#serious-discussion

1 messages · Page 444 of 1

worldly roost
#

im sad

deep mango
#

What does that even mean sully

neat lintel
#

me neither 😭

olive karma
#

i remeber just turning up to school and getting told im sitting the olympiad paper thing

#

Got to the second round for the people that arent smart enough to do the actual thing

thorn brook
#

I remember asking my teacher to sign me up for a math competition thing that leads to IMO. He was like sure. Nothing happened from that point kekw

neat lintel
#

I once went to the second qualifying round, looked at the questions and left as soon as they let us

olive karma
#

yeah im kinda glad i got to the second round for losers, i got like 3 poinst on it or somthing

#

the jump is massive

limber perch
#

I remember going to the IMO and getting 1st place

#

it was a cute test

neat lintel
#

imagine if that is actually just terence tao shitposting

sick burrow
#

if terence tao had an alt on this server who would it be

leaden torrent
#

jacobian

sick burrow
#

who

neat lintel
#

jacobian

leaden torrent
#

sorry that joke requires about 3 hours of deep server lore (TM) to understand

#

let me think of a simpler one

#

@polar panther

neat lintel
#

what about ecneret?

sick burrow
#

he wasn't the guy that said the 0 map wasn't a linear transformation, right?

#

that was like hank or something

leaden torrent
#

that wasnt him

#

well everyone is a jacobian alt

#

so it technically was him

#

but it wasnt

vast surge
#

Was jacobian the "topologies are glorified semilattices" guy?

leaden torrent
#

no.

neat lintel
#

oat ecneret

#

that's who terence would be in secret

deep mango
sick burrow
sharp mulch
#

Mods will unpin it

#

Probably

#

There have been other posts pinned

#

But they were quickly unpinned

blazing pawn
#

Oh they did

#

Thats weird

#

Why

sharp mulch
#

Lol

deep mango
#

The joke is that dicussion-2 doesnt have any messages worth pinning

#

I don't get the joke either

astral marsh
vagrant kestrel
#

[unpinnable drivel]

cold needle
#

there will never be any pins in discussion 2.

sharp mulch
#

Lol

nimble shuttle
sharp mulch
#

Lol

cold needle
#

Not happening chief.

nimble shuttle
#

Not happening chief.

sick burrow
#

Not happening chief.

ancient flame
#

Not happening chief.

#

anyone wanna have a discussion about differentials? I find them fascinating yet strange

#

the fact that dy/dx is written as a fraction when you shouldn't treat it as a fraction but you can manipulate it like a fraction (e.g. separation of variables) is just weird

mild nebula
#

Differentials are invented by physicists to make equations easier to parse. There is no real mathematical object that a differential "is"

#

You can split them and recombine them because the chain rule is pretty

#

Abuse of notation sounds like a bad thing, but u-sub and separation of variables are very handy

mild nebula
#

I don't mean differentials in terms of differential geometry

leaden torrent
#

darn.

mild nebula
#

That's a different story

#

Haha Namington ready

summer nest
sharp mulch
#

Differentials as discussed in physics and odes are a lie

mild nebula
#

Ahh shoot I always forget about those

sharp mulch
#

Differential forms in diff geo are real

ancient flame
leaden torrent
#

thats ambiguous in a context with more than just one variable

vagrant kestrel
ancient flame
#

im really only talking about single variable for simplicity

leaden torrent
#

then you can treat them as fractions without issue

#

as long as youre not dumb about it

ancient flame
#

what about in the multivariable context?

#

is there a difference?

leaden torrent
#

yes

ancient flame
#

it should be partial f / partial x

leaden torrent
#

everything falls apart

#

immediately

ancient flame
#

how so?

leaden torrent
#

in a multivar context

ancient flame
#

you couldn't do separation of variables?

leaden torrent
#

just... try any example of manipulating partial derivatives as fractions

#

itll probably break

ancient flame
#

is there a specific reason as to why?

leaden torrent
#

separation of variables kind of works but with modification

#

you cant just treat it as naive fractions anymore

leaden torrent
#

naively we'd have no reason to think it does

#

besides the suggestive notation

ancient flame
#

makes sense

#

because single variable is like a super simplified case, so it works out coincidentally, right?

leaden torrent
#

coincidentally is a bit overly dismissive, theres deep reasons why it works

#

if you look at exterior algebras and whatnot, its "obvious" the dimension=1 case collapses into simple multiplication of differential forms

#

but that requires a background in analysis to explain

ancient flame
#

how rigorous of analysis

#

I know some real analysis

leaden torrent
#

any differential geometry?

ancient flame
#

nope lol

leaden torrent
#

multilinear algebra of function spaces?

ancient flame
#

no lmao

leaden torrent
#

cant help you then

sharp mulch
#

Lol

ancient flame
#

unfortunate

leaden torrent
ancient flame
#

key word: try

leaden torrent
#

but idk if thatll help

ancient flame
#

yeah it hasn't helped, hopefully I'll be able to understand this at some point, but thanks for trying lmao :')

bold ferry
#

why not read Loring Tu's intro to manifolds

ancient flame
#

any prerequisites for that? @bold ferry

bold ferry
#

you should know a bit of linear algebra. i learned algebra stuff which i didnt know along the way @ancient flame

#

like familiarity with dual space, dual basis,....are needed

#

he discusses all these things so u should be good

ancient flame
#

oh alright

#

thank u so much

bold ferry
#

and later, u will need topology @ancient flame

ancient flame
#

oh

bold ferry
#

topics u will need are discussed in appendix of the book

ancient flame
#

ok that helps

#

Ty!

analog salmon
#

vtuber is doing a "math challenge"

#

stream titled "let's solve all the equations!"

