2025 Scaled And Icy Song Battle #3

[wooden light]

Let’s just pick neither 🤷🏼‍♂️

[versed quail]

PERFRECT

[prisma wedge]

but I already voted 😭

[wooden light]

I pick neither I love them both too much

[restive pulsar]

real!!

[modern gyro]

Erm akshually ☝️🤓 the word is "dragon," not "track"

[olive coyote]

Don’t kill the outside vote the outside

[restive pulsar]

redecorate.

[gusty chasm]

?

[misty gorge]

I DONT WANNA LEAVE LIKE THIS

[void lintel]

🗣️ 🗣️ AT LEAST LET ME CLEAN MY ROOM

[void lintel]

but dragon doesn't rhyme with back

[modern gyro]

I stand corrected 🧍‍♂️😭 I swear I always heard "track and" as "dragon" (tbh I'm listening to that part over and over and I still do)

[carmine delta]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 16!

[modern gyro]

This is not the first time I've made a fool out of myself by going off of what I heard and not looking at the actual lyrics

[modern gyro]

Gee thanks Nico 🫩

[void lintel]

lol happens to me all the time (can't think of any examples rn but i assure you it happens more frequently than one would expect)

[modern gyro]

Me thinking "deny, deny, denial" in polarize was "tonight, tonight, tonight, oh"

[void lintel]

omg wait me too lol

[modern gyro]

I still think "if I'm gonna snap next then I gotta snap back" is better than the actual lyrics which is "snap necks"

[round flower]

Outside

[round flower]

Same

Like if im gonna snap anyway i might aswell snap back to sanity/reality or whatever. Works better imo

[modern gyro]

And "snap necks" just sounds unnecessarily morbid 😂

[round flower]

Def

[prisma wedge]

this battle should've been the finals fr

istg

[deft pasture]

redecorate sweep

ez

[woven comet]

REDECORATE

[trim agate]

OMG REDECORATE!!! <33

Don't get me wrong, I love The Outside 😍

[deft pasture]

my #1 off sai v my #2 off sai 😭

[trim agate]

Damn... 😬

[dull marten]

Oh lord how am I gonna choose 😭

I was just listening to The outside

[prisma wedge]

same here 😭

[trim agate]

I think this is something that happens to everyone hearing Polarize for the first time 😂

[prisma wedge]

fr lol

[golden grotto]

it took me years to figure out it wasn’t that

[void lintel]

<3

[merry anchor]

will i finally be on the side that wins for once

if redecorate somehow doesn't win...

[void lintel]

dude if that happens i will literally cry

its a masterpiece

[merry anchor]

EXACTLY

I dont really like the outside lowkey

[void lintel]

idk i think the outside is great but redecorate easily beats EVERY sai track

[autumn verge]

Redcorate better SWEEP!!!

[prisma wedge]

fr

[prisma wedge]

ikrrr

[merry anchor]

mulberry and never take it got robbed (I will be salty about this for the rest of my career.)

[void lintel]

im never this active in any server, but since its redecorate i am going to defend it with whatever little energy i have

[prisma wedge]

redecorate hits different

[void lintel]

fr idk if its just me but THE TINGLES EVERY TIME THE CHORUS COMES I SWEAR

[olive coyote]

Have all of you no faith in the outside

[prisma wedge]

I think the outside is kinda cooked

I feel bad

but I can't vote against redecorate

[radiant oxide]

i need everybody to rewatch The Outside music video and reconsider/reaffirm your decision.

