#Clancy Song Battle #19

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

balmy doveBOT
#

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1721055600:R>

marble nimbus
#

risk

native cave
#

AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB CHECK IIIIIIIN

rotund anvil
#

h

flat perch
#

ooh

#

this is hard

cinder wharf
#

jesus this is the hardest ive ever seen

native cave
#

ITS NOT WORTH THE RISK OF LOSING A FRIEEEEEEEEND

elfin fern
#

Love routines, but 🗣️ DROP DROP DROP ‼️ 🔥

pulsar comet
#

ITS NOT WORTH THE RISK OF LOSING A FRIIIIEEEEEND

flat perch
#

routines and atrofd 3rd and 4th respectively

exotic fjord
#

atrofd my beloved :(

elfin fern
#

AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB CHIKEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEN

cinder wharf
#

interchangeable 1 and 2 for me

north karma
#

AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB CHECK IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIN

marble shoal
#

ROUTINES AGAIN LETS RUN IT BACK

urban pewter
#

ATROFD is just that bitch

rotund anvil
#

atrofd bc ritn is just a touch repetitive

#

atrofd has progression which makes it cool

#

you're waiting for the next drop literally

urban pewter
#

Progression of height

pine sorrel
#

R O O A T U I N E S 💀

chrome citrus
#

Routines!!!!!

urban pewter
#

ATROFD is repetitive but it’s infectious and super complex. Tyler said himself there were 54 versions. It’s literally a PERFECT song. Routines is incredible too but ATROFD has more to offer lyrically, vocally, and production wise

rotund anvil
#

everyone loved ritn most when it dropped but idk it didn't grab my attention as much as several other songs
also atrofd was immediately my favorite from the first listen

urban pewter
#

Agree

urban pewter
#

Ritn is just grown up blurryface while atrofd is doing something new. It is an essential Clancy track

valid horizon
#

atrofd hit the second i heard it even tho routines is super catchy to me atrofd just like. Hits hard

rotund anvil
#

yes atrofd is very clancy

chrome citrus
#

I dont know both are good but I like the feeling of listening to ritn just a bit more

mellow orchid
valid horizon
#

routines is one of my faves but i just remember being at the listening party and tearing up a little to atrofd and that feeling is not replicable

rotund anvil
#

honestly clancy is all in S and A tiers we're nitpicking for those battles

valid horizon
#

yeah i agree its hard because i didnt pre rank the album so everytime a song battle comes out i have to actually decide which song i love is better than which song i love

shut shadow
#

routines

gloomy frost
#

At the risk of feeling dumb check inmnnn

whole steeple
#

This is it

#

Imma sit this one out

round quiver
#

Others are overcompensating

whole steeple
#

Can’t choose between these two

#

They both my babies I can’t

umbral crown
#

honestly either one can win and I'm not mad

#

i loved atrofd immediately but ritn grew on me pretty quickly

#

buttttt for the sake of my user name imma vote routines

upper rain
#

Routines clears

urban pewter
umbral crown
#

putting routines to the test twice in a row like that is mean tho

shut shadow
#

I ain’t even a routines fan it is just better

#

Disagree with them beating ns

ruby nexus
#

ritn does not deserve to win after ns was obliterated

upper rain
#

Ehh it’s the better song

#

I think it’s the song where Clancy becomes Clancy

thick rampart
#

I'm taking RITN here

thick rampart
upper rain
#

Nonono

#

You misunderstand me

thick rampart
#

you mean the character? or the style of the album

upper rain
#

Alvums don’t need one song to set the album theme they need many

#

Routines is where the albums footing is found

#

Easily

thick rampart
#

It's where it gets into a groove for sure

#

but

#

in terms of the album style, OC is the most Clancy-ish song on Clancy

shut shadow
thick rampart
shut shadow
#

it’s much better then atrofd

#

obviosuly ns deserved that win

thick rampart
#

idk why people are acting like the songs are at fault for winning 💀

shut shadow
#

real

shut shadow
#

Like the most centremost of a ven diagram

thick rampart
thick rampart
upper rain
#

🗣️ WALK THE LAYOUT
🗣️ ROUTINES IN THE NIGHT

urban pewter
#

Listen man imo if all of Clancy was like overcompensate it would beat out trench, but Clancy has more of a vibe close to next semester in all its songs than overcompensate so trench is still the magnum opus

