sorry No Chances you just don’t understand how peak that lovely song is

[wanton ledge]

also idc air catcher was DESIGNED to be played live. it’s the song i wanna see be played live more than anything

[deep surge]

these are my fav from ST

[gentle tulip]

it feels like a live recording already

[bitter shuttle]

Trapdoor is fucking heavenly

[wanton coral]

Self titled solos sai

[deep surge]

they all are

[fading night]

NO SWEEP

[deep surge]

i jsut like those the most

[hasty light]

IMPLICIT IS ALSO SO GOOD

[abstract sequoia]

hell no

[fading night]

SWEEP CHANCES

[deep surge]

YESSS

[abstract sequoia]

hell no

[gentle tulip]

yes because it won't

[hasty light]

I’m a really big fan of the heavy piano stuff in self titled

[bitter shuttle]

I know that part of the band isnt part of it anymore but the harmonization on trap door does things to me

[hasty light]

idk how to explain it

[wanton coral]

I agree, there shall be no sweep

[wanton ledge]

my top 3 from st are
1 isle of flightless birds
2 taxi cab
3 air catcher

[fringe acorn]

i will make u believe u r lovely !

[deep surge]

WAIT I READ THIS WRONG

[fading night]

😭

[royal viper]

valid af

[deep surge]

YES

[gentle tulip]

sai

[deep surge]

NO CHABCES IS SO GOOD

[bitter shuttle]

Also sleeper pick

[hasty light]

idk if this is sai but hellywah

[olive prairie]

Chances of sweep? Nah, Formidable is guaranteed sweep.

[bitter shuttle]

March to the sea is fire

[wanton ledge]

oh im

[fading night]

I was just attacked

[hasty light]

LMAO

[fading night]

NO

[gentle tulip]

my fav on self titled is friend please, pretty easily

[wanton ledge]

i just woke up 30 minutes ago cut me some slack

[wanton coral]

https://tenor.com/view/trent-reznor-trunt-nuke-trunt-nuke-nine-inch-nails-gif-13813864890580222225

[olive prairie]

Formidisweep 🙁

[fringe acorn]

MINE ARE THE SAME but instead of taxi cab its addict with a pen 💔

[fading night]

fr

[fading night]

heck yes

[hasty light]

THE WOULD YOU LET ME KNOW PART IS SOOOO GOOOOD

it makes it unskippable

i really like self titled

[fading night]

💀

[gentle tulip]

friend please is what would happen if at the risk of feeling dumb was done well

[royal viper]

mine are:

Taxi Cab
IDFP
Trapdoor

[abstract sequoia]

friend please is very much skipable

[deep surge]

i cried to these that’s why they’re my favourite they’re so beautiful

[wanton ledge]

friend please was the first self titled song i ever heard because of. that video

[olive prairie]

DEADASS DEADASS DEADASS OH MY GOD FRIEND PLEASE BRIDGE RECOGNITION

[obtuse viper]

WE COME FOR YOU

[deep surge]

it’s alr

[abstract sequoia]

i wont do it but it can be done

[bitter shuttle]

I get why the singing is beautiful there as well

[deep surge]

johnny boy and oh ms believer is alr

[fringe acorn]

i voted formidable too

[gentle tulip]

it's just lyrically very far above most of the rest of self titled

[hasty light]

JOHNNY BOU

[olive prairie]

Woah woah woah slow down Buster

[hasty light]

I FORGOT ABOUT THAT ONE

[wanton ledge]

i cant watch that animatic anymore it gives me a reaction

[deep surge]

i do love friend please but i gotta be in the mood

[hasty light]

ONE OF MY FAVS

[gentle tulip]

nope

[olive prairie]

I love you

[deep surge]

EXCUSE ME

[abstract sequoia]

IF YOU VOTED FORMIDABLE UPVOTE THIS MESSAGE

[fading night]

“WE COME FOR YOU, NO CHANCES”

[deep surge]

WE COME FOR YOU

[deep surge]

same wavelength

[olive prairie]

We cone for you

[bitter shuttle]

Any MTTS lovers in chat

[fringe acorn]

hunga y r u listening to friend please its not even noon yet

[gentle tulip]

Me me pick me

[abstract sequoia]

What does that stand for

[fading night]

No Chances coming for Formidable

[wanton coral]

tf is mtts

[olive prairie]

Unfortunately No Chances is actually a really good song but Formidable is just that much better

[bitter shuttle]

March to the sea

[olive prairie]

HAI :DDDDD

[gentle tulip]

march to the sea

[wanton coral]

Ah

[ripe tendon]

Formidable is like my favourite jenna song

Is it a jenna song? It has to be right?

[olive prairie]

Check Nest

Rn

[gentle tulip]

yes it is the best Jenna song

[bitter shuttle]

March to the sea has gotta be the most underrated ST song

[abstract sequoia]

oh yeah no im not an mtts lover then

[ripe tendon]

YESSSS

[tender dew]

I love formidable so much but its about to get curb stomped isn’t it 💔

[deep surge]

i like no chances BECAUSE of the bit that’s like “we want you home in one piece now, run away run away”

[edgy raft]

no chances obv going to win but i lksten to formidable more and no chances just feels like walmart trench

[ripe tendon]

SOOOO TRUE I WAS SO SAD IT LOST ITS FIRST BATTLE

[gentle tulip]

that's the worst part

[deep surge]

THE CRAVING JV

[abstract sequoia]

no

[wanton coral]

that's so true

https://tenor.com/view/trent-reznor-trunt-nuke-trunt-nuke-nine-inch-nails-gif-13813864890580222225

[deep surge]

WHAT

[ripe tendon]

The craving is good too !

