#Clancy Song Battle #11

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

candid atlasBOT
#

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1720364400:R>

foggy cape
#

oh

warm harness
#

backslide

severe quartz
#

backslide

proud ibex
#

backslide

queen lava
#

backslide ez

versed fern
#

backslide

rocky nest
#

backSWEEP

warm harness
#

i love all of you

severe quartz
queen lava
#

no question like

rocky nest
balmy anvil
#

Backslide, obviously

marble saffron
#

the shots are back

marble spade
#

backslide is probably my least favourite off clancy icl 💔💔

foggy cape
#

im gonna have to go with the craving on this

queen lava
#

it was my favorite single

marble saffron
#

shot back

fallow marlin
#

damn that’s tricky

versed fern
#

the craving is pretty forgettable sorry

wise cove
#

backslide fr

storm shadow
#

single version is not as good as jenna’s version

steel creek
#

TENDENCIES ON REPEAT, INNIT?

storm shadow
#

backslide tops

turbid vector
#

Backslide sweep

silent prism
#

Bro immediately clicked for like 1st message and still lost

marble spade
#

“kinda wishing that i never did saturday” made me so sad i love scaled and icy

fallow marlin
frozen spindle
#

single version loses to everything like every time sorry but sorry

candid atlasBOT
radiant oriole
#

CRAVING

storm shadow
fallow marlin
storm shadow
fair perch
#

Dang these two are tied for me

rocky nest
dusk widget
#

BACKSLIDE MY BELOVED

candid atlasBOT
gloomy swift
#

Craving is better

flint igloo
#

YOO 100

naive badger
#

i love the craving single vers

ripe oxide
dusk widget
#

BACKSLIDE IS FAVORITE ON THE ALBUM WE ARE TAKING THIS BACK YALL

candid atlasBOT
#
An error occurred!

Your Last.FM username isn't connected!

storm shadow
#

wrong one

prime crystal
#

BACKSLIDE KS IT EVEN A FUCKING QJESTION

mental walrus
gloomy swift
#

We need poot

abstract hemlock
#

i prefer single version over jenna's version but that's about all i'd rank it above

fluid citrus
fleet fossil
#

still shaking my head @ the saturday diss in backslide but im voting for it anyways

runic basalt
#

Backslide is Clancy's worst song

rocky nest
mental walrus
#

Poor craving. Its getting destroyed every match

rocky nest
#

totally how it ended

dusk widget
storm shadow
#

this is going to ruin the tour

fleet fossil
storm shadow
#

the world tour

prime crystal
naive badger
fallow marlin
storm shadow
naive badger
gritty gate
fleet fossil
prime crystal
fallow marlin
#

formidable second best

dense stratus
#

Obviously backslide wins over the worse version of the craving

candid atlasBOT
rocky nest
#

oh hecks nah

prime crystal
fallow marlin
#

then smithereens

rain silo
gritty gate
#

TIMH is d tier

fleet fossil
storm shadow
#

formidable eats

fallow marlin
#

then craving

fluid citrus
#

the craving left us craving 💔

fallow marlin
icy jacinth
#

Backsweep

naive badger
storm shadow
#

like i shake ass to formidable and timh lowkey

queen lava
#

the craving is my fave jenna song but it just doesnt have anything on backslide fkr me

fleet fossil
fallow marlin
hidden sphinx
#

craving single version better

storm shadow
dusk widget
#

tear in my heart is best jenna song imo

fallow marlin
storm shadow
#

peter i agree with you this time

hidden sphinx
gritty gate
#
  1. Smithereens
  2. Saturday
  3. The craving
  4. Tear in my fart
  5. The craving (single)
prime crystal
#

im not tolerating timh slander

clever garnet
naive badger
#

SATURDAY?!?!?

fallow marlin
gritty gate
#

Saturday is more about Jenna than formidable

rain silo
#

the craving is a skip

naive badger
#

i love formidable

storm shadow
#

saturday?????