upper rain
#

I'd argue that Snap back is a very clancy sounding song

shut shadow
#

but I cannot suggest an alternative (as of now)

shut shadow
thick rampart
# shut shadow I’m not sure if I agree

I mean there are very evident outliers like The Craving and Next Semester, but for the most part I think it sets the scene stylistically better than any other song on the project could

upper rain
urban pewter
upper rain
#

How is oldies station boring

shut shadow
#

nah the bridge is fire

thick rampart
urban pewter
upper rain
#

It comes after a very exciting instrumental break and leads into another exciting song

#

its simply a breather in the pacing

#

🗣️ RELATIVE PAIN!

urban pewter
#

It doesn’t pick up until halfway through

shut shadow
thick rampart
shut shadow
#

the vocals are varied lol

urban pewter
#

Routines is so interesting tho like the instrumental sounds like a night psycho trip

thick rampart
#

my point is, you can't judge a song solely off the instrumental when the vocals and lyrics are as important 💀

urban pewter
shut shadow
#

instrumental by its own isn’t the purpose of the song lol

urban pewter
thick rampart
shut shadow
#

the vocals are good also

#

they aren’t boring

upper rain
#

I'm gonna cry and report this to FBR

#

what a waste of tiem

urban pewter
#

The vocals are good but Tyler sings so well now I don’t understand why a personal song like oldies station needs 50 Tyler’s singing over one another

shut shadow
#

the you’ve had your turns with relative pain and all that is intresting

thick rampart
#

what are you on

shut shadow
urban pewter
upper rain
#

Why cause im gatekeepin are you sayin

#

cause i was tehre buddy

exotic flare
#

this one hurts T_T

upper rain
#

I REMEMBER

shut shadow
#

I remmeber certain things

thick rampart
urban pewter
shut shadow
#

I’m so confused about saying the vocals are boring

#

they aren’t like an average song

thick rampart
shut shadow
#

there’s loads of different features

urban pewter
upper rain
#

You're attacking oldies stations for vocal doubling and not snap back 🤦‍♂️

urban pewter
#

Snap back’s instrumental is so cool bro don’t even get me started

upper rain
shut shadow
#

oldies stations instrumental isn’t noticeably bad

upper rain
#

Lyrics are the only thing that save it

urban pewter
upper rain
urban pewter
#

I love oldies station btw 8.5/10

thick rampart
shut shadow
urban pewter
#

I’m allowed to say I don’t like certain parts of the song but that I still like the song

#

Am I not

#

Is that not what this whole chat is for bruh

thick rampart
#

yes

#

and we're also allowed to push back on that

#

cause

#

discussion

#

:D

urban pewter
#

Push on

upper rain
#

No you cant criticise songs here

urban pewter
#

Deez

#

Nuts

upper rain
#

Rule 19

shut shadow
urban pewter
upper rain
urban pewter
#

NOOOO DONT GET THE BISHOPS ON MY AHH

upper rain
#

They take the rules seriously.

#

As do I.

hot yoke
#

and i

urban pewter
#

Good for them.

upper rain
#

I was a minimod until last week

urban pewter
#

See how serious I am using periods at the end of my sentence.

hot yoke
#

💀

#

ooo scary...look at me using 3

upper rain
#

bush did 11/9

urban pewter
hot yoke
#

LMAO

upper rain
#

I have knives on me

#

Don't bring the gun owners towards me

hot yoke
#

what's that gonna do in a discord chat

round totem
#

NOO THOS IS SO HARD

#

U LOVE THEM BOTH

#

I

urban pewter
hot yoke
#

WALK THE LAYOUT / ROUTINES IN THE NIGHT 🗣️🗣️

round totem
topaz geyser
#

at the risk of feeling dumb

upper rain
#

Run the layout, irregularities in the day
All windows have "come in" cleaned in black
While all the world's awake, I sit still instead
Away from the memories, up the corridors of my feet
Run the layout, irregularities in the day
All windows have "come in" cleaned in black
While all the world's awake, I sit still instead
Away from the memories, up the corridors of my feet
There goes an old day but I'll keep it back
I won't jump on the last one
I'm testing the confines of what a body can't do
I'm closing my eyelids down, no matter what
So ugly, the lack of distance
A painless forgetfulness and a wonderful reality
I've never been here before and I’ve got no time
I'll deny you the visit, never show you how you-