[olive coyote]

Fr

[prisma wedge]

redecorate bridge goes so hard

[olive coyote]

The outside bridge goes harder

[gusty chasm]

redecorate sweep

[sudden cloak]

Redecorate SWEEP

[merry anchor]

....still going with redecorate

[brazen marten]

fuck

redecorate is so good

but the outside is quite possibly my favourite song ever

[olive coyote]

Valid favorite

[molten canopy]

guess which. guess which song i want to win

(its formidable, shockingly)

[swift charm]

Omg these two really fucked me up

Voted redecorate... It's just... So good

The lyrics man

The outside is pretty fun to dance around to and stuff tho

[rare swan]

Redecorate

[molten canopy]

how’d u know

[coarse topaz]

Redecorate saved my life literally

[astral olive]

I'm on the outside in the summer heat

[olive coyote]

You can pay the cover charge, I’m in the street

[sturdy temple]

Redecorate easy

top 5 tøp songs

in general

easily the best on the album

[gusty chasm]

exactlyyyyy

[prisma tulip]

The outside eats but...

Redecorate was just god or something

[stray ridge]

love both but redecorate…

[ancient tulip]

Wait waif whys there tape

I just got here from vacation 😭😭 did I miss something

[deft mantle]

this album battle is cooked if redecorate loses

[crisp silo]

This isn’t even a competition

[livid canyon]

1k difference in votes fr

[gusty chasm]

its the album covers from the clancy rollout

not lore or anything

[olive coyote]

redecorate sweep

just let it win already we know its gonna win

its really miles ahead of other songs

the outside i like a lot and will defend

[white talon]

well that was easy

resweeporate

[olive coyote]

The outsweep tho

[narrow depot]

VOTE REDECORATE

[karmic badger]

Literally rigged against the outside omg

[neat pecan]

NOOOOOO my son The Outside :(

[olive coyote]

Why did we have to do the final battle as the third one

[fringe basin]

The outside is good and all but I'm always gonna vote redecorate mostly for personal reasons ngl tho it is also a really good song one of my favs from SAI plus mulberry Street but uh it immediately lost soo

Kinda feel bad for any song redecorate goes up against ngl.. 😔

[trim agate]

Same. The entire album is great, in fact, all of them are, but Redecorate is a fave of so many people and that's probably why it gets so much votes

[severe sage]

in none of the billions of universes

[severe sage]

redecorate will win sai song battles
it's inevitable

[brazen pewter]

i love the outside so much man this sucks

[prisma wedge]

nahh fr

[wintry kernel]

The Outside is 100% better

[olive coyote]

THANK YOU

[zealous grove]

oh duh

[zealous grove]

no

its literally REDECORATE

[white talon]

nah I think k best sing on sai has gotta be mulberry st

[olive coyote]

It’s literally the outside

[prisma wedge]

ughh I just listened to the outside again and I'm gonna cry

idk if I can do this

[tardy path]

the outstide, sorry

[gusty chasm]

redecorate sweep

[tardy path]

preach

[zealous grove]

compared to redecorate its nothing, sorry

redecorate is too personal

[olive coyote]

Eh, the outside is better

[zealous grove]

its too infused in my soul

the outside is good but its nothing compared to redecorate

[olive coyote]

Redecorate ain’t shit compared to the outside

[zealous grove]

redecorate is like god tier and the outside is like

e tier

[olive coyote]

The outside is god tier, redecorate is A tier

[zealous grove]

compared to refecorate

[olive coyote]

Redecorate is way too overhyped it doesn’t deserve the glaze

[zealous grove]

not to redecoraye

my bad

i was talking abt my cat xena

like

2 seconds ago

ans she was in mt brain

[prisma wedge]

yes it does

[olive coyote]

It doesn’t tho

[deft pasture]

"doesn't deserve the glaze" one of the bands best written and deepest songs with some of the best sound the band has produced? ok bud

[zealous grove]

uhm

yes it does

[olive coyote]

The sound isn’t all that it kind of fades into the discography

[zealous grove]

maybe you dont understand it

[olive coyote]

Huh?

