#Clancy Song Battle #23
1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)
Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1721401200:R>
risk surely
RISK
Hello
anything else and ur delusional
AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMBBBB
Hi
VIGN FOR THE WIN
Vignette
CHICKEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEN
these are my top two this is so hard
Sorry chat, I'm voting Vignette.
vignette is the only roght answer
I DON'T WANT ANYONE, KNOW ME OR NOT
AT THE RISKKKK
AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB, #1 SONG ON THE ENTIRE ALBUM 🔥
CHECK IIIIIIIIIIIIIIN
FACTS
HELL YEAH
SEE YOU GET IT 🙌
CHECK INNN
Not sure when it started
Peeling from his bones
Clouds pfp nice
Vignette
AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB
love that album
VIGNETTE EVERYDAY 🗣️🗣️🗣️
YOU DON'T HAVE TO DROP DROP DROP ME
noo this is so hardd but I'm going to have to say atrofd
Atrofd easy
nice
i genuinely cannot choose anymore these song battles have been killing me lately
AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB CLEARS ‼️
Vingette eaaaaaasssy
ADVOCATING FOR MY #1 SONG ALWAYS
I DONT WANT ANYONE KNOW ME OR NOT 🗣️
Vignette and Navigating are the best song on the album no doubt
@glass talon what are we voting
r i s k
CLINGING TOOOOOOO
I like the sound of vignette better but the lyrics of at the risk are better
zoinks scoob
ATROFD‼️‼️‼️
ATROFD is an important song to me so I have to go with it.
gotta vote atrofd
YOU ARE TIRED. YOU ARE HURT. A MOTH ATE THROUGH YOUR FAVORITE SHIRT
SEE ME AT MY LOWEST
vignette(im not mystic)
YOU DON'T HAVE TO TO DROP
YOU DONT HAVE TO DROP DROP DROP
Really hard but gotta go w atrofd
He's thinking "theres no way I'm headed there" always sure-footed educated and was never scared 💪💪
ayyo i asked mystic 🤨
DON'T HAVE TO DROP BY
knowing her this is probably gonna be our vote
No not me it's for a friend!!
i mean im voting vignette ofc lmfao
No no not me it's for a friend
Denial
i’m inclined to vote vignette ngl
voted it last battle and it won
I KNOW THAT ITS A RISK SAYING THIS DONT FIGHT ME !!!
BRO PALADIN STRAIT HAS TO WIN
TELL EM
Whatever loses is out
Vignette is good but ATROFD has an important message.
I DON'T CARE WHAT'S IN YOUR HAIR I JUST WANNA KNOW WHAT'S ON YOUR MIND
Bros on the wrong album
I USED TO SAY I'D DIE BEFORE I'M OLD BUT BECAUSE OF YOU I MIGHT THIKN TWICE
COME ON VIGNETTE!!!
what do the skulls mean
anyways
Seed 1 Vignette eliminates Overcompensate out of Clancy song battles and now fights agaisnt seed 4 ATROFD
They lost a round
WE DON'T BELIEVE WHAT'S ON TV!!!
used to be, you and me
C'mon Vignette, sweep 😭
That’s a good song but I think you’re in the wrong year.
I'm joking lol
I was listening to it
help me bowl of rice
AM I THE ONLY ONE I NKOW
CHICCKKKENNNNN
Vignette 🙏
@lyric arch tongue tied is a banger too
I I I I GOT A MIGRAINE
ITS NOT WORTH THE RISK OF LOOSING A HEN
VIGNETTE W
what's that
That made me smile
the song you were listening to
AND MY PAIN WILL RANGE FROM UP DOWN AND SIDEWAYS
before migraine at least (btw the best song on vessel)
which one
WATCH ME AS I BREAK THE TELEVISION TALK ME OFF THE LEDGE I CANT ENVISION
REAL it's in my top 3 on vessel
Im just gonna um. Leave this here
I want to argue for Car Radio, but I'm second guessing myself.
AND ALL YOUR FRIENDS FERTILIZE THE GROUND YOU WALK. SO LOSE YOUR MIND.
Does anyone know this song? I feel it’s an obscure reference
no no you're onto something, continue
VINGETTEEEEEEE
this is the hardest one for me bc these are tied #1 from clancy for me
CLINGING TOOOOO PROMISESSSS FIGHTING OFFF THE VIGNEEETEEE
I'm third guessing myself. Trees.
atrofd is number 2 for me i hope it wins 😭
This one is tough. For me the lyrics are better in ATROFD, but Vignette is better in other aspects.
this was me with the at the risk of feeling dumb VS routines in the night round 
this is so hard
TUNNELS CAVE VISIONS FADEEEE
SWALLOWED BY THE VIGNETTEEE
will seed 1 Vignette be our final clancy top 3 song?