[deep surge]

it made me cry a bit too much hehe

[olive prairie]

UES OH MT GOSH ITS THE BEST OF THE OBLIGATORY LOVE SONGS :DDD

[fading night]

Guys but No Chances just has better lyrics than Formidable

[olive prairie]

I love this message

[deep surge]

i do love formidable

don’t get me wrong

[fading night]

FENG SHUI

[ripe tendon]

Formidable is just like relatable to me

[deep surge]

i love all of scaled and icy

[deep surge]

lucky you then

[fringe acorn]

i prefer the craving but yeah formidable is up there WE UP

[olive prairie]

Clearly you’ve never found yourself in a whimsy romance before 🤬🤬🤬🤬

[deep surge]

ooh arcane fan hurro

[deep surge]

[bitter shuttle]

March to the sea is top 5 maybe even top 3 on self titled for me tbh

Depends on the day

[fading night]

“We get bodies (like formidable) all day, we want you home in one piece now”

[gentle tulip]

it is more interesting lyrically but it also doesn't explore unique themes as efficiently and sensitively as Formidable does. Formidable exemplifies the idea of feeling intimidated by someone that you love because of how awesome they are in a really succinct and beautiful way, and regardless of how much visual language No Chances has it doesn't have that

[abstract sequoia]

YOU ARE FORMIDABLE TO ME 'CAUSE YOU SEEM TO KNOW IT WHERE YOU WANNA GO YEAH YEAH YEAH ILL FOLLOW YOU BUT YOU SHOULD KNOW I MIGHT BE CLINICAL, DONT YOU TELL I WONT BREAK YOUR HEART IF YOU CAN BREAK MY SPELL YEAH YEAH YEAH I CAN DIE WITH YOU DADA DA DA

[fading night]

Clearly you’re lying cause I just recently got out of my first relationship😭😭

[bitter shuttle]

Well put

[deep surge]

IN THIS HOUSE ARE SRE FENG SHUI

[bitter shuttle]

Its a unique theme for a song i feel like

[deep surge]

:P

[olive prairie]

I WONT BREAK YOUR HEART IF YOU CAN BREAK MY SPELL ugh

[bitter shuttle]

"Love" maybe not but they specific message of it

[deep surge]

i didn’t like no chances at first tbut now i want it to win if redecorate loses

[fading night]

ykw, I’ll agree with this.

[deep surge]

STOP YOURE GONNA MAKE ME CHANGE MY VOTE

[abstract sequoia]

JUST LET ME KNOW

[fading night]

Guys please let Redecorate win SAI

please

I’m begging

[olive prairie]

Well CLEARLY it wasn’t whimsy enough 🤬🤬🤬🤬 /silly

[abstract sequoia]

IDC ABOUT REDECORATE FORMIDABLE JUST HAS TO WIN

PLEASE

[fringe acorn]

i want good day to come second that would be funny

not gonna happen but

[olive prairie]

Make the right decision

[bitter shuttle]

I will say no chances is better for a "vibe" as formidable sounds kinda generic poppy

[fading night]

lol

[bitter shuttle]

But i still pick formidable best jenna song

[olive prairie]

I LOVE YOU

[deep surge]

OMG YES

I WANT REDECORATE TO WIN

[wanton coral]

No chances makes me wish I was listening to Trench instead

[deep surge]

I DONT WANNA GO LIKE THUS

[tardy aspen]

Lol this chat is crazy

[deep surge]

:/

[fading night]

Look idrc abt this fight cause both songs cook but we need to let Redecorate win SAI

and if it doesn’t, this Discord clique is controlled

[abstract sequoia]

I MIGHT BE CYNICAL TOWARDS YOU IM JUST WORRIED MY LOYALTY WILL BORE YOU YEAH YEAH YEAH I CAN DIEEE WITH YOU JUST LET ME KNOW

[fringe acorn]

dema 😰😰😰😰

[abstract sequoia]

CHANGE YOUR VOTE TO FORMIDABLE PLEASE

[deep surge]

redecorate, having very clear lyrics on what it’s about

the clique: TRANS 🏳️‍⚧️

[fading night]

😭

[wanton coral]

Dema DOES control us!!

[deep surge]

real.

[forest rivet]

eal.

[fading night]

thats crazy

[fringe acorn]

sai cover is trans colors too tho its all coded trust

[bitter shuttle]

Redecorate i feel like is overrated kinda but its still an amazing song

[modest jolt]

no chances sweep

[wanton ledge]

i can understand why ppl think that tbh

[deep surge]

IKKKKK OTS WHAT IVE BEEN SAYINGGG

[bitter shuttle]

I wouldnt instantly put it leagues above every other sai song but in contention for top sai song yeah id say so

[deep surge]

YOUR NAME >>>>>>>

[wanton coral]

Redecorate is so glazed, but I like it a decent amount so idc

[deep surge]

it makes me cryyyy it’s so good

[olive prairie]

I’M JUST WORRIED music cuts MY LOYALTY WILL BORE YOU

[deep surge]

AND THE MEANING

[bitter shuttle]