[zealous grove]

the way some other peoplw do

but like

[deft pasture]

i could say the same for the outside

[zealous grove]

personal love for songs dictate

[olive coyote]

Huh

[zealous grove]

some peoples votes

[deft pasture]

-# and most of sai

[olive coyote]

Lucky for me I have zero emotional biases toward TOP songs

[zealous grove]

which is fine

but redecorate is very personal to people

[olive coyote]

The outside sounds better tho it’s so funky

[prisma wedge]

me personally

(crying to next semester in real time)

[olive coyote]

Touché mason that was funny

[olive coyote]

Now THAT one is top 5 of all time forever, or at least until a couple Breach songs get in top 5

[zealous grove]

being the titled "||suicide|| song of sai" (they have 1 song abt ||suicide|| every album. i.e. fake you out "what the kids are doing, they're killing themselves", goner, neon gravestones, redecorate, oldies station)

[prisma wedge]

next semester appreciation hooray

[olive coyote]

God tier forever

[prisma wedge]

frr

[olive coyote]

But somehow not quite my favorite Clancy song

[prisma wedge]

what clears it??

[olive coyote]

Overcompensate, that’s the only Clancy song I like more

[prisma wedge]

understandable but I disagree

[olive coyote]

Hmm

[zealous grove]

it being the "personal" song of sai makes it more personal to others for this reason, which is why i personally am voting it

[olive coyote]

Idk overcompensate is my favorite song of all time and I’m definitely hoping at least one Breach song overtakes it

[prisma wedge]

ok fair

if a breach song overtakes overcompensate I will be very happy

[olive coyote]

Where are overcompensate and next semester in your ranking

[prisma wedge]

near the top

top 10 for sure

[olive coyote]

Overcompensate is my number 1 next semester is my 4

[prisma wedge]

but there are so many good twenty one pilots songs it's so hard to rank them

if I made a tier list I wouldn't put a single song below B tier

[olive coyote]

Really? I’d try spreading them out pretty evenly, I already did

[prisma wedge]

I just can't tho I love them all

[olive coyote]

I never wanna be the guy who loves everything or hates everything cause too far one way is too much

[prisma wedge]

as soon as I listen to one too much it just grows on me

[prisma wedge]

but...

[olive coyote]

Yeah that’s definitely my most anticipated breach song

Will it be my favorite? Who knows, but I see some ppl theorize that it’ll be a lore song and that gets my hopes up enough

[prisma wedge]

lol I'm going to marathon the whole album a minimum of 21 times in the first week it comes out

[waxen finch]

redecorate my lovee

[merry anchor]

I DONT WANNA GO LIKE THIS, AT LEAST LET ME CLEAN MY ROOM

[olive coyote]

The outside

[prisma wedge]

I think we're hitting a new total vote count record today

[mellow latch]

same here
i’d make s+, s, a+, and a tiers

[olive coyote]

Nah we need at least 100 more votes to have a chance at that

[deft pasture]

next semester and the craving are also incredibly personal

[slim narwhal]

you’re welcome

[nocturne reef]

this isn't even a contest

what is this

redecorate and shy away are the only tolerable songs on the album

the outside is alright I guess, but redecorate is the only actual good song on this album

[olive coyote]

Oh perfect an SAI hater

[fringe basin]

SAI is kinda underrated imo well post blurryface I should probably specify

[barren olive]

i’m a redecorate fiend

need it to win 🙏

[white flower]

Redecorate FTW please?

[void lintel]

im so with you buddy, trust redecorate is gonna win

[white flower]

Can we make sure to have the owner of this server ban everyone who votes for Bounce Man and Formidable (THIS IS A JOKE GUYS IM JUST JOKING PLEASE DON’T SMITE ME)

[dusk jay]

🧹 🧹🧹

[prisma wedge]

no I think we actually have a shot this time

we just need to pass 2045 I think

that's just 100 or so votes away and we still have 10 hours left

we can do it guys

REDECORATE FTWWWWWWWWWW

RAHHHHHHHHHH

[carmine delta]

LEVEL UP: You are now level 6!