LOCK THE DOORS AND WARN THE FEDERATION BRIGHT AND BOLD HERE COMES THE REVOLUTION
i think im going with vignette
or will seed 4 ATROFD be our final top 3 song?
funny thing is that those two continue to fight for third place on my vessel top 3
MY OH MY THE KING IS ON A MISSION
Vignette should not have won the previous round, but it absolutely has every right to win this vote cause I’m not revenge voting
EASY WIN HERE
CLINGING TOOOOO
I AM ON MY WAY UNSTOPPABLE
Every song should win with Overcompensate
ATROFD is fine but it cannot stack up to Vignette
that is actually insane
woaaaaaaaah
Sorry
PROMISEEEESSSSSS
no need to apologise, it’s your opinion
Bro would vote Snap Back over Overcompensate
PURE AT HEART A KING IN FALLABLE GREAT BIG FUCKING TIME SO POWERFUL IIIII
FIGHTING OFF A VINGETTE
it’s just an untrue one
its not revenge voting, its just if you genuinely like the other song more
I KNOW THAT IT'S A RISK SAYING THIS, DON'T FIGHT ME
ikik but some people genuinely revenge vote even if they prefer that song because it beat a song they like in a previous round
At the risk of feeling dumb has such basic production like come on this is trench 2 bruh
it happens a lot
Ok but does anyone know this song!?
It’s by angels & airwaves
Vignette better win or I will cry
afraid not but those lyrics are interesting
TUNNELS CAVE, VISIONS FADE
Don’t listen to it it’s too catchy
what’s it called
SWALLOWED BY THE VIGNETTE
I have the Numberblocks end credit song stuck in my head anything is better
at the risk of feeling dumb CLEARS every other song on the album
Vignette fans are my actual goats
Voyager
ooh kk
ATROFD is a hard second
Angels& airwaves is so underrated
Thats just a really dumb rebuttal that people do, its confusing. if you cant have your favorite win, just vote so your second favorite may win. I really dont get the mindset at all
And I have two songs fighting for 1st
on the contrary, almost every other song on the album clears ATROFD
yeah like it’s not the song’s fault that it won 💀
No 😭
absolutely not
I overplayed Next Semester so I kinda ruined it
at the risk of feeling dumb and routines in the night are easily tied at #1 for me since the first listen
omg nooooo
to be clear, I like At The Risk and I don’t think it’s a bad song at all. I just think the vast majority of the album is better
the only song I think is absolutely worse is Lavish, and arguably Midwest
When overcompensate, NS and backslide came out I had NS on repeat
This
I favourited Overcompensate ngl
i still do 😜
which are your faves on the album??
hell even my lobby music in fortnite is next semester
Vignette had me IMMEDIATELY tho
lol same
I had the album on repeat for like a week after it came out so I got tired of it
that was exactly me with routines in the night, then at the risk of feeling dumb!! i just heard the beginning and immediately knew it's gonna be my faves 🙌 and i stand corrected
DROP DROP DROP
I think the production perfectly mirrors the message of the song, and is done very maturely through the lyrics and good use of reggae.
Navigating, Overcompensate, Paladin Strait, Oldies Station and Backslide/Routines tied are my top 5
i absolutely love the production 🔥 tyler and paul know exactly what they're doing and how to make it work!
I think as a song on its own it’s great but I had very high expectations for the album and that song was just alright. Loooove the message tho
perfectly put
I would argue that the production and message are fantastic. My main issue with it is the writing and vocal performance
Paul? Am I supposed to know who Paul is?
cool to see people passionate about songs I didn’t really enjoy . Love this server
lead producer for the album
produced Trench too
okayyyy interesting, we got like 3/5 of the same songs in our top 5 🙌
fair, all these songs are very distinct, and everyone is going to have different feelings towards each style.
thats why clancy is so interesting
paul meany!!
Nice nice
AT THE RISK ALL THE WAY ITS HARD BUT I JUST CANT LET RISK LOSE AGAIN MY HEART WAS BROKE AFTER IT LOST IT CANT HAPPEN AGAIN!!!