Real and same

Its a little overloved but im not complaining

[deep surge]

IF YOU FONT KNOW EHY TYLER EROTE IT GO FIND OUT

[fading night]

“AN OBJECT IN MOTION” will always stay in motion🤓

[deep surge]

BEFORE I CRY

[bitter shuttle]

Better than receiving no love

[deep surge]

HELP ME

[wanton ledge]

as much as i love it i have trauma from formidable because. im pretty sure everyone here already knows ive mentioned it several times

[deep surge]

I QUOTE THAT SO OFTEN

[abstract sequoia]

FORMIDABLE PLEASE

[fading night]

INERTIA

I love the song and the actual scientific fact

[abstract sequoia]

FORMIDABLE FTW

[bitter shuttle]

Other than MTTS getting destroyed like 50 votes to 5k

I think glowing eyes not winning rab is a major let down

[jovial inlet]

WE COME FOR YOUU

[olive prairie]

Radiohead mention

[abstract sequoia]

Yeah that was crazy

[bitter shuttle]

Maybe if it reached the final i would be content

[wanton coral]

https://tenor.com/view/marvel-fan4stic-fantastic-four-the-thing-say-that-again-gif-9345984830195785978

[bitter shuttle]

But losing to kitchen sink? </3

[abstract sequoia]

sleeptoken pfp?

[olive prairie]

[olive prairie]

EXCUSE YOU

[abstract sequoia]

WILL YOU HALT THIS ECLIPSE IN ME

[olive prairie]

Kitchen Sink is unfortunately my favourite RAB song

[wanton ledge]

im slow i forgot whats mtts

[bitter shuttle]

Ima say it

[olive prairie]

I could sing the whole song by May 10th quit it

[bitter shuttle]

I could not care for the brother rap in kitchen sink </3

[fallow merlin]

my top favorite 3 songs from every album cus i feel like listing them for funsies

rab: lovely, kitchen sink, ruby
self titled: fall away, trapdoor, johnny boy
vessel: ode to sleep, guns for hands, migraine
blurryface: lane boy, heavydirtysoul, tear in my heart
trench: smithereens, jumpsuit, pet cheetah
sai: formidable, mulberry street, good day
clancy: vignette, backslide, oldies station

i don’t know npi good enough yet and breach doesn’t have 3 songs yet 💔

[olive prairie]

March To The Sea the most underrated S/T song

[wanton ledge]

OH

[fallow merlin]

i’ve been typing that for a while lmao

[mental glade]

Formidable ❤️

[bitter shuttle]

March to the sea

[wanton ledge]

whoopsies

[scenic jewel]

NOOOO THESE ARE MY TWO FAVES OFF SAI SHEHEJEKEKELEO

[abstract sequoia]

FORMIDABLE PLEASE

[bitter shuttle]

Forest and glowing eyes not being in top 3 for rab is crazy but you redeem yourself with the fall away and trapdoor nods

Acceptable...

[abstract sequoia]

oldies station mentioned

[fallow merlin]

that’s valid tbh i do love forest and glowing eyes

[bitter shuttle]

Nevermind good day top 3 on sai 🥀

Ill never not be a good day hater

[fallow merlin]

💔

[bitter shuttle]

Im allowed to hate 1 song. As a treat

Just one

[fallow merlin]

i genuinely don’t hate any of their songs

[knotty girder]

FORMIDABLE SWEEPPOO

[bitter shuttle]

I GENUINELY do not think i would mind good day as much if it wasnt the FIRST SONF ON THE ALBUM

[knotty girder]

if no chances wins im gonna get upset

[bitter shuttle]

HOW

[fallow merlin]

a lot of them are my favorites cus of like. my life circumstances i guess lol

[bitter shuttle]

ALL THE OTHER OPENERS ARE PEAK AS HELL

[abstract sequoia]

i have and will continue to defend good day as an opener

[bitter shuttle]

Should have been shy away

It was their main hit and its a genuinely good song

[fallow merlin]

good day means a lot to me because of the struggles i’ve had with psychiatric medication

and treatment

[bitter shuttle]

Not an overrated hit like ride

[abstract sequoia]

shy away should NOT have been the opener

[wanton ledge]

i’ll let good day play if it comes on but i wouldn’t go out of my way to listen to it

[gilded notch]

I'm so sorry formidable but I like no chances just a bit more

[bitter shuttle]

Good day is usually the only song i skip lowkey

[abstract sequoia]

if anything should replace good day its choker

[wet nova]

this song forgettable to me
yeah yeah yeh

ow wow wow
ye ye yeaa

[bitter shuttle]

Outside of bounce man i usually skip bounce man

[static void]

Formidable all the way

[wet nova]

no chances for formidable

[wanton ledge]

pls reread this message 😭

[bitter shuttle]

Sogging

I meant good day

[olive prairie]

RAB: Kitchen Sink, Glowing Eyes, Anathema
S/T: Addict With A Pen, Friend Please, March To The Sea
Vessel: Guns For Hands, Trees, Holding On To You
Blurryface: Goner, Tear In My Heart, Hometown
Trench: Legend, Bandito, My Blood
SAI: Formidable, Choker, Redecorate
Clancy: Oldies Station, At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb, Backslide

[wanton ledge]

if everyone else is doing it i’ll give my top 3 on each album too fuck it

[fallow merlin]

[abstract sequoia]

oldies station mentioned

[scenic jewel]

