#serious-discussion

1 messages Ā· Page 82 of 1

latent edge
#

use Lagrange inversion theorem

sleek pagoda
#

lol

latent edge
#

no don't pls

static loom
#

let me teach you something

#

premature optimization is the root of all evil

sleek pagoda
#

Ok

#

):

#

what do I do then?

static loom
#

programming is hard enough without creating arbitrary hoops to jump through

solid snow
#

inb4 finds a slower workaround to avoid using 'slow' division

static loom
#

just learn to program in java normally first lol

sleek pagoda
#

Well

#

I kinda want it more for the math

static loom
#

try project euler

sleek pagoda
#

So even if the algorithim is slow

river moon
#

when it comes to programming something it's usually more about the programming part than math part that speeds up things

sleek pagoda
#

I want to try it out

static loom
#

if your solutions are too slow - then you can work on speeding them up as necessary

latent edge
#

you can do some weird stuff like instead of writing if statements, do it as in binary operations. I don't quite remember how does that work but it is efficient

sleek pagoda
static loom
#

likely the solution isn't going to be avoiding division

#

it's going to be some kind of mathematical insight to skip some brute force aspect of your solution

sleek pagoda
#

So is there nothing like the quake algorithim for just plain sqrts?

#

well

#

I guess you could just imput 1/the number you want

static loom
#

there is, it's just newton's method

neat lintel
#

Hello

river moon
sleek pagoda
static loom
#

you're working in Java not C, so I doubt it matters but

river moon
#

at modern cpus the benefit of quake algorithm is probably not even that great, unless you're running it on like a tiny embedded cpu

sleek pagoda
#

Ok well, no matter how bad, terrible or slow it is

static loom
#

I think it does use division

sleek pagoda
#

is there some algorithim like that?

static loom
#

bit shifts to the right by 1 it looks like, that's division by 2

sleek pagoda
static loom
#

yeah, basically you don't know enough programming to realize the solution you are trying to make "better" is misguided and won't help

sleek pagoda
#

I'm not trying to make a better solution now. I guess its now just a arbitrary rule

#

which I realize is dumb

river moon
#

I sullied both javascript and html

static loom
#

shoulda CSS'd whatcanisay

tight comet
#

HTML is a good language

sleek pagoda
#

Ok so like is there an algorithim

#

I know I keep asking this

static loom
#

markup language lol

#

something called an XY problem

#

post the project euler question link

#

and post your current solution that's not working for ya

sleek pagoda
#

What problem

static loom
#

I just came back to see you delete some stuff

#

no idea what you put lol

sleek pagoda
#

Yeah

#

what did you mean about project euler

#

I just posted the code I had

static loom
#

wdym wdim

sleek pagoda
#

Ok the thing I'm doing isn't related to project euler

#

So I got confused when you asked about the what solution isn't working for me

static loom
#

idk thought you were solving some specific problem and wasn't going fast enough

#

idk what you're doing now

latent edge
#

confusion 101

sleek pagoda
#

Yeah

reef carbon
#

@full raven #help-3 locked but jsyk i'm not a guy and don't call me bro

echo tundra
#

She literally mentioned that she's not a guy

#

It literally says she/her on the pronoun star

#

like the small rhombus next to her name

neat lintel
#

i mean

#

all squares are rhombuses but yk

solid snow
#

'so offended'; they just asked you to not call them that

#

does it really matter

echo tundra
#

that one

deep mango
#

Its just that going out of your way to argue with women when they say dont call me bro is very strange

#

It's?

#

Dude

#

Im just gonna ban you

#

Fuck off

echo tundra
#
  1. It's not that weird 2. You could have just asked @full raven
deep mango
#

What an ass

echo tundra
#

and here I thought he genuinly didn't knew

#

welp

deep mango
#

Mfw roles are preuniversity and chess

echo tundra
#

lmfao, I'll just report it from next time

lavish scaffold
#

Is that what those rhombus indicate? Gender

echo tundra
#

More like the pronouns

alpine kindle
#

gender pronouns and communism

quiet geode
#

whomst pingeth

west snow
#

humpty dumpty

bright hill
woven whale
#

HTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETEHTML ISN'T TURING COMPLETE

torn willow
#

Not enough eldritch horror

#

6/10

solid yarrow
#

Why the hate on HMTL?

tepid light
#

😶

echo tundra
torn willow
#

Not enough HTML

#

5/10

echo tundra
rocky shuttle
#

hypertext markdown language catGiggle

lavish scaffold
#

LOL

bright hill
#

@short pumice it's summer so i can kinda just laze around and do math occasionally

short pumice
#

save me from numbers

bright hill
#

I can't

#

They literally everywhere

cursive sun
#

I got an idea for my maths project. Can yall judge it if its good or not?

neat lintel
cursive sun
#

No, no. I just wanted you all to check whether my project idea is good

cinder zephyr
#

just say the idea bruh

fair mural
solar hawk
#

Just write it in

#

Lmao

tepid light
#

can i ask to ask

tame wyvern
#

what if someone then asks to ask to ask

#

thus the natural continuation is someone asking to ask to ask to ask

#

etc

long matrix
ocean harbor
#

lol

obsidian reef
#

when is r/math coming back :(

#

this is killing me

alpine kindle
obsidian reef
#

i wish they had held a poll for the subreddit before making the decision

modest rune
#

I think many subreddits held such polls and for the most part people were in favor

#

I'm not aware of any subreddit that held such a poll and didn't end up going dark?

obsidian reef
#

stardew valley held a poll and stayed open

#

or at least, i think some subreddits held a poll and elected to stay closed for a few days

