#Clancy Song Battle #25

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

craggy jacinthBOT
#

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1721574000:R>

thin lantern
#

oh

vital lake
#

check IIIIIN

frosty latch
#

that was easy

dreamy gorge
#

Voted atrofd

glass junco
#

i don’t wanna pick

oblique python
#

ITS NOT WORTH THE RISK OF LOSING A FRIEEEEND

glass junco
#

they’re both so good

thin lantern
#

this is too hard

glacial goblet
#

ATROFD

crystal moth
#

MIDWEST INDIGO

thin lantern
#

gonna have to go with midwest indigo

soft blaze
#

def atrofd

sleek warren
#

Ah shit

glacial goblet
soft blaze
tough forge
#

if yall vote midwest youre just asking for a navigating and midwest rematch

why would you

image.png
full fog
#

MIDWEST INDIGOO

fading blade
#

I love lowereast lilac guys

shy bough
#

Why cant navigating lose smh

high prism
#

I DONT WANT ANYONE KNOW ME OR NOT

stray lichen
#

If Midwest sweeps I will be very disappointed

ruby oracle
#

this is crazy navigating and atrofd are so overrated 😭 don’t deserve top 5

fluid latch
civic depot
#

DID YOU PULL UP YET 🗣️🗣️

fading blade
gritty seal
rain scarab
#

Hopefully ATROFD can beat Navigating if it wins here

trim totem
#

midwest gotta win here

west compass
#

I CANT VOTE IM GONNA DIE

lapis sorrel
#

No way..

outer rivet
#

damn

#

i genuinely don't know

west compass
#

MY NIGHTMARE HAS COME TRUE

lavish bridge
#

at the risk of feeling dumb sounds like shit compared to Midwest indigo

verbal dagger
#

midwest for me ‼️

serene steppe
#

Midwest clears

orchid zenith
verbal dagger
#

my eta may be 2 minutes

sour stag
#

Midwest fs

earnest trail
#

alright i guess this is the 3rd place battle

drifting geyser
#

CHECK IIIIINNNN

outer rivet
serene steppe
#

Midwest is one of the only songs on Clancy better than feeling dumb

balmy oxide
#

Midwest easy. ATROFD is mid city

serene steppe
#

Let's be real

foggy vector
#

midwest indiGOAT

foggy vector
slate patio
#

it’s nicover oldies shoulda won fr

orchid zenith
#

True

foggy vector
teal lichen
#

I can't do this anymore

drifting geyser
serene steppe
orchid zenith
#

Oldies station should have beaten midwest indigo

fiery scarab
#

MIDwest Indigo

serene steppe
fiery scarab
serene steppe
fiery scarab
#

I quite like it

foggy vector
languid arrow
#

MIDWEST FTW

west compass
#

my 2 fav songs pitted against each other 😿

orchid zenith
foggy vector
#

and I want love and sunny days

outer rivet
#

do you guys even like their music 😭

foggy vector
#

I'm a bit too old to run away

outer rivet
#

i swear y'all just hate

foggy vector
#

best bridge ever

drifting geyser
#

Midwest indigo is such a cute song but atrofd has such a good message and a catchy tune for. e

manic furnace
#

If I'm even gonna vote on this one I'm gonna listen to both first

foggy vector
hallow patrol
coral wren
foggy vector
hallow patrol
#

Sometimes they leave out the message 💀

drifting geyser
foggy vector
#

next semester is goated

hallow patrol
deep spade
#

Midwest Indigo ez

worldly pebble
#

MIDWEST!

dreamy panther
#

REACHING OUT ON MY WAY HOME

queen abyss
#

ATROFD

fair vine
#

ATROFD! 🔥 the meaning of it for me

cerulean fjord
#

i love both aghhh 😭

quasi maple
#

midwest 🫶🏻

left sandal
#

Midwest indigo top 1

dry knot
#

i dont want

#

anyone know me or not

#

to even try

#

stopping me

tropic lily
#

AT THE RISKKKKK

#

ON TOP

torn glacier
#

Midwest a w

ornate ether
#

Midwest>>>

deep elbow
#

Both are good but ATROFD has a more important message.

tropic lily
#

what's the best song on blurryface

prisma minnow
#

HAVE U EVER HEARD THE OUTSIDE CALLING?? 🗣️🗣️

#

ATROFD

deep elbow
tropic lily
pure cairn
#

JIM

tropic lily
#

The Judge for me

deep elbow
pallid jasper
tropic lily
gusty grail
#

risk absolutely

tropic lily
pallid jasper
#

Okay, I know that popular doesn’t necessarily mean better, but I’m still a sucker for the first 6 on that album

rich vale
#

check innnnn

tropic lily
#

I think that's fair

deep elbow
pallid jasper
#

I was just wondering because I’m new to the server (but not TOP) and whenever BF is brought up, it’s like people generally don’t like it, which confused me

tropic lily
low valley
#

BF is my fav album

tropic lily
#

I used to love all the songs on BF

#

but now I have some ones I dislike

#

like Fairly Local and Doubt (just my opinion don't hate on me)

