#Clancy Song Battle #21
topaz raftBOT
Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1721228400:R>
mild oar
NAW
real helm
OLDIES FTW
mild oar
THIS IS HARD
odd mica
MIDWEST INDIGOAT
obtuse saddle
FUCK OFF NICO
waxen cargo
ohh
vale bobcat
u can be so COOOOLDDD
waxen cargo
hmmm
orchid narwhal
Oldies station 
mild oar
I'm going to have to go with oldies station
hot flicker
MIDWESWEEP INDIGO
mild oar
midwest indigo is a close second
real helm
Oldies station <:asscheeker:854378605589037107>
oneshot pfp W
dry wharf
OLDIES STATION SWEEEPS
frosty kite
M I d w e s t I n d I g o
hot flicker
shit nobody's going with midwest indigo😭
hot flicker
M I d w e s t I n d I g o
oh there
odd mica
me the next 5 hours
frosty kite
That’s fair
modest jetty
Midwest >>>
dry wharf
OLDIES STATION
obtuse saddle
me the next 5 hours
Bro same
wintry kestrel
MIDWEST CLEARS
obtuse saddle
I can't choose, I love em both so much 
dry wharf
yall have no IDEA how much i want oldies to win
frosty kite
P u s h o n t h r o u g h
vernal solar
ah yes my favorite song MIDOOWLEST
south phoenix
Nooooooo
obtuse saddle
Push on through vs WHAT'S YOUR ETA
frosty kite
Push on through vs WHAT'S YOUR ETA
Dos Minutos
burnt sinew
What's your eta?
2 MINUTES
...
Chill out man we're right on time
frosty kite
Reaching out on my way home
You can be so cold, I'll try again
You make me sad and second-guess myself
You can be so cold
Reaching out on my way home
You can be so cold, I'll try again
You make me sad and second-guess myself
You can be so cold, Midwest Indigo
Running late so I didn't have the time
To scrape the frosted windshield
Like we're barely scraping by
Concentrate on the little gap in the ice
That seems to be about as wide as our chances
"Did you pull up yet?
Not yet
Did you forget we're tight on time?"
Reaching out on my way home
You can be so cold, I'll try again
You make me sad and second-guess myself
You can be so cold, Midwest Indigo
Cloud coverage matched my outfit to a knife
I requested counsel with the counselor
And he cancelled twice
It's a different blue, it's deeper than it's been
I'll be pulling into the parking lot before the heat kicks in
"What's your ETA?
Two minutes
Chill out, man, we're right on time"
Reaching out on my way home
You can be so cold, I'll try again
You make me sad and second-guess myself
You can be so cold, Midwest Indigo
And I want love and sunny days
I'm a bit too old to run away
You make me sad and second-guess myself
You can be so cold
You can be so cold
Midwest Indigo
frosty kite
Only consistency in your periphery
Is fear and the bridge of your nose
And as you move about
You learn to tune 'em out
But they say they continue to grow
Fear of the past and relative pain
Future's coming fast, you've got nothing in the tank
In a season of purging things you used to love
Everything must go, mm-hmm
Make an oath then make mistakes
Start a streak you're bound to break
When darkness rolls on you
Push on through
Push on through
Then before you know, you lose some people close
Forcing you to manage your pace
Found your capacity for love and tragedy
Embracing how things always change
You've had your turns with relative pain
Little less concerned when there's nothing in the tank
In a season of lessons learned in giving up
You learn what you can and can't take, mm-hmm
Add some years, build some trust
You start to feel your eyes adjust
When darkness rolls on you
Push on through
Push on through
You don't quite mind
You don't quite mind
You don't quite mind how long red lights are taking
(Push on through)
Your favorite song was on the oldies station
(Push on through)
You have it down
That old fight for survival
(Push on through)
You're in the crowd at her first dance recital
(Push on through)
Make an oath then make mistakes
Start a streak you're bound to break
When darkness rolls on you
Push on through
pale estuary
I wonder what its like to be Josh, drummin' away while watching your front man act a fool and get hurt and god knows what else he seems from back there
