#study-discussion
1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)
I've opened it for now to people with specific roles (Honorable, Helpful, Very Active) for the pilot, but the intention is to open it soon to everyone, once the tone of the channel is set.
I'll start us off with a question! How do y'all tend to take notes during math lectures?
Personally I tend not to take notes because I feel like following along with full focus is more helpful, but I've noticed people have a lot of different strategies
write down everything the prof writes down, plus anything remarks I think are relevant or useful to know
I dont, I think it just distracts from listening to what the lecturer is saying.
Uness it's a talk or something where I couldnt have done the reading before hand, but even then I typically just take down some interesting remarks or ways of looking at the problem
I want to try to write a lot less next year though. I've come to notice that I lose track of the lecture quite fast if I'm trying to keep up with the pace sometimes
I think it'll be more productive to try writing only key ideas down, instead of everything
Hmm I guess it's kinda tricky with math though because if you write down the important theorem without any of the context you might not be able to tell afterwards what the theorem even means...
key definitions, ideas in proofs, etc
and very rarely if ever have I went back to look at notes ive taken for anything besides an interesting remark, so theres also that
but not all the dirty details
The context is what I like to take
I can find the theorems carefully stated in the textbook or the paper if thats what I need, the context and lecturers perspective I cannot
i take notes on a tablet, depending on the lecture i either take everything, just big ideas, or nothing. i find that lectures where i take nothing i remember the least and lectures where i take everything i process the most.
i hear a lot of people say that taking all notes distracts them from the lecture, so often what i do is i make lots of space for myself to go back later and create notes for myself explaining the details of what's happening. so my notetaking is really focused on mechanically copying the essentials of what is written rather than trying to interpret or get every detail, then later i can go back and process and expand a bit for myself.
i need to take notes to keep myself attentive to a lecture, otherwise my attention will drift and i'll space out.
Hmm there are some classes where I will write down everything that's written on the blackboard, but that's only if the prof doesn't post any notes and there's no textbook
I hate those classes
What app do you use to take the notes? Just curious
I just always write everything down. I do this because if I don't I'll zone out. I also rarely ever reread these notes unless there are no other resources to use.
I've never actually gone back to reread my notes
do people write notes with the intention of using them later to study?
I have but I prefer not to. I'm not really making notes to reread so much as to process what I'm hearing.
notein
For my algebra prelim I was told that we were going to be tested on what we covered in the class and what we covered in class was based off of notes our prof used that was based off of notes he got from another professor which was based off of df I think?
It was a weird situation, so I actually ended up following those notes pretty carefully.
yeah same on the rereading and studying. very rarely do i reread, the filling in blanks i mention happens right after lecture or even sometimes during a lull in a lecture
I "reread" other things besides my own notes lol
I do for classes where the prof doesn't post any notes, otherwise I literally have nothing to study off of 
Usually I'll rewrite key definitions, theorems, proofs etc in a nice pretty packet. That's sort of how I reread/review things.
That sounds like a horrid course to take, im praying I never run into this lol
most of the courses i have encountered are like this
there is always a textbook of sorts, so strictly speaking you still don’t need to take notes if you don’t want to
I have a slightly unhinged approach to this, i like to make these slightly horrid looking dense sheers with the important points of the course condensed into a couple of pages
I used to take notes for a few classes, but then I just ended up with like 38 pages used up and nothing learnt
I don't think I've ever learned much during the note-taking process
This is an end of semester pre exam review technique though. Mid semester I read notes before the lectures, go to the lecture (sometimes, oops), then usually reread the chapter of the notes again while doing that weeks homework
it's always afterwards when I go over the material again and/or do problems that I find myself learning
Make it prettier, don't be cringe.
The density works for me, it is a concious choice
I'm only kidding
I print them out and pour over it, but its really the process of making them that I feel helps pre exam
its nice to redo everything with the full context of the course
I think this is effectively the same thing I do as well except more dense and in a different format.
I can see a tradeoff here that might be good for certain types of review
I have a horrid attention span and I feel like I actually just end up reading more when I have a wall of text, potentially a very me thing but it seems to work
i dont think i can physically read a huge wall of text anymore
like, my eyes always move somewhere else for a split second and i lose where i was 😔
🔥
Question, regarding note-taking (for those who do take notes): do you later read said notes, at home for instance?
Why am I asking this? I've never done that; the fact of writing the stuff was typically enough for me to remember it, and studying was done through exercises
For classes where the profs didn't post notes, I def read the notes later while doing the exercises because otherwise I would have no way to find the definitions, theorem statements, etc. (or at least the versions that we covered in class)
I never take notes during lectures, because I feel like it distracts me from thinking about what the lecturer is saying. It's not a goal for me to remember everything that is said anyways, as long as I can remember the overall vibes and ideas, then I can look up details in a book or something later
I sometimes take notes in Obsidian when I figure something out that isn't explicitly spelled out in a book, but I rarely look over these notes later
no, and I write notes for the same reason
it just helps me recall things a bit better later on, when I need to solve problems
My note-taking technique is like screaming into the void
I have slowly refrained from taking notes as well, when I'm going through a textbook that is
I just learn the material, then I do the relevant exercises
I used to take a bunch of notes, then I realized I was literally just writing the exact same thing in the book, (basically word for word
) So I just stopped taking notes while self studying
But in lectures... I'm not sure, I haven't attended many good lectures, but I usually find that I struggle to pay attention to the lecturer if I am too intent on note taking, or I struggle to take notes if I am paying too much attention to the lecturer, especially if the lecturer is going at a fast pace
I always tell myself that I'm going to, but I never do 
i tried doing digital notes
like a few months ago
they did NOT work
i think i ended up deleting em since they were taking up onedrive space
onenote is alright as a notes app
but it's just so grating to look at
do u use a drawing tablet?
or like, a stylus + trackpad on a laptop
I have an iPad
Which yes is expensive but honestly worth its weight in gold as far as I'm concerned
With how much I use it
It's all I take notes on, I annotate PDFs on it, I read on it, I sketch out homework and other computations on it
Essential to me
As others similarly remarked, i think taking notes can just be a distraction from digesting the lecture ideas, i rather try to engage and be interactive while only noting down very important remarks, and only after the lecture will i try to write down notes from memory. Luckily it helps that i always had classmates who do write more detailed notes in class, which i can use as a reference haha.