We have the same three for vessel

[bitter shuttle]

I find it weird people can hate atrofd

[scenic jewel]

Same what

[olive prairie]

You’re a peak human girlypop dw

[bitter shuttle]

If i had to pick a good song that was appealable to the most amount of people i would probably pick atrofd

[viscid beacon]

easiest pick in the whole world

[bitter shuttle]

Maybe routines in the night but one of the two

[fallow merlin]

genuinely like it’s a great song

[olive prairie]

Routines is definitely an appealing song for wide audiences

[wanton ledge]

isle of flightless birds, taxi cab, air catcher
forest/glowing eyes, anathema, ruby
holding on to you, fake you out, guns for hands
tear in my heart, polarize, message man
my blood, bandito, leave the city
redecorate, shy away, no chances
midwest indigo, navigating, at the risk of feeling dumb

[wanton coral]

My top 3 per album
st: Idfp, air catcher, oh ms believer
rab: 🤫
Vessel: holding on to you, the run and go, semi-automatic
Bf: goner, polarize, heavydirtysoul
Trench: nico and the niners, jumpsuit, pet cheetah
Sai: shy away, choker, saturday
Clancy: overcompensate, midwest indigo, vignette
The line solos all of them though

[abstract sequoia]

the line is NOT that good

[wanton coral]

dude i got blocked for misspelling goner

[wanton coral]

https://tenor.com/view/frisk-undertale-congratulations-confetti-good-job-gif-13726832184032736667

Idgaf

[fallow merlin]

fellow vignette lover

[wanton ledge]

also my top 3 on npi would be hole in the ground, drown & blasphemy/taken by sleep

[fallow merlin]

i remember liking those

i’ve only listened to npi once

[knotty girder]

yeah yeah yeah

IL L FOLL OW Y OU

[wet nova]

SELF-TITLED :
FRIEND, PLEASE
OH, MS. BELIEVER
ISLE OF FLIGHTLESS BIRDS

REGIONAL AT BEST :
SLOWTOWN
FOREST
GLOWING EYES

VESSEL :
MIGRAINE
SCREEN
TRUCE

BLURRYFACE :
STRESSED OUT
DOUBT
MESSAGE MAN

TRENCH :
MORPH
NEON GRAVESTONES
BANDITO

SCALED AND ICY :
CHOKER
SHY AWAY
REDECORATE

CLANCY :
NEXT SEMESTER
ROUTINES IN THE NIGHT
SNAP BACK

BREACH :
¿¿¿
¿¿¿
¿¿¿

[oblique schooner]

y'all actually being able to choose 3 per album scares me /lh

[wet nova]

it's not that hard imo

[fallow merlin]

scares you how

[oblique schooner]

i opened Trench to try and see if I could choose and immediately turned into the emoji

[knotty girder]

bro already knows the contract isn't gonna be top 3

[fallow merlin]

[fallow merlin]

valid 😭

[knotty girder]

(i think the rest of the album is gonna be so much better than the contract)

[oblique schooner]

i suspect this will be my reaction for most of the albums

[fallow merlin]

they’re all so good honestly i can’t choose top 2 or top 1

[wet nova]

this isn't yet known

[drowsy mesa]

Spotify streams for comparison, there very close on this one

[torn gazelle]

NO CHANCES

[robust plaza]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 1!

[wet nova]

we'll see
i think the contract will be in this list

[fallow merlin]

give me level 3

[knotty girder]

oooh ok ok

[abstract sequoia]

These are in no particular order
ST: trapdoor, taxi cab, isle of flightless birds
RAB: haven’t listened enough but I love clear
Vessel: migraine, the run and go, car radio
BT: hometown, goner, not today
Trench: neon gravestones, leave the city, bandito
SAI: choker, formidable, mulberry street or the outside
Clancy: oldies station, navigating, at the risk of feeling dumb or Midwest indigo.

[soft cedar]

Formidable is best song on SaI fight me on it

[hidden snow]

no chances sweep

[fallow merlin]

i love midwest indigo too

and iofb

[dry dock]

You got my self titled top 3 except I have IOFB at number 1

[gleaming trout]

this is unfair

this is so unfair

im DONE

[dry dock]

No chansweep

[gleaming trout]

god no

[shell sparrow]

i’m so sorry formidable

[dry dock]

Don’t worry this is exactly how I felt yesterday when ppl were obliterating the outside

[misty egret]

no chances SWEEP

WHO is picking formidable (sorry its not that bad it just doesnt come close)

[fallow merlin]

it means a lot to me 💔

i love both songs

honestly

[acoustic cobalt]

was not expecting a setup on this album 💔💔🥀🥀🥀

[fallow merlin]

what’s setup in this context

[wanton coral]

https://tenor.com/view/deftones-chino-moreno-gif-12972075

Me

[acoustic cobalt]

formidable is getting washed unfortunately

[fallow merlin]

yeah

probably but

oh well

i voted for the outside too

[gleaming trout]

i love formidable so much this is so sad

[gleaming lily]

formidable has no chances 😭

[dry dock]

OHHHHH

[fallow merlin]

i can still dream 💔

[mental flicker]

ngl i actually do not know which one is gonna win this time

[nova girder]

I love formidable but I can already tell no chances is probably gonna sweep 💔💔

[deep surge]

