#Song Battle #8

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

pastel spruceBOT
#

Welcome to the song battle! Discuss the two songs here. The winner will be revealed <t:1709827200:R>

spring garnet
#

h

thin compass
#

difficult choice

worn basin
#

ngl i’m cooked

IMG_0861.png
#

i can’t decide

worthy arrow
#

This choice is hard

thin compass
#

i learned Timh on bass and such it's so special to me but Cancer was released when I firstly became a fan... it hit very close home too because of some family issues

#

they're both so special

#

Aaaaaaaa

hidden nacelle
#

gonna be real, it's an easy pick for me

#

cancer

spring garnet
#

hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

hidden nacelle
#

i don't think timh is BAD or anything but

#

it's just like. it's fine

pale vessel
#

It's Tear in my Heart for me.

thin compass
#

I prefer the Cancer cover by top to the original

#

it's so good

#

and the music video is so good

#

well if you can call it a video

#

a music video

#

it is a mv yeah

#

it made my sister cry when i showed it to her lmao

vale isle
#

I gotta go with Tear in My Heart

spring garnet
#

i dont think i want to pick a Cover over an actual song that they wrote, even if their version is so insane that it could still count as its own thing, also it probably wouldnt survive round 2

thin compass
pale vessel
#

First off, I actually love TIMH.

#

Second, I prefer originality over covers.

#

(Though TOP did an amazing job)

#

Third, I remember listening to Cancer lot right when my mom's breast cancer diagnosis happened, so it kind of sits in a mixed spot in my mind.

lunar verge
#

these two songs have totally different moods

#

i feel like cancer has more emotion in it though

swift ledge
#

Ez tear in my heart

median seal
#

I think Tear in My Heart was one of the first tøp songs I heard (after stressed out and ride ofc) so I think I'm gonna go with that

cursive ledge
#

i will go with timh only because its one of the first songs I liked from top and cancer is a cover so

remote sail
#

timh clocks

plush mason
#

Feel like this'll be a sweep lol

low yarrow
#

cancer is ok

#

mcr original much better obv

#

so i guess timh wins

hidden nacelle
#

they offer different perspectives of the same concept

ashen torrent
#

cancer cover is good but timh solos obviously

hidden nacelle
#

not to me

gentle sundial
#

Cancer ftw
It's so nostalgic to me from 2020 when I listened to it on repeat

hidden nacelle
#

timh is like a good song but it's just good

ashen torrent
#

fair

gentle sundial
lusty dock
#

MCR BETTER MEGASUPERHYPERFLUSHED

#

if timh doesnt clear i will be disappointed

atomic bay
#

the cancer cover gives me the chills I gotta go with it

#

plus the annyeonghaseyo “count in” at the beginning makes me cringe

#

y’all can’t complain about the word slits if y’all vote for timh I’m sorry ✋🤚

mint gale
#

Their Cancer cover is definitely underrated, but imo it’s not as good as the MCR original. And c’mon, Tear in My Heart is a classic.

worthy hornet
#

Tear in my heart is about Jenna and Tyler writing songs about her is adorable so it's TIMH for me

#

Cancer is still a good song and it makes me cry but timh is better for my overall most-of-the-time mood

safe canyon
#

Easy dub for TIMH

thin compass
#

timh 🗣️

last pivot
#

Literally TIMH

red mortar
#

I literally love both 💕

red mortar
thin compass
#

i've had my differences with the majority over these battles

#

like my fallen soldier Saturday

#

but this is a no-brainer

#

besides the few who link 'Cancer' to some events in their life ofc

patent garnet
#

I love cancer cover

#

but timh clears

queen jolt
#

both are amazing

#

but tear in my hear

midnight mirage
#

Man this is hard

#

I like both

#

But im leaning towards cancer honestly

tacit meadow
#

It’s weird mcr fans always say they hate the cancer cover even though Gerard himself said he liked it

fierce hedge
#

ok this is the first actually difficult one

silk hedge
#

Tear in My Heart by far

remote sail
low moss
#

wait why dont people like the counting

unborn plinth
#

no way you guys dont like the counting in timh? what?? also how is that comparable to bystyd? Timh counting has literally been a STAPLE in da clique

#

smh

#

this one actually is hard tho, but im going with Cancer. its their best cover and incredibly well done, its not easy to take such an iconic song and make it your own sound

remote sail
#

its their only cover grief

#

at least on streaming

unborn plinth
#

on streaming yeah. but they have mad world, summertime sadness and those rnt terrible but not at all like cancer

queen jolt
#

i prefer jar of hearts to cancer but it’s close

remote sail
#

best cover is summertime sadness

queen jolt
#

also can’t help falling in love

remote sail
#

or cant help falling in love

#

they swept elvis’ ass

queen jolt
#

fr

thin compass
#

TEAR IN MY HEART

#

nostalgia

unborn plinth
#

all timh counting haters have’t seen enough live videos of the boys looking at each other as they count off

low yarrow
#

timh doesn’t even have any counting what 😭

#

oh the korean

atomic bay
#

hana dul ses nes would’ve worked if he just wanted to use Korean it don’t make sense