#

math is closed indefinitely

#

i just don’t appreciate that they made the decision unilaterally

modest rune
#

I think they made the right call and I think they are doing a good thing

#

I get that its like, minorly inconvenient to not get r/math content for a few days

#

but honestly it seems strange to me to act like its a huge sacrifice

#

esp given that its protesting very bad changes to reddit

obsidian reef
#

the argument goes both ways

#

subreddits that almost no one cares about also have basically no effect on the protest

#

so yea no one rlly cares about r/math and it also has a negligible effect on reddit’s decision

#

i’m just saying i wish it would stay open

#

and considering that most subreddits have returned to normal operation means it matters even less

alpine kindle
neat lintel
#

what is

#

$$1.01^{365} = ?$$

fathom swallowBOT
#

brandon_hu

neat lintel
#

what is $$1.00^{365} =?$$

fathom swallowBOT
#

brandon_hu

modest rune
#

I think you'd be hard pressed to argue that they have any better way to protesting

#

the point of the boycott is that the more subreddits go dark, the bigger the cumulative damage done to reddits revenue and image

solid yarrow
#

Why is r/math closed?

obsidian reef
#

i just think their maximal effect isn’t very much, which corresponds to the fact that there are few people who care about the sub

modest rune
#

sure but its probably worth doing

#

given that they don't have a better option

obsidian reef
#

well i wish they would have consulted the users before making that decision on our behalf

modest rune
#

again but its not for you

#

its not on your behalf

obsidian reef
#

it affects all of us

modest rune
#

you are the benefactor of the unpaid labor of all the moderators on r/math

obsidian reef
#

most other subreddits did consult us

modest rune
#

whose moderating tools are being removed by reddit

#

this is like the most transparently self indulgent whining

obsidian reef
#

didn’t reddit say they were making exceptions for mod tools?

obsidian reef
modest rune
#

they've given no explanation of how that could possibly work in practice

#

that was just descriptive

obsidian reef
#

ok bro

modest rune
#

the issue is that a lot of the mod tools are built into secondary reddit clients

#

which reddit does intend to squash

#

so the only option would be creating new, mod-tool only clients

#

which means more people doing more free labor on reddits behalf

#

like reddit only exists because thousands of people are creating content and moderating it for free

solid yarrow
#

Why is r/math closed? thonk

modest rune
#

lots of subreddits went private to protest reddit api changes

solid yarrow
#

What does that mean?

#

Api changes?

modest rune
#

Reddit is basically hurting users in an effort to profit slightly more

#

theres a lot of 3rd party tools that improve the reddit experience

#

and reddit is making it basically impossible to create and run such a tool

solid yarrow
#

So r/math decided to go dark?

#

As a protest?

obsidian reef
#

unfortunately :(

solid yarrow
#

Weird.

obsidian reef
#

ikr

solid yarrow
#

Like I see both sides, but the situation is... weird.

obsidian reef
#

@modest rune are u a mod on reddit btw

modest rune
#

nope

modest rune
#

the moderators are reasonably protesting a change to the way reddit and moderation work

obsidian reef
#

bro said there’s no both sides in an argument

modest rune
#

and reddit is being intransigent

#

and i guess some users are complaining about not using reddit for a few weeks

solid yarrow
#

But as a company, you need money.

#

You need to see both sides.

#

Even though it's truly sad, that such goal leads to such thing.

obsidian reef
#

some people really feel entitled to free content :(

#

everybody wants something for nothing

solid yarrow
#

Welcome to the 21th century.

obsidian reef
#

amen

solid yarrow
solid snow
#

It’s called a community

solid snow
#

The company and servers could run for less than the arbitrary profit margin that they want to upkeep

solid yarrow
#

Money rules the world. Sad but true.

solid snow
#

I mean that’s not really a reasonable ā€˜side’ of the argument, it’s just flat out greed

#

At the cost of the users who use the service

obsidian reef
#

it’s less of ā€œi want them to have moneyā€ and more ā€œit’s reasonable action for them to takeā€

#

ie ā€œit shouldn’t be a surpriseā€

peak tide
#

that's the tradeoff you make when you sell part of the ownership of your company... obviously they're gonna want a return on their investment

obsidian reef
#

yes definitely. reddit was a money loser for a while was it not

solid yarrow
obsidian reef
#

it’s saddening how selfish some of the users are

#

but oh well

solid snow
#

…the users are selfish?

peak tide
#

providing free content isn't my definition of selfish..

obsidian reef
#

they really expect reddit to continue hosting all this stuff at a loss

#

unreasonable imo

solid snow
#

They are literally what constitute the site as a whole

obsidian reef
#

not anymore

solid snow
#

Not anymore as in years

obsidian reef
#

yeah because of the ads

peak tide
#

there are ads on reddit?

solid snow
#

What does that have to do with introducing policy that’s harmful to its userbase

#

How are these things related

obsidian reef
#

cuz the third party apps used the api to bypass the ads

#

so users were getting ad free content

#

thereby losing money for reddit

peak tide
obsidian reef
#

true true but this takes a big step in solving the problem for reddit

solid snow
#

Is there even reasonable statistics to suggest that the majority of the userbase was using third party applications

#

and not the basic reddit app

bright hill
#

ok, sry

#

I shouldn't be flippant

#

but you could argue by that same logic that no one should vote

solid snow
#

It wasn’t just small subreddits though

#

I don’t even use reddit at all but any time I tried looking up any info about a topic the corresponding subreddit would be private

obsidian reef
#

yes it makes sense for those subs to go private

#

but r/math less sense

obsidian reef
#

i’m just tryna discuss

solid snow
#

Isn’t r/math pretty big?