REAL

[fading night]

yeah!? We love it

[solar lantern]

nahhh I'm so sorry formidable 💔 breaks my heart but... no chances

[vernal canopy]

YOU SRE FORMUDDALBE TO ME

love Formidable omg

[strong copper]

CAUSE YOU SEEM TO KNOW IT WHERE YOU WANNA GO

[vernal canopy]

YEAH YEAH YEAH

[strong copper]

ILL FOLLOW YOU

[sonic tree]

FORSWEEPABLE

[grizzled elbow]

Formidable is so skibidi

[misty egret]

sweep chances

[grizzled elbow]

There's no chance no chances is winning

[quasi nest]

Formidable getting hard wiped sorry

Like redecorate did to the outside

[gleaming trout]

i wish

formidable is my baby

this is hurting my heart

[solar lantern]

HOW'D YOU GET THE LOCATION

[nova canyon]

WE SPEND SOME WEEKENDS ON THE GRIND, SURVEILLANCE IS OUTSIDE, WE'LL SEE WHEN YOU ARRIVE

RIDE OR DIE, MY SON

[jolly pebble]

ok this is easy imo 🥹

I HATE THIS THOUGH

MY FAV ALBUM

😭😭

[oblique schooner]

Ok here, since everyone else was doing the lists earlier. This is what happens when I try (and fail) to choose, this is what I mean when I say y'all scare me for how easily you do this

In no particular order, these are my personal "top three" favourite songs off of each album. you'll see where the quotation marks come from

Self-Titled
Trapdoor (duh)
Friend, Please
Air Catcher vs The Pantaloon vs IDFP - I can't choose, they're in a fistfight in my brain

RAB
Kitchen Sink (the only reason this wins over Glowing Eyes here is that the first verse means a lot to me as an artist)
Anathema
Slowtown
-# (honorable mention to Lovely, but I much prefer the Vessel version unfortunately so it didn't make it into this list anywhere </3)

Vessel
Ode to Sleep
Migraine
Semi-Automatic

Blurryface
Goner
WDBWOTV
Polarize (trying to stay in its spot while in a fistfight with half the album lol. I changed this spot several times while writing this)

Trench
Nope. No fucking way I'm choosing here, even a clear top 5 is a stretch.
-# Jumpsuit is definitely on there though

SAI
Redecorate
The Outside
Good Day vs NTI fistfight
-# (Mulberry Street and No Chances are watching their brawl from the stands)

Clancy
Navigating
Vignette vs Backslide fistfight
also Oldies Station vs Paladin Strait fistfight </3

Breach
We'll have to see 👀

Expect this list to change in anywhere from two months to two minutes

[vague trail]

formidable 💔

[shadow raptor]

NOFCORMFDLEA

[jolly pebble]

Just for all the formidable fans im voting formidable

[shadow raptor]

YEP

[undone spire]

i’m heartbroken

[shadow raptor]

okay yall that riff

Is so good

At the beginning

Don't even

[jolly pebble]

[shadow raptor]

Do this to me

[jolly pebble]

I love both omg

Its so hard but so simple

[undone spire]

no chances and the outside against formidable💔💔💔

[shadow raptor]

We have obviously not fast forwarded 13y yet

[nova canyon]

what about taxi cab? :(

[undone spire]

my favorites💔

[nova canyon]

(good top 3)

[jolly pebble]

There is an obvious better but 💔💔

[nova canyon]

yeah it's like we somehow played out in reverse

[solar lantern]

I respect this list on a level I didn't know was possible

[oblique schooner]

good song!!! not in my top 3 but it's hard to get into my ST top 3 because Trapdoor and Friend, Please are pretty much set in stone fhgjkfgh but tbf I also don't listen to taxi cab as often as i should

valid pick though!!

[oblique schooner]

aw, I appreciate that haha

[undone spire]

i love st so much :( i’m butting in with my top 3, fall away, isle of flightless birds, and implicit demand for proof

[oblique schooner]

VERY valid picks!!! idfp my love <333

[undone spire]

dude anathema 😿😿

i love that song sm

my top rab are anathema, lovely, and ruby

i named my dog ruby after the song

[shadow raptor]

AAAAAAAA

[fallow merlin]

aw i love that

[shadow raptor]

MAYBE THE REAL "Scared of you now more than I was at first" WAS THE FRIENDS WE MADE ALONG THE WAY

[undone spire]

this list is beautiful

[buoyant crescent]

NO CHANCESSSSSS

[fallow merlin]

i’m making cookies anyone want some

[undone spire]

yes :3

[oblique schooner]

i've seen people on here sometimes who are like "there's no way you really like basically all of their songs" but like.
i truly do mean it when i say there's very few songs of theirs I actively don't enjoy. even the ones i say i 'dislike' i still dont think are bad songs, they're just not scratching my brain the right way

the only exception i can think of is, like. RAB Trees, which physically gives me a headache

[fallow merlin]

they’re going in :3

[oblique schooner]

thank you <3

[fallow merlin]

unfortunately we didn’t have the ingredients to make them homemade from scratch

[oblique schooner]

ooo whats this

[undone spire]

no same, even rab trees i’ve listened to enough to enjoy..

[late meteor]

THIS IS HARD OMG

[late meteor]

my opinion exactly

[fervent siren]

cookies?

[fallow merlin]

eat or bake chocolate chip cookie dough

[oblique schooner]

i can't </3 i think RAB Trees might hit my sensitivity to auditory stuff in the entirely wrong way, im not kidding w that headache thing.