MIDWEST INDIGO
BA BA BA
BA BA BA
BA BA BAAAAAAAAA
frosty kite
I thought it was oh oh oh 😭
upper shale
NO NO NO NOOOOO
last edge
No fucking way
grave imp
Oldies
last edge
This are my two favorites
frosty kite
Only consistency in your periphery
Is fear and the bridge of your nose
And as you move about
You learn to tune 'em out
But they say they continue to grow
Fear of the past and relative pain
Future's coming fast, you've got nothing in the tank
In a season of purging things you used to love
Everything must go, mm-hmm
Make an oath then make mistakes
Start a streak you're bound to break
When darkness rolls on you
Push on through
Push on through
Then before you know, you lose some people close
Forcing you to manage your pace
Found your capacity for love and tragedy
Embracing how things always change
You've had your turns with relative pain
Little less concerned when there's nothing in the tank
In a season of lessons learned in giving up
You learn what you can and can't take, mm-hmm
Add some years, build some trust
You start to feel your eyes adjust
When darkness rolls on you
Push on through
Push on through
You don't quite mind
You don't quite mind
You don't quite mind how long red lights are taking
(Push on through)
Your favorite song was on the oldies station
(Push on through)
You have it down
That old fight for survival
(Push on through)
You're in the crowd at her first dance recital
(Push on through)
Make an oath then make mistakes
Start a streak you're bound to break
When darkness rolls on you
Push on through
gleaming saddle
Love oldies so much but midwest is my fav
last edge
I can't choose
orchid ember
MIDWEST FTW!!!!
flat lodge
YOU CAN BE SO COOOOLD
zenith fern
PUSH ON THROUGHHH
ripe vigil
tyler wrote oldies station for US
night tangle
Midwest indigo
pale estuary
WHAT'S YOUR ETA?
spark plank
OUCH
ripe vigil
YOU DON'T QUITE MIND HOW LONG RED LIGHTS ARE TAKING
spark plank
i'm going oldies because i like both pretty much equally and midwest still has 3 lives 🙂↕️
fluid anvil
You're in the crowd at her first dance recital 😭
steel cypress
GOSH how am I suppose to choose
pale estuary
DOESN'T MEAN WE CAN'T BOP WITH THE MIDWEST
frosty kite
Oldies is for Oldies
crude summit
Midwest no competition
tardy lotus
frick
smoky heath
midwest indigo easily
ripe vigil
You're in the crowd at her first dance recital 😭
PUSH ON THROUGH😭
worldly fern
midwest guys
tranquil horizon
PUSH ONN THROUUUUGH
gleaming saddle
And I want love and sunny days
ripe vigil
oldies station is "stay alive" in song form
neat hawk
PUSH ON THROUGHHHHHHHH
frosty kite
And I want love and sunny days
Am a bit to old too run away
neat hawk
OLDIES STATION W
rustic beacon
Oldies is my favorite from Clancy
frosty kite
NO
heady oracle
When darkness rolls on you
ripe vigil
When darkness rolls on you
push on through!!!!!!!
rustic beacon
You don’t quite mind how long red lights are taking
ripe vigil
it makes me tear up
errant pike
Oldies
gleaming saddle
Am a bit to old too run away
You make me sad and second-guess myself
frosty kite
rustic beacon
it makes me tear up
Literally same
rustic beacon
Sad but true
frosty kite
You make me sad and second-guess myself
YOU CAN BE SO COLDDDDDDDDD OHHHHHHHHHHHHH
muted hollow
Guys Midwest indego is for Ohio but oldies station is for all of us
smoky heath
boo
frosty kite
Guys Midwest indego is for Ohio but oldies station is for all of us
Not again
smoky heath
midwest on top‼️‼️
rustic beacon
Guys Midwest indego is for Ohio but oldies station is for all of us
What he said
wooden ruin
Most painful possible matchup 😭 it’s my top two on the album
terse bluff
gleaming saddle
Guys Midwest indego is for Ohio but oldies station is for all of us
It's okay I still love oldies station
severe beacon
push on through
wet inlet
Voted midwest indigo
orchid ember
Listen I love Oldies but it was only saved by that switch up at the end.....Midwest is a non-stop banger!!!
gleaming saddle
Listen I love Oldies but it was only saved by that switch up at the end.....Midw...