pallid jasper
#

Nice, I just see a lot of “BF has garbage production and the album sucks other than Goner and Fairly Local”

blazing oyster
#

for as big as it is i feel like i overlook BF alot

deep elbow
#

I don’t like blurryface as much anymore bc I listened to it so much

tight latch
#

nobody’s checking in

tropic lily
#

JUST KEEP YOUR PLANS

#

I HOPEEEE

#

THAT YOU NEVER HAVE TO DROP

tight latch
#

I DONT WANT ANYONE KNOW ME OR NOT

tropic lily
#

SEE ME LOWEST YOU DO DON'T HAVE TO DROP

#

DROP DROP DROP

#

ANYTHING

#

FOR ME

tight latch
#

🎹🎹🎹🎹🎹

tropic lily
#

HERE COMES TO DROP

#

*THE

#

hits different

tight latch
tropic lily
#

oooh my blood

pallid jasper
manic furnace
#

I've decided to not vote on this one

tropic lily
manic furnace
#

tis too hard

spice solstice
#

Midwest indigo

tropic lily
#

AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB CHECK INNNNNNN

deep elbow
thin lantern
#

ima change my vote to atrofd

tropic lily
#

common at the riskkkk

manic furnace
#

Oh also I haven't been pinged for the past few ones

thin lantern
manic furnace
#

Tus terrible

#

Tis*

thin lantern
#

i never even remember to vote so- 😭

manic furnace
#

rargh

rocky harness
#

midwest indigo vs at the risk of feeling peak

thin lantern
tropic lily
#

if at the risk wins then it has to go against navigating and it will probably lose because everyone glazes navigating

deep elbow
tropic lily
#

hehe

rocky harness
#

and i mean mid by the definition

#

people use mid nowadays to be negative

#

i mean mid as in like

#

it might be the most median song on clancy

#

i don't have any positive or negative opinions on it

manic furnace
#

fair

rocky harness
#

incredibly average

thin lantern
deep elbow
rocky harness
#

at the peak of peaking peak

pure wadi
#

Ok Midwest has to win this time

tropic lily
pure wadi
#

it does

deep elbow
hazy pewter
#

at the risk

pure wadi
#

Especially against atrofd

deep elbow
#

ATROFD

midnight obsidian
#

No way y’all are saying Midwest is that much better than atrofd

pure wadi
#

This should be eeeeeasy

thin lantern
#

at the risk of feeling dumb CHICKEEN

pure wadi
#

I’m not saying much better

deep elbow
#

Important message

#

Better song

pure wadi
#

Important message ≠ good song

deep elbow
#

CHICCKKENNNN

deep elbow
thin lantern
#

its not worth the risk of losing a hen 🗣️

pure wadi
#

You could say “suicide bad” over a hyper pop beat and still get a shit song

pure wadi
#

But Midwest is more sonically interesting

#

And more unique

rocky harness
#

at no risk of losing 🧐

pallid jasper
#

I feel like the escalation on AtRoFD is an example of some of the best stuff TØP can do

rocky harness
deep elbow
#

Unless they’re in an egg carton

soft tinsel
#

At the risk of feeling dumb

pure wadi
tropic lily
#

yay Morph

#

best song in Trench fr fr

thin lantern
tropic lily
#

fr

#

Tyler is cooking

pallid jasper
undone imp
#

ATROFD

pure wadi
#

but morph still fucks

pure wadi
deep spade
pure wadi
#

atrofd has the same issue as oldies where it doesn’t get to the good part until the very end

#

or at least the best part

#

Midwest, routines, vignette etc are interesting throughout the entire runtime

deep spade
#

Trench feels like Blurryface
But more rugged and mature from a production and lyrical standpoint

#

Which is why I like it
Even though I became a fan through BF

deep spade
pallid jasper
pallid jasper
tropic lily
loud badger
loud badger
tropic lily
#

BUM BUM BUM BUM

#

BUM BUM BUM BUM

deep spade
tropic lily
#

NOT SURE WHERE IT STARTED

#

me listening to vignette

deep spade
tropic lily
#

CLINGING TOOOOOO

#

PROMISESSSSS

#

FIGHTING OFFFF

#

THE VIGNETTEEEEE

pallid jasper
naive shale
#

At the risk all the way IT MUST WIN

loud badger
#

i would love if at the risk reaches the finals but we gotta be real, i'm surprised my boy has reached this far in the battle, even vignette is not here anymore so i yeah, third spot seems good for me because i think it's gonna lose against midwest

deep spade
pure wadi
tropic lily
pure wadi
#

actually

tropic lily
#

DON'T DISRESPECT IT

pure wadi
#

i wouldnt go as far as amazing but it certainly is a bop

#

i would agree it's consistent

deep spade
#

Lavish is camp asf
I vibe with it

#

Even if it's out of place on Clancy
We vibin

hollow token
#

Midwest

vast sleet
#

at the risk

mighty cypress
#

At the risk 🔥

vale moss
#

Of feeling dumb 🥰

mighty cypress
cosmic dagger
thin lantern
#

welcome back high hopes

loud badger
#

i hope they surprise me with atrofd winning but i think that's not possible

loud badger
crystal moth
#

now that the recency bias is over, atrofd is just not as good as midwest indigo

loud badger
#

it's far from bad don't get me wrong

#

but the hype behind the music videos and the fact that it's the longest song the final song all of that made me rank it insanely high

