#Clancy Song Battle #4
1 messages · Page 2 of 1
i thought there'd be a flood of vignette truthers in here
These song battle pairings are tough asf
COME ON
we lost port
NOOOOO
i lost you guys
OLDIES FOR THE WIN
this is sooooo hardddd
OLDIES IS GOOD
VIGNETTE IS JUST THE BEST
Yes! Except for actually no!!!!!!!!
they're tied 😭
this.
i need an extremely loud incorrect buzzer to keep around you nick
these are genuinely my favourite 2 songs on the album wtf :(
hmm i wonder what i voted
at the risk is much better
Yes it is
what do I voteeeee
Oldies Station si my fav in the album!
I voted oldies
It means a lot to me
But vignette it's one of the best in the record
😭😭
vignette's verses are so perfect
They are killing me with this battles man

Vignette is so astronomically good but Oldies Station just hits different
Oldies Station all the way
Same
ughhhh idkkkk
sigh
UGHHHH
love vignette but gotta go with oldies
other way around for me honestly
suuuuper hard tho
yeah all of these have been so close
ok oldies station or vignette time to decipher this
oldies station hits me so hard
vignette hits me so hard
yeah i can't do this
it's like, oldies station is so hopeful and helps me to push on through but vignette is also something i relate with a lot
These are both soooo good but oldies station is what’s getting me through life rn
wym
Oldies station>>>
Vignette for the VIBES
Oldies for the CRIES
heavy on this
FOR REAL
Vignette, it will always be Vignette!
sobbing
Vignette on top
i ugly cry every time i listen to oldies station
Vignette easy win
fuckkk why is every song so good wtf man I feel bad whichever one I vote they're all amazing 😭😭
oooff these two are like my 2 favourite songs on clanky
NOOO WAIT- these are easily two of my favorite songs on the album
how do i pick between them 😭
vignette ftw
real
Oh they hate us with this one
Both of these songs hold such a dear place in my heart
frrr
i really can't decide, i love both of these songs so much 😭
This is the first one I have to actually think and consider which one
They should've put a ☡ symbol on this one
I think I’m gonna end up going vignette but GOD DO I LOVE OLDIES STATION
The crazy thing is I had a dream about oldies station last night…
I've been obsessed w vignette since I first heard it so I feel like I gotta choose it but oldies station slaps too
The story about addiction speaks too well to my soul, so I agree
MAKE AN OATH AND MAKE MISTAKES
Oldies
yeah I think imma end up going with vignette. but I LOVE OLDIES STATION SO MUCH TOO
Oh this one is HARD 😭 But I gotta go with my girl Vignette
Another huge factor is hearing OS live…
true true
Disappointed lavish lost
i forgot about the
emoji
But it was up against the best song on the album…
I hope OS is on the Clancy Tour setlist...it better be...👀
LEVEL UP: You are now level 1!
It will be
aint no way OS won't be on the setlist
That was one they were “excited to play” in an interview
Bro did good but unfortunately his opponent was too strong
And plus they played it in cbus
Literally tho, I love next semester
oh yeah, I forgot they said that!
But I wanted lavish to win
They'll probably play most Clancy songs live but I bet they wont play Snap Back
lavish is going to be interesting live
my 2 favorites
Maybe they skip that one too
GUYS IDK WHICH ONE TO VOTE THIS ONE IS TOUGH
Lavish and snap back feel like two songs they'd skip
would love to hear everyone sing the proctologist line live
Agreed. I think the only 2 would be snap back and maybe paladin strait. I’m not sure how they’d do that one live.