#

pain

sharp mulch
#

I know a vtuber who does math streams sometimes

analog salmon
#

tfw no vtuber to watch calculate the fundamental group of a wedge of n circles

sharp mulch
#

Yeah the vtuber I have in mind does logic stuff

deep mango
#

logic and final fantasy 14

sharp mulch
#

Yes

cold needle
#

namington's friend

#

from a different department

astral marsh
#

do they also play league

deep mango
#

no, this is the same person i was thinking of

untold sapphire
#

people who try to do all topology via order theory annoy me somewhat

#

well idk. i think pointless topology is interesting because the locale/frame is what you need to do sheaf theory.

astral marsh
#

sounds pointless

untold sapphire
#

yeah people say this about most sheaf theory/category theory lol. rip

#

but i tried to read this book called "monoidal topology" which is all about trying to do topology with quantales and it was less than engaging lol

#

"Posets are just the lax eilenberg-moore algebras of the category of sets and relations enriched over posets"

#

same thing with metric spaces

astral marsh
#

no i was just making a joke

untold sapphire
#

i know, dw

#

I did actually read a legit book review recently of a textbook on sheaf theory where the reviewer was just like

#

"This book is garbage because sheaf theory is not real math"

#

lmao

#

he was like "Category theory and sheaf theory are a language and don't need a whole textbook on them. sheaves should be at most a single chapter in a book on Riemann surface theory or differential geometry, plus a handful of exercises. this book is actively deceptive because it proceeds definition-lemma-theorem-proof and thus conveys to the reader the impression that they are reading mathematics, however, as we have said, sheaf theory is not mathematics, it is a language. Real mathematics is, essentially, geometry."

#

it was such a hot take my god

#

one of my favorite books is on sheaf cohomology so i was just like, damn, what an asshole lmao

narrow rock
#

lol

astral marsh
#

i see lmao

untold sapphire
#

Godement's book on sheaves in algebraic topology, Topologie Algebrique et Theorie des Faisceaux

narrow rock
#

ah

#

ive heard good things about it

civic jacinth
#

help me do this i got 400

astral marsh
untold sapphire
#

it's mostly a standard textbook but there's one piece of originality which is that he gives a "simplicial" formulation of sheaf cohomology, like instead of a resolution of a sheaf being an exact sequence of injective sheaves, a resolution of F is a cosimplicial object in the category of sheaves augmented by F. he then proves that like, all the usual formulas from singular cohomology to define the cup product and so on translate into sheaf cohomology using the simplicial structure. very cool

#

so like, the Alexander-Whitney formula for the cup product

#

or the Steenrod squaring operations

narrow rock
untold sapphire
#

it's also a good introduction to spectral sequences at a very limited level of generality, which is nice because spectral sequences are mega complicated so introducing them at like 20% power and then using them to prove a bunch of cool shit is a very good approach pedagogically

#

and motivates learning more about them later on

narrow rock
#

gelfand and manin's section on spectral sequences is pretty nice

untold sapphire
#

i like gelfand and manin. like gelfand and manin, godement's book starts by stressing simplicial methods, he usually works with simplicial Abelian groups rather than chain complexes

narrow rock
#

yeah and the exercises are pretty nice

#

in the derived/triangulated cats chapters

untold sapphire
#

they're hard!

#

lol

#

sometimes they're a bit brusque for my taste because they kind of gloss over some technicalities that are easy once you get what's going on but like

#

you shouldn't gloss over technicalities in the statement of an exercise that the student is going to have to figure out on their own midway through

neat lintel
#

Quick question can you give a certain number a variable and use that variable in a calculation for example : 12.14 = a / (a +4)/2 = 8.07

#

or would that be illegal in exams

pale orchid
#

can you ask your question again a little more clearly?

#

what do you mean give "give a number a variable", and why is 12.14 = 8.07

neat lintel
#

sorry my english is bad im trying to say if you can give a certain number a variable and use that variable in your calculation

pale orchid
#

if you do it right and following all the basic arithmetic rules, there should be no problem

odd narwhal
#

It's just replacing one symbol with another

neat lintel
#

it just makes it quicker to calculate when using big numbers

#

because sometimes i want to use the precise number when calculating and i dont want to write the whole number down

inner finch
#

yeah

#

you can do that if you want

pale orchid
#

as long as you do it correctly, yeah

#

what you wrote above wouldn't be allowed because you wrote it in a way that it seems you're saying 12.14 = 8.07

inner finch
#

i think they meant

#

a := 12.14

(a+4)/2 = 8.07

pale orchid
#

most likely, yeah, but do be careful to not leave it up to the grader's interpretation

#

stuff requiring more than a couple neuron seconds doesn't tend to be well-received

inner finch
light cradle
#

I have attended school a little late and the lesson I have are sequences, are there any tricks to help me solve problems faster?

devout nacelle
#

Practice

#

What exactly about sequences are you learning/supposed to learn?

light cradle
#

like, 2, 5, 10, 17, 26

#

those kind of stuffs

modest rune
#

17 is my favorite sequence

light cradle
#

and answers are like n^2 + 1

modest rune
#

Oh

#

This is even more practiced based

light cradle
#

I see

modest rune
#

Its pattern recognition

light cradle
#

i thought there were tricks haha

modest rune
#

And pattern recognition is just practice

#

There are “tricks” but the “tricks” are just made up of intuition you build through seeing a lot of examples

whole copper
#

it blew my mind as a kid that the difference between consecutive squares are the odd numbers

devout nacelle
#

You should familiarise yourself with arithmetic/geometric progressions, and practice these problems more and more.

light cradle
#

but thanks for letting me know, It's a relief that I asked this before learning it. Atleast I now know that there's no shortcuts

#

thanks Manan and MaxJ

modest rune
#

But seriously the larger your internal library of examples is the more you’ll be able to fly through these

whole copper
#

there are general ways to go about too, like checking the differences between consecutives in the list and stuff like that

modest rune
#

Yeah having an eye for “growth rate” is good

#

But that comes with practice

light cradle
#

I will keep that in mind

#

thanks pros!