#

for what it is it's really good, but definitely in the middle ground of the album

pure wadi
lime path
#

ATROFD

#

Peak

tardy hinge
prisma minnow
#

atrofd easy

#

CHECK IIINN

lime path
#

This transition is PEAK

#

Best transition ever no competition

#

/silly

lone mesa
#

Midwest Indigo

#

Easy

#

I love ATROFD but not more than Midwest Indigo

lone mesa
full fog
#

Midsweep indigo

lime path
#

I wanna preface this by saying I absolutely do not hate or dislike Midwest indigo this is only for the competition

fading smelt
#

RISK PLEASE

lime path
#

I don't mean it

#

It's just for the competition

#

But ATROFD is leagues better

#

Best song off the album

#

One of the best in general too

sick zenith
#

Seeing people trying to spell the song titles in the reactions to all of these is so funny

lime path
sick zenith
#

Ah yes. Midaw💙est rof

lime path
loud badger
upper meteor
#

Guys it’s clancy song battle number TWENTY FIVE

exotic shard
#

atrofd

cunning ginkgo
#

every single time at the risk of feeling dumb is an option, you'll find me in the song battle chat advocating like my life depends on it grief

#

here we go again...

#

y'all already know what to do

amber stratus
#

Atrofd

#

But winner is already decided

jade quest
#

midwest all the way

orchid zenith
nova cave
#

atrofd easily

grim tendon
#

MIDWEST

trim kelp
#

Ummmm

#

Idk

barren pewter
#

no cuz why did VIGNETTE LOSE WHAT THE FUCK

#

I haven't voted since its loss

#

I can't

#

no mas

gritty tendon
#

midwest heeheegiggle

tame forge
#

why does it only ping me every other day

#

anyways atrofd ‼️‼️

cerulean fjord
stoic sequoia
#

Midwest

loud badger
#

i think it's gonna be more tied than i thought it'd be

#

i thought atrofd was gonna lose by a mile but i'm seeing a lot of atrofd fans here

rapid sinew
#

its a good song

rapid sinew
silent pond
#

atrofd easy

paper mist
#

ATROFD EASY

abstract tundra
#

**ATROFD EASY **

cerulean fjord
#

but lavish is something ;-;

rapid sinew
#

lmao

dry knot
#

wait

#

this is

#

#25 ..

#

oh no

placid mantle
#

WHAT THE FUVJ

#

WHY IS IT SO HARD AGAIN

#

oh its gonna be this vs navigating isnt it

prisma minnow
#

yes

#

forever voting navigating above all else

mild hatch
#

Unpopular opinion atrofd is extremely overrated

rigid oriole
loud scroll
#

Nuh uh

#

Take it back

deep spade
hasty jolt
#

Atrofd all the way

loud badger
#

it might have more people that love it but that won't make it overrated

fading smelt
#

man only one of my all time favs made it to the top 3 😭

#

  1. Next Semester (which died)

  2. At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb (which is still alive)

  3. Oldies Station (which is dead 😭)

loud badger
fading smelt
#

i mean honestly i enjoy every clancy song almost the same amount lol

normal birch
#

midwest indigo

#

enough said

atomic sand
#

Little gap in the 🧊

lunar storm
#

atrofd

#

midwest indigo feels too radio-made idk how to explain it i used to L O V E it but it just feels like a song with no meaning im sorry

stable kiln
#

kinda hard to super love it if youre not from the midwest or ohio

#

def speaks to me more as a midwesterner, but i dont think it has no meaning

#

love and hate between someone’s hometown

fading smelt
#

i don't personally relate to midwest indigo as much as i love the song, but i relate far more to atrofd so that's why i vote for it

cunning ginkgo
rain scarab
lunar storm
#

idk

rain scarab
#

It can be interpreted in a few different was actually

lunar storm
#

idk how to explain it, it just feels like it gets worse and feels more like basic pop-rock every time i listen to it

#

and that's coming from someone who used to have midwest indigo as their favorite song on the album

rain scarab
#

Ok

cunning ginkgo
#

at the risk of feeling dumbbbb

#

check innnnn

#

it's not worth the risk of losing a friendddd

#

even if they sayyyyy

rain scarab
#

Where's the next battle

soft blaze
#

nicos thinking about it

#

hes not sure about this one

rain scarab
soft blaze
#

real

rain scarab
#

Bro refused to show the result 💀

craggy jacinthBOT
rain scarab
#

Speaking of the devil

soft blaze
#

bro is busy leveling you up rn

rain scarab
#

Oh yeah

#

Gotta deal with the important stuff first

deep spade
#

Nico buddy, you okay?😭
Was Midwest Indigo power too strong?

