#Clancy Song Battle #24
alpine arrowBOT
Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1721487600:R>
cobalt dawn
Midwest
balmy rose
MISWEST INDIGOAT
cobalt dawn
If u don’t agree ur wrong
hot dragon
My nightmare
young orbit
what an L lineup
hot dragon
This is impossible
uneven dove
MIDWEST INDIGO
cobalt dawn
Midwest indigo >>>
bright tapir
what an L lineup
No
hot dragon
I honestly don't know
urban cedar
navigating
hot dragon
2 of my fav songs ever
storm hawk
NAVIGATINGGGGGG
ember knoll
NAVIGATING ON TOP
hot dragon
I'm stumped
hollow bobcat
NAVIGATING
hot dragon
But I'm voting for navigating sorry midwest
shy sage
cowabunga
- leonardo divinky
lean fractal
Vignette:(
urban cedar
I know💀
lean fractal
42 votes apart..
I can't believe it
bright mason
supple owl
PARDON MY DELAY
mental ledge
Navigating is good but Midwest is great
prime shuttle
MY OH MY
blissful palm
My delay must be pardoned
im quoting this
low pond
im quoting this
I better be cited in MLA format
alpine arrowBOT
I better be cited in MLA format
blissful palm
I better be cited in MLA format
is my status fine?
hushed jewel
Has anyone else been getting the pings the last few days cos I haven't
blissful palm
yeah
noble onyx
REACHING OUT
low pond
is my status fine?
Indeed
blissful palm
sick
alpine plover
Expected a close battle between Vignette and ATROFD
Voted for At the risk, would be fine with any of those 2 winning
shrewd path
muted garden
ow
weak oxide
Vignette really lost I'm actually shocked
I feel it's the fan favorite
Anyways,
Vote Navigating🗣‼️
livid gulch
Two of my favorites but I have to go Midwest because of Tyler in those overalls! 🥵
lofty rivet
MYYYY, OOOH MYYYYYYYYY
sonic anvil
okay easy
the one that has the most beautiful bridge in the history of beautiful gut wrenching bridges
bleak minnow
This one’s hard, but navigating wins for me
weak oxide
I wish the second verse was extended ;-;
It's too short and makes the chorus a bit repetitive
open olive
midwest indigo has gotten so boring to me 😭
weak oxide
I still enjoy it
lofty rivet
the one that has the most beautiful bridge in the history of beautiful gut wrenc...
"Feeling the reality that everybody leaves" it's sooo 💔💔💔
they bring that topic conveniently in the song of josh being an imagination all this time
how can they do this to me
stiff hornet
this is not fair
lofty rivet
I wish the second verse was extended ;-;
i think if it was longer it probably would've been my favourite songs of all time
it already is though, top 2 off clancy also
worn siren
DISASSOCIATE 🗣️
hallow pelican
midwest
deft tapir
navigating
spice quarry
NAVIGOATING
deft tapir
YES
keen gyro
navigating easy
flat yacht
what your eta? (i chose nav)
lofty rivet
GIVE ME SOME ADVICE
sick solstice
hoary patrol
PARDON MY DELAY
hoary patrol
DISASSOCIATE
fiery compass
Impossible decision
alpine plover
Navigating has a more catchy melody but in terms of lyrics Midwest Indigo >>>
left thicket
navigating gives me plane leaving vibes idk how to explain it
flat yacht
nav deserves to be a big hit SO badly but FBR cant do shit to promote them
sand briar
Navigating has a more catchy melody but in terms of lyrics Midwest Indigo >>>
I agree, I memorized all the lyrics to Midwest indigo just bc it’s fun to sing but overall I prefer navigating
alpine plover
Navigating has a more catchy melody but in terms of lyrics Midwest Indigo >>>
So, to make it clear, I voted MW because catchy melody isn't all that in music it can get boring.
ripe drum
Difficult choice but I went with midwest indigo as I’ve streamed it more times than navigating. Love both🥺
gaunt pebble
not even difficult navigating clears
viral raptor
Midwest indigo. Ik it's probably gonna loose but idc it's still number one
Yall fakes
alpine plover
Midwest indigo. Ik it's probably gonna loose but idc it's still number one
Should win this battle
not sure if it's #1 on the album, but ok
viral raptor
Ritn or Midwest for me
alpine plover
Ritn or Midwest for me
My top 5 (not in that order) is Next Semester, Vignette, Midwest, The Craving and ATROFD.
viral raptor
My top 5 (not in that order) is Next Semester, Vignette, Midwest, The Craving an...