prime crystal
hidden sphinx
fallow marlin
#

formidable goes hard

storm shadow
zenith wave
#

Backslide . I prefer Jenna’s version

fallow marlin
smoky raft
#

Backslide

gritty gate
storm shadow
cobalt dove
#

Backslide please

rocky nest
hidden sphinx
#

the whispering at the beginning scares me

clever garnet
#

Y'all sying sturday's a jenna song cause of the friends line, right?? 💀

gritty gate
#

Formidable ain’t about Jenna it’s about the fanbase

fallow marlin
#

crazy

storm shadow
prime crystal
#

im tweaking out

vocal obsidian
#

Single versión its better than Jenna's, and Backslide is better than both

gritty gate
#

ForMIDable amirite

rain silo
storm shadow
prime crystal
#

i remember when sai came out and i thought formidable was about josh.

naive badger
prime crystal
storm shadow
#

booo tomato tomato tomato tomato

gritty gate
#

Even bounce man and never take it are better

hidden sphinx
rocky nest
#

bounce man is the best jenna song change my mind

near panther
#

BENEFIT FROM A SHOE NO LACE 💯💯💯💯

prime crystal
rocky nest
unkempt oak
#

sorry but craving

naive badger
near panther
#

same

rocky nest
#

the only thing i'm craving is backslide

rain silo
#

forMIDable, sMIDereens, the skipping <<<< mother in my heart

lethal beacon
#

the craving is so good compared to backslide

amber igloo
#

Backslide

gritty gate
prime crystal
rocky nest
gritty gate
near panther
gritty gate
#

Got that penny loafer queef

merry hollow
#

Craving is just better

rain silo
rain silo
gritty gate
near panther
naive badger
#

im craving gyoza

tacit sleet
#

It sucks because craving is a good song its just every other clancy song is somehow better

clever garnet
#

The proctologist is clerly the friends we made along the waay

versed fern
#

formidable more like forMIDable

gritty gate
#

Low key was high as shit when I first heard the craving and thought he said “I hope I can say she ate the craving”

naive badger
clever garnet
#

I will NOT stand for the formidable slander

near panther
#

tbf i listened to both cravings once and that was it

rain silo
#

i can’t remember what formidable sounds like if i’m honest i never revisit it

prime crystal
gritty gate
rocky nest
#

may i say that i only listened to the craving single version when the video came out

hot kiln
#

The voice crack is the part i live for

naive badger
#

ive listened to ritn and lavish like twice and i just dont like them
ik they're like THE two favorites of like everyone but

fallow ledge
#

damn what a landslide victory

rocky nest
#

used to be my jam but i don't like it anymore 😭

fallow marlin
#

how is lavish an unironic favourite of anyone?

tepid condor
#

Backsweep

fallow ledge
#

craving boutta get swept twice

brave glade
#

BACKSLIDE

near panther
#

ritn is one of my least favs

rain silo
#

backslide is gonna crush the craving between thighs

rain silo
prime crystal
#

tbh i love ritn a lot but its not one of my favs

hot kiln
near panther
half tinsel
#

kinda feel bad about the craving cuz it legit is a good song

dapper oxide
#

Backslide easy

brave glade
#

Lavish is my fav sue me

naive badger
#

my favorite is overcompensate

prime crystal
#

tylers backing vocals in the third chorus of ritn are the best part of the whole song

fallow marlin
#

I’ve decided now

outer geyser
fallow marlin
#

backslide

iron kraken
#

the craving is a w in my opinion

prime crystal
#

THE LAYOUT,, IN THE NIIIIIIIGHT

severe locust
#

the craving bc i just don't like backslide

clever garnet
#

🔥 BACKSLIDE GAVE US JOSH'S DIRECTORIAL DEBUT AND IT'S A ABANGER VIDEO

prime crystal
rocky nest
hot kiln
#

The craving is like…its good but it doesn’t necessarily fit its place in the playlist its just a bit random

iron kraken
#

it's not about the video it's about the song

naive badger
severe locust
fallow marlin
rain silo
severe locust
#

but it's still better than backslide

jade swallow
#

backslide vs worse craving

rocky nest
#

backslide

jade swallow
#

i sure do wonder what im gonna pick here

rocky nest
#

🫡

fallow marlin
#

I also voted backslide

iron kraken
jade swallow
fallow marlin
#

I love craving single it much better the Jenna’s but backslide is fucking amazing

naive badger
severe locust
severe locust
jade swallow
#

way worse than jenna's version

hot kiln
#

Craving vs oldies station and risk of feeling dumb is the only way it would win for me ngl

fallow marlin
#

how can one say that

severe locust
fallow marlin
#

Jenna’s version is boring and repetitive

iron kraken
jade swallow
rain silo
jade swallow
severe locust
brave glade
candid atlasBOT
fallow marlin
hot kiln
#

