#2025 Self-Titled Song Battle #2

1 messages · Page 2 of 1

upbeat latch
#

respectable list

#

4

jagged dune
#

If sai is low you're getting burnt at the torch 💔💔 /j

gleaming zinc
#

im asking staff to ban you if you put SAI low

torn knot
#

IOFB

sleek crystal
#

The thing that sucks about tier lists is something has to be low

#

Tho vessel being low is crazy

#

Imo

jagged cairn
#
  1. blurryface sorry chat i love the instrumentals i just close my ears when tyler starts rapping
  2. Trench
  3. Clancy
  4. SAI
  5. self titled the lows are low the highs are HIGH
  6. Vessel I don’t like the production but I adore a select few songs
  7. Rab
gleaming zinc
#

nah vessel is overrated as fuck

trim torrent
#

Iofb gang

gleaming zinc
#

tho car radio and holding on to you is fire

sleek crystal
#

Yall take car radio and migraine for granted

stark apex
#

IOFB is so good

jagged dune
upbeat latch
stark apex
#

My 2nd favorite

jagged cairn
#

thank you

sleek crystal
#

Holding onto you as well and fake you out

stark apex
#

Off the album

gleaming zinc
jagged dune
#

Lane Boy has a good message but some of the lyrics 💔💔

past arch
#

ight chat I gtg do some work, cya

sleek crystal
#

Guns for hands is the only vessel song that i think is overrated imho but

gleaming zinc
jagged dune
sleek crystal
#

The album is still top tier

gleaming zinc
past arch
gleaming zinc
#

that was my first tøp song

#

ride is overrated af

jagged dune
#

Amazing song but one of their most listened to is crazy

gleaming zinc
#

i dont even really like the song tbh

jagged dune
#

I grew up with it so I'm biased

gleaming zinc
#

fair enough

sleek crystal
#

Ride is one of the weakest on the album imho

jagged dune
#

Ride and Polarize are the weakest imo

sleek crystal
#

But tyler likes it so its... acceptable.... (/j its still fine)

jagged dune
#

My dad likes to joke that they hate it because they have to play it a million times every time they go on tour 😭

gleaming zinc
loud vapor
#

March to the sea makes me cry but these two are my fav on the album

jagged dune
#

I don't really like the instrumental but still a good sobg

sleek crystal
#

Polarize sounds bipolar in a good way imo

jagged dune
gleaming zinc
sleek crystal
#

Iofb aint even top half of the album for me

loud vapor
#

I voted for march of the sea bc it makes me emotional

jagged dune
#

Gtg

#

Vyee

sleek crystal
#

Trapdoor is top 5 all time tøp songs for me imo

loud vapor
#

Trapdoor is so good

jagged dune
gleaming zinc
#

taxi cab is top 3 and it aint 2nd or 3rd

half flume
#

Personal album raking that’s really just based on feeling because I cannot choose between them

  1. RAB (scratches my brain and has a lot of relatability to me)
  2. self titled (similar to RAB)
  3. Clancy (again with the relatable songs and great production but not as many favs)
  4. vessel (I really like the electronic stuff)
  5. trench (great album, doesn’t exactly hit as hard as others)
  6. scales and icy (kinda really forgettable for me, and I find myself listening to the livestream versions more than the originals)
  7. blurryface (similar to SAI, but I find myself listening to the different versions more than the originals and it has the least songs on my playlist out them all)
#

Please execute me if this sucks btw

urban valley
#

Gotta give it to march

gleaming zinc
half flume
sleek crystal
#

I feel like trench is a good intro album

half flume
#

But it just is my favorite

gleaming zinc
sleek crystal
#

When i first started really getting into tøp i thought trench was by far the greatest album they could ever do

#

Now i consider it lower than vessel and clancy

half flume
#

I like this band too much to put actual thought into rankings

sleek crystal
#

If i had to rank rab it would always be 7 for me but thats bc like its such a weird album and doesnt exist/half the songs are done better on vessel anyways

half flume
#

Can I say I like the RAB versions a little better than vessel’s?

sleek crystal
#

Yeah its all subjective lol

#

I just find autotune usually grating

wraith olive
#

March to the sea

half flume
#

Like the little lallalas in OTS are really nice

sleek crystal
#

Contract is one of the few times i think their autotune is good

half shell
#
  1. RaB I love the electronic production it's great
  2. Trench the psychodelic sounds in the back are so lovely
  3. Clancy got some hits but a few songs are misses
  4. Scaled and Icy I love how it's different than the other albums
  5. Self Titled idk some songs on it are just kinda weird
  6. Blurryface idk it seems kind of cheeky after the 10 years but still some songs are amazing
  7. Vessel I do not get the hype behind most songs
gleaming zinc
half flume
#