modest rune
#

Wack that I am now literally a professional

#

U r too ryc

#

Don’t emote me

deep mango
devout nacelle
#

MaxJ #PatternRecognitionPro

sharp mulch
#

Lol

modest rune
#

We both get paid to do math lol

deep mango
#

i haven't been paid yet

modest rune
#

Oh me either

whole copper
#

get paid to sit around, the math is just a side hobby

deep mango
#

also

sharp mulch
#

Max excels at finding low dimensional patterns

deep mango
#

if this is all it takes

#

then i was a professional during my reu

modest rune
#

Oh fair

#

Reu is like

deep mango
#

i really think if you're being paid to be a student it doesn't count

modest rune
#

The equivalent of an intern

deep mango
#

i'll consider myself a professional once i pass my oral qual

modest rune
#

We’re paid to be TAs

#

Not students

deep mango
#

hmmm

#

professional TA

#

fine

inner finch
#

and i was too minibrained to look at them and be like oh that's obviously 12n^2 + 1232 + 324n

light cradle
#

i overthink alot

inner finch
#

You can do some linear algebra fuckery with this tho

light cradle
#

my brain is smooth like butter

inner finch
#

You can first assume that the sequence is given by a degree n polynomial p(n)

#

now take in p(0), p(1), p(2), p(3) etc and then solve these simeltaniously for their coefficients

light cradle
#

our n starts with (1)

inner finch
#

You get Ax = b and A is pretty much always invertible for whatever n you choose so you get x = A^-1 b, and the vector x contains your coefficients you want, plug them into the polynomial before and voila

#

its a bit long but if you have a decent calculator itll be quicker i thinks

#

esp if u can save the matrices or sth like that

light cradle
#

this is too complicated for my brain by i think i can manage

inner finch
#

Once im done eating ill work an example for u

light cradle
#

sure thanks

modest rune
#

This is

#

Strange advise

deep mango
#

me: what's the sequence for 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32,...

#

mizzy's method

#

💩

inner finch
#

It's what i did

modest rune
#

Advice*

#

Its terrible lol

inner finch
#

It worked for me kekw

light cradle
#

tbh i cant understand shit, even what's written on this powerpoint

deep mango
#

ok tbf you can analyze lots of recurrences with linalg

whole copper
#

I think its fine advice as long as you guess enough forms... if poly fitting doesnt work try an exponential fit

#

or an exp * poly or something, idk how hard these sequences are lol

inner finch
#

I mean this is going to be mainly easier sequences

#

but at the same time im horrible at pattern recognition

whole copper
#

the main thing is after fitting say a quadratic to 3 points.. check that it actually still works on the rest of the sequence

inner finch
#

so i liked the easy algorithm of the aforementioned method

modest rune
#

So so cursed

#

Also

#

Completely fails for recursive sequences

#

Which iirc aren’t uncommon

inner finch
devout nacelle
#

I mean, if you're studying such finite sequences of integers, in all likelihood it would be a combination of arithmetic/geometric progressions of some nature

whole copper
#

what kind of recursive sequence would they be asking you to get a closed form for that this wouldnt work?

inner finch
#

Well i did assume they are polynomials, im assuming this isnt going to be anything recursive hmmCat

whole copper
#

if they are asking you to get a closed form, presumably you can fit it..

deep mango
#

you're recursive

inner finch
#

im cursive

deep mango
#

cocursive

light cradle
#

it's arithmetic

modest rune
#

I think it’s not uncommon for the pattern to be like

#

“Add 4 to the previous number and multiple by the one before it”

#

Something like this

deep mango
#

gross

inner finch
#

I guess it depends on the syllabus

#

Since the time i was doing the poly fitting shit was when

whole copper
#

this can be fit right? thats yucky in any case

#

but its some sum of exp * polys? solving the recurrence?

inner finch
#

we didn't have any recursion in our syllabus sotrue

devout nacelle
#

The only exams where I've seen pattern recognition in sequences have all been generic/non-mathy papers

inner finch
#

So this worked pretty well 😌

modest rune
fathom swallowBOT
whole copper
#

that has closed form! riemann zeta function

inner finch
sleek wing
# fathom swallow **ryc**

converges to 1 for all starting values, I'll omit the proof as it's a simple application of certain methods

modest rune
#

What about this sequence $a_n=$ the cardinality of $\pi_{m+n}S^n$ for large $n$

devout nacelle
fathom swallowBOT
#

MaxJ #MiuArmy

inner finch
devout nacelle
#

Oof

#

I had a chapter on it

#

In Grade 11

inner finch
#

neanderthal college board

#

our local board does have it tho

devout nacelle
inner finch
#

our board is like

#

calculus guys omg sotrue sotrue

devout nacelle
#

Local maxima fammmmmm

inner finch
#

compute the integral of 123o21u38123213843284302432x^12312312423432423424

#

this mathematics is so ADVANCED

#

there are so many BIG NUMBERS

#

oh hey integral calculator is here

sleek wing
#

123o21u38123213843284302432/123123124234324234245*x^12312312423432423425+c

inner finch
#

hi nG sotrue

vivid halo
#

@modest rune cool topology facts! For X a K3 surface, π_3(X)=Z^252 and π_4(X)=Z^3520+(Z/2Z)^42

inner finch
#

looks like this means you don't know how to integrate :/

#

study harder next time

sleek wing
#

one moment

modest rune
sleek wing
modest rune
#

Just scan it

deep mango
#

this is like when tterra ambushes you for a cool fact from some class you had, and you tell him this to get back at him

modest rune
#

The difference is obvious

sleek wing
#

ok the 23rd place is different if my code is right

#

bro you think I'm reading that

modest rune
#

I did

#

Took 1 second

sleek wing
#

horrifying

deep mango
#

i spent one second and read like 4 digits

inner finch
#

inb4 max grades my papers sotrue

vivid halo
#

don't worry max this is a cool theorem

deep mango
#

theorem A

inner finch
#

theorem N_0 sotrue

sharp mulch
#

Theorem A

modest rune
deep mango
#

does math twitter ever use hashtags that look like you're asking for the cardinality of a set or doing one of those products or whatever

sleek wing
#

4-manifold
😅

inner finch
#

math twitter

modest rune
#

Whats that from nG

#

Should I read it

vivid halo
#

no

modest rune
#

Sad

deep mango
#

oh this seems so cool

#

periodic geodesic asymptotics nozoomi

vivid halo
#

moreover the ranks of the homotopy groups grow exponentially

modest rune
#

Me and ryc reading group

deep mango
#

hmm

sharp mulch
#

Lol

deep mango
#

this is just like, a lot more algtop heavy than the other closed geodesic asymptotic proofs i've seen

