#el_esqueleto_espanol_legendario
1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)
Our volunteers look into many questions every day; sometimes it takes them a little while to answer.
Make it descriptive, including relevant context, but also to the point. This way you improve your chances of getting a more relevant and specific answer.
Context
If all you have is that one extract, then you'll never know for sure.
« Salut, tu as vu Marie ?
– Marie ? Non, pourquoi ?
– **Elle mange une orange ** !
– Du coup… ?
– Le médecin lui a dit de pas le faire, putain ! »
As you can see here, the sentence makes it pretty clear it's talking about one person, Marie, so it's « elle ». « lui » here stands for « à elle (to her) ». If it had been plural (as in we're talking about multiple women), it would've been « le médecin leur a dit »
In other cases, French has this phenomenon where it stresses/emphasises a noun by repeating it in its pronoun form.
« Salut, tu les as vues, Marie et Jeanne ?
– Non, pourquoi ?
– Les filles, elles mangent une orange !
– Du coup… ?
– Le médecin leur a dit de pas le faire, putain ! »
Thank you
As you can see, you can tell
Though i hoped there was a clearer way
There isn't sorry
Merci beaucoup
I will add though that, at least in the present tense, this only concerns the first group of conjugations
so you're not going to have issues with the other groups
You mean other tenses are more clear
By the time you move to the imperfect, you will have already adjusted to the system so you'll do fine
The imperfect and the conditional present aren't
but that's for later waaaaaaay down the line
I will worry about it later then 😅
The other groups don't have this issue (exceptions excluded):
2nd conjugation (-ir): Il finit / Ils finissent | Il dort / Ils dorment | Il vient / Ils viennent
3rd conjugation (-re): Il rend / Ils rendent | Il conduit / Ils conduisent | Il atteint / Ils atteignent
Irregulars (-oir): Il peut / Ils peuvent | Il sait / Ils savent | Il reçoit / Ils reçoivent
Being comfortable with relying on context will do wonders