[prisma wedge]

HE KNOWS WHAT'S UPPPPPPPPPPP

[dry wagon]

LITERALLY IT NEVER STOOD A CHANCE 😭✋🏼

[lone minnow]

NOOOOOO this is tragic

[olive coyote]

redecorate is one of their best songs and would get quite high in a bracket including all their songs

Funny thing both this song and Screen have a lo-fi hiphop style intro

which i find quite funny

[timber mortar]

I love redecorate so much but the outside is also such a good song

[rancid river]

Why would you do this to me

[wide minnow]

I just listened to them one more time and it's very tough to choose

I find that redecorate has the beat while the outside has the lyrics...

[olive coyote]

I would’ve thought most people would switch this around, either way I vote the outside

[halcyon garnet]

"I am I megalodon
oceans feeling like a pond
swimming like a beast underneath
they be clinging on
switch it up on me
meteoric rise
in prehistoric times
now that meteor is comin (comin)
I am megatron
cogs, Im steppin on
then the little cogs got together
start a renaissance
switch it up on me
fuel efficiency
on fumes I am runnin (runnin)"

prolly the first tøp rap I learned all the way through

[marble tendon]

Spotify streams for comparison

[sturdy temple]

what

if you're gonna talk about lyrics Redecorate is top 5 tøp

what do you mean

I think it's top 5 tøp regardless but like

the lyrics are its strong point

[gusty chasm]

this better be a redecorate sweep

[robust maple]

it will be, the outside is awesome but redecorate is more popular (from what i’ve seen)

[olive coyote]

The outside is the one that got number 1 on alternative airplay, it’s definitely more popular

[robust maple]

i guess we’ll see lol

idk what alternative airplay is

[bitter umbra]

redecorate takes

love you outside, i do

but redecorate means so much more to me than you ever will

cant see how anyone would give outside the win

i mean the second verse is basically non-existent

a decent chorus i wont lie

and the rap is also really solid

and i like the ending

but redecorate actually has more to offer

[jagged ivy]

correct, i dont think the outside adds anything new to the album or does anything specifically unique with its style; but that doesnt mean its a bad song i still jam to it
redecorate definitely has more to offer

[olive coyote]

It’s better tho what

[bitter umbra]

lmao no

[olive coyote]

A billboard chart that TOP have a lot of number one songs on

[olive coyote]

Yes tho

[bitter umbra]

ur still delusional i get it

[olive coyote]

No SAI song can beat the outside

[bitter umbra]

alr what is that take

shy away could beat outside

choker could beat outside

[olive coyote]

Shy away is the worst

[bitter umbra]

alr stop talking pls

i swear all of your opinions are ragebait

[olive coyote]

I swear ppl glaze redecorate way too much

[deft pasture]

one hour until redecorate sweeps

[gusty chasm]

i will continue to glaze redecorate

also promoted single means radio airplay it doesnt represent the actual opinions from fans (aka people in the server)

[deft pasture]

it's deserved. but you don't listen to songs for lyrics so you don't understand

[gusty chasm]

also if we’re being real who cares if people “glaze” it like if i love a song im gonna hype it up, it means a lot to me and i will continue to treat it as such

[olive coyote]

happily

[gusty chasm]

everyones got their own opinions

[olive coyote]

So, cause I don’t “understand” the lyrics, so what

Wdym by that

[deft pasture]

exactly that

[olive coyote]

That is mean to scaled and icy tho

i didnt say it wasnt

[olive coyote]

So are you above me cause you “understand” it

yes

[deft pasture]

when did i say i was above you

[olive coyote]

“You don’t listen to songs for lyrics so you don’t understand” so am I beneath you or smth

[deft pasture]

that's not what i'm saying at ALL lmao

[olive coyote]

Kinda sounded like it

[deft pasture]

you're voting the outside because it sounds better to you, i'm voting redecorate because the lyrics are some of the best the band has ever had

we're voting things for different reasons

[olive coyote]