One thing im trying to actively be better at is actually writing notes for myself, i feel like often i end up writing notes as if i'm trying to explain a idea to someone else, or in a way thats understandable for others, when i can be more efficient and try to just remind myself on the topics. Its kinda good practice on formal and clear writing but i definitely overdo it.
I'm gonna write about how silly all of you are in my notes.
i dont learn much in lectures that involve notetaking on my own 
I did this, realized I was copying the book, then continued, since I was writing more explanation when they skipped over a step, and since it had become habit
New channel?
I just solve the problems we do in class
I pay attention and then read the textbooks post-class
Another question. Do y'all take notes in humanties classes? Or pay attention and just read the precribed texts later?
Most of the humanities classes I took involved discussion, so it was more talking than taking notes for the most part
Fair
In my humanties classes, there are a lot of discussions, but they mostly allign with my interpretation of the texts, so my notes tend to be rather terse
Like this sem I took a course on anthroplogical theory and one on critical reading
real credits to Brandon
it seems Emeritus roles can't access this channel, so sadly I can't ping him
I agree with this, for me.
I feel like writing notes during lecture distracts me too much; it just ends up being the worst of both worlds for me.
Stucussion
I like taking notes, and making them pretty. Im quite quick with it, which comes from a few years of experience. I find that it helps me remember the material better
But I understand why it doesn't work for everyone
the same is true for me. i almost never read my notes while i was in college, except for when compiling them for open-note tests and such
I take notes to force me to pay attention
I took very detailed notes while I was taking my grad algebra class and I mainly relied on those because there wasn't a book we were following for that class
new channel!
i’m wondering how do you guys take self notes in cs other than documentation
i use latex but it’s too much work, any other methods
Whenever I try to make notes I just start drawing spirals instead
I mean in high school most of the stuff is just from the book so it isn't that necessary to take notes
don't
just see slidess
the slides are literally generated by ai
they’re too much to read and less information
this is how i self-study the lectures 
Are those the slides or is it your own notes?
my own
the actual lectures they give aren’t that useful
like i said very ai generated ngl
Holy moly
I don't have any suggestions on how to take notes for cs, but I hope you don't try to memorize those validation regexes 💀

lets goooo finally a self study channel
Can't think without writing. So I usually write all the calculations adding in the details I had to figure out
Will also highlight tricks and insights
Ah interesting, I feel like it's harder for me to think while writing, but writing it out afterwards for homework helps me internalize things (usually I realize there's things I thought I understood but don't).
anyone from luxembourg here?if so can anyone show me how 11 grade math looks like there?im kind afraid it will be harder than in my country
You've written this in latex, right? Maybe a stupid suggestion, but since it's mostly code, how about just writing it in javascript files, using comments for explanations? That way you could read it in an IDE, get type hints etc. and it's easier to modify and run the code to see what it does
yes i did write this in latex but i sometimes need read their lectures because they give us multiple choice questions and also it’s helpful for diagrams
i do this but it’s too much and hard to open in other devices like my phone or ipad
so i write them in latex to easy review the stuff
I see. I think learning coding this way sucks, because being able to answer multiple choice questions is so different to being able to actually code. I mean not the way you're learning, just how these courses are set up in general
you're kinda forced to memorize things, instead of just building stuff and playing around with programming
they give us exercises so I get a chance to practice those
sometimes they're useless
yeah
I feel like the next half of js is lowkey cooked 
dom, event handler, forms and node.js
I have an exam about these topics tomorrow and I feel like I'm not getting this shit yet cause professor is replaced by ai and pretends she knows about it. what should I do? I've finished the practice but I don't feel like anything lmao
yeah, channel was created 2 days ago.
its good
maybe some sort of interactive notebook is better to take coding notes? I don't have any particular suggestions just throwing the idea out there
email validation doesn't even look correct
I think it's good enough, it basically matches any string with no whitespace containing exactly one @ followed by atleast one dot. It'll match strings that aren't email addresses, but email addresses can be so complicated that you shouldn't try to match it with regex anyways
For me, I usually take notes in Jupyter notebooks which supports C, R, Python, JS, etc. Beside that, I sometimes make a small project based on the things I've learned in the course, with some comments on my own code.
Although some of my CS classes are syntax- and language- agnostic, so I sometimes write pseudocode as well.
i’m familiar with jupyter notebooks but i didn’t know you could use any language like js
i thought it’s only for python

write one in js 🙂
As long as you have the kernel it's usable
that JS course when they find out about <input type="submit"> and html form validation
What about
^(?:(?:[a-zA-Z0-9!#$%&'*+/=?^_`{|}~-]+(?:\.[a-zA-Z0-9!#$%&'*+/=?^_`{|}~-]+)*
|"(?:[\x01-\x08\x0B\x0C\x0E-\x1F\x21\x23-\x5B\x5D-\x7F]
|\\[\x01-\x09\x0B\x0C\x0E-\x7F])*"))(?:\s*\([^)]*\)\s*)*@(?:(?:[a-zA-Z0-9]
(?:[a-zA-Z0-9-]{0,61}[a-zA-Z0-9])?(?:\.[a-zA-Z0-9]
(?:[a-zA-Z0-9-]{0,61}[a-zA-Z0-9])?)*|\[(?:(?:(?:25[0-5]
|2[0-4][0-9]|[01]?\d?\d)\.){3}(?:25[0-5]|2[0-4][0-9]
|[01]?\d?\d)|IPv6:(?:[A-Fa-f0-9]{1,4}(?::[A-Fa-f0-9]{1,4}){7}))\])$
what does this even match
noted
how did you make this
it took me a whole day LOL

Almost RFC 5322 compliance regex for email matching
the longest regex i've used recently is a thing matching a valid JS import statement
"almost" 
You can find things like https://github.com/brendan-rius/jupyter-c-kernel online
Yeah, unfortunately.
what's the edge case?