exotic shard
#

atrofd

deep spade
rain scarab
#

Maybe he doesn't want Midwest to lose to Navigating again

#

8 more people already voted since that delay

frozen echo
trim kelp
#

Nico is probably busy catching banditos

thin lantern
ruby cypress
amber stratus
#

did atrofd vs midwest break nico

#

OH

#

its because both songs already lost to navigating

rigid rose
#

What happene

amber stratus
#

and poot said they made it so that they wouldnt battle the same songs again

#

so because navigating is left nico doesnt know what to do

#

@earnest trail am i correct or am i yapping nonsense

soft blaze
#

omg😭

trim kelp
earnest trail
#

i think you're right

prisma minnow
#

that means navigating auto wins

#

W navigating clear

amber stratus
grand dawn
trim kelp
#

let's just agree on every song winning

fluid latch
#

Wait so who won?

upper meteor
#

Where’s Clancy song battle number 26 william

fading smelt
#

💀

deep spade
trim kelp
deep spade
#

Trench clears

fluid latch
serene cairn
#

@craggy jacinth WAKE UP

rain scarab
trim kelp
#

@craggy jacinth

#

@craggy jacinth

#

r u ok?

fading blade
#

nico is running late today huh

copper star
#

zzzz

#

bro does not know how long 24 hours is

cunning ginkgo
#

where's the results omg

#

nico you good???

#

anyways i'm pretty sure at the risk of feeling dumb CLEARED as always

#

AS IT SHOULD

thin lantern
#

clancy killed nico 😔 💔

cunning ginkgo
#

damn no wonder he didn't give us an update

upper meteor
#

Nico died after Clancy song battle 25. Coincidence?

vale moss
#

nico what’s your eta

upper meteor
#

24 HOURS

loud badger
loud badger
#

we're all diseased

loud badger
dry knot
#

it is

#

both songs already lost to navigating

#

they wouldnt battle the same songs again so

loud badger
#

ooh

dry knot
#

nico just

#

doesnt know

#

what to do

#

so tldr

#

navigating won clanky song battles ig

loud badger
#

should we just wait or?

#

idk

loud badger
#

if it doesn't know what to do it's gonna stay in that state in some sort of soft lock

cerulean canopy
#

next semester should still have 2 lives

dry knot
#

ok navigating sweep

prisma minnow
#

navigating cleared

#

as it should

dry knot
#

i still fw lavash

amber stratus
trim kelp
#

Routines w was deserved

amber stratus
#

Midwest had a way better run than expected tbh

trim kelp
#

but I agree Next Semester should have come further

prisma minnow
#

NAVIGATING CLEAR

#

LETS GOOOOO

orchid zenith
#

RAHHHHH

muted stump
#

W line up

ornate ether
#

I actually support this win

slate patio
#

hate crime

orchid zenith
#

Rest in peace oldies station

nova cave
#

MID WON!!!

languid arrow
#

Damn how did Midwest lose

slate patio
#

against midwestern people

orchid zenith
#

Should've been 3

vast sleet
#

YAY

vapid vale
#

LETS GOO

ruby oracle
#

worst ranking ever

blissful silo
#

L midwest indigo haha

nova cave
#

I HATE NAVIGATING

naive shale
#

WHAT

slate patio
hard saddle
#

PARDON MY DELAY

dense flower
#

MIDWEST INDIGO SUCKS

serene cairn
#

HOW DID MIDWEST INDIGO TAKE TOP 3

ornate ether
#

YALL i love Midwest but Navigating is amazing

slate patio
#

yall are blinded by the lore 😔

serene cairn
#

IT LITERALLY HAS “MID” IN THE NAME

timber sail
#

LETSGO NAVIGATING WIN

nova cave
#

MIDWEST ALSO SUCKS

ornate ether
ruby oracle
#

how is midwest not 1 😭

stable tide
#

I'm shocked Next semester didn't get higher

barren pewter
#

IT SHOULDVE BEEN VIGNETTE/OLDIES/NEXT SEM

modest obsidian
#

Navigating is soooo repetitive tho 😭😭😭

languid arrow
#

Oh Im talking Midwest vs ATROFD

earnest trail
#

can't believe overcompensate or next semester didnt make it

orchid zenith
serene cairn
languid arrow
#

LETS GO NAVIGATING

trim kelp
#

ROUTINES IN THE NIGHT WHERE

cerulean canopy
ruby oracle
#

navigating and atrofd mid city

slate patio
naive shale
#

AT THE RISK NO AT THE RISK SHOULDVE WON

timber sail
#

NAVIGATING ITS BETTER THAN ALL CLANCY

deep elbow
#

NAVIGATING YEAHHH

west compass
#

navigating is so overhyped personally 😭

cerulean canopy
#

happy with navigating win tho!

vast sleet
blissful silo
trim kelp
#

Next Semester > Navigating

orchid zenith
#

WE GOT 2/3

dense flower
#

SHOULD HAVE BEEN NS/VIGNETTE/OLDIES

bleak canyon
#

i though oldies station or paladin or lavish would have won

pallid jungle
#

guys what’s with this midwest indigo hate..