obsidian reef
#

yea but very few active users

#

it got like 15 posts a day

bright hill
loud snow
bright hill
loud snow
#

Protesting to an uninteresting population make them aware of the issue but they dont care for advocacy so it just irritates everyone and nothing gets done

#

It just stops most people from prefixxing reddit in their search inquiries and lowers traffic to the website

obsidian reef
#

is that how u go about ur day

#

besides it wasn’t just u it was also that max fellow

bright hill
#

but only because I interact a lot more with friends and family

loud snow
#

So you are stupid and im sorry

bright hill
#

I relized I was being rude almost the moment I sent the message

#

I should've rephrased instead of just keeping it there holoApple

loud snow
bright hill
#

that would server literally nothing lel

modest rune
#

Its not just bad for users but bad for reddit too

#

and reddit has a terrible track record with trying to make itself profitable

zealous garden
zealous garden
#

Yes it's a joke

bright hill
trim vessel
#

hey msg me if you can join a server for a few min am trying to find something in it but cannot access server

hardy vessel
#

yea seems like there's a few problems on discord's part atm

#

got disconnected from here for no reason

zealous garden
rocky shuttle
#

delete it

stone ferry
zealous garden
cloud needle
#

@wind epoch hey i saw you closed your help channel, if you find out the proof for the even case let me know

#

im curious

wind epoch
#

Alr.

cloud needle
#

thanks

wind epoch
#

I've posted here as well

cloud needle
#

oh sweet

lime finch
fading zealot
#

It blows my mind how we as humans have such a hard time building intuition about how long the circumference of a circle is, like I know it's more than three times the radius but every time I measure it directly my brain tells me ā€œsurely it can't be that longā€

fading zealot
#

Actually I'm quite curious about that, in what age do children start develop intuition about parabolas

south kelp
#

cannot confirm often play fetch with dog indoors and hit shit all the time devastation

fading zealot
#

Like if they were asked to draw how a thrown ball would fly

loud snow
#

Think about modeling catenaries for example

#

We can also assume that the models atleast visually are polynomial, but this isnt true

loud snow
#

People arent born knowing geometries

south kelp
#

what if they have some knowledge on that before they can even draw Edit: Dumb

#

anyways fwiw kids start to learn how throw at 18 months according to internrt

loud snow
#

Learning to throw is unrelated to geometry

long matrix
south kelp
#

but yeah they could just watch how others throw balls

long matrix
#

If apollo dev isn't downright lying, which it doesn't appear to me, at least, then there are glaring problems with what Reddit is doing.

For one thing, it seems they are being anything but transparent about this process.

#

Whether or not this change is for the better, that's a huge concern to me.

#

And "just monetisation" doesn't explain away the accusations made in that thread. The key point is the numbers are unreasonable. Someone's lying here.

More than one 3rd party dev has spoken out. As well as a bunch of communities from the blackout.

static loom
#

I don't like reddit, so I'm fine with them destroying their own platform

#

although I have a feeling not much will change tbh

tight comet
#

lemmy isn't working out though

#

So if there is another social media exodus

#

it will be quite fractured

#

for like 30+ years there has been no google alternative

#

TBH I think there is now

#

I don't think there's any real alternative to reddit now

#

So for as long as that is true

#

They don't need to listen to any demands

obsidian reef
#

finally

#

this is literally my thought process

long matrix
obsidian reef
#

?

#

y is everyone so hostile

long matrix
#

I find it fairly hard to sympathize with self-centred individuals.

#

I've been inconvenienced myself with private subs, but it's not like I can't understand why this is all happening or what the point is.

obsidian reef
#

o yea i mean i understand the point

#

i just don’t like the point

obsidian reef
echo tundra
#

NO

long matrix
#

well allow me to be self-centred and be hostile to self-centred people sotrue

#

no forgiveness

echo tundra
#

May god forgive you cause we won't sotrue

severe swallow
#

when is "so that" vs "such that" used in proof language
I heard one is kinda like "in order to" and the other is "with the property", but I don't remember which is which

torn willow
#

so that feels informal

#

so that is "in order to"

#

such that is "with the property"

cinder zephyr
#

so that isn't really informal IMO

#

I've seen enough of "we prove X so that we can prove Y"

ripe thorn
#

Hi

long matrix
#

not the actual proof itself

cinder zephyr
#

That's part of a proof

#

If it's a more involved one

long matrix
#

Within the proof, I can't see a strict need for 'so that'

long matrix
#

i dont feel like its a part of the mathematical aspect

#

Whereas "such that" often is

#

informal might not be the word, but I think the 2 are generally used in different contexts

neat lintel
obsidian reef
#

what is wrong with this place

neat lintel
obsidian reef
#

how does one go through life thinking this is a valid comparison to make

#

jesus christ

#

don’t u think a line has been crossed when comparing a subreddit closing and the enslavement of millions and millions of individuals?

eager reef
#

Yeah that comparison definitely crosses a line regardless of my opinion of the discussed topic

daring dagger
#

Probably people could whine for what they can't control and what has been unilaterally decided by the mods and there could be inconveniences due to it

#

But honestly different story for whether the decision by the mods were just

#

It could be one supporting points of whether the users of r/math actually wanted the server to shut down, though

#

And one thing I know is I'm currently very tired to either support or disagree with the mods' decisions there because it's time to sleep for me

#

Goodnight

solid yarrow
#

What are some pens you recommend for doing math?

daring dagger
#

Any pen and paper you're confortable with writing things I guess...?

solid yarrow
#

Yeah just wondering. Mine smears so I'm looking for something better.

daring dagger
#

Might be your paper issue

#

What kind of writing tool do you use?