For no reason

sleek crystal
#

For me not a single clancy song is a miss its probably their most consistently good album of the catalogue for me

#

Maybe no highs as good as trap door but the worst song is better than every other albums worse song imo

half shell
gleaming zinc
gleaming zinc
sleek crystal
#

Im a snap back truther so

gleaming zinc
#

both are goated

half flume
half shell
#

Like a 5/10

sleek crystal
#

Craving is one of the better jenna songs

#

I like it more than smithereens and tear in my heart

frail stratus
#

hydrogen bomb vs coughing baby part 2 oh my god

gleaming zinc
wraith olive
#

March to the sea gives me the chills
So does IOFB but March to the sea does it better
Love both tho

half flume
half shell
sleek crystal
#

Bottom 3 on the album

#

For me

gleaming zinc
wraith olive
#

Why are we talking about other albums in a self titled song battle 😭

half shell
sleek crystal
#

Its alot more intimate

#

Single sounds more radio slop

half shell
#

Too intimate

#

I LIKE THE RADIO SLOP

sleek crystal
#

Single craving sounds more radio slop then the sai songs people say are radio slop imo

gleaming zinc
wraith olive
#

Both versions of the craving are good but why are we talking about them in IOFB vs MTTS

half shell
#

because I said so

#

I started all of it

sleek crystal
#

March to the sea is better for me but i accept thats the hot take and its going to be a blowout

gleaming zinc
gleaming zinc
sleek crystal
#

Now if iofb wins against TRAPDOOR or air catcher then i will riot with pitchforks but

#

This one is a gimme

wraith olive
gleaming zinc
#

it is

wraith olive
#

I mean all Self Titled songs are but moreso MTTS

sleek crystal
#

People put march to the sea in the same class as like pantaloon and start your day and its weird it feels easily top half of the album for me

wraith olive
#

And maybe air catcher

gleaming zinc
#

i dont even like mtts but i can see that its underrated

sleek crystal
#

Air catcher is the definition of underrated

#

Least streamed top song and its top 3 on the album for me

gleaming zinc
#

i dont like air catcher

wraith olive
half shell
#

JENNA SONGS RANKED

  1. Smithereens it's just perfect the "you know I had to do one" bridge is so perfect
  2. Formidable I love how... peaceful... it is.
  3. Tear in My Heart a little too radio for me but still amazing
  4. The Craving kinda garbage imo but the single version is like okay I guess
wraith olive
#

Bashing a cute love song is vile

half flume
gleaming zinc
half shell
#

2nd best self titled song btw upvote_pink

half shell
gleaming zinc
#

no

sleek crystal
#

The craving is the best jenna song in the sense that its a jenna song

gleaming zinc
#

gtg

#

frfr

sleek crystal
#

It doesnt try to be a radio song with basic love messages

#

It feels the most real

half shell
#

I suppose

wraith olive
#

All of the Jenna songs are cute and I love them tbh

half flume
half shell
#

BUT SMITHEREENS MAN ❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹

half flume
#

The craving is just to Jenna

half shell
#

I WILL NOT TOLERATE ANY SMITHEREENS HATEEEEEE

half flume
#

NO SMITHEREENS SLANDER

wraith olive
cosmic lagoonBOT
sleek crystal
#

Its why i hate tear in my heart and smithereens as jenna songs bc dont get me wrong they are fine they feel very general love song-y

#

Good songs but not as good at being jenna songs imo

half shell
#

How the hell is smithereens a radio song

half flume
sleek crystal
#

Tear in my heart was a single for example it was intended to be catchy meanwhile listening to the craving at the concert is like we are listening to him personally sing just to jenna 1 that one song every night yknow

half shell
#

I actually forgot the craving even was on the concert

#

Did I even record it?