young vigil
#

GUYS :(

ruby oracle
#

my oh my is the only good part of navigating

copper star
#

navigating is the worst song on clancy

fresh sage
#

lavish

blissful silo
timber sail
#

NAVIGATING ITS BETTER THAN ALL CLANCY

cerulean canopy
#

twas either navigating or next semester so this is okay

stable tide
#

I'd say Next Semester is top 3. C'mon now

slate patio
#

blinded by lore fr

orchid zenith
cerulean canopy
stable tide
young vigil
#

nothing could ever make me hate you midwest indigo 💔

nova cave
#

navigating is legit bottom 3

slate patio
#

WHY ARE WE HATING ON MIDWEST INDIGOAT

ruby oracle
stiff walrus
#

atrofd should have won bro

modest obsidian
cerulean canopy
copper star
#

ROUNTINES IN THE NIGHT IS BETTER THAN ANY OF THESE SONGS

serene cairn
orchid zenith
shy bough
#

Booooooo

young vigil
shy bough
#

Not my winner

stable tide
young vigil
#

no

stiff walrus
timber sail
#

aside the lore, Navigating it's absolutely incredible, better than atrofd

deep elbow
shy bough
#

Yes

barren pewter
vast sleet
#

everyone has opinions; but my personal ranking would be
1 at the risk
2 navigating
3 routines

slate patio
#

big dema rigged the results

fluid latch
#

Navigating is deserved but At the risk and Midwest in the top 3 is just false imo

young vigil
#

guys im such a hater but midwest indigo was and will always be my #1

deep elbow
stable tide
stiff walrus
#

how is lavish not top 3 though

deep elbow
#

(Joking)

copper star
west compass
shy bough
#

Routines is best. Idc you are all wrong

slate patio
#

lavish was like 3rd to go out

orchid zenith
#

I'm not even a midwest indigo hater I just like oldies more

shy bough
#

Mods rigged it

ruby oracle
#

navigating had so much potential and then it falls off immediately in the first verse 😭

serene steppe
#

Wrong I demand a recount, Navigating is one of the worst on Clancy

vast sleet
trim kelp
slate patio
blissful silo
#

my top 3 wishlist was
Navigating
Oldies
Next Sem

naive shale
#

atrofd shouldve won

serene cairn
#

My personal top 3:

Oldies Station
Routines In The Night
ATROFD

slate patio
#

i claimed oldies way back when and i stand by it

stable tide
fluid latch
#

Next Semester will forever be my number one

ruby oracle
#

tyler is going to throw a fit when he sees this

deep elbow
blissful silo
copper star
#

I DEMAND A RECOUNT

earnest trail
#

navigation

trim kelp
shy bough
#

Not my winner

mild hatch
#

Next semester robbed

vast sleet
shy bough
#

Poot rigged it

slate patio
#

@poot why would you (big dema) rig this election

shy bough
#

🙂

blissful silo
copper star
#

this election was botted

stable tide
slate patio
#

the ones we did in the song battles thread are my real clancy song battles

blissful silo
vast sleet
shy bough
#

And my nickname is the truth

blissful silo
shy bough
#

Its the real winner and anyone who disagrees is wrong

dry knot
#

honestly I wanted a Scaled and Icy 2! Something GOOD for the sou…

west compass
#

I’m honestly glad at least my 2 fav songs on the album won

stable tide
shy bough
#

Nope

haughty acorn
#

LETS GOOOOOOO

deep elbow
#

ENOUGH WITH ROUTINES! I GET IT, YOU LIKE THAT SONG BUT IT IS SO OVERRATED

haughty acorn
#

Navigating deserves the win

west compass
shy bough
#

You are wrong

naive shale
#

my top 3 is 1atrofd 2oldies 3 vignette

haughty acorn
stable tide
shy bough
haughty acorn
vast sleet
shy bough
haughty acorn
#

😡

shy bough
#

Im always right 🙂

onyx bobcat
#

honeslty, PERFECT

stable tide
rigid oriole
#

LESGOOOO YALL

haughty acorn
#

😡😡

onyx bobcat
rigid oriole
#

MY FAITH IN HUMANITY IS RESTORED

west compass
onyx bobcat
#

it was perfect

hazy shale
#

i mean i’m not really surprised. navigating is very good

vast sleet
shy bough
deep elbow
#

Ok, goodbye for now I don’t like arguing see you guys later

hazy shale
#

backslide still should have won (or at least top three) but still

vast sleet
rigid oriole
onyx bobcat
#

should have switched next semester with atrofd

stable tide
shy bough
#

Not my winner

vast sleet
shy bough
#

Not my winner

clear matrix
#
  1. ATROFD
  2. Navigating
  3. Vignette=Midwest
rigid oriole
amber stratus
#