Clancy is definitely the most unique out of all the albums like it has a little bit of everything which is why I think it might be their best
I think it might be their worst
the songs couldn’t be more out of order, but also feel so chronologically correct
I’m definitely glad that it isn’t the end of the story lol it works as a return to trench but not a full story in trench
i love next semester but it does NOT fit after overcompensate 😭
unrelated but i love your korra pfp 🥹
Vignette is 3rd best on Clancy.
how do we know it’s not the end? I mean I’d be delighted if there was confirmation of anything in Clancy’s story past Paladin, but I’m unaware of any solid proof of it
4th or 5th
Thank you! I’m a huge Korra defender
8th IMO
it's not even in my top 5 unfortunately 😭 but don't take that the wrong way, i love the song so so much
I do enjoy some Korra
Tyler described the concerts as remembering why we fight before we do
SAME SAME
I think Navigating is my 2nd favorite TØP song of all time.
I don’t think Korra stacks up to ATLA in any way aside from animation but it is still pretty solid
it just has some issues that makes it not a favourite for me
Think about this
Next Semester
Navigating
Jumpsuit
Chlorine
Morph
i took what he said in a totally different context, so idk what to believe at this point haha
i basically thought he meant that the shows will be kind of like flashbacks leading up to the fight that takes place in paladin strait
i couldn’t imagine it any other way
Chlorine in your top 5 is pretty crazy but I respect it ngl
i disagree, but to each their own
is that your top 5 all time fave top songs??
Yup.
This would be cool
It makes sense
Honestly I feel the complete opposite.
oh definitely, chlorine is one of the best songs ever produced period, definitely top 50 (all artists) from what ive heard so far.
Chlorine is one of TOP best songs what
i mean it's the most streamed trench song for a reason
Valid valid valid valid
Exactly
vigwin amirite
to be fair, I don’t think the writing is that bad; but I don’t think it’s really in keeping with the band’s hyper-poetic style, which I’m not a huge fan of. it’s also a little blunt and hasn’t got too much imagery which is eh imo
I’m not the biggest fan of chlorine, probably cause I listened to it way too much
I’d argue tøp alone has at least 10 songs better produced than Chlorine
yeah, just like how stressed out deserved its fame too. Its a nostalgia song, it gets the heart aching, what else do you expect. I can only imagine how good itll be in like, 30 years or so, for all of us.
That's fair
I'll never get tired of that song
real
lay it out
don’t get me wrong, it’s good, but imo (and at least for me) it’s just pretty generic for them and they have a lot of better ones. Each to their own though
25 gotta mean smth though
Like everytime I listen to Chlroine, there's always something new in the production I discover
Fair enough,
Which songs do you think are better produced then Chlorine?
I'm curious
Pet cheetah !!!!!
I was thinking it was just the day they would have released the MV if we didn’t figure out the puzzle, but they did hint at it a lot so probably not
oh pet cheetah goes stupid
Whaaa
I disagree however I do like pet cheetah
Especially live💪🏾
It was a great experience
first its the piano, then its the suttle synth, so on ykyk
wait wrong thing to reply to
meant this
It's all good lol
Trees, Overcompensate, Jumpsuit, Morph, Redecorate, Pet Cheetah, Shy Away, Next Semester, Leave The City, Neon Gravestones, to name 10. but there are def a few more
Also the hype
That's exactly what I'm talking about
I love Paul meany's video on the making of Chlorine
The end gets me, the imagery and stripped back sound
I love the MV
this is hard
Trees okay
OC hmmm
Jumpsuit very valid
Morph very valid
Redecorate meh
Pet cheetah maybe
Shy away meh
NS interesting
LTC I love so ye
NG hmm idk
lemme name ten
i love how we're just discussing their entire discography in this song battle chat haha
Bounce man bounce man bounce man bounce man Bounce man bounce man bounce man bounce man bounce man bounce man
Overcompensate has some of the coolest, most interesting production of any tøp song ever imo
I just think Chlorine is a solid song overall and catchy, emotional at the end
You right, I'll admit it can be a bit chaotic but for an opener that's good
and Redecorate’s production is crazy underappreciated. In terms of fitting the style of the song, vocal processing and all, and using unique and interesting sounds to complete the track, it’s really just the perfect production for that song
Plus the bandito ref
I don’t think it could have been done better
with Pet Cheetah, I wouldn’t include it in the list if it weren’t for the final minute of the song
that alone elevates it
Shy Away at meh is fair, it was def the most risky placement on the list I’ll grant you
See I'm still not a SAI enjoyer ;-;
So it's hard for me to connect to any of the songs
Redecorate does have beautiful lyrics
that is fair, but from an objective standpoint it does everything right
i agree with a handful, but it also comes down to not which production is better, but instead how do tylers vocals carry the mixing. Which i think chlorine has most of them beat at.
even if you’re not a personal fan
That's me with Clancy
I honestly think most of the time the mixing is the hero in tøp songs, not Tyler’s vocals (aside from a few very evident exceptions like Trees and Goner and whatnot)
I'll have to disagree but it is the best song on SAI I'll give it that
That was me at first cause I was expecting another Trench
So I couldn't connect
But the Clancy songs are fun I feel, not their strongest album but going back to their roots a little :>
I’m gonna have some problems with a lot of people if vignette loses
Clancy > SAI
Also I didn't vote for this song battle yet lol
Who I voting for yall?