Oldies is a banger also like the whole song is just perfect but midwest indigo is like top 1
north shadow
REACHING OUT ON MY WAY HOME
sterile iris
if midwest wins then you guys are immature babies
frosty kite
if midwest wins then you guys are immature babies
W u t
severe beacon
i like MWI but Oldies Station and its lyrics mean too much to me
opaque python
Mwi win
sterile iris
i like MWI but Oldies Station and its lyrics mean too much to me
exactly
mwi is just surface level lyrics
gleaming saddle
if midwest wins then you guys are immature babies
What😭
south rain
oldies is definitely one of the best songs on the album, but like, midwest indigo is just so poetic and feels like a modernized vessel song
safe inlet
oldies i love you
orchid ember
Oldies is a banger also like the whole song is just perfect but midwest indigo i...
Literally!!!!
spiral coyote
What's the status of every song? Like who's eliminated or about to be eliminated?
orchid ember
oldies is definitely one of the best songs on the album, but like, midwest indig...
Lol the way I was just about to say Midwest Indigo is like Vessel's granddaughter
obtuse saddle
HELPPPP
north shadow
Ahhh I just listened to both of them and now I can’t decide
obtuse saddle
frosty kite
https://tenor.com/view/sussy-baka-sus-among-us-gif-27599519
W H A T
mystic hound
Midwest for the win
jade willow
I’m taking Oldies here; it’s a lot more emotionally powerful and melodically sticks in my head better. I also think it’s one of the most perfectly placed songs on the whole album, and the emotional impact of the track really fits its placing, reflecting its role in the project as a whole. However, I will say on behalf of Midwest that it does have slightly more poetic writing
robust moat
Ro! Ro!
analog palm
Oldies Station the best song of TOP
obtuse saddle
LMFAOOOO THANKS FOR THE GOLD 
orchid ember
I feel like Oldies should have been where ATROFD is on the tracklist.....
jade willow
I feel like Oldies should have been where ATROFD is on the tracklist.....
honestly I think ATROFD is the misplaced one, rather than Oldies
it could very easily be in the first half of the album and nobody would bat an eye
thorny hull
this one is easy, oldies station
sleek jewel
i am in denial that at the risk lost to navigating
severe sigil
heady oracle
i am in denial that at the risk lost to navigating
Navigating oldies and atrofd are my top 3 tbh
I'm pining for oldies in second at least
sleek jewel
Navigating oldies and atrofd are my top 3 tbh
same + vignette
orchid ember
honestly I think ATROFD is the misplaced one, rather than Oldies
Oldies always felt like it should have been before Paladin, it just has that vibe
north shadow
YOU DONT QUITE MIND HOW LONG RED LIGHTS ARE TAKING
faint lake
this is probably the hardest one yet but i’d have to say oldies even though midwest is SUCH A VIBE
jade willow
Oldies always felt like it should have been before Paladin, it just has that vib...
I do get that, but it is very close to that spot; and the majority of the other songs on the album could be shifted around anywhere with little to no consequence
the only songs that absolutely can’t move are OC and Paladin
faint lake
considering i’m getting a tattoo of oldies i can’t really vote otherwise 😭
jade willow
the only songs that absolutely can’t move are OC and Paladin
I would argue Oldies is one of the closest in the tracklist to the spot it should be in
jade willow
considering i’m getting a tattoo of oldies i can’t really vote otherwise 😭
LOL betrayal
faint lake
can’t betray the tatt 💔
and i did graffiti of oldies station too so i think my answer is loud and clear 😭
ornate lichen
you can be so cold, i’ll try again
ancient fjord
midwest indigo stands no chance
i don't even think it's that bad just very very average
tawny linden
so either “push on through” or “chill out man, we’re right on time” (ft. josh singing live???)