I don't think the total thing is suitable for my use cases
i can use vscode
RegEx can't match recursive patterns
Yeah it works with VSC as well
there are a few regex engines that support this actually
i think perl can do it
Regex also cant match HTML
That'd be considered extended regex yeah
LLM's are suprisingly good at making regexes tbh
it’s my last day as doing js(read my status) so i might use other languages with this kernel especially py and julia
It's really unfortunately that RegEx can only match regular languages
Yeah, iirc Haskell is also usable, let me check
Yeah there's iHaskell for jupyter stuff
i’m not sure if i’ll go back learning haskell
Haskell rotated counterclockwise by 90 degrees
worth it? idk
I've also been enjoying Idris as well, in my opinion, 'functional programming' languages are really good to know if you study CS.
ew what is this
C++ is my favorite functional programming language
what's idris?
it's also my favorite dysfunctional programming language
C is my favorite OOP language 
It's like, Haskell but with strict evaluation (optional lazy too), and dependent types.
ah so actual FP
It's also built on QTT (quantitative type theory)
As for side effects, Idris leans more on algebraic effects while haskell uses monads
every channel is #cs-discussion fr
Oh sorry.
oh i gtg in a min 😭 sorry
Oh hey new channel
damn it
woah a new one, good channel premise
Get better at LaTeX
Just use it a lot
And you'll get quick enough
Oh you said CS, well for TCS LaTeX is good. For practical stuff I just pray to god
Let’s gooo it released
Snippet stuff!
I'm already better at latex but it takes some a lot of time
This is one of the things that helped me shave a LOT of time typesetting. Template a bunch of what you commonly use and just store them as snippets in for example vscode
For example, I have snippets for a basic table, plot, floats, etc. That i just use everywhere and modify according to what I need
Had what installed?
latex stuff in vscode
VScode is pretty okay for most of what you would need. Although I wouldn't really recommend using the LaTeX workshop extension
Also, you can also write a python script to generate your latex project
I see
yea I just use Overleaf
I haven't really needed anything beyond what Overleaf provides
I open it up, I type proof in LaTeX, I happy
you hit their compilation time's limit quite fast if you are writing something big though
oh yeah if you're writing something like a book or article that would be a problem
and you'd need to buy premium
and money doesn't grow on trees
so I should set up VS Code LaTeX extensions some time
Never really understood why people don't just run it locally, unless you have a really bad PC or something
I think it's just because most people aren't writing large stuff
I've used to write huge latex stuff in hs and it was so laggy
so I have to make it parts cause I don't have premium
the huge latex stuff in question:
\Huge
real
the extensions are really annoying from my experience. You are better off running it from the CLI using latexmk in my opinion but to each their own
but muh linter
the linter seriously was starting to give me an aneurysm
linting and latex just dont go well together istg
Anyways Latex can get very unproductive and there is no helping with that. I wish there were better WYSIWYG alternatives
typst i heard is getting there
but idk
Have you tried https://www.lyx.org/ ? Somebody here recommended it to me some weeks ago and I've found it to be quite good
is that more convenient than using overleaf? overleaf is free anyways and the cloud storage is nice
overleaf gets really slow for me passed a certain document length
Well the aforementioned limits imposed on you by Overleaf are an issue. Plus, it can get really slow from my experience. Also I just generally dislike their UI; I find it clunky and not really suitable for long-term editing
I have heard of it but I should maybe give it a deeper look
Hm the speed hasn't bothered me
It also now gives you a little instant popup whenever your cursor is in a display mode thing, which is pretty convenient
Oh but if what I am working on is meant to be collaborative in nature I tend to use Overleaf
I haven't really found a better alternative, but im sure there are some vscode extensions for real-time collaboration I dont know about
Thats neat
why I feel like I've seen you before
or could be someone else
probably a random coincidence

yeah sorry they’re deleted user now #latex-help message
i need a book or anything of linear algebra i have a homework about system of cramer and i have some questions
Is this your first or second semester doing linear algebra
I.e., is what you are doing purely computations?
Introduction to Linear Algebra by Gilbert Strang
also
this will be quite helpful in developing geometric intuition about linear algebra
first
thnx !
I like my fancy editor shortcuts
fair lol
Do you use emacs? For some reason I get emacs vibes from you
Holy shit 😭😭😭
Amazing
i don’t really take notes, often because the lectures are following a specific book
not in college for math yet, so i usually just use books for everything and richard borcherds
my computer doesn’t seem that much faster than overleaf in compilation, but snippets and vimtex make it so
I'd definitely write down everything that is on the board, the motivation and remarks the professor just mentions I wouldn't and would just keep in mind
hey serge! how's it going
when do you go to college?
Latex
🙂
Very true
Infinitelty. Overleaf is down all the time, I dont always have internet, I have a shit load of shortcuts in VSCode, I can run terminals right there, I have a PDF viewer, I have a spell and grammar check (which is better than overleafs), etc.
The only things id give overleaf is that you can share documents easily and clicking on the PDF to jump to that part of the code is nice
Perhaps all the time is an exaggeration, but its certainly not uncommon, Ive heard people complain about it a non-negligible number of times
I dont want my ability to do work to be tied to some random service running if I can help it
vimtex has this
I think latex-workshop on VSCode is supposed to have it, but it doesnt seem to work for me
ah weird
Ive never tried to fix it though so its potentially just a set up issue
could be a pdf viewer issue
never used vscode but I would guess it probably doesn't use zathura
(that plugin I mean)
but vimtex + zathura works
it might also be ctrl-click instead of just click or double click
Holy shit
:p
Its a ctrl-click lol
Ive never been super bothered by it because it has a stucture tab, so I can jump to subheadings and stuff, but thats very nice, thank you for helping me realise that. Ive only used VSCode all day every day for the last 4 years
i cant do 678436487 x 618313278101019827381 becouse its 678436487 to the power of 5771828317673877728929.678263178287751
opening this channel to the public was a really good idea
Go ask this somewhere else
right sorry
Did you do only a click? Ctrl + Left Mouse Click on the native PDF viewer allows you to jump to the corresponding latex code.