Craving single is a bit eh

jade swallow
#

they took all the emotion out and added a boring, typical instrumental

hollow stump
#

Hot take…….

outer geyser
#

The lyrics of the craving mean the most to me from any clancy song, but single version doesn't slap nearly as much as backslide so I'm going with backslide

jade swallow
#

it was fine acoustic

hollow stump
#

The Craving 🔥🔥🔥

severe locust
fallow marlin
hot kiln
brave glade
hollow stump
#

These are both toward the bottom of my ranking but the craving better

limpid crag
#

backslide

jade swallow
#

i don't like songs just because they're studio

fallow marlin
jade swallow
#

and the single versions instrumentals are honestly some of the worst top has ever made

hot kiln
#

The craving tried to be paladin but failed

hollow stump
#

No it didn’t

outer geyser
hollow stump
#

lol

jade swallow
hot kiln
fallow marlin
hot kiln
#

They ruined it w the single

fallow marlin
#

they ruined it with Jenna’s

hot kiln
#

Nuh uh

jade swallow
#

just took an emotional song and made it a radio song

vital inlet
jade swallow
#

it's not MEANT to be a radio song

fallow marlin
near panther
#

they ruined it with the craving both version amen

jade swallow
fallow marlin
outer geyser
#

Both versions are good in their own ways

hot kiln
#

Its meant to be a heartfelt song not a radio bop

teal portal
#

i think backslide

fallow marlin
near panther
rocky nest
hollow stump
#

What if both versions are good and it’s a sweet love song that works well with two different sounds heeheegiggle

fallow marlin
#

the emotion in backslide is🥵🥵

brave glade
#

This is very heated

rocky nest
#

GUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUYS

lament echo
#

CAUSE I FEEL THE PULL

rocky nest
#

PLEASE

brave orchid
#

THE CRAVING (SINGLE VERSION)

lament echo
#

WATERS OVER MY HEAD

brave orchid
#

LET'S GOOOO

brave glade
#

Backslide 🔛🔝

near panther
#

actually im the craving (s) hater til i die

hollow stump
#

welp I tried

brave orchid
#

this was a tough decision too, but i went with the craving (single version)

brave glade
brave orchid
#

ilysm backslide

teal portal
rain silo
hot kiln
#

Right in the end none of us r gonna have the same opinions so BACKSLIDE OR CRAVING

lament echo
#

ILL TAKE ANYTHING YOU HAVE

#

IF YOJ COULD THROW ME A LINE

hot kiln
#

Not CRAVING OR CRAVING

teal portal
#

I SHOULD HAVE LOVED YOU BETTTER

jade swallow
lament echo
#

DO YOU THINK TJAT NOWS THE TIME? you should let go…..

hot kiln
bright oracle
#

It’s over my head

lament echo
#

it’s OVER my head….

teal portal
#

ITS OVER MY HEAD

brave glade
jade swallow
teal portal
jade swallow
#

where do you guys even get your lyrics?

outer geyser
#

I need help I don't know what to do
I run a lemonade stand and some guy just pulled up on a bike, gave me a hamburger bun, took some lemondade, and rode away
What do I do?