AGHH THIS ONE IS SO HARDD
LEVEL UP: You are now level 3!
redecorate imo might be tylers Magnum opus, not a solidifying song in his discography, but his best
I ❤️ redecorate
I don’t think it’s his absolute best but it is absolutely one of his most important songs
from message to sound
AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMBBBBB
terrible opinion leave
Vignette for sure
vignette destroys
i agree that the mixing is a defining characteristic of TOP, but cmon, the singing is completely on the same level. Both need one another, no one else could sing it differently and still be as good.
chill out 😭
I cant choose any song over the other from my top 5 help meee (ritn, vignette, navigating, atroft, paladin)
at the risk of feeling dumb CLEARS, i said what i said
I love them both brah
sorry took it too far
AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB CHECK IIIIIIINN
It's generic, which I know is the point but I'm not a fan
Shy Away was okay for me
Saturday was VERY generic for me, sounds like something new P!ATD would release
Bounce man nahhhh
I'm not saying TOP can't make happy songs but it's gotta sound good though
IT'S NOT WORTH THE RISK OF LOSING A FRIENDDDDD
Don’t get me wrong, the singing is almost always incredible, but I think without the mixing it would very often be left with a lot of issues, even if impressive
for what reason, boring verses?? Vignette is insane, also the synth solo
the raging falsettos on vignette got bro drunk
U right
I’m the only one who didn’t even offer an argument and you agreed with me, awesome 😂
nah Saturday is mid tbf I can’t deny. Bounce man is bouncy, it’s enjoyable I don’t understand the dislike. I’m all for Saturday hate
let’s go
LMAO
the reason being that it's the best song on clancy, a literal masterpiece 😁 (i love vignette too)
see atrofd is great, the only sort of negative is that the lyrics are a little too direct
vignette has zero flaws
they make me very happy
you’re completely right
how’s it a masterpiece thougj
best song on Clancy is just so insane
espically in comparison to vignette
Agreed about ATROFD
we’ve been fighting the atrofd fans for days now
I'm still undecided, because I still think I might like atrofd more.... idk though bc vignette has no flaws but at the same time... atrofd
Cause I was leaning towards Vignette anyways xD
yeah its the best song, but that just comes with, do you like this? or this? clancy is just a candy bucket with a bunch of different flavors and variety
to be fair, i did say it's tied with routines in the night at #1 for me
all incorrect TB Saga is the best song to grace this planet
we’re weary as we wander, covered in the blood of the countless bodies strewn across the battlefield that we have slain, but we will fight to the end
I have once criticism of vignette but it’s purely personal. I don’t like how it ends on the no not me for a friend
Imo they wane the more you hear it
Just choose whatcha like
No judgement here
omg good point I didn't think of that
regardless of the prospects, regardless of the outcome
I find myself singing Vignette more
we will prevail in our hearts
it just is to me of course, i guess our different taste is music in the only explanation...
Real af
but idk 
but objectively speaking in a sense of what’s a better soongggg, vignette has got to clear
what if we just don't hate any song and instead we just let them be if you don't like it that's fair just don't listen to it and if you like it just appreciate them for what it is for you?
atrofd is harder to sing
nah it is mid lol
that's not what i said
looks like you’re team paladin anyway, just vote for what you favor here
Saturday don’t have feelings don’t worry
true true, it's such a versatile album, there's something for everyone!!
well whatever
opinion, disagreement, and discussion can coexist
it’s soulless
True, but so is the falsetto on Vignette
litaly ✨ 🌞
we are discussing what songs are better in here
wowow I like you
i appreciate peTers freak
i'm sorry, i simply can't agree with you on this, but that's literally because at the risk of feeling dumb is my most listened to song of the year, it's just my fave 
thank you spin man
yeah that's true until they start fighting for songs that were meant to be songs that connect people
cant fight with that
Saturday does feel soulless
I tried my best to like SAI
But after Trench it was a disappointment
np pete the meat
..... paladin strait.