Oh my bad. Someone mentioned it below your original message already.
I'm looking to get started with studying physics as self-study over the summer break. does anyone have any study methods?
also should I stick with latex or try something else? maybe cause I want diagrams for sure
I'd appreciate any advice
TiZ for diagrams
I mean you can use TiKz but you’ll probably spend a similar amount of time making graphics to actually studying
If all you’re making is study notes, take the cheap and dirty route and just include your hand drawn ones as images
For me, I used Obsidian for note-taking, with a pdf reader that allows highlighting text. All exercises are done in Obsidian, and the diagrams were drawn in TikZ and rendered in Obsidian.
Richard Borcherds! so based
I gotta start watching his algebra lectures
My study methods for studying physics are
learn the contents of the chapter
try to solve as many exercises as possible
repeat
also I don't know if you want to Tikz up diagrams, it will take a long time because espcially in classical mechanics you will be drawing a lot of diagrams when solving problems
But it's so satisfying when you draw a diagram of the problem set up and everything falls in to place 
I had this experience with the loop problem in chapter 7 of Taylor
wheres the experiments ...
so everyones just a philosopher
If you want to go into math/physics in the future, it's prob good to use this as an opportunity to get fluent with latex, I agree with Nope for just hand-drawing diagrams for now
You can insert them into a LaTeX document using \includegraphics
Also LaTeXing up stuff is really fun
I mean you can use TiKz but you’ll probably spend a similar amount of time making graphics to actually studying
I am the evidence.
Yeah or use inkscape, which is the method Matplotlib stands by.
You can get some very professional looking diagrams with inkscape. But I still stick to TiKz for the maximally massochistic experience
Inkscape is also nice if you have some diagrams already in a book and you want to manipulate them, it can extract the vector graphics from a PDF
I’ve been doing that for ZX diagram stuff this semester, because dear Christ those are painful
Even with tikzit it hurts
ZX diagram?
Cause like uhh, I’m not making that myself
Quantum programming stuff, it’s a graphical calculus based on the theory of monoidal categories
I see
Some diagrams I have made in recent weeks
Still trying to correct the arrowhead positioning in the last one, but I have no fucking idea how the code for the arrowheads works 
Arrowheads in question:

But yeah long story short, avoid every using Tikz if you can help it
It’s unbelievably time consuming and unless you’re like writing a paper or a book people will actually read it’s just not worth the effort
Well, Tikz can be incredibly satisfying, at least to me.
So, I think it can be nice if you have the time to spare.
A nice side hobby, if you will.
Yeah it makes beautiful things and if you have fun doing it, go crazy, but if your goal is to study physics it’s probably detrimental
Yeah
I have so much math I want to learn but I'm using a lot of time for tikz 
Learn tikz to illustrate mathematical ideas ❌
Learn math to have more tikz diagrams to draw ✅
grass: I wanna do more math everyday 
also grass: is trying to convince himself that he's not just slacking off by spending time on Tikz all day long 

hestrue
literal addict
tikz isnt that bad
iguess
its better than using anything else to draw it on the computer
inkscape
and smtimes when u import screenshots into latex u just think maybe ill not do latex notes at all
i use it when i need to draw like. curves
but using two apps :( cant do that :(
lmao
im happy with my decently buggy latex snippet thing
Eh. It can be a pretty big pain in the arse
especially if you're trying to do something you're not used to
What’s your opinion on using LLMs to generate tikz diagrams?
does that actually work?
anybody know some good youtube videos to learn basic counting and graphs?
Does it actually generate what you want it to generate? 
or switch to typst
It’s better than starting from scratch atleast
I don’t have other usages for my o4-mini quotas so
It's not very good but as you say it's a great starting point
it sort of works if you yell at it a lot and you manually adjust some of the numbers
as for whether it is easier than doing it completely by hand, ig it depends
I have already gotten help on tex stack exchange
I wasn't asking for help here, just showing the pains of tikz.
How would that help in the slightest
Well, I asked that in relation to diagram drawing.
Does typst have nice vector graphics package(s)?
doing smth new is hard
wow. thats poignant

If you do the same thing on paper, its faster and easier by leagues and miles.
typst is great but for a figure like this you’re gonna be in the shit no matter what
Although, one benefit typst has is if something follows a regular pattern, you can automate it using some of its scripting capabilities. Like using a for loop or something. So in some cases you can greatly reduce the necessary code.
Tikz also has foreach loops 
good to know
tbh I’ve never used tikz for plots.
I’ve just used tikz-cd for commutative diagrams, and the circuitikz and quantum circuit (whatever it’s called) packages
for plots I’m throwing it into matplotlib
@ matplotlib
how do u close a chat from a post?
Just type .close
In the form you want to close
Just as an FYI if you’re not aware of it, tikzit is a nice GUI way to do ZX calc for quantum stuff
Thanks for the suggestion.
And for more circuity stuff, would qiskit not be slightly less painful? Perhaps I just really hate tikz but I will avoid it if I can lol
I had been using quiver for commutative diagrams and doing the quantum circuits by hand
qiskit is good. I should probably use it more often
It makes sense to use now that you mention it. I had been using matplotlib for plots afterall.
But tikzit does look great for general string diagrams
Yeah I found it easier to use for ZX stuff than string diagrams generally, but I haven’t spent enough time learning to use it to be honest.