ancient fjord
"mid" by the actual definition of mid
some people seem to think mid means bad
i just think midwest indigo is very average
severe sigil
so either “push on through” or “chill out man, we’re right on time” (ft. josh si...
its JOSH……….
ancient fjord
i don't dislike it
severe sigil
SINGING………..
spiral heath
Midwest easily
south phoenix
This has to be
spiral heath
I like oldies but midwest is one of my favorites
rancid bison
spiral heath
yuhhhh
heady oracle
You have it down, that old fight for survival
vapid steppe
Easy
sick island
This is a tough choice
Getting down to the end of the voting so choices will get tougher and tougher
dim bloom
hard but oldies
jade willow
navigating beat atrofd, really?
yes because it’s the better song by a long shot
heady oracle
i dont care where you come from
If you really wanna know what I'm thinking, it kinda feels like everybody leaves
upper drum
WHATS YOUR ETA
dawn ridge
Stop these are my two favorite songs off the album
harsh delta
Oldies Station sweep
dawn ridge
IDK WHAT TO CHOOSE
dawn ridge
Oldies Station sweep
I think Midwest is gonna win
upbeat quail
This is so hard bc Midwest is SO real but oldies is so REAL
heady oracle
Oldies makes me cry
upbeat quail
They both make me cry
heady oracle
I love oldies station
ornate pawn
Oldies station
upbeat quail
Going oldies bc I’m not from Ohio but I’m in the Midwest
last yew
oldies i love u
vapid shore
yes because it’s the better song by a long shot
All my opinion, but hearing the chorus of navigating for the first time is jarring, and still in a way is. I also think the verses are much weaker than atrofd’s verses.
tawny linden
WHATS YOUR ETA
TWO MINUTES!!
long swan
This is so hard but I gotta go with midwest indigo
“And I want love and sunny days
I’m a bit too old to run away”
burnt coral
oldies station lets do it
heady oracle
mild oar
no no no this is exactly what I was afraid of
mild oar
oldies station lets do it
can't believe lavish is gone rip
kind locust
YOUR IN THE CROWD AT HER FIRST DANCE RECITAL, PUSH ON THROUGH 😩😔✌️
wicked moss
# YOUR IN THE CROWD AT HER FIRST DANCE RECITAL, PUSH ON THROUGH 😩😔✌️
(RO RO RO RO)
worn charm
oldies station is really good
i can't compare it to midwest indigo, the vibes and rhythms are completely opposite
Midwest indigo is really moving while oldies is more calm
worn charm
i wish oldies won because i don't want it disqualified
but i can't do that to midwest indigo
heady oracle
Midwest still has another life
worn charm
yeah that's what i mean like
midwest indigo won't lose
oldies won't have another chance after this if it loses
unkempt sun
Midwest Indigo
Song about Ohio?
Lame
only encompassing a small portion of the clique
counselor kinda lame for cancelling twice
Oldies Station
Struggling in life? it's okay things will get better (I promise)
You don't quite mind
Push on through
Song about hope
Song about US THE CLIKKIES EVERYONE
It's the new kind of Truce but a lot more than just sadnesss
mild oar
MIDWESTTTTT ITS SO GROOVY
heady oracle
Midwest Indigo
> Song about Ohio?
> Lame
> only encompassing a small portion of ...
I'd argue oldies station is kinda like a distant cousin of WDBWOTV
Like a distant cousin
unkempt sun
isnt wdbwotv like a 2nd cousin removed from like Tear in My Heart
heady oracle
Kind of
waxen pine
Midwest easy
worn charm
Midwest Indigo
> Song about Ohio?
