kzzak

[drowsy oriole]

Please be patient

Our volunteers look into many questions every day; sometimes it takes them a little while to answer.

Pro tip: you can rename the thread title with `.tr <thread name>`

Make it descriptive, including relevant context, but also to the point. This way you improve your chances of getting a more relevant and specific answer.

[south sorrel]

Note how you lose the auxiliary in #3

Faut juste faire pareil :p

[hollow gust]

Have tried

• En ayant avons écouté
• En ayant eu écouté
• En avans ayant écouté
  but nothing's working 🫠

[quaint surge]

Elle a fait => En faisant
Nous avions écouté => En ........

🙂

[quaint surge]

Think about it

[hollow gust]

En ayant écouté 😭

[quaint surge]

Noon, laisse l'auxiliaire de côté comme tu as fait avec la #3

[hollow gust]

wait I got it

[quaint surge]

Ok tell me

[hollow gust]

en écoutant

[quaint surge]

Yes !!!!!

Great job

[hollow gust]

Got confused because of the avions écouté lol

thought it had to be in the form of participe présent passé

[hollow gust]

also this confused me hehe. Because the auxiliary would be 'Elle a fait' and I tohught I was missing the a equivalent

pain

[fierce cairn]

For 1 and 3, notice how the tenses line up. That allows for the gerundive because the two actions are happening on the same timeline (simultaneously)

For 4, that’s another function of the gerundive: expressing a condition.