(I am team paladin but I love all of themmm)
I enjoy sai don’t put me in with those guys. Saturday just bad
you can still debate about songs that connect with people?? just keep your emotional bias out of it and you’ll be fine
paladin isn't gonna win anyways :')
sadly this is true
paladin isn’t mid but it’s not as good as the others
mental i might be buggin, but i think my blood might be in my top 3 now
or at least top 10
My Blood is very good, imo not top 3 material but I can see it for someone with an affinity for certain sounds
like i am fully expecting it to be my top song on spotify wrapped this year... we'll pretend to act surprised in unison though 🫶
if it’s managed to top your songs for the past 12 months when it’s only been out for 3, every other song has no chance
ever since I got last fm wrapped gonna be so underwhelming lol
get navigating higher pls
maybe its a phase
True, I like hearing different opinions :D
It's fun to discuss with others
Agreed
it’s all fun until they don’t like my favourite songs😡😡
My Blood is very catchy
Pretty good tune
real
oh absolutely!! funny thing is that it was already up there within the first few weeks of the clancy release as well, it might as well already claim it's victory
hear me out
consider
voting vignette
you won’t regret it
Bruh
Me with Chlorine, but I still hear others out tho
itll change proms 🙏
VOTE VIGNETTE 🗣️
me when vessel haters
but I don’t hear out vessel haters
backslide based
it surprisingly got a little bit info wrong last year, so there was a bit of the surprise factor still there at least lol
🗣️
LEVEL UP: You are now level 9!
it’s infectious, tantalizing
working on it 🙌
it isnt even top 3 on clancy
gets better every time
Fax
very
the chorus is very very powerful
si
but to be fair I understand people who don’t like the verse
it’s not bad but it’s nothing special
josh needs to direct more
frr
i'll consider it... but i won't do it 
consider it enough
this is entirely unrelated, and I might get hate for it
but if y’all want a Neon Gravestones/Snap Back/Goner (not completely accurate, but they’re the closest tøp songs I can approximate) style song, definitely check out Hate Myself by NF
Consider it again
He did a great job
i LOVE seeing snap back at the top
I say I might get hate because people seem to have a grudge against NF everywhere I go
but I highly recommend
how’d snap back get in there😭😭
What's nf
a little bit drums-wise
ah, okay
guy from fortnite
Why people don't like NF?
I heard his stuff and he's aight
cuz he's got a song in fortnite
kerisha u have really good takes
Fortnite battlepass
bounce man also
I love NF
I didn't know that
But I don't play fortnite like that
what’s NF stand for
ohhh
not funky
because he borders on the pop sphere and is a hip-hop artist, he doesn’t really fit anywhere in a defined music scene. but because he’s usually considered mostly a rapper, people dislike the fact that he’s not very hip-hop culturally/was influenced by Eminem in a lot of his artistic decisions early on
Not Fortnite
i think the search is in fortnite or wtv that song is called
wow i'm so smart
well done
mental ops on glowing eyes
I'll listen to. Oth then I'll decide for sure
but yeah DEFINITELY listen to Hate Myself
it’s so good
masterpiece of a track
That's kinda crazy
You'd think people be drawn to unique music artists hmm
I love glowing eyes
well he has a lot of pop appeal so
it can simultaneously be criticised as generic and corny
which is not great for hardcore stans of any genre he goes the line between
Ah I understand
it’s fine, I like the production
more like peak eyes
not my fav though
Lovely is kinda forgettable
for me lovely is that DUDE
forest I like and don’t like
Forest is all fine except for the stupid I scream bar
same with kitchen sink
REAL
lovely is pretty based
Voted atrofd
don’t come back
I’ll have to relisten cause I don’t remember a thing about it
fair😞
i kiss you on yo forehead
nooo how do i voteee
I’m relistening and it has a Tyler rap verse in it instant 0/10
I'd listen the dx one maybe you know that one but it's miles better than the other one
okay it’s not as bad as most of the rap on Vessel tbf
nahh
guns for hands rap good
Migraine rap is horrendous
thats one of their best songs for me, everything from the specific lyric choices, the feature, the ending, all phenomenal
the feature is kind of bare minimum for a rap verse imo but it’s fine ig
I don’t have anything against Kitchen Sink
it’s just
not amazing to me
VOTE ATROFD
i think zack's part is what people disagree(? not sure but there's something that people don't like about kitchen sink
i guess, but would it be as good if they got lil yachty or young thug
no because it wouldn’t fit the song
exactamoondoe
but like Denzel Curry, JID, Big Sean, even NF would fit the song, and they’d do a better job of the verse than Zach did
i mean is zach even a rapper like professional? cuz i don't know man
Idk
and if he’s not really a rapper, props to him cause he did a decent job there