Which craving
alpine plover
Jenna's version
viral raptor
Based
alpine plover
But the single version is ok as well
viral raptor
I only have a top 3 because all the other songs can be mixed and matched in any order
Midwest indigo, ritn, and vignette
alpine plover
I don't know why so many people are criticizing The Craving
Especially Jenna's version
I loved it immediately
viral raptor
I like Jenna's over single but idk
alpine plover
I loved it immediately
Which wasn't the case with other songs
viral raptor
Out of the singles it was the only one that had to actually grow on me
alpine plover
I really didn't like Overcompensate
viral raptor
That's an opinion I guess
wind river
This is a hard idk if I wanna vote on this one tbh
vagrant nacelle
i feel like Navigating will win but im voting Midwest Indigo
alpine plover
navigating is the best song off clancy
How is it the best
sick perch
if it doesnt win ill go mental
Same
craggy oracle
How is it the best
its peak clancy
the catchiest song i think theyve ever made actually
low hornet
MI
But how did lavish lose
weak oxide
not even difficult navigating clears
True
rotund escarp
Guys what should i vote
I dont really care
Both are great
But my favorites are already eliminated
I think i should vote midwest
lofty rivet
Guys what should i vote
navigating is insane if you like rock heavy instrumental with deep lyrics, midwest indigo if you prefer more of an indie band vibe that sounds catchy
rotund escarp
I think midwest lyrics are also deep
lofty rivet
I think midwest lyrics are also deep
oh yess they are though I wasn't comparing them, i think the entirety of clancy is deep and worth analyzing
even lavish
sonic anvil
"Feeling the reality that everybody leaves" it's sooo 💔💔💔
and his VOICE when he sings that bridge and also after the bridge urgh
it's just so beautiful
iron shore
Navigating
lofty rivet
and his VOICE when he sings that bridge and also after the bridge urgh
i see you love navigating, but also at the risk, and that's insane because they're my top 2 and top 1 it feels good to see people with such similar favourites
sonic anvil
i see you love navigating, but also at the risk, and that's insane because they'...
wait i love that so much!! and i agree, it's so awesome seeing that there's others with a similar ranking 🙌 what's your final one in your top 3??
lofty rivet
wait i love that so much!! and i agree, it's so awesome seeing that there's othe...
it's hard to choose 😅 it's either next semester or vignette, i'm not quite sure
sonic anvil
it's hard to choose 😅 it's either next semester or vignette, i'm not quite sure
ahhh both are so good!! my final one in my top 3 is routines in the night 🔥
at the risk of feeling dumb and routines in the night are tied at #1
and then navigating is 3rd
lofty rivet
ahhh both are so good!! my final one in my top 3 is routines in the night 🔥
that's insane i love that one so much
alpine plover
the catchiest song i think theyve ever made actually
That's the thing
The catchiest =/= the best
There are more important aspects to music than the catchiness (is that a word?) of the melody.
quaint socket
lofty rivet
the catchiest song i think theyve ever made actually
i agree and ironically it's probably a style they've never done until now
craggy oracle
There are more important aspects to music than the catchiness (is that a word?) ...
the music just flows amazingly and its such a banger song its my favorite off clancy
alpine plover
There are better songs on this album
craggy oracle
well each to their own i suppose
pure arch
routines 
safe snow
MIDWESTTTT
weak oxide
routines <:grief:768046797637419059>
Avenge Routines😔✊🏾
weak oxide
Who allowed atrofd to beat vignette
I didn't
silk elm
JIM
haughty valley
navigating > almost every song I've ever heard
hot laurel
Based
stuck portal
there is a reason why midwest indigo has MID in it
that’s all i got to say
good night fellas
weak oxide
MY OHHH MYYYYYY
uncut cliff
there is a reason why midwest indigo has MID in it
there’s a reason why navigating has ig in it
because that’s what I say whenever navigating comes on
sonic anvil
that's insane i love that one so much
it's honestly so hard to rank the rest of the album!! i just know my top 4 or 5 and the rest i can't rank lol
lofty rivet
it's honestly so hard to rank the rest of the album!! i just know my top 4 or 5 ...