brave glade
hot kiln
teal portal
brave glade
#

Legrands

jade swallow
rocky nest
outer sorrel
#

DON'T DO THIS TO ME

teal portal
storm shadow
brave glade
jade swallow
hot kiln
#

I would swimm the paladin straitttt

#

And come out the other side gayy

jade swallow
teal portal
hot kiln
#

Ahem

outer geyser
jade swallow
brave glade
drowsy halo
#

CAUSE I FEEL THE PULL🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️

hot kiln
hot kiln
rocky nest
storm shadow
brave glade
#

Actually 🤓

outer geyser
jade swallow
hot kiln
jade swallow
brave glade
jade swallow
rocky nest
#

this heat is killin' meeeeeeee

jade swallow
rocky nest
jade swallow
#

illegal business practices

storm shadow
#

you can get an ac for like 50 bucks

hot kiln
jade swallow
hot kiln
#

That is also sarcasm

jade swallow
hot kiln
#

Aka buying a bottle for £1 but it’s disposable costs a fish life

jade swallow
storm shadow
#

personally i pretend my electric bill doesn’t exist

hot kiln
jade swallow
#

my parents probably pay more for our electric bill than our mortgage

storm shadow
#

that’s kind of insane 😭

outer sorrel
#

The heat in this chat is making me sweat

jade swallow
brave basin
#

Backslide is hella mid craving Single version is peak

jade swallow
brave basin
hot kiln
#

Im bored so imma go learn paladin 🏳️‍🌈 on uke, hope backslide wins, arrivederci

storm shadow
rocky nest
storm shadow
outer geyser
#

I just realized that josh decided to film a music video where he can just sit with the camera and look into tyler's eyes while he rides a bike right in front of him

rocky nest
#

guys pliz no fite grief

outer sorrel
#

The Craving is catchier but Backslide is superior

rocky nest
#

no fite in da chat pliz

jade swallow
storm shadow
#

before i moved out i was in an apartment of 5 and i think the bill was still like only 300ish

#

i kept my ac on all day so my mom made me pay her 50 bucks twice a month lol

fallow ledge
#

ngl this is the real battle of mid

storm shadow
#

you’re mid

fallow ledge
rocky nest
#

you are

fallow ledge
#

nuh uh

storm shadow
#

!!^

#

wait no

storm shadow
#

you’re mid no backsies

trim trout
#

definitely backslide

tepid condor
#

it's just more personal to tyler so yeah

#

it was expected for us to not enjoy it as much as the other ones

#

the single is supposed to be a more radio accesible version, also a version that all of us would enjoy but idk, if it weren't for the fact that it gives a second message to the song it wouldn't be that neccesary

#

i love that criticism to how you would put a lot of care and effort into something just to be discarded if it's not a "hit"

#

the music video of course

#

so yeah it's still a great song

tepid condor
dusky kernel
#

Backslide

faint prawn
#

not me trying to protect The Craving while voting against it every time 😭

pastel dawn
#

The craving is peak fr

winter niche
#

this one is a hard one.

#

i’m choosing backslide :p

candid atlasBOT
onyx cipher
#

Backslide is better of the two; I really like backslide

tepid condor
#

backslide came to me in a really important moment so yeah

exotic shadow
#

Unpopular opinion but I actually like the single version

#

A lot better than JV

rough obsidian
#

Oh backslide 100%

warped sandal
#

backslide

trim trout
#

backslide

abstract mason
#

BACKSLIDE

marble spade
#

how it feels to be a craving defender

abstract mason
#

BACKSLIDE AHHH

abstract mason
#

I’m gonna backslide

tulip plover
#

backslide no question tbh

abstract mason
#

I don’t understand y’all backslide is literally SO GOOD

#

AHHH

drowsy panther
tulip plover
#

love that song so much especially "i should've loved you better" hits every time

abstract mason
abstract mason
#

I don’t if it’s lonely

#

ITS SO GOOD

#

RAHHH

tulip plover
#

you get me 🙏

tepid condor
#

that one part that it says "i should've loved you better, do you think that now's the time you should let go? it's over my head" GOSH

#

hits so hard

tulip plover
#

lol just said that

tepid condor
#

nice coincidence

tulip plover
#

i'm not mad i'm just saying agreed fs

#

i have 66 listens for backslide lolz

abstract mason
#

Lavish next semester and backslide

tepid condor
#

I don't know how many listens i have for clancy and i'm probably better off not knowing that fact

abstract mason
#

Vignette is good af as well

#

This entire ALBUM IS FIRE

#

I CANT DECIDE

tulip plover
#

i'm ngl i haven't really touched next semester since i replayed it too much

vocal valve
abstract mason
#

Listened to it so much

#

I skip it now

tulip plover
#

fair

abstract mason
tepid condor
maiden sorrel
#

BACKSLIDE! LOVE!!!