but
Wrong wrong
it’s still not very good as rap goes
nah it’s terrible idc
Migrain is so peak
the delivery burns my eardrums
he'll say every rap is bad except for levitate we gotta deal with it because he actually has a point 😭
I think it’s good
guns for hands
very good
untrue - Neon Gravestones, Overcompensate, The Outside (kind of a little bit), No Chances, and Backslide (sorta) also have good rap in em
Obviously yeah it was meant for tylers brother, but even if it wasnt his voice still fit the song and moment a lot more than a random feature
it’s just not very common
I really don’t like the overcompensate rap
and you do like the Migraine rap?? What are you on
it’s the lyrics more
they feel just bad
neon is spoken word
I genuinely thought i was the only one that thought that verse of backslide qualified as a rap, this is interesting
mental ops on guns for hand rap
gotta relisten to judge but iirc it’s bad
if you’ve heard rap, like rap rap. Its not neon
tylers best rap was either the ending of fake you out, or levitate obviously
fake you oht also good
my personal favorite off vessel
LEVEL UP: You are now level 5!
same here
Fake you out is so unbelievably peak
trust me, I’m a hip-hop head through and through. if there’s one thing I can do, it’s identify rap. even if it’s not the prime example of a rap verse, or to phrase it better, the most conventional example, it still qualifies
it’s good but not best a lot top
why thank you 🥹 and so do you honestly!!
(In no order)
fun fact i'm pretty sure tyler said fake you out was the worst off vessel in his opinion
TELL EM
Tyler opinion doesn’t matter after navigating
same as he said ritn was the worst off clancy
FRFR
the music at the very start of "screen" makes me sob, like the song JUST begins and i already start tearing up every single time
fair, but that would also mean it qualifies for spoken word as well. Tyler is versatile and plays around with genres, its probably a mangle of both.
I'M NOT BUYING HE SAID THAT THAT MUST'VE BEEN A JOKE OR SUMTHING
an artistic choice
on a relisten, the rhymes are pretty creative and the flow is fine. The delivery just kinda sucks as usual though
we did well peter
there is no we😡
see i refuse to believe that tyler is such a tasteless man because come on now...
navigating is his least fave, routines in the night almost didn't even make it onto the album and now this??
Idk for certain if it does, because as far as I’m aware spoken word by definition can’t be on beat. otherwise it defaults to hip-hop on a technicality. I do see your point though
but theres a we
The songs are probs gonna mean a lot different to him then us, it’s music to us but it’s personal to him
Navigating almost didn’t either, it was in the same boat as RITN
I want to listen to the songs but Spotify is being wonky asf
yes
its a this or that sit
okay yeah, if you think about it from that pov then that's fair tbh!
yeah, so vote atrofd you loon
I thought better if you
of
I was wrong
IKR forever grateful that josh fought for those songs, those are both in my top 3
it is
because it is 👀
maybe the navigating almost not making it into the album probably was because of the fact that it's a personal song for him?? idfk he's just being sarcastic or smth 😭
you just like fireworks
It is brah
I can second that
clancy has been out for not even a full two months, so we'll have to get back to this in a few months 🥹
as a non atrofd voter
its my 4th favorite, overcompensate has amazing production, too amazing to dislike
it better then oc
oh damn
nah it’s alright but not as good as others
Overcompensate is good but not as good as RITN
a lot*
its an easy 10/10. and if it makes you even happier, its better than navigating
nope nope
spin man we aren’t friends anymore
the "sahlo folina" made the song so much more special to me especially since i always mention that bandito is my main comfort song, hearing it again in a different song is just so amazing 🫶
litaly
you were fine until you said that last take xziwueyd
i also HAVE TO listen to the full song, the overcompensate edit version can LEAVE
tough crowd
think atrofd is better then NAVIGATING, and the oc is better then navigating. Insane
like the beginning of the song is perfection, i don't wanna skip all of that
the edit version played on shuffle a couple of times and i was OFFENDED lol, immediately switched it to the original
tyler considered the boot for a reason
you wanna know how it should've been?
overcompensate without and edit
paladin strait with an edit that cuts the minute for the ones that don't like it
the edit sucks
you have vignette IN YOUR BIO come on give it a vote
love the instrumental, maybe one of tylers catchiest songs in his discography. The lyrics just dont come off as groundbreaking like some of his other songs.
oohhh see i personally don't mind the pause in paladin strait, i think it adds to the song in a way! but i've seen a lot of people complain about the pause so you're definitely right about that!