#

When I was in highschool I used a mechanical pencil named Graph gear 1000

#

I use my tablet nowadays though

stone ferry
#

so you can erase it

daring dagger
#

Yeah

#

Erasability is definitely a factor

#

If you do have to use ballpoint ink pens I kind of recommend PILOT FRIXION

solid yarrow
#

Why's that?

daring dagger
#

Can "erase" with the back of the pen

solid yarrow
#

Hm.

daring dagger
#

The ink becomes transparent when you apply heat by friction with the back of the pen

#

Any erasable pen is fine I guess if you're not writing important documents

#

It's just the first pen that came up to my mind was frixion

#

Or you know

#

Just use a pencil

solid yarrow
#

And what would you recommend for important documents like exams?

daring dagger
#

It's kinda annoying though but yeah better than your answers getting erased

solid yarrow
#

Hm.

#

Should I look out for specific attributes for the black pen?

#

Like line strenght etc.?

daring dagger
#

Idk about that much but I guess how the ink comes out of the pen could be important

#

For example SARASA ballpoint pens were usually wetter than Jetstream when I used it

#

Could be different for what your pens would be

solid yarrow
#

And how do you avoid those ink blobs? Like you write and suddenly the ink flow is stopped and you get this one big smear.

#

Is this a pen problem or am I doing something wrong?

daring dagger
#

Yeah that's probably an issue of the pen and the paper

#

Use a drier pen

#

The drying speed of the ink is the issue if I'm correct

solid yarrow
#

I'll look out for one. Thanks for your help.

daring dagger
#

Idk what pen you're using but I guess it's generally pen issue

neat lintel
#

2 + 2 = 22

#

*"2" + "2" = 22

stone ferry
#

pen issue

rocky shuttle
echo tundra
#

discussy moment

alpine kindle
#

@onyx holly gender is not the same as sex
gender is neurological while sex is physical
gender dysphoria is where an incongruence between them causes discomfort

#

you can change sex characteristics through surgery/hormones
you cannot actively change gender (as far as we know), though some people's gender is fluid and changes without input

stone ferry
#

I bet someone can probably change their gender at will

alpine kindle
#

also @onyx holly i apologise for calling moderators
at first glance your message looked a lot like the hateful shit matt walsh fans spew but i can see that it is not

cerulean quiver
#

Moral crusader

halcyon lichen
alpine kindle
#

this is a good thing

#

matt walsh is a horrible person

cerulean quiver
#

Yes, restrict information, everyone knows the only way to defeat an opponent is to pluck your eyes out

halcyon lichen
#

aint no way udk who he is
he was all over the internet abt 1 month ago

#

based

#

bruh šŸ—æ

#

šŸ¤“

cerulean quiver
#

I only know who because my brother told me

halcyon lichen
#

good 4u man

#

politics is a shitshow

#

clowns on both sides

cerulean quiver
#

Great things can be achieved if you ignore American socio cultural situations

halcyon lichen
#

no use exploring that field

cerulean quiver
#

Indeed

cloud needle
alpine kindle
#

transgender people have existed forever
they were the spearheads of the stonewall riots for instance
and there is evidence from much earlier even but you'd have to ask people studying that facet of history for specific examples

#

it is not a craze

cloud needle
#

there is plenty of history of a wide spectrum of gender identity and expression, especially in non western cultures

cerulean quiver
#

Can't tell if I am eastern enough to comment

cloud needle
#

lmfaoo

alpine kindle
#

there are also neurological research papers about transgender people but again
i am not a neuroscientist
ask a neuroscientist working in that area

alpine kindle
cerulean quiver
#

Define gender

cloud needle
alpine kindle
halcyon lichen
#

yea ur gonna get banned bruv gg

alpine kindle
#

people in most countries do get a gender assigned at birth

#

on their birth certificate

#

yes

cloud needle
#

yes, because gender is socially constructed around biological sex

bright hill
alpine kindle
#

it's assigned almost always based on sex

bright hill
#

that's like

cerulean quiver
alpine kindle
#

gender is NOT a social construct

bright hill
#

who's given a platform to air their opinion

cloud needle
cloud needle
alpine kindle
#

wakebloom you are wrong please stop

cloud needle
#

and since gender norms vary by culture and time period, it is quite difficult to concretely define

#

really?

alpine kindle
#

yes

cloud needle
#

can you explain?

alpine kindle
#

i am transgender

cerulean quiver
#

I sorta figured

cloud needle
#

awesome!!

alpine kindle
#

this is not because i violate social norms or whatever

cloud needle
#

nono

#

sorry

#

bad phrasing

alpine kindle
#

this is because my brain actively conflicts with my physical sex

cloud needle
#

rightyes

cerulean quiver
alpine kindle
#

there is no social construct

cerulean quiver
#

Enough beating around the bush, buttercup, WHAT IS YOUR GENUS??

cloud needle
#

i mean

#

gender norms are 100% socially constructed

#

im not trying to disagree with you tho

cerulean quiver
#

Why view social construction as separable from biological circumstance

#

Yet to understand that.

cloud needle
#

ive talked to many of my trans friends about this extensively as well, i dont want this to come across as an uninformed opinion

#

but again, i may be phrasing things wrong

cloud needle
cerulean quiver
#

But why

#

And how

alpine kindle
#

i think that's a reasonable definition

cerulean quiver
#

That is something entirely defined by what it corresponds to

#

How do I know it exists in of itself?