#

impressive

vivid halo
#

so this is one of the coolest papers I've seen in ages

deep mango
#

that looks very exciting and pretty, but i don't have the context to see what's going on i suppose

neat lintel
#

closed geodesics cocatThink

narrow rock
velvet dagger
#

That's nifty but it's so scuffed lmao

pale orchid
#

ah yes, hunting down unpublished papers

#

good practices

bronze pelican
#

@vivid halo

inner finch
#

ou wou

bronze pelican
#

i love the juxtaposition of math and anime in a naive google search

light needle
#

math is just anime

neat lintel
#

Wow, I just developed crushes on those girls in the top right

light needle
#

have you not seen the galois corrospondence between fields of math and subanimes

leaden torrent
#

at most

neat lintel
light needle
#

anime has ruined your brain.

bronze pelican
leaden torrent
#

dude their heads are like half the size of their upper bodies

#

you cant convince me they're older than 14

#

admittedly though those legs are long as shit

sharp mulch
#

Namington has lots of experience determining whether girls are legal

light needle
#

yes

cold needle
#

Namington has lots of experience stare

limber perch
#

actually you probably knew that if you posted the pic

#

nice 👍

leaden torrent
#

wait i had no clue stoner transitioned

#

now i feel bad for posting a pre-transition pic

astral marsh
limber perch
#

the guy on the right looks awkward

#

but this is exactly how my dumbass would stand

latent forge
light needle
#

so the general idea is that, pre-transition stuff like a dead name or pictures or w/e can trigger dysphoria, and also is in general considered disrespectful to the trans person

latent forge
#

oh ok

#

do all trans people have dysphoria?

light needle
#

hmm most I know do but also there are cases where people dont have dysphoria i think? im not super well educated on the nuances of that lol

#

i just use the rule of thumb of avoiding anything pre transition that could be harmful

latent forge
#

ill follow suite

light needle
#

and whatever the person tells me is ok/not ok

inner finch
#

You don't have to have dysphoria to be trans, but a lot of trans people do have dysphoria

#

Posting pictures of you pre-transition is akin to like

#

hm

latent forge
#

Is it like posting child pictures

#

and then not associating with yourself

inner finch
#

constantly reminding you of your childhood in a sense thonk. In this analogy trans people are seen a children (i.e. who they were before) constantly

latent forge
#

No not necessarily

inner finch
#

Bad analogy but you get what i mean

latent forge
#

I see it as a distant past

#

That isnt relatable due to memory

inner finch
#

What's the difference opencry

latent forge
#

Well there doesnt need to be the implication of seeing the person as a child

#

rather they are a different person in ideas and thought such that they cant relate as well

#

If im interpretting this correctly thats the feeling?

#

I dont know if I need to understand

inner finch
#

im not getting what u mean KEK

light needle
#

cis moment catThink

inner finch
#

isomer moment sotrue

light needle
#

lol brain washed by ochem

inner finch
#

its over sotrue ochem losers have entered the chat

latent forge
light needle
#

im mostly meming

inner finch
#

become trans sotrue

latent forge
#

Maybe in 2070

light needle
#

its nice ur trying to understand kek

inner finch
#

detroit: become trans

light needle
#

true

#

john nb moment when catThink

latent forge
#

How likely do yall think a world war is?

#

Im estimating in 30 years arbitrarily

light needle
#

ah the very related topic

latent forge
#

Well I wont be me in 2070 hopefully

#

Hopefully I ascend to heaven

#

mentally ascend

#

Hmm my phrasing does sound sus

inner finch
#

i am nb catThimc

latent forge
#

I will become this person

#

By 2070

light needle
#

I like the nb colors in ur pfps hair

#

it contrasts nicely catThink

latent forge
#

what is nb?

#

neon blue?

light needle
#

yes.

latent forge
#

there is purple and baaige though

#

blonde?

#

,av zzymiz

fathom swallowBOT
#
mirzathecutiepie#7210's Avatar

Click here to view the image.

light needle
#

<@&268886789983436800>

latent forge
#

They disnt

#

He is asking a valid question

leaden torrent
#

nah

#

fuck that

latent forge
#

Was that bait?

light needle
#

this is common holocaust denying language

leaden torrent
#

its holocaust denialism

latent forge
#

wait what

#

what was he going to say next

leaden torrent
#

usually something along the lines of "im just asking questions bro"

latent forge
#

or is he implying it didnt happen because population is off

leaden torrent
#

yes

#

thats the implication

light needle
#

basically

leaden torrent
#

or at least that the numbers are forged

latent forge
#

why deny a genocide existence?

leaden torrent
#

usually to imply that the nazis werent so bad.

light needle
#

happens in a lot of context

leaden torrent
#

either that, or that the jews are pulling the strings of world politics

light needle
#

like ppl deny it for whats going in china

leaden torrent
#

and inventing genocides to jsutify their persecution complex

#

or what-have-you

light needle
#

is a common recent one

latent forge
#

idk whats happening in china besides displacement of falun dafa

toxic schooner
leaden torrent
#

armenian genocide denialism is also a big thing in turkey

latent forge
#

and falun gong

leaden torrent
#

although at least turkey doesnt try to downplay the numbers

#

they just say it wasnt a genocide

#

and rather was a contracted civil war, or was justified actions against dissidents, or was internal infighting

#

or whatever

torn willow
latent forge
#

what is uighyur

leaden torrent
#

math discord tries to spell "uighur"

light needle
#

this is why i didnt try to spell it.

leaden torrent
# latent forge what is uighyur

a muslim population living in western china that the government is widely believed to be engaged in active genocide against.

torn willow
latent forge
#

oh

torn willow
#

Ok, spelling is wronh

latent forge
#

how do i even know these things exist without internet

leaden torrent
#

news media?