I'm quite the opposite of that, not only on album ranks but on everything that I like and can be ranked it's so hard for me to rank the best of something, but for some reason the weakest of something is probably the easiest part for me, the middle ground is also kind of easy because everything there kind of just places there by default because what doesn't ends up higher or ends up lower stays stuck in the middle kind of by default, so yeah only like the top 5 is usually the hardest part of a ranking personally
it's perhaps something weird 😅
uncut cliff
like i guess or some
yeah lol 💀
im just playin though i love navigating
Midwest just clears
lime oar
lofty rivet
DON'T KNOW HOW... LONG IT'S BEEN.... since i responded to your question.
mossy hill
Pardon my delay
steel marlin
Love midwest too much
old orbit
navigatingggg
uncut cliff
Midwest clears what are yall talking about
limpid wraith
if midwest wins im gonna 
prime shuttle
Navigating pls
thorny ether
Good
prime shuttle
LETS GOO
thorny ether
As it should
prime shuttle
JOSH WAS RIGHT
thorny ether
JOSH WAS RIGHT
FRR lmaoo
if tyler sees these song battles he must be so annoyed at us
the song he doesn't really like being the one we love the most
prime shuttle
Navigating on the tour set list please 
slim pelican
FIRST MIDWEST L LFG
old orbit
the song he doesn't really like being the one we love the most
i hope it makes him feel a little better like you dont love these songs but look how much we love these songs
thorny ether
i hope it makes him feel a little better like you dont love these songs but look...
i hope so 🥹
validation
all of these songs are amazing but damn navigating hits diff
shy sage
prime shuttle
Navigating supremacy
balmy rose
what do you MEAN
brisk raptor
Once again WHY DIDNT I GET PINGED?!?!
copper pasture
Once again WHY DIDNT I GET PINGED?!?!
If it makes you feel better I wasnt either
weak oxide
Navigating clutches💪🏾
Love to see it
craggy oracle
NAV CLEARED
spark totem
Que os mejoréis (del gusto)
sonic anvil
NAVIGATING WONNNN
thorny ether
old orbit
navigating this W
slim pelican
Lfg
balmy rose
viral raptor
Lavish v navigating battle when?
sonic anvil
the song battle is over 😅
thorny ether
viral raptor
the song battle is over 😅
We need full discography song battle now
alpine plover
We need full discography song battle now
Also No Phun Intended Song Battles
winter hollow
We need full discography song battle now
we we already did that
alpine plover
we we already did that
Yeah, but didn't Car Radio lose to Next Semester?
thorny ether
alpine plover
Yeah, but didn't Car Radio lose to Next Semester?
That's messed up
sonic anvil
We need full discography song battle now
YESSSS
but at the same time it would be absolutely chaos haha
viral raptor
yeah ofc next semester beat it its objectively a better song
This is an obnoxious take
winter hollow
its not a take thats why i said objectively
alpine plover
yeah ofc next semester beat it its objectively a better song
You're objectively insanely wrong because Car Radio is clearly much better. Not sure how you could even come up with this ridiculous take.
winter hollow
youre crazy
rotund escarp
Next Semester is one of the best they ever made
prime shuttle
It’s rage bait
craggy oracle
when your circle small ..... but yall are crazy!!!!!!!!!!!
winter hollow
It’s rage bait
me or the other person
viral raptor
its not a take thats why i said objectively
These opinions are the exact reason that the lyrics in pet cheetah were written
winter hollow
its also not an opinion thats why i said objectively
alpine plover
youre crazy
I'm not you're the one who said Next Semester better than Car Radio. Most messed up take ever.
winter hollow
blah blah blah shut up
alpine plover
blah blah blah shut up
No. I can't stay quiet while seeing heresy like this.
craggy oracle
I'm not you're the one who said Next Semester better than Car Radio. Most messed...
car radio is the only skip on vessel
rotund escarp
car radio is the only skip on vessel
doesn't surprise me to hear this from a mulberry street hater
alpine plover
car radio is the only skip on vessel
Your takes can't be taken seriously from now on.
weak oxide
car radio is the only skip on vessel
Lol
I wanna hear an explanation for this please
weak oxide
doesn't surprise me to hear this from a mulberry street hater
As a SAI non enjoyer I also do not like Mulberry street
sonic anvil
As a SAI non enjoyer I also do not like Mulberry street
audibly gasps
weak oxide
It's shocking I know >-<
Unpopular opinion:
I know Choker is beloved but I thinks it's kinda boring
I would love to hear what yall like about the song :>
craggy oracle
Lol
I wanna hear an explanation for this please
its boring its a snooooozoe fest
craggy oracle
Your takes can't be taken seriously from now on.
i only have good takes actually
mossy hill
Unpopular opinion:
I know Choker is beloved but I thinks it's kinda boring
I wo...