There’s also freetikz, but I’m so shit at drawing I struggled with it lol
Still it’s a good way to get roughly what you’re after then you can just edit the tikz it spits out
I knew everyone is gonna say tikz
not going into math or physics in the future it's just engineering things in general cause you need physics. also I've used tikz before with math and it's just so painful, takes a lot of time indeed. so I'll keep in mind to draw the diagrams on ipad and make it regular if it's taking too much time for sure
the \includegraphics is what I usually do
like this is fine i guess 
inkscape 🗿
lol yeah I feel like there's no point in learning tikz for this, although you might be able to get chatgpt to generate you tikz code tbh
FreeTiKz could be good if you have a drawing tablet
Possibly better than chatgpt, but i don’t have enough experience with either to really say. It’s rare that I need to do anything more than a commutative diagram, and when I do I usually just adapt stuff I can already find
yeah and there is https://q.uiver.app/ for commie diagrams
A modern commutative diagram editor with support for tikz-cd.
gpt sucks #advanced-lounge message
i tried this but how i can make the object comes a little bit closer
since it won’t let me
hahaha
wdym comes a little bit closer
Learning TikZ isn't that bad. Using it can be a pain though, but I don't think that's specific to TikZ. Creating graphics in general is hard and time-consuming
I don't think learning it is that bad but it's probably pointless if you're not going into math, physics, etc.
I'm guessing if you're going into science or engineering, your time is better spent learning Illustrator/Inkscape
honestly i can’t find it so im gonna move on
dw about it
Probably
But the best is to learn PDF graphics operators so you can implement TikZ stuff yourself
pdfMsym
pdfMsym
pdfMsym
pdfMsym
is making organized calculations important? like when ur doing a math test and the teacher gives you one of those blank sheets, this is how i usually calculate on most questions, id love to hear thoughts
Depends on whether you're handing that sheet in as an answer or it's just for scratch work?
just for scratch work
i see a lot of people online doing super fancy scratch work, so i got curious to see if its truly necessary
If it helps you organize your thoughts, maybe
Else not really, especially if it's scratch work
though even for scratch work, you should make it at least a little bit organized, because I've sometimes done scratch work and come back to it to see that I don't understand anything I wrote 
At the very least, use symbols or arrows to connect one part of your writing to another
please keep it organized, it'll make your life easier
plus when you go to explain something to others you can just use your scratch work to show them which is nice
I think having an organized writing process can also help organizine your thinking about a problem, otherwise you're not really sure what you have or haven't figured out yet
unrelated: I made this monstrosity today while reviewing for a final...
for scratch work, my notes are even messier
for anything I need to hand in, I do all the messy scratch work on a separate piece of paper, and neatly write up the solutions later
Eric hand writing reveal
Hell nah what math topic is this
Same
Looks to be Harmonic anal
^
it is precedented #math-discussion message
you're doing well, buddy. i do the same. Plus nobody gives you credit for calculations, do what floats your boat...
Hey guys, I'm doing cartesian product right now, I'm taking discrete maths.
I might be a little sleepy but...
called a relation
• A={a, b, c} and B={0, 1, 2, 3}, R={(a, 0), (a, 1),
(a,3), (b, 1), (b, 2), (c, 0), (c,3)} is a relation
from A to B
• A x B ≠ B x A
– B x A = {(a, 1), (a, 2), (b, 1), (b, 2), (c, 1), (c, 2)}
Here in the last line, B x A, shouldn't the order of the elements be reversed? B = {0,1,2,3}, so we should start with that no?
And also, why were 0 and 3 not paired? Is there a mistake in the presentation I took this from or?
sorry should this be moved to a help forum?
No selfroles matching studyinf.
See ,selfroles --list for the list of valid selfroles.
very sorry guys wronf channel 🙏
BxA is not that. it is {(0,a)...} and all the elements should be included. Rest however depends on the question configuration.
The slide was misleading
The final line uses the first line's set instead of the second one for whatever reason???
Extremely dumb and took me a while to realize it lol
Yes, this channel is for discussion about study techniques and such
my apologies, first time using this server, i moved it to another channel afterwards. I answered my own question
Anyone using Anki here? I started using it very diligently last semester, but I haven't used it at all this spring. I think maybe because there's less weird stuff to remember in the courses I'm taking now, and I'm trying to focus more on doing exercises instead
I really like it! Haven't used it for math before tho
I know someone here uses it for math...
@kindred vine and @short dirge ?
oh waittt maybe it was swiftee not suremark oops
definitely not me, i don't know what anki is haha
it's a flashcard program lol
ah
I remember there was someone who loved Anki here, I think they were called Pseudo something? Haven't seen them in ages tho
I'm guessing you use it to learn languages?
I need mathematical advice, I'm planning to take the EA exam of the summer July 18th approximately, to take the Algebra 2, I'm currently using Khan Academy, and wondering if it's a smart decision.
I already took algebra one and geometry, and I'm debating if I should schedule the exam, if I don't pass it's on my transcript. https://www.friscoisd.org/departments/testing/home/exam-acceleration
Exam for Acceleration (EA) - Provides an opportunity to earn grade level or course credit in which no prior formal instruction was completed. The EA is designed for a very small percentage of learners who have both the academic and emotional need to advance a course. Exam for Acceleration is not designed for grade level recovery when a student is retained in a previous grade level. Students must demonstrate mastery of 80% or higher on an EA to earn credit.
Thanks to anyone who give me advice.
Could you help please.
yeah and neuroscience terms
@tropic void heyhey
do you have access through a university slash library? otherwise there are a number of math textbooks that are freely available online on the author's webpage
what does the exam get you if you pass?
ohh
Ah yes, that was the name!