dim light
#

Love songs come in all shapes and sizes yall no need to compare em

wraith olive
#

How can a song be too "Radio song-y" aren't radio songs every goddamn song

sleek crystal
#

I love all these songs im just sayin my take

#

People are allowed to have takes

#

Except against trapdoor ofc if u hate it im coming to your house /j

wraith olive
#

Nobody stole my car radio and I hear single version on the radio 😔

#

I meant

#

Jenna's version

half shell
#

The only ever twenty one pilots song I hear on the radio is stressed out

wraith olive
#

I've heard songs like navigating and Jenna's version on the radio

wraith olive
dim light
#

I always hear ride on the radio

half shell
wraith olive
#

Ride is a good song what do you mean by that 😨

dim light
#

Lmao what

sleek crystal
#

Ride is alright but compared to the great top discography its lackluster imo

half shell
wraith olive
#

Ride is so good sijfnsmmerm

#

Blurryface on general is really good

#

Not one bad track

sleek crystal
#

Ride is like a goofy catchy radio song that i can enjoy but it doesnt hit the themes that i think of when i think twenty one pilots as much

half shell
#

Goner is a bad song

dim light
#

Well at least it’s a tøp song on the radio. That’s a rare pokemon

wraith olive
#

/nsrs

sleek crystal
#

Honestly blurryface is my weakest album from them

half shell
#

up until the build up it's so mid

sleek crystal
#

Its not bad its just so much twenty one pilots is good

drowsy briar
#

why did they make me choose between these two masterpieces

sleek crystal
#

Blurryface is the only album i will reliably skip a couple songs on usually the others i play full usually

dim light
#

Damn life must be hard

drowsy briar
#

i could never skip a blurryface song

sleek crystal
#

Tear in my heart is one of the few songs i skip reliably

half shell
#

Why do you guys even skip songs

sleek crystal
#

I know thats a very hot take but

half shell
#

nah but like i am not skipping any song on my playlists

dim light
#

Same except the overplayed ones

half shell
#

like if I don't like a song I don't have it on my playlists as simple as that

#

For your simple ass

sleek crystal
#

I listen to the songs by album generally

#

I dont have like a playlist

wraith olive
#

I'm the most basic ass person ever bc my favorite album is still Blurryface and my favorite song is still Stressed out

sleek crystal
#

Im not a fan of changing up albums in the middle of my listening

drowsy briar
half shell
wraith olive
sleek crystal
#

Listening to ode to sleep then jumpsuit then bounce man then paladin strait then ride is kinds disconcerting to me

wraith olive
#

I grew up with it... Explains my love for it lmao

gleaming zinc
dim light
half shell
sleek crystal
half shell
drowsy briar
sleek crystal
#

I said i dont listen to playlists i listen to albums bc jumping around is disconcerting

#

Just for me idk

wraith olive
gleaming zinc
#

i have a playlist thats dedicated to tøp

solid bridge
#

This is a war crime

#

HOW CAN I CHOOSE

dim light
#

Stressed out is one of their most relatable songs if you ask me

silk crow
#

Isle of FB is really good but march to the sea has always hit me in the feels harder

half shell
#

I have only listened to self titled like 9 months ago

drowsy briar
wraith olive
drowsy briar
gleaming zinc
drowsy briar
half shell
drowsy briar
gleaming zinc
#

for me it was

solid bridge
wraith olive
#

Stressed out is a little TOO relatable I'm CONSTANTLY stressed out 😨

drowsy briar
sleek crystal
dim light
subtle idol
#

iofb sweeps imo

sleek crystal
gleaming zinc
#

frfr

sleek crystal
#

Just i gotta be in the mood for music yknow

solid bridge
#

I don’t know Id say Kitchen Sink is pretty relatable

#

Helped a lot of people through tough times

half shell
#

I'd say every tøp song is relatable in some way

solid bridge
#

Yeah

#

That’s what I love about them

wraith olive
#

I think IOFB and The pantaloon are on the more popular side of the ST album and then Air catcher and MTTS are a bit more underrated

solid bridge
#

AIR CATCHER MY LOVE

silk crow
#

stressed out is the second best on blurryface by a bit

dim light
#

Did someone ever go to a tøp concert in pantaloons ?

wraith olive
drowsy briar
sleek crystal
#

Ive always thought it was one of if not the weakest on the album 😭

wraith olive
drowsy briar
solid bridge
#

And for good reason

half shell
solid bridge
#

That song hits so unbelievably hard

drowsy briar
dim light
solid bridge
drowsy briar
silk crow
#

if Implicit Demand is up against Trapdoor idk what im going to do

wraith olive
half shell
#

YOUR PROCTOLOGIST

sleek crystal
#

Trapdoor is honestly the number 1 top song for me period.