CLANKY RANKINGS AFTER CLANCY SONG BATTLES:
#1: Navigating (up from #3)
#2: At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb (up from #4)
#3: Midwest Indigo (up from #9)
#4: Vignette (down from #1)
#5 Oldies Station (down from #2)
#6: Routines In The Night (unchanged)
#7: Next Semester (down from #5)
#8: Overcompensate(up from #10)
#9: Paladin Strait
#10: Lavish
#11: Backslide (down from 8)
#12: Snap Back
#13-14:The Craving (both versions)

shy bough
copper star
#

hi

#

lol

clear matrix
stable tide
rigid oriole
shy bough
rain scarab
west compass
vast sleet
#

goodbye brethren

deep elbow
rigid oriole
amber stratus
hazy shale
#

no offense but to the nobody asked people you are using seventh grader comebacks

tropic lily
#

at the risk will always be #1

rain scarab
#

Jenna's version is one of the best songs on the album

amber stratus
shy bough
#

And routines didnt win

deep elbow
#

Snap back doesn’t deserve this hate

stable tide
onyx bobcat
#

routines mids song battles

west compass
shy bough
vast sleet
rigid oriole
shy bough
#

Cause they cant handle im right

onyx bobcat
hazy shale
#

for me it’s 1. backslide 2. lavish 3. craving (single version) but i think all of those were eliminated pretty early

shy bough
#

Coward

civic depot
#

Lol Tyler Joseph your least favorite song won

onyx bobcat
#

LMAO

rigid oriole
hazy shale
onyx bobcat
#

lmao

shy bough
#

Do it then

west compass
shy bough
#

Routines is the best song and if you don’t like it

#

You are with the idiots who rigged song battles

prisma minnow
onyx bobcat
#

woah

#

found a good pun

deep elbow
winter crest
#

RAHHHH

#

NAVIGATING

rain scarab
placid mantle
#

next semester doesnt deserve what it got

amber stratus
#

Midwest going from #9 to #3 is mad crazy, deserved tho I should've ranked it higher in the seeding but oh well it's #3 overall now so

shy bough
winter crest
#

YAYYAYAAY

rigid oriole
vast sleet
onyx bobcat
#

routines is edgy so it should be called edgy teens in the night

shy bough
rigid oriole
onyx bobcat
prisma minnow
shy bough
west compass
#

Justice for the craving & next semester 😞

rigid oriole
rain scarab
stable tide
rigid oriole
shy bough
vast sleet
#

alright i’m outta here 😭

frozen echo
#

idc next semester should have won

barren pewter
prisma minnow
#

navigating deserved the win

shy bough
#

Routines is the real winner

hazy shale
# shy bough Wrong

did you know that music is entirely subjective and all people’s favorite songs and such are entirely based on personal preference? :0

rigid oriole
prisma minnow
#

vignette made it way too far its so mid

prisma minnow
prisma minnow
onyx bobcat
#

navigating deserved, but next semester should have been higher

prisma minnow
#

frl

shy bough
#

Nope

rigid oriole
hazy shale
shy bough
#

Keep being wrong

onyx bobcat
prisma minnow
rigid oriole
shy bough
#

Can someone downvote all their comments

onyx bobcat
#

sob

deep elbow
prisma minnow
#

routines is boring after the intro ends

west compass
hazy shale
frozen echo
grim pelican
#

I thought SB winner is gonna battle clanky winner at the end :( @earnest trail

rigid oriole
shy bough
#

Song Battles is rigged confirmed

frozen echo
amber stratus
hazy shale
#

your face is rigged GOT EM

shy bough
#

And thats my last words on this

frozen echo
#

i like kiwis

deep elbow
rigid oriole
shy bough
prisma minnow
frozen echo
west compass
#

I feel like it’s the fan favorite

onyx bobcat
shy bough
amber stratus
#

Too anyone who wants the clanky community rankings after song battles here you go:

#1: Navigating (up from #3)
#2: At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb (up from #4)
#3: Midwest Indigo (up from #9)
#4: Vignette (down from #1)
#5 Oldies Station (down from #2)
#6: Routines In The Night (unchanged)
#7: Next Semester (down from #5)
#8: Overcompensate(up from #10)
#9: Paladin Strait
#10: Lavish
#11: Backslide (down from 8)
#12: Snap Back
#13-14:The Craving (both versions)

rigid oriole
#

I’m learning new things here

deep elbow
rigid oriole
#

Cool

onyx bobcat
#

#MID: Routines In The Night (unchanged) 😭

deep elbow
#

Some acid

#

Thing

#

Idk

onyx bobcat
#

mid as in Middle

rigid oriole
frozen echo
#

funny acid

barren pewter
#

enzymes

shy bough
#

Hiroshi funny way to say your opinions are mid

rigid oriole
onyx bobcat
worldly pebble
#

this result is unreal

#

How’s Midwest lost that

rigid oriole
amber stratus
worldly pebble
shy bough
#

Most people arent me

onyx bobcat
#

this result is kinda goated except Overcompensate and Next Semester being SO LOW

rigid oriole
shy bough
#

Navigating is top 5

#

Not 1

rigid oriole
worldly pebble
#

Atrofd IS NOT the second best

onyx bobcat
#

real

worldly pebble
rigid oriole
onyx bobcat
amber stratus
frozen echo
#

for me it is grief

prisma minnow
deep elbow
amber stratus
#

But nah it lost to ATROFD so welp

prisma minnow
#

I thought oldies would be higher but it's top 5 so it's all good

hazy shale
#

my top three are in the bottom four of community rankings 🥲but i think in general navigating is the fan favorite and it’s a very good song so i think it deserves the win