aww man i hope not, I love lavish 😅
Like Tyler just doesn't sing it and let's us do it instead
yeah unless they do something fun with paladin towards the end
Go with your heart! This is one of the hardest ones yet 🥲
That was one of tyler's favs, I don't think that will happen honestly
DID YOU THINK THAT THIS IS THE END
Paladin strait must be live, its duch a song to play to live
Yea, I'll have to pick oldies, but vignette is still one of the best
during the birds they just start doing backflips and then punch Nico
Plot twist: Tyler punches himself
Vignette, midwest indigo, craving, backslide, overcompensate, next semester and oldies station are basically confirmed for tour
I could see them doing PS as the last song before the encore. Then the encore picks up with the “so few….” Bit
🇻
I still am so confused as to what the birds were all about
Imagine the transition between paladin strait and fairly local
if they dont put navigating on tour im gonna explode my venue
Would be crazy
I think they were to confuse people listening for the first time
actually this might be the way
Same, I NEED that one
THEY BETTER PLAY NAVIGATING OR SO HELP ME TYLER JOSEPH-
i need snap back live but i feel like if they're gonna cut one then
They basically confirmed navigating on the set list with Josh’s interview
it's the least concert sounding song to me
where did you get vignette from
It was 4 in the morning and I was in the middle of my bed stretching for my phone to be connected to the charger. Imagine that.
Some interview or sh
guess i haven't seen it
Keytar 🤤🤤🤤
that's gonna be sick live
Tyler did say Snap Back and oldies are his favorite, so hopefully he’ll do his two favs
I was like oh the song was supposed to be 6 min no way the end is just birds- HOL UP
exactly!! I almost clicked out of the livestream, then I was like- wait a sec
My mom's alarm set off when Nico started talking and I was like NO, GO BACK TO SLEEP IM STILL WORKIN
Navigating is joshs 2nd or 3rd fav he gotta step for us
Nah 😭
Ruined the moment...
Navigating is his favorite I thought. He also loves routines
I thought it was Nico for a sec 💀💀
I thought routines were Nr 1
Those are the ones he saved, and tbh, two of the best
THIS ONE IS SO HARD WHAT
still can't believe they were almost cut
FR DONT PANIC
But he never did a tierlist so ye...
I CANT HELP IT THOSE ARE MY TWO FAVS
But josh said he wanna play navigating live so I hope he'll force tyler
Exactly... Like, what's more depressing than staying up at night thinking about "what ifs?" I THOUGHT THAT WAS TYLER'S THING
LMAOO SAME
I had to pick oldies, but I feel Tyler is coming after me 😭
i sat there debating for a minute but i had to pick vignette i just had to 😭 but i’m regretting my decision because i think about the Ro chant in oldies at least five times a day
same!!
Thank you. I appreciate it.
You can change vote:) (DO IT!)
SAY LESS
Good luck with that buddy, for me it's the WHOLE LAVISH GOOFY PART 😭😭
i think about the capri sun line all the time tbh 😅
yess me too
🗿🗿
i had to go oldies station
good choice
Amen
clearly oldies is gonna win
Vignette is beloved tho
i love vignette but that ro chant has me in a chokehold
very much but the meaning in oldies is so chefs kiss
No not me its for friend is corny
literally same 🤠
Not reallysure about that...
it has to 🥲
"i wrote oldies station for you guys" 🥹
People love vignette tho
That only reminds me of drugs 😭
yeah this one is really hard
it really is
The song is about them so I guess that was the intention
i love vignette too 😭
Yes, he talks about addiction, AND THAT MAKES IT EVEN SADDER
Songs about addiction Don't really speak to me so I meh about that :/
A lot of clancy is about that which makes it even worse
Guys I just got apprehended in Nills district 👁️👄👁️
I can turn it back around and make it talk about depression so... It's up to the person, really
Some of them, but definitely not vignette
Yea, still a banger tho
Vignette on first hear sounded like lore song which is why its meaning kinda disappointed me
Bruh
Unpopular yet mine opinion
U can't make me pick between my two favourite songs 😭😭
this one is the first hard ish one
but also somewhat easy
i mean oldies station is really good but until the bridge part it's slightly bland
vignette is fantastic all throughout
Hi my name is basic
Basic gang rise up
oldies station best song on the album :3
THESE ARE LIKE MY TWO FAVORITES ON THE ALBUM 😭
when i heard vignette in the listening party i instantly loved it
it was the only one i actually remembered walking out of there
oldies is so good too
@unique shore thoughts?