Then what’re you talking about when you say “you don’t understand”

redecorate sounds better 💀

[wide minnow]

I'm a newer fan and haven't listened to Scales and Icy yet. I would have to look into it

[brittle kayak]

you're voting the outside cause its a song in the lore, i'm voting redecorate cause its message

it's such a good song, gotta be my favorite out of sai

[olive coyote]

redecorate is one of the most lore driven songs theyve ever made

it starts with a line spoken by Clancy

[olive coyote]

Not only lore, also cause the outside is the perfect example of what Tyler can do without any other producer alongside him

[brittle kayak]

yeah

[brittle kayak]

i wouldnt say so.

imo.

[olive coyote]

Not really it just has the Clancy line

[brittle kayak]

i get where people are coming from with the clancy line

[olive coyote]

Then it tells its own story after that

[brittle kayak]

but one line doesnt make it that lore driven.

i appreciate it does sneak some lore in there, but the songs message imo is "Do you ‘honor’ their memory … Or do you want to … change things until you can move past it?"

[olive coyote]

JUST has the clancy line? Hello?

[brittle kayak]

which i hold to heart

[olive coyote]

The song starts by establishing itself in the storyline

[olive coyote]

Yes, it tells its own separate story after that

😭 Is this ragebait

[brittle kayak]

are you ragebaiting?

[olive coyote]

This is the truth redecorate’s only lore implication is the Clancy line

[brittle kayak]

I don't think it has anything to do with the lore other than the clancy line.

[olive coyote]

The song starts with a direct exerpt from a Clancy letter and the song is not related to the lore? Oh please 😭 reevaluate all of their music

Its a concept album

[olive coyote]

Yes that is a fact. Starts with a Clancy line then tells a separate story

[deft pasture]

i don't think people are voting it because of clancy dawg

[gusty chasm]

the entire lyric video is written out like a clancy letter

[brittle kayak]

i feel like thats just overanalysis.

[olive coyote]

I know that I’m just trying to say that’s the only lore implication of redecorate

[deft pasture]

k?

[gusty chasm]

girl half the lore is overanalysis

[olive coyote]

Yes the song technically has no ties to Clancy past that point but to blow it off as just a reference at the start and not the precursor for the entire story the song tells is misleading

This is not overanalysis

its a CONCEPT ALBUM.

[olive coyote]

Yes it is misleading

[brittle kayak]

girl, redecorate isnt supposed to be lore imo

[olive coyote]

Outside of dmaorg and the music video, the songs themselves are telling a story

[gusty chasm]

i can say the outside isnt supposed to be lore, doesnt effect if it is or not

[olive coyote]

It is so 2 Dimensional to think that the story is just this one music video storyline when it has its roots in nearly every song

[olive coyote]

Dude scaled and icy is not a concept album on paper. Trench is, Clancy is with the opener and closer, but SAI is only a concept album if you read between the lines it’s not really

The Outside on the other hand has little reference to the dema storyline yet i can fit it through links to the storyline thats being told

[olive coyote]

brother

[gusty chasm]

the main story is the mvs but a lot of the songs help u fill in the blanks in between everything

[olive coyote]

you did not just say those first 11 words seriously

[gusty chasm]

they can all have lore interpretations bc theyre PART OF THE LORE ALBUMS even if its not entirely NATN lore

[olive coyote]

scaled and icy... is not... a concept album???????????????????