I would say typically I read them very slowly, I try to take a little time to attempt to prove theorems myself when I can without looking at the book, I try to make sure to do the exercises, etc
that's in an ideal world, in reality sometimes I just skim books and hope for the best...
it's always nice to read and talk about books with friends tho
For taking notes, I think a good approach could be to reproduce what's in the book, but without looking at the book. Try to write down theorems, proofs and definitions from memory, then just sneak peek at the book if you need to
And it's good to bear in mind that reading a textbook is usually very nonlinear, you need to jump back and forth a lot. Don't be afraid to skip sections you are struggling a lot with, you can just come back to them later
I personally don't really take notes on math texts unless I'm really struggling to recall definitions
Maybe I'll take notes at the end of the chapter briefly on the main points of the chapter as review
the most important part is prob just to go slow enough that you don't trick yourself to thinking that you understand stuff when you don't, but fast enough that you feel like you're making reasonable progress
if you feel like that's impossible, it might be good to just find another book
I get to go to AP Pre-Calc, and a credit for math, but it doesn't count to GPA.
@fleet hill
Please let me know when you come back, thanks!
Exam for Acceleration (EA) - Provides an opportunity to earn grade level or course credit in which no prior formal instruction was completed. The EA is designed for a very small percentage of learners who have both the academic and emotional need to advance a course. Exam for Acceleration is not designed for grade level recovery when a student is retained in a previous grade level. Students must demonstrate mastery of 80% or higher on an EA to earn credit.
wtf is this
can i dm someone my math questions
you can just open a help channel with your doubts
It's not allowed
wdym?
who said that? Why would you not be allowed to open a help channel?
bro you tripping hard
lmao
lmfao
they should learn from me fr fr 
A moderator
He said that this is the best place, and that help is only for math problems.
they weren't talking to you
they were talking to the person looking for help with math problems
oh okay, yeah that seems like a good thing to try for!
what do you think is the issue? like anxiety or not having enough time or something else
No, just lose interest
why do you think that is
Study before the exam season
. Can I have more context
for the long term yeah "study before" is good advice, it's best to review your notes or do some exercises roughly every week during the semester, and on another hand it's normal to feel more anxious or lacking time during exam season
or worn out as well
That's what I do
so I just lose interest during exam season
Start anticipating the new content

Maybe don’t study before exam season and study when exam season starts? A rly bad idea but eh
Very bad idea impo
Well I suggested it particularly because you got bored
During the exam season because of you studying before hand
It's more like next sem is very exciting for me
RA, AA, Dif Geo, Operator theory, probability
And this sem is just calc
so you can understand why I'm bored
Multi calc right
Still study so you don’t bomb exam
yea
I've studied
When is exam
The current time for math_rocks is 08:20 AM (IST) on Tue, 29/04/2025.
I know, but as I've said, I studied,( even yesterday), just with as uch enthu as I would have liked
What is uch enthu
much enthusiasm
holy this sounds so fun
It is
:D
Operator isn't confirmed( There's another course that may win over it)
👀
but diff geo is
What about point set top
I think that will be offered later
I think this is a course specially designed for 2nd years
so is it correct for me to use this channel to avoid studying but instead thinking about how to study?
diff geo of curves and surfaces probably
No that's #「the-obsidian-twink-jesus」
yea
imo
Next sem is 🔥 🔥 🔥
Anyone know where I can go to get a better understanding of the differential operator (d_/dx). I'm just a bit confused on how you can and can't algebraically manipulate them and the reasoning behind it.
Trying to get ahead in school and I've gotten to a bit of a block
Wdym algebraically manipulate ?
🔥 Operator Mentioned 🔥
Like (D^2 + D + 1)f = 0
Like multiplying through by "dx" ? Or do you mean treating D as linear operator
I'm in calc 1 can u dum it down a bit
Wdym
The properties covered in algebra 1 basically
On what
With variables
"factoring out" the derivative is dependent on what d/dx "distributes" over in the first place
i use quotations because we kinda treat the derivative in handwavy ways
so you know functions right? a function is a map f : D --> C, from a domain D to a codomain C, we have something called operators which are basically the same as functions, but the domain now is itself a space of functions
probably still a little too complicated of a way to describe it
the "multiplication" of operators D you've seen is literally just function composition
and taking inverses (that would be dividing I guess)
D (derivative) is a linear operator which means D(cf(x)) = cD(f(x)) and D(f(x) + g(x)) = D(f(x)) + D(g(x)) and prob smth I'm forgetting
nah thats it
okay
Probably taake thiis to a help channel ?no?
anyways, the only special ways that the derivative interacts with a function is the fact its linear
otherwise its pretty normal
function-wise
Alright
normal operators mentioned??!?!? 
every day i wait to eventually study hilbert spaces
idek if i will end up doing so
ig ill see
you will
func anal is SO fun
everyday I too wait to study it
func anal is the highest level of math here at my college
isn't it exam season?
just like in terms of how the classes are numbered
so you will get your wish soon enough
It is, exams end on the 3rd for me
May?
yea
i want this semester to be over so im free from writing papers
But I stay until the 15th 😔
my last exam is tomorrow, after that I gotta grind to get into a good maser's program
man i think i might have to change my secondary major
Good luck! Applying to ISI and CMI I pressume?
you're double majoring?
yup and other institutes as well
writing papers is like the entirety of philosophy and i just cant make myself enjoy it
Awesome! Good luck!
yeah
what are you writing papers on?
im procrastinating on one where im analyzing how Locke counters Descartes's account of rationalism
and how a rationalist might respond to locke
then theres another that ive been working on for months about AI ethics and mathematical logic
Did I share my insane progress with chat? Went from 0 in my first vector calc quiz, to 100 in last 2 ( and almost 100 in the midsem)
ive had huge writers block on that paper for weeks
math + philosophy double major?
im still like 300 words short and its due in a week exactly
yeah though philosophy will prob be a minor
awesome!
or ill switch it
switch to physics
since i want to focus on math
come to physics
no id have to take gen chem 1
nothing is worth taking gen chem 1 again
can't you take an equivalent class to gen chem 1?