#

Definitely top 5 at least

drowsy briar
wraith olive
solid bridge
#

GOT BOTH HANDS ON YOUR SHOULDERS WHILE YOUR BOTTOMLESS

sleek crystal
#

And thats coming from someone who says clancy is the best overall album

gleaming zinc
#

lavish is peak

drowsy briar
dim light
#

The word lavish is just so satisfying to say

wraith olive
#

People that say stressed out is bad just bc it's overplayed make me angry 😔

gleaming zinc
drowsy briar
dim light
gleaming zinc
wraith olive
#

Best Clancy song is routines

drowsy briar
#

my top 3 from Clancy would probably be midwest, oldies and navigating in no specific order

dim light
#

Ouuu yeah routines

solid bridge
drowsy briar
dim light
#

Obssessed with the back vocals on routines

solid bridge
#

My favourite songs shift every other week

#

Lately I’ve been listening to Oldies Station on repeat

drowsy briar
sleek crystal
#

Which is why i was so fucking pumped for contract

gleaming zinc
#

guys its clearly oldies station

solid bridge
#

In my humble opinion I think their most relatable (released) album is Vessel

#

Like every verse on every song in vessel is relatable

sleek crystal
#

The contract is like routines if it was better and had the best parts of all the other albums

#

Contract might be top 5 all time for me but im not going to say for certain bc recency bias

solid bridge
#

The contract is like every album smashed together in heartbreaking lore

drowsy briar
dim light
#

Vessel just has so much meaning in every damn songs. I die everytime i listen to that album

gleaming zinc
#

the piano in the contract is crazy

solid bridge
solid bridge
sleek crystal
#

Every album has so much meaning

#

except some of sai

solid bridge
#

And then he started screaming and I was like IMAGINE THIS LIVE

sleek crystal
#

I only say that bc bounce man

gleaming zinc
#

sai is very relateable

solid bridge
#

If you focus on the lyrics

gleaming zinc
#

for diffrent sections of ones life

dim light
#

I think sai was just meant to be a vibey album

solid bridge
#

“Man tries to escape and gets framed for murder”

#

That’s how I interpreted it

#

“And then the gov. kills him”

sleek crystal
#

I hope the next album after breach is sai vibes

#

I want the optimistic sai vibes with some of the bass and shit from trench

#

And more synth

solid bridge
#

I kinda love SAI because of how ironic the music is versus the lyrics

#

LOST MY JOB MY WIFE MY CHILD

sleek crystal
#

HOMIE JUST SUED ME

gleaming zinc
#

honestly breach should have just randomly dropped

viscid creek
#

EASYYYYY Isle of sweepung birds 🔥

solid bridge
gleaming zinc
dim light
#

i gotta go study 🤓 hope you guys have a nice weekend

gleaming zinc
solid bridge
#

Because on Saturday we paint the town

late thorn
#

March To The Sea man

dim light
#

This exam week is a taste test of what i hate less (i hate everything)

sleek crystal
#

They wouldnt shadow drop it the store says its shipping september

#

Maybe they say september 20th and drop it 13th or some shit but def september

half shell
#

chat should I order the doubt demo vinyl if I don't have a vinyl player and don't really like the song?

lunar frigate
#

I get that Isle is technically a more catchy song but ugh I get chills every time I listen to March

ruby sable
#

Isle of flightless birds is peak bro

dim light
#

Keep your money for the concert

half shell
dim light
#

Dude im a 99,8765% sure there will be a europe leg anounced right after

wraith olive
#

Some of the lyrics that hit the most hard:
"Promise me this
If I lose to myself
You won't mourn a day
And you'll move onto someone else"