Invalidated everything youve said so far

[olive coyote]

People are always attempting to make SAI more lore related than it actually is. The only songs with any lyrical ties to the lore is no chances and redecorate

[deft pasture]

1/10 ragebait

[gusty chasm]

ah yes the album about clancy being captured by dema and forced to perform for them isnt a lore album

[deft pasture]

sai is LITERALLY dema propaganda 😭

[olive coyote]

That’s the thing about scaled and icy. The actual lore going on is hidden behind the album

[gusty chasm]

ITS IN THE SONGS TOO

[olive coyote]

Correction: the only songs that directly mention elements of the lore are the last two songs. the rest of the album fits into themes of being stuck in cycles and finding the courage to break them, parallel to clancy's story

[gusty chasm]

WHAT DO U THINK GOOD DAY AND MULBERRY STREET AND CHOKER ARE SAYING

[olive coyote]

Barely, no chances and redecorate are the ones that break free

theyre saying nothing. music is 2 dimensional 🤓

[olive coyote]

It’s all propaganda

Wait its all propaganda... but its not a concept album?

can you make that make sense

[gusty chasm]

that doesnt mean they dont have messages in them

[deft pasture]

https://tenor.com/view/wall-gif-26450094

[gusty chasm]

that heavily tie into everything else in the lore

[olive coyote]

Because to know it’s propaganda you’re forced to read between the lines so it’s not an upfront concept album

Theres level to concept albums

[gusty chasm]

music is 2 dimensional and objective and people shouldnt glaze it or have any emotional attachment to it

[olive coyote]

trench is a concept album youd say? Nobody is denying that

yet make my blood and legend make sense

pet cheetah?

[olive coyote]

Ew

[deft pasture]

of course

[olive coyote]

I can make all the songs of trench fit into the dema storyline, same with scaled and icy though i wasnt too fond of the execution

[brittle kayak]

how did this argument start cause I said that redecorate wasnt strictly lore.

[olive coyote]

Redecorate is directly linked to the lore

Only with the first line

[brittle kayak]

in like 2 lines

[olive coyote]

The two opening lines set the stage and directly tie the song to the storyline

please tell me why they included those lines

just a little fun call back?

[olive coyote]

Cause it’s directly after no chances, then it moves on to redecorate’s own story

[brittle kayak]

all im saying is redecorate wasnt made to be entirely connected to the lore. saying the entire song is lore related is just plain wrong

[olive coyote]

No Chances have no lyrics which link directly to the lore yet you say it is

[gusty chasm]

or you can imply something is off with Good Day and figure out between that and No Chances that something is Off at least

[olive coyote]

It has the bishop vocals what’re you talking about

[brittle kayak]

the opener lines does not = entire song should be taken into the story

[olive coyote]

it is not wrong when youre in the middle of a set of concept albums which lyrically anchor back to the lore

[brittle kayak]

erm, it was the last track

[olive coyote]

oh so were basing whether its lore based on sound now?

[olive coyote]

reread my message

[brittle kayak]

oh, misread it

mb

[olive coyote]

Do you hear the deep voices going “we come for you, no chances” that is lore straight up

Yes I agree but no chances and redecorate are both equally lore so basing one off the sound and another on the lyrics is a fallacy

[gusty chasm]

how is that different than a clancy letter being read at the beginning of redecorate

[olive coyote]

No chances is way more lore than redecorate

[brittle kayak]

i dont think its a clancy letter imo

[olive coyote]

Look at dmaorg the quote is taken from a Clancy letter

[gusty chasm]

IT IS DIRECTLY A CLANCY LETTER

[olive coyote]

The vibes of the song feel more connected to the storyline but so is redecorate tied as the closer to this chapter of the dema story

[olive coyote]

No it’s not redecorate tells a completely separate story outside the lore

[brittle kayak]

i mean the lyric video. not just that.

the entire lyric video

[olive coyote]

a lot is left up to interpretation in these albums but to view each song as disconnected from the greater concept is missing the point in my opinion

[olive coyote]

Of which song

[olive coyote]

How is it outside the lore in which way

[brittle kayak]

redecorate

[olive coyote]

Every single verse

[brittle kayak]

i never interpreted it as a clancy letter

[olive coyote]

Oh yeah, no the song isn’t a Clancy letter

it is a clancy letter

the opening

[gusty chasm]

ah yes “i am a megalodon” is more lore than “scaled back and isolated”

[olive coyote]

The opening, and that is it

[gusty chasm]

yk. what theyre doing to clancy. why the album exists.