#

the chinese government itself admits to using "re-education camps" and actively discouraging islam

#

and trying to prevent uighurs from reproducing

latent forge
#

im not arguing specifics im just speaking in generalities

leaden torrent
#

if you believe the reports of (american-aligned) journalists and the CIA, their actions are far more aggressive than that, including forced sterilization and work-to-death camps

latent forge
#

Why would anyone have reasons to downplay a genocide

#

If evidence exists

inner finch
#

reeducation camps sotrue

#

There was the uh

#

big brother and sister thing as well

latent forge
#

Has the downplay genocide strategy ever worked?

torn willow
#

See Holodomor

light needle
#

yeah a lot

leaden torrent
#

well, if you want to defend the communist party of china, acknowledging "yeah theyre currently genociding some folk but thats okay" is kind of a losing battle

inner finch
#

where they sent ppl from "educated" parts of china

latent forge
#

holy shit you cant expect me to keep searching these hard af names

leaden torrent
#

so defending the communist party kind of requires you to deny a genocide

light needle
#

like hell even in like canada

latent forge
#

im in mobile

sharp mulch
#

The British have committed a few genocides that people don't really know about now

light needle
#

ppl still deny the stuff against first nation ppl

inner finch
#

a lot of the

light needle
#

which was practically genocide

sharp mulch
#

And yeah Canada with first nations peoples

inner finch
#

countries that colonized did do genocide

leaden torrent
#

sure but canada continued well after occupying the territory in question

#

the intention wasnt just to settle the land

#

it was very actively to "de-indianize" the first nations

latent forge
#

Makes sense i guess

inner finch
#

awal mumalik sotrue

leaden torrent
#

like, old laws and whatnot use precisely that term

latent forge
#

thats what colonizers do

#

its literally capture the flag but irl

#

and everyone dies

sharp mulch
#

For China/Uighurs it's a lot of tankies being like CCP good and what not

latent forge
#

what is a tankie

inner finch
#

see see pee

inner finch
latent forge
#

communist facist?

leaden torrent
#

tankie = defender of authoritarian communism

light needle
#

basically

inner finch
#

communist person who ends up just being a facist

leaden torrent
#

the USSR, the CPC

light needle
#

they jerk of china

#

and soviet

leaden torrent
#

or CCP or whatever acronym they prefer to use

latent forge
#

i still dont know what facist is

leaden torrent
#

often north korea as well

latent forge
#

besides something something authority

inner finch
#

the united states of states of russia sotrue

leaden torrent
#

though some draw the line at north korea

#

not all of them

#

but some

light needle
#

nazbol moment

latent forge
#

Have any genocides ever been fiction?

light needle
#

ever heard of

latent forge
#

Just devil’s advocate

light needle
#

white genocide

latent forge
#

what?

#

no

torn willow
light needle
#

its really funny lol

inner finch
#

white genocide sotrue sotrue

light needle
#

basically the idea is like

#

more interracial babies

latent forge
#

Oh i googled it

light needle
#

is wiping out pure white blood

#

so white genocide

devout nacelle
#

Ooof.

light needle
sharp mulch
#

Lol pure white blood

inner finch
#

progressive movements are authoritarian and are out to destroy the poor weak american white boys

sharp mulch
#

Blood is red

latent forge
#

It sounds weird ig

leaden torrent
#

well it's been believed for a long long time that jews are planning on genociding good ol' christian folk

devout nacelle
#

This stupidity is omnipresent across cultures

sharp mulch
#

If you're blood is white then something is very wrong with you

latent forge
light needle
#

i just have a lot of white blood cells ok

leaden torrent
#

but not really, generally accusing someone of a genocide requires a fuckton of evidence

#

the nice part is that genocides typically produce a lot of evidence

#

in the form of bodies

#

although of course, you can hide bodies

sharp mulch
#

That's why you burn the bodies

leaden torrent
#

as canada recently found out

latent forge
#

@inner finch they killed jesus.

sharp mulch
#

And use the ashes as fertilizer

inner finch
#

lol

leaden torrent
#

uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

inner finch
#

jewish people did xyz thing long before this must mean that all jewish people are exactly the same sotrue

leaden torrent
#

not a good line chief

latent forge
#

Am I wrong? I thought the Abrhamix religions hate eachother

#

for different reasons

light needle
#

i mean not reallllly

#

like

latent forge
#

I thought Muslims for false prophet

light needle
#

its dislike in the sense

latent forge
#

Christians for false prophet and not recognizing mohammad

leaden torrent
#

its possible to think a religion is false without literally hating its practitioners

devout nacelle
#

A small subset of overly religious people hating other people is not the same as saying an entire community hates another.

leaden torrent
#

also muslims dont think christians had a false prophet

#

they believe in jesus

inner finch
leaden torrent
#

they just think some prophets came after him

#

mohammad being the last

inner finch
#

we call him hazrat isa

#

well not we

#

but you get the point kekw

latent forge
#

cheistians belive muslims have false prohpet I meant

inner finch
#

I mean sure thonk

#

but people don't hate each other for that lol

leaden torrent
#

sure

#

but that doesnt mean all christians hate all muslims

latent forge
#

and muslims are critical of idolization of jesus

inner finch
#

Vast majority just leave each other alone

light needle
#

i mean this is just religion

latent forge
#

Yes but im speaking in religious generalities

light needle
#

disagreeing with each other

latent forge
#

Yes

light needle
#

which happens cause ya know

#

different religions

latent forge
#

Many people died over these things

#

and still do

inner finch
#

Yeah but the religious generalities don't extend to actual people thonk

#

ehh

leaden torrent
#

the correct conclusion from "interreligious conflicts exist" is not "all followers of x religion hate followers of y religion"