[fallow merlin]

yes

[robust plaza]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 4!

[fallow merlin]

YES

[oblique schooner]

omg dough

[undone spire]

i definitely understand that because when i heard it at first i was like dawg what is THIS

[fallow merlin]

yeah it’s made with salmonella free eggs and stuff so it’s safe to eat and you can bake them instead too

i’m baking half and leaving the rest as dough lol

[oblique schooner]

there are still preferences between songs of course, to be clear, and there are some i'm less likely to intentionally queue up than others. but that's the minority, and even those i don't typically think are Bad Songs, they just don't scratch my brain as much
-# Formidable is actually one of these songs for me, at least currently. maybe i'll come around to it in like a year like I did with e.g. Saturday though lol - it's not a bad song by any means, just not my thing

[oblique schooner]

ooooo

man now i want some

i hope you enjoy!!!

[undone spire]

it’s okay, i feel that way for sure and the songs i’m feeling meh on are songs that i’ve severely overplayed (the entire trench album.) when it came out in 2018 that was the only music i listened to for over a month straight

[willow falcon]

forsweepable?

[slim dawn]

Doubtful

Resweeporate

[alpine kernel]

Formidable is alr but no chances is just better

[oblique schooner]

had a hardcore Craving (Single Version) hater tell me they'd rather listen to RAB Trees so i went and listened to the entirety of RAB Trees to see if i could at all understand.

I gained no understanding for their opinion, all I got was a hurting head and the desire to listen to regular Trees

I'm impressed on you being able to come around to it

[slim dawn]

Real

[nova canyon]

aww that's nice, glad to know you like it though, it's what happens when a song is very good but it's just the songs above are so so good

this would be my top 3 (after years of listening and giving my meanings, but believe me it wasn't an easy task whatsoever):

• Self-Titled:

1. Taxi Cab
2. Isle of Flightless Birds
3. Addict With a Pen
   -# (interesting how I haven't seen it mentioned so far)

• Regional At Best

1. Anathema (which is my favourite tøp song c: )
2. Forest
3. Slowtown

• Vessel

1. Fake You Out
2. Holding on to You
3. Ode To Sleep
   nvm about having them decided the top 2 (not even 3) is constantly changing, a month ago i had migraine as top 2 then car radio showed up and then ode to sleep, but literally everything from vessel but fyo (which is my clear top 5) could be perfectly placed in any of top 2 and 3 spots (vessel is their best album every single song is like top 15 😭)

• Blurryface

1. Goner
2. Lane Boy
3. Heavydirtysoul

• Trench

1. The Hype
2. Leave The City
3. Neon Gravestones

• Scaled And Icy

1. Redecorate
2. Shy Away
3. Choker

• Clancy

1. At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb
2. Navigating
3. Next Semester

• Breach

lol

i realized even making top 3 hurts because my top 4 is ALWAYS a really good song, i'm not kidding. self-titled: trapdoor (MY GOAT), rab: kitchen sink (that one hurts me a LOT to leave behind), vessel: literally the rest of the album but let's say car radio/migraine, trench: my blood, sai: the outside and clancy: vignette 😭

[undone spire]

i hated it at first but somehow my brain was like “i want to listen to this more”. it’s like so bad that it’s endearing in a way

[oblique schooner]

mmm that's very fair! there's deffo some songs on the list i sent that would've placed differently if they'd been more recent. e.g. ATROFD was one of my most listened clancy songs in the first few weeks and then had a sharp dropoff, and there's also the obvious example of like. half of blurryface

[undone spire]

i feel that with navigating, love the song so so much but i listened to it SO MUCH. now snap back is like my all time favorite

[fallow merlin]

excellent list i love it

addict with a pen is amazing

[nova canyon]

ahh yes microwave trees

i feel listening to rab trees is what really makes you appreciate trees (also like, watching it live makes you fall in love with it too)

but the same thing happens with every rab song that got its remaster, if you listen to the first version with flaws and that needed a revamp then it makes you appreciate the things that they fixed and improved in the vessel songs

[oblique schooner]

I respect this list so much!!! so many bangers on there
I feel the Top 3 pain! I would've had an easier time on at least some of the albums (glares at trench where this would Not have been enough to help) if it wa top 4 or top 5

your comment on addict with a pen is funny, because i almost wrote "Air Catcher vs The Pantaloon vs IDFP vs Addict With A Pen" but then i was like. no im too indecisive as it is i HAVE to cross off at least one of these
love Addice With A Pen so much. prolly one of my most listened ST songs tbh

[oblique schooner]

oh yeah, absolutely! and for that i think RAB Trees (along with the other RAB Demos) are worth listening to at least once or twice. even if i otherwise dislike em. it was wild listening to RAB trees fairly shortly after having seen it live for the first time

[nova canyon]

my headcannon about the reason why it's a little less loved amongst cliklies is because everyone just fell in love with josh's drums for awap

it would be really funny if that's the case lol

but i can totally see it happening

[oblique schooner]

also your vessel expeerience is my Every Single Album experience trying to rank the songs

[nova canyon]

yeah totally, even though they're almost objectively the weakest tøp songs they're still worth listening to, especially for what we're saying: to appreciate the vessel songs a little bit more

[oblique schooner]

with trench i had to just give up

[oblique schooner]

yeah!!