[brittle kayak]

scaled back and isolated is what tyler interpereted the world to be during covid.

[gusty chasm]

double meanings are a thing as well

[olive coyote]

to look at this and just say "oh yeah the song is outside of the lore" is WILD

[gusty chasm]

Clancy is in captivity, he is LITERALLY scaled back and isolated as well

[brittle kayak]

i get that

[olive coyote]

i interpret redecorate as the story of the lives of other dema citizens

[olive coyote]

You’re misreading what I’m saying completely. I’m saying while the opening line is from a Clancy letter, the song itself is not lore

[brittle kayak]

but redecorate wasnt ever intended to be entirely considered to be lore

other than the first line

there is nothing you could directly connect to the lore

[olive coyote]

youre misinterpretating what im saying: im saying you are factually wrong

[gusty chasm]

where is that ever said

[gusty chasm]

theres a lot actually

[olive coyote]

That is a lie

[olive coyote]

You’re factually wrong, redecorate’s only tie to the lore is the first line and it tells its own story after

[brittle kayak]

unless you overanalyze it.

[gusty chasm]

AGAIN

[olive coyote]

OVERANALYSING A CONCEPT ALBUM?

[gusty chasm]

THE LORE ITSELF IS OVERANALYSIS

[olive coyote]

who would have thought

i could get a fucking phd in this lore

[brittle kayak]

like putting blankets over mirrors OMG! INSECURITY, INSECURITY = DEMA LORE!!!

[gusty chasm]

how did we find dmaorg in the first place. overanalyzing.

[olive coyote]

Holy shit you aint gonna believe this

[gusty chasm]

clancy is dead ? overanalyzing

[olive coyote]

Broseph I could get a phd in the lore if I ever deliver my 118 page lore script

[brittle kayak]

the fact is you're misinterpreting the lyrics. this is going in a loop cause you wont see the side we're talking about rather centralizing your entire argument about your side.

[olive coyote]

yes and you view the lore as a strict storyline whilst the lore actually has roots in every single facet of the albums and the overarching themes

[brittle kayak]

you seem like the kinda person to say self titled is lore related

[olive coyote]

Fr

[olive coyote]

misinterpreting...l yrics.... in a concept album... by linking them... to the concept... established throughout 5 albums... and the start of the album... and the start of the song....

[olive coyote]

no i dont say that

[gusty chasm]

the lore is as deep as you make it, its either only MVs and lore songs or you can try and connect everything

[brittle kayak]

so the craving is also lore related with that logic

[gusty chasm]

backslide isnt direcrly lore either but everyone kinda agrees it fits

sure yeah

[olive coyote]

Connecting everything is a waste of time and energy, like the shirts from the Clancy tour. While the images are lore related they added nothing to the story

[olive coyote]

Oh yes it is

[brittle kayak]

okay, this is so fucking cooked.

[brittle kayak]

ITS A SONG FOR HIS FUCKING WIFE

im out of here, y'all make no damn sense

[olive coyote]

Each song is a part of Clancy's being

This is established in the opening track

[gusty chasm]

i dont think it is personally but it could be interpreted as such

[olive coyote]

This is a journey of cycles for Clancy and finding his place so he can come out on top

[gusty chasm]

again, the lore goes as deep as you want it to

thats the point

[olive coyote]

Wait what don’t leave me alone with these arguments help me

The lore is in all the albums... Whether a strict story being told within the walls or of Clancy's mindset in another track

[gusty chasm]

im also dipping bc this is getting nowhere but yeah saying redecorate is irrelevant is crazy

[olive coyote]

Oh yeah by the way The Craving references a clancy letter

forgot to mention that one

[olive coyote]

I feel like besides the 3 lore videos in Clancy, backslide and snap back could tie to the lore cause we could easily think of the thing he’s backsliding to as Dema

[olive coyote]

Omfg no it doesn’t

[livid canyon]

hello

[gusty chasm]

vignette also

[livid canyon]

redecorate by far

[olive coyote]

Oh my god i have proof

[livid canyon]

fr?