worldly pebble
#

message doesn’t matter when the song isn’t as good as the other. If they were equal in quality, message would top it. But atrofd is just not as good

rigid oriole
shy bough
#

Top three to me. Routines, vignette, midwest

#

And nobodys gonna agree

amber stratus
west compass
#

esp the second half of the song

rigid oriole
trim kelp
#

At the moment at least

rigid oriole
worldly pebble
amber stratus
#

Snap back, vignette, ritn for me

hazy shale
rigid oriole
worldly pebble
#

oops

hazy shale
#

oh wait that would be bottom five my bad

#

not four

fluid latch
vocal rain
#

Lets go NAVIGATING WON!!
My personal top 3:

  1. Navigating
  2. Next Semester
  3. Midwest Indigo
west compass
amber stratus
worldly pebble
#

I don’t think it props atrofd so high it’s very mid level in the album

onyx bobcat
#

routines lowkey in the middle
oc top 5
ns top 5
navigating top 1

upper meteor
#

my top 3:

  1. Next Semester
  2. Vignette
  3. Navigating
prisma minnow
frozen echo
fluid latch
#

My personal top 3:

Navigating
Oldies Station
Navigating

Though Oldies Station and Navigating can really swap, I love both of them

But I think that's the beauty of Clancy though I disagree with a lot of takes I can see each song being someone's favorite

west compass
#

my top 3

  1. Lavish
    2.Lavish
    3.Lavish
worldly pebble
#

backslide is insane it being so low is ridiculous

hazy shale
prisma minnow
prisma minnow
rigid oriole
#

My top three are:
1: Navigating
2: Overcompensate
3: Oldies Station

but that third spot is constantly being fought for. sometimes it’s Oldies, sometimes it’s The Craving, sometimes it’s Backslide

onyx bobcat
#

i love backslide but i think i like, almost all the other songs more than it

worldly pebble
prisma minnow
#

lavish is the real winner in my mind

rigid oriole
fluid latch
vocal rain
fluid latch
rigid oriole
#

That voice crack makes me cry

#

I swear

pure wadi
#

It’s joever

upper meteor
#

idk if navigating, overcompensate, or atrofd should be my #3

prisma minnow
frozen echo
#

that voicecrack tho

prisma minnow
#

single verison is kinda boring

#

jenna is so raw and powerful

hazy shale
#

ok for this conversation i want everyone to know i respect your opinions and music and stuff but i am going to start disagreeing

prisma minnow
#

single version literally has the most boring basic sound ever

shy bough
#

Also am gonna say

prisma minnow
#

jennas is so much better

#

its so pretty

rigid oriole
hazy shale
shy bough
#

I don’t ever wanna see song battles appear again

#

Im done with them

rigid oriole
shy bough
#

Thank you very much

#

No

frozen echo
prisma minnow
upper meteor
onyx bobcat
#

me after i saw some random vessel song win all albums song battles:

worldly pebble
prisma minnow
#

YALL R CRAZY

#

HOW IS JENNAS BORING

#

😭😭

worldly pebble
hazy shale
#

neither is boring???

rigid oriole
west compass
shy bough
prisma minnow
#

people who hate tyler love songs are just mad that they cant pull

amber stratus
onyx bobcat
#

jenna's version is not Boring

its as entertaining as an acoustic song can be 🧍‍♂️

shy bough
frozen echo
hazy shale
upper meteor
#

jv being stripped back does make it more boring but its still raw and emotional

shy bough
#

Im saying that song battles bring out the toxicity in fans. Me included

prisma minnow
#

jennas version isnt supposed to be jumpy and exciting its pretty and beautiful

amber stratus
shy bough
#

Nope. Im literally not mad at all. Keep assuming

amber stratus
#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

rigid oriole
# worldly pebble NAH WHAT JENNAS IS 10x MORE BORING

do you want a slowdancing, acoustic, emotional, stripped back love song to be exciting…? it’s supposed to be simple and clear, the single version’s instrumental clunks everything up and makes it feel like the epitome of a radio song with no soul. In Jenna’s version it feels like he means every word

worldly pebble
west compass
hazy shale
#

i am actually loving the conflict here this is immensely entertaining (probably more than it should be haha)

frozen echo
#

THE TOXICITY OF OUR CITY OF OUR CITYYYYYYYYYY

worldly pebble
amber stratus
rigid oriole
shy bough
onyx bobcat
prisma minnow
west compass
worldly pebble
shy bough
#