-# man, y'all are so much more chill than the ppl i usually encounter in the poll chats, what the heck /pos

[nova canyon]

you know an album is really good and really consistent when you're virtually incapable of making an album ranking 😅

i feel the harder it is for me to rank something the better it is

either that or the album's songs are just really close in terms of being good

like there's no clear bad songs and good songs or a clear top 1

[oblique schooner]

Yea for me its usually either theyre similar in quality, or i have multiple with similar personal stuff attached to them, or a mix of the two

[lavish tendon]

No Chances clears easily

[fallow merlin]

cookie update, my kitchen smells like cookies

[oblique schooner]

Yea half of trench feels like a song i can't leave off the list 😭

[reef sphinx]

No chances easy

[sand path]

WAIT I LOVE BOTH OF THEM NOOOOO

[oblique schooner]

that's rough buddy

[olive prairie]

No Chances is in my top five but unfortunately Formidable is in my top one so it can’t compete

[fallow merlin]

[fleet ravine]

wait I love them both. This isnt fair 💔

[marsh glacier]

You wanna know what Formidable has…

No Chance at winning 👀

[uncut raptor]

No chances is an absolute banger

[odd vector]

I didn't expect SAI battle to be this hard... I don't understand the hate for this album, it's so cool, and I love every song on it ! How can you make me choose between them ?!

I fear the Clancy Battle so much 😭

[woven breach]

WE COME FOR YOUUU 🎶

[woven breach]

Yessss

[paper harbor]

i know a lot of people have formidable as a spcial place in their heart so i feel like it has a godo chance at winning but i gotta vote no chnaces

[dense orchid]

NO CHANCES!

[wise saffron]

No chances for the win! I love this song I need more of this on Breach.

[woven breach]

Don't get me wrong, the Jenna songs are cute, but I'm not married to Jenna which is why I never vote for them in the song battles. They're great, just not relatable for me personally 🤷

[paper harbor]

hey i'm not married to jenna, or for that matter, married to anyone, but it still sounds pretty good. Anyway that's a good reason not to vote for it but if it wasn't against no chances i'd probably be voting formidable just becuase it sounds so lovely

[fringe acorn]

lol lmao i have a playlist just for this https://open.spotify.com/playlist/6RFq76GuAHcUmU37xAHbTh?si=l9XQDH78Rj-KdhSZRIZOKQ&pi=ESKsnulMTimbb

i swap em out pretty often tbh but yeah

[plain garden]

"Formidable" and "No Chances"... It's so hard to choose!

"Formidable" is relatable to me in a platonic kind of way and I just love it's wholesome melody, and "No Chances" is just so hardcore!

[random ridge]

no chances 🗣️🔥

[plain garden]

Since I listen to "Formidable" more than "No Chances", I'm just gonna choose "Formidable".

[wispy flame]

FORMIDABLE MY GOAT

[woven breach]

Yeah, true. They still sound great

[woven breach]

That's understandable. Formidable does sound quite friendly

[plain garden]

It does - and also nostalgic for some reason!

[real silo]

FORMIDABLE

[plain garden]

I voted for "Formidable"!

[golden ore]

Ik that No Chances first introduced me to tøp but I’m sorryyyy 😭
Gotta go with Formidable 🙏🏾🙏🏾

[signal cosmos]

no chances sweep

[undone nacelle]

NO CHANCES BEST SAI SONG

[dry dock]

double sweep

formidable is my least favourite on the album and no chances top 3

[restive shoal]

fоrMIDаblе

[severe pike]

YOU ARE FORMIDABLE TO ME

[restive shoal]

jk i vоtеԁ fоrmiԁаblе

[cosmic verge]

formidable is about josh so

...

formidable it is

[restive shoal]

fоrmiԁаblе is nоt аbоut jоsh 😭

[steel karma]

no chances on top.

[dry dock]

What no it’s not, it’s another Jenna song

[paper charm]

For my fellow lovers of Pet Cheetah… No Chances is like Pet Cheetah part 2

[dry dock]

I don’t see the similarities

[brave onyx]

mmm

ba da dum ba da dum dum

we got people on the way

we want you home in one piece now

(run away run away)

[olive prairie]

<3<3<3<3<3 PREACH

[cloud needle]

forMIDable

most absolutely mid song they may have ever released

not bad

bad is bounce man

[olive prairie]

Smithereens exists

[cloud needle]

smithereens at least has a good instrumental

[olive prairie]

Well Formidable has got some amazing lyrics so

[cloud needle]

to each their own

[olive prairie]

You clearly have never been a dedicated member of a whimsy romance before /silly

[fallow merlin]

real

[woven breach]

It's ok to not like it, but Formidable, is for Jenna so I think we should atleast respect it. As well as Smithereens, Tear In My Heart, and The Craving

[woven breach]

Pet Cheetah 🤝 No Chances 🤝 Lavish

[cloud needle]

i mean… at least timh is good

[woven breach]

I think we should be nice about the Jenna songs because imagine if someone made a song for you and someone else said that it wasn't good? I think that would be really hurtful, so I think we shouldn't be too harsh about our opinions towards them

[cloud needle]

i don’t hate any of their songs really

any song i talk badly about i still enjoy over lots of other music

buuuuut

tyler has the capacity to make good songs, i’m not doubting that whatsoever

i’m just not a fan of formidable and the craving

[oblique schooner]

oh that's a good idea, i should try and do that instead of trying to make a top 3s list and giving up when i realize it will inevitably be null in void when i change my mind a day later
-# also im curious, are some of the playlists on your profile OC playlists?