[olive coyote]

Oh yeah I’ve heard those theories. One of my favorite YouTubers said he thinks of the Blurryface paint as the vignette he’s being swallowed by, what do you think I’m curious

[livid canyon]

oh damn

[olive coyote]

Oh shit

I stand proven wrong

[livid canyon]

thats crazy he cant even write a song thats just for jenna

the lore is more important than his own wife

married to the grind

[olive coyote]

It's interwoven, Clancy is Tyler's projection of his fighting self, his warrior.

These albums are all up to interpretation so my way of viewing it cannot be proven, but redecorate directly opens the stage by linking it to the storyline thematically, so therefore I will always view it as lore

He wrote the craving 6 years before it dropped confirmed

He knows this storyline in and out, all the letters, the themes, the content, the visuals. He borrows from old work all the time

The idea that he is crippled by the fear of the unknown might just be something he thought hed write a song about

[deft pasture]

12 minutes until redecorate sweeps

11

@

[robust maple]

i kinda wish the outside showed up later so it could’ve hung on a bit more

i wouldn’t be surprised if redecorate won the whole album

[gusty chasm]

better to get it out of the way imo

[olive coyote]

This is the most votes any song battle poll so far has gotten I think

[robust maple]

yeah that’s fair

[gusty chasm]

makes it less painful

[robust maple]

💔

[olive coyote]

It makes it even more painful if the outside loses

[robust maple]

two minutess

[short umbra]

Chill out man, we're right on time?

[deft pasture]

t

JESUS

[robust maple]

yeah

lmfao

[gusty chasm]

NOT EVEN CLOSE LMAO

[olive coyote]

Fuck y’all, that’s all I’ll say

I will avenge you the outside

[robust maple]

uh huh

[silent meadow]

the outside is not that bad

[deft pasture]

uh huh

[steady kiln]

Damn

[gusty chasm]

it isnt

[steady kiln]

People hate the outside ig

[gusty chasm]

but redecorate is just better

[deft pasture]

redecorate is just better

[robust maple]

the outaide is really good redecorate is just more popular

[steady kiln]

Outside was my favorite on my first listen of the album personally

[silent meadow]

over 2k votes is crazy

[steady kiln]

Not anymore but still

[robust maple]

i literally voted for the outside

[gusty chasm]

like the outside is top 3 but redecorate is top 1 lol

[robust maple]

i can’t spell 😭

[rare swan]

dawg

shit was destroyed

[graceful compass]

That’s crazy

This is the biggest voting difference I think I’ve ever seen 😭

[robust maple]

anyway goodbye outside v redecorate thread

[gusty chasm]

the topxmm votes were brutal

[deft pasture]

awap v bysyd doesn't exist anymore

[viscid fossil]

ngl The Outside did worse than I expected

[echo peak]

well good to know which song is winning the sai battle!

[shy quarry]

DAMN

I’m so happy but I’m shocked it was that much of a landslide

[shy quarry]

Same

[rancid river]

Hello Nick.

[shy quarry]

hi

[rancid river]

HmmMm

Ok bye have fun

[prisma wedge]

yall we did it new total vote count record

[brave dew]

I knew Redecorate would win, and I'm happy with it 'cause I love both, but I didn't expect The Outside to have so few votes !

[olive coyote]

I’m disappointed in all of you

[coarse arrow]

Same, The Outside is so good

[brave dew]

Yes !!

Btw, I didn't tell you, but I like your profile picture, we're twins of Jumpsuit Tyler !

[tawdry nymph]

WHAT??

The outside is so much better huh….

[coarse arrow]

OMG THANK YOUUUUUUUUUUU

[brave dew]