topaz geyser
#

its a simple answer

#

ritn does not have

#

CHECK IIIIIIIIIIN

upper rain
#

ATROFD doesnt have reocuring KEEPS CUMINARUND

round totem
#

True

urban pewter
upper rain
#

cuminarund

urban pewter
#

I will not be doing that to arund

topaz geyser
urban pewter
#

Thank you

worthy kettle
#

at the risk of feeling dumb easy

topaz geyser
#

used to be you and me matching kawasaki z's ridin round 270 matching kawasaki tees

#

so much catchier

upper rain
urban pewter
upper rain
topaz geyser
urban pewter
#

ATROFD to paladin is the most based lineup on the album

topaz geyser
#

which

upper rain
round totem
upper rain
#

Actually both songs have great placement

#

🗣️

urban pewter
#

Although that hit of Midwest to routines to vignette is fucking insane

#

The best flow of getting hyped up on the album

fervent island
#

Routines in the night

turbid peak
#

Routines

rustic berry
#

atrofd, this is very easy

round totem
#

RARGHH NO ITS NOTTT

rustic berry
#

routines is a somewhat boring song to me in comparison 😔

#

also im mad it beat ns

round totem
#

grrrr

upper rain
rustic berry
#

atrofd better

hot yoke
#

ritn better

urban pewter
#

Finna be the closest vote yet

#

Wait is this is finals? Which songs are left?

hot yoke
#

took me a Long time personally to like that song, but now that I do it's awesome and I love it
ritn tho? instantaneous
in my top 3 for clancy fr

topaz geyser
#

i like the intro it goes hard in the beginning but then like

#

after that it just gets kinda boring

urban pewter
topaz geyser
#

very true

urban pewter
#

Even if the lyrics are relatable I don’t think they can beat out the message of check in on your friends

topaz geyser
#

yeah plus atrofd just goes harder

#

banger

urban pewter
#

100%

#

EVERYONE NEEDS TO KNOW ESKI IS BASED

round totem
#

Okay

#

I love ATROFD

#

But

#

RITN

#

AGH IDKK

urban pewter
#

Damn

#

that’s a really good point

round totem
#

AGHH I THINK OM GONNA FLIP A COIN

#

MAYBE NOT

#

RATHHHHH

urban pewter
#

ATROFD has more to offer

topaz geyser
#

real

round totem
#

I'm so sorry my love.. RITN
But it has been done

#

Fym 🔪

topaz geyser
#

YEAAAH

round totem
#

I still love them both still

#

But ATROFD

#

Just

#

RARGH

topaz geyser
urban pewter
round totem
#

grah

round totem
late hawk
#

this is for Next Semester

quartz crystal
#

AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB CHECK IIIIIIINN

quartz crystal
neat pelican
quartz crystal
#

man the best three has 2 lives

and ns eliminated but we don't talk about that

topaz geyser
#

if navigating dont win the whole thing im gonna be violent

neat pelican
#

im just glad that oldies is still there

balmy doveBOT
quartz crystal
neat pelican
#

i’d go risk

topaz geyser
#

id go navigating

#

i love risk but

#

myyyy ohhh myyyy

quartz crystal
#

we gotta admit

#

those 2 are the best of the album

#

well

topaz geyser
#

real

quartz crystal
#

personally

#

jxksne

drowsy karma
#

Ritn 2 for 2 🙏

ebon ocean
#

Holy shit routines won

#

I thought we were cooked

upper rain
# neat pelican

im going to murder people for the next semester eliminatin

hard mason
#

agreed

pastel sparrow
#

I'll vote for Routines but after its recent win I'm not happy about it

broken yew
#

I'll be happy either way ❤️🖤

gentle idol
#

at the risk ALL THE WAY

gentle idol
vast bolt
#

Damnnn ATROFD way too overrated

upper rain
vast bolt
#

It's good but Routines In The Night production = better

upper rain
#

Yeah I agree with you

#

No clue why I clowne

vast bolt
#

Is RitN R&B?