abstract mason
tulip plover
#

i'm not even sure what my top 3 are anymore

abstract mason
tepid condor
#

even the craving jenna's version is worth listening, that one's beautiful

tulip plover
#

i think for now it's midwest indigo, routines in the night, and oldies station

#

something like that

abstract mason
abstract mason
#

As a punk fan

#

I think yk

#

What my favs are

tulip plover
#

navigating ik

tepid condor
#

navigating next semester uhhh atrofd

#

maybe

abstract mason
#

Atford is good

#

But

#

Vignette or backslide

#

Fit me more

#

If anyone says they don’t like legend

tepid condor
#

right vignette is also really heavy i totally forgot

abstract mason
#

They are a liar

tulip plover
#

like i'm too tired as is

abstract mason
#

WHERE DO I GO FROM HERE

tepid condor
#

CLINGING TO

abstract mason
#

PROMISES

tulip plover
#

that's why i love lavish and midwest indigo 🙏

abstract mason
#

FIGHTING OFF

#

THE VIGNETTE

tulip plover
#

welp

#

y'all saw his comment on instagram ab vignette right

abstract mason
#

What is it

tulip plover
tepid condor
#

am i the only one that doesn't take lavish as a joke song?

abstract mason
abstract mason
#

WELCOME TO THE NEW WAY OF LIVING

tepid condor
#

yeah me too

tulip plover
#

what r u laughing at 💀

abstract mason
#

ITS JUST THE BEGINNING OF LAVISH

tulip plover
#

pretty sure he's saying they're playing it on tour

tepid condor
tulip plover
#

whoops

tepid condor
tulip plover
#

i’ll make it 300 soon

tepid condor
#

i have zero confidence i'm not gonna have that much listens

tulip plover
#

loll

#

i think that's counting my singles scrobbles too tho

tepid condor
# tulip plover

it counts one listen every time you play one song from the album or every time you listen the entire album?

#

probably the first one though

tulip plover
#

the first one lol

#

i'd be insane if i listened to the whole album 300 times

#

that would be almost 4,000 listens help 😭

tepid condor
dusty sierra
#

I DONT WANNA BACKSLIIIDE

tulip plover
loud horizon
#

im sorry jenna's version you were up against oldies

#

i would've voted for you if you were here (maybe)

nocturne fractal
#

Craving getting decimated out here

eager stump
#

Aaaa

flint pollen
#

it’s Backslide and it ain’t even close lol

winter niche
#

Yeah this is a landslide.

livid bough
#

backslide

civic vigil
#

single ver, i don't really like backslide that much

civic vigil
civic vigil
#

bc snapback has that "i've been praying for my elasticity" bit that i love but backslide is just

#

meh

#

also the single version is like 1000 times better than the album ver (no offense jenna or tyler) it just is

#

i put it on a cd

#

so yeah the craving

karmic heath
#

anything is better that the single version

#

not to hate on it tho

winter niche
#

Tragic.

karmic heath
#

backslide made me cry the 2nd time I heard it (bc I didn't know what was going on in the livestream and was just too excited lmao)

winter niche
karmic heath
#

the craving is in my top 5 easily but it has to be Jenna's version, otherwise I skip

grim sail
#

I love single Craving but in no way is Backslide worse 😭

civic vigil
civic vigil
karmic heath
civic vigil
#

yeah

#

idk what's wrong in my brain but i'm generally wired to hate/dislike acoustic versions of songs unless i heard them first

also, offtopic, i can't heard the word layout anymore without immediately thinking of routines in the night

cobalt dove
#

WALK THE LAYOUT

glossy hill
#

How did the craving get here???? It lost to routines????