i just dont want to do anything of the sort
plus i probably wouldnt like physics very much anyways
ive heard it just lacks a lot of rigor that math has for too long
you would love it
it lacks mathematical rigor yes, but that's because physics' job is to describe the universe, so proof are replaces by experiments
well yeah but i dont care about experiments
experiments are proof that your theory is a correct model of the universe 🔥
erm technically they are just evidence
theoretical physics 
i might do theoretical physics eventually
i think my fall research plans are related to it
but id need to do too much other stuff that i just dont have the will to do
if i switched majors from philosophy id probably switch to percussion performance because ive always loved drumming and playing all the keyboard instruments
plus i dont really have to worry about job security because im pretty sure the industry for math majors is doing just fine
I'm planning to minor in Sociology bad idea?
so i can chill with my secondary area of study
(btw should we take this to advanced lounge)
I did one course, I really enjoyed it
i love how canvas messages you multiple times about grades
i get to see the 78% i got on my hume quiz multiple times
Any number theorist here
@crimson elm
deltoid does number theory?
And anyone who knows a lot about 3d geometry
bestie...
is studying for IMO worth it?
or should I switch to immc and programming
Do whichever one you enjoy more
Learn number theory, Work for the government cracking codes
I think most governments do this no?
I see
what's your question anyway
update: woooo crushed the final!!!
are there any discord servers about numberical optimization
what
I don't know what channel I am typing this in but whatever
theres a channel #optimization here dont know if youve seen that
ure in #study-discussion
Yes
Let's gooo 
if you're looking for a channel here, there's also #numerical-analysis in addition to #optimization
I always wondered, when studying what does everyone use / do with scrap paper? Doing math problems takes a lot of pages.
How do I get used to reading theorms peroperly
at times I think it's iff when it's only in ione direction
Like I did today, which is going to cost me heavily(1-2 marks 0n 60)
hmm, fair
huh?
but when I read theorms at times but brain inserts an iff even if there' s only an if
nvm, wrong reply
Most theorems are pretty clearly stated no?
yea
with what theorem did this happen?
altenating convergence test
I said an alternating seqeunce doesn't converge as it isn't montonically decreasing

which is onviously wrong
you should recall the definition of a series converging, and compare it with that
like -1,1-1,1,1,1,1,... is a simple example
yeah, I know
the divergence test works easily here
the thing is , I thought it was an iff statement
I guess proving it earlier , wouuld have re-enforced that
I'm not sure how that confusion happens
but one thing that can help is
to be on the look out for iff statements, since iff statements are relatively rare
most statements in math are if-then
and the converse is usually either false or only partial converses are available
iffs are rare
you should be assuming the opposite and be surprised when a result is an iff
I think the fact that I didn't bother to prove these played a role
I don't think well under pressure
they are especially rare in analysis
calc 2 class?
yea
yea then dw too much
should though, I've done proof writing ,a did well in taht too
😭
A- in that
This is def a bad sign
very bad sign
same
for what?
I keep a ton of loose scrap paper in my room from various old paper handouts and stuff, then I just write on it whenever I want to write out a problem
can't say it's the best approach but it is an approach... advantage is I never waste paper
fire hazard
okay the pile of scrap paper is not that big
i just buy stacks of printer papers, much cheaper than notebooks
I've got a few notebooks leftover from school cuz I didn't take notes anyway
and maybe a few nice markers that were... unattended to
parhaps abandoned
Any number theorists?
Yes
Doesn't answer back
medium size notbook
I buy cheap notebooks in bulk
i use small notebooks for scrap work or chicken scratch note taking
then LaTeX it up
Wish I had the energy to latex my notes
I tried to just take notes in latex in my first semester
Gave up after a week
I find it fun and helps me find whatever I need
overleaf + table of contents
My alg prof very obviously writes all his class notes on the back of unused exam cover sheets.
Peak
I haven't looked super closely so they might also be old exams
That's why I only use notebook for scratch work
And sloppy notes
who looks back on notes anyways
I rewrite everything in LaTeX anyway
me sometimes
tbf I usually defer to textbook so maybe you have a point
No.
LaTeX good all my homies use LaTeX
Latex is good 👍
Number of people who use typst:
I haven’t heard of typst though
Where the typst visual studio and vim extensions at
Completely unusable
I don't wanna learn helix 😔
hmm
what is the tikz equivalent
nah I tried it and it just wasn't for me
vern noun way more intuitive for me
b
is it as bad as tikz
bruh
im sticking to latex
😎
Skill issue
I type blindly and it always ends up being correct 🗿
I wrote 12 pages of LaTeX for my homework a week ago 😭
Real analysis is hard man
It was 4 problems
My solutions ended up being 12 pages total
Probably can be shorter than 12 pages I think a lot of my classmates did under 10
I mean it would be silly to not use latex
Handwriting that stuff is suicide
I scored among the highest though 🗿
Turn in latex
to show them who's boss
if their standards are low, raise them
What in the name of applied math is that
God I'm glad I never have to take applied math courses
Such a drag
oh
Praying for your wellbeing brother 🙏
ee is almost as hard as pure math I hear
maybe harder
So sweaty
Maybe that's just my uni?
EECS is very sweaty
ee major be like: they gave me a bunch of nand gate transistors and told me to make a cpu
😭
what is engineering math though
is calc 1-3 not engineering math??
Is it diffeqs
They call that calc 4 in my uni
Bruh
Very funny
unfortunate
I was wanting you to suffer with me
I suffer; everybody must then suffer!!
I don't know if I will get the opportunity to learn complex analysis from actual course. There's the complex variables course but the actual analysis is grad level at my uni 😔
and idk if I'm built different enough to be able to do that
How old are you?
Well you don't have to answer lmao
Pretty sure most folks in my phd program are around 24 or older
I am 33 so uhh...
Either you'll be fine (as far as age goes) if you wanna do more or I'm fucked!

1: what is the point of that double major and 6 years of loans vs majoring in 1 and adding courses from the other as you please, especially if you want to do grad school afterwards.