> Lame
> only encompassing a small portion of ...
a few (lot of) things wrong but overall u got it
unkempt sun
a lot????? I get it that Lame and Truce comparison is a long reach (I like Midwest) but how is most of it wronng??????
worn charm
a lot????? I get it that Lame and Truce comparison is a long reach (I like Midwe...
nah it's just kidding, just like 2 things
unkempt sun
H we fhshd
burnt coral
pick oldies
normal roost
im abt to pick oldies station..
vivid mantle
These two songs are very different so hard to compare
midnight umbra
I like the vocals from OS but I love the synth from MI
midnight umbra
I'm still mad that ✨✨✨LAVISH✨✨✨ lost
sullen panther
midwest indigo???
oldies station fs
vast hawk
How does Oldies Station have 1 loss? 😭
Lost to seed 1 Vignette
If anything tho that will be it's only loss
past hearth
Midsweep
past hearth
Midwest Indigo
> Song about Ohio?
> Lame
> only encompassing a small portion of ...
Oldies Station: snoozefest until like the last quarter of the song
Midwest: a banger throughout
fierce condor
Was just gonna say that
unkempt sun
snoozefest? sounds like a you problem
mystic hound
Oldies Station: snoozefest until like the last quarter of the song
Midwest: a ...
U right
past hearth
snoozefest? sounds like a you problem
lol
lmao even
oldies is so generic
but it doesn’t do anything super special to make it stand out from anything else that sounds like it
Midwest you could maybe argue is generic but at least the synths add something unique
oldies is good but absolutely not on the level of Midwest
torpid moat
I have to go oldies. It’s what’s been keeping me going rn
past hearth
totally fair
jovial totem
I have to go oldies. It’s what’s been keeping me going rn
Same 
I love Midwest but oldies is just too good
outer salmon
OLDIIIIIIEEEEEEES
waxen mist
OLDIES PLEASE
arctic cipher
oldies station so that both the songs survive for longer
prime venture
past hearth
actually insane im seeing more support for oldies wtf
topaz raftBOT
actually insane im seeing more support for oldies wtf
past hearth
im surrounded by lunatics
vivid mantle
actually insane im seeing more support for oldies wtf
midwest indigo is a soulless song
mystic hound
midwest indigo is a soulless song
I find it heartwarming and nostalgic
worn charm
midwest indigo is a soulless song
nah it covers the topic of nostalgia and time pressure in a really fcking relatable way
pale estuary
CHILL OUT, MAN, WE'RE RIGHT ON TIME
night sage
Crap, idk which to choose, I think I have to go with oldies bc I cant let it be eliminated
worn charm
Crap, idk which to choose, I think I have to go with oldies bc I cant let it be ...
same
I'm like struggling also
i love both of them
but i don't want it to be disqualified
midwest indigo will have another chance, but if oldies lose it's over
night sage
midwest indigo will have another chance, but if oldies lose it's over
NS, snap back and backslide are gone so I’m rooting for oldies and navigating now
ATROFD is also a good song
Important message
worn charm
Important message
yesss love when people appreciate atrofd
jade willow
correct me if I’m wrong but I feel like a lot of people call Oldies boring because it has a lot of instruments and it’s not particularly slow; so it feels like it should be something more than it is?
I’m just trying to get into the mind of someone who would call the song boring
because to me, while I can acknowledge that there isn’t a ton going on, I feel like that helps its case rather than hinders it
like it’s supposed to be slow and simple so that the lyrics and emotional impact really shine
like Truce, like Goner, like Neon Gravestones
people don’t usually call those songs boring, because the lack of generally interesting elements/distracting elements is so evidently intentional
I can see how Oldies doesn’t quite do that as obviously or as effectively, but I still would say boring isn’t the best criticism to make of the song
past hearth
midwest indigo is a soulless song
where is the soul in oldies
it’s generic as shit lol
jade willow
aren’t you a The Craving single version fan
or am I mixing you up with someone else
there’s a ton of people here 😂
empty egret
both of them r so good but oldies station just brings out the feels!!!!!!!!!