half shell
#

Ion have money either way

dim light
#

Then don’t waste your money on something you don’t like

sleek crystal
#

Id rather see top once than have all their merch ever

dim light
sleek crystal
dim light
#

Same

half shell
#

Breach seems mid anyway

#

hopefully they catch a break and won't do a tour outside of north america

dim light
half shell
dim light
#

I kinda agree but we havnt heard the rest of it sooo

#

And it’s kinda catchy once you listen to it a couple of times

#

Love the video

dusk narwhal
#

ISLE OF FLIGHTLESS BIRDS MY GOATTTT

unborn ruin
#

cries

#

I’m sorry March to the sea

cinder hedge
#

March to the sea

sleek crystal
#

Also its not like they only play their most recent album

spiral spire
#

Putting flightless birds up against march to the sea

drifting steeple
sleek crystal
#

Praying for a march upset but i know it wont happen

drifting steeple
#

it felt so one sided earlier lmho

#

here’s hoping the quiet majority vote mtts

sleek crystal
#

I know it wont win but im voting that shit all day

spiral spire
#

I cant decide, both are in my top songs off of self-titled

drifting steeple
#

it clears

spiral spire
#

As much as I like flightless birds, i voted for mtts

sleek crystal
#

Flight is good of course but march is just straight up better for me

cinder hedge
#

I love March to the sea

lunar mural
#

IOFB!!!

fresh lily
#

iofb sweep

tardy prawn
#

ez

bronze plume
#

iofb solos

willow pagoda
#

sweep

fierce cedar
#

March To The Sea

#

Underrated

nimble anvil
#

IOFB is that final boss music. It’s also my top3 self titled songs.

random plume
#

I love them both so much but for me the outro from Isle of Flightless Birds is just too beautiful for it not to get my vote.

shut yoke
#

see i feel like such a traitor 'cause i used to say self titled was my favorite but then i realized that it was just select songs on them I loved more than all the other songs combined but as a whole I don't love most of the songs. I don't really like either of these either

#

i mean they're both really good, but i don't enjoy listening to them

#

i'll probably say march to the sea though

topaz raptor
#

birdy

manic iron
#

🐤

small root
#

march to the sea is so underrated the vibe is unmatched

#

the bridge is so good

charred gust
#

ISLE IS ONE OF THE BEST TWENTY ONE PILOTS SONGS I SAID IT

cosmic lagoonBOT
charred gust
strong condor
#

Isle of flightless birds

cinder palm
#

im ngl i never fw iofb idk why but yeah I do like march to the sea so im going with that

dim spoke
#

IOFB FTW!!!!!

drifting steeple
high eagle
#

march my guy

fresh lily
#

It's too cold in March to go to the sea anyway

#

iofb better

woven falcon
#

“Giving birth and stuff”

#

Peak writing Tyler thank you so much

runic ice
#

All we are

acoustic vortex
#

wait this is crazy i just spent all of last night learning iofb on guitar

#

gives me all the more reason to vote for it

charred gust
#

All we are is an isle of flightless birds
We find our worth in giving birth and stuff
We're lining our homes against winding roads

#

Absolute peak writing

urban fable
#

EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL FUXKING ROUND

#

YOU CANT FUCKING DO THIS

#

NOT ON ROUND 2

spice widget
gray saddle
#

ISLE OF FLIGHTLESS BIRDS

spice hawk
#

iofb is TOO iconic to lose to march to the sea bro

analog moon
#

Yeah Isle of flightless birds is def winning Paimonsnack

spice hawk
#

no chances it loses

runic ice
#

It deserves it. It's also great live.

cosmic mason
#

i love march to the sea but this is an easy isle sweep and i ain’t complaining 🐦‍⬛ 🐦‍⬛ 🐦‍⬛

high eagle
#

i hear a voice inside my head
saying follow me instead

high eagle
spice hawk
high eagle
#

lol

lunar frigate
#

🛸 Follow me instead

sleek crystal
#

Saying follow meeeeeeee

lunar frigate
#

Lol why did that send soooo big

fluid karma
#

I change my vote every hour

#

I can't decide

strong cedar
#

Idk but for me it's easily Isle of flightless birds

analog moon
pastel snow
#

good golly this one’s hard

#

but mtts 🥺

frosty badger
#

march to the sea is my favorite twenty one pilots song ever

fresh lily
#

but consider this

#

iofb

strong cedar
frosty badger
vapid crescent
#

Johnny boy losing is criminal

gleaming zinc
viscid creek
#

Hell yeah

cinder palm
#

what the fuck

gleaming zinc
#

ez

strong cedar
#

I knew Isle of flightless birds would win clancheeheegiggle

sleek crystal
#

Yeah expected

#

But even by that much

#

God damn

pallid yacht
#

JUSTICE FOR MARCH TO THE SEA

green basin
#

i HATE isle bro

upbeat latch
#

not surprising

#

the 3 fans of mtts are probably mad

pallid yacht
fresh lily
#

sweeeeeeep

pallid yacht
#

Justice for March to the sea 😭

spice hawk
#

genuinely not surprising 💀