cloud needle
# cerulean quiver But why

if not, social construction will be based on one's assigned gender at birth and will not allow for the existence or acceptance of transgender people

long matrix
#

big words im seeing here wg

cerulean quiver
alpine kindle
#

ok <@&268886789983436800>

cloud needle
#

...

echo tundra
cerulean quiver
#

Neuroscience is after all a relatively new frontier.

echo tundra
#

Like religion or even atoms sotrue

cerulean quiver
#

Why do you hate atoms

echo tundra
#

We should only do things we really understand lmfaoo

solid snow
#

I’m vacuuming my house rn

cerulean quiver
alpine kindle
cloud needle
#

it may not be demonstrable to you but gender dysphoria is surely demonstrable to the people who feel it

neon tundra
#

Gone.

hollow sundial
#

ty @alpine kindle for trying. that person's just too ummm brainwashed?

alpine kindle
#

it is not a hypothetical or whatever

cloud needle
#

thank god

alpine kindle
#

thanks tropo ā¤ļø

echo tundra
hollow sundial
#

can't spell demonstrable without demon

cloud needle
#

pri demon th

cerulean quiver
hollow sundial
#

aurum works for satan confirmed

echo tundra
alpine kindle
#

aurum i cannot demonstrate it explicitly

cloud needle
cerulean quiver
#

But I don't see how it's related.

alpine kindle
#

nobody uses string theory

cloud needle
#

i use it on a day to day basis sotrue

#

i love this emoji sotrue

hollow sundial
#

does tying your shoes count

cerulean quiver
echo tundra
#

proof

alpine kindle
#

string theory is a shit example

cerulean quiver
#

It's literally called a theory

halcyon lichen
#

this convo is getting dumber by the minute

cerulean quiver
#

That makes it better

echo tundra
#

discussy moment

alpine kindle
#

aurum the main one is like

#

emotions in general

echo tundra
alpine kindle
#

or actually you know

hollow sundial
alpine kindle
#

the existence of subjective experience

cerulean quiver
hollow sundial
cloud needle
alpine kindle
cloud needle
#

or are you talking like actual neural pathways or chemicals

#

in which case, the same would apply for humans we just havent gotten there yet

solid snow
#

Free thinkers when I tell them to experience a new emotion

cerulean quiver
alpine kindle
echo tundra
#

Honestly you can experience a new emotion just not be able to describe it

solid snow
#

Sign that you should read and write more

alpine kindle
next schooner
#

🟩

cerulean quiver
#

Just how subjective is identity though...

next schooner
#

checkmate brain theorists

cerulean quiver
#

Isn't that the final question here?

next schooner
#

what could possibly be more subjective than one's own personal identity lmao

alpine kindle
#

yeah

cerulean quiver
#

It's certainly very subjective, but how subjective is it?

echo tundra
alpine kindle
cerulean quiver
#

Because no matter how subjective your sense of identity it has to have been inspired by an external source, no? Even if a particularly unique combination.

alpine kindle
#

going back to gender

cerulean quiver
#

Isn't this why most people who are confused about their gender tend to believe they should generally be the opposite gender, since that is their only example of gender?

next schooner
obsidian reef
cerulean quiver
alpine kindle
#

you can feel gender dysphoria and incorporate that into your identity

next schooner
#

ok...?

alpine kindle
#

that's entirely internal

next schooner
#

I don't really see what point you're getting at

#

How I percieve myself is between me, myself, and I

#

External factors influence this, sure, but these factors are ultimately filtered and interpreted by me

cerulean quiver
#

And you are a compound solely of external factors...

next schooner
#

Ok sure

#

But this is a weird philosophical line of discussion that I don't really see the point of

#

What are you getting at

cerulean quiver
#

Tbf, separating sex and gender was also a weird line of discussion

#

I'm primarily curious

#

It's my main question too

next schooner
#

Why sex and gender are distinct?

cerulean quiver
#

Yes

alpine kindle
next schooner
#

Why wouldn't they be distinct?

#

Let's take an example

#

An example that I do not expect to reflect at all the genderqueer experience, but rather the separation between physical reality and self-perception

cerulean quiver
#

I agree with that premise of course

next schooner
#

Alright

cerulean quiver
#

But sex is inherently defined hormonally

next schooner
#

Sex is perhaps not so easy to define as you may think

#

But that's besides the point

cerulean quiver
#

Go on

alpine kindle
#

yeah sex is weird as well

next schooner
#

Even if we could 100% definitively define sex

cloud needle
alpine kindle
#

probably not as complicated as gender

#

sex can be changed
this is besides the point

next schooner
#

Why should our ability to make this definition impact on the validity of one's personal experience

cloud needle
#

i agree

next schooner
#

Or, rather, their identity

cloud needle
#

you shouldnt have to justify your own identity

#

it is unfair to ask that of someone

next schooner
#

Indeed

cerulean quiver
cloud needle
#

i have never had this discussion with mathematicians before, but the real world works differently than math does

cloud needle
cerulean quiver
#

Well it's true...