#

<@&323555864646647808> ^

#

Sorry to bother, I'm just confused

fluid citrus
#

Hi

glossy hill
#

Oh my... thank you so much!!

fluid citrus
#

You're welcome

olive lintel
#

every song has 2 lives

clear vigil
#

Backslide

winter niche
#

Single version is 100 times better than jennas tbh

dusky kernel
flat cypress
#

single version

#

backslide is probably the worst song on the album

dusky kernel
#

You’re not that low yet

cobalt dove
karmic heath
dusky kernel
#

IM GOING TO PUNCH A WALL

delicate wing
civic vigil
# karmic heath ah that's fair

im really iffy with versions of songs
i usually like whatever i heard first and then more times than not every other version is cancerous
((offtopic, but in a weird kind of way, i'm the same with facial hair, i have no idea why, like i hate it when my dad shaves but i want my boyfriend to shave))

civic vigil
tepid condor
civic vigil
#

right, i know its more personal to him
i mean, it makes sense that a personal sonmg would be slower, i think it's fine that it is, just personally not my favorite
im sure if i had heard it first, i probably woulda been more into it

karmic heath
delicate wing
flat cypress
karmic heath
#

same w falling in love w you

#

etc

flat cypress
#

backslide just didn’t hit right

flat cypress
#

yeah it’s probably because i hear the craving on the radio a lot so im more used to it and like it a lot more

tepid condor
#

i know there's the craving single version as a single also, but it's like the second version of the craving, i wanted to focus on the first three songs on the album

full tangle
#

da cravey

hearty eagle
#

guys, if backslide wins, ill ask my crush out :)

dusky kernel
#

I wish I asked mine out

#

Its too late after you leave

hearty eagle
#

I WILL

#

ill probably get rejected, but i'll do it wearing my Blurryface hoodie

dusky kernel
#

befriend first

#

always

#

humans are friendly

hearty eagle
#

oh ive known them for 5 years :'3

#

but if Backslide wins, ill go for it

#

im betting my love life on a song vote, les go

dusky kernel
tepid condor
#

you've got nothing to lose

dusky kernel
#

Don't let anyone else tell you

tepid condor
#

go for it

dusky kernel
#

tell yourself

tepid condor
hearty eagle
#

bro me and her met because of the self-titled album.
im gonna pray she doesnt reject me.

#

but hey, backslide better win :D

queen lava
#

backsweeeeep will win dw

final moon
#

NOOO i have to vote backslide (i mean it’s backslide) but the craving deserved to go further. love that song, especially the single version

harsh solstice
#

didnt both of these songs lose already 💀

cobalt dove
#

good luck btw

final moon
cobalt dove
hearty eagle
hearty eagle
#

i love josh

tepid condor
#

and josh also

#

waiting for tyler to come with the buns :c

wheat sentinel
#

imma be real there really isnt much to say

#

backslide

rain atlas
#

Nah Craving single version was good though

wheat sentinel
#

Yeah

#

But like

#

Isn't much to say 😭

hybrid zealot
#

bro i voted the craving thinking it was jenna's version 😭 chat am i cooked

#

but i do like single version more than backslide

#

backslide has actually grown on me tho

#

i prefer the craving

queen lava
#

i love the craving but backslide is my favorite single and i love it a lil more

kind topaz
#

battle of mid imo

dusky kernel
#

Backslide is not mid

#

its just stripped back which gives it a greater impact

queen lava
#

yeah i agree

full tangle
#

9 minutes

lethal beacon
sick schooner
#

Last second changed my vote

#

nerdssss

#

I'm so rad 😎

cobalt dove
#

Come on backslide

#

whoa

#

sweep

rare frost
#

wasn’t even close

glass vale
#

people really don't like the craving

onyx cipher
#

Yeah! Backslide.

onyx cipher
cobalt dove
#

No I like The Craving, but it's not as good as Backslide

glass vale
queen lava
#

i like the craving as well but its just not as good as some of the other songs on the album i still like it tho both versions

onyx cipher
covert gulch
#

what

#

the craving deserved so much better

cobalt dove
#

let's go

vocal valve
#

I've listened to both and decided midwest indigo

#

While I do love ns, I had more fun listening to mi

hearty eagle
#

UPDATE: i did it
they said "Maybe" MAYBE????
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN CHAT

cobalt dove
#

was it a "I don't wanna say no but I don't wanna see you- Maybe" or a "I am interested but too shy to say yes- Maybe"?

iron tree
#

does anyone have an overview of eliminated songs (twice lost), twice won and all of the others in-between?

turbid vector
wise cove