#

we are not denying the former statement

inner finch
#

Not very sure about the still do part

leaden torrent
#

we're denying the latter

latent forge
#

Well hate/dislike

leaden torrent
#

i dont think thats true either

inner finch
leaden torrent
#

i know christians with very close jew friends

#

this region has like 0 muslims so i cant say anything there

inner finch
#

most people will be respectful to ppl with different religious beliefs

leaden torrent
#

but one would expect it to be the same

latent forge
#

Im first generation middle east and parents give impression that they are accepting of other religions but its dangerous to be atheist in some places

leaden torrent
#

certainly zealots hate followers of other religions

#

thats like, the definition of a zealot

light needle
#

yeah it is

leaden torrent
#

but the fact that "zealot" and "follower" are different terms

light needle
#

but i think thats probably more of a

leaden torrent
#

should be pretty suggestive here lmao

light needle
#

socioeconomic meme

inner finch
light needle
#

then a fully bc of religion thing

inner finch
#

but yeah denying god can be dangerous here

light needle
#

also its the US' fault dont @ me

leaden torrent
#

eh sure, religious conflicts are often a convenient excuse for other forms of discrimination

inner finch
#

you're ofc going to get shit for it at the very least KEK

leaden torrent
#

like a typical US anti-muslim is more afraid of arabs than islam

inner finch
#

indeed

latent forge
#

And some people are really open with their hates so its suprising

light needle
#

yeah i got beaten up pretty daily by religious zelouts in my school in bangladesh lol

inner finch
#

I mainly am speaking about pakistan here

#

This can get kind of complex thonk

#

with secretarian infighting and stuff too

leaden torrent
#

if anything, i'd say that jews are uniquely tolerant towards other religions, largely for historical reasons

#

as well as the fact that the jewish faith doesnt really like spreading itself

inner finch
#

Anyways gotta go sotrue

leaden torrent
#

and is more inherited and whatnot

#

like you can convert to judaism but its rare

#

and jews aren't as encouraged to proselytize as other faiths

#

typically speaking at least

latent forge
leaden torrent
#

(as with anything, exceptions exist)

light needle
latent forge
#

I dont know many people mind you

light needle
#

gl on chem memes or w/e

leaden torrent
#

israel-palestine is a pretty big exception to a lot of things lmao

latent forge
#

I rarely have exposure to people who are practicing jewish

inner finch
#

nevermind im back sotrue

latent forge
#

and the hasidics in nyc arent that open in my experiences

leaden torrent
latent forge
#

Not suprising given their historical displacements

#

Similar to african diaspora and connection to the continent some of my family has

#

Mostly the first four points

leaden torrent
#

that 34% supporting BDS is pretty representative of the "strongly pro-palestine" subpopulation of US jews

#

but it seems the plurality are slightly pro-israel or don't take a side

latent forge
#

Yea but to quote someone earlier complicty in these situations doesnt really help

leaden torrent
#

2/3s don't believe the israel government is actively seeking piece

#

the point is that the opinions of israeli jews might not line up with those of international jews

#

(oddly, though, it seems netanyahu has more support among US jews than he does among israelis - lmao)

latent forge
#

Namington are you jewish by chance

leaden torrent
#

no

latent forge
#

or

#

by birth

leaden torrent
#

no.

small kayak
#

I am

latent forge
#

The only other genocide that ive heard people say was faked was something starting with a B or A

#

Oh yeah

#

Belgium Congo genocide

#

I remember watching this guy who does free software stuff on youthbe

#

and for whatever reason he brought up a point of belgium congo genocide being fake

#

I truly don’t understand motivations sometimes

leaden torrent
#

there's a valid argument that the congo genocide gets undue attention when basically every colonial power was doing something similar

#

but thats certainly a different thing than downplaying its severity lmao

latent forge
#

undue attention?

leaden torrent
#

you could argue it wasnt "genocidal" in that the goal probably wasnt to wipe out any particular race

#

and was instead just to milk them for as much money as they could

#

but thats a definitional issue that distracts from the fact that, yeah, they were putting millions through a lot of suffering and death to turn a profit

leaden torrent
#

and the congo genocide is only the "most well-known" because of heart of darkness

latent forge
#

I dont know what heart of darkness is

leaden torrent
#

a book from 1899 about the author's experiences in the congo

#

its not biographical, it's a fictional work about fictional characters undergoing a fictional journey

latent forge
#

o ok

leaden torrent
#

but it's based on his experiences when he toured there

#

er, "toured" is the wrong word, i think he worked for some company there

#

the point being that he saw a lot of shit

#

and wrote a hugely successful novel about it

velvet dagger
#

Oh huh, were the other colonies treated as badly as the Congo?

leaden torrent
#

that kinda woke up the eyes of europeans to the mistreatments of "savages" in africa by colonizers

velvet dagger
#

I actually was under the impression that it was orders of magnitude worse there

leaden torrent
#

but the difference certainly wasnt orders of magnitudes

#

congo was probably the "worst" but it was far from the only place where really bad shit was happening

#

its just that like, coverage of south africa was "we have the maxim gun; and they do not" while coverage of the congo was joseph fucking conrad

#

so there's a difference in how they live on in the historical memory

latent forge
#

online deathtolls look yikes

velvet dagger
#

I guess the only point of comparison I have is Morocco

latent forge
#

says around 9-10 mil

leaden torrent
#

yeah north africa fared considerably better

#

relatively

velvet dagger
#

And Morocco's shtick with France was not that bad

leaden torrent
#

south/east africa is where most of the brutality occured

latent forge
leaden torrent
#

france owned morocco for a while but didnt really make too many extractionary attempts in it

velvet dagger
#

I mean Morocco was officially a protectorate rather than a colony. And to my understanding you didn't have stuff like forced labor or heavy death tolls

leaden torrent
#

thats not to say they were entirely hands-off

#

but they werent all that involved

velvet dagger
#

They built some roads, probably told the king what to do a bunch

obsidian parrot
#

Please anyone know answer for this

leaden torrent
#

it served some military utility as well, the north african theatre was of course very famous in ww2