rain wolf
vast bolt
rain wolf
vast bolt
#

Routines In The Night is like the Morph of this album

rain wolf
vast bolt
rain wolf
#

Jumpsuit, Levitate, and Morph are the strongest songs that play back to back

upper rain
rain wolf
vast bolt
rain wolf
upper rain
#

modern age-soma-barely legal >

rain wolf
vast bolt
rain wolf
frail fiber
#

AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB CHICKEN🗣️🔥🗣️🔥

gentle idol
#

Who do y’all think will win

quartz crystal
#

(i just said the first part already lmao)

quartz crystal
#

you don't have to drop... anything... for me * drops the mic *

spare plaza
#

FOR REAL

#

the song means so so much to me, like yeah i was ascending to the heavens when i heard routines for the first time but AT THE RISK IS LITERALLY ME

#

i gotta choose at the risk

cyan moth
#

Routines and it’s not a question

spare plaza
#

i claimed risk before the album came out and it did not disappoint, i love u so much routines but at the risk is just too good 😔🤚🏽

unkempt crane
#

These are my two favorite songs grief

gentle idol
unkempt crane
#

I think I’ve got to go with AtRoFD though. The song resonates with me the most on the album

zinc mulch
#

ATROFD sweep??

#

I love navigating and I love oldies station

#

But ATROFD is going undefeated so far

gentle idol
gentle idol
upper rain
#

Who's voting RITN!!!!

whole steeple
#

Me

#

Even though I said I wouldn’t vote

#

But seeing Routines have only one chance left I just can’t

late hawk
quartz crystal
#

tl;dr i love atrofd best off of clancy for me

spare plaza
#

REAL

#

🤝

flat perch
#

Both are so good I'm actually conflicted

zinc mulch
#

At the risk of feeling dumb check in 🗣️

next falcon
#

ritn

quartz crystal
flat perch
thorn night
#

don't do this to me 😭

spring pilot
#

okay this is a tough one

lofty nebula
#

Ritn

ruby nexus
lunar trail
#

Used to be you and me
Matching Kawasaki Z

chrome citrus
#

Walk

#

The

#

Layout

#

Routines

#

In

#

The

#

Fucking

#

Night

quartz crystal
#

RITN but generic hip hop song

robust perch
#

voted atrofd

quartz crystal
#

thank you

shy sail
#

sad i cant add a chicken emoji to the battle post

quartz crystal
#

:🐔

shy sail
#

it's at emoji capacity : " )

red sage
#

ritn for sure. both are great and atrofd definitely has higher highs, but it takes a while to get good imo while ritn is great throughout

azure yarrow
#

can the dickriding stop 😔

#

mfs fr got next semester

balmy doveBOT
remote prawn
#

again routines is just not as good

wary belfry
#

dont make me pick.

#

😭

whole chasm
#

BYE

#

I CAN'T BELIEVE WE'VE ALREADY REACHED THIS ROUND

#

HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO CHOOSE BETWEEN MY #1 SONGS

#

this round was a personal attack

flat hedge
#

Routines

upper rain
#

Parcourir le site, poutine dans la nuit

atomic bone
#

BRO AT THE RISK OF FEELING DUMB BETTER WIN IF NOT IM GONNA CONSUME LETHAL AMOUNTS OF MERCURY

languid bluff
#

Get the mercury ready, dumb is the best song in the album

velvet lynx
#

But they said if it doesnt win they would eat mercury

normal heron
#

ATROF BEST SONG ON THE ALBUM

azure yarrow
#

Easily

foggy iris
#

atrofd obviously

languid bluff
urban compass
#

AT THE RISK OF FEELIN DUMB CHECK INNNN ITS NOT WORTH THE RISK OF LOSING A FRIEND

thin quiver
#

rip routines, you deserved to win 😔

kindred nova
kindred nova
#

The first part of both were fully swapped

azure yarrow
#

eat the risk

quartz crystal
zinc mulch
#

My top 3 are all still kicking

#

ATROFD navigating and oldies

quartz crystal
#

thought paladin strait might fall out of the top 5 because midwest indigo is growing on me and also the paladin strait mv hype is kind of vanishing