Bro the last verse on choker is peak though
craggy oracle
i really like the beginning of choker the most thats what hooks me in and i kinda lose it at the chrous
"i dont bother anyone .... nervous when i stand" gah it has me ascending
mossy hill
winter hollow
No. I can't stay quiet while seeing heresy like this.
waa waa waa get over it
weak oxide
its boring its a snooooozoe fest
Car radio is the most interesting song on the album, lyrically at least
It's not a song to jam out too it's more introspective and makes ya think
Vessel does have a few skips for me but mainly it's just:
The Run and Go
Semi-Automatic
Fair enough though
weak oxide
Bro the last verse on choker is peak though
Nah I think the verse is just mid, there's way better verses TOP has, way more
The song just keeps the same slow vibes throughout and I find it boring
I also don't like the "mmmm mmmm" hook
I like the music video alot though
weak oxide
https://tenor.com/view/twenty-one-pilots-choker-drums-tyler-joseph-josh-dun-gif-...
Iconic mv though✨️
weak oxide
i really like the beginning of choker the most thats what hooks me in and i kind...
The chorus really doesn't feel strong
SAI does have its good moments though
Like redecorate, the outside, no chances, never take it, shy away
craggy oracle
Car radio is the most interesting song on the album, lyrically at least
It's not...
lyrically i think its great but i just dont really like the sound and flow of the spoken rap
weak oxide
lyrically i think its great but i just dont really like the sound and flow of th...
I can understand that :>
So do you prefer Neon Gravestones over CR? Or does NG still fall under the spoken rap sound that you don't like?
winter hollow
neon gravestones is oodles above car radio in terms of lyricism
rotund escarp
Unpopular opinion:
I know Choker is beloved but I thinks it's kinda boring
I wo...
I actually kinda agree with you. Not my favorite song on SAI. But it is a class album, especially Mulberry Street, The Outside and Redecorate.
hallow pelican
Unpopular opinion:
I know Choker is beloved but I thinks it's kinda boring
I wo...
its not my favorite from sai either, but its not the worst
craggy oracle
I can understand that :>
So do you prefer Neon Gravestones over CR? Or does NG ...
neon gravestones i've come to like not only lyrically but soundwise like the production of it is just extremely pretty especially after the bridge, but the spoken rap at the end of ng i dont like at all bc the former parts of ng isn't quite as like talking sounding spoken rap as much as the end of it is or car radio is, if that makes sense
weak oxide
neon gravestones is oodles above car radio in terms of lyricism
Oh for sure, I'm not discrediting that
I like that NG's message is directly stated through the lyrics more
While CR's message is more implicit and a little confusing to just "get" on first listen
weak oxide
I actually kinda agree with you. Not my favorite song on SAI. But it is a class ...
It's definitely an album
But not my fav
weak oxide
its not my favorite from sai either, but its not the worst
Yea if anything it's just average but charming I admit
weak oxide
neon gravestones i've come to like not only lyrically but soundwise like the pro...
That makes sense, the final bit of NG seems very strip back
Like Tyler speaking directly to the listener so it breaks the immersion a bit
hallow pelican
Yea if anything it's just average but charming I admit
i felt it could’ve been great, just not a fan of the vocals, the lyrics are nice enough
the beat is very interesting and catchy
winter hollow
i love choker so much its my baby
weak oxide
i love choker so much its my baby
What do you like about it? :o
sonic anvil
i love choker so much its my baby
ME TOO
viral raptor
i love choker so much its my baby
So true
viral raptor
What do you like about it? :o
Everything
alpine plover
i only have good takes actually
You cancelled them with that one take. They can't be taken seriously anymore.
winter hollow
what
rotund escarp
I want a blind song battle
Every battle is just song 1 vs. song 2, and in the end it is revealed which song passed on and which one was eliminated.
half cypress
i love choker so much its my baby
Choker is such a weird song to me
cause it feels like it could be INCREDIBLE and one of the best on SAI with just a little more thought put into it production-wise, but as it stands it’s a bit forgettable imo
weak oxide
Choker is such a weird song to me
Frfr
Choker feels anti-climatic for some reason
I feel like the production is minimal and the chorus is just very weak
The last verse is alright, nothing special
winter hollow
choker is like midwest indigo to me
happy comforting sort of nostalgic song that stays home
viral raptor
cause it feels like it could be INCREDIBLE and one of the best on SAI with just ...
I don't hate you I just have not had an enjoyable experience reading your opinions 😭