👴 🚉
💀
VVVVVIIIIIIIGGGGGGNNNNNNEEEEEEETETETETETETET
NAAAHH this one is just pure evil
oldies station makes me bawl my eyes out and vignette makes me scream my lungs out so how do i even uuuuhHHHH??????!!!!
only consistency in your periphery
Dude same
I voted oldies cause im in a bawling mood rn
Vignette is prolly gonna win
OLDIES OLDIES OLDIES
VIGNETTE IS BANGING BUT OLDIES IS SO SO SO GOOD
the little ro ro ro chant????
insane
if vignette loses im gonna do something horrid
OLDIES STAYION OLDIES DATION OLDIES STATION
no song makes me cry like that okay
oldjes station u deserve everything in ghe world
vignette is like the loud older brother oldies is the really cool quiet little sister
oldies station doesn't have NO NOT ME, IT'S FOR A FRIEND
so oldies station has to go unfortunately
(oldies station i love you)
but i love vignette
vignette hits different
vignette is life
(but oldies station is also life)
He's thinking there's no way I'm heading there
Always sure footed educated and was never scared
Now he cant hold out his hand without it shaking
Didn't expect this vote to be as clear cut as it is
Vignette ftww
Agreed
i gotta keep checking every now and then
No wonder he sounds so pissed
Oldies is my favourite off the album so I easily picked it
as you should
damn this one was hard but oldies ily
Yep!! I’m gonna cry hearing it live 😭
me tooooooo
i'm not ready at all 😭
Me either but I really can’t wait to re experience another concert with them!! It’s gonna be my second concert ever and my second time seeing them
this is gonna be my first concert w them i'm so excited
Awesome!! Well I’ll tell you that you’re definitely gonna have a wonderful time!! 
might be a bad take, but i think vignette relies to heavily on THAT sequence of chords to do work most of the work for it which i didnt particularly like anyways. That along with the vocal whatever u wanna call it he does on "his bones" makes me cringe at the start
Song topic is well handled imo, and good lyrics too but the above throws me off
I find the pre chorus REALLY freaking annoying tbh
The rest of the song is good tho :)
I voted oldies but vignette bops ngl
The return to the bridge in the final chorus slaps
I voted Oldies too cause it's like easily the best on the album for me
impulse voting oldies because the thought of it losing makes me sad
but i will be happy with either winner
I know im gonna sound annoying when i say this but i have a hard time ranking any of the songs on clancy, or otherwise, because i have constant changes of opinions anyways with my mood swings and sometimes lavish is miles better than any other song on there and sometimes i need to hear paladin strait or oldies
All of them hit hard at different times
Sometimes they all hit equally hard too those days are fuckin awesome
True mood makes a difference cause I was listening to Midwest the other day and suddenly it SLAPPED
And also emotional whirlwinds
YESSSS
i definitely agree w this! its rly hard to make a decision between most these songs and i dont have a tier list or anything bc i just love the album
Yeah honestly like often going into these polls it's tough cause there REALLY isn't a song on this album that I don't like
and I like all of them for different reasons, often it feels like comparing apples and oranges
The only top song I feel I can REALLY say I don't like is Levitate and that's cause I'm not a fan of rap
i loveee levitate but thats fair for sure if you dont like rap but i definitely agree on the apples to oranges!!! such different songs that i like for such different reasons
I am torn I love these songs so much

vignette easy
HAVE TO VOTE VIGNETTE
you know you wanna vote vignette 👀
ended up voting oldies station bc i relate to it a little more 
vignette.
thats fair this was a really hard choice
Pico makes a point if you cant decide choose tylers favourite
whos tyker
The guy who plays clanky
ohhh tyker
this guy right?
mods make this an emoji PLEASE
Fr!!
bwahaha
"teh few te prowd teh emotiwnal >:3"
“If you can’t see he is Clancy prodigal kitty”
here ya go
YO SCORE FR
ur my best friend now
Hehe okie!