#

(though you might have better luck in physics server, see #old-network )

#

but yeah, turns out that a country thats 90% barely-habited desert doesnt have many resources to extract

#

at least excluding oil

velvet dagger
#

Oh tru when Vichy France was a thing I think they told Morocco to start handing over Jewish people

leaden torrent
#

and there was much more "history" between berbers and the french

velvet dagger
#

And Morocco was like how about you fuck yourself

#

Wait I'm Berber and I didn't even know that part lol, what history?

leaden torrent
#

well i phrased that poorly perhaps

velvet dagger
#

(I'm not as well-informed as I should be about this stuff)

leaden torrent
#

its just that french people were more... familiar with berbers/north africans in general

#

because of centuries of mediterranean trade

#

they didnt have that for south africans

velvet dagger
#

Ah

leaden torrent
#

far easier to dehumanize them and ignore their suffering

latent forge
#

Hopefully all this history erases over time and the world is completely globalized

leaden torrent
#

berbers often had more of a "noble savage" aspect to them

#

in how they were portrayed in a lot of european media

#

now of course the "noble savage" idea is kinda racist itself but like

#

far better to be a noble savage than a subhuman one

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

velvet dagger
#

That makes sense, and lmfao the noble savage, I wonder what that must've looked like. I didn't know if they were portrayed much at all and if so, how

#

@latent forge would be tough. Some would argue it shouldn't happen, idk about the merits in the abstract to weigh in on that

#

But with power dynamics as they are it feels tricky to imagine globalization happening unless someone with less than pure intent decides to just roflstomp everyone

latent forge
#

Everyone would argue for it not to happen since people see erasure of culture as bad

leaden torrent
#

afaik they were often seen as like, bands of muslim traders riding berb horses through their tents and deserts

#

and while thats not the most accurate representation, its certainly better than "jungle people spending all day killing each other with spears"

#

oh yeah, i'd imagine the muslim aspect helped quite a bit

#

like europeans at the time didnt like muslims but

#

they at least KNEW muslims

latent forge
#

Tfw spanish in arabic script

leaden torrent
#

muslims believed in the same god and had largely predictible and understandable religious ideas

#

whereas south africans were a whole other can of worms

#

its a lot easier to dehumanize someone if you can portray them as worshiping river spirits and shit

#

at least from the perspective of a monotheistic christian

#

now im not pretending that colonizers treated north africans 100% nicely

#

i mean, the various infrastructure projects the UK tried in egypt are quite infamous at this point

#

but they were spared from the brunt of colonial abuse

velvet dagger
leaden torrent
#

the suez canal construction has an estimated 120k deaths attributed to it

#

over 11 years

velvet dagger
#

Holy shit

latent forge
#

Only 11

leaden torrent
#

this was before the UK formally conquered egypt mind, but egypt was solidly in their sphere of influence

latent forge
#

Thas a lot of people

leaden torrent
#

the construction was led by a UK company and funded by UK capitalists

#

(though actual work was mostly done by egyptians)

latent forge
#

tbh I wish these genocides were fake

leaden torrent
#

er oops

#

bad history

#

one sec

#

the canal was mostly funded by french interests, not UK ones

#

the UK conquered it later

#

sorry, wires crossed a bit

#

the UK was opposed to it because they preferred routing trade through the cape (which they controlled)

latent forge
#

so they bought the canal eventually?

leaden torrent
#

not bought, it was legally transferred over in the 1888 convention of constantinople but de facto controlled by them for a few years earlier iirc

#

in that they stationed massive boats near it

#

which mostly didnt bother trade ships but certainly restricted military ones

latent forge
#

Whats your opinion on expanding empires?

leaden torrent
#

uh

#

imperialism bad

latent forge
#

Do you think they should be a thing

leaden torrent
#

expansionism bad

latent forge
#

What do you do though

leaden torrent
#

i currently do not own any empires.

latent forge
#

there is only so much you can do on your own soil

leaden torrent
#

i'll keep you posted once i get my hands on one

latent forge
#

bruh

#

idk either lol

#

but i think expansionism is the easiest and least risky strategy for improving

latent forge
#

im just thinking in hypotheticals

#

if i had control over a small country that could barely produce its own food and relied mostly on trade

#

im not sure what id do

light needle
#

just trade thonk

leaden torrent
#

that country is not in a position to expand

#

lmao

#

i mean expansionism makes sense from the perspective of a selfish king in the 1500s

#

it does not make moral sense

#

but it makes political sense

#

and sure, if you want to boil down political discourse to realpolitiks you can do that

latent forge
#

so what do you do as leader of that country to improve lives of people and in affect your own if you cant self sufficient your own land

leaden torrent
#

but like, realpolitiks today says that expansionism is usually a very very bad idea

#

russia only barely got away with crimea

latent forge
#

expansionism today would be shut down hard

leaden torrent
#

and that was with a lot of posturing and stomaching a lot of sanctions

leaden torrent
#

unfortunately i'm not so sure the math discord's gonna be able to crack this nut chief

latent forge
#

no im just saying expansionism seems like the only natural thing to do );

#

but there is no moral way to handle that

#

because you will be destroying others to benefit

leaden torrent
#

the way that most small powers nowadays are coping with their position is by aligning themselves with china and getting a fuckton of support from them

latent forge
#

globalization isnt so bad see

leaden torrent
#

well, china's interests clearly arent altruistic here

#

they're seeking to expand their international sphere of influence

latent forge
#

no need

leaden torrent
#

but at least for parties involved, it's mutually beneficial

latent forge
#

yea sure

#

i mean full scholarships isnt that bad

#

and most small powers should be softlocked

#

because they cant make any agressive moves for improvements

inner finch
#

gloob

#

i rode the bike today sotrue

#

my dad was holding the controls only a little it felt p good

light needle
#

nice

inner finch
light needle
#

mfw still cannot ride bike

inner finch
#

will soon take my brother out once i know how to do it fully sotrue

#

i can ride the non motorized ones

#

the motorized ones are a bit sus tho

light needle
#

oh right lol

#

mizzy on motorbikes catThink

inner finch
#

m & m sotrue

light needle
#

motorbikes are p cool imo

#

i wanted to get one

#

but ya know

#

i cant do regular bikes lol

inner finch
#

thonk

#

bikes arent hard actually

light needle
inner finch
#

try it sotrue

#

it'll take like an hour or sth and then ull be zoomin

light needle
#

i did smh

inner finch
#

do it again sotrue

light needle
#

my friends forced me to back in hs

#

was failur

sly thistle
inner finch
#

do it again sotrue

light needle
#

ok

sly thistle
#

Wait John doesn’t know how to ride a bike?