#

It's a chromosomal factor I didn't include

next schooner
#

Well yeah this is a good reason why hormones cannot alone be a defining feature of sex

#

Chromosomes contribute, sure

alpine kindle
#

they aren't everything

next schooner
#

But again, not as much as you might think when it comes to the expression of phenotypic "sex" traits

alpine kindle
#

there's also primary and secondary sex characteristics

cerulean quiver
#

It's a contributing factor ofc, along with hormones.

next schooner
#

Yeah absolutely

alpine kindle
#

but all these things are separate to gender

next schooner
#

If you are interested in the biology of it

#

There is much literature on this

#

As with any definition, one needs to think about what purpose this definition is going to serve

cerulean quiver
next schooner
#

This is why there are countless proximate definitions of sex just within biology

#

For example, a simple chromosomal definiton of sex does not sufficiently serve to determine whether any two individuals can procreate

next schooner
#

The causes are proximate and poorly understood

alpine kindle
next schooner
#

It may be that some transgender individuals suffer from some hitherto unknown neurological condition that causes feelings of dysphoria

#

It may be that other transgender individuals do not

alpine kindle
cloud needle
#

also just cause people should be free to identify themselves without needing to justify it based on their brain chemistry

#

yeah some trans people don’t have gender dysphoria

next schooner
#

Yeah I mean I think this is what it boils down to

cerulean quiver
#

It feels to me identity has always been a subject of scrutiny

#

And questioning

alpine kindle
#

identity is just

cerulean quiver
#

I don't really see any reason we shouldn't question this on principle at least

alpine kindle
#

really messy

cloud needle
#

prescriptive definitions of personal identity are lame in general, especially with something like this that is so important

cerulean quiver
#

I mean in the end you can always say "I am X" and you will find at least 1 person with a sound critique on why X is bad

next schooner
#

Eh

#

I mean

#

What you mean isn't entirely clear to me

#

Identity has always been questioned, yes

#

But this doesn't mean it's a good thing that we should continue

cloud needle
neon tundra
#

It's a difficult question to discuss, because some transpeople do insist very hard that their experienced gender is due to objective physiological facts about their brain -- a position that if nothing else nips the attack "you could just choose to conform if you wanted to" in the bud.

cloud needle
#

i don’t get the point

lime finch
#

not enough studies on ROGD tbh

cerulean quiver
next schooner
#

To question what

#

Other peoples' identities?

cloud needle
#

question someone’s personal identity?

cerulean quiver
#

Yes.

next schooner
#

Why?

#

What business is it of yours?

cerulean quiver
#

What business of mine is it not?

cloud needle
#

???

next schooner
#

Why should other people have the right to freely question the contents of my own mind?

alpine kindle
lime finch
cerulean quiver
#

Behaviour is questioned

#

Actions are questioned

lime finch
#

how people act on a societal level very much impacts everyone

cerulean quiver
#

Ideas are questioned

next schooner
#

Yes but we generally afford people the right not to have their minds read

cerulean quiver
#

Why? That's entirely arbitrary.

next schooner
#

I mean

cloud needle
#

so at the end of the day you want to push back on gender nonconformity?

next schooner
#

If you sincerely believe that nobody has a right to any kind of privacy whatsoever then

#

I mean I don't really know what to do with that lmfao

cerulean quiver
#

I never said interrogate

#

I said question

lime finch
#

wish I could have read the mind of my crush back in highschool

cerulean quiver
#

Insofar this is displayed

next schooner
#

Alright

#

Consider that questions can be draining

#

They can be damaging to the person who is being questioned

#

Why should people have to tolerate other people harassing them with questions about the contents of their identity

cerulean quiver
#

I mean if you're already going for deconstruction of the arbitrary on principle

#

Ethics also fly off the board

cloud needle
#

in this instance, with gender, why do you want to question it??? what behaviors could possibly be harmful

next schooner
#

Deconstruction of the arbitrary?

#

Eh?

cerulean quiver
#

Basically, the previously held understanding of sex and gender is arbitrary, no?

next schooner
#

Which previously held understanding

cerulean quiver
#

That they are inherently tied to one another

next schooner
#

That sex = gender and that both are biological absolutes?

cerulean quiver
#

Yes.

next schooner
#

Right

#

Why does challenging dumbass historical ideas mean we have to do away with ethics

#

lmfao

cerulean quiver
#

Because why is it inherently moral to challenge them?

next schooner
#

Because they're wrong

cloud needle
#

W

next schooner
#

This is literally the scientific process

cerulean quiver
#

Yeah but, so is ethics on the same basis.

alpine kindle
#

they contradict the lived experience of real people

next schooner
#

What does ethics have to do with this at all

alpine kindle
#

yeah that's like

#

not what we're talking about

next schooner
#

Incorrect science should be corrected to the best of our ability

#

The historical understanding of sex and gender was incorrect science

#

You're injecting complexity here where it does not exist

#

The only place ethics enters the picture here is if you want to ask the question of whether it is ethical to continue doing science

#

In which case I don't fucking care about that question lmao

cerulean quiver
#

They are wrong because people's self perception of gender and sex differ. People's views on ethics also inherently differ.
Both of these are fundamentally social constructs.
If then, per say I were to question you on your gender identity, even interrogate. There is nothing but physical boundaries from stopping me.

next schooner
#

ok....?

cerulean quiver
#

As there should be nothing but physical boundaries (i.e physical force) from identifying as what I want to identify as.

next schooner
#

What does this mean

long matrix
#

Stepping away from gender... would you do the same on a person's religion

#

or political position

#

not the same situation, but not a million miles off.

next schooner
cerulean quiver
#

Basically, by the same principle you identify with a gender. I can question you on that gender, irrelevant of its impacts on you.

next schooner
#

Yes, you can

alpine kindle
#

yeah you can

next schooner
#

That doesn't mean you should

alpine kindle
#

why would you

cloud needle
alpine kindle
#

you are only hurting people by doing so

next schooner
#

I can drive my car at 100mph through the front entrance of a shopping mall

cerulean quiver
#

Yeah, but why is that bad, if I feel like it?

next schooner
#

That doesn't mean I should

woven whale
#

what

next schooner
cerulean quiver
#

Yes.