If oldies station loses, I swear-
Oldies 🔛🔝
facts
No worries my Oldies stans remember that we can still have a second chance (as do the other songs that have lost so far)
both in my top 4, maybe even top 3, on the album tbh. this is unfair 😭
i’m picking oldies station but i haaaaate to vote against vignette
Oldies stations has the best chance out of all the lost songs to actually get a second chance
it unironically does
with ns already winning and navigating being seed 3 here Oldies will have a comfortable run in losers because Oldies is seed 2
I’ll be honest, I think the subject matter is Vignette’s weakest point
it’s very unclear what he’s on about for the majority of the song imo, unless I’m dumb
The Pantaloon 2.0 better
Legend 2 vs Pantaloon 2
I see it as just addiction, the specific type is up to interpretation, i think it fits substance abuse best, "hand without it shaking" "There's no way I'm headed there" "Always sure footed, educated"
this one is hard 😭
lmao for me it's one of the more straightforward top songs
I feel so bad for choosing
oldies is like something that is dear to me bc it helped me through darker times years ago
but vignette hits different
this battle has happened before
unless the oldies nation is stronger than before vignette is winning this
years ago?
it’s been months
in terms of the grand scheme of their career, yeah
but within the album it’s one of the least clear ones imo
like in contrast to The Craving, Oldies Station, ATROFD, Snap Back, Backslide, Next Semester?
it’s hyperpoetic
I mean if I had it years ago it would feel sentimental by now. I am in a better place now though
I think I get what you mean but that's what I like about vignette
That’s very fair
but
you have to admit it’s not a topically straightforward song lyrically
even if that’s an element you like
hm it is very figurative, painting a lot of metaphors. But I think from a perspective on addiction everything is consistent
I think your right but what is or was Tyler addicted to? Pretty sure he is very much straight edge.
You can be addicted to just about anything
one hour and 8 minutes left
and then we have to vote AGAIN😭
It could also be not about him, just addiction in general
True, didn't think of that
Like "this os a tale of a guy fighting off an addiction, not me tho!! But some guy!" Type of thing
And I mean, if not a substance then it could be about self sabotage, harm or smth like that y'know
This is what I was originally thinking. The feels drives his music. I see the sleep deprivation connection as well. Thanks for responses.
Oooooh sleep deprivation's a good one too
I just listened to the songs again and realized it’s definitely Oldies Station
I predict Overcompensate vs The Craving
Which version?
I leave that up to Nico to decide
If it’s Jenna’s version we all know which song is gonna win
Jenna’s version is just so striped down compared to the single version
W
It was close
Omg oldies noo
NOOOOO
Big W
OLDIES MY BABYYY
OLDIES NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
ITS OKAY FAM
you don't deserve this song
average vignette W
NOJOJOOOOOOOOO
OLDIES WILL HAVE ANOTHER CHANCE
YES
Wait, really???
Lessgooooo
but if they lose the 2nd time it's joever
Im already bored
Im pretty sure ive seen this one before
devastating for me but also i totally get it 👍
noooooooo
unexpected
why are all my favs losing 😦
I forgor to vote but I am disappointed
when youve read the book then they make a movie out of it
Oldies my beloved 
LET'S GOOOOOO
OLDIEEEEEES 😭 😭
VIGNETTE'S AWESOME BUT I WANTED OLDIES TO WIN AT LEAST ONE ROUND THIS HURTSSSS
oh this one was pretty close so i can't be mad
this is betrayal
Which one actually did win?
vignette
Wait guys no why did Oldies Station have to lose 😭
Oldies got more votes than I expected it to get tbh, but still tragically died :(((
goodbye oldies station 
Not oldies stationnnnn my heart
ggs guys
YEAY
Push on through 😭
Noooo!!!
Vignette is phenomenal and I can see why it won but Oldies Station is just sooo good
this is not very 'push on through' of you guys to put viginette
darkness rolled on oldies station fr
SO LITTLE DIFFERENCE?? I mean Oldies Station is one of the best songs but I thought Vignette is like "next level"

not dead dont songs go twice
wait what

of a violent and possibly fatal nature
i love oldies but i cant think of one clancy song im willing not to vote for to support oldies
Dog vs. Cat - the ultimate battle
sry
100 %
not against tootie
cries
i think there's a redemption round (?) so if that comes up im definitely bringing Oldies Station back 😭
Cat 💪
VIGNETTE WONNNN
against MY WIFE??????
yah

Fr
ily
YEAAAAA WE WIN
PALADIN
if navigating loses im leaving the server
NO. Oldies station is my fav song on the album:
Me Fr. Oldies is my favourite off the album