light needle
#

i will try it at some point

inner finch
#

everybody laugh at john sotrue

sly thistle
#

Lmao

#

Damn

#

I didn’t know some people didn’t learn how to ride a bike

#

Don’t they teach you at school

light needle
#

I take pride in the fact that i can make ppl laugh at me

inner finch
#

sus

light needle
#

half my personality is being so dumb with everyday things that its funny

neat lintel
#

I can't ride bikes because of the gears

narrow rock
#

what

light needle
#

I have the perfect sol actually that makes perfect sense

#

@inner finch ur gonna have to teach me how to bike

narrow rock
#

there's nothing to teach

#

just sit on the bike

sly thistle
#

They made us ride bikes at school

narrow rock
#

and pedal

sly thistle
#

If you didn’t know how to ride a bike I’d assume you would learn then

velvet dagger
#

Lmao Brofibration

narrow rock
sly thistle
#

Well idk I’m Australian maybe it’s different here

#

They also make it so you have to learn how to swim

#

Idk how some people in America I’ve seen in movies, they’re like “I can’t swim” like is that a thing

inner finch
#

thonk o think

#

just st on the bike and pedal brofib is right

light needle
#

this is a perfectly reasonable solution

#

smh

sly thistle
#

Ok

#

Do u got training wheels?

#

Also put on a helmet

#

Cause ur probably gonna fall

light needle
#

sadge

narrow rock
#

or get a motorcycle

#

you dont even have to pedal

#

ez

inner finch
#

motorcycles are heavy

#

today i was trying to turn the bike around

#

shit took long af

#

probably bcs my dad was in the backseat but sotrue

sly thistle
#

By “bike”

#

Oh

sly thistle
#

Nvm you mean motor bike

cold needle
cold needle
#

how does one conduct themselves during office hours

#

ive never been to them

#

what happens in them

#

i feel like if i go into them now i will just say hello to the professor and then sit down and say nothing because idk why im there

#

what do u do during office hours tutorial pls

torn willow
cold needle
#

um

#

what am i supposed to talk about

torn willow
#

Your doubts?

cold needle
#

oh

#

okay

#

that

#

makes sense

#

um so do i just don't go to them if i don't have a question

torn willow
#

Yea

#

ig

cold needle
#

okay

slim meadow
#

no you can go if you don't have questions too

#

sometimes to listen to other students' questions

cold needle
#

oh

#

ok

velvet dagger
#

I have done that yeah

#

"Yeah I'm just here to chill"

slim meadow
#

or to extend the ideas brought up in class

cold needle
#

ok that sounds good too

#

i was just wondering because ppl say to go to them but idk what to do in them

#

but yes ty for advice all

somber kite
#

I’ve heard it’s good to go to office hours at least once to introduce yourself and make a connection? Is that a good idea?

velvet dagger
#

Very important when you take differential geometry for sure

vivid halo
#

yes

#

absolutely

somber kite
#

Cool

velvet dagger
#

If other people are there observe

vivid halo
#

like the main way I built connections with professors that gave me okay letters as an undergrad was going to office hours or setting up meetings

velvet dagger
#

If nobody else is there ask generic cool questions

vivid halo
#

not necessarily about class material but just to chat math

velvet dagger
#

"What do you wanna cover but not have enough time for?" is a question I just thought of which tbh I should've asked more in undergrad

vivid halo
#

ooh yea that's good

torn willow
#

So, office hours are like this server but better?

velvet dagger
#

I mean depends on the prof

#

Office hours with me are the closest you'll get to eudaimonia

vivid halo
#

lmfao

velvet dagger
#

If you do it with some second rate prof then maybe not

vivid halo
#

I mean the point of office hours is to just socialize mathematically

#

not to get perfect answers to everything you're coming in with

#

if you wanted that you would just read papers and never talk to anyone

velvet dagger
#

Lmao I remember in algebra one time I was the only one in office hours

#

And we were just thinking about simple groups a bit

#

Like A_5 is the smallest aside from Z/pZ

#

What's next?

#

And we were working through some problem

#

I remember I said something clever, I can't recall exactly what it was

#

But I made a good observation and my prof was like ooh nice

#

Feels good man

somber kite
#

Nice

#

Yeah I’ll definitely go to office hours

velvet dagger
#

👍

somber kite
#

I’m going into undergrad this fall

vivid halo
#

lmfao Dami from the mini conference today

#

check this dumb number theory problem out

#

consider ordered factorizations of natural numbers. What proportion of these are palindromic, asymptotically?

#

which proportion are anti-palindromic?

velvet dagger
#

Huh

#

Wait what's our order here

vivid halo
#

I just means like

velvet dagger
#

Because in my mind ordering them excludes palindromes lol

vivid halo
#

for 12 considering (2,2,3) versus (2,3,2)

velvet dagger
#

Oh oh

#

I thought you restricted to ascending

#

For some reason

#

Hmmmmm

vivid halo
#

in the palindromic case the proportion goes to 2/(12-π^2)

#

man I love zeta functions

velvet dagger
#

Nani the fuck

vivid halo
#

if I'm remembering the details it's like

#

assemble the number of palindromic guys into a sequence P(n), form Dirichlet series

#

this resulting Dirichlet series is some explicit rational function in \zeta(s) and \zeta(2s)

#

now apply Wiener-Ikehara