[fringe acorn]

yeah, ngl i switch them out pretty often but it's definitely fun to do imo :DD
(and yea,,,, )

[oblique schooner]

yeahh i'd probably switch stuff out every other listen ahfhkg
(hell yeah!!! i love OC playlists, that's awesome. the art on them also looks really cool)

hmm id prolly have to either leave RAB out or finally import it as local files 🤔

[fringe acorn]

ghghhh so true twin 💔💔💔
also tysm :DD

and yeah importing files is annoying but worth i think

[oblique schooner]

Hope this isn't weird because I'm a stranger, but if you ever need to ramble about them, feel free to shoot me a message!! I love learning abt peoples OCs and I'm obsessed w OC playlists haha
-# I can't guarantee how much i can always respond right away because of arm pains BUT i will try!!!

[oblique schooner]

Ive done it once or twice for other songs but haven't gotten around to doing it w the missing TØP stuff yet

[fringe acorn]

i love yapping,,,,

i cant atm but i will perhaps shoot u a dm sometime later (if i remember 💔 ill try!!)

[gentle tulip]

the two best Jenna songs

[low moon]

Tear in my heart?

[gentle tulip]

nah

tear in my heart is cute but it's no formidable or the craving jv

same goes for smithereens

[oblique schooner]

woah we have opposite opinions on jenna songs

smithereens and timh are my favourite jenna songs <3

[restive shoal]

what the fuck

[winter tendon]

TL the people voting Formidable

You can’t sleep Formidable without MID

Chat can we please shame the people not voting for No Chances /j

[cerulean raptor]

hahaha nooo i love formidable 😭✋🏼

but unfortunately, it doesn’t compare well to no chances 😔

[gentle tulip]

you gotta work on your spelling first

[gentle tulip]

nah cause you got no chances of winning

[winter tendon]

https://tenor.com/view/tyler-joseph-message-man-twenty-one-pilots-message-man-ritual-icy-tour-gif-2677154325679046083

[woven breach]

That's understandable. I really like Smithereens

[woven breach]

Smithereens and The Craving are my faves. Probably because I really like Clancy and Trench a lot, though 😅

[frank aurora]

I wholeheartedly agree with everything in this sentence

[brazen valley]

DUDE WHY THESE TWO 💔💔💔

I CANT CHOOSE

[heavy storm]

no chances fss

[grizzled sentinel]

NO WHAT THIS IS SO HARD IM GONNA CRY

[viscid beacon]

no chances biggest sweep i hope

[dry dock]

It better be bigger than yesterday’s

[steel thistle]

Formidable tbh

No chances gets stale after the first monute

[odd vector]

Hum... Tbh, I think Bounce Man is really good. Like, it has a good rhythm, and it's funny and catchy. I like this song and don't understand why nobody likes it 😭

[sharp rock]

FORMIDABLE

[dry dock]

forMIDable

[spice junco]

No Chance to live now.

[mint basin]

I was gonna say that

[spice junco]

Forsweepable.

[dry dock]

Fr

[viscid beacon]

formidable gets stale after the fist second

[steel thistle]

That sounds like a scaled and icy problem not a formidable problem

[dry dock]

second half of the album falls off then no chances saves it

[viscid beacon]

yes

and redecorate

those two<3

[abstract sequoia]

nah cause what actually is theese parrings

[autumn pendant]

These two are good

[radiant notch]

quite honestly this one is an easy choice for me

we come for you

no chances

[fallow merlin]

good day dema

[nova girder]

Tears in my formidable eyes 💔💔

[sudden night]

im out of this server

HOW DID NO CHANCES WIN AGAINST FORMIDABLE

[oblique schooner]

so sorry formidable fans 💔 unfortunately it had no chances

[oblique haven]

Formidable did better than expected

[drowsy portal]

BRUH

[oblique haven]

I'm not mad

[drowsy portal]

😩😩😩😩😩

[knotty girder]

FORMIDABLE IS SO MUCH BETTER THAN

[sudden night]

FR!!!

[knotty girder]

we come for you 😭

[vernal canopy]

NOO POOR FORMUDDABLE

[sudden night]

no chances is the least good song on SAI

[knotty girder]

someone plz make a poorly edited sped up version of no chances that mocks the song 😭

[sudden night]

the kind of breakdown on no chances is awful

[abstract sequoia]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[olive prairie]

I’ve lost all faith in this community.

[vernal canopy]

Told my friend (who isn’t in this server) that Formidable lost against No Chances and she replied with
“People in the Discord server have no taste smh”, fully agree
-# joking lol, everyone likes something else BUT STILL

[bitter shuttle]

heartbreaking

[acoustic sky]

The hell
How could formidable lose

[jade flax]

there was No Chance(s) of Formidable winning

[snow gust]

Yall are unrecoverable

[elfin vessel]

I hate this fandom

[vague trail]

[latent mortar]

why did no chances win wtf i thought formidable was a fan fav

[fleet ravine]

formidable should of won

[sharp rock]

NO

[severe pike]

choker easy

formidable shoudlve won

[latent mortar]

should have

should of is mot grammatically correct

[rough blaze]

mot is not grammatically correct either