You guys are weird

frozen echo
ruby cypress
#

Vignette deserved better😞

fluid latch
#

Speaking of love songs Formidable is so underrated, in the theming of SAI I think it's such a clever subversion of an Acoustic pop Love song where instead of singing solely about how he loves Jenna he talks about how his love can be toxic by putting her on such a high pedestal

prisma minnow
#

vignette is so mid no it didnt

prisma minnow
worldly pebble
prisma minnow
#

formidable is easily my favorite tyler love song

rigid oriole
# worldly pebble yeah but it sounds better🥺

It is technically better produced, but imo Jenna’s version sounds better simply because of his performance being the star throughout the track. The instrumental only supports him and his voice, his words, do all the work of making the song beautiful and meaningful

prisma minnow
#

im just worried my loyalty will bore you

#

yeah yeah yeah

frozen echo
#

formidable more like forpeakable

prisma minnow
#

amen

rigid oriole
fluid latch
#

Formidable is probably still my least favorite love song (other than the craving single version) but I still love it

ruby cypress
hazy shale
#

formidable is one of my favorite twenty one pilots songs to be honest, maybe the favorite

onyx bobcat
#

i have absolutely No idea who formidable is about ngl

worldly pebble
prisma minnow
worldly pebble
#

and*

prisma minnow
#

it cleared

fluid latch
winter crest
hazy shale
winter crest
#

bro i love formidable sm

west compass
#

I honestly haven’t listening to the craving single ver ever since it came out

prisma minnow
ruby cypress
rigid oriole
# prisma minnow navigating

same, honestly as soon as I heard it on my first album listen I knew it was my favourite. Even before the rest of the tracklist played I knew that was the one I’d love

ruby cypress
#

THE FACT ITS TYLER'S LEAST FAVORITE IS CRAZY

onyx bobcat
worldly pebble
#

when it came out navigating hit harder then everything

prisma minnow
rigid oriole
hazy shale
#

navigating was probably my favorite on the first listen through, others have grown on me a ton though

low ivy
#

How is vignette not a top 3

prisma minnow
#

(and i have)

worldly pebble
rigid oriole
frozen echo
#

oh my gosh leak listeners

worldly pebble
#

It was so hard to not listen to leaks but I didn’t😬

ruby cypress
ruby cypress
prisma minnow
low ivy
#

I only listened to the craving becaus he sang that at that one concert anyways

prisma minnow
rigid oriole
west compass
rigid oriole
#

But I only listened to the concert recording

onyx bobcat
#

i listened to the LQ leak and i thought it was Shit 💀
then i listened to the HQ leak and got 923092932 plays

rigid oriole
prisma minnow
#

lq leak was not a good first listen

#

i enjoyed every song so much mroe when it leaked hq

onyx bobcat
#

for real

prisma minnow
#

midwest took time to grow on me

#

i didnt fw it lq but

#

as soon as i heard it in hq i knew it was my true love

frozen echo
#

i loved it first listen

onyx bobcat
frozen echo
#

groovy as shiz

ruby cypress
rigid oriole
#

Midwest has kinda grown off me ngl. Imo it’s a well written song but instrumentally I’m not a big fan of it, I feel like they could have done more work to make it more interesting; added more layers or something

onyx bobcat
rigid oriole
#

As it stands it’s the shell of an incredible track

west compass
#

as soon as I heard Midwest on the livestream i immediately added it to like all my playlists 😭

onyx bobcat
#

this time it was different imo

#

bros postponed the album

#

i bought like 2 copies i didnt feel bad at all

ruby cypress
fluid latch
rigid oriole
fiery scarab
#

No idea how At The Risk did so well

#

Navigating is a fair winner but wouldn't be my pick

rain scarab
cunning ginkgo
rain scarab
fiery scarab
rain scarab
cunning ginkgo
#

2/3 of my top 3 on clancy ended up being the top 2 in the song battle, i am NOT mad about this at all haha!! CONGRATS NAVIGATING 🏆

cunning ginkgo
rain scarab
rain scarab
fiery scarab
fiery scarab
cunning ginkgo
placid mantle
#

next semester should have won im so mad

upper meteor
fiery scarab
worldly pebble
frozen echo
rain scarab
#

There was a discussion about Tyler's love songs, I'm surprised nobody mentioned Smithereens

#

Also

#

This one is 🔥

trim kelp
#

Fine I'll re-listen to the whole NPI album

#

CAN I UNDERSTAND YOUUUU

hybrid oak
#

well deserved navigating 🧭

prisma minnow
#

hands down

#

oh yeah i-i-i belieeve in looooove

#

and i hope i can show you what i meeeeeeeean

manic furnace
#

What does npi mean?

trim kelp
#

no phun intended

#

tyler's early solo album

vernal summit
#

Lame

rapid sinew
#

ah hell nahhh they shoulda had a rematch it woulda been cooler

#

wait nvm navigating didnt even loose once alr whatever

loud badger
#

congrats navigating it's one of the best songs on the album !

#

my 2nd favorite since the first time i listened to it

loud badger
#

you can see how tyler is experimenting with different styles and stuff it's cute to see those minor mistakes because he was just starting lmao

#

going down for example has a really similar style to some songs on self-titled, so i'm assuming that one's one of the last ones he made before his first tøp album

wintry perch
#

navigating won 🔥

cerulean fjord
#

navigating w 🔥🔥

drifting geyser
#

NAVIGATING WON LETS GOOOO

#

my #1 honestly

#

I'm sad the craving Jenna's version didn't make it far

placid mantle
#

im not

rain scarab
rain scarab
rain scarab