REAL, it takes so much away from the song, it needs the full instrumental at the start
yeah that's why i clarified because i like it too! but it's fine if people find it like a nuisance
listen Ill still be satisfied if vignette wins, its top 3
help it win
please no
Wtf 😭
and navigating is one i wouldnt mind winner either.
but like
dont let lavish win
can it even win?
i love lavish
just dont let it win
whyyy
lavish is out tho
lavish is NOT as good as some of the other songs, always a vibe too listen too though
its not top dog
oh
yeah, i've seen a lot of people mention that they struggle to listen to it on repeat because of the pause, so i guess an edited version would have been good for them, but i'm perfectly fine with the full version haha
ofc
okay question, what's everyone's fave clancy video??? or videos???
It annoyed me there wasn’t the silence in the mv, BECUASE WHATS THE POINT OF IT IN THE ACTUAL SONG. I thought cool it’s important in the mv, there is literally nooo point
Merp paladin
LAVISH ALL DAY
do not including paladin
I don't think the lyrics have to be groundbreaking to make it one of his best though
cuz like
Your name always makes lavish get stuck in my head
besides paladin, Vignette without a doubt
hehehehe
also I don't like the pause in that song but the only reason is that it's not in the video. at least make it consistent
fake fan I haven’t sat and watched the mvs yet
it puts me in such a good mood, i smile at the screen like a total idiot every single time 😭
sameee
well, anyone can write a song about farts, and make it considerably catchy
oohh nice nice
PRODIGAL SON
DONE RUNNING
COME UP WITH JOSH DUN
it ain’t about farts though🙏
WANTED DEAD OR ALIVE
its about navigating
it’s great
its too much of a vibe to have a deep topic
real
especially the part where tyler is like "ceilingggg" and starts laughing right after 😭 like idc how many times i see it, i giggle every single time
PREACH
it's not about farts though, it's about a powerful emotional experience; and the writing is extremely good, mature writing with good rhymes and great flow. all I'm saying is a song doesn't have to be mind-blowing to be incredibly solid, which I think Navigating exemplifies
yea that part is funny
i was honestly surprised that they didn't add it to the video
this is amazing
me too, and very disappointed. why would you make your song 6 minutes long and then make the video a whole minute shorter
atrofd?
i need to see a full behind the scenes video for that because the small clip we got was so funny
yes we do
no
we NEED one
i would have definitely expected it to be the other way around, like the video being longer than the song if not the exact time frame
okay not my best example. I see your point too. I just thought i cleared up my opinion about how i think other songs in the album had more interesting and complex lyrics, but i respect the appreciation towards navigatings structure.
AS YOU SHOULD
FOR REAL
what was the point of the birds
yeah it's definitely not a complex track, but it's one of the rare instances where tøp pulls off simplicity perfectly
which is honestly a breath of fresh air
in what is a very complex album, if nothing else
Good way of putting it, simplicity, I fw that
I saw a theory that Voldsoy is the Isle of Flightless Birds, and that's what it signifies
with like a cycle repeating back to the start of their discog and allat
thats tuff
NoLifeShaq in disguise I see
for me its josh here its so funny to me😭😭😭😭
🤞🌞 kingalicious yk me
Easily Lavish or Midwest
Routines is up there, and of course Paladin, I mean that is literally movie quality cinematography right there
I can see why they delayed it
Paladin Strait or Overcompensate, I think
they complement their songs the best
Lavish mv is funny though
hmmmmmmm is that what you want to pick?
i og picked viginette
kinda feeling it more
didn't this match up already happen I feel like it did
I remember saying I loved atrofd since day 1 and it took me a while to appreciate vignette
maybe in the gamer station battles
Vignette easiest choice ever
Vignette, i agree
gamer station battles 😭
atrofd ofc
atrofd GOATT
In ATROFD I just really like the lyrics. For anything other than the lyrics I like Vignette more (the intro is very good). Tough one, but I decided to go for ATROFD.