alpine kindle
cloud needle
#

😭😭😭😭😭😭

next schooner
#

lmfao

cloud needle
#

you are DYING on this hill

next schooner
#

Alright okay so the fundamental issue here is that you appear to be an actual psychopath

neat lintel
#

HUH psycopathic behavior

cloud needle
#

screaming crying and dying on that hill

long matrix
cerulean quiver
#

Yes.

next schooner
#

Let me lay down the law here

cloud needle
next schooner
#

You are welcome to think what you like

#

But you are not permitted, on this server, to harm people just because you feel like it

cerulean quiver
next schooner
#

This includes questioning or interrogating people on their identity if they do not want to hear such questions

alpine kindle
lime finch
lime finch
#

yeah that was scary!

woven whale
alpine kindle
#

in general society

#

don't do that

#

that's not permitted in most places

#

for good reason

cerulean quiver
next schooner
#

Good

#

I don't care about your rationalisations

cerulean quiver
#

What I said was fundamentally true, and was using the same logic.

solid snow
#

I mean you can argue something without necessarily holding it as belief

cerulean quiver
#

Indeed.

next schooner
#

I don't give a shit

long matrix
cerulean quiver
#

Well tbh, then you are just being logically inconsistent

#

Which is fine with me.

#

I am just here out of curiosity is all

next schooner
#

My logic is that it is my responsibility to look out for the wellbeing of our users

alpine kindle
#

aurum do you not understand why hurting people just because you feel like it is bad

next schooner
#

Whatever rhetorical nonsense you want to use to justify harming this wellbeing is of absolutely no relevance or interest to me

#

Don't do it and we don't have an issue

cerulean quiver
#

It's not rhetorical though

#

Prove me wrong

#

I don't intend to do it

lime finch
#

aurum what was your argument again

next schooner
#

I will not, because I don't care

cerulean quiver
#

It's a logical inquiry.

cloud needle
#

not everything can or should be rationalized

next schooner
#

I have better things to do with my time

alpine kindle
cerulean quiver
next schooner
#

Incapable of what?

neat lintel
#

Can we ban debate lords

cloud needle
cerulean quiver
next schooner
#

Maybe, maybe not. It doesn't matter because I don't care to try

alpine kindle
#

aurum i literally gave you a 2 line proof

cerulean quiver
cerulean quiver
neat lintel
#

NERDGE Just curious

alpine kindle
#

now go away

next schooner
#

If you want to debate some philosophical point of ethics then you can find someone who wants to do that with you

#

I don't want to so I will not

#

Quite straightforward

cerulean quiver
#

It's logical. But fair enough.

cloud needle
#

logic isn’t always so cut and dry

next schooner
#

It is much more logical for me to get on with my actual mathematics research that I am supposed to be doing rather than waste time debating a random on the internet

#

I've already wasted enough time

cerulean quiver
# lime finch aurum what was your argument again

Gender is subjective. Ethics are subjective.
If we should prioritise subjective identity above all else. I am technically as justified in tormenting others as I am justified in identifying with whatever I want.

next schooner
#

So that is what I'm going to do - ping mods if there are issues.

neat lintel
#

😭 there is an issue tho. bro is debating his right to tormenting others

lime finch
cerulean quiver
long matrix
#

@cerulean quiver idm a philosophical debate

lime finch
cerulean quiver
long matrix
#

and like I said, I don't believe in an objective answer

neon tundra
#

I'm sure there must be an actual nihilism server somewhere where it would be better for this conversation to take place.

alpine kindle
long matrix
#

You cant convince people of most things apriori with purely logic

cerulean quiver
#

If you don't want me to talk about it, I won't

alpine kindle
#

please stop

cerulean quiver
#

Alright, if you guys want me to stop

neon tundra
#

Kindly please with a cherry on top.

cerulean quiver
#

Very well then, Idm

alpine kindle
#

you can read above if you so desire

cerulean quiver
long matrix
#

lazy, no.

cerulean quiver
bright hill
rustic wraith
cold turtle
neat lintel
#

so insane how there's so much talk about a submarine

#

but not the 300 people who died after their ship sunk

zealous garden
#

What ship sunk

craggy gust
#

I've seen a nearly similar sizable conversation for the exact reason of "why does nobody talk about this?" (someone immediately posts about it after)

#

Maybe because people don't generally talk about the thousands of the other tragedies happening around the world every day. Many of us who don't talk about it are distanced from it and it doesn't affect us.

#

always good to create conversation about issues though I think

#

also $$$$

bright hill
half kayak
#

I’m testing out this server’s stickers

leaden torrent
#

or some other spam channel

#

we have three

half kayak
#

My b

leaden torrent
#

oh i guess two you can see

#

still

bright hill
jovial ember
neat lintel
#

i wonder how it is like modding a server with 100k people bleakkekw

jovial ember
#

It’s really great especially when you have way too few mods and then when anyone tries to implement solutions to increase the # of people who can help moderate things the powers that be shut them down because apparently in a server with 150k people only two people are deemed of good enough character or responsible enough to be considered for a mod because I guess mod abuse is something that must be avoided to the extent that you can only have 15 or so mods in a server with 10,000 times that many people

#

Not like I’d know from personal experience or anything

sterile river
#

@opaque fossil

#

Ik of this route (which Im doing rn)
Kinda in order but not sure
-calc 1
-calc 2
-real analysis
-linear algebra
-point set topology
-algebra of some sort (group theory, etc)

#

U don't necessarily need multi calc but I think it helps

#

For lin alg I think proof based is preferred

#

I think u can take functional analysis after that tbh

#

Personally Im just finishing calc 1 and starting calc 2 next week, then my plan is to take multi variables alongside lin alg and then take real analysis next spring.

velvet dagger
#

Better to do linear algebra first

sterile river
alpine kindle
#

it's a joke based on someone a few weeks ago misreading "abelian" as "albanian"

flat harbor
#

abelian nationalism šŸ’Ŗ šŸ‡¦šŸ‡± šŸ‡¦šŸ‡±

neat lintel
#

Feeling unloved, unwanted, and like everyone I’ve been into is incapable of loving me is hard to ignore shortly after a nap where I was down beforehand

#

Maybe music helps

#

Music kinda helps.