#

it's a great song still, it's one of the best album enders

whole chasm
whole chasm
quartz crystal
#

that usually helps to decide at least for me :)

whole chasm
#

but i haven't fully decided yet

gloomy yarrow
#

dude this is the hardest one yet

#

both of these hit so close to home 😬

quartz crystal
quartz crystal
quartz crystal
gloomy yarrow
#

that was an easy next semester for me lol

zinc mulch
#

Hardest battle will be oldies vs atrofd

#

My beloveds

whole chasm
flat perch
left storm
#

i have to go with atrofd but im so sad about the last round :(

remote prawn
#

if atrofd loses im gonna say a slur

stone quail
#

atrofd but I love routines sm

#

ATROFD

#

nvm atrofd is my #5 fav song on clancy

#

routines is #10

remote prawn
#

next semester is already out im gonna be so mad if ritn tried to kill another good song

#

i HATW ritn no i ont

#

avenge ns vote atrofd

stone quail
topaz geyser
#

yeah vote atrofd please

#

get ritn out

#

last life

stone quail
#

next semester deserved better

remote prawn
#

next semester is literally the best song on the album what the fuck

#

get ritn outta here

#

if it wins the whole thing im genuinely gonna go insane

pastel sparrow
#

I like ATROFD and it's grown on me but it's still at the bottom of my Clancy ranking

pastel sparrow
stone quail
#

I'm so sorry but next semester is #12 for me just bc I'm mad I didn't make it to the mv filming 😭😭😭

pastel sparrow
#

And Oldies Station but that's more wishful thinking because I know it's a more divisive song

whole chasm
#

i voted but i will NOT say which one because this one was personal

#

it hurt me actually

topaz basin
gleaming herald
#

OK IDC ANYMORE I HAVE A GRUDGE AGAINST RITN BC IT BEAT NS

#

and at the risk of feeling dumb is so much better

#

Improved Clanky ranking

#

RITN doesn’t exist

#

NS wins by default

slender forum
#

My two favorites from Clancy

umbral crown
#

yall voting for atrofd just because youre salty that ns lost, please reconsider tylerblobdisappointed

#

if you really like it more so be it

#

but dont do it just to hurt my baby >:(

#

also if you vote routines out it implies that atrofd > ns not that ns > ritn

turbid peak
#

routines

turbid peak
#

WHAT

umbral crown
#

noooooo

forest hedge
pastel sparrow
#

At the risk is getting too far along

#

The fact it's got 2 lives and NS is out is criminal

flat hedge
#

At the risk is so repetitive like wtf

arctic jungle
#

How did Routines lose dang

gleaming herald
#

HELL YEAH! THATS WHAT YOU GET FOR BEATING NS, RITN

quick mango
flat hedge
#

Revenge voting is cringe

gleaming herald
#

I assume you’re talking about me

flat hedge
#

I just meant in general i feel revenge voting caused this win. I voted for ns but still voted ritn here.

pastel sparrow
gleaming herald
pastel sparrow
#

And that's okay! Your opinion is valid

wide plover
#

Goodbye Routines grief

rain wolf
#

You did good Routines, ya did good :,)

elfin fern
#

Damn, well fought Routines my baby

gentle idol
#

YES WE WON

umbral crown
#

but at what cost? grief

tranquil jetty
#

BRO WHAT

winter turret
#

YESSSSSSS

tender summit
#

no SHOT routines lost omg????

remote prawn
pastel sparrow
remote prawn
#

no its not shut up change that please

pastel sparrow
#

Okay

Top 5:

ATROFD
Next semester
Oldies Station
Navigating
Vignette

late hawk
whole chasm
#

ROUTINES IN THE NIGHT I'M SORRY 😭😭😭

#

both of these were my #1 faves, so i was bound to be happy and sad about the winner and loser regardless

surreal leaf
#

bro there ain’t no way