#Whirlwind

91 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

static orchid
#

A fighter very capable at attacking ground targets, whilst still being hard to take out itself.

trail oak
#

very strong

static orchid
#

Yeah, maybe I should up it’s cost

#

Nerfed!

storm pebble
#

still super good

arctic edge
#

Warhawk + Airacobra hybrid. Zamn

storm pebble
#

this thing can trade a panther g and survive

static orchid
#

Make it cost 7?

#

Thing is it gets shredded by other air units like a Corsair or Ki

#

Plus in tactical strike range and such

arctic edge
#

Reduse to takes 2 less damage from combat damage from ground units

static orchid
#

Very well

ripe oar
#

Hornisse is 7k with same stats

#

Think it should be 2 less

static orchid
#

Has it been balanced to an acceptable extent?

storm pebble
#

no 💀

#

i dont even get the effect

#

its pretty boring

#

doesnt fit into an archetype

ripe oar
#

It’s good now

storm pebble
#

just like super stromg vs most decks

static orchid
#

Well historically the plane was very good against ground targets, both offensively and defensively

storm pebble
#

so was the p47

#

still a normal plane

#

same as corsair etc

#

point is u can do something more original

ripe oar
#

P47 destroys frontline

#

And draws when kills a unit

#

I think it’s fine now

#

Maybe add 5 defense

#

And 2 attack

lunar harness
#

man brits really did themselves dirty by not producing more whirlwind

ripe oar
#

Or 6 defense

static orchid
#

I think it needs to be vulnerable to orders like tactical strike

storm pebble
storm pebble
static orchid
#

Well then it’s just going to get patrolled or United we stand’d

arctic edge
# ripe oar Or 6 defense

With 6 defence they can be destroyed in oine turn ground units like tiger 1-H or IS-2 if take ground units

static orchid
#

Which is a bit too vulnerable in my opinion

storm pebble
static orchid
#

Not the very cheap orders

storm pebble
#

then throw balance out the window lmao

#

most ger control decks dont even bring tactical strike as far as i can tell

static orchid
#

Brits cannot be balanced

storm pebble
#

ok then just make it op

#

immune to ground units

#

5-5

#

who tf cares

static orchid
#

Immune to all units

storm pebble
#

sure

#

idc

arctic edge
#

uh...

#

What about 3/4 Deployment: Deal 3 damage to random unit, if it's ground unit destroy in instead

static orchid
#

So very similar to Mosquito?

arctic edge
#

this just my idea

static orchid
#

Idk if the random aspect really fits Brits

#

Since I’d argue Mosquito would just be vastly better

arctic edge
#

well if do this target then more likely with him will target only ground units

static orchid
#

Maybe “pin target ground unit and deal 3 damage to it”?

#

Stall + damage

arctic edge
#

or Pin unit. If in already pinned deal 3 damage

static orchid
#

Well that’s a lot weaker to surprise attack

#

Also there’s already a 5k Japanese air unit that does the same, but destroys if already pinned instead of damage

arctic edge
static orchid
#

Forgot the name

arctic edge
#

Oh... what if...

static orchid
#

Basically inherent surprise attack

arctic edge
#

The Empire Strikes effect but instead bombers - enemy pinned units?

static orchid
#

Pin units equal to total number of bombers plus 1?

arctic edge
#

then cost must be 7-9

#

Oh

static orchid
#

Well monty pins all for 1…

arctic edge
#

you think in thah way

#

i think about Deal damage to each enemy units equal to 1 plus the number of enemy pinned units

static orchid
#

Oh

arctic edge
#

Dirt effect

static orchid
#

That’s interesting

#

Would require a combo from other pin cards though

#

It has potential but needs setup beforehand

arctic edge
#

well yeah but what i said in this way cost must be at least 7 or 8

static orchid
#

If 8 then you couldn’t combo with shelling beforehand, making it less desirable

#

I think it would be too expensive then

arctic edge
#

well monty still can do brr in that way

static orchid
#

It depends on too much to be useful then

arctic edge
#

well you can make it 7 - this minimum cost for this

static orchid
#

If it was something more like “Pin all enemy units. Deal damage to all enemies equal to 1 plus number of pinned enemy units” that would be better since it can have a big impact on its own, which is what an elite needs

arctic edge
#

well in this way.... 8 kredit cost minimum

static orchid
#

It would definitely be an expensive card

#

I think 7-8 is the sweet spot

hasty ether
#

I dont like this card thematically. It is an air defence fighter.