#

I make good judgments 😌

south kelp
#

damn that's too real for this server

#

let's think about math instead yes makes world very simple when you ignore your own feelings happy

#

I've been reading about localization hype

bright hill
#

I trust lumin

solid yarrow
#

How do you guys structure your scratch work for doing proofs and stuff?

proven knoll
#

i copy my lecture notes proof and math books proof

neat lintel
solid yarrow
#

Interesting.

neat lintel
#

Yeh, I learned it from somewhere i dont remember

#

It's a brilliant technique, but using it didn't make me any less suck

woven whale
#

@neon tundra wait you have a phd?

neon tundra
#

Yes.
I'm not giving details of the topic (other than it was in theoretical computer science) for self-doxxing concerns, though.

cinder zephyr
#

TCS chad

zealous garden
torn willow
#

Is it fine to describe the subfield?

#

Like cryptography, networking,etc?

zealous garden
#

I can handle the mod pings

woven whale
#

trust

zealous garden
#

I mod for a server with about 2k

sonic prairie
zealous garden
#

Thanks

sonic prairie
#

But still, I don't know why my math teacher hates Topology

zealous garden
#

But topology is cool

sonic prairie
#

He is the Linear Algebra one, who is riding planes

#

I know right

#

And its applications as good as itself

#

In physics

surreal sapphire
sonic prairie
woven whale
compact tartan
#

I'm a mod on an IRC channel of 50 people smug

surreal sapphire
#

"mod"

#

irc only have @ and +

compact tartan
#

the largest IRC channel I modded was about 2000 people

surreal sapphire
#

seems pretty large for irc

#

the only servers of this size i know provide some kind of service with bots and dont have actual chatting

compact tartan
nocturne tusk
#

wow

flat harbor
#

weather is so good today

long matrix
#

lol lifehacks

nocturne tusk
#

weather is nice but when I went out in it I immediately imploded

long matrix
#

i dunt like hot weather

flat harbor
#

theres this guy in a blue shirt styrofoam coffee cup in one hand zooming around talking abt fivepointfivethree percent and business with the government of japan and kazakhstan

nocturne tusk
#

my shoulder started hurting very bad and my tummy started to ache

flat harbor
#

doctor time

#

go to ur gp time

nocturne tusk
#

it healed when a went back inside

long matrix
#

free health care

#

sotrue

nocturne tusk
#

I think my tummy is just hunger

long matrix
#

the outside is a very dangerous place

flat harbor
#

time to reap the benefits of ur parents taxymoney

nocturne tusk
#

but I also just have no appetite

flat harbor
#

try eating jelly

rigid lion
#

Jelly get in my belly catKing

flat harbor
#

like nutrient filled jelly

#

u need nutrients to function

#

i can confirm this depressing fact

rigid lion
flat harbor
#

maybe im tired of hunger migraines

#

maybe im tired of feeling fucking dizzy half the day

#

@mental stratus im here

#

no slowmo in this country

nocturne tusk
#

I don't want eat...

flat harbor
#

yea neither do i but we cant all do what we want now open up sweetie eat ur vitamins

tight comet
nocturne tusk
#

sounds alright

tight comet
#

awwwww

#

But it lessens the chance we'll meet

nocturne tusk
#

how

neat lintel
#

Maybe all the discussion channels should have 30m slowmode

mental stratus
#

sup luvvers

nocturne tusk
#

hii

mental stratus
#

hmm

mental stratus
#

think i know you

rigid lion
#

This is me frfr

tight comet
nocturne tusk
#

looking good > being healthy

neat lintel
rigid lion
neat lintel
#

being healthy means you can do things

nocturne tusk
#

its not that tho I just have no appetite

mental stratus
#

neither do i look good nor am i healthy

nocturne tusk
neat lintel
#

they aren't interesting

nocturne tusk
#

so be it

neat lintel
#

D:

tight comet
neat lintel
#

i wish i could stop being such a degenerate

nocturne tusk
#

no there is already food being prepared

solid snow
nocturne tusk
#

I don't want it but I must

neat lintel
#

but ye

#

not true

solid snow
#

Ye

nocturne tusk
#

katie is sexy and interesting and cool

cyan goblet
#

@flat harbor do u know anything about complex manifolds

#

and if so can u tell me if they are cool

#

because they sound cool

neat lintel
rigid lion
neat lintel
#

first step is self-beleif

rigid lion
neat lintel
cyan goblet
#

aha

#

aha aha

neat lintel
#

FAKE NEWS

cyan goblet
#

we got some comedians in the chat today huh

#

some real funny guys

neat lintel
cyan goblet
#

some jokesters in the chat

rigid lion
mental stratus
#

@flat harbor tell me about complex manifolds too

#

i wanna hear it

rigid lion
mental stratus
#

out of yo mouth

cyan goblet
#

blo ā¤ļø dont talk to pika ā¤ļø

neat lintel
mental stratus
#

no, blo talk to both of us

neat lintel
#

šŸ˜”

rigid lion
cyan goblet
#

no only talk to me upthumbs