#

the bridge of timh does make me waver a bit now that’s iconic

low moss
#

just listened to them and its gotta be cancer

#

timh is a little bit grating on my ears I have come to realize

hidden nacelle
#

agree

thin compass
#

cancer is good but I don’t rly like the top version
Mcr goes hard

quick moss
#

Cancer is pretty good but I don't think Josh did any drumming for it and I think it only gets really good near the end.

static estuary
#

going with timh

crude basalt
#

Relistening tear after so long makes me realize I do like it. Still difficult to decide

valid heart
#

tear in my heart is quite good and i dislike the cancer cover

unborn plinth
#

this is tough bc i think it comes down to connection with the cancer cover. like if you really prefer MCRs original version then i doubt many would pick the cover

#

timh is too good live and is honestly so much more enjoyable to me than smithereens as being a love song

gentle sundial
fierce hedge
remote sail
#

oh yeah

#

irrelevant

fierce hedge
#

oh

hidden nacelle
remote sail
#

WELL YES ACTUALLY

fierce hedge
#

WHY

remote sail
#

ITS@JUST WHATEVER

#

WHEN YOU THINK OF TWENTY ONE PILOTS COVER YOU THINK OF@CANCER

#
  • JOSH ISNT RVEN IN IT
#

THEY LITERALLT SPECIFIED TYLER JOSEPH OF TWENTY ONE PILOTS IN THE TITLE

manic locust
thin compass
queen jolt
remote sail
#

BUT IRR

#

IRRELEVANT

#

I DIDNT SAY IT WAS BAD!!!!

queen jolt
#

maybe

fierce hedge
thin compass
#

im gonna have to go with tarron mahar

remote sail
fierce hedge
#

...

#

nah

#

just most of the time

remote sail
#

literally all the time

gaunt remnant
#

so my experience with cancer is this: tøp was my first experience with it and i loved it. it actually pushed me to listen to mcr a bit, but now that im into mcr im not as into the top version

#

but the vibes between cancer and timh are

#

very different

#

and i also recognize that what pushes me to pick cancer is that i like the song more so than the cover of it

#

and for that

#

im choosing timh

#

also timh was one of the first songs i got into when i was first exploring top

#

i liked stressed out so i started listening to the album

#

and i got super into that song lol

#

look at where its led me

#

kuddos timh, kuddos

jaunty stone
#

this is tough

#

prlly timh because its about jenna and cancer doesnt even belong to them. and timh has a better melody and beat in my opinion

runic kindle
#

im choosing TIMH just because the pilots version of cancer makes me cry every single time i hear it LMAOOOOOO

brittle pivot
#

Cancer hits hard for me. Especially because it came out right when my mom got cancer. I gtg with Cancer tbh

fierce hedge
ionic gale
#

Is “Time to say goodbye” in the song battle list?

patent garnet
fierce hedge
#

but is it

tranquil zealot
#

I kinda liked the Cancer cover... but the way the chorus is structured I can't

#

if it was structured like the song itself and just had the emphasis of "I won't kiss you" "lips are chapped and faded" as like a background vocal then maybe

#

but 언! 녕! 하세요!!

gaunt remnant
#

whats kuddos?

#

oh

#

that explains the red squiggle

#

its nothing

bitter onyx
#

timh sweep OR ELSE

#

best bf song

unborn plinth
bitter onyx
#

nope!!!

#

my memory is perfect actually

sage bone
#

CANCER EZ

#

wait maybe not so ez

#

But I think the song is cool

#

Does anyone know if we can change votes? Not going to rn but for future referencd

bitter onyx
#

yeah you can

sage bone
#

Ok

safe canyon
sage bone
pallid summit
#

TIMH

midnight mirage
#

Id say cancer barely edges it out imo but that’s just my respectful opinion

golden elbow
#

It's got to be Cancer for me because I remember listening to it for the first time on a bus ride to school and how close it had me to tears.

#

It's a powerful cover

silk abyss
#

First time I’m going against the majority here

#

Tear In My Heart is decent, one of my least fav Blurryface songs though. The Black Parade is one of my favourite albums ever and the TOP cover of Cancer is almost as gut wrenching as the original, so it’s easy for me

bitter onyx
#

i hope you're going against the majority

#

i fear for the fate of timh

hidden nacelle
#

no timh is def gonna win

#

unfortunately

slender timber
#

It's a no brainer for me. That cover came out around the same time when my grandpa actually had cancer and it really helped me cope. As much as I love timh it just can't compare Cancer

hidden nacelle
#

welp here we go

#

the comments make it seem like it'll be close but i have a feeling timh will win

#

im rooting for cancer tho

silk abyss
#

Yep

hidden nacelle
#

yeah i had a feeling