But I can't blame anyone for picking Vignette.
paladin strait objectively but it's obvious since most of the mv's budget went there
so i think i'm going with atrofd for this time, because it manages to portray a message that complements the message of the song in a simple yet creative way
the outfits are insane too
i love your point, i also agree with you, both of them are great vignette is my top 4 but i prefer atrofd for just a tiny bit more
Same
can i steal this idea i might need it for the last couple rounds at this point 💀
go ahead
Routines in the Night, Midwest Indigo, and Vignette
I voted Vignette
Cause I be singing the "no not me it's for a friend" part alot
The paladin strait video was good and well done, I just wanted a proper, definite ending
The delay of the video coming out didn't make it better
I love the lighting and the overall aesthetic of it✨️
Add snap back to that and those are my favs
Interesting
I would also add Lavish
That one was really fun
Even though the song feels out of place on the album
ITS THE SAME GAME TODAY AS IT ALWAYS IS
🔥
yessss
at the risk of sweeping
i love vignette but i have such a connection to the risk 😭
am i right
atrofd 100%
i totally agree with you
BRO THIS ONE IS SO HARD FOR ME
I LOVE THE "CLINGING TOOO"
BUT ALSO THE "DROP DROP DROP"
THE BEAT OF VIGNETTE
BUT ALSO THE SOUND OF ATROFD
vignette is my favorite song and atrofd is just lyrically so mid
also it shouldn't even be here right now
how hasn't atrofd lost like every time
i thought the intro to risk was weird the first time i listened to it so i never have actually listened to it until recently
it sounded too much like a clown song idk why😭
Lmaoo clown song
i think its ok now
but since i first listened to the album i’ve always liked vignette a lot
Same
ok atrofd wins this one
Vignette
The line when he says it's not worth the risk of losing a friend just hits too hard for me.
guys all im gonna say is the first vulture screech in vignette sounds like a minecraft horse dying so if you vote vignette you hate horses
i don’t speak yappanese
apparently they do, and pretty fluent in such language
No it doesn’t
Vignette has been on my mind as of late, BUT I LOVE AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB BRO
Ayo
Vignette more like Vigpeak #smartphoned
Atrofd
At the risk of feeling dumb!
LEVEL UP: You are now level 1!
CHECK IIIIIIIIIIIINNNNNNNNNN
gotta vote atrofd even though my name says otherwise (lyrics from vignette)
bro is not fighting off the vignette 😓
LOL i just relate to atrofd more tbh 😭 vignette is definitely my 2nd favorite tho
i think that's what people forget when they argue why people like it so much
ok wrong reply
there
how so? 🤨
like, the song is really relatable to us and some people that don't like atrofd that much kind of forget that i'm pretty sure
they would say stuff like "why would you prefer at the risk instead of X song" when probably the main reason is the message of the song
ah (i understand half of that)
Vignette might be the best song on Clancy in my opinion
My brother loves lavish 😄😄
ilywm
home of phobia
so true
@frosty barn vote vignette for clear skin
person named phobia:
vignette is so clean but atrofd means a lot to me esp rn
I love both of these songs ;-;
Vignette
1 hour, 20 minutes until the next song battle y'all
get voting for at the risk of feeling dumb ‼️
josh didn't drum in the most insane places for y'all to vote something else over at the risk of feeling dumb
and THAT FIT
that angle is amazing
how are song battles everyone i haven’t been here in a while
next semester is out for some reason and i think that's all that's happened xjdkdkd
Thankfully Overcompansate lost
It's crazy considering the fact that 2 months ago people voted for it over Car Radio which was an insane choice on it's own and now it lost to Midwest Indigo and Routines In The Night.
WHAAAT
that’s crazy
YALLL DONT DESERVE VIGNETTE
we won
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
HOW
SO FUCKING CLOSE
now how does at the risk of feeling dumb beat the best song on clancy
risk is good but it does NOT beat vign
STOP THE COUNT!
im so mad
these server takes INSANE
real
paladin strait, overcompensate and vignette just GONE. </3
dam wow
Overcompensate rightly so
WHAT
Overcompensate rightly so
get out rn :(
lets go at the risk
don't worry unfortunately it's gonna lose against navigating it already lost against it before so that's the most likely outcome
and next semester 💔
YEAH </3
NOOOOOOO ATROFD ALWAYS SWEEPS MY FAVOURITE SONG I HATE IT
LETS GOO
good
AS IT SHOULD TBH
Damn that was close
closest one by far holy crap
i didn't even notice how close it was until now tbh haha
i didn't pay much attention to that, i just looked at which one won
Vignette was robbed 
Bro at the risk is not that good wtf
vignette stood NO CHANCE
more like midnette
as long as navigating doesn't win
Atrofd over vignette is criminal
oh this kinda surprises me tbh
I get sad every time I remember this song battle
Atrofd >>>>>>>