worn charm
where is the soul in oldies
oh my goodness i can't believe that's a genuine question
unkempt sun
where is the soul in oldies
nah ur ahh tweaking bro
past hearth
or am I mixing you up with someone else
You definitely are lol
past hearth
oh my goodness i can't believe that's a genuine question
In the lyrics sure there is
But listening to it is like eating a cheese sandwich
Good writing doesn’t save a boring song
worn charm
that might be true but the instrumental is genuinely good, it's like truce, because it's a slow song and only piano it doesn't mean it's the worst on vessel, this one's slower and more calm, not the vibe of midwest indigo or navigating but that doesn't mean it's bad
that takes back to the fact that music is subjective so if you don't like the instrumental that's totally fine
but oldies station is a song full of meaning
and not solely on the lyrics
past hearth
i should clarify that I don’t dislike the instrumental actually
I think it works for the song but im not gonna pretend it’s anything special
Midwest just does better at remaining interesting and unique in lyrics and instrumentals
worn charm
Midwest just does better at remaining interesting and unique in lyrics and instr...
gotta admit you got a point there
from start to finish it maintains the listener interested
oldies is the same style all the way through up until right at the end with the you don't quite mind and all that, and it's not that big of a change
calm nest
i have to vote oldies
but sad these two are up against each other 🤧 i would've voted midwest over atrofd or navigating easilyyy
mortal quest
oh shit
oldies makes mw cry midwest makes me indescribably happy
i cant watch oldies die im sorry midwest
unreal frost
the amount of people that vote specifically to not let a song die instead of which one they like better is annoyingly high
worn charm
the amount of people that vote specifically to not let a song die instead of whi...
that's true
same shit happens when people vote songs on revenge for other songs that won over songs they like and now they're avenging them by not voting the song that kicked the song they didn't want to see lose
copper plover
oldies
heady oracle
Thanks poot
mystic hound
the amount of people that vote specifically to not let a song die instead of whi...
Fr like why all the grudges lol
Just pick the songs ya like
unreal frost
same shit happens when people vote songs on revenge for other songs that won ove...
so annoying bruh
like yall made so many songs lose 😭
worn charm
im still salty over routines losing to atrofd
the bros that thought it was a nice and fair idea 😭😭
gritty flax
Oldies deserves another chance at life
I love Midwest Indigo but oldies station just hits different
heady oracle
Ro ro ro
odd elm
mellow pier
this pains me
mortal nova
WHAT'S YOUR ETA
trim axle
mortal nova
but also consider the live version of midwest indigo with josh's angelic vocals
dusk sleet
This is a hard one!!!
jade willow
But listening to it is like eating a cheese sandwich
cheese sandwiches are the best don’t go dissing cheese sandwiches like that
mortal nova
tbh this one will difficult
but i went with midwest indigo
but considering switching to oldies station
nah nevermind
changed my mind
i'm sticking with midwest indigo
CHILL OUT MAN WE'RE RIGHT ON TIME
not oldies station playing on shuffle right after i said this
wow
okay nevermind i think i'm gonna change my vote
😭😭😭😭
give me a break you guys
opaque python
okay nevermind i think i'm gonna change my vote
Bruh
opaque python
i ended up not changing it 🥹
Good
mortal nova
yeahhh i was considering it but i stuck with midwest indigo after all
muted hollow
NOOO
copper ore
vast hawk
is that oldies out?
obtuse saddle
NOOOOOO
swift otter
This song battle has been going downhill for a few battles .
dry wharf
OLDIES MY BABY
heady oracle
💔
mystic hound
W
past hearth
LFGGGG
real helm
YALL DONT DESERVE OLDIES STATION
errant pike
Common song battles L
vast hawk
Midwest upsets:
seed 6 Next Semester
seed 2 Oldies Station
What more mass destruction will this song commit
minor dagger
Midwest deserves it
minor dagger
Its good but midwest is better
kind locust
HOW TF DID OLDIES LOSE
gritty flax
Oldies my baby
unkempt sun
:(
harsh jungle
AIN’T NO WAY MIDWEST IS BOUTTA COME OUT ON TOP 😭
At this point i’ve watched all of my fav songs off Clancy get brutally murdered and I’m never going to let that go
safe inlet
yeah oldies def deserves better