2: many people enter grad school at a later age for a variety of reasons so don't fret about this.
or other way around idk
I mean did single major Math and CS minor and got to cherry pick the CS courses I wanted to do and this worked out well for me
money is a very valid concern
idk, I'm of the opinion that a double major is overrated
and that doing a single major and cherry picking courses from the other major for your free slots is the superior move
especially if it tacks on extra years that you have to pay for
but that's just my opinion not based on much more than vibes and my personal experience
that's true but I quit cs 
everyone is literally replaced by ai
and they force you to learn a language that almost everyone hates it fr
garbage language
what isnt
js has a very practical builtin ide to almost everyones systems
sorry but not sorry, get me one of those and ill switch to your lang 😔
your browsers dev console 
Hello
Python
There are only two kinds of programming languages
- languages that people complain about
- languages that no one uses
I have zero debt
My situation was complicated as I went to school mostly on the GI bill though.
I don't think I'd recommend this kind of plan to most folks.
gastrointestinal? 
wait, what
wasn't that in the 1940s
- I complain about java and js
- I don't use assembly
I mean if you mpreg you kinda use asm in an indirect way
Why is studiscussy devolving to CS
I don't get it
I see
everywhere is a #cs-chat
Speaking of that, I need to make an ffmpeg wrapper, I’ll probably ship it as a SaaS too
have fun!
Shhhhhh let it cook
Yes I am pushing 100 at this point
Jk
The actual program began in the 1940s but still currently exists.
im gonna puke
"studiscussy"
It’s study+discussy
So real.
It's the simplest language that teaches you about what's happening under the hood. When you see C code you know what it's doing with the computer.
I'm learning Rust currently.
I'm just done with so much of memory problems just in getting a string.
can we move to a diff channel
which one and why?
it's off topic
Ohh maybe because this is for study
ohh yeah sorry
Because cs is really cool
Also all the cs people have taken over I guess
hi iraqi btw I'm ksor
They are very useful
can someone help me with percentage increases & decreases
What why 😭
You can make so many cool custom data structures
Pointer syntax is intuitive
Use * on the left side to indicate a pointer type, * on the right to dereference a pointer, and & to make a pointer by grabbing an address
*a = addrOf(a)
&a = valueAt(a)
yeah
its just compact
what about ** or &&
isn’t this backwards
also study discussion = cs discussion once again 
yes.
time to promote #1213610885277421588 to a full channel
&a gives the address, thats for sure
and *a should give the value stored at a, if I am not mistaken
yea
contradictory how people say something is intuitive, yet they confuse them while attempting to give an example
a classic of how easy is to shoot yourself in the foot with c++, by the time you think you know something, you dont
I just started partial derivatives, working through James Stewart Essential Calculus
Which style of d should I use for the partial derivative? I like the first and last but I'm not sure if the small delta is appropriate ? I'm really picky about the style haha
I've seen quite a few ways people write it lol
Not the left one, that's lowercase delta
Mine is similar to the one on the far right
I suppose the 2nd is easiest to write but could also be easy to write too wide, kind of like drawing a semicircle then closing half of it with a circle, last one I guess is really like a super curvy lowercase d isn't it. I'm just thinking about a shape to think while writing to allow myself to make the calligraphy consistent so I can write it very neatly without lots of variations in shape
any of 2, 3, 5, 6
1 and 4 are weird and shouldn't be used to denote partial derivatives
alternatively you could use the much easier Lagrange's notation
$\frac{\partial}{\partial y} \frac{\partial f}{\partial x} = f_{xy}$
Neamesis
Ah yes ofc, Lagrange notation looks quite easy to write consistently. Thank you all :)
I've gotten it down to more of 2 but narrower, so far trying to write the little bend like on 6 makes me a lot less consistent lol
I default to subscripts for partials unless I have a bunch of indices
on paper at least
I mean if you only have like a few expressions w partials that’s one thing but like if they’re more frequent it’s a lot more efficient
to do subscripts
that being said 2nd from left and far right are def the best
as qiu mentioned tho don’t do the lowercase delta 
4th from left is just fried idk who sanctioned that
your name 
LMAO
As I started working on problems I started to realize how much nicer that is just writing like f_xy and such lol
Hahaha yeah I realized after I sent it I'm like "wait lower delta does not seem right actually"
real yeah
\[\del_x \del_y f\]
Zanarcane
ts pmo
hm, what package is that from?
I dunno what package does that in particular but it’s just like defining \del as \partial
,, \partial
qiu
Same thing?
hmmmmmmmm
yeah I think it is and the color scheme accounts for any perceived difference
I mean u could always just overlay it to check but I’m on my phone so
You know I think the biggest obstacle, at least one of the biggest obstacles when I'm self-learning math is struggling to find someone to check my proofs and my solutions to problems
If you're in a university and are taking a course on something, the professor will assign homework problems and you'll do the homework, submit it and the professor will check your work
that's basically part of the prof's job
But when you're self-learning something out of a book and you're doing the exercises, you need someone to check if your proof are correct
for that (and more!) this server is amazing 
Eric did say that I should get used to checking my own work
and get better at it, which makes sense. You can't just close your eyes and say "okay I'm done! Someone check my proof" after finishing a proof
you have to look at it and read through it and check if each step logically follows from the previous one
I need to work on that 
perhaps even multiple times! perhaps even upside down!
it is hard to catch mistakes in your own work
You can check the meanings lol
See if they're the same
Ah Xannie just defines \del to be \partial in his preamble
Is it just me, or does anyone else hate coding
I hate coding too, I enjoy programming though
Okay, I hate coding and programming
Oh. Fair.
it's neutral to me. i like to see it like knowing how to use a drill or something, useful skill at times, can be fun at times, but I probably have more fun hobbies that take priority, and I definitely wouldn't like to work as one nor am I good enough for that
a power tools are cool as hell
C is a pain
No. Absolutely not.




