#Clancy Song Battle #9

1 messages Ā· Page 2 of 1

fading yacht
#

but this was TOUGH

west wyvernBOT
fading yacht
#

because snap back is criminally underrated

#

it deserves so much better

#

BUT i'm also being fair and basing my votes on which ones i prefer over the other

#

and i just prefer overcompensate

#

but I LOVE SNAP BACK

#

always have

#

always will

#

urgh i kinda feel bad for not voting snap back

#

not gonna change my vote though

fading yacht
#

level 13, i'm gonna get ya

#

JAIL. NOW.

#

THAT'S MY FAVE FROM THE ALBUM

#

along with routines in the night

winter summit
#

LOL

#

dude I am a rapper and have been studying hip-hop of all kinds for close to five years straight, I can give you the detailed breakdown if you want šŸ˜‚šŸ˜­

lapis tide
winter summit
#

just to be clear

#

Iā€™m not saying ā€˜the songs with rap in them suckā€™

#

Iā€™m saying the rap sections suck for the most part, despite them very often being in good songs

#

I like Vessel a lot

winter summit
#

Navigating, Overcompensate, Oldies Station, Next Semester>

lapis tide
#

Do you think self titled rap sucks as well?

winter summit
calm goblet
#

Routines has another life, it's not taken out

lapis tide
#

But seriously though

#

What about self titled

winter summit
#

so I canā€™t judge

lapis tide
#

Try no phun intended then self titled. Iirc some lyrics are used from no phun intended into self titled

winter summit
tribal inlet
#

Wow havent listened to self titled D:

winter summit
#

listening to self titled now though

winter summit
#

I got nothing to do rn

tribal inlet
#

its honestly a well put together album thematically

#

just suffers from poor vocal performanc eand production

lapis tide
winter summit
#

Iā€™m on Implicit Demand for Proof rn and nothing is sticking out as bad so far

#

only thing Iā€™d nitpick is the mixing

tribal inlet
#

Yeah that songs alright

#

The drums dont sound too bad on this album

#

Im sure youve heard trapdoor

#

thats an example of hwat this album does right

winter summit
#

oh okay Fall Away just started and this performance is kinda grating

#

I see what you mean

#

oh no some rapping

tribal inlet
#

March to the sea is one song i do not lik

#

e

#

btw this album has no josh dun on it

#

might be obvious

winter summit
#

Iā€™m glad the rap didnā€™t last

#

cause that wasnā€™t enjoyable

tribal inlet
#

Second half of the album is more listenable

winter summit
#

good

#

looking forward to that

#

oh boy this falsetto on The Pantaloon could be a lot better

#

oh no more rapping

#

okay this rap verse isnā€™t awful

#

I hate how nasal Tyler sings on most of this

#

but this ending chorus is good

tribal inlet
#

Very nasally album

winter summit
#

Bruh - Friend, Please is just ATROFD but better

tribal inlet
#

No theyre different sonsg

#

different messages

winter summit
#

cause it feels like the same idea

tribal inlet
#

well friend please is talking to your friend

#

whos on the brink

#

atrofd is encouraging others to

#

expansion of themes

winter summit
#

it's about the same thing though, thematically

tribal inlet
#

its like comparing snap back and backslide

winter summit
#

but my point is that Friend, Please talks about the concept of checking in on your friends in a much more poetic and interesting way than ATROFD does

#

lyrically, if not anything else

tribal inlet
#

I DONT WANT ANYONE KNOW ME OR NOT

winter summit
#

ALR

#

just finished Self Titled

#

and I have to say I was pleasantly surprised by the majority of it

#

very much picked up in the second half

#

the performances werenā€™t all great

#

but

#

overall very good

#

my favourite songs were:
Friend, Please
Air Catcher
Taxi Cab
Before You Start Your Day

and Addict with a Pen is an honourable mention lol

winter summit
#

technically, the majority of the rap sections were as bad as Vessel; except for a couple of sections where some good technicals shone through. However, I found the rap more enjoyable on this album for two reasons. one, it didnā€™t occur as much, so it feels like each time rap is included itā€™s a tasteful addition to each song (except for maybe Isle of Flightless Birds, which I donā€™t think needed any rap). and the second reason is that it doesnā€™t sound like heā€™s trying too hard to sound cool or quirky, which the Vessel rap suffers from really badly

vapid ingot
pulsar dragon
#

i didn't even vote

blazing shoal
#

im so sorru snap back

pulsar dragon
#

too hard catcry

blazing shoal
#

i love you enough for everyone

noble oasis
#

snap back is the best song on the album thatā€™s crazy

blazing shoal
#

its so sad but its okay. I love snap back enough to cancel ALL THE SLANDER

vapid ingot
#

Smh

pallid flame
#

rip snap back ilysm

brittle jewel
#

wait

#

@pallid flame

#

we matched yesterday too

pallid flame
#

@brittle jewel did you vote sb?

brittle jewel
#

@pallid flame i did

#

it ranks over oc for me

pallid flame
#

@brittle jewel they're both S tier for me I couldn't choose but I knew oc would win and I didn't want sb to be swept

brittle jewel
#

@pallid flame thatā€™s fair

calm goblet
#

rip snap back

stray barn
#

Pour one out for Snap Back

fading yacht
#

snap back i'm sorryyyy

brittle current
#

Yā€™all did dirty on Snap Back

fading yacht
#

i voted overcompensate between the two, but snap back deserves so much better in general

dusky mica
#

Yā€™all suck! Justice for Snap Back

dark rampart
#

so true carlee

#

snap back is slept on HARD

gusty heart
#

oldie station

slim flicker
#

Nope

grizzled oasis
#

oldies station easy dub

past ruin
#

NO!

scarlet flint
#

rank, runk, and stunk statement

blazing shoal
#

i have enough love for all the snap back slander

dull breach
fading yacht
#

i also love snap back!!!